@@deepaknishad2325Let me stop you right there. You're gonna say, 3000 years ago Jewish people lived there then they got displaced and thousands of years later they came and reclaim the land, aren't you?
@@deepaknishad2325why there are country for jews only that ridiculous More that jew said its forbidden for them to make a country or even join military
@@deepaknishad2325if your claim is right Why you guys suddenly remembered that this land is for jews only, This idea suddenly appeared in in 1911 If something really stolen from you we should have learned from long time before 1900 or before than that We should have heard in history book that Something like " jews keeps fighting to bring back their stolen land" But in history that Israel came in 1948 Lefting their nearly 5900 years?! And they like "OH wait a minute our grand grand grand used to live here" Kicking Palestinian out who lived there for along time Mocking them , killing their children Have you heard of first nakba?! Have you how they brutally genocide them?
This is not possible with Arabs who are always ruled by extremists "by accident" because that's their heart and they always rule them in every Arab country. They still live by kings and extremists that's why they will never get to a solution. Saudi Arabia.. Rich people vs very poor people . Lebanon.. Rich politicians vs poor people Iran.. The same.. Syria.. The same. Of course there are good arabs. But not the leadership, this is the problem.
If so, blame Hamas who governs Gaza. I didn’t know concentration camps had yacht clubs, mansions, high end shopping, restaurants, 2 universities, an airport (destroyed by Hamas). Learn history 🤡
I still can’t believe that these people expect the people of Palestine to not resist and fight for their lands, is been happening for almost 60 years and still have the hope of winning but how they going to do that when the people of Palestine are very resistant and are not willing to hand their beautiful land to the thieves
Thieves? What thieves? Israel got land from Britain. Palestine never belonged to Palestinians originally. During the 1900s they didn't own Palestine, Britain did. They divided the land. Britain. I don't see any thieves here except Britain. And yeah countries steal land and conquer land. The land you're living on is stolen. Your ancestors had to do the dirty work before you so you could live in peace. Be thankful.
GAZA is barely twice the size of SOWETO in the city of Johannesburg, South Africa. The Kruger National Park in South Aftica is 53 times the area of gaza. 2.5 million people forced into such a small concentration camp. It's inhumane.
It’s not a prison if they share borders with Egypt and Jordan (which are allies with Palestine) allies like them aren’t giving any water or supplies to Palestine why because Palestine is only a pawn in their game if they were true allies there would be no water problems in Palestine it’s not Israel’s responsibility since they left Palestine to do their thing for 18 years not to mention the only reason those people were displaced was because a nazi leader wanted to massacre all the Jews who wanted a home in Palestine Israel didn’t start that war it was Palestinians
@@TmanRock9I'm German. I've visited a concentration camp. I had to learn quite a lot about them. They definitely have many similarities. Yes, Palestinians don't get gased to death, they don't have to do physical work until they drop dead but they will be shot if they want to flee, get killed randomly and only get very limited access to food and water (and electricity and gas but I don't think they had that at all in concentration camps).
@@uff069 yeah they will be arrested if they cross the border into another country. They have property, stores, markets, hospitals, job, government roles etc. They aren’t killed randomly, casualties occur during raids, or military operation. The differences are night and day. It’s not a concentration camp. I’m concentrations camps you didn’t own property, their were no markets, you didn’t have a government, you didn’t have elections, you didn’t have cars and freedom of movement, you didn’t have money, you didn’t own things at all, you didn’t have schools, or hospital, or health ministries, or a standing army.
Hamas had every opportunity to make Gaza into a great nation. But they chose to buy weapons and smuggle bombs into Gaza, basically forcing israel to take control of import and export to keep hamas from getting weapons. If hamas just chose not to be a constant threat to israel, I guarantee you that Gaza wouldn't be a open air prison. Plus, israel was there long before Palestine. Even the quran mentions israel being given to the jews by God as a holy land. But the Jews were repeatedly attacked and kicked out of their land. Eventually to be brought back again. The jews claim to israel is thousands of years old. The region was changed from Judea to palestine during the reign of the Roman empire. Most believe the Roman's did this to erase the presence of the Jewish people.
