You seems to give legitimacy for Tibet being invaded and ruled by the CCP by comparing the reign in the 1950s and under the control of the PRC. How would you know that Tibet would not progress under the Dalai Lama from the 1950s till today through its own religious and spiritual path rather than the materialistic path as you have portrayed? Tibet could jolly well be like Bhutan... its people being the happiest in the world.
The Bhutanese is happy because they are ignorant of the outside world. If they knew how poor they are when compare to the developed countries of the world, they won't be happy anymore.
China government liberated Tibetan and lead themselves into betterment. Western countries media and politicians hide many facts away as they intend to break Tibet away from China and temp India to invade these area like what they did with UK influence and support at Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh. General perspective to TIbetan was living happily under the previous westernized Dalai Lama (whom have been living in US with millions being paid to him per annum) but people didn't know the serf system that had caused so much suffering, unjust, death etc. The western propaganda machinery cover up all these negative element and fact about the life in Tibet. Now majority of them in Tibet are living in better environment, happier, modern and knowledgeable BUT China government and people must not let your guard down and takes thing for granted, those enemy will not stop their aggression to cause trouble in Tibet, Xinjiang and South China (well nothing much they can do to Northern and North West China now)
My biggest dream is to be able to bring my son to visit our motherland, China! I was born and raised in Malaysia and my son is American, but we are Chinese descendent. What a beautiful country and can’t wait to visit her!
From France : Thanks Alex, very instructive, and wonderfull pictures, and I love the music. I am reading a lot about Chinese history these days. Its incredible what your country as achieved in the last 100 years. PRC gives me so much hope when the rest of the world makes me dispair.
@@fannybirot2362 About the US anti-China propaganda, I think it would help if French and Chinese schools could set up student exchange programs. That would be very good for both country's relations.
mao communist party liberated tibetan serfs from slavery & oppression by the elites & ruling class noblemen led by dalai lama. All slaves were freed & became equal citizens of China and former landlords lands were distributed to all tibetan man & their families.
Who is this Alex , is he from Uighur or a foreigner. Alex does not looks like a Uighur name. Must be PRC’s propaganda hired person. He try to show worst video of 1920s and try to show best of PRC’s achievements but he didn’t show the destructions of Tibetan culture , language, script, history, Buddhism and huge migrations of Han ppl into Tibet, great damage of natural resources. PRC took a lot of natural minerals and they just spent 10 percent minerals back on Tibet and rest spent on China. They r truly robbers, I mean Chinese Communist party. They just only think on power and money, they don’t hve humanity at all….!!!
@@livelife5448 LOL you are ironic... But first who are you? How much you know about China? Did you even been to China? Or just knowing China via western media? LOL You questioned Alex identity but he's actually born and raised in Xinjiang. If you been to Tibet, you will know all you mentioned are craps. On every single RMB notes, you can find all ethnicity languages. Potala Palace is still there, Buddha statues are still there. Even the human skin and bone artifacts are still there. You should question where are the native Indian American heritage? Native American almost extinct due to the white rob and massecre.
@@halfbottleofwater I hve been to China and Tibet as well. I want to say that potala image on the money is not real potala and real tibet is actually lost in the mouth of dragon CCP. Only left is most properly just image
@@livelife5448 😂🤣😂🤣I think you are the one not real but talk craps.... Potala is still the same Potala in Tibet... Just that no more nobles, no more slavery and no more skinning of children and teenages to make thangkas, and using human bones to make artifacts. LOL the one losing are those nobles Tibetan diaspora that escape. The population of Tibetan diaspora ain't growing. In contrast, the population of Tibetan in China has grown a few folds.
@@premchopra6521 Says the idiot brainwashed by U$ anti-China propaganda . You should stop consuming so much U$ propaganda before your brain lose function . 2022 new account, are you 1450?
