Тёмный

Traveling through North Korea | DW Documentary 

DW Documentary
Подписаться 6 млн
Просмотров 3,4 млн
50% 1

This documentary provides a rare glimpse of change in the notoriously closed country. Filmmakers Gregor Möllers and Anne Lewald discretely shot the video on trips to North Korea in 2013 and 2017, when they were not allowed autonomy or spontaneity.
Despite the fact that their itinerary was arranged for them in advance and guides chaperoned them everywhere, the two Berliners found a way to register their impressions. They depict a city lacking authenticity, a country longing for reunification and a people shaped by Juche beliefs and socialist propaganda. In a society steeped in obfuscation and spectacle, where deception is necessary for perception and expression, the filmmakers were forced to play a double role, secretly recording without permission while also genuinely relating to their hosts. By blending travelogue and espionage, A Postcard from Pyongyang captures what happens when you rely solely on what you see, not what you’re told, and reveals a reality Kim Jong-Un’s regime doesn’t want foreigners to see.
------------------------------------------------------------------
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch high-class documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Also subscribe to:
DW Documental (Spanish): / dwdocumental
DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو: (Arabic): / dwdocarabia
For more visit:
www.dw.com/en/tv/docfilm/s-3610
Instagram:
/ dwdocumentary
Facebook:
/ dw.stories
DW netiquette policy: p.dw.com/p/MF1G

Опубликовано:

 

1 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 3,3 тыс.   
@Eqvil
@Eqvil 2 года назад
I understand that they went in and filmed incognito, but showing the faces of their guides while probing them, and endangering their livelihoods after these guys go back to safety of their own country is absolutely detestable.
@Trollika_Devi
@Trollika_Devi 2 года назад
Yeah ! Just what I was thinking while watching it. Those people could get murdered because of this. Dw should have blurred their faces
@Eqvil
@Eqvil 2 года назад
@@RedScotland a guide deemed them too risky and swapped with another. This does not happen unless real danger is in the picture for speaking negatively against the regime.
@kek207
@kek207 2 года назад
@@Eqvil I don't think they were sent to a labor camp for that but they might have gotten in trouble with their supervisor
@lelz0394
@lelz0394 2 года назад
​@@RedScotland You really shouldve been born there
@hungerhaken9682
@hungerhaken9682 2 года назад
@@RedScotland what do you mean by enslaved consciousness?
@anya5893
@anya5893 3 года назад
I'm obsessed with documentaries about North Korea. I've watched almost every single one on RU-vid.
@kaitertot
@kaitertot 3 года назад
Me too! It's fascinating
@Steveinthailand
@Steveinthailand 3 года назад
SAO Documentary on DPRK are by far the best insight
@CANvsDK
@CANvsDK 3 года назад
U must like cult like mentality videos. I watch Both north Korean and cult documentaries they are very similar
@douglasallen511
@douglasallen511 3 года назад
@@Steveinthailand but some of the episodes are really boring, like in the shoe factory as an example.
@eedragonr6293
@eedragonr6293 3 года назад
@@douglasallen511 outsourcing leasing?
@Kdude563
@Kdude563 Год назад
When I went to South Korea 3 years ago to visit my family, I had the opportunity to visit the DMZ. I was surprised at how still the soldiers are. On the border, the north and south Korean soldiers stare into each other's souls. There was also that eerie atmosphere on the border.
@dcollier7239
@dcollier7239 Год назад
NK party soldier's have no soul. Their not allowed too. It's called brainwashed and threatened.
@1deep499
@1deep499 Год назад
Strange.....😳👀
@yarajax5023
@yarajax5023 Год назад
May I ask how did you get to leave? And we’re you afraid you wouldn’t be able to go back to where you were coming from?❤️
@Kdude563
@Kdude563 Год назад
@@yarajax5023 It was a guided tour.
@larim4445
@larim4445 Год назад
It's still technically a warzone
@sus10651
@sus10651 Год назад
I hope that lady is doing okay. You guys should have blurred her face and protected her identity. I really hope she is doing okay.
@taijisyxom6888
@taijisyxom6888 Год назад
absolutely. and why is this not a 10 hours video? too many cuts
@ChrisCer1
@ChrisCer1 11 месяцев назад
Detestable is the regime not the media
@potatosalad6699
@potatosalad6699 10 месяцев назад
I’m sure the government knows who the guides are and are aware foreigners are in their country well ahead of time.
@nonenone4433
@nonenone4433 7 месяцев назад
This might not necessarily have helped. There is a good chance NK keeps track of everyone guiding or contacting with foreigners (be it a minder or a museum guide). esp. after such videos have been released.
@Gusr404
@Gusr404 4 месяца назад
She probably gone by now
@hourz
@hourz 3 года назад
I feel bad if any of these people get in trouble for unknowing being recorded.
@sherwood9917
@sherwood9917 3 года назад
I share your concerns.
@erikthehalfabee6234
@erikthehalfabee6234 3 года назад
I hope they thought it over well
@sth7603
@sth7603 3 года назад
Diffidently , it is a crime the #DW must be acted as responsible
@chrisp755
@chrisp755 3 года назад
original lol
@dothedelima1065
@dothedelima1065 3 года назад
Collateral Damage?
@emthebest
@emthebest 2 года назад
Honestly, I’m a little worried for the people that were unknowingly recorded. I wouldn’t be surprised if they got in serious trouble.
@allbyhisgrace8925
@allbyhisgrace8925 2 года назад
Exactly my thoughts.selfish from.this guy really didn't try to sensor anything or protect these people in any way ,cared about himself and making a name foe himself at the expense of these peoples lives and safety. Entitled, selfish guy.
@DWDocumentary
@DWDocumentary 2 года назад
We received the following statement from the filmmakers regarding people's safety: “This was of course a question we asked ourselves after we first went into editing, after all we were simply travelers and not trained experts. Accordingly, we gathered various expert opinions, had long conversations, and therefore decided not to publish certain scenes. Therefore, there are no statements of the guides in our film, which are not also in accordance with the regime.”
