Тёмный

This TikToker Can't Stop "FIXING" Your Art 

Rin
Подписаться 138 тыс.
Просмотров 416 тыс.
50% 1

We all remember where we were when that Jojo one dropped.
👺 THANK YOU FOR WATCHING 👺
You can support me on Patreon!
/ eiririn
My brushes:
eiririnn.gumroad.com
Socials:
-Instagram
/ eiririnn
-TikTok
/ mean_kyo

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

30 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,5 тыс.   
@cidevant002
@cidevant002 Год назад
I can't help to notice that in all of his fixes he always makes the boobs bigger than they were originally. Like, if you want that for your art more power to you, but what is so wrong about having a female character without cleavage? Small chested characters deserve love too.
@L0rdOfThePies
@L0rdOfThePies Год назад
Bet it’s simply his lack of awareness for certain features he doesn’t fully align with as an artist
@upumpkin
@upumpkin Год назад
The eyes too, he always make them the same shape
@iseeyou2211
@iseeyou2211 Год назад
9:10 ??
@sentane8031
@sentane8031 Год назад
He should do that with the male characters, we need more man tiddies...
@mitzymoomoo6658
@mitzymoomoo6658 Год назад
Bro as a member of the itty bitty titty comittee I love some flat boob rep
@Giantsans
@Giantsans Год назад
Changing the whole art in the name of improving is just friendly way to say "your art is ugly let me draw it in my own style 🥰"
@cryingwatercolours8127
@cryingwatercolours8127 Год назад
this is how i feel koolean sees the world
@tomriddleschild6256
@tomriddleschild6256 Год назад
​@@cryingwatercolours8127 kooleen? I watch her..she doesn't seem like that. 🧐 ----Months later I've now realized.. ...she's exactly like that. Koolen sucks.
@Adaysaria
@Adaysaria Год назад
Cough cough kooleen cough cough
@amaiodayaka8926
@amaiodayaka8926 Год назад
@CryingWatercolors , honestly, Koolean does have some good advice.. the thing is, her advice isn’t universal and mostly applies to her own style. Each time she redraws someone else’s drawing it always looks like either: A) sexy mommy or B) sexy daddy, which is fine, really, but it’s sometimes kinda sad to see a very charming drawing turn into a thirst trap.. Just my opinion of course, I still think what she does is impressive anyways (I could never pull of semi-realism, cartoonism for lifeee).
@cryingwatercolours8127
@cryingwatercolours8127 Год назад
@@amaiodayaka8926 oh yeah she has *some* good advice… but yeah it’s very much directed to her style which is fine ofc but not when everyone is following them to the point… it just looks like a style challenge. ppl are losing what made their art unique, what gave it life, by following koolean and i just find it sad :’)
@tikimillie
@tikimillie Год назад
The thing is, drawing conventionally attractive characters, when you got decent skill is easy. Drawing conventionally “unattractive” characters and making it look good is the real show of skill
@keeratkahlon9035
@keeratkahlon9035 Год назад
Honestly same. I also find stylized art more difficult than realistic art, cause with realisim you know the rules and references and you can follow them which can be done with practice but with stylized you have to not only be very well aware of those rules to break them, but you have to break them in a way that looks aesthetically pleasing. Like i am not saying realistic is easy cause it isnt but man i am having so much trouble with making my own style especially if it is detailed stylized it ends up looking like hochpoch mess of anime style
@randomstuffs7648
@randomstuffs7648 Год назад
@@keeratkahlon9035 yeah as an artist i'm really struggling to get the spot right in the realm of stylized things.
@Suited_Nat
@Suited_Nat Год назад
Yep!!
@aezoax8321
@aezoax8321 Год назад
The image of the DaVinci sketches where he exaggerated "ugly features" to figure out what "beauty" is pops into my head. Because those still looked really pretty
@monikasalt
@monikasalt Год назад
@@error-try-again-laterliterally a lot of twitter artists lmao
@Ghost5O5
@Ghost5O5 Год назад
My jaw actually droppped when he detransitioned the character 😭 The fact that he "fixes" art by making it coventially pretty and completely erases the original concept is absolutely wild omg
@hoetrocity
@hoetrocity Год назад
He doesn’t pay attention enough to the art
@Ghost5O5
@Ghost5O5 Год назад
@- glitchbug. 💫 I'm an invasive species 😌
@Sasha-up9er
@Sasha-up9er Год назад
"conventionally pretty" I'm not so sure about that one... Did you see the first fix she showed?
@Savage.-_.Gamer1
@Savage.-_.Gamer1 Год назад
I swear if he “fixes” my art- I WILL do- that son of a b-! Politely 😊
@Savage.-_.Gamer1
@Savage.-_.Gamer1 Год назад
Glad he doesn’t go after random artists who might be content creators… 😅
@teor.rogers6765
@teor.rogers6765 Год назад
There’s a difference between helping someone be a better artist vs helping them be a better kenton Scott.
@jester6623
@jester6623 Год назад
this is a great way to word it. this is gonna stick with me
@soontobechannel743
@soontobechannel743 Год назад
Seriously, there’s this thing called “artsyles” and even if the artstyle is “ugly” in your opinion, it’s still not like it’s offensive and doing actual harm, god I hate cringe culture it’s so dumb, if the person in question isn’t doing /showing anything offensive or harmful such as hate towards a group/community of people then it’s fine.
@spooooket
@spooooket Год назад
This! So true!!
@Cool_Chill
@Cool_Chill Год назад
This comment👏
@NelsonStJames
@NelsonStJames Год назад
Dude.
@gj5748
@gj5748 Год назад
Oh my god when they detransitioned the character I lost it 😭💀💀 THAT WAS SO UNNECESSARY?????
@hibaelb8909
@hibaelb8909 Год назад
But like he didn’t know. The artist in the comments said that it was okay
@cidevant002
@cidevant002 Год назад
​@@hibaelb8909 That still makes it unnecesary.