To be honest, there were less than 10% of population in Tibet at that time were regarded as human. They were nobles and religious lamas, while over 90% of the rest were serfs who were like livestock. They lacked food, had no clothes but only some cloth to cover the bodies, and had an average lifespan of less than 30. The ruling class in Tibet was expelled by the CPC, while the remaining serfs became proud Chinese citizens. Their population has now doubled, and their life expectancy far exceeds that of modern South Asian countries. Education, healthcare, and income are all close to the average level of China. And today, do you want to persuade them to bring back those cannibalistic nobles and religious leaders to continue enslaving them? You can try running to the center of any Tibetan community in Tibet and loudly proclaiming your idea. I'm curious how long you can hold out without being beaten to death
Oh god again a disgusting history professor. Little knowledge is very dangerous. So don't poke your nose in Tibetan history. Share your false version to your dirty Chinese people.
Great job Alex👍👍👍 The world needs to know that it was PLA who truly liberated Tibetans from serfdom. According to Guardian news reporting at that time, 90% of Tibetans were slaves of different caste under a religious monarchy up to time of Dalai Lama who now lives in india. Uass has been financing the religious monarch in exile and india providing sanctuary using it as the Tibet card against China. Just compare the standard of living between Tibetans governed by PRC in Tibet and the Dalai Lama separatists living in india and one would undoubtedly appreciate what the Chinese government had done to not only free Tibetans from serfdom but also the spectacular transformation that happened in a few decades.
You are so right! 99.999999999% of the Tibetan people do not want to go back to Tibet under the slave system before 1950, and there are many portraits of Mao Zedong in the homes of Tibetan herdsmen. They thank Mao Zedong from the bottom of their hearts for bringing them and their generations The descendants were released from slavery.
and not the slavery society where Dalai was chosen as ... if Dalai love Tibetian he should go back Tibet be the leader there lead their people and not as refugee in India enjoying his life with the support by those slavery head ( tibetian rebelion ) who refuse abolish slavery ... as Budha born from King/Royal family willing to take the hard path to understand life and cont teach people ... Dalai is nothing compare to Budha and the reincarnation is so fake ... stop telling me Dalai love democracy .... i feel sick of tht
I noticed on RU-vid there are some Tibetan name users, who would argue anything happens right now in the land of Tibet is the the most shitty situation. On one occasion I was explaining to a Tibetan name user he should go see the temples in Lhasa where believers bring countless offerings, exotic fruits,candy,food, alcohol and tea,this didn't happen 50 years ago. Walking into the tea house and seeing a full house of locals,man and woman,old and young socializing and having a good time, this didn't not happen 50 years ago. This Tibetan name user of RU-vid finally said to me,he is not not a Tibetan. 🤦I laughed so hard.
Where is freedom speech.what about free press. What about Tiananmen Square massacre. What about millions of Chinese people killed during cultural revolution.why people protest during Covid restriction. Why Xi is president for life. Why China is the only country being friend with dictator and criminal putin.
This the best evident on how an impoverished Tibet has transformed itself under meritocracy government. By eradicating the culture of elitism, the vast majority of Tibetans got to enjoy a better quality of life. This is at the dismay of the West who would wish to see that Tibetans remained poor and be dependent on the handouts from Washington.
Actually the vast majority of Chinese people live in total misery, plus you talk as if Tibet wouldn't have evolved by itself without the invasion and opression of China... but keep up the Chinese propaganda. Ask tibetans themselves about the shit you are saying...
but have instead enforced orders totally erasing Tibetan culture and language in Tibet by separating and isolating Tibetan youth in boarding schools away from their families and connection to their Tibetan roots!
@@Sincerelychem That’s just education…. Tibetan allowed to speak Tibet as they like. But it’s very important for minority to learn the majority language: Mandarin.
@@BruhTNT4258 education is the key to everything. They r using education to separate families and eliminate any cultural connection they have and brainwash them in these schools. When they come home they cant communicate w their parents. Is that not sad?
tibet is a huge province...people in the country side live far apart from school in towns & cities. unlike city kids that can easily walk or ride a bicycle to school. don't think with your butt and talk rubbish out from that sh1t hole of yours. @@Sincerelychem
fack your chairman Mao and communist party, how long will your evil china hold tibet ? you people killed 1.2 million Tibetans, so we will definitely take our revenge
I visited Lhasa in 2010. What surprised me most when I visited Potala Palace was the luxury and amount of gold and jewery that were used to build the shrines of each of the past Dalai Lama were unbelievable. Buddhism belief is we come and leave this world empty handed, how come past Dalai Lamas' shrines in Potala Palace are so luxury ?