@Thursdaym2
@Thursdaym2 2 года назад
@@allbyhisgrace8925 Bet you watched it to the end though.
@1TUFZ71
@1TUFZ71 2 года назад
@@allbyhisgrace8925 what's selfish and entitled are your baseless assumptions, as if you have a clue what's on the cutting room floor 😉
@in9725
@in9725 2 года назад
who cares
@alexq.8696
@alexq.8696 2 года назад
I never understood why reporters like you keep asking those kind of questions knowing they could get in a huge trouble or basically disregard your entire question entirely. It's so irresponsible.
@miaomiaou_
@miaomiaou_ Год назад
Yes it’s upsetting. We all know the sort of fate they could be subjected to yet they probe them anyway. It’s cruel. What sort of answers are they expecting to get anyway?
@never_give_up90
@never_give_up90 Месяц назад
I bet you they got some real answers before, on camera but never shared. They even pointed out how the guide was loyal to the country and said nothing, while chances are he said something that got him in trouble.
@merricat3025
@merricat3025 Месяц назад
Are they actually reporters?
@DJMUHIB
@DJMUHIB Год назад
I honestly feel so sad for these poor souls who were recorded unknowingly. This is not responsible journalism when you already know what type of critical environment these people live in. I hope they are alive and safe. Feel so worried for that lady who was talking about South Korea and also the guide who shared their personal lives.
@pbond9405
@pbond9405 5 месяцев назад
A very irresponsible documentary putting lives at risk. Extremely unprofessional. I don't expect this from DW.
@strykerthepsycher8412
@strykerthepsycher8412 5 месяцев назад
Do you know the time stamp of the lady who was talking about South Korea?
@KokomiyaSangonomi
@KokomiyaSangonomi 3 месяца назад
​@@strykerthepsycher841219:52
@user-dd1ud1tu2r
@user-dd1ud1tu2r 2 месяца назад
⁠@@strykerthepsycher8412 19:45
@amaduconate5262
@amaduconate5262 3 года назад
These DW Documentaries are getting so addictive
@Kimjongun19841
@Kimjongun19841 3 года назад
North Korea is the best Korea
@twizzy4285
@twizzy4285 3 года назад
@@Kimjongun19841 Heil Kim Jong-un!
@at2509able
@at2509able 3 года назад
True that
@Kimjongun19841
@Kimjongun19841 3 года назад
African Pirate thank you comrade
@bethroesch2156
@bethroesch2156 3 года назад
They're definitely helping make my days better 👍🏼 I love their documentaries ❤️
@ld7599
@ld7599 3 года назад
I'm surprised that the juche museum guide admitted that the south has a higher standard of living
@richshipman9738
@richshipman9738 3 года назад
Send the guides mail to labor camp 40
@punypunic2224
@punypunic2224 3 года назад
She was never heard from again.
@flashladderacrobat
@flashladderacrobat 3 года назад
She lost 60 lbs. in the labour camp where she was sent for reconditioning.
@conorquarry615
@conorquarry615 3 года назад
I’ve seen in a couple of documentaries North Korean people have said this, and have heard them say they are taught this, but that the higher standard of living has lead to a degradation of society, so it’s taught as a bad thing
@richshipman9738
@richshipman9738 3 года назад
I can't help but think what DID happen to that young lady and three generations of her family???
@ohlordy9680
@ohlordy9680 2 года назад
The fact that we get free documentaries on RU-vid by DW Documentary is truly a gift 👍👍👍
@AWindy94
@AWindy94 Год назад
You speak the true true.
@jawarren7
@jawarren7 Год назад
I've watched so many of these types of North Korea documentaries, and what struck me most was the woman discussing religion - her tone was so friendly and casual compared to almost every other official I've seen. It was such a contrast.
@CNYKnifeNut
@CNYKnifeNut Год назад
I agree. I've never seen such (seemingly) genuine curiousity.
@taijisyxom6888
@taijisyxom6888 Год назад
This video is the answer of: Why is dictatorship beautiful? Such a contrast indeed. While Russia is bad at everything, North Korea is doing better than many thought
@alexm6193
@alexm6193 3 года назад
"Don't point at the statue" he says, pointing at the statue.
@scotthull2141
@scotthull2141 3 года назад
LoL😂 he's saying: rike me, you white people don't get to point at Supreme Leader
@marlistrioakbar1227
@marlistrioakbar1227 3 года назад
Lol 😂😂😂😂
@Mona.2307
@Mona.2307 3 года назад
Hilarious 😂
@earlaweese
@earlaweese 3 года назад
*He’s probably dead now.*
@Kimjongun19841
@Kimjongun19841 3 года назад
Pointing is only allowed for Koreans
@oudumbarrajput1858
@oudumbarrajput1858 3 года назад
I think the identities of North Koreans who interacted with DW should not have revealed irrespective of their opinions rearding the regime.
@zambe811
@zambe811 3 года назад
Right. They might be killed
@courageunitycompassi
@courageunitycompassi 3 года назад
I agree. I assume all the people interviewed in these shows end up in labor camps.
@vitalino1981
@vitalino1981 3 года назад
I think they already killed or jailed
@nehcooahnait7827
@nehcooahnait7827 3 года назад
Sigh. DW made this documentary to debunk the myths concerning N Korea yet people like you are still like ‘should reveal the identities’ ‘could be killed’ ‘ yeah yeah’
@Miller-hg9dw
@Miller-hg9dw 3 года назад
I don't think that people were being negative about their country. Also blurring their faces would not made a difference anyway. If thats the case, many documentaries shouldn't be ever been published.
@deltillis
@deltillis 2 года назад
These reporters were very irresponsible in recording their minders, grilling them, and then not even trying to blur their faces. It is obvious these reporters did not care for these people's well being So sad...I really hope they are ok.
@jackbrown4120
@jackbrown4120 2 года назад
Of course they're OK.
@martafiord
@martafiord 2 года назад
Even if they blurred their faces, the dictator, sorry leader, knows who they are as it’s all registered.
