TIME AFTER TIME - boa wendy ningning vocal showcase 

Do u guys like this format?

Wendy's vocal slayage just hits different, she's really a versatile singer and a powerhouse vocalist

Ningning is only 2y old in the industry and she’s already proving that she’s an amazing vocalist

Update : ningning is the one who sang the headvoice

Ningning getting the main vocalist treatment that she deserves 💅💅

Ning Ning G5 is an another level!! 💘😭

BoA's strongest in her mid and lower register. Her tone is so unique and because she's more chest dominate it really gives her belts some power. I also like how her voice can be soft but also husky at times. Ning Ning and Wendy of.course are vocal monsters in their upper range.

U know what, those adlibs of wendy we can definitely hear it more clearly and loud if sm gives us the live perf and can sound more heavenly

Wendy sounds so expensive. Giving me international vibes, and that is what makes her stand out. Such a diva!

WOW WENDY IS JUST DIFFERENT 😩🔥🔥♥️

the best song on this SMCU album!!!!!!

Wendy’s E5s and G5ss are so good I can’t help but replay it over and over again

damn so at 0:46 it’s actually ningning not wendy 😯 can’t wait to see how she progresses as a vocalist the potential is 100% there, she’s already really good and her tone is beautiful

Ningning voice is 🍯✨🫠

THEIR VOICES SOUNDS SO GOOD TOGETHER

wendy switching between all those notes... its so insane to me

OUR GENIUS SINGER SEUNGWANIEEEE😍💙💙

Queen Wendy of House vocals, thee archmaester of 9 voices, thee autotune slayer, main adliber, thy maester of the background vocals, the recording booth slave, a niece of Queen Whitney Houston and Queen Mariah Carey sunbae-nim of the West land has Wenriah carry-ed her way throughout the song like she's some sort of a holy spirit, singing gospels and cleansing our souls

0:46 Ningning head voice 😁

Boa has been singing for 20 years now. Her voice got husky. Still the nasal type of singing as her old style but i will still commend the talent that she still has. Also, her voice now is so unique than most tiny voice of female vocalists of kpop. I will forever protect Boa. Unless you will show me a main dancer, main vocals, main visuals in one body like Boa which is not happening anytime soon.

Wendy’s tone and her ad-libs are the real deal

Confirmed: Ningning did the ad-lib in 0:46 to 0:50 !! She keeps on surprising us with her vocals hope we see her achieve resonance in ae1 it will be a big shocker

I realize once again how Wendy has the best technics, really it gave me thrills all along as I was listening 🤧

THAT PHRASED G5??? I think there's no way a unit beat these girls in vocal

Idk how sm gatekeeping top tier vocalist like Wendy like she's too good, I wish I can hear more Wendy soon for her second solo album

justice for ningning to show these capabilities in aespa songs as well. shut up the haters doubting her main vocal status.

boa and ningning's g5 sounds so light, but wendy's sound sooooo full and powerful omg the main vocalist she is

I love boa's tone so much

those were the most challenging vocal acrobatics i‘ve ever heard from ningning. that was harder than anything she did before. people truly were always underestimating her. 0:27 and 0:32 are so amazing

0:21 that sustained G5, she's crazy

just watched the live performance and the d5-b5 run in the end is really ningning's 🥺

I'm a bit surprised that Ningning is even capable of singing the parts given to her. Those are NOT EASY even for kpop main vocals. More difficult than anything I've heard from the Aespa albums. She's either improving a lot, or showcasing what she has never shown before. I knew SM (famous for xenophobia) wouldn't let a foreigner be the main vocalist for nothing. Some people say Ningning is the weakest SM main vocal but I don't think so. She's scarily good for a 20-year-old. Edit: I’m not gonna argue with anyone about whether SM is racist or not. They just are. I have been following SM artists since the early days of Super Junior, SNSD and f(x). I know this company. Just look at how Yuta and WayV have been treated for years. For Aespa, the favouritism towards the Korean members is so obvious that it’s actually quite funny. I can’t bother listing the examples. Just know that it’s so serious that some Aespa fans believe that Winter is the main vocal instead of Ningning. It’s just too ridiculous that I can’t even be angry anymore😂

The three of them sound so good together likeeee 🤯🤯🤯

A recording session for this song came out, turns out that last run with the B5 is actually Ningning 🔥, so impressed by her everyday Edit: I forgot to put Ningning's name lol

I don't think it's possible to find a perfect queen like BoA again. Since the 1st gen no one can come close. She's the main visual main vocal main dancer in one person. And as a performer her stage present is always No1. Thanks you for this video. This is another validation for queen BoA.

