Тёмный

This Failed Propeller Powered TRAIN Was Actually Ahead Of Its Time... SO I BUILT ONE! 

ScrapMan
Подписаться 921 тыс.
Просмотров 172 тыс.
50% 1

Welcome to another episode of Scrap Mechanic! Today I am recreating the propeller-powered train known as the Bennie Railplane. It was a train that had a lot of plane-like design elements to enable to go faster, and traverse a wider variety of terrain elements. Despite having a relatively successful test version, it was unable to get funding to make it into the mainstream. Yet, with the exception of the propellors, a lot of modern trains don't seem that different than this one.
Stuff Referenced:
Article: oldmachinepres...
Found and Explained Video: • This Insane Plane/Trai...
More recreating real-life machines: • This Was (and STILL is...
My Most Popular Videos (for whatever reason): • ScrapMan's Most Popular!
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
♦ Join the Scrapper Community: / discord
♦ Merch: scrapman.store
♦ Like my Tweets: / scrapmanyt
♦ My Doggos on Instagram: / scrap.dogs
♦ My RU-vidr Setup: www.amazon.com...
♦ I Make Metal Music: / catarinth
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
If you want to see MORE Scrap Mechanic videos, please like and subscribe! Leave a comment and let me know what you'd like to see in future videos.
What is Scrap Mechanic?
Scrap Mechanic is a multiplayer sandbox game with imagination and ingenuity at its core. Create fantastic machines, transforming vehicles or sneaky traps. The possibilities are endless with Scrap Mechanics powerful tools.
Find the game here: store.steampowe... #scrapman #scrapmechanic

Опубликовано:

 

28 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 432   
@xX_Fighter_Xx
@xX_Fighter_Xx 2 года назад
If you would like to make a longer track I have made monorail terrain assets. There are a couple of tiles with them but you could also make a tile yourself. And yes I know this isn't a monorail lol.
@FerrowTheFox
@FerrowTheFox 2 года назад
Kinda reminds me of the German experimental railcar called "Schienenzeppelin" (rail zeppelin) from around the same time. It only had one prop in the back, but the front was pretty close to today's bullet trains, very aerodynamic and sleek looking. It set a land speed crecord of 230 km/h back then. Pretty interesting thing imo.
@himenaaa3565
@himenaaa3565 2 года назад
Damn reading the Rail Zepplin, causing my brain to remember Fate Series,
@Yosh-wt4lg
@Yosh-wt4lg Год назад
oh that's like the french aerotrain, its cruising speed was 400km/h
@Der_Yoloist
@Der_Yoloist 2 года назад
5:25 That sneeze caughed me of guard and gave me a spike of laughter xD
@SapioiT
@SapioiT 2 года назад
Man, you need to make more videos on similar subjects to videos Found And Explained made. Including the Arctic Land Train, which used electric engines with power from a generator wagon, and could go on any kind of sneaking/snaking/snake-ing road. And this also works well with the Scrap Mechanic physics.
@squoshi307
@squoshi307 2 года назад
Man, I really love the new editing style. Especially the bloopers. Good man.
@diyshah8861
@diyshah8861 2 года назад
He's not Good man, he's scrapman (terrible dad joke even though I'm not a parent yet)
@Apersonl0l
@Apersonl0l 2 года назад
i think the bounciness is due to Scrap Mechanics hates having a giant thing made of the same material (maybe it calculates collision on one giant object), try alternating materials when making the rail (so it maybe calculate the collisions on only a few blocks at a time), Kan and kosmo did this on their rail systems over on their coop multiplayer or it may just be scrap jank
@Crummieboi56
@Crummieboi56 2 года назад
Moonbo? You meant kosmo right?
@1mariomaniac
@1mariomaniac 2 года назад
I think they figured out that even painting them different colors will fix the issue
@aircraftcarrierwo-class
@aircraftcarrierwo-class 2 года назад
Truly before his time, this was the first "bullet train". I'm sure Mr Bennie would be proud to see the European and Japanese bullet trains scooting around these days. Though he'd probably be disappointed that they have yet to catch on in the USA.
@gerrard1144
@gerrard1144 2 года назад
Yeah pretty much. Although Britain had it's own sort of bullet train with the Class A4 Pacifics and the LMS Coronation, until they were taken out of service because the diesel's were taking over.
