Тёмный

Vampyr Critique - Some Life in This One 

Kaldini
Подписаться 1,9 тыс.
Просмотров 8 тыс.
50% 1

Vampyr is an action rpg developed by Don’t Nod Entertainment and how you'll feel about this game will likely come down to which half of that genre, action rpg, you care most about.
A look back and a look forward at what lessons a potential sequel or spiritual successor should learn from this game. What it gets right, what it gets wrong, and why after five years it perhaps deserves a sequel.
Thumbnail art by: Chloé Perez
www.artstation.com/yprkaz
Intro: (0:00)
Part 1 - A Doctor Walks Home Alone at Night: (5:01)
Part 2 - We Had to Burn the Donkey: (26:50)
Part 3 - Trying to Ice-skate Uphill: (1:05:26)
Part 4 - You Don't Want to See Me When I'm Hungry: (1:25:23)
Part 5 - Open the Window, Mark: (1:54:34)

Игры

Опубликовано:

 

8 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 63   
@kaldini
@kaldini 8 месяцев назад
Ten points to whoever can figure out the theme of the chapter titles and can give me specifics of where each comes from
@PlaidSuitPinstripeWorld
@PlaidSuitPinstripeWorld 8 месяцев назад
My fondest memory of this game is when i trusted a dude that was eating human remains in some dark basement... My reasoning was "hes acting TOO evil it cant be THAT obvious, im gonna trust him" Then like half the map ended up diseased and everyone died. Lesson learned 😂
@StephenxTehxLefty
@StephenxTehxLefty 5 месяцев назад
I trusted the priest. Never again.
@AnIdiotsLantern
@AnIdiotsLantern 4 месяца назад
My fondest memory was when I found the Nurse and I could either screw her over, make her dead, or use vampire powers to wipe her memory. And I thought, good, my vampire powers will actually help save someone for once! She’ll keep being a nurse and the vampire lady will be safe. Win win! And uh It didn’t work out that way. I maintain it was an accident, I’m a new vampire, I didn’t know I could do that! But damn did I have an emotional reaction to that. I was so determined to save whitechapel. I went to sleep thinking I’d done it. I hadn’t done it. Oof.
@Jan_Iedema
@Jan_Iedema Месяц назад
I love a little lore tidbit where it’s described how vampires don’t die when exposed to the sun but slowly crumble to a blackened skeleton only to regenerate when the sun goes down. It’s a horrifically painful experience and to me it’s a perfect blend between the original literary vampires not having any weakness to sunlight and the now cliche turning to ashes when exposed to the sun. 10:38 and its mentioned 4 minutes later 😂😂
@ashleyyoung2597
@ashleyyoung2597 2 месяца назад
This game is way better then people give it credit. The dialogue is crazy good. Just listening to NPCs in the background give hints to quests. Plus the fact that you can fail dialogue without save scumming is great. You need to listen to everyone's emotions. Great game. Who cares about the combat. If that's what your into then your playing the wrong type of game.
@xTheOneToSaveUsAllx
@xTheOneToSaveUsAllx 8 месяцев назад
So when I heard of aggravated damage by sunlight, I went "oh like in the tabletop game" since the World of Darkness also uses aggravated damage. Then when Embrace was brought up, I also went "oh like in the tabletop game" since Vampire the Masquerade used this term for turning someone into a vampire. Then it was explained and I can't help but think about the people who also were into tabletop games, would fast forward the embrace explanation because they thought they knew what it was, chose to do it and then went "Wait wtf, he's dead?!". That would be one heck of game experience.
@AnIdiotsLantern
@AnIdiotsLantern 4 месяца назад
Playing this game to fill the “Bloodlines 2” sized hole in my life was a trip. What with the “legally distinct not Brotherhood of St Leopold” who the human vampire fanboy belongs to, and the “Legally distinct not Camarilla” that Lord Redgrave runs. Also “Ekon” is a lame substitute for “Kindred.” Kindred is just a better word for it
@RedSpade37
@RedSpade37 Месяц назад
Yeah, I'm not sure why they chose those words. In any other work, Embrace means to "turn someone into a Vampire" or "Grant them the Dark Gift" or "Work the Dark Trick upon them" etc. It's never meant "Kill someone by feeding on them to the point of their death" Potato, Potato, I guess.
@AnIdiotsLantern
@AnIdiotsLantern Месяц назад
My comment disappeared what did I even say
@RedSpade37
@RedSpade37 Месяц назад