Here I'm a Napalese, speaking about Tibetan people's misery in the past, we've a very close acquaintance with Tibetan people historically and culturally_Before Tibet was liberated and reunited with China, the dalai lamas, predecessors of current dalai lama even persuaded the serfs (Tibetan people) to eat 'herbal medicine' that was made from his dehydrated feces turned into pills look alike. The serfs then were made to believe it in a true sense that they were indeed medicines. That is how horrible was the situation of Tibetan people in those days.
That is very interesting. Do you mind elaborating on the topic? Any recources or links to sources? I am eager to learn more about the topic. I am spending a lot of time trying to open the eyes of westerners to what really happened in Tibet.
@@MediaCreatorscheck results from Tantric Buddhism😂 there are unaccountable layers of rites, each of them may mean having sex with someone or sacrificing humans.
Oh now Nepalese are speaking shitty things too. We know how much CCP paid n your poor country is in debt. We know how you people have tortured Tibetans n handed them to Chinese government. That is why deadly earthquakes are occuring in your country. So daju, if you don't know the history of Tibet, don't speak. Don't you know that your people are taking refuge status in foreign country under the name of Tibétains? Shameless
I am Indian and my grandpa use to visit lhasa, Tibet very often for trading. He told me that the people were very kind. I live in Uttarakhand which shares it's border with China and Nepal, I still get to visit my relatives in Nepal everday as the houses opposite to my house all are under Nepal.
jab India British ke gulam tha tab tibetan kabi bhi aisa Nahi bolte thi ki Tibet aur British border share karte hai lekin tum sacchai janke bhi India aur china border share karte hai aisa bolta hai agar sach kaho toh northeast India, ladakh aur Uttarakhand yeh sab tibat ka part hai samjhe
Tumhari bhosidike prem chopra ki aulad ..tumko saale mein chinese dikhai deta hun?😂... I am from uttrakhand. Haramkhor jab tune uttrakhand dekha nahin wahan ke logon ko janta nahin toh bukradi kahe chodta bey? 😊
RU-vid is interesting, when you talked about tibet good then only few people is recommended. If the video is about tibet bad , then you will be recommended so many times
Tibet 'rose from the ashes of feudalism' into a thriving society within the same growth years as the rest of China. It is good to see such phenomenal change for the good of all people.
So you agree that Tibet was an independent, run by feudalism. Ok, now they are educated, modern and serfs are no more seen, kind China should free and return it back, right ?
Tibet is and will always be a part of China. Those who live in India or other western countries claiming to be real Tibetans cannot and will not represent us which are real Tibetans who actually living in Tibet. Those people don't want or are willing to understand what Tibet is like now. We don't want the so-called "Free Tibet". In fact, now Tibet is free in a real sense. We have freedom of speech, freedom of religion, no more poverty, development, believe it or not, everything is just amazing. Those people always like to imagine that the CCP has repeatedly persecuted all Tibetans, which is ridiculous. Come on, come to Tibet, come to your homeland and see for yourself.
99% of the Tibetans in tibet are secretly feeling for freedom but under communist China not possible. No freedom of speech.you don’t represent Tibetans inside Tibet. Hahahaha.
Everybody feeling tibet should have invaded by British instead of Communist China who killed millions of Chinese intellectuals during cultural revolution. 36 million Chinese died during great famine. Thousands of Chinese students were massacred in Tiananmen Square asking for democracy.these are the one concerned to the world. The world is not talking about Tibet. There are so many other problems china facing like human rights problem with Uyghur genocide.president Xi act like dictator and choose president for life.China is the only country being friendly with war criminal Putin of Russia.spying on other countries with secret balloon. Chinese people are facing economic downfall. Ignorant people like you talking about Tibet and Tibetan haha. The world is not interested in tibet and Tibetans. This is small problem for them.
Hahhahahahahhahah Oh, sure, and there are angels now in Tibet, and flying cars and free icecreams in every corner... and all thanks to the Chinese Communist Party hahahhahah seriously, you chinese trolls are so funny!
