UN was designed to keep colonization going on look at that map and tell me there was hope of peace. By design the conflict was intended and by confiscating weapons from arabs before giving stolen land to israel they ensures that white minority from Europe would win thus colonization was guarenteed to continue. Remember there is no easier way to start war than unfairness 55% of the land to those who had deeds for 5% of the land? Is that even remotely fair or just? Europe and US intended there to be war they knew what they were doing. Same happened when india got independence they designed conflict for centuries ahead.
@@michaelw2288awesome British empire did a Good job. Israel was going to be very tiny until Arabs kicked out jews from all over the middle east and declared war. Then they lost the war and lost territory.
According the the UN plan, Jerusalem was supposed to be a "corpus separatum " administered by the international community. After the 1948 war and the seige of Jerusalem, Palestinians conquered all of the old city of Jerusalem ( East Jerusalem) and gave it to Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan. All of the indiginous Jewish population were expelled and their houses given to Palestinians by the Jordanian Custodian of Enemy Property .
We as Muslims know everything that happens and we are against the world. People are so worried about anti semite and they forgot what Islamophobia did all along as well.
Why is the internet full of people lying about this topic? It is embarrassing the amount of nonsense and ahistorical stuff one has to hear. This is educating people with a distortion of history, disgraceful and dangerous.
Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
British occupied Palestine without jordan was still named Palestine. In any case Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
Arabs were alloted 80 % . It doesn't really matter any more because Islamic Jihadist have infiltrated Arab Palestinian groups and are just using them now . And Jews would make a success of any land they were given because they were motivated after WW2 horrors.
Bro, I know you’re not talking about American people number one because if you did, I’d have a problem with you. Do you wanna talk about a government go ahead But you got a Nazi symbol NASA Learn your history bro the Nazis started NASA in America and you try to play all righteous and shit Research operation paperclip, and don’t generalize America with the American government because I’ll take that personally. And stop your anti-Semitic bullshit. Jews in America have nothing to do with what is going on in Israel.
The 55% of the British Mandate of Palestine that would form Israel contained the Negev desert which represented 60% of that territory, and the new state would have a 45% Arab population. So the most prosperous, fertile, and populated regions would go to the Arab state of Palestine which would have had a Jewish minority of 2%, while the "Jewish" state of Israel would have had a 45% Arab "minority" and 60% of its land would be sparsely populated desert.
Yea he was slightly wrong but your comment is trivial It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
@@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0 “European Jews”? Israel existed 5000 years ago already, and the Jews never left. It is documented by every major nation / school/religion in this time. The old Greeks, Egyptians, Babylonians, Romans, Ottomans, British. The holy Bible, the quran, They all mention Israel.
@@Jopie350 it was the homeland of judeans, many thousand years ago. the european jews made europe their home. wanting most of them out of europe is what the nazis and antisemites before them wanted. If the european jews that created the Israeli state wanted a 2 state solution, they should've done it in europe, where they had been living for consecutive centuries
@@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0 your seperation between european jews and other jews is artificial. You would not do that to any other nation (Chinese, Turks, etc) Jews all over the world have always said: next year in Jerusalem. Don't forget they were expelled there for 90%. This 90% did not just leave out of free will.
@Jopie350 yes I would. Either way it doesn't disprove my comment. Europeans rejected having the euro jews as their neighbors. Australians also rejected the Kimberly plan. Arabs shouldn't have to pay reparations for something the europeans caused. European jews like herzl wanted a country? Fine, they should've made it in europe. But obviously, they would've been invaded.
his guy is really a pseudo scientist. Palestine contained Jewish and Arab Palestinians. He plays the old trick of interchanging "Palestinian" with "Arab". The Arab Palestinians actually wanted to be part of Syria, and were present at the Syran Conference of Damascus in 1919-1920. The arabs have their Palestine already: Jordan. Reading history is more reliable than RU-vid
It is a shame that more is not known about the Middle East, does he have a Lecture Series on Lebanon? I would love to see what he says about the 1960s and 1970s since I know quite a bit from family members who survived, I would really enjoy a truthfully history lesson.