Yeah, it needs a sequel. I'm slowy slogging my way through my first playthrough, and I'm close to the end, but it's starting to gnaw away at me. Never have I felt so 50/50 about a game before. My original plan was to play the game twice, once as super evil eat-everyone, and then again with a super good no-embrace. But... If I finish my current run, I'll probably move on to something else and hope for a sequel. If it wasn't a vampire game, I seriously doubt I would have given this game a chance, let alone attempt to finish it. At any rate, good video!
@crispyshadow3729
@crispyshadow3729 2 месяца назад
I think if not for Vampyr's esthetic I wouldn't have played, I personally don't mind the combat because of the little things like dashing around and I personally love all the powers because i cant think of another game where you can blood bend a target or hold someone down to get butt penatrated by a shadow, I don't think the game is supposed challenge you very much because narrativly speaking you seem to be one of the powerful vampires in London so who really could stop but yourself and I really like that. All the problems you mentioned 100% agree with and I would like a improvement cause that mesmerize lvl is super limiting, I don't know why they even put in hard mode where the npcs have specific powers yet at low lvl you can't even have a good select of targets seems like an oversight.
@RedSpade37
@RedSpade37 Месяц назад
Yeah, the Mesmer Level mechanic is unfortunate, for sure. Part of choosing to be evil should be pragmatism: Eat too many people too fast, and the district falls, locking you out from having a chance to eat the rest of the citizens. The Mesmer Level kinda forces this upon you anyway, and I don't exactly like that. Kinda weird. Lots of strange choices with this game.
@guga5708156
@guga5708156 2 месяца назад
Very good but I disagree with being punished for being a vampire, since you are rewarded by it: - Killing people makes you a stronger vampire, specially if you are evil, serving like a curse and lost of humanity - Trying to resist it is possible but lets you weaker, you struggle in game because he is struggling against the curse What you cant is be a vampire hero, since killing anyone even if they are bad, is morally gray on human society and would in theory strengthen your curse.
@chidzhustle3570
@chidzhustle3570 2 месяца назад
Can't wait to watch this over my next three meals. Loved vampyr, ambitious and innovative social circle/pillar structure, even enjoyed the combat, very curious what the critique will be like
@kaldini
@kaldini 2 месяца назад
Let me know your thoughts once you finish it.
@chidzhustle3570
@chidzhustle3570 2 месяца назад
@@kaldinidefinitely will! So far very good analysis, your suggestions on how to improve the systems and specific embrace/turn choices are incredibly fitting and a bit bittersweet they weren’t originally in the game
@andrejmasin2533
@andrejmasin2533 24 дня назад
Bro you way too underrated, banger critiques
@user-fl9dx3rx4j
@user-fl9dx3rx4j 7 месяцев назад
Dude, this is really stellar video, you have very soothing pleasant voice Do not give up, your channel will blow up sooner or later
@rodi3332
@rodi3332 Месяц назад
I stopped playing at chapter 3 right before you find Sean, I'm glad I happened upon this video. Because while the setting and the plot was interesting, I couldn't stand the actual gameplay mechanics. Great video!
@demoney5897
@demoney5897 4 месяца назад
I may disagree with the soothing voice bit, but your insight and understanding of the games you discuss is enough to keep me watching and coming back. I appreciate how well-structured your reviews/analysis are
@WestyDesign
@WestyDesign 8 месяцев назад
I went back through the backlog to 100% this one earlier this year; wasn't great nor terrible. Could definitely use a sequel to find its footing
@kaldini
@kaldini 8 месяцев назад
Hopefully their new game Banishers built off of Vampyr's foundation.
@satyasyasatyasya5746
@satyasyasatyasya5746 3 месяца назад
really enjoyed this. hope for more! :)
@zb5902
@zb5902 8 месяцев назад
kaldini strikes again with a top tier video
@phasewalks
@phasewalks 7 месяцев назад
great video as always, good stuff man!
@grahamthomas6389
@grahamthomas6389 8 месяцев назад
High quality content as always!!! Thanks magician kaldini!!
@roytomasvillasor9228
@roytomasvillasor9228 8 месяцев назад
I love the opening monologue of the game
@gaiusfulmen
@gaiusfulmen 8 месяцев назад
Me too. It's a little melodramatic but so earnest...much like the game itself
@nightangelx1513
