Тёмный

Ukraine Soldiers Share What Happened in the Offensive 

Task & Purpose
Подписаться 1,6 млн
Просмотров 823 тыс.
50% 1

Customize your engagement ring or jewelry piece today with James Allen and get 25% off at bit.ly/49ZfzAf
What really happened during the Ukrainian 2023 counteroffensive? 30 senior Ukranian and US military officials in addition to 24 officiers and regular grunts explained their expierence during combat and the planning phase.
The first thing you need to know is that Ukrainian soldiers who are veterans of the battle were shocked by the density of Russian minefields. To give you an idea of the scale here. One Ukranian soldier recovered a Russian map used to mark their minefields. For just that small area near Robotyeen 20,000 land mines were listed. They were placed four miles long and four miles deep. Ukraine T64 tanks with anti mine rollers were used to clear a path. but the rollers were destroyed after only one mine when they are supposed to withstand 4 hits. This is because Russian forces triple stacked the mines. This supports the Post’s claim that 60 percent of Ukraine’s de-mining equipment was destroyed in the first days of the offensive. According to Melnik the air support that was supposed to come never made it.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @taskandpurpose
Written by: Chris Cappy
Edited by: Maksym
When Ukraines troops trained on the M2 Bradley in Germany they drove in optimal conditions on smooth terrain. A far cry from the muddy earth they encountered on the front. Add to that the stress of driving under fire and it’s a bad mix. Some of the transport drivers accidentally steered out of the safe lane that had been cleared and hit stacks of Russian mines. This map shows a clear picture of why it was so difficult to advance south in Ukraine. There are only several main highways in the region that go south one of which passes straight through the town of Robotyne on its way to Tokmak. These two roads heading south are narrow choke points through which you have to pass. Russian forces have encountered the same problem with their past failed attempts to advance in Vuheldar and elsewhere.
Task & Purpose is a military news and culture oriented channel. We want to foster discussion about the defense industry.
Email capelluto@taskandpurpose.com for inquires.
#UKRAINE #WAR #ARMY

Опубликовано:

 

14 дек 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 4,7 тыс.   
@Taskandpurpose
@Taskandpurpose 6 месяцев назад
Hey Spare Parts Army thanks for watching, our sponsor supported the animations in this episode: Customize your engagement ring or jewelry piece today with James Allen and get 25% off at bit.ly/49ZfzAf
@isidrobotello8680
@isidrobotello8680 6 месяцев назад
1:20 the invasion did not begin in 2024 but in 2022!
@cityofgarlic4088
@cityofgarlic4088 6 месяцев назад
If you get your information from The Washington Post you sir are just a y.t propagandist like them
@Atari5732
@Atari5732 6 месяцев назад
Experience*
@dr.jamesdenton3051
@dr.jamesdenton3051 6 месяцев назад
LOL, what offensive? they have less land now than when they started lol, and they are now making their females and children fight as well due to the horrendous losses.
@raptorhunter5549
@raptorhunter5549 6 месяцев назад
I have a gaming channel with my soon to be wife when i get married ill use your link bro
@KombatKochPartDeux
@KombatKochPartDeux 6 месяцев назад
"Don't worry about drones, we never had to deal with those in Iraq and Afghanistan"- Most of the US senior leadership.
@greenhat7618
@greenhat7618 6 месяцев назад
Uh no? They literally just got a new air defence system DE M-SHORAD specifically for drones and other small projectiles?
@anxel-
@anxel- 6 месяцев назад
@@greenhat7618Vs guys with Ak47?
@greenhat7618
@greenhat7618 6 месяцев назад
@@anxel- what?
@KombatKochPartDeux
@KombatKochPartDeux 6 месяцев назад
@@greenhat7618 I made the joke in jest since I was in the US Military. The problem is that they are just now bringing this into operation when the drone problem has been an issue for years at this point.
@lechuck312
@lechuck312 6 месяцев назад
'Hey, don't worry about those landmines, just drive around the minefields'. I think i even heard something like that from an instructor in one of the DW reports when he was asked about it
@rajatsinha6607
@rajatsinha6607 6 месяцев назад
Lesson number 1: Do not drink your own koolaid, dont believe in your own propaganda.
@arostwocents
@arostwocents 6 месяцев назад
So true. Half the NPCs in the west still believe the propaganda - this video was full of delusional thinking based on propaganda only. Talking about 350k Russian casualties as a success when Ukraine TV admitted they have lost 1.2m, so only 350k for Russia is a major disaster for Ukraine, not a success.
@RUTHLESSambition5
@RUTHLESSambition5 5 месяцев назад
This video was hard to watch😂😂😂the cope is amazing. Broke Ukraine wants to come up with it's own defense line in a month. They are done for
@e.g.8018
@e.g.8018 5 месяцев назад
@@RUTHLESSambition5 cope
@cliftonjames785
@cliftonjames785 5 месяцев назад
​@@RUTHLESSambition5didnt russia say they'd take kyiv in less than 4 days and all of ukraine in less than a month or two? They've lost half of the territory they took and most offensives have failed but in yet they have convinced themselves they are winning the war outright. The russian government has even said they have blown up all the himars sent to ukraine too when in reality ukraine has lost no himars
@RUTHLESSambition5
@RUTHLESSambition5 5 месяцев назад
@@cliftonjames785 no they never said that 😅😅
@michaelerzuah1105
@michaelerzuah1105 6 месяцев назад
I remember when there was so much mockery of Russia's defensive lines. I guess the worst thing go do is underestimate your enemy
@fantomedorient6216
@fantomedorient6216 4 месяца назад
That is not underestimating. That is lying blatantly. remember all the time western media was claiming that Russia is losing badly? They kept on lying until the bitter end. And here we go, Ukranian minister announced they lost 500k men, and when we look at the map, do you see any advancement? Even this clown is one sided....Better check Douglas Macgregor or Judge Napolitano or even Mearsheimer....
@nadiasawicki4108
@nadiasawicki4108 4 месяца назад
Ukraine I can assure you know their enemy very well. They've been fighting them on and off for centuries.
@ArcticDucq
@ArcticDucq 3 месяца назад
Yes first thing i tought as well , peoples aside even most of the media outlets were making fun of Russian fortifictions. In a way they looked ww2 style ,outdated and shouldn't work at modern era but it did worked big time. I think there was also bit of a ecstasy of victory , Ukraine won massive victories at Kharkiv and Kherson so after that peoples tought those fortifictions were piece of cake. Gotta give big credits to Sergei Surovikin , retreat is one of the hardest maneuver to pull off sucesfully and Kherson wasn't easy place to retreat from. Supplying Kherson wasn't easy but leaving it also wasn't easy both physically and mentally. They could have struggled there and lost so many , i think it would hugely favor Ukraine. Anyway sucesfull retreat there and building mass fortifictions at zaporizhia looked pathetic back then but it actually became turning point of the war. Now Ukraine preparing defenses who knows where this war will go...
@bigolboomerbelly4348
@bigolboomerbelly4348 3 месяца назад
Me too
@ikaustralia
@ikaustralia 3 месяца назад
Well, there mere fact that Ukraine decided to confront Russia was a joke of itself. Even with NATO help.
@SamuelK4747
@SamuelK4747 5 месяцев назад
"I recommend you check out the Washington Post article" - said with a straight face 😂
@xtsmbayi3028
@xtsmbayi3028 3 месяца назад
🤣🤣🤣
@felawes
@felawes 3 месяца назад
Great comedy.
@TheDigimarauder
@TheDigimarauder 6 месяцев назад
Before the offensive, the generals launched 8 combat simulations. They used a special computer called CORA for this. -Well, it seems they played it on "easy" settings...
@marinblaze
@marinblaze 6 месяцев назад
Creative mode was left ON
@jamieHSquare
@jamieHSquare 6 месяцев назад
@@marinblaze lol 🤣🤣
@ronn9853
@ronn9853 6 месяцев назад
Did you miss the part where Cora gave them only a 50/50 odds of success?
@anxel-
@anxel- 6 месяцев назад
⁠@@ronn9853Nop, Cora give 100% win
@ondrejdobrota7344
@ondrejdobrota7344 6 месяцев назад
So true, just like your kid wanted to play Warzone and DMZ, finishing dead each time he launched a game.
@LeonWagg
@LeonWagg 6 месяцев назад
The greatest lesson here is that one should never underestimate one’s enemy. I remember last year when everybody was making fun of Russia, saying they had already lost the war. The expectations of this counteroffensive were through the roof because they were based on the assumption that the Russian army was weak and inferior. The West also has this same mindset with regard to China, and so we have to be cautious here too.
@Jupiterxice
@Jupiterxice 6 месяцев назад
Exactly..... like we lost or forgot history from WW2 and Napoleon how tough Russia is. Smh we cant seem to learn.
@craterus-ii9im
@craterus-ii9im 6 месяцев назад
You sir are correct. But we also must admit that our media has not told the truth or dont "know" the truth of what happened at the start of the conflict. There seems to be a peace deal made that tricked russia to back off. Evidence UK prime minister visit at time and also putin has it on paper, who knows.