😂😂😂 exactly its al a fairytale. israeli people are living in the matrix. they al believe this nonsense of gods chosen people and that the europeans are natives of palestine pfff
How fucking insane are you. The biblical stories can be traced back thousands of years. Muslims came in and stole their land first. All they wanted was a piece back.
Created out of thin air right ? Go back a bit more why 1948? Jerusalem Jewish city, betlehem Jewish, Beer Sheva Jewish all colonised by Muslims the last being the Ottoman Empire. If you want to go back in time go back not from where it suits your narrative.
He says Palestinians at the time were not Palestinians there, they were different groups of Druss, Arabs, and Jews none of them was called Palestinians
@@lucretiuscaro The founding document of Israel acknowledges a land of Palestine before it. So what are you talking about? You act as if the land was empty which makes no sense because who did the European Christians fight during the Crusades? Themselves 🤣
@@srouji6 The Balfour Declaration refers to the geographical area in the southern Levant, not a country or a state. That area was inhabited and not empty.
I’m guessing this guru graduated from an UNWRA school. The Jewish state was 60% wilderness (Negev desert), with a 45% Arab minority. The Arab state was NOT meant to be secular and “for all”, but for Arabs only, with a 1% Jewish minority. Hence the name ARAB State. ZERO Jews remained in the West Bank And Gaza after 1949. The Arabs rejected the partition plan because they refused to recognize-and still refuse to recognize-ANY sovereign Jewish presence in the land.
Did the Palestinians tried to counter offer? Or just decided to attack Jews? Because if it’s the second option they should lose the land, that’s how war works. By the way most of the south was owned by no one, it’s called the Negev Desert
Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
Why should we be forced to share it in the first place ? Just ask yourself this question... Besides, they could have come and integrated to the population and it's culture like every other ethnicity moving in a foreign land... And if with all consciousness or in your subconsciousness... you think that you're entitled to decide who should live there and who shouldn'.... well... chill... okay... you don't decide... You are entitled to absolutely nothing, especially Jerusalem... And I think you should maybe stop mentioning, debating, and exchanging about this subject at all... It's better for us all...
Most of the land allocated to Israel was useless southern desert. If they were willing to coexist with Israel under different terms they could have proposed that but didn’t. They just said no and five countries invaded to try and destroy Israel, which they didn’t want in any form. Also there were Arabs within the original boundary of partitioned Israel and the state was never intended for only Jews. This is factually untrue.
Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
If it's so USELESS then WHY are you destroying and forcibly relocating the Bedouin LOCAL nomadic people every F-ing year once they settle in one place, destroying every building in sight, including the UN and British donated schools? Why are colonizing "useless land" that others are PROPERLY USING for their pastoral herding jobs? And yes, animal farming, including pastoralism, is A JOB and it's exactly the same type of job MOST OF YOUR ANCESTORS HAVE DONE FOR MILLENNIA before starting local sedentary businesses.
"so basically 50% of Palestine that didn't belong to the Israelis would be simply handed over to them..." 1:21, a complete distortion and misrepresentation of the facts. The speaker failed to mention that the other 50% did not belong to the Arabs; it belonged to the mandatory Power, namely, the British, who had taken it from the Ottomans in WWI. Additionally, he fails to mention that most of that land was desert or swamp land that was uninhabited and that the Palestine partition map looked very similar to the Palestine malaria map, with the malaria portions going to the Jews. This is probably what Twain had in mind when he said, "There's lies, damned lies, and statistics."
Even a zionist like max nordau admitted the arabs had possession rights to the land and Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
So the people that live there are not entitled to their freedom? And needed israel and un and evryone to get them their land? .... you speak about the land like it is a waste land and no people livong there? Is this your view on the shit? The video is very informatif about a lot of things . Britain did invade it so it is belonging to britain? I think britain should pay billions for all the stolen wealth from countries and reperation for all the death , famine and war that they did.