The Statue of Liberty is not the least bit embarrassed or ashamed. She was a birthday present from one free republic to another: "Liberty Enlightening the World". New York pro-settler Jews wrote a poem by the Jewess Emma Lazarus and used that as a Kung Fu move to flip her 180° into the Statue of Jewish Settler Immigration.
When your land is seized, dispossessed, occupied and you are expelled. The only natural thing to do is to resist and defend yourself. Only people not in the right mind says the contrary
that isn't what happened. they left Europe out of their own free will to go to Palestine as "refugees", many of their officials have their applications papers to Palestine online, yet they became extremist zionist militant groups and seized land that wasn't theirs. which is why btw, you can't even take a DNA test in Israel, because then you'll know there is no middle eastern heritage in you. @@BB-gs5rs
What does that have to do with modern day Palestinians? They been there since birth! 3000 years ago, don't mean crap Where I live there were Indians. People still find the arrowheads.@@CaptainTodger69
Hamas had every opportunity to make Gaza into a great nation. But they chose to buy weapons and smuggle bombs into Gaza, basically forcing israel to take control of import and export to keep hamas from getting weapons. If hamas just chose not to be a constant threat to israel, I guarantee you that Gaza wouldn't be a open air prison. Plus, israel was there long before Palestine. Even the quran mentions israel being given to the jews by God as a holy land. But the Jews were repeatedly attacked and kicked out of their land. Eventually to be brought back again. The jews claim to israel is thousands of years old. The region was changed from Judea to palestine during the reign of the Roman empire. Most believe the Roman's did this to erase the presence of the Jewish people.
They brought this on themselves the vast majority of the population in Gaza supported Hamas and it's genocidal aims against Israel. If the vast majority of people did not support Hamas they could not have built the large Terror infrastructure that they have
@@HOGH22 No Hamas? Who were all those underground tunnels built for? I'll give you a hint; They were NOT air raid shelters for the people. The whole of Gaza is Hamas or Hamas sympathizers. There's no way Hamas could have become as big as it is built all those tunnels launched all those Rockets hidden all those weapons in private homes and schools and Moss if the vast majority of the people in Gaza did not support them. The vast majority of people in Gaza are Hamas or Hamas supporters that give them material aid.
As an orthodox jew. I support the creation of a free and independent Palestinian state. This will end all the violence. As Jews we need to accept that Israel is the occupying force and we need to do the right thing and give Palestinians their own independent state free from Israeli interferences. ISRAEL, USA AND UK NEED TO STOP THE GENOCIDE TAKING PLACE ON THE OCCUPIED PALESTINIAN LANDS or history wont be kind to them as it wasn't to the Nazis and every other occupation.
@@nzothfatherofdream9231 In my view, it is natural for groups to form that oppose the unjust occupation of the motherland, especially if there is systematic killing, displacement and extermination. If you read a little in history, the Islamic Jihad group has the same perspective as the anti-occupation groups in Ireland, Vietnam, Iraq, Algeria, etc. and the list goes on. It does not make sense for an oppressor to occupy your land, take away your resources, and kill your children and women while you smile and offer him everything on a golden platter as if you are saying oh please be my guest!!!
I'm not real sure, but I was in the West Bank in May. There are border crossings all over since both Israel and the Palestine Authority control zones within the West Bank. There is typical lift gate and guard shack where I had to show a passport coming and going. Being an obvious foreigner to both Arabs and Jews I could pass easily. I think there are only two border crossing between Gaza and Israel, and only one between Gaza and Egypt. Unlike Israel, Palestinian Arabs are not welcome to live in Egypt or Jordan. @@teresavarghese1177
@@sergeharrison5804Go ahead, what's the reason to occupy the Palestinians for 100 years? What did they do wrong in the first place? You won't answer, and if you do, I'll easily wave away your nonsense, because at the end of the day there is literally no reason other than that _they_ wanted to be the ones doing a holocaust this time.
@@ascelinred1000 no life expectancy is 73 years, same as Croatia and Turkey. reason majority is under 18 is that the average children per female is 5-7 since the 1990ths. you have been fed lies. read the real stats, the real facts.