I saw some videos overseas calling for the independence of Tibet, Xinjiang, and Inner Mongolia, and I felt inexplicable. Where does this go. To be honest, no matter how many problems the CCP has, it still treats ethnic minorities very well in China. The ethnic minorities enjoy many preferential policies, but the Han people do not. And based on our own experience growing up in China, people of all ethnic groups get along very well. Except for sometimes different diets and clothing, people from different ethnic groups simply ignore them at other times.
Fantastic video as always, Alex👍 I've been seeing many videos of small towns (county seat town) in Tibet lately (in Chinese) lately out of personal interest, just me being nerdy haha😂. I still don't understand the language tbh but I don't mind the language barrier and I can confirm with certainty they're all very modern and clean. Even on the most remote part of China such as Mêdog (Motuo) County bordering the India state of Arunachal Pradesh, the main town itself is very modern and fitted with the latest infrastructure standard and public amenities (yes, modern supermarket too)! Native Tibetans also live there and enjoy a prosperous lifestyle contrary to the common beliefs🥰
The liberal west is extremely fearful of letting people know the real China, because it is an example of authoritarian conservative system that is able to build a prosperous country. The same reason why they always chat shit about Hungary (despite Hungary being part of the west) and discredit all the improvement made during the so called "authoritarian right" regime. The same reason why they are fear mongering when Italy vote for the so called "far right" during the latest election, or when the so called "far right" won in Israel. This is in contrast with how the librul left destroy civilized society, such as heavily increasing crime rate, increasing degeneracy, etc due to their unnatural outlook of life, and they are most fearful of the fact that more and more westerners realize that authoritarian conservatism is the only thing that can make their country great again. No matter where you live, the enemy is not any of these imaginary foreign enemies, but the regressive left which promote wars and fearmongering. Ukraine war would not happen if Trump is still in power. But instead now we see democrats colluding with corrupt ukrainian officials to siphon American tax money.
Tibet lucky be part of China. If Tibet isn't under by PRC rule. Probably Tibet now is still the same as 1950 which have no change. Thank you so much PRC ❤👍
I watched the Last Emperor, starring John Long, an American film directed by an Italian. The 1920's shot reminds me of the the Tibetan monks in that movie, travelling to the Forbidden City to pay homage to the new emperor, Puyi.
Fascinating. Thank you. Tibetan Traditionalists will despise the takeover. Modernalists will applaud it. I am guessing there are families today where both sleep in the same bed & argue only after eating great meals together. Life as a human being . Appreciate the learning. Thank you. don
(Tibet) A lot of attention should be paid to the production of magic utensils, for example, dead bodies cannot be used to make utensils. This means that the production process must ensure that the raw materials are alive. Therefore, the production of skull instruments is more difficult. Many people don't know why the eyes of the serfs were gouged out. Sometimes eye gouging is just a simple step in crafting a focus. Using serfs as raw materials was very common before PLA liberated Tibet. It can be said that the death of those landlords and monks is not a pity
hands down it was a theocratic serf based society ruled by monks and nobilities, my BF is half Tibetan and his grandma lost 1st two of her unborn children during Tibet's harsh winter for working in the manor of her "owner", they work for the elites and sleep with their owners' livestocks there's a famous book called "The Struggle for Modern Tibet", an autobiography of Tashi Tsering who was a member of Dalai Lama's palace dance group, he died in China in 2014 and honored as China's “Inheritors of intangible cultural heritage ”, his autobiography did publish in China but censored many details, Because he was sent to the Potala Palace at the age of 10, soon got raped by a high ranked monk and he took the boy as a sex toy, later on, that rich monk sponsored the young boy to went to America to study, he returned to Tibet after the 14th Dalai Lama's fleeing highly suggest you to read the book if you want 2 understand more abt Tibet and probably will have an unbiased view towards both sides
Quoted by you: "they work for the elites and sleep with their owners' livestocks" Do you know that there were 4 categories Serf in Tibet during Dalai Lama times & earlier ?? 1) live in the same house as the master 2) live within the house compound 3) I can't remember 4) those that live with the animal & animal' shit, owned by the Master. Your grandma was the 4th category !! The lowest of all serf. Once a serf, will forever be a serf including their children & grandchildren & all descendants. As an old Taoist/Buddhist may our Goddess of Mercy & Lord Buddha bless your grandma & all Tibetans with peace & prosperity. And all those who perished by the harsh live during the Dalai Lama' times & earlier. Er Mi Tau Fut. ps: as an old Taoist/Buddhist, I have TOTALLY no more respect to Dalai Lama who is bought & paid for by the foreign power with at least 2 million USD yearly. He personally owned 300 serfs.
we know you know,but the main midea don't know? You know why? Because the west government want folish the normal people, when the midea they can't control like tiktok came up, then the politics want to block and shut down.