@hibaelb8909
@hibaelb8909 Год назад
@@cidevant002 he didn’t do it on purpose. If he did it on purpose then we would have a problem
@cryingwatercolours8127
@cryingwatercolours8127 Год назад
@@hibaelb8909 yeah but it just shows how careless he is. he barely pays attention to the characters actual features.
@yashuari
@yashuari Год назад
​@@hibaelb8909 The character literally has breast reduction scars, he didn't even notice which says a lot about how he's just projecting his own standards into the drawing and not caring about the original artist intentions, and intentionally or not is harmful. It's not as much of a problem as if he was doing in purpose but still shows how closed-minded he is, not only cause of the detransition but because of how he's kinda saying that his way is the correct way
@sophitiaofhyrule
@sophitiaofhyrule Год назад
Artists like him really take away diversity in drawings. People in real life have different faces and bodies, yet he wants every character to look the same. It's so boring.
@gildedpeahen876
@gildedpeahen876 Год назад
Taking the downturned eyes on the Asian female (which is so beautiful, some Korean people have this eye shape, square and slightly downturned) and taking away the lil pooch of fat under the eye and making them big, open, upturned eye…gross. He took the diversity and ethnicity away and made it generic.
@overgrownkudzu
@overgrownkudzu 11 месяцев назад
@@gildedpeahen876 yeah his "fixed" drawing isn't bad or anything, but it just isn't the same person. the negative canthal tilt isn't a mistake that artist made, it's a choice how they wanted that girl's eyes to look. same with the longer face and nose, those weren't wrong they just weren't his beauty standard
@gildedpeahen876
@gildedpeahen876 11 месяцев назад
@@overgrownkudzu you hit the nail on the head, he’s just enforcing Eurocentric, modern beauty standards onto artists and saying he’s fiXiNg the drawings
@10feralratsinacoat76
@10feralratsinacoat76 6 месяцев назад
Yeah oh my god when he said positive canthal tilt or whatever I was like oh my god he's removing her intentional eyes
@eliandree7172
@eliandree7172 Год назад
"HE MAKES THE BITCH BLOND . HE DETRANSITIONS THEM" HAD ME ROLLING SHDGDHDH i love love your vibes i need to check out your other vids. i absolutely agree with everything you've said in this vid, this guy makes me so annoyed 😭 completely strips every drawing of its character...
@Suited_Nat
@Suited_Nat Год назад
FRRR ^
@losemyhead419
@losemyhead419 8 месяцев назад
"He transgenderedly gayed down the street NO MORE." 💀
@S1LLYBUGZ
@S1LLYBUGZ 7 месяцев назад
timestamp??
@notsoptimistic
@notsoptimistic 7 месяцев назад
​@@S1LLYBUGZ8:20 8:32
@yulebones
@yulebones Год назад
Ohhh my good lord. Him taking someone with obvious top surgery scars and turning the character into a conventionally comic-book-sexy woman with huge bazoongas straight up made me see red. UURGGH
@Urmommmmmmmmmmm904
@Urmommmmmmmmmmm904 Год назад
Yes!! Like I think it’s obvious what the person of the original artwork had in mind? And even if it wasn’t, he could ask them before doing his “fixing” …
@yulebones
@yulebones Год назад
@@Prrrprrt If you're going to be "correcting" someone publicly, you have the responsibility to know what you're looking at.
@sophitiaofhyrule
@sophitiaofhyrule Год назад
It's the transphobia for me
@sophitiaofhyrule
@sophitiaofhyrule Год назад
@@Prrrprrt Those are very obvious scars what
@Denayja29
@Denayja29 Год назад
@@sophitiaofhyrule not trynna be rude but I’ve thought those were boobs too but I’ve never seen transition scars so
@DioSpeedwagon
@DioSpeedwagon Год назад
How he messin up my boy Weather Report like that bruh. like he completely missed the essence of the original piece, which captured the JoJo aesthetic and the artists own touch. I‘m sobbing
@otakuweeb8557
@otakuweeb8557 Год назад
I thought it was so obvious that the op was tryna go for a jojo like art style, how did he miss that😭
@jessicacallender
@jessicacallender Год назад
​@@otakuweeb8557 not everybody knows Jojo.
@jessicacallender
@jessicacallender Год назад
@@GoingSwimmingly not everybody knows what Jojo is. no matter how popular. additionally why would he look up something when he wouldn't know what it was supposed to be other than a drawing.
@animeismylife7656
@animeismylife7656 Год назад
I very much agree weather deserves more than that 😭😭
@Joseph_joestars_bf
@Joseph_joestars_bf Год назад
#justiceforweather
@monoex
@monoex Год назад
Oh nuh uh. This guy reminds me of my HS art teacher, who assumed everyone wanted to draw people with a realistic style... and basically ONLY euro-centric features. One of my friends in that class was a Chinese transfer student, and we sat next to each other during a self portrait project. I vividly recall the teacher walking up to us, picking up an eraser, and changing literally everything about her self portrait to make her look less like HERSELF. I dunno, something always rubs me the wrong way about art teachers or critics who think stuff like epicanthal folds, aegyo sal, eyes turned in any way that isn't perfectly straight, curly hair, thick hair, etc. are "wrong." Like no... I'm not gonna make accusations as it's not really my place, but it's a very telling bias.
@gildedpeahen876
@gildedpeahen876 Год назад
He made the asian character have upturned disneyfied European eyes, and took away the fat pooch under the eye, which is a mark of beauty in Korea! Boo! This was all terrible.
@k4nd1incyb3rsp4c3
@k4nd1incyb3rsp4c3 10 месяцев назад
@@wolvesbane_and_buttercups bro if anything black hair has more defined shapes??? like, an afro is very circular, braids and dreads hang down in chunks and are easier to define than white hair. like that's a really poor excuse. it terms of shapes, black hair is way more defined than white hair.
@wolvesbane_and_buttercups
@wolvesbane_and_buttercups 10 месяцев назад
@@k4nd1incyb3rsp4c3 right??? it was so weird and nobody liked her
@oceansolstice608
@oceansolstice608 10 месяцев назад
Wtf how is the art teacher allowed to physically take a student’s artwork and change it? Like they can give tips but like…what?