When Israel was given part of Palestine, the Palestinians had to shift from their land to the Gaza area while Israel took most of the area. If all the people of US had to live only in California then they too will have a very large population.
@@teresavarghese1177 That doesn't mean the US population would near a billion if that happened. The Arab population has increased dramatically in general.
From my understanding, the immigration restrictions were implemented after Hamas took control of Gaza and Hamas is currently backed by Iran who is an enemy of Israel and the U.S.. Iran's goal is to cause instability in the region, and Hamas has vowed to destroy Israel. I also read that Isreal is looking for countries willing to take in palistinian immigrants. Its importsnt to tell the whole story so that people dont come to wrong conclusions (though i undertsand that this is a short). Also Im sure theres also a lot more to this story than what I mentioned as well.
It all depends on what you read/or listen to. I take my News from the Middle Eastern News Outlets. That does Not include Include Isreal! To be on the right side of History, one should look at the Victims. We are trying to open the hearts and eyes of the cold-hearted! #SAVEPALESTINE #STOPGENOCIDE
it was never really about Hamas, they're trying to twist it into this narrative so that they can kill the only Palestinian resistance. P1:Do the Palestinians have the right to resist apartheid? P2:Yes, but then they're terrorists. (they're also anti-semitic)
Gaza is not a prison because a prison is filled with guilty people (Sorry if I wasn’t right Or something along those line wasn’t right but that’s what he said ) -bassem yousef Also as a Palestinian free Palestine and make dua for my people
I always think, if the roles were reversed, and the Jews were in Gaza and the Palestinians were on the other side of the fence, Gaza would be a top-notch resort and tech hub on the Mediterranean. People would be trying to break into the prison to find work.
This isnt about religion, thats like Putin defending his nation against NATO aggression and only Belarus publicy backed them. You can say So much for christian brotherhood there also lol? This is purely ethnic, racially motivated. They are not attacking religion, just the skin color of the other.
The closure of the Gaza Strip was a complex decision influenced by several factors, including Palestinian violence, the Egyptian offer, and Israeli security concerns. And btw, Egypt could take Palestine members to Egypt, They didn't want it. So don't put it on "Israel's fault".
@@albertbresca8904 I'll tell you more than that, when the war between Russia and Ukraine started - full of statesmen offered the citizens of Ukraine to come to them so they wouldn't be harmed, there are a ton of Arab countries right? Why didn't anyone suggest that they come to her? Syria/Jordan/Egypt and a whole lot more.. for the simple reason! They know that as soon as the Palestinians come to them, they will be harmed in their country, and Hamas will also be harmed, this is exactly why no one takes them. And after that they blame Israel for this... It's really not Israel, it's them and what they can cause.
Because the border is controlled by Egypt and Israel. keyword "and", no Palestinian passes except with the agreement of both Egypt and the Zionist terror state. Ya'll really be saying the same stuff, talking to one of you is like talking to everyone, that's how brainwashed you're.
Palestinians wouldn’t have to go to Egypt if Israel wasn’t murdering tens of thousands of innocent babies. But you already know that, just pushing racist propganda against innocents
Ironic to say that in prison they give you food , clean water, a bath room, Free medical , a place to sleep , electicity , and a chance to leave. Not bombs day and night and no ramdom shootings.
Because, based on history, Egypt knows that Israel will never allow the Palestinians to return. Israel is intent on making the Palestinians of the Gaza Strip refugees a second time.