I have travelled through a lot of Tibetan areas, so many families worship Mao Zedong's portrait, regarding him as the avatar of Buddha, even more sancred than Dalai Lama
You are right that the Chinese minority who are poor and neglected by the ROC (Taiwan) government are loyal supporters of Mao, in return Mao gave special administrative territory status to minorities.
As a Tibetan, these chinese propaganda don't even know which to play music, its a chinese song, using tibetan instrument. The CCP promotes music that blends traditional Tibetan elements with Han Chinese and modern pop influences. This fusion aims to present Tibetan culture as an integral part of the broader Chinese cultural mosaic. The music often includes Tibetan instruments, melodies, and lyrics but is composed and produced in a way that aligns with Chinese nationalistic themes.
Good to see people in Tibet live free from chain of Dalai Lama, people should to live free from religious worship and crawl through the street make no sense. They should worship real God without dressing jewelry and burning incense sticks. People are the world shouldn’t worship to any human or image. real God, God never required anyone to worship Him with anything sacrifice, but God only requires people to worship Him only believe, worship in the Spirit and in the truth.
I went to Tibet over 20 yrs ago. Tibetan ppl may not appreciate being freed from slavery as they believe that if they were slaves, that was their fate. And by their actions, they would be elevated in their next life. Religious Tibetans for example would walk and crawl for miles to the monastery in Lhasa, give all their money to the very corrupt monastery, and then beg for alms outside the monastery. In my eyes this is crazy. But it’s what they believe…
the perfectly conditioned brainwashed gullible ignorant serfs masses dalai lama & his ruling class elites preyed & leeched on. Till now, they are still very butt burted living in india doing nothing much living off cia funding.
might not? you should be more firm if you are able to provide solid evidence. And you should travel there again now to see if they have changed their mind. Nobody wants to be slave, not you, not me, nor the Tibetan people. They might have believed it was their fate because they were brainwased by the Dalai Lama, but with correct education, people will understand, all men and women are born equal.
surprise, i've never thought about tibet would transform with modern looking society. crystal clear sky, looks no pollution, western medias never aired this program.
Terima kasih Alex untuk video yang bermanfaat ini. Apakah anda juga punya vlog apa yang terjadi di Xinjiang pada etnis Uyghur? Apa benar pemerintah PKC ingin memberangus Muslim disana? Jika PKC ingin memberangus Muslim, mengapa hanya terjadi pada etnis Uyghur saja, bukankah etnis Hui, Dongxiang, Bonan, Uzbek, Tajik dan lainnya juga mayoritas Islam? Jika anda sudah buat vlognya, mohon berikan linknya pada balasan anda ya. Sebelumnya saya ucapkan terima kasih, semoga channel ini dapat mencerdaskan manusia untuk menerima berita yang sesuai dengan fakta, bukan yang ditumpangi oleh kepentingan politik.
Proofs of the so-called-genosida. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-67pU0Ybovnc.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-CqiW1GrmMj0.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-4omEaTJyyCM.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-xNbwWzKi0Dc.html Well, dont know how real this is. But they certainly look turkic. At the very least, they arent han folks. And oh look...mandarin on the door. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-1-ef9t2slCE.html Seriously mate, who spread the info about it? The West. Who said theres WMD in iraq?
Hey Alex. Iam from India. Iam Monpa ethnically. Iam here after seeing monpa Doctor in this video. Im very much eager to know about Monpa people of Tibet since I'm Monpa people from India. Before 1959 we Monpa people were also under Tibetan rule. We had to pay taxes and had to do potter work compulsory. But now we come under India. Therefore, I'm requesting you to please update me about monpa people of Tibet. What is their status in the society?. Their culture and tradition. How they progress they are? Because we Monpa people in India are very much happy and progress under India. Thanks Regards