@@mohamedbradai9657 Of course they're entitled to freedom. In fact, only the 2 million Arabs or so who are citizens of Israel have the right and freedom to vote for the government. (There are currently 10 Arabs in Israel's House of Representatives.) Which other country in the Middle East has open elections?
@@Mendeyk Israeli talking points of a land without people for people without land is a lie. Why then did the Israeli have to evict at gun point 700K Palestinian Muslims and christians from their home in 1948? To create a Jewish majority state and a "democracy" that can pass apartheid laws. The token Arab representatives cannot change the laws and appointment of the token Arab judge will have to judge based on the apartheid laws. It is all gas lighting.
@@Mendeyk Also just to add it does not matter who is the ruler at the time be it the British , the ottomans etc. or they there is a change in the rulers. You have no right to carry out ethnic cleansing and oppressing the indigenous population.
Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
Illegal land grab is the initiation of war, not necessarily the first bullet. If someone went in to your house and said “this is my house now” then you rejected and happened to be the one throwing the first punsh doesn't mean you are the aggressor. You incredibly fail to understand that the vast majority of people stand behind justice, not behind those who have bigger muscles.
My ancestors and together with 1 million other Jews who lived in Islamic kingdoms and states for 1400 years were living in states that were entirely ruled by Muslims with zero rights whatsoever for minorities which included Jews and Christians but when the Jews wanted for the first time in over a thousand years their own state it was too much for them it wasn't fair that is utterly ridiculous
Even david ben-gurion admitted that if he were an Arab, he wouldn't have made peace with the zionists either. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
@MrPickledede you are just repeating Israeli talking points. Under Sharia law the non-muslims have rights. You however have no rights to evict millions of the indigenous people out of their homes and lands just because you feel entitled because you are the "chosen" ones. Forever the victim because of the Holocaust. Why should the Palestinians pay the price instead of Germany? Palestinians is not responsible for the Holocaust. Worst part you consider Palestinians as less than human.
@@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0 I will answer. For example, showing this tiny map is a lie. Because this area wasnt a state yet nor a country. It was part of a huge area called the british mandate, and before that the ottoman empire. The arabs in this area weren’t called palestinians, they were the same culturaly, ethnically and religiously as Syrians from Damas or as arab from what is called today jordan. They didnt have any national aspiration. They didn’t have any notable political leader. They just continued refusing the UN plans, not because it was not fair, but beacause they didn’t want a state at all…
Curious to know this guy's sources because he gets really important things dead wrong. He talks about a "Jewish-only" state, but the Partition Plan (which required full civil rights for all residents of each state) would have created a Jewish state with a significant Arab minority (about 1/3 of the total), whereas the proposed Arab state's Jewish minority would have been negligible.
ממש לא מדייק באופן שבו הוא מנסח את הדברים. הוא מגמתי באופן ברור. על פי התוכנית, חלוקה ל2 מדינות, אחת יהודית ואחת ערבית. במדינה היהודית נכללים כמעט חצי מליון ערבים. במדינה הערבית כעשרת אלפים יהודים. אבל אז הם פתחו במלחמה והדברים השתנו. 0:29
You're mostly right but Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
There are a number of untruths in this lecture. The main one is that Israel was defined by the UN partitian plan as a Jewish only state. This never was the case, and indeed many Muslims, Christians, Druze Bahais, and others live today in Israel, enjoying equal rights.
The nation state law was passed into law in 2018, 70 years after the events described in the video. The law says that Israel is the nation state of the Jewish people. How that makes Arab and Druze members of parlement, supreme court justices, university professors, army vetrens, business tycoons, etc. second class citizens is not clear to me. There is a star of David on the Israeli flag, just like there is a cross on the Swiss, English, Finnish, Swedish and other flags. Jews lived happily in thesecountries for centuries. The Star of David - and the Nation State law - does not exclude the 25% of non Jewish Israelis, who are full and successful citizens enjoying more rights and freedoms than they would in any Arab state. It does mean that Israel as a state has a responsibility to be a protector and homeland for the Jewish nation.
