USA Vs India (Parliamentary Vs Presidential) | Whose Democracy is better | Eclectic 

India should adapt American Political System to become United States of India. and Leave Party System of democracy

In short Indian parliamentry system needs huge changes....👍🏼

The evilest is the multiparty coalition 😂😂🤣🤣🤣😂🤣😂😂🤣😂😂🤣😂😂🤣😂😂🤣🤣

Shame this video has only 47 k views after 2 years😭

Dr. Babasaaheb Ambedkar was not in favour Parliamentary system. He said Federal system be good. He was real intellectual.

The mind-blowing content forced me to comment... keep up the good work man👏👏

I was also expecting for the advantages and disadvantages of presidential democracy in US to show up in the video. Anyway thank you.

Direct voting...is better

very well made video. short and with so much infooooo. long way to goo

A very mediocre explanation of the differences between the 2 systems, although there were some crucial points covered like the fact that the constituent people choose unfit candidates as their MPs in order to see a particular individual win a prime ministerial position in a parliamentary republic. And not even wholly accurate. The US president is elected, not directly by the citizens, but through an electoral college. A very important distinction between other presidential republics and the US. Secondly, the executive branch is not wholly unaccountable to the legislative. The US congress can summon a bureaucrat or even a secretary of a department for questioning. A federal officer can be held in contempt of US congress and questioned by the members of its oversight committee. Another thing you should have brought up is the fact that there is a much frequent rotation in office of legislative branch compared to parliamentary system because the lower chamber of US congress undergoes a complete change as well as 1/3rd of senate (upper chamber of congress) midway through a president's 4 yr. term in office. Through Something known as midterm elections. So, if an individual from party A holds the presidency and party A also happens to hold the House-chamber of Congress, this may not necessarily be true 2 yrs later during the midterm elections, so that party B can go on to hold the house majority and maybe gain some senators in the senate as well during shuffling of the 1/3rd senate seats. Now that the congress becomes more in control under part B, the preseident of party A will be more restrained and accountable.

Ohh...at last Thank you Sir for clearing about those topic Thank a lot ❤️

THANX BRO TUMNE MERA KAAM AASAN KR DIYA ESSAY LIKHNE KHA THANKYOU BRO

This series is so mesmerizzzing.... 👍👍and really knowledge boosting..... Thanku prtik.

Thank you... Very good explanation

Loved the way you present it. Keep it up 🤩

Thank you so much sir I am a class 10th student and the video was really helpful for my project. Thank u again. It was like a brief research.

Extraordinary differentiation Myy doubts cleared

your video are superb...make more videos on diff topics...history political,social..moral etc

Nice explanation . presentation was too good.👍👏

Thanku so much sir Nice explaintion

Really helpful content 😍🙏

Thanks my all dough are cleared.🙂👌👌👌🙏🙏🙏

I think wide representation : slows down the amendment and passing of bills !

Nice.... Ur video cleared my doubt... Thank u

Superb explanation bro👍

Nicely presented 👍

Thank you brother for explaining in a lucid manner...

This was the question in upsc 2018 mains ..😊

Tquu sir God bless you..🙏

Thank you.

Any member of parliament from Party have to vote in line with his party even if he dislike the candidates so parliamentary system failed here

Well explained .

For India presidential system is good than parliamentary. Why because if a powerful of a party dies then their will be a downfall of the party. It leads to creation of new parties which makes more instability .

Nice bro..keep moving

Brilliant explanation

after see your video i thik that the Presidentual system is good for us

Thank you so much 🥰

Excellent

Superb

Awesome

Wonderful

India needs presidential democracy

You did good man.

Nice Content.

Misnisters should have well educational qualifications, then only nation will develop. With 1.3 billion people in India unfortunately a school dropout is our leader.

Extremely good

U Grate

The United States Congress is the bicameral legislature of the federal government of the United States, and consists of two chambers: the House of Representatives and the Senate. @1:06

tq

Bhai iska source do 40+ pages ki file banani hai

Nice 👌👌

Central Govt. Decisions should be final.... Problem is state Governments and Local Administration .... In US there is no CM...only Governor's... And All the Governor's follow President strict Action...across 50 States in US... (Panchayet... Municipality.... Corporation ) no Politics only central govt. Politics One nation one Election.... ..

