Rose voice is unique but it's really hard to beat someone who have stability and power in her voice like wendy, i think wendy is the best 3rd gen main vocal
Not even sure rose in the top 10. She has a great tone, but her poor technique is ruining her voice. She’s already lost partial support since bps debut by not taking care of her voice
From a purely technical perspective it's somewhere along the line of Wendy > Yuju > Solar >> Sejeong / Seunghee / Dawon / Yeonjung > Jihyo / Kei > Sungyeon >(?) Rosé Wendy and Yuju are both quite wellrounded with Wendy supporting a bit more and therefore coming out on top. Also Gfriend's songs rely on Yuju's ability of mixing very high and that's hard to keep up to, so she often shows signs of fatigue. Solar is a pushy af queen (love her tho). OMG's Seunghee is promising too as well as Sejeong. Both rely more on technic than pushing and screaming. Yeonjung's natural talent reminds me of Yuju's but with less resonance and more pushing. Dawon might be slightly better (and a smarter vocalist) but who knows for sure. Jihyo and Kei have a solid base established. There's a lot of room for improvement. Actually to me Sungyeon and Rosé sound kinda similar. Both are very bright and tight and limited through their singing style. Dreamcatcher's Siyeon got a nice tone but she's very rough in her approach. One of their lead vocalists (forgot her name) shows a lot of promise though. Don't know about LOONA, all of them seem very inconsistent? But then, I don't know them that well... Personally I like all of their vocal colors and hope that they can improve in the journey ahead of them ☺️♥️
Lunafreya Nox Fleuret it is Not about high Notes it is about the technique yess Let say Wendy has has higher voice but Yuju has special technique... yes let say it irritate to ears but she sings it to the right notes and agilty of her voice she can switch notes perfectly and she has emotion too alright
Dreamcatcher SIYEON can sing any kind of Song, From low to high notes a peach kind of song or to be deep... I don't really know how to say but.. she can sing any kind
@@mooo6187 my guy I'm a somnie too and they gave her 4th place. That's really good. She's only behind Yuju Solar and Wendy, that's some elite company...
I think your opinion is one of the best opinion I've ever seen really nobody says like you said (I think the same), everyone just look at the people who are famous❤️🙄
Almost nobody mentions the girl from dreamcatcher, Siyeon. That girl is a beast. She and her group are underrated as f*ck. I guess it's just hard for people to stan a group from a small company.
@@IsaacMokChuangXing exactly...but i wonder people said like she was one of the greatest vocalist when she cant properly support an a#4..i means i dont think it reasonable enough to put her along with yuju/wendy..its irrelevant..hope,she learn how to properly support her voice
My thoughts exactly. I'm so happy that she was included on this list, but her skills are more advanced than many of the girls ranked higher than her. 12 is just too low. 😔
@@imuniplayz7779 No yuju can't achieve any kind of high note.... She can only achieve her supported range. In this video she also didn't hit the resonance people are talking about so......... This video shows the wrong yuju video??
Wendy’s falsetto in psycho is proof that she’s the best main vocalist. I’ve seen a lot of comments comparing Wendy to yuju. But Wendy has much more versatility imo, her whistle/falsetto’s are everything. I still support both artists tho.
Asterthie in the pre-chorus Wendy uses a technique called the falsetto, and to "achieve" that technique you have to use your head voice ,so we're both technically correct. But thanks for the correction!
For me when it comes idol group vocal Yuju nothing else.. But when it comes Vocal Group. Solar .. they way she hold the mic .. you know who's the pro.. For Idol vocal : yuju For Vocal group : Solar..
I think yuri can be higher, she still 17 years old but have a unique and husky voice, also kei can be higher, anyways good ranking, love to see jungwoo of bvndit here. SIYEON I LOVE HER SO MUCH, that cover of speechless was amazing, people start noticing her little by liitle. Yuju my beautiful multitalented Queen and bias, love her voice too much, Stan gfriend Stan art
Honestly, i'm a Yuju(GFRIEND) biased. She can hit those high notes easily. But when it comes to the best main vocalist, i really think its Wendy(RedVelvet).
