Tudor Black Bay 58 Watch Long Term Review 

I love the fact that you now show yourself on your videos. Great job, love your reviews.

The feel of the Black Bay 58 is so hard to describe. The bezel action is crisp and it's incredibly refined for a dive watch. Looks fantastic on that bracelet.

I have owned my Black Bay 58 for about 4 years now and I still love it. Great size, finishing, accuracy, classic looks. It is still one of my favorites.

Love my 58. Owned for 3 years without any issues. Accurate, durable and beautiful. Worth the money. Had mine on a nato for the last year. So comfortable, doubt I will ever go back to the bracelet.

I have the BB58 and use it all the time for fishing, field work, hiking, exploration work hunting and farming. It is very versitile and it is essential it can go down to 200 meters when I bring it to holiday trips and diving.

It’s so cool to have Yul Brynner reviewing my favorite watch. A great 20th century actor and a great timepiece. You made my day. 😉

Just bought the BB58 in blue preowned- It’s a terrific time to be a buyer of this piece,

The 58 is so well made and perfectly proportioned for a sports watch. It borrows from classic Tudors and Rolex without being a slave to an exact copy . It really is it’s own thing. The gilt bezel gives the 58 a warm feel, the red triangle offers a pop of color paying homage to the Rolex Big Crown, the chunky coin edge crown is so satisfying to wind with a refined matching coin edge bezel and I love the snow flake seconds hand. Owned my BB58 OG black for 3 years and it is one of my fav watches in my collection.

There is something about the blue Black Bay 58 I absolutely love. The size, the colour, the proportions, it's just a dream watch.

Amazing watch wearing it everywhere, gym, swimming even sauna had no problem for a year and a half. Strong and classical look 💪👌

Great long term feedback Pete. That blue 58 is just stunning

I’ve owned/own Rolex, omega, Breitling etc. Have owned 4 Tudors - currently have a blue BB58 and the silver case BB58. Never had a problem with any of my tudors. The BB58 is a wonderful watch IMO. Design, history, quality, VFM all top notch.

Epic to see this Australian-Greek hunk showing his face. Great vid as always.

That's beautiful watch, Pete 😊 The most important thing is that You love the watch. It is nice to hear others opinion but your opinion is the most important. We are buying and wearing watches for ourselves, not to impress somebody ❤ Ps. Sorry about my English, I'm from Croatia. Cheers Pete

Idk who said that but, they are wrong, tudor is not rubbish

I picked up one of these recently, and I love it! It’s my first watch at this price point and is such a leap forward in so many ways compared to my SPB237 and 143. It really feels like it’s MY watch.

Completely agree. It’s hard to describe exactly - but my collecting stopped the day I got the BB58. I didn’t expect that.

I’ve had my blue variant for almost 2 years now & it’s been an outstanding watch. It’s incredibly accurate! I wear it every day; the only time I don’t wear it is doing yard work or working on my car. It’s only stopped once in 2 years, and that’s when I ran it out to test the power reserve!

I have both the Blue and Black versions and agree 100% about the wearability if the case. I recently added Steel Reef extension links to the bracelet and that solved my problem with 'on-the-fly' adjustments. How I wish Rolex would offer the Submariner in this perfect size as an option.

I got into the 58 craze with the 925 and, as Tudor had no boutiques in Switzerland at the time, I travelled to Rome to get the Bronze for my 30th. A couple of years and a bunch more watches later their value dropped as the craze went and availability came, but they still hold a special place in my collection and in my heart, could not agree more with the conclusion.

I've had the BB 41 burgundy bezel for over 4 years now and it's my favourite watch. It's just brilliant and I even love the riveted bracelet.

I also love my BB58 Navy. Had the same issue with the bracelet and tried a few aftermarket options until Uncle Seiko released a 1/2 link that matches the OEM bracelet. Completely solved my fitment problem and I would highly recommend.

Sharing knowledge is not about giving people something, or getting something from them. That is only valid for information sharing. Sharing knowledge occurs when people are genuinely interested in helping one another develop new capacities for action; it is about creating learning processes. - Peter Senge Thanks for sharing - Peter!