@nope6021
@nope6021 3 месяца назад
YUP!!! My buddy had an art teacher in high-school who insisted the students needed more *texture* in their art, and more *expression.* Soooo she tossed SAND on my friends painting, insisting it made it better. Said painting was a gift for his partner, who he's still with 10 yrs later. That teacher may have been all about Expression and Abstract Elements and Texture... but heaven forbid you have your own vision for a painting. She would change it to suit her taste before you could even tell her what you were going for.
@riverofchaos13
@riverofchaos13 Год назад
When he “fixed” the character with transition scars made me mad. The character is obviously not a woman but he made them into one, practically detransitioning the peice. All because he thought that it was “wrong” or whatever. I hate art fixers but whether or not it was intentional is in poor taste
@soup5634
@soup5634 Год назад
Exactly! Even if he "didn't know", it just proves that he doesn't communicate with the artist at all.
@Rosalin997
@Rosalin997 Год назад
@@soup5634I didn’t know either 🤷‍♀️ not everyone noticed it
@Dancinglemon
@Dancinglemon 10 месяцев назад
@@Rosalin997People are going to be upset over something like this, it’s a big thing to mess up for a trans person. If it’s an well intentioned oversight that’s fine as long as he realises what he did and doesn’t do it again but it’s something that needs to be addressed.
@odiousghoul
@odiousghoul 10 месяцев назад
​@@Rosalin997no shit you weren't asked to critique the art, he was. he drew over it. no excuse, hes just bad at what he does.
@userhandleb
@userhandleb 8 дней назад
​@@Dancinglemon if you feel offended by every little thing, it'd be better if you go to therapist instead of "transitioning"
@nondescriptindividual3793
@nondescriptindividual3793 Год назад
I was quite shocked when he got rid of the transition markings and - like you said - detransitioned the character all of the fixing disguised as critique is bad enough, but that especially rubs me the wrong way :( (not trans myself, but still - not cool)
@riverofchaos13
@riverofchaos13 Год назад
As a trans ftm person I agree. It’s not cool at all.
@materialgrowIl
@materialgrowIl Год назад
@@riverofchaos13 it wasnt on purpose
@riverofchaos13
@riverofchaos13 Год назад
@@materialgrowIl still it’s not cool regardless if it was on purpose or not
@1roentgen
@1roentgen Год назад
i think it’s likely he just didn’t know, but imo its still a facepalm moment lol
@XemeraldXD
@XemeraldXD Год назад
Even if he didnt know they were topsurgery scars and thought it was a woman, he still wouldve been "fixing" a flat chested woman by giving her huge tits. I dont even know which possibility is worse.
@verymuchcake6553
@verymuchcake6553 Год назад
I CANNOT express how annoyed I am at him completely changing the expression of the sad girl drawing, sure the position of her facial features may of been anatomically unrealistic but it made her look so expressive!
@thatfuzzypotato1877
@thatfuzzypotato1877 10 месяцев назад
I wonder if the eyes being slightly high is to exaggerate the looking-up of her expression. Thr 1/2 1/2 1/2 rule of feature placement is general averages and the original work was still within range. It didnt cause the 'uncanny valley'by being slightly out of perfect proportions. The 'fix'was your standard vanilla pout face and I hated the fix on the eyes. Didnt just adjust placement but completely changed thwir expression! Why!
@Tamaki742
@Tamaki742 Год назад
Back in my art school, whenever we asked our teachers to paint over for guidance, they'd ask us first what direction are we going for, like if the character is supposed to be cute, is it anime style, what parts are these, etc. The guy could at least take the base designs into consideration. It just seems like he just goes with what _he_ wants.
@greta.s_art__
@greta.s_art__ Год назад
I think this is more of an issue with wanting to put out content fast and so by assuming a lot of things he makes many mistakes. Like the idea of helping people is ok, but there is poor comunication on both ends.
@eternallustformedusa4844
@eternallustformedusa4844 Год назад
he’s sucking all the fun parts out of the pieces. cannot be messy. can not be fun. can not be queer. even the unique outfit and unique facial structure had to be changed. he seems to not understand that “imperfections” in a character or in the art piece as a whole can be placed on purpose and mean something. these are the types of people who make me not want to do visual art. no appreciation for the experience and creation if it doesn’t look how they think art should.
@NWolfsson
@NWolfsson Год назад
"This character (The trans dude with puff sleeves) is dramatically melancholic? Mh we can't have that, let's make them solar and joyful. And let's remove the mask, change the hairstyle and change the clothing." My man, the artist specifically asked for technical tips whilst not changing the fashion.
@supotter377
@supotter377 11 месяцев назад
He always tries to follow these ridged rules that should be treated more as guidelines. No one is perfectly symmetrical and always having the same proportions in your art is gonna make you develop some bad same face syndrome as he definitely has.
@neex_da
@neex_da Год назад
If they’re going to do these things they should change their title from “fixing” or “critiquing” your art to REDRAWING you art in my style.
@KhayJayArt
@KhayJayArt Год назад
They won't bc their goal is to humiliate you by saying they made your art better
@dani.5087
@dani.5087 Год назад
at 4:02, where he redraws the jjba fanart, aside from the obvious way he completely destroys the face i'm *losing it* at how he misinterprets the character's horned hat thing as straight hair with horns. If you're going to, in Rin's words, warp something into a weird caricature, at least know what it's fanart of. Jesus christ
@formerctgovernordannelmall1452
Original Fanart of Weather Report: maintains a bit of the original manga’s style, but has its own unique vibe going on, and keeps Weather looking like a badass “Corrected” Weather Fan Art: Fabio as a Homestuck OC
@vshiki4872
@vshiki4872 Год назад
EXACTLY!
@BananLord
@BananLord Год назад
Nah, he entered the Habsburg lineage with that protruding jaw
@asiafracassi5823
@asiafracassi5823 Год назад
Poor Weather...