@nightangelx1513 9 дней назад
your section on mesmerizing Dorothy and the way it's not explained to the character are spot on. On my second playthrough I attempted a Paragon run, and got punished for selecting the non lethal option. I felt the game cheated me and never progressed after that section.
@gargamellf59
@gargamellf59 8 месяцев назад
i love your videos man
@garethphillips2179
@garethphillips2179 Месяц назад
15:28 I can relate to the dating app comment man! 😂😂
@x-actotron9275
@x-actotron9275 5 дней назад
Personally played this game over and over again... but have only completed it once. It has good bones but just can't hold my interest for the entirety of the story. I am a bit of a completionist though so I lose a lot of time in the side missions; trying to become an overpowered vampiric badass without 'embracing' people.
@raulwalther1497
@raulwalther1497 5 месяцев назад
What a great video! I always disliked the combat system so much, that I stopped playing, but this video makes me wanna play it again, cheers!
@Thedownliner2015
@Thedownliner2015 Месяц назад
Great game and amusingly I had no idea that the blood meter could be replenished until AFTER I fought the first boss in the Pembroke Hospital Morgue lol. Kept wondering why my heal ability wasn't working and could only be used 2 or 3 times until I noticed the bite icon showing up and figured it out. You are right though as a day/night cycle could've made things even more interesting however how that would work as a plus for the game rather than an inconvenience you could just skip by sleeping until nightfall is anybody's guess. It would've been nice to see London town in daylight though and it could've been used as a nudge to get to a safehouse rather than just going there to restock and skill up. Like a reverse Dying Light mechanic. Fast travel would've been nice but I can see how they didn't do it given how small the map is and the fact you would miss all the fights in between getting to different locations. I will say however that like most games today it does feel like the end was rushed as you mentioned with the pointless choices near the end where it should've mattered. It did make the whole thing feel pointless at the end and that's a real shame considering how much time you put into this game making choices. The plot was flawed from the start with the Doris Crane outcome because it didn't even matter what you did with her because Lady Ashbury is an integral part of the story. Charm, Embrace or fire her the outcome is pretty much the same. BTW has anyone actually managed to achieve Sanitized status on a single district? I embraced 4 bastards and kept healing the rest and still couldn't get the district past Stable and the Pembroke was always around Healthy to Stable.
@RedSpade37
@RedSpade37 Месяц назад
As far as my research and own gameplay suggest, the only way to reach Sanitized is if all the Citizens are alive, and you've chosen to Spare the Pillar. It seems like you "Unlock" the ability to gain the Sanitized status for a District after making the major story choice with their respective Pillars. But I'm not 100% on that.
@rae5425
@rae5425 7 месяцев назад
BABE WAKE UP KALDINI HAS JUST DROPPED ANOTHER TWO HOUR BANGER
@Eingefallen
@Eingefallen 13 дней назад
HAHAHAH WE USED TO BURN DONKEY DUNG AS FUEL
@kaldini
@kaldini 13 дней назад
Did you catch the reference?
@blinstales1554
@blinstales1554 Месяц назад
The player does have a reason to turn Dawson: It helps them stay on good terms with the Ascalon Club. Admittedly this doesn’t have any real effect but it makes sense from an in character point of view. We don’t know that King Arthur’s blood can turn people because to my knowledge the game never states that stored blood can turn people. Embracing Clarence’s wife does have a gameplay consequence he won’t accept medicine from you.
@kaldini
@kaldini Месяц назад
As you stated yourself, neither really had an actual impact. The point I was making is that many of choices don't have actual, real, meaningful impacts to the gameplay or narrative.
@blinstales1554
@blinstales1554 Месяц назад
@@kaldini Alright maybe I wasn’t clear enough in my original comment what I mean is that while the player has no incentive to turn Dawson the character of Jonathan Reid does.
@kaldini
@kaldini Месяц назад
