Тёмный

vhs-decode TBC test 

AnalogVideoChannel
Подписаться 161
Просмотров 4,2 тыс.
50% 1

Comparison of vhs-decode output with 2 capture cards and a dvd-recorder on a camcorder that seems to have had some issues during recording causing a lot of jitter
Diamond VC500 USB 2.0 capture dongle - (Conexant CX2310x-based video IC),
I-O Data GV-USB2 USB 2.0 capture dongle - (Renesas/Techwell TW9910 video decoder)
Panasonic DMR-EH58 DVD/HDD-recorder - Panasonic video IC
All captured from a Panasonic NV-SD220. Haven't fine-tuned levels to be compatable as this was mainly to see how stabilization compares.

Опубликовано:

 

16 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 28   
@petes.9111
@petes.9111 10 месяцев назад
This was super helpful for me to understand that yes the VC500 I bought to capture is kinda crap. This vhs-decode project seems promising
@analogvideochannel4612
@analogvideochannel4612 9 месяцев назад
The VC500 (and other cards based around the same hardware) are fine with stable in-spec video input but yeah it can not cope well with direct video from videotapes or non-standard video output from e.g old game consoles at all (though this is an extreme example). If you don't want to go all in with tinkering vhs-decode which can be a bit daunting, you can pass the video via certain models of dvd-recorder like one of the ones demoed in this or the second stabilization video on my channel to stabilize it to get pretty decent results with the VC500 (though I've also had some issue with the audio levels being a bit too high on it, not sure if that's still an issue)
@ConsumerDV
@ConsumerDV 7 месяцев назад
@@analogvideochannel4612 The VC500 is known - and confirmed by me as well - to change video levels mid-scene, so even with a stabilized video it is not the best solution.
@ivok9846
@ivok9846 6 месяцев назад
@@analogvideochannel4612 " (though this is an extreme example). " i have some rather more extreme examples on my channel. those examples make me not believe in tbc at all. in this case it's well known fact diamond is bad, gv seems acceptable, while vhs-decode has best sharpness and stability, ie it's not doing oversharpening like others...oversharpening in the end destroys detail....grass looks better with vhs-decode
@rassilontdavros3004
@rassilontdavros3004 Год назад
Highlights and shadows seem noticeably less crushed on vhs-decode, even compared to the Panasonic!
@TMS5100
@TMS5100 8 месяцев назад
DMR-EH58 does really well, but you of course can't beat virtually unlimited compute power in vhs-decode.
@taymur0804
@taymur0804 7 месяцев назад
Excellent presentation. What software and codec did you use for capturing?
@surject
@surject 9 месяцев назад
Dang, VHS-Decode looks awesome. I still go the DV route (JVC BR-S525E -> Panasonic WJ-MX50 -> Panasonic NV-DV10000 -> Scenalizer -> AVS/QTGMC) and I'm wondering how close the quality is to VHS-Decode aka if it's worth it... ?
@orihalcon8693
@orihalcon8693 9 месяцев назад
Would love to see more comparisons like this. I do wonder though if the VCR used has a line TBC and if so, was it turned on for these tests? Just looking at the captures it looks like there probably isn't one in use?
@analogvideochannel4612
@analogvideochannel4612 6 месяцев назад
No, the VCR used here does not have a TBC
@srmusicomusic4279
@srmusicomusic4279 Год назад
VHS decode is the best. Panasonic DVD does a really great job also. EH58 is similar to ES10?
@analogvideochannel4612
@analogvideochannel4612 Год назад
It's a little newer, so more like the models from ES15 and newer. Usually it's about the same as the ES10. I don't have a ES10 sample of this uploaded but this tape was one of the very rare cases where there was actually a very slight difference and the EH58 couldn't quite keep it completely stable at the very end while the ES10 did.
@srmusicomusic4279
@srmusicomusic4279 Год назад
@@analogvideochannel4612 Ohh, really interesting. Have you read about that German guy who defend that is better to capture directly from HDMI port from these modern Panasonic dvds ? Seems that have HDMI and being digital, there are some advantages than goes to SVideo analog output again to enter in your capture card..... What do you think? Regards!
@analogvideochannel4612
@analogvideochannel4612 Год назад
@@srmusicomusic4279 Yeah that's what I mostly use, you skip the conversion back to analog and it also gives the full 720 pixels of width without the left/right edges being blanked on most dvd-recorders I've tried on unlike the analog outputs.
@srmusicomusic4279
@srmusicomusic4279 Год назад