@mohamedmido4866
@mohamedmido4866 6 месяцев назад
​@@Jupiterxice They believed that zelensky is better than Hitler and Napoleon combined
@intractablemaskvpmGy
@intractablemaskvpmGy 6 месяцев назад
@@mohamedmido4866 Like sliced bread?
@baha3alshamari152
@baha3alshamari152 6 месяцев назад
Russia is weak actually However their nukes aren't
@nicksonassailant8480
@nicksonassailant8480 4 месяца назад
It was not the russian surveilance drones and spies that gave away the axis of attack. IT WAS UA MOD THAT POSTED A FREAKING TRAILER FOR IT LMFAO
@joethekinghawk7514
@joethekinghawk7514 2 месяца назад
🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫lol
@spiraboy
@spiraboy 5 месяцев назад
One is winning the propaganda war, another is winning the actual war. Kings and generals was a good channel. Thanks for all the great videos of ancient battles.
@VVV85650
@VVV85650 5 месяцев назад
well said
@ottersirotten4290
@ottersirotten4290 5 месяцев назад
Given KaG coverrage of current history, I highly doubt they ever did a good job at covering ancient history. So I dont think they ever used to be a good channel
@d.g.2288
@d.g.2288 5 месяцев назад
Yeah, that's basically all that Russia has at this point. Propaganda.
@RUTHLESSambition5
@RUTHLESSambition5 5 месяцев назад
Yeah that channel ruined its credibility. The BS videos on Ukraine made ,e question every video they did😂😂😂😂 They push OBVIOUS lies and so does this channel. Sad sight
@RUTHLESSambition5
@RUTHLESSambition5 5 месяцев назад
​@@ottersirotten4290they had me fooled until I saw the Ukraine videos then I stopped watching, good lord it was hard to watch. Every video they did was BS. Made up facts 😂😂😂
@col.waltervonschonkopf69
@col.waltervonschonkopf69 6 месяцев назад
71 Leopards?! Really? That's hardly two armored regiments or battalions! It's delusional thinking to believe that just two armored regiments can be the spearhead of a strategic counter-offensive.
@JustChill-zd4ib
@JustChill-zd4ib 6 месяцев назад
Its all propaganda media game for them. Forgot about real world and that no one actually cares.
@abbottshaull9831
@abbottshaull9831 6 месяцев назад
Maybe if they were going to be used as pure Armored units, but they were used in correlation with IFVs that the West had sent them. Enough to give them one solid Brigade. When compared to the Armies of WWII, one Brigade at the right place could with the right conditions really mess up the opposing force day.
@videobegucker
@videobegucker 6 месяцев назад
Zey ar Wunderwaffen!
@irrelevantfish1978
@irrelevantfish1978 6 месяцев назад
Ukraine is short on equipment, facing an existential threat, heavily reliant on assistance from fickle allies, and fighting a war significantly different from those of the past, both due to proliferation of drones and the fact that the opposing militaries are only _partly_ modern. While the Ukrainians' plans _might_ have been delusional, believing yourself qualified to make that call almost certainly is. And even if you _are_ one of the vanishingly few people in possession of the necessary information and expertise, then commenting on this video is stupid. Intelligence agencies get nervous when people in possession of classified information engage in public discussion on the topic, whether they reveal that information or not.
@jeffdriscoll9503
@jeffdriscoll9503 6 месяцев назад
And only 50 of these were in place them, Spanish and Swedish Leopards 2s arrived very late.
@darthsidius9631
@darthsidius9631 6 месяцев назад
Lesson one: you can't fight companied arms warfare without combained arms Lesson two: you can't just run through minefields with tanks and without mineclearing equipment Lesson three: you can't go on offensive without proper airforce for offensive of this level
@darthsidius9631
@darthsidius9631 6 месяцев назад
Just to be clear I am not blaming Ukraine they did best they could with what they had
@Insideman666
@Insideman666 6 месяцев назад
Solution: send more money
@johnmoser1162
@johnmoser1162 6 месяцев назад
@@Insideman666 And this is not happening. Ukraine defeated - qed.
@SerpkoBakotiinii
@SerpkoBakotiinii 6 месяцев назад
@@Insideman666 The main problem, that USA and EU has enough money, they don't have factories and workers to build equipment. All Production lines now in Asia, where Russia has support.
@orkhepaj
@orkhepaj 6 месяцев назад
whsat?
@MajorCaliber
@MajorCaliber 3 месяца назад
Wait, so a huge resource-rich country, with an advanced space program and aerospace industry, can make drones? SHUT UP! I don't believe it. 🙄🙄🤣🤣
@IgorProhorov1986
@IgorProhorov1986 6 месяцев назад
If you've listened to "The Duran" and "The New Atlas" you would have seen this failed offensive miles away.
@sababugs1125
@sababugs1125 6 месяцев назад
Those guys are consistently pro Russia , they'll never admit a single defeat of Russia. This time they were right but many times they have been wrong
@sayrebonifield4663
@sayrebonifield4663 6 месяцев назад
Troops trained in Germany for a rapid advance were greatly slowed by muddy terrain in the Ukraine? Seems like I read about a similar story that occurred about 80 years ago. I must be mistaken though, otherwise the US leadership advisers would look really foolish.
@ronkostars4258
@ronkostars4258 6 месяцев назад
The incompetent disaster known as General Mark Milley was involved.
@JVMorgan-vz5mh
@JVMorgan-vz5mh 5 месяцев назад
Nato training is a joke
@thatguy22441
@thatguy22441 5 месяцев назад
Why is nobody referencing that? FFS, it took place exactly where the current conflict is happening
@davidryke113
@davidryke113 4 месяца назад
Lmao. Rasputitsa strikes again! Hot damn!
@dejannincic9671
@dejannincic9671 4 месяца назад
Geting training from an army that hasnt fought a proper war since 1945
@denzelfashington3110
@denzelfashington3110 6 месяцев назад
I like how US planers just ignored civilian drones during planning just because US don’t use them😂
@Mortablunt
@Mortablunt 6 месяцев назад
The American military is extremely arrogant. You can just tell the overall culture of arrogance by seeing our track record in recent wars. We haven’t triumph in a conflict since 1991 because we think military force console, fundamentally, political and social problems and we make the assumption that anybody who doesn’t think and act like an American, and want to join the American side and would oppose us is only doing it because they’re a stupid barbarian for no reason.
@mikhailkh8560
@mikhailkh8560 6 месяцев назад
In russia it was exact the same issue. High command totaly underestimate importance of drones at battlefield. But it seems - lesson has been learned.
@HubertofLiege
@HubertofLiege 6 месяцев назад
Because at any time the U.S. military wants it can focus satellites onto the battlefield and read nametags
@MegaVodka
@MegaVodka 6 месяцев назад
​@@HubertofLiegesummon the piss rain on enemy positions with super secret zaza technology stolen from ancient Egyptians?
@daniel_dumile
@daniel_dumile 6 месяцев назад
@@mikhailkh8560yep Russia uses shaheeds like cruise missiles instead of tactical weapons which never made sense to me
@Irewiking88
@Irewiking88 6 месяцев назад
I was one of the people who landed across Kherson. Lost my arm. We didn't have covering artillery fire for way to long, and the Moscovians just kept shelling us and we didn't even have trenches. We were told to not even being sleeping bags lol. Freezing nights, no shovels. Exciting boat trip though.
@filosov
@filosov 6 месяцев назад
Шо, сынку? Помог тебе твой контрнаступ?)
@Irewiking88
@Irewiking88 6 месяцев назад
@@filosov чи можете ви принаймні говорити краще мовою. Контрнаступ на півдні успішний поки що, поки його тримати. але схоже, можливо, нам доведеться повернутися назад.
@filosov
@filosov 6 месяцев назад
@@Irewiking88 mogę mówić lepszym językiem. Problem w tym, że w kontronastup włożono dużo pieniędzy. I pieniądze nie wasi, a europejskie i amerykańskie. Ale nie ma rezultatu. Dlaczego więc Europa powinna inwestować pieniądze na Ukrainie jeśli to nie przynosi rezultatu?
@tibor1234
@tibor1234 6 месяцев назад
In other words they send you in to a suicide mission so western media can report positive about that doom offensince ?!? Not a single country from the Nato would did this "counter offensive" because the generall would go in to jail after this.
@arostwocents
@arostwocents 6 месяцев назад
Im sorry your leaders did this to you. You must inspire other Ukrainians to march on Kiev and remove zelensky. How can anyone support a section of the line being held by only women? Or support pregnant women being in combat? Women storm squads? It's pure evil from the leaders.
@Lvov_Aleksandr
@Lvov_Aleksandr 6 месяцев назад
Так в комментариях правы. Но все совершенно забыли одну очень важную вещь: к этой войне Украина готовилась последние 8 лет. Её накачивал "весь цивилизованный мир" оружием и инструкторами. Даже уже давно есть "налог на войну" на Украине. Так же ещё все забыли, что сама же Украина заявляла, что у неё "ВТОРАЯ АРМИЯ В МИРЕ/ЕВРОПЕ"!!!))) И первой была не Россия....)))