@@blinstales1554 I got what you meant but I appreciate you reexplaining it. What I meant was that even in theory if it surface level makes sense for Dr. Reid to consider it, it actually even narratively ends up being pointless. Even if you've pissed the Ascalon club off by refusing, you're still able to acquire the blood in the finale without fighting. So there's no benefit to turning him. I'd also argue that Dr. Reid would not consider the value in turning him, even in regards to remaining in the club's good graces as from the moment they're introduced Jonathan shows contempt for them. Lady Ashbury discourages it and it's clear from his pre-decision discussion with Dawson that Jonathan understands he is selfish and would do more harm. So in my opinion, no there's no real reason Dr. Reid, the character, would turn him.
@alexsm3882
@alexsm3882 3 месяца назад
I really don't see why the name is dumb tbh
@jonrambo416
@jonrambo416 2 месяца назад
Love seeing your abundance of xp when i went to fight the last boss i was -720 exp 😅
@mz4637
@mz4637 8 месяцев назад
cool
@Sylentmana
@Sylentmana 3 месяца назад
I liked this game. I like the feeling of cultivating cattle for my consumption so that I can get cool powers.
@kaldini
@kaldini 3 месяца назад
It's a game that I enjoyed quite a bit myself. Are you planning on getting DontNod's upcoming game Banishers? Allegedly it's set in the same universe as Vampyr.
@Sylentmana
@Sylentmana 3 месяца назад
@@kaldini no, it doesn’t really appeal to me.
@sensoeirensen
@sensoeirensen 7 дней назад
I never understood the critique of the combat system. I'm a huge sucker for good combat as a Soulsvet and over 1000hrs in both Niohs. With that said the combat in Vampyr is not bad at all. I think a lot have skill issues (as always). There are easy talent combinations that make it rly smooth and fun. When I watch youtubers it's almost always a bad button mashing.
@kaldini
@kaldini 7 дней назад
My understanding of many of the critiques isn't that it's too hard but rather that it's too boring.
@bradbrown7273
@bradbrown7273 2 месяца назад
Load times game crashes alot
@rodrigoluzz7534
@rodrigoluzz7534 Месяц назад
If Vampyr were a linear action-rpg it would be 200% better. The open world aspect is so unnecessary, and at the cost of better graphics and more refined mechanics.
@kaldini
@kaldini Месяц назад
100% Have you played DontNod's recent followup game Banishers? Even worse in this regard in my opinion.
@rodrigoluzz7534
@rodrigoluzz7534 Месяц назад
@@kaldini yeah the "return later with the right skill to get this chest" is such a PS2 game mechanic lol
@Hangman1
@Hangman1 2 месяца назад
Game would be great if not combat, combat is atrocious 😢
@apocolypse11
@apocolypse11 9 дней назад
Swj game kcd way better.
@kaldini
@kaldini 9 дней назад
What?
@ravingdeath5182
@ravingdeath5182 8 месяцев назад
It does have a dumb name I must admit
@docrock3234
@docrock3234 15 дней назад
🤣the least fun you’ll have as a vampire. The more vampire things you do, the more you get brutally punished by the strongest part of the game….the story. What kind of vampire game has your vampire fighting with swords and guns..GTFO. You do too many non-vampirey things in this game. I think this is one of the most adult games though, they talk about politics in a very mature way. Extremely rare in games. How about how extremely weak you are due to the dumb RPG leveling. This skinny weak guard is like an immortal god because the #5 above his head is greater than the #4 above yours. GTFO. What a devastating design choice making the combat all the more worse than 9/11. But the story seduced me and I bought the soundtrack. I never forgot what made the game good.
@Timlagor
@Timlagor 2 месяца назад
The RPG is the only thing worse than the combat
@kaldini
@kaldini 2 месяца назад
You didn't like the RPG aspects of the game?
@Timlagor
@Timlagor 2 месяца назад
@@kaldini I didn't like any aspect of it -and I really wanted to
Далее
Banishers Critique - Wasted Potential
1:20:54
БАБУШКА И ИНТЕРНЕТ
00:30
Просмотров 139 тыс.
TRIUMVIRATE STREAM [REDUX]
19:48
Просмотров 10
Ubisoft Isn't Bad... It's Infuriating
22:01
Просмотров 750 тыс.
We Happy Few: An Amazing Story Weighed Down By A Bad Game
1:49:25
Vampyr Build Guide: or How I learned to Love the Blood
38:26
Control Critique - Fascinating Yet Frustrating
2:04:14
Vampyr | A Critique | Luke Stephens
32:50
Просмотров 63 тыс.
Shadow of Mordor: 9 Years Later
1:04:10
Просмотров 1 млн
Games that Won't Leave the Dark
34:00
Просмотров 642 тыс.
Dishonored 2 | An Uncanny Sequel | 2021 Review
57:00
Просмотров 331 тыс.
ТЁМНАЯ СТОРОНА BLIZZARD
31:11
Просмотров 75 тыс.
Я Выжил 500+ Дней в Майнкрафт !
1:3:35