@itsStiflersMomTTV
@itsStiflersMomTTV Год назад
@@jackbrown4120 how would u know? :)
@rashiidabdallah1648
@rashiidabdallah1648 Год назад
@@itsStiflersMomTTV how would" you" know too?🙄🤔
@EvelinaNinudottir
@EvelinaNinudottir Год назад
@@rashiidabdallah1648 Where does Stifler claim to know?
@laikanbarth
@laikanbarth 2 года назад
I loved the girl in the green outfit that was showing them around the museum and teaching them about the “juche”. I hope she’s okay. I really hope you all didn’t get her in trouble by recording what she said. Her English was perfect!!
@sirapos6550
@sirapos6550 2 года назад
Me too,I liked her much,great body !
@Nocgirl
@Nocgirl 2 года назад
She was the first curvy North Korean I have seen. I liked her. She seems sweet.
@riturajborah382
@riturajborah382 2 года назад
I the reporters are not that understanding to take all that in to consideration.
@jonkoss3867
@jonkoss3867 2 года назад
I'm sure she's doing fine, infact probably better than you.
@FOOJFOOJIYAMA
@FOOJFOOJIYAMA 2 года назад
Every people that work under NK tourism has a handler. such small mistakes like that are usually overlooked after a talk with their handlers. worst case scenario is a pay cut. sure they are trained what to say to foreigners but what foreigners think that guides are avoiding question in fear of punishment is actually their sense of patriotism. lets not forget that North-korean people are trained to be patriotic at a very young age. punishing people for petty mistakes is expensive and western media poisoning.
@farfarokfarfarok
@farfarokfarfarok 3 года назад
They shouldn't ask guides provocative questions. It's putting them at great risk.
@tpenoel88
@tpenoel88 3 года назад
that is a journalist job, thats why north korea prohibited journalist as stated in the begining of the video
@Jerry-gt7kx
@Jerry-gt7kx 3 года назад
Sad contradiction. Journalists had to ask. Guides had to shut their mouth.
@MrThe1234guy
@MrThe1234guy 3 года назад
@@Jerry-gt7kx they are ambush journalists. Unfortunately not the first either. They know they are probably being recorded too. Do they think they are dumb?
@deepdivedisco4779
@deepdivedisco4779 3 года назад
@@tpenoel88 Yeah but they signed a contract saying they wouldn't pose those journalist type questions. I mean it's great that we can see North Korea on video, but there's no need for a political commentary.
@jennamiles8787
@jennamiles8787 3 года назад
I dont think so, in the past the guides have not been killed.
@user-qy4sp4fv2r
@user-qy4sp4fv2r 2 года назад
As a south Korean It's painful to see only through a western person's eyes
@daveseemerollin6357
@daveseemerollin6357 2 года назад
@@reedfaulk much, much worse I've done a lot of personal research on this subject dating back to 2010. It's worth a read if you're interested.
@Maplelust
@Maplelust 2 года назад
@@reedfaulk the guy in this video only saw what they allowed him to see. notice how many peope were spying on him when he was running the Marathon to make sure he didn't run off course. they had him locked up. whatever is happening there is obviously awful. it's sobering to see the lengths they goto to hide their true colors.
@naimishmaniya8382
@naimishmaniya8382 Год назад
@@daveseemerollin6357 I'm interesting
@javiermartinez-pais767
@javiermartinez-pais767 2 года назад
I feel bad for the guides. They are just doing their work, they are not doing anything wrong, just trying to live peacefully. Why ask them uncomfortable questions??
@Page57
@Page57 Год назад
Why not?
@marianamartinez9311
@marianamartinez9311 Год назад
@@Page57 they could be killed, quite simple actually.
@hypnobearcoup2505
@hypnobearcoup2505 11 месяцев назад
Not just them, North Korea has a three generation punishment policy. If you say something wrong they won’t just kill you, they’ll kill your parents and children.
@karthiksivasiva
@karthiksivasiva 3 года назад
I hope the guides don't get punished for the secret recordings of the these journalists.
@jennamiles8787
@jennamiles8787 3 года назад
@Chime In I dont think so, in the past the guides have not been killed.
@chanelvenus
@chanelvenus 3 года назад
Obviously these journalists don’t care.
@SubscriberswithDankPlaylists
@SubscriberswithDankPlaylists 3 года назад
I thought of that too
@Kimjongun19841
@Kimjongun19841 3 года назад
We have sent them to camp Just to be sure
@TrashyBadBitchVivi
@TrashyBadBitchVivi 3 года назад
It's not like they have access to RU-vid in NK, even if they did, what are the chances of them finding this exact video? Little to none, they'll be fine.
@TenshiProductionz
@TenshiProductionz 2 года назад
"Plastic flowers that brought back to the stand to be sold again." Thats actually a pretty good idea lol.
@jsteinman
@jsteinman 2 года назад
Very capitalist
@yasserhussaini2104
@yasserhussaini2104 2 года назад
Yes definitely a record-breaking idea!
@usman_ghuman
@usman_ghuman 2 года назад
Very common in subcontinent. religions places like temples/tombs use this method in Pakistan & India to recycle the baits/gifts which visitors buy and offer to holy sites 🤣
@ferosemariehass4576
@ferosemariehass4576 2 года назад
🤣
@piero17y65
@piero17y65 2 года назад
The environment is also important.
@alexjacoboramos
@alexjacoboramos 2 года назад
I’m so happy I found this RU-vid channel, such great content.
@DWDocumentary
@DWDocumentary 2 года назад
Thanks for watching and subscribing.
@mikael557
@mikael557 8 месяцев назад
What a well put together documentary. It was cool to see the contrast between the first and second visit. There is hope.
@DWDocumentary
@DWDocumentary 8 месяцев назад
Thank you for watching and taking the time to comment!
@bartcolen
@bartcolen 2 года назад
Almost invariably, such travel documentaries about North Korea feature Westerners asking difficult political questions of their minders, seemingly unaware that even the slightest mis-step on the minders' part could see them and their entire families wind up in prison camps. It's a kind of thoughtlessness that, at least in this person's opinion, is in no way justified under the name of "fair and honest reporting" or "journalistic integrity." It's putting people's lives at risk.