That’s what happened when all girlgroups sang Into The New World together in KBS Girls Present 2016, out of all the girl groups Yuju was the main volcanist with all the high notes and ad libs! Search it on RU-vid ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE--P3rZOmau-g.html
for me (based on high notes, low notes, stamina, emotion...) 1. wendy 2. solar 3. siyeon - yuju this is only my opinion and this is only a top 3 + special mention to taeyeon, ik she debuted a long time ago like...2OO9 i think??? but she will be forever in my heart.
Based on low notes emotions I agree but high notes?.. of course most vocalist can do it but Yuju's on another level when it comes to high notes..and stamina
@@johnminlal3745 Yuju is not another level lol. She uses mixed range when she belts those high notes and it’s very nasally. She sounds just like any other idol singer. The only singer that belts with full chest voice is Solar, which is why I prefer her over others.
@@lilith5752 I respect your opinion. Yuju is good too, definitely up there, with all of the other above average vocalists. Regardless, let's just support our faves❤️
Both are great and at the same level one is better in something then the other I am yuju biases but I don’t think she is better then Wendy neither do I think Wendy is better then yuju . For me both rule 3gen
@@junsseorafim your opinion but they opinion is yuju and not that because they being a bias is just they opinion that yuju is the best and we know that we have different tastes you have different tastes and they have different tastes as well
my top 8 1. Yuju. She is the queen of vocal. 2. Wendy. 3. Solar. 4. Yuri(yes, i'm placed her that high because she is only 17 years old and slay her high notes) 5. Sejeong 6. Kei 7. Rose 8. Jihyo
My Top 5 and my reasoning: 1. Yuju- her beautiful vocals are out of this world. 2. Wendy- amazing range, projection and emotion. 3. Seunghee- Her voice is beautiful, crystal clear...but also surprisingly airy. She has the voice of a literal angel. 4. Haeyoon- A beautiful and emotional voice. Her voice pulls at my heart strings when she sings ballads. 5. Yuri- her voice is unique and airy and husky. She has a deeper voice than most main vocalists. Also, she improved drastically in a short time. (Most main vocalists have a lot of professional practice singing before debut but Yuri was not really able to because of financial issues. Idol school was her first time getting any sort of training and then she only trained for 9 months before pd 48.)
Ah yeah.. Yuju is one of the best main vocalist in this gen. but we can't still deny the fact that she's still underrated. People nowadays just really loves to sleep. 😪😪😪
Zelly Jung lol she’s far from underrated and she’s not even underappreciated many people acknowledge her skill but her voice isn’t for everyone I think
I’m surprised and rather disappointed that no one’s talking about Siyeon... She truly is an amazing vocalist. She’s very diverse, not the widest range, but her technique is very good. I really hope she gets the recognition she deserves. In my opinion, I believe she should be at the top.
The problem is that siyeon doesn't really support any of her note( she has shown some shallow supported G#4 that's all) so seeing her in 4th is a real problem 🤣 ( she is my bias and it's heart broken that someone with a very good vibrato and a wide range doesn't really support her note 😭) so she should be 15 or under unfortunately!!
I know it says "main singer" which Joy isn't, but to me, Joy is the most interesting singer in Red Velvet. Her phrasing, the way she interprets and delivers a melody, is so idiosyncratic, creative, and pleasing. IMO she's the most remarkable and memorable singer in Red Velvet and one of the very best in Kpop.
@@ilanakidiadia3181 Siyeon "IN DC" is not underrated she always has the chorus, most lines, she shines a lot, but AS A GROUP yeah obviously Dreamcatcher is underrated.
@@quememirasfeo have you not read what I 've said. Siyeon is the main vocal and one of the best vocalist in KPOP ofc she shines a lot. SHE IS A BEAST. Every members have their moment, every members shine in DC. DC IS UNDERRATED which means SIYEON TOO.
1. Wendy and Yuju? No sera 1. Yuju 2. Wendy Osea ya que pusiste todos los números menos el dos. O no sera que deberias haber puesto a Yeonjung de número 2.