@aircraftcarrierwo-class
@aircraftcarrierwo-class 2 года назад
@@gerrard1144 ah, I didn't know about those. I'll have to look them up. I find trains and train history fascinating but have precious little knowledge about them.
@gerrard1144
@gerrard1144 2 года назад
@@aircraftcarrierwo-class i believe on the mainline they go as fast as 90-100mph, but the A4 Mallard reached 126mph on the stokes' bank, beating the previous record for fastest train of 124mph by the Germans. It is now the world's fastest steam locomotive ever to run, although it's middle bearing melted lol. They stuck to 90 since then, when diesels took over, steam trains are only allowed to go 75mph on the mainline, but that was lifted i think. Trains are amazing pieces of engineering.
@FastForwardPlans
@FastForwardPlans 2 года назад
Trains are actually fairly extensively used in the usa, you can spot rails all over the place, like a lot a lot, like the usa has the longest rail network in the world, with china coming in second. Not a close second though, its a solid 150,000 km extra of track over China. The US totaling 250,000 km, china 100,000 km, and russia sitting at 85,500 km. The assumption that the us does not use them is because they are not a popular means of transport for people. For good reason really, the issue is quite simply that setting them up as a means of public transport would be too inconvenient, the USA isn't like Europe where towns and housing was set up around horse and foot travel. A lot of US development was thanks to the goldrush, followed by the rise of cars, thousands of people settled along the long path from east to west and started to spread out rapidly once there was a fast long distance means of personal travel. Convenience and price is mostly why things ended up the way they are. Say for example I did want to go somewhere a track exist and was planned for, maybe a trip from new york to chicago. That would cost me, 215.69, and 1-2 days. For that same price, I can get on a plane and get there in a few hours. For that same amount of time, but cheaper, I could just drive there. If I am instead visiting family, somewhere outside of a major city, even if there is a track that crosses there, as its not a major line but a similar distance away, that would likely cost me 300-400 dollars, would require me moving between multiple trains, take a few more days, and that is only one way, the price would double if I wanted to take the train back home. It's just not worth it when cheaper and faster options exist.
@aircraftcarrierwo-class
@aircraftcarrierwo-class 2 года назад
@@FastForwardPlans Yeah I know the USA uses trains to move lots of freight. I was more referring to people-movers being unpopular.
@anthonyvargo7109
@anthonyvargo7109 2 года назад
5:25 that sneeze killed me😂😂
@DragonSirenHITOMI
@DragonSirenHITOMI 2 года назад
I would love to see this in trail makers lol Hoped you have a good day scrap man! My daughter gets so excited to see your videos she is gonna love this one too
@tobawoobossam7198
@tobawoobossam7198 2 года назад
I think the torque from the propellers is affecting the way the wheels tilt and that's why one way works better than the other
@flyingmunk8956
@flyingmunk8956 2 года назад
I like this kind of montage editing better than the usually just fast forward montages
@DanB-0
@DanB-0 2 года назад
This is a pretty neat train design and reminds me of a more modern idea variant I saw on tv years and years ago the High Speed Tubular Rail, there are a few videos of the animation of it here on youtube, but basically the train has rail top and bottom and the "track" is towers with wheels in the top and bottom for it to slip through which the towers would shoot it through them with powered wheels.
@Audjem1
@Audjem1 Год назад
Only scrapman can make a time lapse funny
@s.s.j5046
@s.s.j5046 2 года назад
Your sneezes always gets me..!
@bobbyhill3535
@bobbyhill3535 2 года назад
Hey scrapman you should do the watermans arrowbile I think me and a whole lot of people would love to see this
@hfpewe7872
@hfpewe7872 2 года назад
Scrapman's sneeze is so funny idk why
@moroblizniak4457
@moroblizniak4457 2 года назад
Damn, building montages are so nice now!
@wojciechikropka.4316
@wojciechikropka.4316 2 года назад
Great series and I love those random sneezes xD
@mommyjardinedeleon8064
@mommyjardinedeleon8064 Год назад
Finally I found a Scrapman vid w/ intro
@divy9474
@divy9474 2 года назад
you can paint in-between the segments and it will change the structure calculation without adding extra supports.