@bmshavel6737
@bmshavel6737 6 месяцев назад
I knew the offensive was not going to go well once European news outlets started referring to it as “the big push” like it was WWI again
@yaboisterling796
@yaboisterling796 6 месяцев назад
😂😂
@JoeyP946
@JoeyP946 6 месяцев назад
I don't get this none of the news agencies I watched said this. They just called it a counteroffensive with very moderate success
@mw9297
@mw9297 6 месяцев назад
The big attacks coming too, the one that gets the Americans mad.
@OleDiaBole
@OleDiaBole 6 месяцев назад
@@JoeyP946 But success never the less 🤣
@glenglen6386
@glenglen6386 6 месяцев назад
Yeah I remember articles and videos showing simulations of the Russian defensive lines. Ukrainian tanks ramming the dragon teeth out of the way. Stormshadows knocking out Russian airfields and British Challengers moving ahead impervious to Russian antitank fire. The internet has made the average man and journalist to look at war as if its a action movie.
@timothyseeger5296
@timothyseeger5296 6 месяцев назад
It was said " To the sea of AZOV by 9 June and in Crimea by the end of June on the beach , didn't get to the Surovikn first line , actually didn't get further than 10km from where they started from , I bet the people saying Russian weapons were junk are shocked.
@TomG1555
@TomG1555 6 месяцев назад
The minefields made the difference. Offense is always harder than defense, which is why the Ukrainian leadership was trying to moderate optimistic Western expectations going in - they knew it was going to be hard going, though nobody expected the minefields to be as dense as they were. Point to Russia, they've adapted to what they have to work with. The back-and-forth continues...
@TomG1555
@TomG1555 6 месяцев назад
@@etienne8110 ...problem is, the pro-RUS side has been proclaiming over and over that the war is essentially over/won for the past year+, and it keeps not happening. Neither side is capable of making a decisive breakthrough, and neither side really has the option of even entering negotiations, since Putin needs a decisive victory over UKR in order to not appear "weak" (which could be fatal to him as de facto tsar), UKR knows even a ceasefire in place works towards the eventual RUS resumption of the conflict down the road, and the only outcome RUS would consider acceptable is UKR becoming reduced to the status of a vassal state again. It's a real mess without any end in sight right now, once one lays aside wishful thinking and the propaganda by each side.
@evilleader1991
@evilleader1991 6 месяцев назад
Dude, most pro-UA youtubers were laughing at Russian defensive lines prior to the offensive xD. They called them stupid and not knowing how to create trenches etc, look how that turned out. Mines are one thing, but there are other weapons that contributed heavily to Ukrainian losses (Ka-52, FPV drones, lancets, ATGMs, artillery etc).@@TomG1555
@TomG1555
@TomG1555 6 месяцев назад
@cl1ntonbodycount652 Define clearly what "beat Russia" means, otherwise discussion of it goes nowhere, since everyone's interpretation of that is different and leaving it vague tends towards "no, what I *really* meant is..." moving-the-goalposts waste of time.
@ungas024
@ungas024 6 месяцев назад
​@cl1ntonbodycount652 Are you trying to claim that Russia killed 2 Million Ukraine conscripts in the past 2 years?
@Kris-ym2zr
@Kris-ym2zr 5 месяцев назад
The info on how mines were stacked was very interesting to hear. Thanks for making this video, your content is great as always
@tieroneoperator635
@tieroneoperator635 5 месяцев назад
Iraqis did that too in mid 2000s.
@zjpdarkblaze
@zjpdarkblaze 4 месяца назад
@@tieroneoperator635 well they learned that from the soviets.
@tommytomas-fr3sh
@tommytomas-fr3sh Месяц назад
They are not stacked but it is just a dense minefield. Instead of 1 per 2 square feet, Russia put 4 per 2 Square feet.
@mostlymessingabout
@mostlymessingabout 6 месяцев назад
Ukraine is mobilising 500,000 including women to an already 1,000,000 army... so the figure of 300,000 lost is probably not far off
@mariano98ify
@mariano98ify 6 месяцев назад
No way 300k lost. More like they need to refresh the troops in the front to rest until Spring and Summer to keep pushing. They know Russia either will lack in manpower and they need to entrenchment the frontline.
@sanniks
@sanniks 2 месяца назад
lol, they recently banned demobilization and lowered the age of conscription. Are you still sure they couldn't have lost 300k?​@@mariano98ify
@scale6977
@scale6977 Месяц назад
​@@mariano98ify Russia will lack in manpower?!😂
@mariano98ify
@mariano98ify Месяц назад
@@scale6977 in young people as skilled workers, yes.
@ca5da3pl
@ca5da3pl 6 месяцев назад
The American military geniuses who were really running the show have never gone into a battle without overwhelming air cover. The Russians have surveillance drones spotting anything that moves. They also had plenty of artillery and ammunition. The Ukrainian soldiers were told that when they contact Russian soldiers, the Russian would run away. They didn’t. What a disaster.
@jtothed8575
@jtothed8575 6 месяцев назад
Very different than fighting Iraqis who were under sanctions for years and had a military completely devoid of any modernity.. Russia is a different level.. But Americans do not care. It’s not their soldiers dying. But Slavs. Who are not humans to the U.S.
@jeremyhansen8186
@jeremyhansen8186 6 месяцев назад
The comment about air power on demand is false. Many times guys had to fight a determined sizable force in Afghanistan with no air power to be heard of, and zero artillery either. Facts
@user-ru4iq3ss9m
@user-ru4iq3ss9m 6 месяцев назад
@@jeremyhansen8186Total nonsense. The Air Force is the backbone of the US way of war
@johnlenin830
@johnlenin830 6 месяцев назад
@@jeremyhansen8186 we are not talking about small units fighting, we are talking about a major offensive planned by the Americans in Ukraine. Washington would never send its soldiers to break through a strong line of defense without air supremacy; Ukrainian soldiers are another matter. Ukrainian soldiers for the US are cannon fodder, expendable material with the help of which they want to harm Russia and weaken it. There are no other reasons for direct U.S. involvement in this conflict.
@vknight7497
@vknight7497 6 месяцев назад
@@johnlenin830US sacrificed Ukraine on the altar of global hegemony. It did not please the Gods.
@JustRootsAndLeaves
@JustRootsAndLeaves 6 месяцев назад
After twelve weeks they breached Russia's first line... Three months. It took three months to beach a defensive line that Russia would have expected to have been broken within days. No matter what shine you try to put on it, the offensive was already a failure before it was a month old. A catastrophic failure paid for in blood by young Ukrainian men.
@Demane69
@Demane69 5 месяцев назад
Not many young men left. More like middle aged.
@JustRootsAndLeaves
@JustRootsAndLeaves 5 месяцев назад
@@davidagudelo2435 i wasn't talking about bahkmut or avdiivka. Do your have an actual point? Feel free to explain why your whataboutism makes the deaths of so many Ukrainians less pointless or tragic.
@schokobar4133
@schokobar4133 5 месяцев назад
​​​@@davidagudelo2435also when we can take prigozihin as an source did he claim that 10k regular russian soldirs died in bakhmut,10k prisoners and atleast 50k ukraniens confirmend, believe it or not but prigozihin talked honestly about the loses even if its an absolut disaster and even western like to quote him because he was the only russian than oppenly and confindent speak against the regime
@RenanMendes-zd8hj
@RenanMendes-zd8hj 4 месяца назад
​@@davidagudelo2435 why would it be a failure? Russia is conquering the most fortified cities in the region, Avdivka is the place where the Ukrainians use to 💥 civilians in Donetsk, even their tactics were better than the Ukrainian, in both cases the Russians secured the flanks advancing first in the high ground and then imposing a tactical encirclement, forcing the Ukrainians in the most dangerous supply lines, furthermore, the Ukrainian continue to do the same mistakes, they defend at all costs, Zaluzhny was dismissed because he wanted to pull back from Avdivka, but Zelenskystein don't listen to his generals. Russia fights tactical battles, Ukrainians fight propagandized battles with political objectives
@wallingnaga6563
@wallingnaga6563 3 месяца назад
@@davidagudelo2435 Lol look at the map now dude .
@paulkirby2761
@paulkirby2761 6 месяцев назад
"The results might have been different with a different plan" Pure genius! 🤣
@WorldTravelerCooking
@WorldTravelerCooking 5 месяцев назад
Hard to have the element of surprise when you publish your plans openly for months ahead of time.
@carlitos2k2
@carlitos2k2 6 месяцев назад
Biggest lesson, don't underestimate your enemy. Ukraine lost so many troops for such a small achievement.