@Squirrel Hoseok lee todo lo que puse antes por que a lo que yo iba era a que tenia que dejar a alquien en segundo lugar por eso puse que pusiera a Yeonyung de las segundas en ves de la tercera y wacho a mi parecer la tecnica de Yuju es mejor. (Mi opinión comprendes)
@@فرقان-ص7ه pues para mi Yuju es mejpr y no se necesita solo talento para cantar así que piensa lo que quieras. Ah y solo estoy dando mi opinión no es para que empiezen a reclamar además tenia una duda por eso puse eso.
If we talk about the main voices, wendy is a little better than yuju as she has better technique but if we talk about the group, gfriend is better, the top would be 1.mamamoo, 2.gfriend and 3. red velvet.
@@marf_23024 For me, individually Mamamoo are best because they overpowering each other when group performance. When in Group Red Velvet are the best because of the flavor of their voices including the emotion they give something about that nobody can offer.
@@melonization1049 their Just sound the same like other album, yeah yuju, eunha, eumji hit the high notes nad get mush line, and the rest just for the complement
I'm not even a fan of Red Velvet. I stan three GGs 1. Dreamcatcher 2. Mamamoo 3. G idle But Wendy is the best main vocalist and noone can tell me otherwise
@@mooo6187 ikr Dreamcatcher are so UNDERRATED. They're the best GG for me because they don't have a weak link. Hardest choreographies, one of the best dancers, rappers and vocalists, ground-breaking concepts which no other group has done till now and rock metal music. People need to stop sleeping on them.
Miyeon seems underreted too :(, i found that her vocal technique is better than rose and jihyo, sadly she well known because her visual more. This video is just seems like who can sing the highnote higher, because wendy should be number one even tho i'm a buddy.
Taste! I also stan DC and Mamamoo and I really like (G)I-DLE and RV although I wouldn't say I stan either. I'm admittedly biased, but I'd put both Wheein and Solar above Wendy. Wendy has a great voice but in the lives I've seen she likes to reach for little flourishes that she's hit or miss on. Maybe if she played it safer I'd never notice and I wouldn't be writing this comment now, but I can't trust that Wendy's going to consistently nail parts like I can with Solar and Wheein. I'm actually here because I read a comment on another video that was basically the same thing as yours and I couldn't believe it lol. Sounds like lots of people agree with you though!
no offend but critically speaking i think wendy has more better technique, i mean yuju is good but there's also solar to be tied with her, but overall wendy is just amazing like she has 4 octave and emotion as well she know how to hit the song in low and high register perfectly it just so imposible not to rank her in the first position.
@r v e l v e t s look who's commenting on every post dumbass.. I don't hate Wendy at all I just hate those who don't accept Yuju jst becoz she ain't that popular.. just coz u like Wendy doesn't mean we have to keep her in first ..wht a loser u are
@r v e l v e t slol u r a joke you are the one coming here and stating your fcking opinion and bashing others.. Yuju is first coz she's the best at hitting notes you shld get ur facts straight.. where does it says Wendy is best at singing wider range? If u don't agree with the video then get lost with ur stupid opinion and start ur own
@@johnminlal3745 ofcourse I know her but technically she would come third. Gfriend is my second biased girl group after dream catchers so there's no way I hate yuju. It's fine that you might prefer yuju vocals more but technically this would be the order.
@Jaasmi Remington both yuju and solar get a little shouty after the fourth octave. And also their head voices are a little weaker. Wendy has a more healthier technique and is also more versatile then both of them.
@@johnminlal3745 this video is not rated by someone who does vocals and is opiniative and also biased to a point. And being unbiased solar and wendy are better Vocalists then yuju.