@jeanneann3545
@jeanneann3545 2 года назад
Ikr i always feel enraged at that kind of thoughtless actions. Like... They are not animals in zoo for people to peek and poke at them and put them in danger. When you see north Koreans got questioned and they shuffling, looking around and then looked at the camera hopelessly it didnt feel fun... It feels horrible!
@RyanWolfNZ
@RyanWolfNZ 2 года назад
I have to agree with you on that. While I do appreciate the doc they should have blurred peoples faces for their own protection. Typical western selfishness.
@ems7623
@ems7623 2 года назад
It's an impossible situation for journalists. They are so restricted by the PRNK that if they don't do things that are unwelcome or risky, they can only produce the exact propaganda footage that the PRNK wants. That, of course, is a disservice to everyone including Koreans who suffer under the Kim regime. I'm not sure the criticism you make is one that can ever be redressed. It's very serious, yes - but it's also a complete conundrum for journalism.
@Ss-qr2lp
@Ss-qr2lp Год назад
Totally agree with you
@user-dw1it5rs8o
@user-dw1it5rs8o 11 месяцев назад
슬프지만 그들의 작은 실수로 죽을 수 잇고 감시와 검색을 당합니다.
@georgepetrin1334
@georgepetrin1334 3 года назад
Well done. As much as I dislike the regime, I have a lot of empathy for the people.
@Rossbrian1
@Rossbrian1 2 года назад
Don't worry too much , if you are American they hate you
@holonow4298
@holonow4298 2 года назад
@@Rossbrian1 because they are brainwashed to hate america. Duh 🙄
@scythal
@scythal 2 года назад
@@Rossbrian1 They don't hate the American people lol, they see the American people as "oppressed" by the American government.
@tyronevaldez-kruger5313
@tyronevaldez-kruger5313 2 года назад
@@scythal Do you really believe that North Koreans - who live under the epitome of opression - care about Americans who perceive bs like mandatory vaccine passports as oppressive measures? You wouldn't survive a single day in North Korea. Unbelievable...
@tyronevaldez-kruger5313
@tyronevaldez-kruger5313 2 года назад
@Repeeel19 Amendment It's the government that provides freebies. First blame those mf's, then the lazies but please leave ppl tf alone who really need it. You really believe that passport is oppressiv? I remember half of America used to believe in Trump's downplaying of Covid plus the urgency to find a vaccine, until he got infected and took the in the meantime created vaccine. All of a sudden hooray🍻... the very same praised the new "Trump vaccine" and today that little piece called vaccine passport is supposed to be Hitleri-sh? What if a vaccine passport saved Trump's life? I know it's a bs thought but just a scenario, what if🤔
@jharris947
@jharris947 2 года назад
22:02-23:42 Very impressed by the timing and co-ordination of all who took part. 😎As always, an excellent video.👍
@DirtyMikeandTheBoyz
@DirtyMikeandTheBoyz Год назад
0: cool! Worth the click. Thanks bro. ❤️
@djphilipj
@djphilipj 8 месяцев назад
Very interesting information along with footage. Well made documentary.
@kaitlin2400
@kaitlin2400 3 года назад
I got to travel to South Korea years ago and take a tour of the DMZ. Looking across the border and seeing the soldiers on the North Korean side was scary. It was very quiet and eerie but it was an experience I’ll never forget.
@annacargill6066
@annacargill6066 2 года назад
that is scary indeed
@Trollika_Devi
@Trollika_Devi 2 года назад
The streets are all so empty in these videos. It's sooooo eeerie
@Kim_Jong_Un_2023
@Kim_Jong_Un_2023 2 года назад
I saw you from the other side
@TheFakeyCakeMaker
@TheFakeyCakeMaker 2 года назад
It's mad but I actually want to go to North Korea.
@Maplelust
@Maplelust 2 года назад
the US had to fight those people at one point.
@alias11786
@alias11786 3 года назад
Couldn't think of anything worse than running a marathon then immediately being stuck on a bus for 4 hours.
@Step2thebar
@Step2thebar 2 года назад
I was in pyongyang as part of a tour group in june 2019. We were in a tour bus. After visiting the Victory Arch, the NorKor version of the Arc de triomphe, on our way to our dinner venue, our bus, along with all other vehicles were halted at the intersection, a main artery leading from the palace, supposedly to let the visiting Chinese president Xi jinping and Kim jong un pass through, we were stuck for almost three hours waiting, my bladder was unable to find relief, i cannot go down to pee at some random store nor were there public toilets or a fast food restaurant, no pictures nor videos allowed as well. It was a memorable but vividly horrid time. I only got to pee as i hobbled to the restaurant restroom arriving there after a further 20 minutes from the time theintersection was opened.
@tijuanaiguana190
@tijuanaiguana190 Год назад
This was dangerous how you were interrogating the guides and not protecting their identities. Very irresponsible
@farhadfarhadian1111
@farhadfarhadian1111 Год назад
Thanks for the fabulous work
@ellen5572
@ellen5572 2 года назад
This documentary shows only what the regime wants visitors to see, i.e., Pyongyang and the ski resort. From books by North Koreans who escaped North Korea, the rest of the country is very poor. People live without enough food, without electricity, etc., in addition to fear of expressing an opinion against the government.
@Abman31
@Abman31 2 года назад
This country looks like a gigantic stage where all its actors are trained from the moment they are born .
@niklasfreericks5436
@niklasfreericks5436 2 года назад
Yeah, everything just feels fake
@iurietivladut7607
@iurietivladut7607 3 года назад
I am surprised how open was that museum guide towards them...stating that the south koreans have a higher standard of life and even pointing at her clothes like "i mean...look at me and how I look" ...I just hope that nobody got in trouble after those discussions.
@DWDocumentary
@DWDocumentary 3 года назад
Hi Iurieti, might be interesting for you to check out our DW Documentary Instagram Channel, where the authors of this docu give you more personal information about there experiences!