@CollaredConsulting
@CollaredConsulting 6 месяцев назад
No, they lost so many troops because NATO and the Biden regime sabotaged the peace steel worked out in March 2022. Since then Ukraine has lost hundreds of thousands of its best and bravest men and the war
@samuellopesbaule5745
@samuellopesbaule5745 6 месяцев назад
The western taught Ukrainians how to look down and underestimate Russian army and they got hammered down, 😂😂😂😂😂
@b2serious
@b2serious 6 месяцев назад
​@@samuellopesbaule5745 HAHAHAHAHAHA!!! Hammered down? This "2 day special operation" was hammering???
@JackSlajter
@JackSlajter 6 месяцев назад
@@b2seriousпрояви свой интеллект и узнай источник этого заблуждения который вы так яростно смакуете
@CheekyMenace
@CheekyMenace 6 месяцев назад
​@@samuellopesbaule5745 Did you even watch the video?? Ukraine literally didn't do what the west recommended and went with their own plan which didn't work.
@amcf18
@amcf18 6 месяцев назад
You mentioned Russian losses, and efforts to compensate, but I missed the part about Ukrainian losses, and what measures they might be taking to fill their ranks. Are they being dragged off the street and sent to fight? What age groups are they conscripting?
@simonpriest4345
@simonpriest4345 6 месяцев назад
Apparently the Bradleys saved all those inside despite looking completely burnt out from the photos.
@karambasankoumbafadiga3229
@karambasankoumbafadiga3229 6 месяцев назад
😂😂😂😂
@karambasankoumbafadiga3229
@karambasankoumbafadiga3229 6 месяцев назад
This is the root cause of the failure of the counteroffensife, believing in one's own propaganda instead of facing reality. If they had listened to Zhaluzny they would've been in a better position today. That man is an excellent General
@messier8379
@messier8379 6 месяцев назад
​@@simonpriest4345yes probably with the crews losing one of their feet or Arms
@brycenlanager1216
@brycenlanager1216 6 месяцев назад
I like Cappy and this channel, but this seems to be a major blindspot for them, to the point where I think it's somewhat intentional. The war is going badly for Ukraine but a lot of Pro Ukraine people don't want to admit it. I remember earlier videos where they claimed that the small gains made during the earlier offensives weren't that bad because the advancements made after D-Day were small too. Now a lot of Ukrainian gains are being whittled away by the Russians proving the skeptics right.
@davidblake1663
@davidblake1663 6 месяцев назад
Regarding the captured Bradley; there's a video on YT of a museum in Russia containing captured western military equipment. Some of them are vintage, but there's a large display of equipment captured in Ukraine including drones, various tanks, and Bradleys.
@AstroSardaukar
@AstroSardaukar 6 месяцев назад
The museum of NATO's shame.
@lorddaquanofhouserastafari4177
@lorddaquanofhouserastafari4177 5 месяцев назад
All these ukranian fanboys won’t talk about the losses
@davidagudelo2435
@davidagudelo2435 5 месяцев назад
​@@lorddaquanofhouserastafari4177Lets talk about the losses according to OSINT then and tell me which side has lost more vehicles. Visually confimed 😂😂😂
@mrdoerp
@mrdoerp 5 месяцев назад
​@@davidagudelo2435referring to proven low-quality / fake Oryx numbers? Same Oryx that announced stopping their work after the failed counteroffensive 😂
@davidagudelo2435
@davidagudelo2435 5 месяцев назад
@@mrdoerp Funnily enough, I still seem their numbers done after the offensive, and until you show me a visually confirmed database other than Oryx I will trust them more than "Telegram authored post number 7" and "salty ruzzian troll number 3 on youtube". :*
@emilv.3693
@emilv.3693 6 месяцев назад
The defenders had the element of surprise
@sindicatohonorarios
@sindicatohonorarios 6 месяцев назад
It is often repeated that the 1939 war between the USSR and Finland was won by the latter. In reality, Finland had to accept the peace agreement proposed by the USSR, which included the delivery of 11% of its territory and 30% of its economy to Russia.
@Wifyish
@Wifyish 6 месяцев назад
This. So many times I heard this lie as a Swede. How the brave finns won against the USSR. They were offered a deal which they refused, war ensued, at the end of the war they had to concede much more than the initial suggestion, which you do not do if you win.
@dv2045
@dv2045 6 месяцев назад
​@Wifyish regretfuly that might be the end for Ukraine but you cant blame them: if a thug enters your house and you have a gun you defend it. Ukraine might ask for terms but not yet
@chainoad
@chainoad 6 месяцев назад
Almost. The goal of the invasion was to take over Finland and make it another "Socialist Republic". That failed. So Finland won in the sense that they kept their independence.
@Wifyish
@Wifyish 6 месяцев назад
@@chainoad source?
@schokobar4133
@schokobar4133 6 месяцев назад
​@@chainoadfinland totaly surrender to the red army and they president and 2k of they highest people was send to a prison or a gulag, just because stalin wanted them as a bufferzone are the reason why they get not occupied
@charleshixon1458
@charleshixon1458 6 месяцев назад
I think everyone who knew anything about the conflict realized that the counter offensive was going to be hard to pull off. Without airpower, you can't really assault positions like that. Desert Storm still provides so many lessons to this date. The reason why the ground forces has such an easy time of it in Desert storm was the intensive bombing campaigns that destroyed 70% of Iraq's artillery before the first US troop had an engagement. The Iraqis also built a massive series of defensive lines, with mines and layers of trenches (however I don't think anyone has ever built a minefield like the one in Ukraine, this is Crazy Ivan level of mines) but they were bombed all up and down the trenchline and in front and in back. After the first set of works was breached, the tank drivers said they just used the plows on the tanks to bury the soldiers hiding in the trenches and rolled on. In Ukraine, you cant get within sight of the defensive works before artillery has spotted you and started firing. The Anti tank weapons of today are ahead of the armor in the forever arms & armor race and neither side really has a competent airforce capable of effectively performing hunter killer missions against enemy support units, like artillery and air defense, or performing substantial bombing attrite the defensive lines. The only long range fires either side has is artillery or cruise missiles. Sure they CAN drop bombs and do, but I'm talking about a high tonnage over a relatively short time. You'd want to have 70% attrition on that first defensive line before you even start the offensive.
@daejavue69
@daejavue69 6 месяцев назад
Like your posting makes sense, also artillery is critical to the longer range fighting on front line The 😊drones are now the greatest danger as we all see the Ukraine RPG straped to a drone & explosion 💥boom turret toss of the Toss 1 , thermobaric weapon million dollars to build destroyed by a 10 dollar RPG strapped to a Drone Boo🎆
@olegmakogon7447
@olegmakogon7447 6 месяцев назад
I closely followed the actions of the armed forces of Ukraine, they did what they can - methodically destroying all logistic they could reach, all air defence and artillery to make at least a little easier to ground forces to push... But minefields were really crazy. Also Ka-52 helicopters were serious threat to ground forces as their rockets can be fired from small atittude from 12-15 km distance. AFU have destroyed big quantity of these helicopters only when received ATACMS in October (a way too late)
@charleshixon1458
@charleshixon1458 6 месяцев назад
@@daejavue69 Yeah, drones have changed warfare. It seems very hard to stop the sheer number of drones and they provide a cheap form of guided weapons and reconnaissance compared to what used to cost hundreds of thousands of dollars if not millions to produce something with the same capabilities 10-15 years ago. Still, it doesn't replace the tonnage that is dropped by a capable airforce. Of course artillery is crucial and with drone spotters its become deadly accurate, but the way you counter artillery is by destroying them from the air. The little FPV drones with Rpgs just dont have the range to strike the backline support units, nor are they able to lift and drop tons of ordinance to decimate enemy force concentrations.
@devilik3692
@devilik3692 6 месяцев назад
copium, not how yall talked before it happened
@charleshixon1458
@charleshixon1458 6 месяцев назад
@@devilik3692 Well, I thought so anyways. The offensive came too late and without the tools they needed to be successful.
@Pakils
@Pakils 4 месяца назад
the elemwnt of surprise is gone the moment they release a trailer about their counter offensive 😂😂
@Ltasty
@Ltasty 6 месяцев назад
We saw what happened. They get demolished
@vladddtfan
@vladddtfan 6 месяцев назад
The WaPo article was also scrutinized by Ukrainian war correspondents. There was also a third direction of the offensive towards Vasylivka, to cover the western flank of the operation. In hindsight, Gen Milley’s idea to concentrate all of the available forces in the main direction of Robotyne would have been a huge gamble that would have also failed but with bigger losses because of the exposed flanks. Regardless, the elephant in the room is that the amount of military aid to Ukraine is absolutely inadequate for conducting offensive operations, despite the huge stockpiles of weapons the US has accumulated during the Cold War. The US has over 6000 tanks, over 11000 IFVs, 1400 MLRS, and so on. The fraction it has made available to fight Russia is so minuscule makes you question its intentions in supporting Ukraine. WaPo article also has an element of a political request to shift the blame to the Ukrainian army. But how do you expect a combined arms offensive to work without air support and without combined arms? Ukraine simply did not have enough armor in the direction of Robotyne: 100 Bradley’s, 18 Leopard 2s, and Soviet tanks. This is nothing. And, drones were apparently an even bigger problem than mines.