@jksupergamer
@jksupergamer 10 месяцев назад
Tbh both are kinda bad
@luginni
@luginni 10 месяцев назад
@@jksupergamersure the original art wasn’t the best but he removed all the jojo parts
@wolfgangd3653
@wolfgangd3653 Год назад
The fact that he changed the artstyle created by one of the biggest mangakas in the world Hirohiko Araki... And he didn't even acknowledge that the drawing is ok besides it being a bit deformed, and he drew it ALSO deformed but in an odd "semi realistic" style
@BananLord
@BananLord Год назад
He straight up gave Weather a Habsburg jaw
@DoroNijimaru
@DoroNijimaru 10 месяцев назад
looks like the most recent episode of American Dad where Stan got facial reconstruction surgery (Saving Face)
@DoroNijimaru
@DoroNijimaru 10 месяцев назад
preview.redd.it/just-rewatched-saving-face-and-god-chris-diamantopoulos-v0-f6xb37mgw0bb1.jpg?auto=webp&s=dd63802e2d1936ab8855667b186e68a4ddc3584f
@kookiemilkshake6099
@kookiemilkshake6099 Год назад
As someone that is currently majoring in the fine arts I have had teachers that draw over some of my art before but it's never been over a stylized piece, just studies of real life people and learning proportions. If someone wants to idk improve upon their art style it is nice to have a critique then the artist make the changes themselves. All this is to say, if you want to improve and get critiques it should be on the basics not your own creativity
@cryingwatercolours8127
@cryingwatercolours8127 Год назад
a teacher drew over my art once too… black felt tip scribble outlines. absolutely ruined the soft watercolour piece i was working on. a lil bit of me died that day 😂 all i asked for was some ideas and she demonstrated
@kookiemilkshake6099
@kookiemilkshake6099 Год назад
@@cryingwatercolours8127 oh my god... at least use the same materials
@PthumerianDusk
@PthumerianDusk Год назад
@@cryingwatercolours8127 oh my god that is horrible! Drawing over stuff is tricky enough even when you can do it in a non-destructive way (another layer on a digital piece for example) I don't get why someone would do so on a traditional piece. Just give the feedback and have the student try again ffs. Absolutely horrible
@jermiachrist2049
@jermiachrist2049 Год назад
@@PthumerianDusk I agree, imo redraws and corrections should be done digitally or on tracing paper
@lukassjogren7910
@lukassjogren7910 Год назад
But those are art teachers whos job it is to teach you art and you chose to go to art school knowing this A random kid posting their art on instagram shouldnt be bombardered with unwanted criticism, some people just want to have fun with drawing and thats totally okay! If they ask for help sure but otherwise people just need to learn to shut up imo
@alienatedcanine4680
@alienatedcanine4680 Год назад
As a trans person myself, who has gotten top surgery, i think making them into boobs was probably just an ignorant mistake (hopefully) because i honestly didn’t recognize they were top scars at first glance, and, if someone didn’t know much about trans people (or double mastectomies for that matter at all) they probably wouldn’t recognize it either it’s still a facepalm moment, and he shouldn’t have fixed things that dramatically, i’m only trying to look at it from an optimistic standpoint
@maddieb.4282
@maddieb.4282 10 месяцев назад
Obviously it was a simple mistake but it means he didn’t communicate with the original artist at all before redrawing their entire piece
@websicat
@websicat Год назад
Taking away racial signifiers, useing the extremely rough face layout you get taught at eight years old as gossiple, misunderstanding the stylistic intention of artists, changing fundamentals about a character... does Kenton even like art? 😭
@felix-xd4mx
@felix-xd4mx 10 месяцев назад
i feel like he's a beginner that's really good? his understanding of art seems like beginner to me, he looks very young too... he's technically good at drawing characters that are attractive to him, in his own style, but doesn't seem to understand the essence of art, it's odd
@just_resa
@just_resa Год назад
I think that's a huge problem in the art community. A lot of artists think that the only good art is realism and that a more stylized artstyle is automatically bad. Which is so stupid
@Lumina_Solaris
@Lumina_Solaris Год назад
To paraphrase my sculpture teacher, Thad Duhigg: It's my job to help you elevate your own artwork and style. If your art comes out looking just like mine, I'm failing.
@IronMask57
@IronMask57 Год назад
He's not giving any sort of critique that the person can use to improve, he's just changing it to what he likes.
@OpheliaTerat
@OpheliaTerat Год назад
Tbh with the detransitioned one I think he just mistook the scars for underboob or something. I feel like it would help if he communicated with the artist about what they're trying to go for first. He's also clearly not very experienced with anime styles, so he should probably just stick to critiquing styles he's comfortable with.
@cidevant002
@cidevant002 Год назад
And that is part of the problem she is adressing, that this guy didn't seem to have even talked with their artists to even know what they were going for and therefore help them to get there.
@hoetrocity
@hoetrocity Год назад
How does the look like an under boob? It’s clearly a flat chested person
@Emu19
@Emu19 Год назад
I think the thing that makes this even funnier, is that even if that was what happened, he still inserted his own bias in when he clothed the character 😂 Like, if it was supposed to be a woman with her bacon bits hanging out, why would you change it so drastically haha. He's not really helping anyone achieve the drawing they wanted to achieve, he's helping people achieve the drawing HE wants them to achieve lol
@NWolfsson
@NWolfsson Год назад
@@cidevant002 And I mean, this artist specifically said _in the communication with the "fixer"_ they didn't want to change the fashion... The guy transformed the hip bits into gloves, removed the puffy sleeves, changed the headpiece and removed the mask, alongside with going for a joyful vibe rather than a sad one... Dude had one job.
@simplenlocal
@simplenlocal 11 месяцев назад
@@NWolfsson bro is an average McDonalds worker 💀
@cryingwatercolours8127
@cryingwatercolours8127 Год назад
5:25 this one! literally took the life out of her and made her nose rlly thin and her nose bridge really obviously- basically changed the whole facial structure. first one i saw
@shar4803
@shar4803 Год назад
6:20 The eye proportion thing is good for beginners to have a rough baseline as to where the eyes should be. But that is all it is, a ROUGH baseline, lots of people (esp poc) have features that are not conforming to this art rule! When you have the basics down, you can try to mix it up a bit and slightly deviate from this guide. I agree that the eyes were a bit far from the lower features but everything else was good. It was just the eye to nose ratio.