@ElliotWORLD
@ElliotWORLD Год назад
Well done! Most interesting RU-vid watch in a very long time.
@DWDocumentary
@DWDocumentary Год назад
Thanks for watching and your positive feedback:)
@xindigochildx
@xindigochildx Год назад
Sorry to hear that you felt unwell, hope you felt better 🌸
@jianpingwang6916
@jianpingwang6916 3 года назад
3:11 Odd to hear a North Korean guide referring to their own country as “North Korea”. They typically just say “Korea” based on what I’ve heard in other travel documentaries.
@denise5879
@denise5879 3 года назад
They say Bokdu in Korean and South is hageuk. So in Korean they use 2 different words. Idk about English, though.
@meddena
@meddena 3 года назад
The shots are pretty amazing considering the circumstances they were taken in.
@Rossbrian1
@Rossbrian1 2 года назад
What circumstances? You are allowed to film anything you want except military lol
@Scythical
@Scythical 2 года назад
@@Rossbrian1 actually not true. You're only allowed to film what the military allows
@seltaeb3302
@seltaeb3302 2 года назад
His camera stick must have a gimball thing as he ran & filmed with hardly any shaking unlike his stomach.
@seltaeb3302
@seltaeb3302 2 года назад
@@Rossbrian1 he made a fair point no need for the juvenile Millennial sarcasm.
@misslevapor
@misslevapor 2 года назад
After listening to the woman speak about North Korea and the juche, and her English I have a greater respect for North Koreans . The leader but the honest regular people who somehow find the path to be able to learn about differences and other truths of the world
@Bedroom_Musician
@Bedroom_Musician Год назад
Knowing more about North Korea give me sadness and depression. I literally cried. Those people are like they don't even have their own life. I really feel sad for them. I pray to God that This people can enjoy their life one day, May God helps them that one day that they can live their life freely .🙏
@diesel_dawg
@diesel_dawg 3 года назад
At that festival in the arena, I thought that was a screen in the background. But kids with cards? Insane! :o
@jupitercyclops6521
@jupitercyclops6521 3 года назад
An old American saying -"believe none of what you hear, and only half of what you see"
@wilfredzielinski5685
@wilfredzielinski5685 2 года назад
what a great video thankyou
@banistan3500
@banistan3500 Год назад
спасибо за контент
@somethingaboutbeaute
@somethingaboutbeaute 2 года назад
I don't think I've missed a single DW DPRK documentary & I'm certain I've watched each one at least 5+ times because they're just that interesting. There's 2 of them I've watched over 10 times. You've been a godsend during covid. Keep up the great content. Watching from Canada.... Nancy. 🙂💯👍❤️😁🇨🇦
@gmoney3479
@gmoney3479 2 года назад
I know what you mean .. very interesting
@somethingaboutbeaute
@somethingaboutbeaute 2 года назад
@@gmoney3479 you definitely nailled what i meant for sure. 🙂
@fresatx
@fresatx 2 года назад
You have Juiche powers now!!!
@josesalas2232
@josesalas2232 2 года назад
Foreal they are
@cindysandberg643
@cindysandberg643 2 года назад
Another Canadian here. I just love these kind of videos.
@Neillan
@Neillan 3 года назад
7:16 "We wanted to leave the country in one piece." The difference here is, unlike the people you recklessly filmed UNCENSORED, *you can leave.*
@suziwatkins5499
@suziwatkins5499 3 года назад
I don't think I would want to visit North Korea...thank you very much.!🤔🤨
@FlamJongUn
@FlamJongUn 3 года назад
@@suziwatkins5499 why not? It's a charming country
@aessedai2739
@aessedai2739 2 года назад
@@FlamJongUn pretentiously charming
@joeyd4364
@joeyd4364 10 месяцев назад
Extraordinary footage. Outstanding!
@quadraticequation8803
@quadraticequation8803 Год назад
I can't believe you finished that marathon!
@leasmith914
@leasmith914 3 года назад
this documentary is pretty insightful but I'm really concerned about the tour guide and woman's safety.
@neptunevibe
@neptunevibe 3 года назад
"In South Korea they care about money.. In North Korea we care about leader.. his money!"
@andresd3104
@andresd3104 3 года назад
You would be sent to the north korean gulag for saying that.
@companybroadcast2890
@companybroadcast2890 3 года назад
@Blaz Blaz good joke
@eedragonr6293
@eedragonr6293 3 года назад
@@ezfist9204 tell us what is the procedure of claiming political asylum at the USA embassy
@makemarker
@makemarker Год назад
I don't think unification is possible without getting rid of that atrocious regime.
@parkinggirl
@parkinggirl Год назад
so interesting
@ninana143
@ninana143 2 года назад
That feeling of euphoria he got while people where "cheering" him on is the reason why Kim's grandpa, father and himself are a leaders. The feeling is prob an addiction you can't quit.
@henrimatisse7481
@henrimatisse7481 2 года назад
The same with Trump. A drug he was willing to lie for and get others to die for.
@quackss6384
@quackss6384 2 года назад
@@henrimatisse7481 difference is he was elected.
@alexslater4185
@alexslater4185 2 года назад
The reason for the euphoria when he enters a room, or in a public place is that the people there get photographed,.and get severely dealt with if they are seen to be applauding less energetically than they should be.
@jackbrown4120
@jackbrown4120 2 года назад
@@alexslater4185 how do you know?
@alexslater4185
@alexslater4185 2 года назад
@@jackbrown4120 How do any of us know anything Jack ? We learn to read at school, we read books and other people's texts, we watch documentaries, and films, and as life goes by we learn to authenticate the truth, and dismiss the drivel. We aren't always right, but when we get the same information from different sources, the later information we get tends to verify what we have seen before. If you watch a leader like putin enter a room full of his cohorts in the Kremlin, the same thing happens, they are all applauding him because they know that they will receive severe punishment when the videos are rerun later if they are not seen to be loyal, yet reading news items would suggest that there is a high percentage of them who definitely don't support him. It is also an ego boost too.