@Taskandpurpose
@Taskandpurpose 6 месяцев назад
yes I thought I was the only one who detected an implication between the lines in that article that "if only the US generals had been followed" "if only american plans were followed then it would have been a success" we have no way of knowing what would have happened if that was the case and we have zero evidence to support it wouldnt have been worse
@falconeaterf15
@falconeaterf15 6 месяцев назад
Erwin Rommel was quite good at using defensive tactics as a means of attriting a numerically superior force. Maybe Ukraine is playing his game.
@sullathehutt7720
@sullathehutt7720 6 месяцев назад
​@@falconeaterf15 If they are, they're not doing as well of a job. And even if they were, they'd still lose, just as Germany lost, and for the same reasons. 🤷
@huntergatherer7796
@huntergatherer7796 6 месяцев назад
Ukraine isn't supposed to win. They are given enough equipment to stay in the fight but not enough to defeat Russia.They are being used to degrade Russias military capabilities. Everything else is secondary to that mission. U
@vladddtfan
@vladddtfan 6 месяцев назад
@@huntergatherer7796 ⁠suppose that’s the strategy of Jake Sullivans et al (the very cohort of Kissinger students who led to this mess). So “degrade” not by defeating it, but just a little nibble😂? Don’t you sense the nonsense in this? Russian army is getting hardened on the battlefield, adopting to new tactics, has gained advantage in drone warfare, and its munitions factories are working in three shifts. And the fact that Poland is preparing for a possible war with Russia is also telling.
@user-qw2qm5hw4x
@user-qw2qm5hw4x 6 месяцев назад
People love to talk about air superiority, but how are you going to get air superiority against an enemy with huge number of air defences. Just look at what happened in Vietnam. USA lost 10k aircraft thanks to Soviet air defences. You get air superiority only against starving countries
@peterhansson2634
@peterhansson2634 6 месяцев назад
Exactly. Well said
@tvo726
@tvo726 6 месяцев назад
Air Defenses are not the end all be all to counter air superiority, look at the Gulf War or OIF. advancements in technology and intelligence allowed for Air power to effectively and accurately target anti air instalations and batterys. I'm confident that western Air power beats soviet Anti air in a modern war today.
@ikbalshaikh3614
@ikbalshaikh3614 6 месяцев назад
Look at the iraq war, thats the example you should look at, not the vietnam war, the rolling thunder campaign was unsuccessful not due to military reasons but political reasons, the vietnam war didnt really have standoff weapons against enemy defensive systems but now we do, + most aircraft were lost due to gunfire because they flew at low altitudes to avoid missiles, autocannons arent really used as anti aircraft now a days, + US air doctrine is much more refined, youre forgetting that the vietnam war was one of first with jets and missiles together
@matthewvargas2264
@matthewvargas2264 6 месяцев назад
​@@ikbalshaikh3614 iraq is a horrible example bro . The iraqi army was a complete joke .
@tvo726
@tvo726 6 месяцев назад
@matthewvargas2264 The Iraq army had hundreds of SAM and anti Air batteries... my father was in the air guard during the gulf War and OIF and can attest that the air cover was no match for western stealth jets and bombers but it was definitely not a slouch of air cover
@user-re3nl6oy9r
@user-re3nl6oy9r 3 месяца назад
Maybe the US military industrial complex should start producing some of those old Russian shovels and chips from washing machines? I’m starting to think Russia might have its own military industry in that big farmland of theirs 🤔
@esra_erimez
@esra_erimez 5 месяцев назад
Chris, Happy and Healthy New Year to you and all the Task & Purpose viewers.
@mnk9073
@mnk9073 6 месяцев назад
Lessons from "counteroffensive": 1. Don't run headfirst into a f*cking concrete wall for 6 months. 2. Don't take the advice from "superpowers" who only punched down at farmers and goatherds armed only with soviet surplus for the last 80 years and still managed to lose most of those. 3. Don't drink your own Koolaid.
@Praetor95
@Praetor95 6 месяцев назад
The tankman in the first shots, wearing a helmet and goggles. That's a friend of mine. Sergeant Vyacheslav Bashta. He rammed an enemy BMP-2 on this mine trawl. He fought in the 25th Airborne Brigade. The photo was taken during the offensive in Kharkov region. He was a very good friend and soldier. He died a brave death in the autumn of 2022 near Liman.
@J0hN_TF
@J0hN_TF 6 месяцев назад
RIP
@OleDiaBole
@OleDiaBole 6 месяцев назад
He probably killed 70 Russians and saved 1000 children while dying... Am i right???
@Warszawski_Modernizm
@Warszawski_Modernizm 6 месяцев назад
May he rest in Peace. Niech spoczywa w pokoju. PL🤝 UA
@augustusaurelius2628
@augustusaurelius2628 6 месяцев назад
He met bandera
@genem895
@genem895 6 месяцев назад
Slava Russia!
@no_return1471
@no_return1471 6 месяцев назад
Killed it on this vid brotha. As always your informative and non biased pov is very much appreciated Sir 🙏✌️
@spetsnaz892
@spetsnaz892 6 месяцев назад
Non biased hahahahahahahaahhaahahahahahaahahahahha
@sirdronexxiv2868
@sirdronexxiv2868 6 месяцев назад
Love the channel and you have helped me through a tough time just by giving me good stuff to watch
@Sarge714
@Sarge714 6 месяцев назад
This is a good teachable moment for the US Military. When you can't do combined arms, what do you do? Ukraine has done a good job with the forces they have. I'm sure in the future there will be a lot of What If History channels asking what if F-16's were present during the counterstrike. Also I wonder who will get the contract for a demining system that can handle the mine density the Russians laid down.
@NonEuclideanTacoCannon
@NonEuclideanTacoCannon 6 месяцев назад
At that phase, that really bothered me that there was a sense of outrage that Ukraine had rejected a combined arms doctrine that they were physically not able to do. Hindsight is 20/20, but the process of transferring F-16s should have began the moment they were requested. Hell, I would have pushed for F-35s, but I suppose that's why they don't let me make important foreign policy decisions.
@sithersproductions
@sithersproductions 6 месяцев назад
F 16s would have been pointless since Ukranian and Russian military doctrines both operate on the assumption that they will not have air superiority. The problem was that Ukranians and their Western backers started to actually believe their own hype. The real opportunity for Ukranians was immediately after the Kharkov offensive when they should have struck in the direction of Crimea instead of getting bogged down defending Bakhmut.
@mw9297
@mw9297 6 месяцев назад
@@NonEuclideanTacoCannonPutin said nato jets in Ukraine will only escalate this whole thing.
@OleDiaBole
@OleDiaBole 6 месяцев назад
@@NonEuclideanTacoCannon How funny you are... Russia uses 5% of their army, has economy growth of 5%, military production inhrease of 10fold. Your economies are plummeting and warehouses being emptied... yet here you are wet dreaming 🥲.
@isellcrack3537
@isellcrack3537 6 месяцев назад
@@mw9297 "Putin said..." :D
@snipe918
@snipe918 6 месяцев назад
A lot of officers tried to attack on a concentrated front in WW1. It was clear after huge losses that the only way to have a chance at defeating such vast mutually supported trench systems is to attack on a wide front with adequate preparation. At least the Ukrainians knew not to concentrate their force, likely saved many lives.
@FabiusPolis
@FabiusPolis 4 месяца назад
7:10 Funny, on a map on that scale, a village so small like Robotyne would never appear as a dot.
@joethekinghawk7514
@joethekinghawk7514 2 месяца назад
Yep, he’s a pro Ukrainian bot, he still don’t get it, the USA proxy is doomed.
@antonleimbach648
@antonleimbach648 6 месяцев назад
When we compare the amount of armor that Germany used in 1941 in Ukraine to the amount of armor Ukrainian forces were given to break through Russian defenses we can only conclude that Ukrainian forces will need nearly a thousand tanks to break through. The Ukrainian army has to be able to absorb the loss of dozens of tanks in an attack and not even blink. Unfortunately the West has been fighting small conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan where small units were predominantly used. Well guess what, this is a war on the scale of WWII in the Eastern Front.
@bubba842
@bubba842 6 месяцев назад
They don't have the manpower anymore. You can give them all the equipment you want, but if there are no men to man that equipment then it is a waste of time..
@TechnoMinarchist
@TechnoMinarchist 6 месяцев назад
They already lost. This is propag
@augustusaurelius2628
@augustusaurelius2628 6 месяцев назад
But i was told the ghost of kyiv was more than enough, that Ukraine was going to be taking Moscow by Christmas. What happened? Who lied?
@FreedomFox1
@FreedomFox1 6 месяцев назад
The US has thousands of tanks in storage. We gave them what, a few hundred? Which we still won’t let them use (perhaps because it looks bad for Russians to kill US tanks?).