@abdulazizafaizal7448
@abdulazizafaizal7448 2 года назад
we need more satisfying builds scrapman
@anonymouscoward7559
@anonymouscoward7559 2 года назад
Maybe the reason this era had so many crazy inventions is because there were so many great inventions form inventing greats like Westinghouse and Tesla. You never know what silly idea will be the inspiration of the next great idea.
@LindenF
@LindenF 2 года назад
We need to be using these irl.
@cookaracha6272
@cookaracha6272 2 года назад
5:25 never mind the random sneeze I cant stop laughing
@franciskurian9392
@franciskurian9392 2 года назад
Scrapman, I got an idea. Make a beyblade and surround it with magnets facing outwards and use thrusters to rotate it. Use a swivel to cancel out the beys rotation and place another swivel on top of it and place some thrusters to use for changing directions (in instruments of destruction)
@roelieboy204
@roelieboy204 2 года назад
Yeah, very big object can glitch out the game. I build a very big bridge to an island in my survival world and when i walk or drive over it you can randomly fly up into the air.
@XA_GAMER
@XA_GAMER 2 года назад
I love you r videos
@Peekofwar
@Peekofwar 2 года назад
I think the upper wheels are hitting the structural pillars on the other side of the rail.
@BBAMblog
@BBAMblog 2 года назад
Its so crazy to think about, the guy who designed this would not have had even the slightest concept of computers, much less video games. And now, decades and decades later after he and his idea died, its getting seen by tens of thousands of people on a medium he never could have imagined
@WoH9Shadow
@WoH9Shadow 2 года назад
@Scrapman the bouncing can be avoided by alternating materials in about 10-15 blocks each... so 15 block metal 15 blocks wood and repeat. ask Kan and cosmo about it!
@ft3917
@ft3917 2 года назад
you have magnets .. i think you could try and make a megnet train rail.. a maglev type train. it could be a fantastic fast train
@notanagger4861
@notanagger4861 2 года назад
To combat the bounciness u should divide the rail into chunks or either different colors or different material all together
@arnarmar7038
@arnarmar7038 2 года назад
Allso wery nice build
@SteinGauslaaStrindhaug
@SteinGauslaaStrindhaug 2 года назад
The big problem with this and all elevated train ideas (monorail etc); is that unless there's water below or extremely rough terrain; it's much cheaper to just flatten the terrain and put normal rails on the ground. And even if the terrain is rough or covered with water etc, it's much easier to just build a normal rail bridge over it than an entirely incompatible mono-rail system.
@akhtardanishm21
@akhtardanishm21 2 года назад
there is always "SO I BUILT ONE" in scrapman's videos now
@Hiro_blee3292
@Hiro_blee3292 2 года назад
Yeah your right he's really on a ride
@henrystickmin8812
@henrystickmin8812 2 года назад
This guy: Lets put the tracks in the AIR! Some other guy: Lets create a train... with no train tracks!
@durp3226
@durp3226 2 года назад
I have 2 different ideas for multiplayer monday Challenge 1 "not my build" you build vheicals for your opponent to use in a race so the crappyer you make it the better chance you have...let the sabotage commence Challenge 2 "dont spill" a race where you have to carry an extremely awkwardly shaped object limitations being the object has to be free floating and not fully encased. Add obstacles as you see fit
@wiktorldaplag2695
@wiktorldaplag2695 2 года назад
5:25 bless you 🙂
@moorurr
@moorurr 2 года назад
i liked your previous outro song more, but this one is still good
@piersmundy
@piersmundy 2 года назад
This makes me want to see a multiplayer Monday monorail race
@maxmachac9756
@maxmachac9756 2 года назад
You need to check out stuff made by Frank Tinsley, like his Submarine Tank and Baby Assault Tank concepts
@johnkim5854
@johnkim5854 2 года назад
The one direction being weird might be cause by the Axial forces caused by the propellers both spinning in the same directions, causing the wheel just after the bump to collide with the pillars that hold up the top rail.
@collinrichman1921
@collinrichman1921 2 года назад
You should add more sections to the train
@fikrierdogan8525
@fikrierdogan8525 2 года назад
Scrapman when building long tracks if you change block types every 20-30 blocks (wood-meatal-wood-metal) you dont have any of those weird collision issues
@huey2026
@huey2026 2 года назад
The smooth direction has the torque of the propellers push the top wheels away from the top rail "wall". The not smooth direction has the propellers torque pushing the top wheels into top rail "wall" possibly causing them to try to ride up and off.