Best explaination

Brother you said that prime minister has limited Choice for selecting a minister as he has to select from an elected member..but this time he appointed s. Jaishankar as his foreign minister??.. He did't contested parliamentery election?

Good

Who is actually responsible for personality cult based politics ? Is it the voters or the politicians ?

Well said about the voting mentality of Indian citizens 😂👍🏻

Indian Education minister 12th fail.😂🤷

super

I don't think anyone can explain better than this

Education of ministers and MPs is not a problem. They r just for giving approval and commands. It's the civil servants, economists who do the actual job not ministers. I just need a leader who believes in doing something better not how to do it. There r many people and machinery available to answer how to do it.

Goood

Nice video ☮️☺️

In India pm won 300+ seats but he is still nagging about election it's always about election

Bro, if people select MP and MLA based on candidate profile then how they will form government with majority??? Suppose in all the constituency independent candidate wins means what will happen????

Due to lack decisionbmaking power our india is a developing country

For making any decision government needs majority. There will only be a majority for a candidate if most of the representatives belong to the same party. So, there is nothing wrong in voting for BJP because they are portraying Modi as PM or as any ather party. I am from jharkhand, here is a collition govt. at the time, I am feeling that the government is unable to act properly because it is bond with congress. Because without them they cannot get a majority, so for me presidentialisation of parliamentary form of government is not wrong. It is good for decision making.

Even if member of parliament is representative of some part but prime minister is the representative of india so if we think about india then we should think about election of prime minister not only for region where we live Think about it !!!!

Which is better

While the Indian system is unstable, its executive and legislature's power is greater than the American republican system. The constitution of the united states heavily constrains the government to not impead the rights of the people, while the Indian system allows any majority party to easily change laws as it pleases. Thats why India can just ban imports or exports levy massive taxes and tariffs, subsidize or hand out freebies without as much as a lokh sabha vote. The federal system is extremely broken because the states are way too big and communal parties hold monopolies in several states with vote banking strategies. The best compromise in my opinion would be an even stronger constitution that heavily limits the central government from intervening in trade and business, limiting its ability to tax, and limiting state's ability to tax and borrow money. And breaking up of large states such as Uttar Pradesh and Maharashtra and ideally having only around 50 million people per state. China already has very small states and despite not being a democracy in reality it still has way better state governments than us.

united nation's president and families and friends and citizens souls children's livingly peacefully fearlessly happily until their all births completely holy births this is my prayers for you respected brotherhood we are remembering your souls service and sacrifice respected brotherhood...

India should also have presidential system for 100% development now the Time is came india should destroy parliamentary system

India is going in the wrong direction. the argument is flawed when u say strong PM will solve all issues in states. The videos is exactly on the same topic that,bcoz the way we started to follow presidential style election for Modi, it made undeserving MP and MLAs get votes,its a fact. The issue here is that these guys dont serve the demand of the indigenous people. And since center is taking the decisions without research on local needs, the ground issues are not resolved. Thats exactly the reason why BJP lost Jharkhand. Same issue with Orissa ,west bengal and even Assam,these states have their own problems with several tribals and associated local needs. Which the centre doesn't understand, forget serving right. On the other hand, they will vote for Modi for center but not for state or Vidhan sabha elections. Regarding power dynamics, both state and center have enough power and enough funds. if the govts concentrated on development,they will definitely be able to do it without losses and debts as done by Kejriwal govt in Delhi.Jan 2020. Its very important we vote a party with a unifying agenda concentrating on development and happiness of the citizens.

Just as police upped they game on the front line. Think that Hiroshima and Nagasaki was not to warn us but rather to advertise it on the basis of it being controlled to some extent. Big industry in those early days. Rules of engagement will change. Don't get left behind.

I agree with Shashi Tharoor India has a Parliamentary system, but the Indian's act like it's a Presidential system. And it's the reason why BJP says vote for BJP candidate is a vote for Modi.