@FreedomFox1
@FreedomFox1 6 месяцев назад
@@augustusaurelius2628Everyone lied.
@andrescarmona6993
@andrescarmona6993 6 месяцев назад
There is not element of surprise in todays battlefields. Satellites, drones, awacs, etc. are aware of all movements and make it impossible to amasse enough forces in a limited area to break through russian defenses.
@DeadPixel1105
@DeadPixel1105 6 месяцев назад
I've been thinking the same these past few years. With modern technology such as drones and satellites, coupled with the fact that every nation is basically spying on one another at all times, is the element of surprise even *possible* in today's world with modern technology? Seems extremely difficult to maintain the element of surprise, if not outright impossible.
@dmitriyzhukov9193
@dmitriyzhukov9193 6 месяцев назад
Thats not true. Look how Israel got suprised.
@AaronRMG
@AaronRMG 6 месяцев назад
@@dmitriyzhukov9193It is possible that that country was not caught by surprise. They have a reputation for having one of the best intelligence agencies in the world, especially when used against their enemies. I suspect it's true they weren't surprised. By they, I mean the people in power.
@DeadPixel1105
@DeadPixel1105 6 месяцев назад
@@dmitriyzhukov9193 The thing is, not many people believe that Israel was caught by surprise. There is strong evidence that the Israeli government were warned numerous times, yet didn't do much to prevent it. Same sort of situation as Pearl Harbor and 9/11. The government knew an attack was being planned and was coming, but for whatever reason, they failed to take the appropriate measures to protect against it. I do not personally believe that the Israeli government and IDF 'upper brass' were legitimately caught by surprise. That's just my own personal opinion though.
@andrescarmona6993
@andrescarmona6993 6 месяцев назад
@@dmitriyzhukov9193 I think we are talking about different things. I am talking about a war between two peer armies fighting each other, not about a group of militants attacking a line border. By the way!! Israel got information about Hamas preparing an attack from different sources (Egypt inteligence) and decide to do nothing .
@KingsleyIhejirika-mu7si
@KingsleyIhejirika-mu7si 4 месяца назад
I think you’re more of pro Ukrainian than neutral commentator.
@Bleckyyyy
@Bleckyyyy 2 месяца назад
A smart man
@kalle19
@kalle19 6 месяцев назад
Milley calling the enemy and warning them may have been a reason for failure too.
@JenniferA886
@JenniferA886 6 месяцев назад
So the counteroffensive has clearly failed 👍👍👍
@vladddtfan
@vladddtfan 4 месяца назад
no kidding, US has 11,000 IFVs, it donated 200+ to Ukraine. Meanwhile Russia deploys its entire Cold War stock of weapons to murder people in Ukraine. US is not serious. US is confused. And it’s receding on the world stage.
@Mriswith2k
@Mriswith2k 6 месяцев назад
I remember that long before these offensives there were talk about using the mine-clearing line charges (which clears up to 100meters) which I believe worked well at the start of the war to clear minefields and led to some ukrainen breakthroughs, but Russia then responded by making the minefields 300 meter deep which requires multiple charges and causes the clearing vehciles to be much more vulnerable to artillary and drone fire. Ukraine then requested a large amount of normal mine clearing vehicles using chains and similar techniques to help in offensive opperations, Russia then started stacking mines on top of each other solely to take out the mine clearing equipment. I honestly can't see a way to ever properly conduct ground offensive operation against a country which military doctrine is so heavily weighted towards both mines and artillary (and currently also loitering/drone ammunition). I understand why Ukraine is building defensive positions to prevent Russian attacks, but at that point it seems you've already recognized that the current areas are in all essentials completely lost, since at the same time Ukraine is building defensive positions I assume that Russia is also fortifying/expanding their own which means breakthroughs will be significently harder if not impossible the next time.
@jordansoviet23
@jordansoviet23 3 месяца назад
Russia also deployed their Agriculture mine laying vehicle as a response. They kept putting up mines that actually caused the Ukies to be stuck on one spot, thus becoming easy target for Russian drones, helicopter, artillery and warplanes.
@henryvacal3544
@henryvacal3544 6 месяцев назад
Western armies training Ukrainian army how to lose a war. As if western armies won in Vietnam, Afghanistan and other other parts of the world. Pathetic.
@luigimrlgaming9484
@luigimrlgaming9484 4 месяца назад
Western Armies know how to win… it’s just their methods need all the stuff Ukraine doesn’t have.
@momkidnapper9697
@momkidnapper9697 Месяц назад
@@luigimrlgaming9484 bros trying to argue with russian bots
@jzakary1
@jzakary1 6 месяцев назад
I'm an American working in Ukraine for a humanitarian organization, and what terrifies the people here is the West's waning support for this war. Putin knew from the beginning if he stretched this conflict, eventually the American and Europeans would pull their support.
@rupertbe
@rupertbe 6 месяцев назад
Pretty sure they are more scared of forced conscription and dying for zelensky
@Spectre4490
@Spectre4490 6 месяцев назад
А коррупция людей не ужасает? А воровство денег у армии не ужасает? И как же мы должны победить пока военокмы покупают виллы в Италии, депутаты голосуют что бы не открывать декларации о доходах что бы не ШОКИРОВАТЬ людей и президент который на вопрос о коррупции говорит что бы американцы не переживали, ведь деньги которые власть ворует - это деньги украинцев Война в тупике и никакая помощь не поможет если в управлении сидят предатели
@easalsoeas4565
@easalsoeas4565 6 месяцев назад
​@@Spectre4490, Yes the Ukrainian Spring Counterattack was a huge success at the true purpose of the corrupt money laundering scheme. The side show of gaining back territory was a failure but it allows the corruption the Ukrainian Government to expect and demand for more Western Money . This is how corruption has always worked and explains why the Ukrainian Government refuses to give honest and accurate information about the war. Instead the Ukrainian Government only demands more Western Money and is constantly threatening the West with blackmail.
@Taskandpurpose
@Taskandpurpose 6 месяцев назад
there is a concern now that the US might not be able to commit to more support. we'll know more next month. a lot is going to play out this year, how effective is Ukraine's defensive fortifications going to be? can they recruit more troops? will Russia be able to push forward more in 2024?
@josesbox9555
@josesbox9555 6 месяцев назад
China is watching…
@timkey_4542
@timkey_4542 6 месяцев назад
6:40 I'm rewatching the Great War series right now (the week by week by thr great war channel) and god damn this feels familiar
@scouterstu5856
@scouterstu5856 6 месяцев назад
You are correct. See W2 Battle of Kurst. The Russians todays type defensive system that their Soviet grand parents used to defeat the Russian combined with modern high tech communications, drones precision guided missile..
@timkey_4542
@timkey_4542 6 месяцев назад
@@scouterstu5856 I'd compare it more to the german hindenburg line from WW1 as Kursk were mainly temporary fortifications while the Surovikin line just as the hindenburg line have a more permanent character. It remains to hope that just like the allies in 1918 Ukrainian tactics catch up with the defense. The Hindenburg Line was broken, among other things, by the fact that the Entente only "bit out" a kilometer or so at a time, fortified it and then waited for the Germans to counterattack, which led to higher losses for the Germans and, in combination with material superiority and a better supply situation, ultimately led to Germany's defeat. Whether Ukraine will have the same conditions depends on whether Russia's puppets in the West, such as the AFD in Germany or Orban in Hungary, do not achieve a majority after all.
@secondlook
@secondlook 6 месяцев назад
That channel really is exceptional
@prison1231
@prison1231 6 месяцев назад
No air support suicide mission
@johnallen6945
@johnallen6945 6 месяцев назад
I have also participated in joint US exercises with our Allies at sea. I agree it's more about coordination of efforts and determining which countries' forces are best equipped to get the job done. All done in English even with 10 different countries which I found interesting. I thought there would be more translating.
@tommytomas-fr3sh
@tommytomas-fr3sh Месяц назад
You all should learn how Russia conducts its war. Sadly many think that the way Russia conducts its war is considered crude but fails to see that it works.
@up4open
@up4open 6 месяцев назад
Reporters have near zero caution in sharing those images and recordings, and it makes their interviewees less safe.
@daninquin2732
@daninquin2732 6 месяцев назад
Not only that but the hype for the offensive was too much
@StridentSloth
@StridentSloth 6 месяцев назад
The counteroffensive was the most telegraphed military move of all time and there was zero chance of hiding its targets from Russia. Concentrating as much as possible was the only play and I don't understand why the Ukrainians thought differently.
@daninquin2732
@daninquin2732 6 месяцев назад
Maybe they were too over confident, maybe they wanted the russians to think that it would be a repeat of the kherson offensive that was hyped and then ukraine hit another front too that they didnt anounce
@lethalfang
@lethalfang 6 месяцев назад
Because while it gives you a higher chance at a successful counteroffensive, it also gives you a higher chance of catastrophe if your counteroffensive fail and your enemy attacks elsewhere.