Lies lies lies. Its all a Conspiracy، just lies to give jews a land cuz they were so hated in other countries all they did were troubles and troubles, why you think hetler did what he did to them? Its all a Conspiracy to put them away from europe. Thiador hertzlz, the one that “said” that jews should have a land, and sadly palestine was chosen
@@asilkinder3609 It is understandable that children in an asylum do not know history. Here it is: 1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state 2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state. 4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state. 5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state. 6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state. 7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state. 8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state. 9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state. 10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean(Jewish)state, not a Palestinian state. 12. Before the Hasmonean(Jewish)state, there was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state. 13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state. 14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state. 15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state. 16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state. 17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state. 20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been everything, EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE. A little more history for those wanting to 'restore Palestine'. After the Jewish revolt of Bar Kokhba in 132 AD the Roman Emperor Hadrian resolved to stamp the Jews and their religion out of existence. He sold all Jewish prisoners into slavery, forbade the teaching of the Torah, renamed the Kingdom of Juda Syria Palaestina, and changed Jerusalem's name to Aelia Capitolina. He renamed the land to wipe out the national identity of the Jews. So if you are looking to 'restore Palestine to the Palestinians', you need to give it back to the Jews. Besides how can a people call themselves by a name they can not write. The letter P does not exist in the Arabic script. The Palestinian ethnicity was invented in the 60' by Yaser Arafat along with the now so ubiquitous flag. They are Arabs. 90% of them came during the British Mandate from adjacent countries for work. So there is no historical bond to the land. When modern Israel was established they had been there for 20 years. The ones who lived there longer came from the Arabian Peninsula with the spread of Islam in the 7th century. By then 3000 years of Jewish history had been written. The land was bought not stolen. There is plenty of proof. Also Palestinians are not the Philistines from the Bible. Those were Greek seafarers from the isle of Crete.
Gaza isn't, on examination, a prison. A prison implies that there are criminals or law breakers inside. Instead it can be viewed as a camp, a huge camp, into which am ethnic population has been concentrated against their will. Similar to what the British did to Boer populations in South Africa at the end of the 19th century. A camp. Concentrated. Now.......where else have I seen this phenomenon in modern history??
Don't try and justify the genocide of the Palestinian people. They didn't start a war, they are defending themselves from a 24 billion military budget aggressor.
@@layla-co1jtcan’t claim you are oppressed because the people you started wars on to commit genocide on do not treat you nicely. You’re acting like holocaust survivors should of invited nazis into their homes.
If they have a land border with Egypt 🇪🇬 how can it be a prison? Is South Korea a prison because they can’t go to mainland Asia because of the problem with North Korea?
The prison narrative is false. “Buy words”. Get on google and zoom in on southern Gaza. Plenty of houses and some estates. If 800,000 people can live in San Francisco (40sq/miles) 2 million can live in 140 sq/miles. Stop wasting resources and energy on rockets, weapons and tunnels, make a life.
Yeah that is a good idea and if you do this you will see how insanely overcrowded it is. this is what happens though when you have 5-7 children on average per female for 70years.
because the border require both Egypt and Israel to be opened... you think big daddy U.S.A won't intervene? besides, why should Palestinians become refugees in their own countries? just give back Palestine and go back to Europe.
The largest prison should goes to North Korea due to it's size of the land. But Gaza is slightly a bit better and a bit more freedom than North Korea such as internet access and freedom of speech. North Korea is more like a bigger prison than Gaza and you have no choice to speak out and if someone has internet access to the outside world, watch TV channels outside North Korea via terrestrial TV or listen radio outside North Korea and spread info about the anti North Korean government sure ends up in jail until death. If Gaza, you can still access information outside Gaza via internet, radio and TV. But still, certain things like the anti-Gaza government or the Palestine government are rare. If talking about war, yes, Gaza and Israel are still at war compared to North Korea and South Korea. There are pro-Palestine and pro-Israel going on around the world. Some are pro-Palestine because Israel is taking Palestine land while some are pro-Israel because Palestine are terrorists. I really hope the war will end on both sides and make peace on both sides.
Gaza is the size of detroit with 2 million people and their land was taken from them and shrunk until they were herded into that small area. All Palestinians are not terrorists but yeah most want their land back, their homes and businesses back and better education for their children. If someone came in and took your home and destroyed your business and there is no police or court to help you because there is only Israeli police and court left, what are you going to do? Happily leave and be content with the injustice? Or would you want to protest and fight for your land? Most of them are innocents that didn't hurt anyone and havent killed anyone despite the injustice done towards them. Why do you support Ukraine and call their homegrown army freedom fighters for defending their land against Russia but you cant see the same for palestine? Because make no mistake, Israel IS the occupying force in this ordeal.