@Frog_c0rpse
@Frog_c0rpse Год назад
He is helping. Hes showing people what absolutely NOT to do 😂 He’s completely ruined countless pieces of beautiful pieces.
@Alfr3dDaButtler
@Alfr3dDaButtler 11 месяцев назад
That top surgery one is so upsetting to me, as a trans man I love making those scars visible on my male characters because it’s a comfort to me and a way to express my ideas..and he just put the chest back on?? That’s so icky, the scars are there because they didn’t want the chest
@ChibiChidorii
@ChibiChidorii Год назад
I hope that one day an *actual* realism artist does the same to his art
@Mothmansinsomnia
@Mothmansinsomnia Год назад
I really enjoy that you see art for what it is. Its Objective! and every art that is 'corrected' by a random , it looses what makes their art individual. Love your standing point. Have a greate day and stay critical. 💝
@mnpxdrm
@mnpxdrm Год назад
i think you mean subjective!!
@Mothmansinsomnia
@Mothmansinsomnia Год назад
@@mnpxdrm yea, I got lost in translation. Modern art is rather Subjective while old, (classical art) were objective. c: thx
@masonjar1405
@masonjar1405 Год назад
9:57 im a trans guy and ur so right like wtf is he doing to the character designs 😭
@gamegirl8722
@gamegirl8722 Год назад
4:04 - He changed the hat into hair... Why would you bother "fixing" something when you clearly have no idea what it's meant to be like... 💀💀💀
@montymints
@montymints Год назад
6:40 “I’ve normalized the facial features” the caucasity
@no1legobatmanfan
@no1legobatmanfan Год назад
I can’t beleive tjis… bro literally got rid of a characters top surgery?? also on the last example he made the chest bigger??? this man is weird..
@lenny.d884
@lenny.d884 Год назад
Your hand has more attitude than my entire body will ever have
@bruttyc7072
@bruttyc7072 Год назад
I remember seeing him do a ‘critique’ of a piece he thought the character was supposed to be tilting their head back and instead of helping the artist get the perspective on something like that right, he just,,, made them looking face on which rubbed me the wrong way because that’s probably what they needed help with because perspective is fucking hard
@tivaspotato
@tivaspotato Год назад
honestly why i like it when people submit their art to be "fixed" by certain artists like jackie drujko (forgive me if i spelt her name wrong) is bc people like her don't "fix" their art the way some artists do or draw over their art with her own standards and style, but work with the person's already existing art style and give tips as to how their art would work better in a certain context, which in her case is 2d animation. there is a clear purpose in what she's fixing and it's not just an artist imposing their own standars over everyone else.
@goddammithoward
@goddammithoward Год назад
This!! I love her critiques and "fix" videos. They're insanely helpful. She was the first person I thought of who does this "the right way"
@therealdirkstrider4555
@therealdirkstrider4555 Год назад
people in the comments of the vid where he detransitioned the character are insisting that it's "almost impossible" to see the scars. and im here to say that's fucking bullshit. even if it was just a mistake something about that gives me such a major ick, between that and the completely unnecessary hair color change.
@ablacklatina
@ablacklatina Год назад
It feels weird, I'm kinda used to Rin's voice but can associated it with the face 😂
@ceasefireforpalestine
@ceasefireforpalestine Год назад
I thought she was super asian 🥲
@cypstfu
@cypstfu Год назад
@@ceasefireforpalestine shes romanian
@ceasefireforpalestine
@ceasefireforpalestine Год назад
@@cypstfu ik ik
@EvaIdk__Romania
@EvaIdk__Romania Год назад
​@@cypstfu HUH WHAT YAY
@EvaIdk__Romania
@EvaIdk__Romania Год назад
​@@cypstfu YAYAYAYAYYAYAAAAYYYY
@Roses6858
@Roses6858 Год назад
4:02 Aint no way he mades Weather Reports hat in to hair 😭
@Snow_Sailor
@Snow_Sailor Год назад
7:19 As a person who has aegyosal mistaken for eye bags them being removed servely pains me and I will now explode.
@zbvvk
@zbvvk Год назад
As someone who is still a beginner in art. I would really like someone to look at my pieces and tell me what I should improve etc. but after seeing his videos I’m kinda scared lol
@DeeFig66
@DeeFig66 Год назад
I think what's important is to ask about specific things you want to improve and have that person ONLY respond about those specific things. ALSO they have to give you tools so you can go yourself, find these tools & use them your self. Like, I dunno: "I want to improve my facial structure". Then I'd say, to look at facial anatomy images (real ones, not drawn ones) & take notice in how everything is placed & is tied together. Even practice placing where muscles & features should go for a bit to really get a sense of facial balance. Then when you do your own work, keep them in mind. Then it's just practice, practice, practice. People say you should do realism first before stylizing your art but I personally think that you should just do what your heart & inspiration tell you to do. You need to find joy in it & if you get bored practicing basics, then draw stuff for fun & get back to that if you want to keep studying. It's very true that basic exercises in drawing with strengthen your understanding in how to draw but there's more than 1 way to do it.
@yulebones
@yulebones Год назад
I suggest finding a community that draws the sorts of things you like! There are entire websites for some types of art, with forums and such, and people there should be able to give you really good constructive criticism from a place that understands what you're going for. Good critique, like Rin said, isn't like this. A good critique shouldn't say "See all this art? Change all of it." And it should also praise you for the things you've done well to encourage you to keep drawing the way you love.
@DeeFig66
@DeeFig66 Год назад
@Rowan Crane You know what's up! Drawing as to be fun & personal. Otherwise, might as well use AI art for soulless "pretty" pictures.