@gregmiga1393
@gregmiga1393 3 года назад
There is NO reason for anybody to go to nk. Just the fact that some innocent may end up in a gulag for being on film is reason enough.
@eedragonr6293
@eedragonr6293 3 года назад
Some are ready to buy everything. Perhaps make the gulag private too.
@gekkegerrit5245
@gekkegerrit5245 3 года назад
I want to visit after watching this
@lizmowrey9866
@lizmowrey9866 3 года назад
Yep. I wouldn't go unless things got better
@k3kboi665
@k3kboi665 2 года назад
Its the last socialist state on earth thats reason enough.
@lzl4226
@lzl4226 2 года назад
My friend actually went there..... and thought the food was great, some crazy shit..... although I don't think guides or the people being filmed would get into trouble, some of the stuff has to be overexaggerated, they wouldn't have too many german speaking guides to replace with and if they made big deal out of everything it would be negative propaganda too
@Knite_el6767
@Knite_el6767 2 года назад
Seeing the smiling excited older women, children, etc. who were even ready to high five a foreign runner was such a trip. I wonder in their minds if they really imagine people are traveling to the Pyongyang marathon because it's a big tourist draw in the usual sense.
@eprohoda
@eprohoda 2 года назад
broth!how you doing?! you created outstanding !:))
@Eponimos
@Eponimos 3 года назад
The lady in the museum was so cute Please blur her face, she might get in trouble after this
@alasdair6654
@alasdair6654 3 года назад
Naive is the word I'd use
@diana23456
@diana23456 3 года назад
Akrivoos
@reina13301
@reina13301 3 года назад
Yeah... I hope that they didn't execute her..
@MustangRimsJason
@MustangRimsJason 3 года назад
Same with the tour guides. I’m worried for their lives
@fadhhh
@fadhhh 3 года назад
Even it blurred, they will found her later or soon
@zarinacabarlo5758
@zarinacabarlo5758 3 года назад
Thank you DW Documentaries for this really awesome piece. I am addicted to NK documentaries and yours are my favorite. p.s. I am very curious on the hidden camera used in filming this docu. A very good quality camera 🤔😄
@rush_han_
@rush_han_ 2 года назад
I am concerned about what could happen to your guides after this material had uploaded
@Garbagepai1Kid
@Garbagepai1Kid 2 года назад
Could you imagine the Olympics being held in North Korea? They would totally nail the opening/closing ceremonies.
@sakshi3344
@sakshi3344 2 года назад
And they’ll nail you to a prison cell if u missed a beat while final performances
@medaraudoekong7586
@medaraudoekong7586 2 года назад
@@sakshi3344 lol
@geraldmiller5260
@geraldmiller5260 3 года назад
Reunification has not worked well for Hong Kong. North Korea is a dictatorial communist nation, it is NOT socialist.
@davidorlando6904
@davidorlando6904 2 года назад
have you thought about the repercussion of your work towards the two guides you met and you filmed? are them been considered responsible about letting you film? the video you made has been clearly seen in North Corea and i assume this created a lot of problems on the two tour guides............i hope for you it doesn't
@katerinacapova
@katerinacapova 2 года назад
The thing is, that Pyongjang people are the top layer of society. Poor people from villages can't get there without permission.
@allthingstravon21
@allthingstravon21 Год назад
its insane that Pyongyang, a city of 3 million has very few cars on the road. Its eerie to see. North Koreans, unless you're an elite or in government, don't even get to have cars. Its horrible. I hate that the world has turned a blind eye and continued to allow this. Also it would be scary to stay in a North Korean hotel. With there only being two for foreigners, I'd bet a trillion $ that Kim Jong Un himself is watching you on a camera from his compound 😩
@blackmamba5593
@blackmamba5593 Год назад
huh horrible? In fact it helps protecting environment whereas all your cars only pollute it. And it's also healthy to walk, be active and inhale fresh air.
@kurt168
@kurt168 9 месяцев назад
@@blackmamba5593shut up
@jaybministros7980
@jaybministros7980 2 года назад
I'm amazed at how DW journalists have managed to hide their cameras while filming secretly at the same time all throughout their tour without being caught by their minders.
@TheSmartLawyer
@TheSmartLawyer 2 года назад
I think this was allowed
@TitoTimTravels
@TitoTimTravels 2 года назад
@@TheSmartLawyer Well he said all the way through that he was filming in secret...
@karolsjolund4244
@karolsjolund4244 2 года назад
They’re German so I think they know what they’re doing. Well done!👍👏🇨🇦😀
@henrimatisse7481
@henrimatisse7481 2 года назад
it was said at the beginning they had cameras with a video function. Something that wasn't checked.
@curtgottler9961
@curtgottler9961 2 года назад
@@henrimatisse7481 So this guy is secretly filming while running the marathon, but no one noticed? I think this guy is lying about something.
@OilBaron100
@OilBaron100 3 года назад
I really like these DW documentaries. It was good to get an explanation of how the tour guides monitor each other.
@OilBaron100
@OilBaron100 3 года назад
Can you do a documentary, in English, about the Stasiheit?
@Oskar_A.
@Oskar_A. Год назад
Wonderful documentary! I enjoyed watching very much. Such a fascinating and unique country!
@jayaramanp7267
@jayaramanp7267 Год назад
A very pragmatic picture of North Korea without much negativity. This is in contrast to other videos about North Korea which I have seen. Was able to get a glimpse of NK, Thanks DW for this wonderful documentary. From Tamilnadu India.
@Lauraisabelgonzalezart
@Lauraisabelgonzalezart 3 года назад
Apart from an ad every 5-6min, this is a great documentary!
@kennyclauw9713
@kennyclauw9713 2 года назад
addblock lol
@ruwiki
@ruwiki 3 года назад
really love your documentaries!
@Whoknows688
@Whoknows688 2 месяца назад
39:39 I remember singing this song in Chorus class back in middle school. They gave us a partially translated version to sing, but I had forgotten about this song until now!
@yohanmaduranga
@yohanmaduranga Год назад
Good video 📸 thanks dw
@DWDocumentary
@DWDocumentary Год назад
Thank you for your comment!