Steel reef adjustable half link is a game changer for the Tudor bracelet.

One of my dream watches is the Tudor Black Bay 58 dark dial and vintage yellow hands and markers. The only thing anoyes me it´s there is no on the flight adjustement. Nice to see your face Peter, greetings from Spain, I agree with you this blue version needs blue luminova!

Thank you for the long-term review! The Blue BB58 has been one of my favorites for years! I’m saving up for it now and hope to get it someday soon!

That Seiko SLA043 has got to be one of the most charismatic and beautiful divers I’ve seen in a good few years. Something about Seiko divers man , they seem to have a Soul and spark about them that you just can’t feel with any other brand ever!

Was one of the lucky first few to get a 58 at the very end of ‘18. Sold my BB41 in favour of the 58 after trying the very first one the AD got in. Knew I was in trouble, it just wore so nicely compared to the slab like BB41. It’s been STELLAR, no regrets. Probably due for a service soon, will cross that bridge when I get there. 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽

I’ve had the Black Bay 41 since 2015. Love it!

Love your reviews Peter. Honest, not hyped, and not trying to sell me something.

Have the exact model as you for 2 years now, still love it, one of the best

I got my 58 in 2020 and it is one of my favourite pieces, excellent. That and my gs sbga415 are my, I have to own watches. As soon as I first set eyes on them they were a must have. Both forever keepers for me.

Great video, I bought the Tudor Ranger when it came out as it has the BB58 movement. To be honest out of all the watches I have, and I have way too many, the Tudor is the one I enjoy wearing the most, it just makes me smile every time I look at it, and I feel it is great value for money

I love my BB58 blue today as much as the day I bought it!

I still think the blue on the BB58 is one of the most attractive. No watch is absolutely perfect. And, I don't think Tudor is rubbish. However, as a whole kind of over-hyped these days, still. Almost a given common recommendation for a high quality Swiss dive watch for around $3-4k. But, I suppose for good reason. They have solid offerings in two of their most popular model lines, the BB's and Pelagos, that do and offer what they do very well and for reasonable price. I know I was very happy with my BB58 Bronze. Definitely, buy what you like and enjoy your watches.

Sold mine after close to 3 yrs of ownership and don’t really miss it. I wanted to love it but just couldn’t connect with it emotionally.

Got mine (black/gilt version) in the summer 2022, picked up the Ranger bracelet for it in that fall, it's my favorite and a forever keeper.

Well done Peter. If anyone wants to see a true watch collector/enthusiast,watch your videos. Great watch by the way.

Very good video and well explained. I'm not interested in other people's opinions on my watch collection either. I also bought the same Black Bay and I can confirm your arguments 100%! I actually like the original riveted bracelet and I'm going to get a nice blue NATO strap. The build quality of the Tudor is really very good and the accuracy of the 70h movement is very precise. Why do you need a spring drive movement again ;-) Thanks again and good work Sir.

I’ve got two Tudor’s, a P39 and a BB925 and both are outstanding.

That’s a beauty Pete. So glad you had it repaired and are keeping it. Thanks for another terrific video. 👊🏻

nice to see you in the flesh. Love your content

Love the bb58. Mine has all sorts of scratches and is well loved. Such a great and reliable companion

Love the video mate. Suggest you try out the Steel Reef “on the fly” extension link for the original bracelet. It’s great!

Agree with you on Tudor. I don’t have a 58, but you’d have to pry my pelagos 39 out of my cold, dead hands. The quality is absolutely superb on their pieces.