@PthumerianDusk
@PthumerianDusk Год назад
If you want some valuable feedback, look for examples on how someone gives it before submitting. Good feedback should take into account what you want to do and your style. I was lucky because in the online course I attended the teacher really took notice on what we each wanted to do, it was very rare to have the same advice as any other student if it wasn't exclusively technical. He even gave us some names of artists to go look at based on our styles
@Te3time
@Te3time Год назад
Ideally it should be irl or at least talking to someone one on one so if they have a question or assume something you can immediately answer like if they go "oh here it looks like you were trying to do X" and then you can go "actually I was trying to do Y" that way the critique is actually useful rather than if someone just assumes you were trying to do X and then they tell you how to improve X even though that's not what you wanted to do in the first place
@rachelpickett8832
@rachelpickett8832 Год назад
Great advice! I've not seen this chap's videos but yeah, agree that you have to be careful with criticism and give yourself a chance to evolve your art organically...
@unoriginalpersonALT
@unoriginalpersonALT Год назад
@@aiiluves what?
@therealdirkstrider4555
@therealdirkstrider4555 Год назад
i actually study fine arts, and critique is amazing for improvement. the problem i have is that he's not critiquing shit! like, this guy would be kicked from any actual college-level critique circle. one of the main things with critique is that you have to honor the artist's original intentions and help them elevate it, not just make it look more appealing.
@unoriginalpersonALT
@unoriginalpersonALT Год назад
@@aiiluves but kooleen actually critiques stuff.. she helps people with proportions and also if people didnt like their art being "roasted" why would they post it in? lol she does say "this is how _i_ would do it" not in a way to tell them, "this is how you should draw" but just giving her fans, that clearly enjoy her art, a way that she would do something.
@aiiluves
@aiiluves Год назад
@@unoriginalpersonALT yeahh sorry bout that deleted it tho, the comment
@overgrownkudzu
@overgrownkudzu 11 месяцев назад
critique is good but to give criticism you first need to understand what was something is going for, so you can then improve upon those things. he seems to completely ignore the style and subjects and just slaps some proportion on it, sometimes not even correctly.
@MybodyJetBlackschoice
@MybodyJetBlackschoice Год назад
THE WAY HE FUCKED UP WEATHER REPORT HAS ME SOBBING
@Nhaptenkenh
@Nhaptenkenh Год назад
Ikkk
@Cinnie.Stories
@Cinnie.Stories Год назад
If someone tells you a part isn't working, they're probably right. If they tell you how to fix it, they're probably wrong. No one can art for you, your style is unique to you!
@KiraandtheSurvivalPod
@KiraandtheSurvivalPod Год назад
You deserve millions of followers. Keep going. I'm not even an artist - I can hardly draw a stick figure, but this is entertaining as f***.
@Shiralkian
@Shiralkian Год назад
I wonder how he'd fare with my stuff, I purposefully draw features way outside the beauty canon because they're very underrepresented (and because I have them :D). It'd be funny to send a caricaturized self-portrait and end up with a beautified pretty picture 'cause that's what he likes to draw, lol.
@NWolfsson
@NWolfsson Год назад
Yassified underrepresented features 💀
@gints2766
@gints2766 Год назад
Jackie Droujko has good examples of how to do it right, she has actually good videos doing this. She maintains the original art entirely while using editing and liquify tool and says what she’s doing and why. Only some parts are redrawn and it’s coming from someone who is a professional character designer with a professional ability in character design, colour, lighting, posing. It just feels right, I think it can be done right. I would want some artists to do it to my art to see what they would change for their aesthetic.
@Drakochannojutsu
@Drakochannojutsu Год назад
The way he changes all the art he touches to more white "conventional beauty" standards
@CaffeAmericanoIsMyKryptonite
I came across your video on my feed and I was intrigued by the title and figured I'd watch it. No regrets, you spit out a lot of good points and you're so damn funny.
@confusedcrying986
@confusedcrying986 Год назад
The de-transition just pissed me off. As a trans guy that really just made my blood boil.
@crowfeatherz
@crowfeatherz Год назад
That teal haired character that he 'fixed' was looking at an angle. Does he not understand the concept.. of someone looking down a little..? Why did he make them face up??? I'm screaming
@gsprout_official
@gsprout_official Год назад
I'm about to cry, he just changed the whole identity of those characters. 💀😭
@lens_turtles
@lens_turtles Год назад
the way he went:"I normalised the facial features" LIKE EXCUSE YOU? Normalised???? nah man open your eyes and see
@aequoreavicq
@aequoreavicq 10 месяцев назад
A big problem with all these “art fixers” have in common, is that they change the proportions and features to make them more white. wither they realize it or not, they are. The traditional “proper proportions” taught that are supposed to replicate the “old masters” are very Eurocentric. Not only that, but they erase the “ugliness” of characters. All of which are features that aren’t Eurocentric or realistic. Not everything needs to be pretty or happy, and they can’t understand that.
@iconsumetea
@iconsumetea Год назад
he's able to recognize that there's something to improve but he can't figure out what it is so he just redraws it ☠️ in the drawing with the person with blue hair all that he had to do was to maybe bring the nose and mouth up a bit, instead he changed the whole drawing?? like how did the eye shape relate to the height of the facial features
@glow-jv6wt
@glow-jv6wt 7 месяцев назад
completely agree with every point you made. these aren’t critiques. these are redraws. i can’t even fathom how he even justifies these as critiques, because like you said, there is no back and forth discussion being had between himself and the artists who submit work to him. if he had the smallest amount of respect for the original works, i genuinely believe he could help fix what might be considered the weaker parts of the work while retaining the artists style and the vibe they’re going for.
@Suniixox
@Suniixox Год назад
BRO WHAT DID HE DO TO MY BOY WEATHER REPORT 😭😭
@lightdolce
@lightdolce Год назад
DUDE "FIXED" THE HAIRSTYLE AND EVERYTHING 😭😭
@SlightlyAlive.
@SlightlyAlive. Год назад
I cant get over that he re-titty-fied that one drawing. so many other issues, but like fr??
@oryantge
@oryantge 3 месяца назад
I love jackie droujko because she always tries to maintain their style, while just editing the anatomy or pose to make it more dynamic.
@mrbusinesss1
@mrbusinesss1 Год назад
NAHHHHH WHEN HE DETRANSITIONED THE CHARACTER 😭😭😭
@avawilliams4979
@avawilliams4979 Год назад
The redoing of Weather Report’s face from jjba is so fucking funny. Like it looks NOTHING like the original character bro.