@roycebottoms4570
@roycebottoms4570 2 года назад
The synthesizer they use for the voice over is really impressive. You'd almost think it's a real person.
@walking_in_the_shade
@walking_in_the_shade 2 года назад
Hahaha that hilarious!! 😄
@damzstudio
@damzstudio 3 года назад
I love the way they show their experiences in so complex country
@billybob3563
@billybob3563 Год назад
The ironic thing about North korea and South korea is that they have the best of both worlds. North korea is rich in mineral wealth but because of hilly terrain most of the land isn't good for farming. Meanwhile South korea has farmland and is the literal breadbasket for the land but lacks the mineral wealth of the North so it must import mass amounts of raw materials. If they ever united they would become the 2nd strongest asian superpower behind china.
@ratanaheng9705
@ratanaheng9705 Год назад
Very nice
@mikethespike7579
@mikethespike7579 2 года назад
My job as an engineering consultant brought me to quite a few communist ruled countries in my time, some times for months on end. What I learned there is that the capitol cities of all these countries were just Potemkin villages. Beyond the city boundaries, where tourists didn't go, was a different country, one which wasn't happy and colourful, where everything was rundown, where there were hardly any street lights, the streets broken, where people looked malnourished, their skin grey. I'm under no illusions that that's what N. Korea is like beyond the city limits of its capitol.
@martafiord
@martafiord 2 года назад
To be honest, even what they could see and film was pretty horrible.
@kham6006
@kham6006 Год назад
Tell that to the Americans that are dying to become communists-
@ebberton
@ebberton Год назад
@@kham6006 I have a friend who wants to be a communist then I showed them this and they had changed there mind so fast
@mikethespike7579
@mikethespike7579 Год назад
@@kham6006 Nobody needs to try hard to become a communist. You just need to read Marx and a couple of other books by communists - Lenin for instance - and turn a blind eye to all the crimes that have been committed in the name of communism.
@blackmamba5593
@blackmamba5593 Год назад
@@ebberton I might show homeless and drug addicts on streets of america and those praising capitalism might also change their mind. This is such a narrow-minded logic. Communism is utopia and is not possible in a society driven by self-interest. Also idea has nothing to do with people who abused their power. You can take some elements from it, to narrow the gap between rich and poor and to ensure everyone has access to equal opportunities such as good education and health care. That's what happens in scndinavian countries and people there are happy and have much higher standard of living than in US.
@brokenomad
@brokenomad 3 года назад
Landscapes wise, it looks like a beautiful country
@Step2thebar
@Step2thebar 2 года назад
Very pristine and well preserved nature i can attest to it from my visit there
@Trollika_Devi
@Trollika_Devi 2 года назад
It really does ,doesn't it
@romystumpy1197
@romystumpy1197 2 года назад
@@Step2thebar my thoughts are that due to hunger they eat what ever they can.
@romystumpy1197
@romystumpy1197 2 года назад
@@RedScotland they dont have any forests as they have cut down all the trees for fuel
@apollon6870
@apollon6870 2 года назад
no adds, beautyful
@akari8168
@akari8168 5 месяцев назад
6:21 ich weiß nicht ob ich das richtig verstehen kann wegen dem Übersetzer aber für mich klang das deutch dieses Guides so gut das ich dachte der ist einer von euch und ihr unterhalten euch nur 😮 ich war total verwirrt als erwähnt wurde das er ein Guide ist, wie kann er so gut deutsch?
@JML6988
@JML6988 2 года назад
I'm curious if those guides would have been penalized for "allowing" themselves to be filmed undercover.
@Landis_Grant
@Landis_Grant 2 года назад
They were probably shot by a firing squad.
@deleted72636
@deleted72636 2 года назад
They didn't speak against their regime rather spoke in its favor so I doubt it.
@Jsodat
@Jsodat Год назад
Wrong! These guides would be severely punished! It’s ashamed they should have been blurred
@anitk.brahma7354
@anitk.brahma7354 2 года назад
I love all the documentary videos broadcast by DW Channel on RU-vid. Really I am an ardent follower of DW documentaries. All videos are very interesting and informative for viewers like me. Long Live DW ! Thank you..... Anit Brahma from Assam, India.
@user-fv4kr9qz5z
@user-fv4kr9qz5z 2 года назад
DW, это лживая западная утка.
@J.Cameron.Stuart.Adams.
@J.Cameron.Stuart.Adams. 2 года назад
If you consumed coffee, tea, or anything which used water from the tanks on the plane and/or from the kettles on the flight your gastrointestinal issue is easily explained. My enitre trip to NY was spent in the apartment because I had coffee on my flight. Never again. Great reporting. Although I would not have exposed my guides. Despite your filming in total secrecy, they could face punishment for not discovering your devices and methods. Cheers!
@carlahead5072
@carlahead5072 2 года назад
I think it’s very interesting to learn about North Korean culture and in many ways how different it is from South Korea . You guys are so brave to have visited such a place and these children are so talented!! My heart goes out to those and makes us who live in the US appreciate how it is to express our opinions openly without being punished.. happy that you guys went back and seen things had changed for the better for North Korea though and a different perspective. Great 👍 tours of North Korea and interesting culture
@G0t2luvMaggie
@G0t2luvMaggie 2 года назад
Ummm you should listen the podcast Jordan B. Peterson with Yeonmi Park; the woman who escapes the poverty of North Korea and it explains the class system. The reason tourist cannot go unaccompanied outside the hotel is that they might actually find out the grueling details and the dead people they’re hiding with the masked Korea is great, let’s show you our high class people and well fed children. There’s another video in which the French went to the Northern part of North Korea near the boarder of Russia and they literally showed them a fake village where no one lived. It was picturesque and the tourist was trying to sneak behind the brass large gates and fence and kept asking the guards if they can wander alone. They didn’t allow them and the person took a small clip of what was behind the fence through a small slot of the gate and they were children working and dragging things. They also accidentally went to the beach and found impoverished women picking up seaweed from the ocean to eat and immediately the tour guides and the guards told the tourist to leave the beach and the other tour guide said no you cannot go back there while they were attempting to go back to the beach. He said you can’t go there and they asked why and the man motioned with his hand to his neck basically letting them know that if he allows them back on the beach he’s risking his life. So if you call that children are so talented and how North Korean has changed for the better; you are certainly wrong. This is all a simulation to display North Korea’s good side and ignoring the devastation and mass deaths due to starvation.