That's where I see how SM vocalist really have a good training. Seunghee from Oh My Girls struggling when hitting the same notes in Happiness, where Wendy can do it with ease
@@lynarachedi3078 Yes, she's incredible, but I forgot to mention her name ... I swear I do not know how I could forget her. Sorry if English is wrong, all right?.... I'm from Brazil🇧🇷
4 octaves and one note (one of the only two KPOP vocalists to have this range) not only skilled on high notes but also stable with her low notes, great technique, has 8 different voices inside of her, well developed head voice... Nah. Wendy is first.
infinite sis You’re right. I’m sorry for the way I acted. It’s just that I ult RV so I act up when someone undermines Wanda. At this time, we shouldn’t be arguing but coming closer together. Solar is injured from the leg and Wendy has a broken pelvis :(
@@anandariffan2261 Yes, Jihyo trained for more than 10 years and I love her vocal, but still I think the vocal of Solar better because it has more power, I'm sorry but it's my opinion...
Wheein is actually a better vocalist than Solar but people think solar is the main vocal is becuz she gets the most high notes out of the members and they don’t have official positions cuz they’re all that good, I watched on Samuel Bradley’s channel (he’s a vocal coach btw) and he ranked wheein as number 1 vocalist in mamamoo
I'm gonna be objective here 1. Wendy (F#3 - D5 - A5) 2. Yuju (A3 - C#5 - F5) 3. Solar (A3 - C#5) 4. Seunghee (A3/Bb3 - B4) 5. Sejeong (A3 - B4) I don't remember the note they support in lower range, but it would be those notes around F#3 - Bb3 Wendy is better than all these vocalists because of her technique, so she should be higher
Another immature fan. Can you please do not compare your idol to other idol?because they have their different style where they can shine more while the others are lacking in that part. So don't say that this one is better than this one. I understand that it is your opinion but can you keep it to yourself?what if your idol can see this?what would she feel?of course hurt because she's being compared to other idols that is also her friend. So if you want to stop fanwar then don't compare because it sound like you're immature. Sorry but it's true. So avoid comparing other idols if you want to stop fanwar. We should act like a young adult, we should act like a mature person so that we can be a better role model to other young kpop fans. Thanks.
@@costamaresangelyn2516 It's not my opinion, it's vocal technique, that's objective. If I give my opinion I would say Seunghee is better, but I'm talking about their technique. Search about it I don't wanna start any fanwar, I just wanted to share what I know
YESSSS, someone finally understans, have anybody heared before of technique, or smth called falsetto?? Or even LOW NOTES, which is my fav type of singing and alot of people's fav type of singing. Like hell, peopel be saying wendy is better, yuju is better,solar is better, when they are all basically doing te same thing ( hitting high notes,lol) like until now i have never seen a main vocalist who is like ADELE for example, i know adele has nothing to do here, but people keep telling some singers "perfect" just because they hit high notes, who knows, maybe they can't go deep and falsetto, i didn't see yuju go deep before ?? I know low notes is also not everything, but high notes are also not evevrything, people need to get that.
Joy Myelin listen to psycho by red velvet. In the first pre-chorus Wendy hits a falsetto, people are saying she's the "best" because she has a lot of technique, and can adapt to different styles.
@@winston970 I know wendy can go alot of things, and in my opinion, she is way better than yuju, cuz i have never seen yuju going deep or falsetto for example, that is why i am so confused how many.people say she is the best main vocalist, when i actually see both wendy and solar are better than her,P.S THAT there is smth called uniquness and low voice, and that is honestly my fav type of voice,yuju's voice is too high and that is why i don't prefer her vocals very much, i respect and appreciate her sm, but i don't see her that "perfcet" and actually there is no main vocalist in the third generation that can get the title of "perfcet" until now, like i have never seen a main vocalist like tayeon for example ( a 2nd generation singer) or any other singers who are not from the 3rd generation, i don't understand so much in vocals, i am just saying my opinion and what i am basically seeing. I love all the main vocalists and groups btw, and i respect and apprecaite each one of them cuz each singer has her own style in singing, but beside technique, there is smth called preference, that is why some may like wendy, and some may like yuju,etc. But in my opinion, i prefer wendu the most, and if i could, i would honestly give her the title of the best main of the third generation, but i don't see someone perfect, that is it.