@eggtoucher
@eggtoucher Год назад
his art style is literally "pretty bitches only" /neg
@purpletailsproductns
@purpletailsproductns Год назад
not only did he mangle poor weather report, making his hat into hair and giving him a weird white guy smoulder, the way he draws chests is uncomfortable. he detransitioned that one character, and on the one with the red dress (that he also made the eyes MILES apart) he made their bust a bit bigger?? also again w the person who wanted to improve their art and not the fashion, there was NO reason to take away half the outfit. that isnt what they asked for! if they used thinner lines and more highlights, i think thatd make their design work pop more.
@miles1560
@miles1560 Год назад
Genuinely there are a million ways he could be critiquing these pieces without doing what he does- like on the last one, I know why he made the character blonde. It's totally because the value shading is all too similar, muddying an already dense design more. What he should have done is make it greyscale, demonstrate and explain value grouping (by copying and doing a side by side where he changed up the values a little while preserving the haircolor) and explain the *why* he does it. Like, in the first one? I can agree that the features on the face are a little low. But then he did shit like changing the expression, tilting the eyes, and shit that shouldn't be touched. Art critique should always cater to how a person can apply art values to their style to make it more like what they want.
@jankhambrams
@jankhambrams Год назад
I greatly appreciate this video! Not just from an angle of having realized that online critique is...difficult at best, but also that I think encouragement can go a very long way. It takes time for folks to learn not just how to make art, but also what art they desire to make.
@lemonmeat
@lemonmeat Год назад
4:07 jojo fan here to tell you how badly that dude butchered the original character.. that character is weather report from jojo part 6, HE TURNED HIS HAT INTO HAIR LMAOOOOOO
@CorvusCarmen
@CorvusCarmen Год назад
I'd like to point something out with the character with white hair and horns. This has most definitely been said before but that is fanart if a character from jojo's bizzare adventure, his name is weather report and his hair is up in an almost pillar shape, when this guy redraws art, not only is he misunderstanding what is originally shown (which I notice he does a lot in just what you've shown here) but he also messes with the character's design which is 1. not what he was asked to do and 2. belittling.
@juliawho
@juliawho Год назад
omg people have to relax. He is literally getting paid to do it. It’s not like it’s unwanted. All in all I think people should be less attached to their art if they want to progress
@Isimarie
@Isimarie Год назад
One person I think who does the “drawing over art” thing well is Saito Naoki. He really goes in on the intent, and while he draws over he explains every step, how to get across what you want, and the end result always keeps the essence of the original artist
@jumies4056
@jumies4056 Год назад
i went on a bit of a ramble ahead so i just want to preface it by saying that you're really funny and i had fun watching this video despite how frustrating the actual subject was. on that note, i also really like how you express your points and how you emphasize that what he's doing doesn't work because every artist is different and has their own skill set and their own intentions and that art is something too personal to be one size fits all. i think that's a perspective that can be lacking in those kinds of "critiques," and even lacking in actual professional art teachers which SUCKS. there's so much beauty in all the different ways that people make art and express themselves through that, to try and erase that and "fix" it feels so disingenuous. i appreciate the way you see that and point it out and talk about it. have a good day! 💙
@KuriousCitten
@KuriousCitten Год назад
People ask for something new, and then when they get it they suddenly don’t want it anymore. ITS SO HARD TO PLEASE ANYONE ANYMORE
@sunolili862
@sunolili862 Год назад
Cooleen is guilty of that too. She erases all the personality from pieces she submitted. I remember her fan submitting a drawing of a kakeguri character - a teenage girl with a fairly sad look on her face, kind of blocky, sketchy art style, and cooleen made her into a perfect smug Barbie doll that doesn't even look like like a young girl anymore. Like your art not perfectly fitting European beauty standards is a fucking flaw
@randomguy3895
@randomguy3895 Год назад
the intensity of the eye contact in this video is awesome, I've never felt less blind. Thank you Rin!
@KC-135A
@KC-135A Год назад
An artist i think has mastered the video art critique is Sinix Design with his Paintover Pals videos - he doesn’t paint over the entire pieces and follows the requests of the person (AND he knows what an art style is!!) I’m totally with you on your critique of this creator’s critiques and honestly the problems you listed in the beginning with video critiques as a whole.
@Te3time
@Te3time Год назад
Yess I love sinix he always tries to enhance the vibes of the original piece instead of making it fit his own aesthetic and when he changes stuff he also explains why you might want to change it that way AND he never makes it sound like his opinions are fact but rather just suggestions
@esztertakacs737
@esztertakacs737 Год назад
YASSS I've been waiting for someone to speak up about this! The saddest thing is that (from what I've seen) soooo many people in his Tiktok comment section agree with him, some people are downright mad that he gets so much negative feedback.
@rebelsleighter
@rebelsleighter Год назад
why dont they just call it "redrawing ur art in my own style" that would be sm nicer
@minx9325
@minx9325 11 месяцев назад
Mm in my opinion lot of these “correctional” RU-vidrs really irk me because most of them have only studied one “ideal” face shape from one demographic and then “correct” the artist’s art according to that Which not only leads to same face syndrome intensified, the removal of crucial features in poc (bigger foreheads, larger noses, bigger lips, stronger cheekbones, headshape litterally changing the eyeshape u get the idea) and they also end up taking away the uniqueness of the artist style And stuff like removing “imperfections” like lazy eye or discoloration on the skin And in general idk how to feel about taking someone’s art and just drawing on top of it to “fix” and “correct” art
@minx9325
@minx9325 11 месяцев назад
And then there comes rediculous things like 9:10 Where nothing was truly wrong with the peice they just want it in their style Like ???? The eyes completely changed the outfit is different along with the hair and the boobs got bigger for some reason like ?? All he did there was take the character and draw it his way there was nothing constructing about that Maybe most of these artists have good heart and just really poor execution but with big following and easily influenced artists you should take that into consideration If you want a blooming flower give it the right treatment to grown dont just plant a new one (That made no sense but it’s like what five in the am for me so)💀
@Lou-fb9ii
@Lou-fb9ii Год назад
'He messes up the vibes.' - Couldn't agree more :D
@scorchingbread
@scorchingbread Год назад
This, this, this!! Though I had to drop out, when I was in art school we did critiques to help us on our subject. And it never addressed the style, it was always technical (i.e, I really like the composition, but think there could be more variety in shading.) And that was just us speaking, walking around our easels or drawing horses. The only time a mark got made on our work was by the professor in our beginning stages to help us with the proportions of an object by making a small dash in charcoal where a certain part of it would end.