मला अध्यक्षिय लोकराज्य भावते.

Omg the Parliamentary system seems very stupid !

Are indirect saying that all should vote for Modi instead of Mahagathabandhan and Congress. Because multiparty coalition is weak and ineffective.

True ..Minister needs to be educated and practice knowledge. not like dumb finance minister

I liked the advantage/disadvantage part

I think Parliamentary system is for the states with high population but people our country need to change their mind by voting the correct representave instead of voting for a party But I believe Honest executives are more Important than the educated executives because every executive is provided with many educated officers who can do everything executives just need to say yes or no honestly

Kindly read Dr. Ambedkar speech on ‘Stability versus Responsibility’ delivered on 4th Nov. 1948

😉😉😉🙏🙏🙏🙏

Yes,you are right we should elect that representative who is good enough to understand the problems in his/her constituency.Not on the name of honourable Modi and Rahul gandhi

You are wrong?????👺👺👺👺Multi party coalition is good .actually in 1996 only they brought this.state gov. Should have power over central government then only the state can be benefited or else centre may dissolve state government

America is a Constitutional Republic, not a democracy.

oh sare dhaarti faar rehenewale sarva athmaho ishwar ka bachi sabhko duwa bejarahahai manglo khy chahihe his kaliyugh kallas hanewalahai jarur anewale sathya yugh mai khy pad chahihe appko appka pariwar ko manglo ishwar ka bachi duwa bejarahahai manglo anewale sathya yugh threta yugh dhwapar yugh mai khy pad chahihe raja maha raja rani maha rani nowkar chakar daasa daasi senadipiti senapati agriculture class industrial class economy class golden lifestyles daimonnd lifestyles until all the ages this is my love letter forever grateful dad first love forever grateful god first love forever grateful sarva athma honka palana haar lalan haar sarva athma honka dhukha hartha shukha kartha sarva athma honka sacha sathya sadguru sadhgatidaata vidata sarva athma honka sacha avinashi pita paramapita paramathma shantidaam bhramandha nirvanadaam muktidaam nivaasi Incorporeal invisible shining light shiva baapdhada first our souls father first living god first love forever unconditional unshakable unstoppable unbelievable unbreakable unfold love high respect lots of hugs peace joy happiness power purity health wealth care completely divine births especially our nation's all souls children's ishwar ka bachi duwa bejarahahai manglo khy chahihe appko manglo anewale golden age as soon as possible pita paramapita paramathma shantidaam bhramandha nirvanadaam muktidaam nivaasi Incorporeal invisible shining light shiva baapdhada ka phyar ka aghe sare dhaartiwalonka phyar mitti ka samaan hai sathya hai mai athma care of pita paramapita paramathma shantidaam bhramandha nirvanadaam muktidaam nivaasi Incorporeal invisible shining light shiva baapdhada ka phranh phyare bachi until all the kalphas until our souls all births no doubt about it

125

USA

Please videos hindi mein banaye sir English mein kuch samaj nahi aata sir

Hi it's me modi plz vote for me

oh bhaghmash pattaronko poojya phyar karanewale bhaghmash desha vashiyo represent our your souls father mother teacher lover friend companion true caretaker government court judge justice system army arm's nominee supreme creator supreme producer supreme protector supreme director supreme guide supreme 🌟 soul 🌟 god father incorporeal invisible shining light shiva baapdhada first our souls father first living god first forever grateful dad first love forever grateful god first love forever grateful ishwar baba first our souls father first living god first government means god bhaghwan ishwar baba ishwar ka samane shapath karokhe applogh kisiko ajaro dharma ajaro jathiya ajaro dirty culture ko represent kararahhai one god one language one government one culture one system one parliamentary one religion not thousand gimiks that's all

Presidential system is the best 👍💯

Telugu movie🍿🎥

So today the day what usa did broking glassess use the guns and broking every essential things today So that why everyone is telling that indian democracy is strongest in world

He is totally wrong

Indian government is so bad

I felt this was a little bit biased.

Seeing this bullshit for my history project 😂

Good