I feel that your ranking is pretty good For me( My opinion, everyone has different taste so please respect it), My top 15 1) GFRIEND Yuju (duh!!!!, No need for me to explain, she's the undeniable queen of this generation) 2) RED VELVET Wendy (Though she is not my bias in the group, there is no denying her talent) 3) MAMAMOO Solar ( One of the best vocals, though her technique seems a bit inferior to the other two above her , otherwise she is as good ) and Siyeon DREAMCATCHER ( Awesome high notes. An underrated member belonging to an underrated group, Stop sleeping on Dreamcatcher!!) 4) LOVELYZ Kei ( A extremely lovely goddess with a heavenly voice) 5)OH MY GIRL Seunghee( Oh my girls main vocalist has one of the best technique and range) 6)WJSN Yeonjung ( Good enough talent that she could improve and join the top three in another year or two) 7)GU9UDAN Sejeong ( Good vocals and emotional singing) 8) IZ*ONE Yuri ( As young as she is, a lot of untapped talent, her potential is the highest in the top 10.) 9) Sungyeon and CHERRY BULLET Haeyoon ( I just can't decide between the two because the differences are almost negligible) 10)TWICE Jihyo ( People often overlook her talent. But to me she has good vocal technique and range) 11) MAMAMOO Wheein ( Another kpop idol who gets overlooked, She can go to extremely high notes) 12) Chuu ( Again another idol who can stand at the top in the future) 13) KHAN Minju (Though her vocals are not as unique compared to others, she had one of the best vocal control and had one of the best live vocals, Stan KHAN) 14) BVNDIT Jungwoo ( Like Yuri, she also has a lot of potential) 15) BLACKPINK Rose ( There is no denying that her voice is unique, however singing nasally is not healthy in the long run)
After a year, a change I would make is to put Wheein in Top 1 to 5... She can be considered one of the kpop prodigies at present... For people asking why.. just look at her performance in Queendom especially 'I miss you'. I have never seen someone sing as flawlessly as her LIVE . She ain't my first bias,and while I stan Mamamoo ( multistan here), they aren't my first group.... but Wheein deserves a lot of praise.
@@junsseorafim Well everyone has their own opinions I guess . Nowadays I put Wendy/Yuju/Solar/Wheein/Siyeon all at the same position taking in to consideration how much they maintain stable vocals and according to how hard their dance routines are ,during their vocal routines. Can consider this the hardships of a multistan..lol I would also put Spica's Boa at the same rank ... sadly they disbanded. ( Present group- Keembo)
For me, Wendy is the best singer in 3rd generation.. she can sing in every genre and she mastering various vocal techniques.. she also have power and her registers tho.. she deserves to be the queen of vocals in 3rd generations
Mariyam Nasira we know she’s a queen and underrated 💖 I love her voice but she’s weak at her low registers. Not hating its just my observation💖 but she’ll definitely beat wendy at a singing competition💖
Kenichi Ono but Technique wise Wendy is way more superior and her technique is desirable. Try to listen to Yuju now her voice is overworked and tired due to pushing for them high notes and the company did nothing. Wendy keeps on getting high notes and still hasn’t damaged anything due to having a good upper register that isn’t being overuses
I'm sorry friend, but Rose is CLEARLY not a top 5, questionalbe as a top 10. Trust me BP was my first ever girlgroup and Istill stan but everytime I go over this list there's no scenario where Rose gets out of the basement. I assume your opinion is really bias for Rose (thats ok 👍) but objectively speaking, the rest are just better.
Yuju always Queen , her voice is the prettiest thing my ears hace heard , vocal legend 😍❤️ Wendy angel, her voice is beautiful ❤️😍 Solar's voice is powerful and stable love her so much ❤️ Chuu is a wonderful vocalist ❤️ Siyeon Queen ❤️ All of the vocalist in this ranking have an amazing voice, each one with them own technique , stability
Listen u all sucks. This doesn't mean that who have highnotes is the best vocalist in kpop girl group. Lolll u fucks. And I am not hating I am just telling
![TOP 15 BEST MAIN VOCALIST IN KPOP GIRL GROUP [2014-2019]](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