@craighealy4069
@craighealy4069 2 года назад
I would love to see those 2 Kim towers torn down like the totalitarian fascist and communist leaders
@craighealy4069
@craighealy4069 2 года назад
You can basically get punished or executed for selling food to South Korea destroying newspapers turning off the radio shouting in public being to happy after the leaders death being to sad in public after the leaders death failing at the performance being religious the leader holding a grudge for no reason against you or if he is just in the mood to kill torture or lock up people in concentration camps trying to leave North Korea insulting the leader assaulting the leader military government official not placing or putting an image of the leader correctly showing anger happiness or aggression telling jokes having a phone calling a foreign relative having internet being to smart or dumb being to white or black unlawful sexual relationships or being related to someone the government didn’t like
@johnrakthai
@johnrakthai 11 месяцев назад
But we actually can’t express our opinions openly anymore. You get cancelled or blacklisted.
@merppa9842
@merppa9842 5 месяцев назад
⁠​⁠@@johnrakthaiyou are not seriously comparing ”being cancelled” to physical punishment, labor camps and worst case scenario, death. Surely not, right? Freedome to speak your Opinions does not mean that your words don’t have any consequences. But you are free the Express your opinion without systematic covernmental suppervision that leads to the punishment mentioned above. Come on now…
@SpecialKay24
@SpecialKay24 3 года назад
The image of that little girl waving throughout the documentary and at the end is heartwarming
@hullzor970
@hullzor970 2 года назад
Seeing the last parts of the documentary, really gives me hope for NK people. I've seen so many documentaries about that country over the years and in that final bit the people dont seem so stiff like in any earlier films where everyone walks around like there are spies everywhere (which there are, ofc). Also I belive im just fooled by the laid-back acting, like the lady carrying the groceries is going through the back to put them back into the store, I really hope she brought that bag home, even if they are the most privilidged part of NK people.
@joecalonge2220
@joecalonge2220 2 года назад
Un
@StoryBgTeguh
@StoryBgTeguh 8 месяцев назад
Jadi penasaran tentang negara korea utara.. pasti menegangkan untuk berwisata ke negara itu
@potatosalad6699
@potatosalad6699 10 месяцев назад
This is a great documentary. Doesn’t just show the down sides of the country but shows beautiful moments. The show they attended was the coolest thing ever and I go to many college marching band competitions 😂
@nancyhobson9710
@nancyhobson9710 3 года назад
Yes, amazing documentary considering the conditions in which it was filmed.
@tombombadil9123
@tombombadil9123 3 года назад
6:20 it's obviously embarrassing for him to talk about it. just as if I came to Germany and all I wanted to ask about was holocaust. I'd probably find same reluctance with most people.
@lunafringe10
@lunafringe10 2 года назад
germany has a lot more to hide then North Korea, The industrial destruction of humans
@PurooRoy
@PurooRoy 2 года назад
Or the witch burning.
@James-os2eg
@James-os2eg 2 года назад
Now that was an amazing documentary. Truly amazing
@axelsandi
@axelsandi 2 года назад
i am the laziest person i know, yet you motivated me to consider preparing for a marathon.. besides that, amazing insights about this forbiddingly fascinating country.. 10/10
@stephanemiallet6090
@stephanemiallet6090 2 года назад
Thanks for this documentary !
@TheAgim1
@TheAgim1 3 года назад
Thanks for this. I was running out of NK documentaries/footage to watch.
@omq_seqxuia8571
@omq_seqxuia8571 2 года назад
35:17 I cried out when I see these 2 little girls cheering up for him
@fightingfinn1503
@fightingfinn1503 2 года назад
I appreciate you adding subtitles but wish you didn't add them on the middle of the screen.
@pratheesh2312
@pratheesh2312 3 года назад
Even covid19 is afraid to enter north korea
@earthboundbella
@earthboundbella 3 года назад
@@thomasjamest why are u supporting North Korea so much ? Do u live there?
@blankblank5409
@blankblank5409 3 года назад
She he
@sunwukong5518
@sunwukong5518 3 года назад
@@earthboundbella yeah he writing with his samsung galaxy a 51 while eating at a restaurant
@rhysgriffiths3346
@rhysgriffiths3346 3 года назад
@@earthboundbella How does the possibility hes joking slip your mind?
@CanYouRememberWhen
@CanYouRememberWhen 3 года назад
I remember when it first started the news reported, the first man found there with covid 19 had been shot. I wondered if that was how they were going to control it in that country.
@MultiKwolf
@MultiKwolf 3 года назад
I'm not being rude or anything. But I think you should censor someone's face when they talk about something that is have nothing to do with the government's system. Keep it in mind, they have a horrible system in their prison. Where the next 3 generations will be punished severely by forced labor regardless if their next 3 generations are innocent.
@541katy
@541katy Год назад
thank you i think the same the people in this video probably got punish :c
@JaneDoe-ql7sc
@JaneDoe-ql7sc Год назад
That one guide who was replaced that evening might've been interrogated. Please be careful not to give the impression of a verboten type of conversation, so as not to give anyone a possible bad time.
@eMiLy-gr1pz
@eMiLy-gr1pz Год назад
What is the song called that is playing while they r in the train its beautiful
Далее
Пробую торты
00:43
Просмотров 225 тыс.
The Hermit Kingdom | VICE on HBO
31:11
Просмотров 14 млн
North Korea’s ‘Return to Paradise’ nightmare
19:01
INSIDE NORTH KOREA (Surreal experience)
14:23
Просмотров 13 млн
China's competition for living space | DW Documentary
42:27
The Great Game (Full Episode) | Inside North Korea
47:23
Пробую торты
00:43
Просмотров 225 тыс.