GD mod here. Here's my opinions: 1) R3d Rooms. I already sent this for epic. This must be a case where rob saw the level and chose not to rate it. I'd say the most likely reason is that it was a 2.2 gdps level or because it is too gory? 2) 1052 step. Not seen before, I sent for star rate. The decoration is good but the main issues are the fact that it uses a NONG (radiohead song) and that it is too short (54 seconds excluding the empty wait at the end to make it long length). 3) Chaos. Already seen and didn't send. Its too messy and kinda unoriginal since its a killbot clone. 4) Stellar Night. Already seen and didn't send. It was close to a send but the main issues with it were that it feels too static due to a lack of movements and that it uses a NONG song. 5) C Sharp. Not seen before and didn't send. The main issues are that it is too generic for a nine circles level (creativity is really important for nc levels because of how stale they have become), some parts feels unpolished and that the colours could be worked on. It also doesn't have enough variety and the last wave part goes on for ages without any meaningful deco changes to keep things interesting. 6) Fried Egg. Already seen and didn't send. Not a fan of the decoration, it looks too messy and unpolished. It also doesn't stick to its style and is all over the place with parts that are 1.0, a city parts and black silhouette parts. 7) Punch Drunk. Already seen and didn't send. The last 80% of the level is basically a challenge layout that uses the same background with no deco changes. 8) Panadol Vortex. Not seen before, I sent it for feature. Good decoration, nice effects, lots of variety and creative nine circles designs. 9) Grains of Sand. Not seen before and didn't send. The effects are pretty dated by today's standards and most of the level is just repetitive challenge gameplay. The fact that it is NONG too does not help. 10) Bloody Knuckles. Not seen before and didn't send. Too empty, basic and unpolished. So that's 2 sends from this vid :)
gameplay is entirely subjective, some people hate the gameplay of super probably level, however I love it. gameplay is subjective and should not be judged
@@death0910 thats bullshit sorry just the sheer amount of wrongness in your sentence is astonishing like its subjective yes but with enough opinion it wiull be an objective veiw, such as spl its objectively ok memory is memory its not gret or good but its okay
The fact that after years and years The Eras of GD is still not rated in spite of it being sent like 20 times and with not a single reason given still makes me frustrated.
I actually know 2 levels that should 100% be rated. 1.) Eternaltheory (It's been well over a year since it was verified and I think it still isn't rated. It could be though and if so just ignore this.) 2.) Voidclub (It's that one level that looks like a top 5 ILL level that is actually just a hard demon. The deco is fantastic, and it is a pretty interesting concept for a level. (also fun fact, I think it was actually placed pretty high on the ILL until people realized that it was actually really easy and then it got removed :D))
Exosphere by doggie a great level that it is very sad not to be rated, considering how beautiful the decoration is and how much time was probably put in love the list so far though❤️
Thank you so much for acknowledging C sharp at 8:43 ! It means the world to me as when i verified it it was my magnum opus and so much work went into it, both from me and fladalt who is a great creator and quite unrecognized, it would be so heartwarming to have this testament of both his creations and my verification journey on the demonlist ^^. Anyways thank you so much for trying to help us and doing your part for unrated levels, i hope this series can help at least a few levels and bring positive emotions to people like me for a bit :D
I think PunchDrunk isn't rated because it's main idea as a level is taken from Game Over by Pennutoh, and that level was unrated for a long time, but now it is rated, and maybe Rob doesn't want 2 rated spam challenges with the same concept
on the dasher podcast icedcave said he wont do a deco update, because he doesnt really care if its rated, but he said it was sent multiple times already
Thank you for including C Sharp! While it might not have the best deco I think the almost 2-year verification journey should be taken into consideration :)
FemboyFox by ShizuSss is an effect level with a newgrounds song that’s around easy demon difficulty. The effects go pretty easy until around 60% but the decoration looks good the whole level. The gameplay syncs really well and is fun and not too crazy.
Id like to recomend checking out Acuerdo II, Its the only other level that really captured that same feeling acu gave me (even though Im not even close to beating acu) The gameplay is a little rough, and theres a few ways to accidently fall out of the map but I think its still a good one to check out.
You should look into Hephaestus by zYuko & more, it's a really good Promethean remake imo, and it's sad to see it not rated, considering it probably looks even better than Promethean lol. In general, I think it executes it's theme a lot better than Promethean, and just feels a lot more energetic and intense, which is great ngl. Also the song fits Hephaestus way more than the other song did with Promethean. I think Promethean kind of wasted the the song, while Hephaestus just uses it very well imo. What do you think?