@roaring.can.opener
@roaring.can.opener 6 месяцев назад
Asking for red lining is really helpful. Without re-doing the whole thing and just explaining anatomy is really helpful.
@Haruki_chan
@Haruki_chan Год назад
Love your energy, your personality, and your art !! and you're so pretty too !!!!
@rubenpereyra2967
@rubenpereyra2967 Год назад
We a legion. 5.8k !
@squesh5974
@squesh5974 11 месяцев назад
not only did he take away the whole idea with the face being obscured BUT THE DETRANSITION? HELLO?
@aleech1933
@aleech1933 10 месяцев назад
I think I understand where you come from, disliking the idea of “fixing” someone’s art (even after receiving permission). Art is really subjective so the idea used to peeved me too but i think a good example of someone who does this is Saito Naoki. I find his tips really helpful since he touches a lot on composition and how it can better convey what the original artist wanted to convey. He tries not to change the original artstyle, and actually researches or reads the background story behinds the character or oc, and tells the audience when the things he changes are more personal preference and taste. So yeah if you already hate these types of videos he might not change your mind or anything, but he’s a good option for those who are searching for new approaches to drawing! 😊
@ChaoticMarko
@ChaoticMarko Год назад
9:14 the "improved" one just looks constipated 💀💀
@daniellet6517
@daniellet6517 Год назад
i just love everything about the message you’re putting out with this, so sweet
@odin-aries
@odin-aries Год назад
I agree. Art is a VERY deeply personal thing. If someone asks you to critique their art, stay true to the style, and build on it or give them ideas they can try. But you should never NEVER redraw someones art the way YOU want it to be, and call it Critique. Thats just disrespectful. And detransitioning a character is also VERY disrespectful. What if that character was an embodiment of the artist and their soul?? You dont DO that! That guy is NUTS!
@entirelybonkers8832
@entirelybonkers8832 Год назад
I love how his videos just kind of take away all of the character and creativity and emotion from all of the art he “fixes” and he usually ends up ruining it not everyone is conventionally attractive and not every character is perfect and that’s ok if every character fit the “golden standard” of human face every character would look the same
@minsungswifey
@minsungswifey 7 месяцев назад
HE UN-WEATHERED WEATHER REPORT 💀 he thought weathers hat thing was weird hair 😭
@kryptic.korvid
@kryptic.korvid Год назад
Ok can we talk about the fact that he's just whitewashing these drawings?? Like with the first drawing he did, I forgot what it's called but that line on the lower eyelid is a common feature among Asian people and it's actually often exaggerated in certain makeup styles because it's seen as beautiful by a lot of cultures in eastern Asia. And he gets rid of it because he thinks it's to make her look "tired"??? No babe, it's an ethnic feature
@Kays_Cottagee
@Kays_Cottagee Год назад
this is why i dont ask people online to give there opinions on my art it took so long to draw in a style i like and people suck so yes stay safe
@LJXrot
@LJXrot Год назад
And another thing about Kenton hes apparently been called out for saying passive aggressive things on Black history month webtoon posts on Instagram saying the whole thing was cringe. It checks out considering he constant pushes for Eurocentric features and gets rid of any uniqueness and pushes for this conventionally attractive stuff
@lordgigaraticus1121
@lordgigaraticus1121 Год назад
I feel like I am being yelled at by a cute French mother. Thank you🥹🥹🥹
@crappylittleelf4205
@crappylittleelf4205 Год назад
This is like the most favorite video I have ever seen in the art community! I love your vibes, its just amazing. I would love to see more content like this! I will be here when you get big. :)
@Mars-qe1cg
@Mars-qe1cg 11 месяцев назад
his critiques to me feel less like "here let me give you some pointers on your art" and way more like "i dont care about what you drew, watch me!! look how good i can draw a conventionally pretty face!!!" ☠️ like hes teaching these young artists to only ever draw one face in one way
@edenwayne8407
@edenwayne8407 11 месяцев назад
I saw the art in the thumbnail and i can immediately notice that the original artist had great choice with their color, specifically with the shading. Infact I've been trying to learn this sort of shading, using desaturated and hue-shifted colors in the shadow. The sort of stylized realism that I really love Honestly my only criticism I have for their art is better application of their materials, and since its a close up which makes the hair take up somewhere like 30% of the artwork, the hair needs more attention. It has the texture of hair but not the shape of hair which kind of clashes with the style of the rest of the piece.
Далее
Kooleen and Her INSANE Tutorials
20:14
Просмотров 455 тыс.
Stray Kids <ATE> UNVEIL : TRACK "MOUNTAINS"
00:59
Crazy Girl destroy RC CARS 👩🤪🚘🚨
00:20
Просмотров 4,2 млн
Kawanocy And His Disgusting Comic
44:00
Просмотров 414 тыс.
This Artist Traced AI Art And DENIES It?!
11:33
Просмотров 230 тыс.
Ylanast Is A Scam Artist
17:43
Просмотров 364 тыс.
Kooleen Pissed The Internet Off...AGAIN??
18:54
Просмотров 379 тыс.
KOOLEEN: The Most Hated Artist On The Internet
29:46
Просмотров 324 тыс.
Art Lore is a Plague on TikTok
25:06
Просмотров 164 тыс.
Fixing YOUR art!
21:02
Просмотров 290 тыс.
pretending I SUCK at drawing, then drawing them
13:14
телега - hahalivars
0:54
Просмотров 2,6 млн