@StephenYuan
@StephenYuan 6 месяцев назад
Gathering a concentration of forces for an offensive in secret is practically impossible nowadays with recon drones and satellite remote sensing.
@L3v3LLIP
@L3v3LLIP 6 месяцев назад
That's BS. Intelligent people know it does not matter if you throw 1 or 10 battalions into a sea of mines. In hindsight the correct move would have been to just not try a fast attack at all and do it the slow infantry way from the start. Or attack somewhere with less mines. The real shocking mistake is that they where surprised by the amount of mines. Why was that not known?
@haywire4686
@haywire4686 6 месяцев назад
@@L3v3LLIP Because mines are under the ground..?
@jeffbenton6183
@jeffbenton6183 5 месяцев назад
This is one of the most informative videos I have seen on the topic. Thanks!
@streetsbehind247
@streetsbehind247 6 месяцев назад
The cope of this video is off the charts.
@AlexLee-dc2vb
@AlexLee-dc2vb 6 месяцев назад
I really appreciate the Ukraine content. As the Middle East enters the spotlight, attention is fading toward the most important war of the century. I really hope that soon we can get some good news about the European front.
@Taskandpurpose
@Taskandpurpose 6 месяцев назад
there doesn't appear to be much interest in the topic anymore from the viewers but I will continue to cover it anyway
@AlexLee-dc2vb
@AlexLee-dc2vb 6 месяцев назад
Thank you Chris!@@Taskandpurpose
@bleekskaduwee6762
@bleekskaduwee6762 6 месяцев назад
​@Taskandpurpose thank you , this is a very important war and it cannot be forgotten about
@user-kr5ho3wr3v
@user-kr5ho3wr3v 6 месяцев назад
Result. The Ukrainian offensive completely failed, it was an ordinary PR campaign paid for with the lives of Ukrainian soldiers. * New* NATO equipment or equipment from the USSR is nothing when the fields are mined and dozens of drones and Lancets are flying over you. The Russian army is slowly but inevitably moving forward, and the Ukrainian command, after 2 years of war, remembered that it was necessary to build defensive structures in winter (when the ground freezes). Oh yes, there is also a Ukrainian landing party on rubber boats, which is pressed to the bank of the Dnieper River and is being destroyed by the Russian artillery. The author of the video calls it *a small victory for the Ukrainian army*. OK:) Now think about why the Russians are not trying to eliminate this suicidal breakthrough of the Ukrainian infantry completely? But they give new and new Ukrainian soldiers the opportunity to arrive on this small piece of land. There is no doubt that the most combat-ready brigades of the Armed Forces of Ukraine have already been lost, their defenses will be broken by the superior forces of the Russian Army next year, then peace negotiations on the terms of the Kremlin.
@None-ss1zi
@None-ss1zi 6 месяцев назад
Yeah, no one talks about Yemen nowadays
@Alexander-le7qk
@Alexander-le7qk 6 месяцев назад
Russians stopped the whole NATO and its subordinates in Ukraine. What a brave and smart defense!
@Grizathvili
@Grizathvili 3 месяца назад
This offensive indeed not a big battle in Ukraine, the biggest is yet to come, the one after Aavdiivka defeat.
@weaseltheweasel302
@weaseltheweasel302 6 месяцев назад
So many excuses for Ukraine’s complete and utter failure.
@knightlord368
@knightlord368 6 месяцев назад
People can't accept failure and making 20 minutes vedio to only to make excuses for it it's basically ironic
@DebutModestes
@DebutModestes 6 месяцев назад
Let them cope with the situation
@johnnycaps1
@johnnycaps1 6 месяцев назад
Clearly War is very complicated. The planners and strategists carry a heavy burden as well as the soldiers having their legs and other body parts blown off. Your videos helps a simple person like myself almost understand how complicated and horrific war can be. Thank you for your excellent work.
@kingsman3087
@kingsman3087 6 месяцев назад
US marines are nothing without war
@skywillfindyou
@skywillfindyou 6 месяцев назад
@@kingsman3087 fast, small war with comfotable seat and happy meal
@mrdoerp
@mrdoerp 5 месяцев назад
​@Readthis880they have to walk back all the way to the Dnipro..
@8menincostume
@8menincostume 5 месяцев назад
​@@kingsman3087did you know that they can also participate in disaster relief and emergency rescue response? I just learned that military not only kills but, they can save, such as the coast guard. 😮
@ThumbsHunter
@ThumbsHunter 5 месяцев назад
Robo teen is a sick name for a town.
@VIDireWolfIV
@VIDireWolfIV 6 месяцев назад
honestly I can understand his apprehension over the risky plan. The russians have a very long history of seeing battles coming and closing in on bulges from armored offensives like this one. While they're not like how they were in the second world war they still have that heritage and we all know they love tradition.
@latewizard301
@latewizard301 4 месяца назад
In history, russia has won like 3 wars and lost the rest...
@goatman3828
@goatman3828 6 месяцев назад
Kinda hard to have combined forces movements when you lack half of the combined forces types. With their initiative blown, and no air power there was absolutely zero chance of success raming through minefields and entrenched bunker systems. Lacking air power eliminated any hope of success. And lacking long range missles means the opposite side can stack their defence tight to the front.
@garethmartin6522
@garethmartin6522 6 месяцев назад
Yes, there was zero chance of success, but the Americans encouraged to go forward and die for nothing anyway.
@ChucksSEADnDEAD
@ChucksSEADnDEAD 6 месяцев назад
Air power does not disable mine fields. Combined arms means the combination of arms, it doesn't require ALL types of arms.
@garethmartin6522
@garethmartin6522 6 месяцев назад
@@ChucksSEADnDEAD So in other words, you can only fight when conditions are perfect. Also, American and other NATO officers not only helped plan and signed off on the Ukrainian counter-offensive, but have since admitted that the results were much worse than they expected. Expected. They knew that the Ukrainians didn't have air power, and expected them to win anyway.
@goatman3828
@goatman3828 6 месяцев назад
@@ChucksSEADnDEAD I think you'll find I stated that there is no quick way through a minefield and entrenched positions. But with the air space under control it would allow the mine clearing to be done without artillery falling on your head.
@goatman3828
@goatman3828 6 месяцев назад
@@garethmartin6522 the point of combined forces is that it allows movement in less than ideal conditions. Where 1 part is disadvantaged another has an advantage. This working together results in a more likely advance. Also, US and NATO pushed for a different strategy than what Ukraine wanted to do (and did do). Good thing too because if they went with the US plan (lacking air cover as they did and do) 5he mechanized losses would have been huge. And infantry would have been worse. The US and NATO are so used to air supremacy for so long that they don't understand using ground forces without it. Had the F-16s been in theater with trained pilots things may and I say may have been different. But 2 miles deep minefields will be a problem if the opposing force can offer even limited resistance.
@Lizz_ss25
@Lizz_ss25 6 месяцев назад
Spoken with a few war vets it’s the fact they’re human and not just robots. Ranging from my grandpa in ww2 to the Yugoslav civil war.
@paskilbok
@paskilbok 5 месяцев назад
Он с таким восхищением рассказывает про то, как украинцы обосрались, что начинаешь думать, что они не обосрались, а победили.
@ehrendamitz2555
@ehrendamitz2555 4 месяца назад
Thanks Buddy, great update.
@michaelfaraday8391
@michaelfaraday8391 6 месяцев назад
The Ukrainians downfall was to allow nato officers to train them. How can someone who hasn’t dodged a grenade before teach you how to escape a grenade? Everything they teach them only works in Afghanistan and Iraq but not in a real war against an enemy in the stature of Russia.
@plwn6468
@plwn6468 6 месяцев назад
Miley as a senior adviser !!! Opponents not needed for utter failure.
@TheDaviddraws
@TheDaviddraws 6 месяцев назад
Congrats on your engagement! How exciting!
@christianroberts8134
@christianroberts8134 6 месяцев назад
Cappy you do a great job mixing your experience and research and this video is a perfect example of this. Keep up this fantastic work!
@Taskandpurpose
@Taskandpurpose 6 месяцев назад
I tried my best, thank you for watching glad some people found it valuable in some way
@benjaminlehmann
@benjaminlehmann 6 месяцев назад
Congratulations! Lovely to hear that you've got engaged. Thanks for all your hard work and reporting.
@RUTHLESSambition5
@RUTHLESSambition5 5 месяцев назад
He spreads Ukraine propaganda. Destroyed all his credibility for Ukraine views.
@Jeremy-sc2qv
@Jeremy-sc2qv 6 месяцев назад
Good overview, thankyou
@_SYDNA_
@_SYDNA_ 6 месяцев назад
".. but without proper air support ..." Exactly.
@joshuawstone08
@joshuawstone08 6 месяцев назад
The thought of western militaries playing combat mission Black Sea would be funny, awesome and scary at all at once.
@JoeyP946
@JoeyP946 6 месяцев назад
It's time the West starts showing some strength again. We have been weak and lazy for too long
@SD78
@SD78 6 месяцев назад
Combat Mission is very heavily flawed to the point of being unrealistic.