Palestinians are not only Muslims, Palestine is a multicultural place with all religions and multiple ethnicities. Don't make this about Muslims only because thats exactly what the zionists do with the Jews
I personally don't differentiate the UN from israel but of coarse I'm old fashioned. I don't pay much attention to what is said, only what is done and the UN has done nothing but assist israel since day one.
My favorit History teacher hi is an exeptional in Middle East history ,and history in General ,hi is a star in his devotion to History ,non byased and profoundly knodgble …..❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
it was the homeland of judeans, many thousand years ago. the european jews made europe their home. wanting most of them out of europe is what the nazis and antisemites before them wanted. If the european jews that created the Israeli state wanted a 2 state solution, they should've done it in europe, where they had been living for consecutive centuries
Well there was no international law taken in regard or human lives from the beginning and as people keep justifying injustice there is only that path left.
On the opposite, the ones fighting for Palestine liveration are some of the most moral amd dedicated resistance fighters you’d ever encounter! Just look at how they treat war prisoners and how they treated civilian hostages! and compare that with Israel’s treatment of the thousands of Palestinian civilian hostages! There is no comparison
That's trivial. Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
That changes very little. Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
@@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0Newsflash: Jews are the original Palestinians of their own Promised Land renamed in AD135 as Palaestina-Suriana by Emperor Hadrianus who built stonewalls to Northern England few years earlier in 128AD.
There is no provision in A/RES/181 (II) to explicitly create a multicultural state in the Arab state of Palestine. Likewise, there is no provision to mandate a Jewish-only state. As a matter of fact, it gives the freedom of movement to both populations to opt for citizenship in the opposite state within a year of the recognition of the independent state. This is so untrue that falls into the realm of conspiracy theories. I do not know where he is getting this information from.
He did mess up there but at the end of the day Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
1) Israel ended up a multi-ethnic democracy and Palestinian territory is exclusively Muslim so that reversed in practice and 2) Israel is surrounded by pure Muslim states including the majority of Palestinian land which was made into Jordan so the idea of one small Jewish state wouldn’t have been crazy even if they didn’t end up becoming the only democracy in the region with broad rights for all ethnic minorities.
Doesn't change the fact that Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
They used to have these things in old history books I bet. I never thought about it til now, but is this why reprint new history books so often. Shouldn’t the history books just be added to?
Israeli have it easy because they have NOTHING to lose. As shown by recent event, they just migrated back to their natural habitat, meanwhile palestinian cannot go elsewhere because IT'S THEIR HOME 🤷
Newsflash: Jews are the original Palestinians of their own Promised Land renamed in AD135 as Palaestina-Suriana by Emperor Hadrianus who built stonewalls to Northern England few years earlier in 128AD.
@@brotherjay7506 and european jews, are not one of them. They were mostly descendant of Ukrainian Convert Jews, not of jewish ethnicity. And Palestinian, were mostly came from jewish ethnicity, but most of them converted to Islam, and blend with Palestinian People we All know today. And if we follow your logic, we could say that, Native American deserves the control of the US and Canada, because it's their ancestor land
@@brotherjay7506 and i don't care what kind of history they had with their beloved land, you simply cannot rob someone's house, it's agreed on many book of laws, made by human
History just shows that borders change. So get over it and move forward. All this money and time spent fighting, if was spent towards improving and growing, what ever home a person home would be happier.
Not everyone rolls over to immigrants to easily. Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
It wasn't supposed to be Jewish only. The existing population was supposed to be respected. BY 1947, Jews had already stolen a lot of land AND said that the partition plan was just a starting point for expansion.