Netanyahu’s real name is Mileikowsky, a Polish name Ariel Sharon’s real name is Ariel Scheinermann, a German name If the evidence to their real home land doesn’t prove that Israelis aren’t from the Middle East, I don’t know what does
The original number of Arabs displaced by the creation of Israel was less than a million. In order to put pressure on Israel, no Arab country allowed the displaced people to emigrate and become citizens. Big, highly visible refugee camps were created and maintained to this day. Over time the concept of a Palestinian nation was created for the international press.
And that's grace? forcefully expelling people out of their home then blaming others for not taking them also egypt has millions of refugees since nakba
@@scorpi972 christliche Nächstenliebe? Aus demselben Grund, weshalb wir Juden in Deutschland hatten. Damals, als sie von Arabern vertrieben wurden aus Jerusalem.
That’s funny! Why would Britain and usa supporting them? And give them the right to occupy ? That’s unbelievable, how about the Christian’s there too u think Jews want them to stay there, they consider them animals too deserve to die! Like they killed Jesus in the first place! Look at the bigger picture!
Came to write the same response. At least in Gaza they have access to the internet, the have a country club, equestrian club, restaurants, cafe's, beautiful beaches, nobody there is starving ... In North Korea they have non of the above.
@@klaudiadelmer1064 exactly, they want the freedom to commit atrocities against a country that has many times given them a chance for peace. They want the freedom to praise hamas as heroes after they killed women and children from Israel. get a clue read a book.
Egypt also closed borders with Gaza. But yet you only blame Israel. Wonder why? Wonder why calling for diversity only applies to Israel but not to it's neighbors? Hmmm?
Its not egypt duty to take or open border, also egypt had conflicts with isreal before and kinda threatened by them, its easy to understand why isreal is the most hated government with war crimes, yes they lived there in 1st century but they couldnt defend it and driven out by romans and etc... For many years they were living in europe and muslim countries, while those who were refugees in nearby countries slowly moved back and became known as Palestine (jews, christians and mostly muslim) isreal had no right to claim on that land just because it was theirs centuries ago and couldnt keep it, thats a fact in history whats gone is gone, you cant sell your house and return after years with violence to the new owners driving them out... Things that their government did is not even okay or illegal in jewish religion, all the shitty, slavery and lowest level jobs were done by Palestinie (muslims), just google how many palestine died in all these years (mostly children) thousands vs only hundred
because the border require both Egypt and Israel to be opened... Besides, why should Palestinians become refugees? just give back Palestine and go back to Europe. colonial apologists really have single cell brains.
You ignore the question. Why do you blame Israel for imprisoning all the Gazans, and not Egypt? The whole section with the establishment of the State of Israel is a subject in itself@@aledexia8895
Definition, Prison: 1 : a state of confinement or captivity. 2. : a place of confinement especially for lawbreakers. specifically : an institution (such as one under state jurisdiction) for confinement of persons.
@@raja332 I gave you the definition buddy, & it fits. There are prisons in South America where the prisoners are armed, but they are prisons none the less. Calling a spade, a spade.
Imo a prison means you're not able to leave, but they are able to leave. You have to ask if all their neighbors don't want them, is it the neighbors or is it the aggressive nature of their solutions. It's crazy how it seems like some people think the world began in WW2 (1940s), the moment you go past that date the Palestinians "home land" debate falls apart
that's like saying that the British would be in danger if they let British India become independent. colonialism apologists would go to the moon and back, except admit their own supremacists views.
we really can justify anything can't we? just watched the show midnight mass.. entire town wiped itself out by using religion to justify a fallen angel taking them out
They can feed many children, have several wives, well fed some even fat, education, hospital, communication, SMUGGLE ROCKETS, BAZOOKA, FIREARMS, ETC. Does that sound like prison to you ?
so are we going to talk about the horrendous false claim? or are we going to talk about the FACT that Israel's attack on hospitals left babies for dead on incubators?
I stand with Israel 💯. They should flatten Gaza as the civilians aren't totally innocent. They elected and support Hamas and cheer when Israeli civilians are butchered. I have very little sympathy for them.