Long-term reflections from knowledgeable collectors are actually about the most valuable and regrettably quite rare. In the fast moving world of watch releases, especially among microbrands and the many limited runs or preorder phases, there barely is any time for reflection. For me, it would be great to see more of this, including the microbrands. Which ones are keepers and why? How do they stack up against the barrage of new releases? How much joy do they give within a diverse collection or against the pressure of renewing or trying something else? This Tudor, as I understand it, is already a member of a longer lineage of related models. In that sense it might have previously proven its worth. Except for the frequent reference to the acronym BB58 I'm delightfully unaware of the hype or what it consists of. This and actually most Tudor watches that I see come by, just do very little to excite me or connect with me. I find this generally applies to Rolex tool watches too. Perhaps it is because they stay so close to the cocktail of elements that made the brands famous and then many others started following, so it just doesn't grab me among the crowd, or where this series is concerned, because ultimately I'm not that into dive watches unless they become quite dressy and elegant and possibly a tad quirky, in other words a very untoolish dive watch. Yet, I can appreciate how refined and honed the crafting of this watch is, and for those with that preference, i can imagine it serves them very well indeed. Excellent accuracy is just not something I particularly seek or expect from a mechanical watch (price dependent). I just don't expect it to be off by a full minute after five days' wear. That's why I do appreciate some regulation or slightly higher grade movements than the most basic automatics, but find it hard to justify paying much more for the marginal gains thereafter.

Pete, if you ever come by the UK, hope you do a meet and greet :) Always great reviews, no gimmick, no BS and purely for the passion of horology and mostly on watches that are more affordable to the regular folk as they say in the US. We need to figure out a way to boost our audience and subscribers. You should have over 100k by now, I know you don't chase those numbers but I think it's deserved. Maybe a collab, seems to be the thing to do now :)

Cheers Peter- always enjoy your thoughts and views. I have had my BB58 for around 12 months now and love it. Not sure Tudor could ever be described as trash, for the price point they're extremely hard to beat.

It’s a stunner on that bracelet mate, I could definitely put up with no half links for that perfect fit 😂 Good to see your smiling face, it definitely makes for a better review video and personalises the whole experience that much more. Good to see you followed your heart and not your head with holding onto the watch, collecting is such a personal thing, there is no right or wrong collection 👍

I exchanged by beloved blue bezel Tudor Black 41mm smiley dial for this exact watch and I couldn't be happier. It's a phenomenal piece. That cobalt blue resonates with me like no other watch.

Totally agree with you on the lume color! It’s something I’m picky about it - should always be blue IMO.

I have NEVER listened to any other person who criticised my watch / collection. I like what I like you can go fourth and multiple.

Thanks Peter I'd love to have a Black Bay 58 I'd choose the black over the blue.

You might be on to something, Pete! Every time I wind my BB GMT, I am amazed at how smooth and silky the feeling is as I wind it. My Rolex is really good, but not that good. With a 21 cm wrist, my GMT fits me well and is my daily. I added the Steel Reef adjustment link and life is good. You definitely have a keeper!

Beautiful piece - looks great on a cloudy day! When the blue first came out I wasn't sure but it has definitely grown on me over time from afar. Anything with a vintage warmth always gets my attention and the BB58 has it in abundance. Nice video chief.

Bought my bb58 last year as my 1st (aside from watches gifted to me 20yrs ago when I was a kid). Had a time thinking between bb chrono which is also looks great and a hard to get by that time but there's something in the 58 that draws me back to it. I just thought that if I ever buy the chrono chances are I'm going to get the 58 sooner or later so I saved myself some money for maybe a while (hopefully). I think for me looking simple makes it perfect for most use and I like that it doesn't get too much attention as well.

I’ve owned my bb58 since may 2021. Since then, I’ve played volleyball with it, went swimming with it, I’ve handled oscillating saws with it, I use it in the gym, etc etc etc. I take it to the hospital and basically everywhere, is still ticking perfectly and it’s still extremely accurate. Not a single scratch on the cristal, no real flex on the bracelet. A true sports watch. The only negative aspect about the watch, at least for me, is the lack of on the fly micro adjustment on the clasp. Great video 👍🏽

Have the same in my collection and it is really, really good! Keeper for many years to come!

Just follow your heart and your budget...a great quote👏

Tudor are brilliant watches. They have been able to make a range of watches, from the ground up, which really work in everyway. They can be flexible. Other manufacturers are frozen in time, because their past successes stop development.