@Angry.Canuck
@Angry.Canuck 6 месяцев назад
Thank you very much for this video. It was very informative and in my opinion... makes sense now. There was some media networks who spoke of disagreements at the top military level of Ukraine, but never mentioned NATO nor the US... for obvious reasons now that I watched this video. Thanks again! I'm hitting like and subscribing. 🎉
@Taskandpurpose
@Taskandpurpose 6 месяцев назад
great to have you aboard thanks for joining the spare parts army
@TheNab89
@TheNab89 6 месяцев назад
Counter offensive failed, bro. They didnt even take their minimum objective, which was the city of Tokmak. And honestly tho, mines did play a role. But Russian KA-52s, recon and ATGM teams ate the bulk of Ukrainian offensive. What is it with westerners always trying so hard to minimize Russian resolve. "oh.... it was just the mines". Bro, even the mine laying is commendable. But you go for mines, because its the furthest from any direct prowess. Kinda pathetic. This is "Russian winter" and "burning of Moscow" all over again. ThAtS thE OnLY RAeSon ThEy wOn! lol.
@starstray4326
@starstray4326 5 месяцев назад
Spot on
@th3_l1nk28
@th3_l1nk28 5 месяцев назад
least obvious russian bot:
@pablodasilva7119
@pablodasilva7119 6 месяцев назад
Im sad for the young people that lost their life’s in this conflict but the outcome was expected if the leadership could not do a simple operation of leaving Afghanistan without failing imaging a complex war with a real army
@james94666
@james94666 6 месяцев назад
Great break down of the offensive many thanks from Scotland.
@adamzuraitis3267
@adamzuraitis3267 6 месяцев назад
Pretty sad when we can’t get updates like this from journalists… keep up the good work Cappy
@picklethepirate
@picklethepirate 6 месяцев назад
You're right. Journalists actually take the time to learn how to pronounce city names (Ro-bot-any. Not "ROBO-TEEN". Jesus christ).
@adamzuraitis3267
@adamzuraitis3267 6 месяцев назад
@@picklethepirate ah yes… pronunciation is always so easy
@adamzuraitis3267
@adamzuraitis3267 6 месяцев назад
@@picklethepirate who am I kidding… nobody really cares how it’s pronounced, he’s actually reporting on it unlike the entirety of Western Media
@picklethepirate
@picklethepirate 6 месяцев назад
@@adamzuraitis3267 I like this channel for the video reviews of new military tech, but i find him very unreliable about actual wars. i read the NYT & WaPo articles about UKR every day, as well as listen to two podcasts from the Russian side. T&P is in line with the rose-tinted goggles WaPo has - pure UKR bias. Don't believe him. For pro-NATO stuff, NYT at least reports when bad things happen to UKR. Even if they get their $60 billion, it's over.
@mr.z3664
@mr.z3664 6 месяцев назад
What update? The real update is that Ukraine has lost and they better start negotiating for peace. If you want actual interviews with Ukraine soldiers, check out the BBC.
@AnInterestedObserver
@AnInterestedObserver 6 месяцев назад
Thanks. Very informative. Soldier's stories are always good, first- hand. News abour the changing tactics in changing weather is always interesting too. Maybe you could do something on what soldiers do to keep warm and dry in the trenches and battlefield, specialist kit and weapons.
@seeker5632
@seeker5632 5 месяцев назад
What happened in three words: Minefields, drones, artillery. End of story.
@victorguimaraes1969
@victorguimaraes1969 4 месяца назад
Calling an M16 a premium equipment is kind of a streach. No ammo to repleanish during combat and a gun that can jam with dust is no match against that mud
@angman1966
@angman1966 6 месяцев назад
Hey Cappy! Another great show, keep up the good work!
@mathewgomez1142
@mathewgomez1142 6 месяцев назад
Your channel is very informative. Thanks for the current event updates.
@Jay-om8gr
@Jay-om8gr 6 месяцев назад
Yall mfers are coping hard
@powerstroke6.7
@powerstroke6.7 5 месяцев назад
They crossed the river not against all odds but at any cost! Played right into Russian playbook. Look at the comment of the guy who actually crossed.. they were played by the Kiev.
@mrdoerp
@mrdoerp 5 месяцев назад
There is a more recent article (think it was WaPo as well) with soldiers from Krynki who (again) confirm the obvious, which is that droves of them are dying (even during the crossing) for what can only be described as a PR campaign
@Lu_si_ya
@Lu_si_ya 6 месяцев назад
The soldiers I talked to said they expected one demining vehicle for 4 combat vehicles. The result was one demining vehicle for 70 combat vehicles.
@Amradar123
@Amradar123 6 месяцев назад
Lesson 1: you cannot be "slightly" at war. To win you need to provide all required materials and scale up production accordingly and be 100% committed as allies. No political games, nothing.
@malickbolisca2259
@malickbolisca2259 26 дней назад
Great video! Keep up the good work!
@scrimshaw7470
@scrimshaw7470 6 месяцев назад
I was shocked that the counter offensive failed. The months long publicity tour that advertised it ahead of time had me convinced.
@blyatiful4157
@blyatiful4157 6 месяцев назад
Smell like coping, river crossing doesnt change anything and they just stay in there
@joethekinghawk7514
@joethekinghawk7514 2 месяца назад
And in the end they were slaughtered, Ukraine must surrender
@estebanpacheco7102
@estebanpacheco7102 6 месяцев назад
Sounds like reality is going to happen. Task & Purpose, prepare the speech for the unavoidable result.
@precious_orim
@precious_orim 6 месяцев назад
Can't believe people still watch his bs 😅
@rafatlatif544
@rafatlatif544 5 месяцев назад
When did M16 became a primium equipment. It's just a toy if you consider a war
@ivanchubb885
@ivanchubb885 5 месяцев назад
Unfortunately, as soon as The Washington Post was mentioned as a source, the credibility immediately dropped.
@chimangoestudios
@chimangoestudios 6 месяцев назад
Weeb union or military summary are a must for people who want to know the truth about Ukraine. You can check old videos to confirm they are objective
@jamesdunn8013
@jamesdunn8013 6 месяцев назад
Really appreciate the way you explained the summer offensive, and how a number of things all played a part in it.
@doublehelix7880
@doublehelix7880 6 месяцев назад
Actually he spared a lot cause the sheepopulation can't handle the reality. The 47th brigade lost about 70% of its personnel in the first two weeks of the summer fiasco. When they reached the actual first line of the Russians beyond Robotyne it already went through 2 cycles of replenishing the manpower with mobilized men (yeah - the ones dragged like stray dogs from the streets). Now what is left from this brigade is ditched in Avdeevka to plug the holes. And the situation is more or less same for all the other brigades that Ukraine kamikazed in the Russian defenses.
@Charles-pf7zy
@Charles-pf7zy 6 месяцев назад
⁠@@doublehelix7880the article you’re referring to says that 70% of the 47th brigade has no combat experience, not that they perished. You can’t even read your own propaganda right 🤦
@doublehelix7880
@doublehelix7880 6 месяцев назад
@@Charles-pf7zy Actually, I got this info from Ukrainian sources and people I know from Ukraine. One of them fought at Robotyne, so I guess he have a clue what was going on there. You are free to believe in anything that copes you - I don't really care. Neither does the reality.
@picklethepirate
@picklethepirate 6 месяцев назад
@@doublehelix7880 what makes me really sad is in 5 years, all these warmongers will be saying "of course i opposed prolonging the war! It was obvious UKR couldn't win!" Just like with Iraq in the 00s.
@thotmorgana
@thotmorgana 6 месяцев назад
@@picklethepirate I don't know though. You do know that Russia literally rolled in with lots of mobile crematoria with the intent of mass genociding the Ukraine population right? I wonder how many people have said 'of course i opposed prolonging the war, US and britain can't win from Germany' after the 2nd world war?
Далее
Why Russian Forces Threw Everything at Avdiivka
21:13
Просмотров 936 тыс.
Why this American F-18 Shot down a Syrian SU-22
18:54
Спасибо Анджилишка, попил😂
00:19
Monster shops mini mart 👻🛒 #shorts
00:49
Просмотров 7 млн
Russian Offensive and Europe's Response
35:05
Просмотров 1,7 млн
How the Worst Group was Destroyed
21:29
Просмотров 1,4 млн
How Powerful is Lebanon’s Militant Force?
23:51
Просмотров 1,2 млн
Why US Troops Fought Wagner Mercenaries in Syria
18:01
The Rise of War in 2023
31:15
Просмотров 2,1 млн
Why Wagner Coup ACTUALLY Stopped before Moscow
17:55
Просмотров 2,5 млн
Why France is Preparing for War
31:54
Просмотров 4,2 млн
The Fentanyl War is Worse Than You Think
16:36
Просмотров 2,5 млн
Britain's New Tank is Legitimately Insane
21:05
Просмотров 901 тыс.
Спасибо Анджилишка, попил😂
00:19