I LOVE HOW ALL OF THEM JUST HITTED A G5 AS IF THEY WERE BREATHING, QUEENS INDEED, SM VOCALISTS Y'ALL

the way they make these notes sound so easy.... like ningning practically breathed them out. can't wait to hear this live ugh

Wow Wendy G5!! The Real Vocalist

I can’t stop loving BoA's vocal. She's amazing💛

this is ningning 0:46 not wendy, they released the recording video

head voice is ningning (B5)

Recording behind the scene is out and 0:46 is ningning

Ningning's phrased G5 was not given justice during the live performance of Time After Time 💔 What a shame

The whistle part was ningning!!

Ningning voice 🧎🏻‍♂️🗣️✨

Wendy's runs toward the end.. im going insane

0:45 gosh i want to hear it live so bad 😩 edit : we'll hear it live guys, they'll perform time after time on the new year concert 😭🙏

update: 0:46 is actually ningning!

B5 head voice is ningning, watch the studio recording vocals on smtown and it sounds a lot better live

There is so many G5's and Im loving it.The 3 SM Main Vocalist in one frame😍

0:46 is NINGNING

0:46 i think thats ningning

0:33 those G5's in unison from BoA and NingNing tho. Tell me you're a group of sopranos without telling me you're a group of sopranos

The amount of G5‘s lmao

Seen the live performance and the head notes are actually NingNing

0:45 was Ningning.

0:47 is Ning Ning

Boa high notes sound so full

Wendy slay

i did not know boa could sing like that wow

I also think that the head voice after wendy's run is ningning. The vocals are slightly overlapped at the end so i guess it couldn't be Wendy

i really like boa's tone her chorus sounds richer

hold on, BoA and ningning go so well together. i need them in a GOT unit soon

Ningning G5🔥

BoA’s tone is so unique, I love when she belts. I need people to stop underestimating her vocals

The vocal slayage but Miss Wendy’s adlibs and flow(?) runs(?) it’s so good

BoA ❤. So much desperation and longing in her delivery, telling a story. My favorite all rounder, full package recording artist. However, I prefer her younger singing style when she has more power and support. Vocally, I’ll give it to Wendy. She is impressive.

i actually feel like tearing up 😭 the emotions they are potraying is amazing

0:46 is ningning tho

just SM thingz❤️❤️❤️❤️ Imagine Ning's vocal when she grows up and her voice matures more. cuz she is still so young like 20 or 21?

ningning did the last adlip not wendy

0:32 slayningg🧎‍♀️🧎‍♀️🧎‍♀️

What a beautiful Songgg!

wendy main slayer

I think the head voice on the last part was Ningning.

Wendy Ningning Boa all the best 😊

Head Voice B5 is ningning

FULL QUEEN GROUP!

Ningning 0:47 oh~~~~~😳😳

I'm pretty sure ningning did the b5

NINGNING SLAYAGE 4TH GEN BEAT VOCALIST

Let's be honest this is one of the best song on smcu palace album

Honestly, BoA's vocals are underappreciated.

0:47 Definitely Ningning. Wendy headvoice sound more full, just listen to her headvoice in "In My Dreams", sound very different with this, in this video it sound very airy, not sound like Wendy.

NINGNING WENDY 💚

Does SM forget that Wendy sound so effing gorgeous with low notes? I kinda want her to do the low notes parts too

BoA is teaching you what is exactly vocal means xD Queen

my fav song on this album ❤️

SUSTAINED G5 ????? My gosh it's so hard.

Ningning… for her to be so young and new in the company and she already sings like this??? She’s going to surpass everyone in no time and become the best vocalist of all time I just know

Everytime sm main vocals did a high note it's so pleasing to the ears 😍

ningning's head voice omggggg

Im so proud of ningning 😎 she the sm maknae but she can balance boA and Wendy hereee Dang i wish taeyeon could join the slayage in this song, but we got Priority toooo hahha

0:46 there a mistake here that head voice is Ning Ning I know it

Wendy just ate🔥

i think the head voice going into B5 is ningning

Wendy here making me learn all the alphabets on an Octave ranging from C to B.. DAYMN !

Pov : That b5 was Ningning not Wendy 💀❤️‍🩹

*Just wow.* The veterans with a 2-year old kpop idol singing, in one song.

Ning Ning ❗️💖💖💖💖💖💖