Absolutely agree. My wish is a smaller BB54 and I'll probably get it in the next year or two. It's a great brand that holds its value and does absolutely everything regarding style, versatility and function. Was looking at Baltic or Lorier, but now that I have a microbrand, I'm saving for the real deal. Thank you again Pete, you style in watches is inspirational.

I have no idea what Omega that was in the opening footage but what a watch! As for the BB58 I think it really is a watch for passionate people. Those who love watches. Those who want a symbol of success without the negative stigma attached to Rolex. I would gladly add one to my collection.

I have a BB36 and a BBB/B, and they are both excellent, the bronze is under a second a day. I like the C3 against the blue BB36 dial, the blue/green combo is gorgeous. Cheers-

Glad you're enjoying it. Because I'm not a dive watch kind of guy, and because I tend to gravitate to less "hyped" watches in general (I prefer to wear something different), I'd pass on this one, but to each their own. I'm still rocking my SAR Rescue Timer on the bracelet, btw. I know that one fell out of favor with you, but calling a good watch for what it is and how it holds up after a year on the wrist is always a good testament. Enjoy your Tudor, and keep the videos coming!

Thank you for sharing your long-term experiences. I always found the Black Bay 58 to be a bit boring and middle-of-the-road. The thing I have been missing is to experience the watch, wear it and be able to take a close look, maybe that could change my impression.

Great review, Pete, im still enjoying my bb58, after three years, 👍

I‘m sitting in Delhi now, wearing my SLA043, and smiling while watching this video. Tried on a Pelagos 39 in Zurich en route-impressive watch but I felt nothing.

Love that watch. It’s one that I haven’t pulled the trigger on yet. So tempting. Your friend’s comments about Tudor being “rubbish”-are the types of snobbish comments that make me want to exit the hobby all together and not wear a watch at all. Those that think “If it’s not Rolex, it’s not worthy”🙄Too many people are in the hobby for status signaling one upping others. It’s a shame. I agree with you-Always wear what you like. Beautiful BB58 you have there.

Great review, I've got a BB 41, I bought it in 2019 just before the hype train kicked off and it was great, but then they appeared everywhere and put me off the watch and it didn't get much wrist time, fast forward to the end of 2023 and I started wearing it again, because the hype has died down, have they over hyped the BB models over the years, yea probably, but for me it's still a quality watch which I own and have started enjoying again... all the best Pete...

Wow congrats on 50k subs mate, I started watching your videos 3 years ago and they only keep getting better. Seeing your mug bow adds a personal touch too lol. This watch is now back on the grail list. Thanks for making me spend more money lol.

I also have many watches that are highly coveted and many multiples of value. The BB58s value to me, the quality, the looks, it hits far above its weight for wrist time.

Lovely video, Peter. Nice to see you. That's a gorgeous watch you've got.

USD 2,500 for a 1 yr old piece, it's a steal!❤

Wow... What bracelet is that... Doesn't look like the factory it doesn't have the rivets... I love it... And I just recently obtained this watch... And it amazing... I will never get rid of it... It will be the watch I pass down to my children... Stay blessed

Nice to see Grand Seiko popping up again 😊

Be well and safe also, my friend. Thanks for sharing.

Owned it for 4 years, went through highs and lows with it perception wise.... but really I never get disappointed everytime I wear it. Only 1 thing I dislike is the square-ish clasp blade end. Call me snobby but I have really gotten used to the rounded and flush ones with modern Rolex.

Thank you Peter, as always mate!

The BB58s still regularly go out of stock at my Rolex/Patek AD. I had to wait a few weeks to get one

Great update on your Tudor journey!

I like how your videos still have a sense of 'watch enthusiast's feel to it. You are sharing your feeling of a watch - which is something hard to convey and quite uncommon in most watch channels as they are most likely a vendor of some sort. The accuracy of a watch can play a big role in the user experience - My current daily is a Seiko alpinist GMT which I absolutely adore the design, but the accuracy is all over the place which really detracts from the overall experience. By the way do you have any Discord or Whatsapp group to talk about watches? I'm also from Melb but I can't seem to find a community here.