@YusufKayeht
@YusufKayeht 2 года назад
14:06 I know this kind of phrase, I say it a lot as a programmer
@hunkbaloni960
@hunkbaloni960 2 года назад
Strv 103, tank with cool way of aiming
@nathanielhill8156
@nathanielhill8156 2 года назад
The train might be torquing due to the propellers. If it is, the tires might be hitting the rail supports. Double blades (one clockwise, one counterclockwise) on the propellers might have a better time with staying straight and might even be faster.
@Phant0mBr8k
@Phant0mBr8k 2 года назад
Bless you
@cafdodo5629
@cafdodo5629 2 года назад
I know it's been going on for a while now, but I wanna say I I really like this part of your channel, and how it's sorta passivly edjucashanal (and I need it).
@themusicship_
@themusicship_ 2 года назад
I learned more in this video then in a year of school 😂😂
@Kateykat
@Kateykat 2 года назад
please upload this to the workshop
@axisrespawn4557
@axisrespawn4557 2 года назад
First hi scrapman love the vids I've been watching since 2016
@RlCHIE
@RlCHIE 2 года назад
bless you (you sneezed at the start of the video)
@soezere3177
@soezere3177 2 года назад
propellers are rotating the train. so upper wheel hubs are colliding with the upper rail holders. making the same bar to the other side of the upper rail would solve.
@blackoak4978
@blackoak4978 2 года назад
Pretty sure the difference in performance depending on direction is due to the torque of the propellers. Since the attachment point isn't symmetrical it would experience friction differently between the two
@Valkyr13
@Valkyr13 2 года назад
Scrapman can you please make a video where you modify the railplain and replace the wheels with the frictionless blocks and make it much better
@devastation2005
@devastation2005 2 года назад
Hey scrap man. Since you did this, so you think you could make the rotodyne, it’s a plane-copter hybrid that has the same story as this air train. Please?
@vrex899
@vrex899 2 года назад
I think he already did it in trailmakers, not sure tho, but I think he at least did something very similar to it
@vrex899
@vrex899 2 года назад
Wait actually no, I confused it with something else
@CheeseballsX
@CheeseballsX 2 года назад
He is always so cherw
@_Cheko_
@_Cheko_ 2 года назад
I know right, so cherw
@generalcat7678
@generalcat7678 2 года назад
You should try to re-create the UFO design from Germany in World War II
@codyfannan7518
@codyfannan7518 2 года назад
Scrap man you should try building the walking crane
@funky_pepe
@funky_pepe 2 года назад
5:22 scrapman jumpscare
@andywang1950
@andywang1950 2 года назад
The propellers's angular momentum is rotating the "train " in different directions as you spin them in different directions. that's why you get different results when you go in different directions.
@kopow4320
@kopow4320 2 года назад
i love the montage
@8bitbunnie936
@8bitbunnie936 2 года назад
5:25 bless you
@Shitballs69420
@Shitballs69420 2 года назад
Hey, you should build a 'Hulett ore extractor' its a very interesting piece of shipping related equipment history.
@errorerror8700
@errorerror8700 2 года назад
Reminds me of the Schwebebahn in Wuppertal / germany.
@pumbaboi6056
@pumbaboi6056 2 года назад
We need a Dornier Do 335 build
@DamacusSquared
@DamacusSquared 2 года назад
I wander if using upside down wedges would allow you to have a "consistent" flat surface while still allowing the sections to remain separated from one another. Worth a try
@apersunthathasaridiculousl1890
@apersunthathasaridiculousl1890 2 года назад
scrap did bennie justice, :’) kinda
@z4clewis
@z4clewis 2 года назад
Hi persun
@meme_arecool121
@meme_arecool121 2 года назад
Day 2 of asking scrap man to build the kamov ka-22 in trailmakers
@TERRAZERO666
@TERRAZERO666 2 года назад
Scrapman I have a challenge for you[] I dare you to try to make one of your past builds from ether scrap Mechanic or trail makers and I want you to make it in the game Instruments of destruction
@raffia16thblaze10
@raffia16thblaze10 2 года назад
Build an ekranoplan. A russian ground effect plane that was very successful at its task could carry A lot of weight. Like those things were HUGE.