My top pics are still lightness and radience, although with how much better optimized 2.2 he could probobly even rate full light it up, especially since the song isnt a nong anymore
I’ve been watching your content for a long time now, and all of your videos are super well written, but the generally negative tone of your content kinda pushed me away. The fact that you’re making a much more positive series is exactly what I wanted from your channel, keep up the good work!
One level I remember that really deserves to get rated is Scarlett by RedHuseey. It got verified over 2 years ago after 4 years in production & despite being sent by several mods still isn’t rated to this day.
I REALLY wanna see Set Me Free, Poocu and Twocu rated. the decoration is definitely on point in those levels, although Set Me Free has pretty simplistic designs which i guess mods dont like
set me free is not getting rated because the creator sexually harrassed other people (i like the level too but i think its good that its not getting rated), poocu and twocu are very based tho
This was a great video and I think some levels you could add to the list for the next video could be gang, the gins 2, and exosphere, all of which are on doggies account and have verification videos. Thanks for reading my comment
Muddevouer has a lot of extremely cool levels that imo deserve epic or even legendary, he also only has a single rated level currently. Theres also tungsten85 with no creator points and a bunch of great levels like stellar wandering. Theres this one unrated level i also really want rated because i think its really cool, its called “man made god“ and theres currently no existing videos of it and no victors.
0:06 dude lightmare is my favourite eightos level. PLEASE USE EIGHTOS LEVELS IN YOUR BACKGROUND MORE(e.g s2e2 hc,formosa,xane gets trippy,ripple,second reqiuem,devourer and more)!
Levels to include next..? I'd like to hear your thoughts on these. -uhhh every akunakun level -also every lisp level i dont care -the nautical (extremely biased) -levigo -eternaltheory -THE ROCK HOUSE (yeah) -VOID (could go either way) -gracefulgracefulgracefulgracefulgracefulgracefulgracefulgracefulgraceful -Void of Thought -THE WONDER OF YOU PLEEEASE -wind (biased) -RAIN, FACESHOPPING, KULT -Stygian Storm -SET ME FREE (efext's actions have nothing to do with gd) -COME TO DADDY -Hephaestus -Decks Dark, High on fish (etc yuko lvls) -Buff this 2 (yes unironically) -phonk town/cannon bay -Shirinai -Gravity -Bramble Scramble -ETERNAL ENDING -The pioneers by starkythesalad my beloved -world war, devin2003 -troll level 2
I think Sandstone Barrens by TheNoWeeker should be rated. Its a collab of creators with no creator ponts (some of them have creator points now) and the level looks really good
CHEYENNE by thejosiahturner and more was verified over 2 months ago now without a rate and definitely should. Its an incredibly well executed Lithifusion type level and one of my favorite unrated levels
For me I always wanted Siniristi rated, since it was a really big hit in the Finnish gd community, and also a sort of ''tribute'' level to Finlands 100 year anniversary. Anyways turns out it was rated a couple of days ago so now I dont have a level i really want rated lol.
This would be my list 1-deimos, (akira kurisu v. Nerfed): For me it is one of the best collaborations in all of gd, since almost all the parts have great quality, each one has a different style but remains consistent with the theme general level 2--the nautical (nerfed): an nc with a great deco and a relatively creative use of the effect, the only reasons for not having a rate are the duration and the noNG song but other than that it completely deserves the rate 3-fracture: the nc effect is excellently used with interesting and quite complex patterns 4-birde: a colorful and fluid level with one of the best uses of the glow
I know you probably have enough suggestions but "Not Limbo" by Doomclaw Simply put, it's a really cool level, and one of my favorite levels... In general. The only reason I could possibly see for it's unrated status is the simple fact that RobTop never saw it, aside from that it passes all the rate standards in flying colors and I'm excited to see where that creator goes from here.
Another unrated Limbo inspired level that relatively few people have seen but is really good is Herculaneum. It's basically just an easier version of Limbo, and it's actually very fun.