I really like the snowflake hands on the Tudors'. That creates extra real estate for the lume material to reside in, as well helping them jump off the dial and be easier to pick up, in my opinion. I am looking to get into my first one, and cannot decide yet between the Pelagos, Black Bay Pro, or the Ranger, even though it has different hands.

Tudor are great, love the black bay, would go for pelagos 39 though, and hopefully not scratch the titanium.

Hi Peter, fantastic video! Love the daylight shots because you can really see the beautiful details. One question. Would you recommend me to get the Tudor BB41 Burgundy METAS, Tudor BB54 or Tudor BB58 Blue? I have 6,25 inch wrists. Really love the new T-fit and tougher looking bezel and crown on the 54 and 41 compared to the 58. I currently wear the Omega Seamaster Professional Diver 300M and love the on the fly adjustment in the clasp. Thanks!

100% agree. I have the same BB58 Blue and it is a watch that surpasses the hype.

Got my BB58 Navy in August 2020. And I’ve been wearing it daily since then. At least 4-5 times a week. My most reliable and and understated watch in my collection. I’d never let it go.

Ive got the s and g version in 41mm and its so accurate. Its also grown on me more over time. As you know Peter I love the sla043 as much as you do , but I wish that had came with a bracelet. Considering both watches cost about the same new in the uk, I feel the tudor is probably better value. That said the 043 just makes me smile every time I look at her , so the seiko takes it for me . But the bb is better value overall. Its a hard life , with all these 1st World problems !!! Lol.

Sometimes a watch hits the sweet spot. For me it's my Omega GMT 50th Anniversary. My Sinn 104 and Glycine GMT are close behind.

Whenever someone said Tudor is trash, they are disrespecting Hans Wilsdorf, and I take it personally 😂

Love the content, keep up the great work. Not sure if you heard of them, but there is a company called Steel Reef that makes on the fly extension link for BB54 blue. They also do this for some Rolex models and offer full or half links for some watches too. Maybe this will help you out! Take care and stay safe, fan from Toronto Canada!

Honestly my Tudor and my Hamilton are the best two watches in my collection as far as accuracy and quality.

I have the blue heritage 41mm. The only thing that leaves me cold is the Tudor blue leather deployment strap. I need to find a bracelet for it.

Much better now. Watch is still quality timepiece and more people can afford it.

I have the black one and it’s the only watch that I want the same version but in blue - no other watch do I want in two colors

Stunning watch, great story with interessting observations - and I love this informal video format👍

Hello @Peter Kosta, from Portugal! Opposite side of the Old World 😊 Nice to see your thoughts about Tudor almost bought the Blue version you have went to big Boy Pelagos LHD love it by the way that steel bracelet I’ve got on your BB it looks like same design maybe Aquaterra models😊 In my experience have watch’s since kid ( not billionaire) always like Rolex submariner 2000€ at 80’s was huge amount of cash on those years all that said do like Tudor a lot ! Very good watch for the price point but since January they already increased prices 😳 my last watch December was the Tudor Pro such wait and go for a chronograph S&G but out stock anyway hopefully Tudor makes a smaller chronograph it’s way to big even my Pelagos but as it’s a such Pro Monster diver it’s amazing some people don’t like the roulette date or the left hand crown don’t care about it it keeps awesome time same as my GMT Pepsi and the BB Burgundy ( my opinion the best ever combo ever made by Tudor) The Ranger have covered it by a Sinn 556 A I amazing watch for less than a Tudor and very well made Always go mad when see those awesome Artem bracelets sailclothare they soft or stiff ? I’m almost want buy one black or dark blue it will cost price of an OEM Tudor bracelet hybrid still waiting…. Congrats for sharing your opinion on this beautiful pieces by Tudor! Hopefully they will make a nice smaller chronograph 😉 mate cheers from Portugal

Great video Peter, thank you.

my favorite reviewer, thanks Peter.

I own the blue BB58. The one which always finds itself in my wrist.

I absolutley love it on that what rubber strap !!!!