How many 2,000 year old Jewish coins exist today versus 2,000 year old Muslim coins? The Jewish religion has been around for thousands of years before Islam was founded.
it was the homeland of judeans, many thousand years ago. the european jews made europe their home. wanting most of them out of europe is what the nazis and antisemites before them wanted. If the european jews that created the Israeli state wanted a 2 state solution, they should've done it in europe, where they had been living for consecutive centuries
But Jordan was part of the British Palestine, dividing the land between the jews & arabs came into effect then the kingdom of Jordan which is ethnicly 70% Palestine gained independence owning about 70% of the British Palestine territory leaving 30% for Israel, which has Arab Palestine population in it, but they didn't want to be part of the jewish state so the UN had to divide the 30% again giving the Jewish state 55% due to they brought most of the land from the orthoman then declared the arab 45% as secular because it has Muslims, christians, druze and ethnic jews, but the Arab (Palestine) rejected it wanting it to be only Arabs. Your story is correct but not complete & you didn't start earlier you started in the middle
Jordan was given self determination. According to french historian henry laurens, palestine wasn't given self determination in 1920 because everyone knew the population would reject zionism.
@@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0 And in case, I wasn't clear Transjordan, or simply Jordan, makes up 80% of British Mandate for Palestine. Israel including the disputed territories of West Bank and Gaza is only 20% of British Mandate Palestine.
The 1st Century Aramaic word for God is Elaha/Alaha. In Arabic, the word for God is Allah. Arabic Christians use 'Allah' in their prayers. BUT what Muslims call Allah is a pagan diety whose name was Allatha/ Allahu. It was a moon goddess in the Arabian peninsula before Islam. Mohammad chose this goddess to unite the Arabian people under one umbrella. This is exactly why muslims still carry ☪️ a on all over their flags and mosque.
Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
When we stop learning about our own histories...it might look funny to it from others..but we it's NOT FUNNY AT ALL ..no offence to anyone..but muslims need to learn and study about their religion as a whole...politically islamically..socially..everyway
Palestine has always been to the West of the R.Jordan. The state of Jordan was part of Transjordan, at the end of WWI. Early in WWI, Britain promised the whole area to the existing population in return for their help fighting the Turks. Britain reneged on that once the war was a won.
This guy is really a pseudo scientist. Palestine contained Jewish and Arab Palestinians. He plays the old trick of interchanging "Palestinian" with "Arab". The Arab Palestinians actually wanted to be part of Syria, and were present at the Syran Conference of Damascus in 1919-1920. The arabs have their Palestine already: Jordan. Read history.
Doesn't change the fact that Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
it was the homeland of judeans, many thousand years ago. the european jews made europe their home. wanting most of them out of europe is what the nazis and antisemites before them wanted. If the european jews that created the Israeli state wanted a 2 state solution, they should've done it in europe, where they had lived for consecutive centuries
@@user-yy3wf8pw4w You need to understand that this isn't some controversial or disputed opinion. The US had an arms embargo (against both sides) during the war. You're incorrect.
@cap00ify you keep smoking that stuff. The Holy lands were stolen by the British colonisers and handed over to the zionist entity. The whole world knows this.
You should tell the truth about how when the Jews left Palestine in the late 1940’s they left all the factories, farms, shopping malls, farms literally everything they the Jews had built but the Palestinians burned everything to the ground. Literally anything the Jews built they demolished which was basically the whole city. The Jews left a fully functioning city and the Palestinians burned the lot. I only know this because of a Douglas Murray video I’d watched. You only find the truth when you watch what’s considered conservative videos nowadays
The majority of the blue zone, in the South is empty barren desert. The much of the land of the coastal strip, plus Jesreel Valley and Hula Valley had been malarial swamp, reclaimed by zionist settlers.
@michaelw2288 It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
It's not about religion. It's about property. All these Lands belong to Palestine and the Palestinians. Settlers have to leave to Europe, the place where they come from. It's as simple as that. FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸
THE NATIVE DO NOT COME WITH A TENANCY AGREEMENT. ONLY COLONISERS NEED STUFF LIKE THAT. NO MATTER HOW MUCH YOU SPIN IT WE ALL KNOW YOU ARE CHATTING SHIIIIIITE.
Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