Idk if anyone remembers this level but there is literally no reason why this level shouldn’t have been rated, the level im talking about is Interstellar Entropy by LastPrismAlex, the level is a rainbow themed glow megacollab that was send by 26 MODS (Im not 100% sure about the number of mods that sent it), and not only that the gameplay is very fun, The decoration is pretty good, it uses a newgrounds song and it was verified on stream, this level was pretty famous in the spanish speaking community. I don’t really know why robtop didn’t rate (im pretty sure he knew about the level, even Viprin send the level) Sorry if my grammar isn’t good
I've been campaigning for panadol vortex to get rated for quite some time now so I'm glad it's getting more attention, akun has so many unrated levels that deserve a rate
great video as allwais! sme levcels i would include are: the void v2 by reduniverse, a realy cool remake of the void by xcy7 witch itself is a kinda bad level, imo reduniverse improoves upon it heavely not only in deco but in gameplay too, apostrophe by colon, yes its a 1.0 level with a single gimmick, but imo the gimmick it realy cool and the gameplay is realy fun, z3ll1nk by dr0me, memes aside, its a realy cool effect level, yes its messy in parts and the gameplay is iffy but thats on purpose, i would alsow include rainbow circles by natcho, but it got whiped from the servers
Gigawatt by Jackaezie is one of the most fun unrated levels I’ve tried. It’s an easy extreme imo, around Allegiance difficulty. It’s fairly unknown, too. The song is intense and the wave sections are awesome to play. However, after 61% the level kinda falls apart with gameplay and becomes much more inconsistent. MK and 1945 by LFritz are 2 great levels, too. I’m not really sure how hard MK is… but it’s a sequel to In Rainbows, which is a great hard demon. 1945 is another easy extreme demon but it’s super reliant on click sync. It’s a blast to play, and although I haven’t beaten it, I have a few runs and it’s a really fun level and has good deco. XO Circles is a pretty fun upper-end insane demon NC level. The only issue I see with it not being rated is that it is verified by Crazen… it’s a very fun level nonetheless, and the deco is decent. Another insane demon NC level I’d love to see rated is FNAFcave by Fawxu. This level is a sequel to FNAFbass which is a very well received Hard Demon NC level. This level has amazing sync with the song and the wave. It’s a lot of fun to play.
as someone with sortof significant progress on bloody knuckles, I'd like to mention that the level is fun if you don't take it seriously, otherwise it's super annoying to play. besides that I probably disagree that it should be rated despite it being actually kinda fire sometimes
I have made a level almost 1 year ago, it's called White Way ( i'm not the only one that thinks it's rate worthy) and for some reason mods keep ignoring my requests 😭
Agree with all of them but grains of sand because the gameplay is consistency, and most consistency levels are not rated and it's fair. But your opinion is valid so... Fair enough ig My submissions: Rain - rain should be rated (the nerfed version that was verified a few years ago), sequel of Blood in the water, it has a nong but the level is completely cool Insane techniques - my favourite 2.1 unrated level that deserves it, when SrGuillester verified it i thought it would be insta-rated but it was not. The deco is really cool and the replacement song (it has a nong) is really cool
Fez by Serponge. It's better than most 1.9 private server levels, and was actually made in 1.9, but wasn't rated at the time for going over the object limit.
I hop off ultrakill and watch this, you mention ultrakill, I go to the channel of the creator of 1052 step and the first video that appears on their channel is Minos Prime from ultrakill 😭
You should have given a better example for rated gdps level.. because in the castle was a remake not a port.. better example such as "lost in the forest" or "friendly menace" which both are rated in 2.2 :) Also another levels that should be rated: TheFirebird by team tcm and 3rror and dash v2 by MasterTheCube5 :)
i hate to self promote but i really think my level 'mod abuse' got the short end of the stick (it's fully decorated, not from a 1.9gdps or anything, not a nong, and even has a victor that says the gameplay is great). looking at what kind of levels were getting rated at the end of 2.1 i can't help but feel like if i put it out a couple of months earlier it might have even gotten featured but right now it's just fading into irrelevancy
r3d rooms to me looks like it crosses the threshold of how much graphic imagery rob can tolerate in a rated level, on top of the explicit music 1052 step is probably just unknown so spreading awareness might get rob to rate it chaos looks like it took stuff from nhelv at the beginning but idk the icedcave level might get rated later bc rob is just like that c sharp doesn't really do anything new to the NC style so rob's not gonna rate it fried egg can't say anything that hasn't already been said punchdrunk to me relies too much on its nong song to play the gameplay, which is why rob might keep it unrated the akun akun level is prob gonna get rated sooner or later since it does do something different with the NC style the auto version of grains of sand by pocke is rated so idk if 2 grains of sands can exist bloody knuckles COULD get rated if we make enough awareness of the level sinc I don't believe rob knows of it I sure hope this brings some nice discussions and not discourse
FARTARUS by Tarrytar should get rated honestly. Now i know the name makes it sound like its gonna be bad. But it actually has great gameplay, and its two victors agree! Its been sent once (thats how i found it) and the deco looks great! Probably not a feature or anything, i even talked to the creator once and they agreed that its prob only rate worthy and nothing more, but still.
About R3D ROOM, it may also not get rated because it's too bloody, gory, and brutal. However, I don't actually think this is a good reason to keep it unrated per se, because Triple Six is rated