@jamesTBurke
@jamesTBurke 2 года назад
Should've tried a short oval track
@afiqnawawiamaluzzaman6165
@afiqnawawiamaluzzaman6165 2 года назад
Building montage good
@Gomorragh
@Gomorragh 2 года назад
damn ... i bet if this got less crowdfunding than Star Citizen did in equivalent for the day amounts we might have propellor monorails rather than rail networks in the uk ... the support rail may need to be a tube instead to stop the majority of the close interractions and frictions
@crystar6265
@crystar6265 2 года назад
Scrapman can you do train revolusion
@brodyheaven7221
@brodyheaven7221 2 года назад
It would be super interesting to see how this invention would have affected the evolution of transport. If it got the traction it deserved.
@dinodude7773
@dinodude7773 2 года назад
Nice.
@yellowsdotlxf
@yellowsdotlxf 2 года назад
If we are going along with weird locomotive things, check out the Fontaine? For the best information on the three of them, check out the Scientific American Supplement Issue 305, from November 5th 1881.
@McGeraet
@McGeraet 2 года назад
i did a monorail in survival and ran into the same problem with having one big rail and having to devide it into smaller pieces to make it work..
@Chexmix6
@Chexmix6 2 года назад
4:15 It's so sad! 😢
@temhgb
@temhgb 2 года назад
I think it's because of the fact that you used the small pipe pieces, and that the wheels were hitting the stilts keeping the top rail up. this could've been fixed by you replacing the one small pipe piece touching the track with a large one (with bearings on both sides). you can put a bracing around the side of it made of the small pipes to keep the wheels from jiggling.
@TiffanyL2
@TiffanyL2 Год назад
What is scrap machinanics obsession in yellow as a common color scheme when thing like the tire, and the logic gates etc.
@mtvandamme
@mtvandamme 2 года назад
counterpoint; trains are STILL the best modes for long distance transportation
@Gustaf_ru
@Gustaf_ru Год назад
PROP FANT MOD * ITS COOL*
@knightbeforedawn
@knightbeforedawn 2 года назад
Could the issue when going one direction vs the other be something to do with the torque offset caused by the propellers twisting the car slightly? EDIT: maybe you could add a stabilizer glitch or a gyroscope to counter the effects?
@gunman5253
@gunman5253 2 года назад
if you used more propellers it would go fast
@Looki2000
@Looki2000 2 года назад
it worked on the second side beacause first segment on the first side is too long. I was building a monorail in my survival world and had to sha divide the track quite often to avoid this issue
@friskdt6296
@friskdt6296 2 года назад
Bruh this needs to be made irl perma
@__franz_
@__franz_ 2 года назад
i like new building time.
@jamesTBurke
@jamesTBurke 2 года назад
Sounds like it was the grandfather of the monorails and bullet trains
@kurosumomo
@kurosumomo 2 года назад
was it intended to go a straight line only?
@travissquiers2932
@travissquiers2932 2 года назад
Is it the propeller rotation can't really tell in the video it looks like they're both rotating in the same direction
@Ragdollot
@Ragdollot 2 года назад
You should play zeepkist
@Mrbubz-xl2wb
@Mrbubz-xl2wb 2 года назад
Next multiplayer Monday do a resource collector long jump and build a vehicle made of resource rods drive over a line of resource collectors and whoever goes the farthest wins
@AnimoInc7461
@AnimoInc7461 2 года назад
Can you please make the Canadair CL-84 "Dynavert" Its a tilt-wing.
@anitawong846
@anitawong846 2 года назад
Wow
@kaidenlemonaden
@kaidenlemonaden 2 года назад
3rd time asking for Goodyear inflataplane in trailmakers
@theloganpresley
@theloganpresley 2 года назад
It didn't take off because it was on rails, Scrap
Далее
Can Dangerous Saw Blades Cut Wood?
25:34
Просмотров 160 тыс.
Reaching SPACE in KSP using ONLY JET ENGINES!
28:24
Просмотров 34 тыс.
The Spooky Science of Wedge Powered Objects
19:48
Просмотров 338 тыс.