@@analogvideochannel4612 wow ! Really interesting 😊. I want to try it . What would be the best Pal Panasonic (or other brand ) model to do it with a good balance with good line tbc and ? My main tapes are mostly in a good condition and I have also a good VCR (Philips DVHS VR 20D) (I Normally disable the internal TBC to use my DMR ES10 . with my Aja Kona LHi solve all drops) Thanks for your videos and knowledge!
@analogvideochannel4612
@analogvideochannel4612 Год назад
@@srmusicomusic4279 Most PAL Panasonics with HDMI out are pretty similar afaik.
@lollo5468
@lollo5468 Год назад
Thanks, excellent comparison. I understand VC500 and GV-USB2 had no (line)TBC correction from the player, DMR-EH58 DVD has its own stabilization, and vhs-decode intrinsic TBC features. Correct?
@analogvideochannel4612
@analogvideochannel4612 Год назад
Yup, no TBC in this VCR. I have test captures from the same tape section from a HR-S8600 as well with the TBC on and some other devices.
@lollo5468
@lollo5468 Год назад
@@analogvideochannel4612 If you can upload the test, it will be interesting to compare the quality of the USB cards fed with (line) corrected signal versus vhs-decode and DVD-R recorder with no (line)TBC active in VCR
@PopcornWeasel
@PopcornWeasel 3 месяца назад
what is a good capture device for bad signal like vhs generation loss without dropping frames and gives a proper picture and does not cost an arm and a leg
@frown
@frown 11 месяцев назад
I have a powerful pc and an upper tier dvd/vcr unit. I'm currrently viewing my tapes via an arrangement of both hdmi and a lower tier usb capture card. With the tedious adjustments through OBS, I'm able to yield pretty high quality. Can you point me in the direction of a guide for obtaining the results you've shown here through decoding? What am I missing, besides the I-O Data capture dongle?? Software? Hardware? A decent grasp of coding languages?
@analogvideochannel4612
@analogvideochannel4612 11 месяцев назад
Which part specifically? I forgot to link it in the description but if you google vhs-decode you can find info on what it is, it's a bit much for a comment. The others are just direct captures using virtualdub with the respective devices (with panasonc eh58 I recorded the HDMI output from it with a hdmi capture card going via a HDMI splitter to evade HDCP) Then used avisynth to line up all the captures and used a simple deinterlacer (yadif). For an actual capture rather than a comparison I would have used a more sofisticated deinterlacer like QTGMC though. If you just want a pretty decent result on a budget without a ton of extra work, sending the video via one of certain dvd-recorders which have good video stabilizing capabilities and recording thhe direct output with a capture card is an option that can provide very good results.
@BuyThisCoin
@BuyThisCoin 8 месяцев назад
What was your hardware path for vhs-decode?
@analogvideochannel4612
@analogvideochannel4612 8 месяцев назад
Pansonic NV-SD220 VCR connected to a domesday duplicator using standard oscilloscope probes
@duncanmacleod2136
@duncanmacleod2136 6 месяцев назад
I am wondering about clipping with VHS decode. This video looks like there is a lot of clipping in it. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-pEzmbw_Y-Tw.htmlsi=arzxvpL0mpnCVX4K when you go to 15:22 and also about all of the clips in this video have clipping. I think the proc amp in my TBC 3000 would prevent those colors from being clipped but the decode people say that they can prevent clipping just as well as a proc amp because they don’t capture YUV. Can they prevent clipping as well as a Proc Amp?
@analogvideochannel4612
@analogvideochannel4612 6 месяцев назад
In this video I didn't really bother to fix the video levels as noted in the description so there may be clipping in several of the clips. The DMR-EH58 (and other panasonc dvd-recorders) do have a design flaw where they tend to clip very bright from vhs though which can't be fixed after capture (though can be worked around to a degree if you can lower the video signal level going into it.) With vhs-decode you capture the raw signal from the tape, not the decoded output so you can avoid any clipping if you want as you have full control over all of the decoding steps so you can adjust as needed. The person in that video may not have exported it to youtube that way though. The TBC-3000 has a proc amp so you can adjust the levels on it to avoid it clipping though the built in TBCs in some VCRs which you have to use since it doesn't stabilize horizontal jitter much on it's own (as seen in my followup video) do. The TBC/DNR unit in PAL JVC SVHS VCRs is one example, those do clip very bright parts, not sure if the same is true when it comes to the NTSC variant.
@duncanmacleod2136
@duncanmacleod2136 6 месяцев назад
@@analogvideochannel4612 okay cool that’s interesting. I was wondering about that with decode. Yeah I have a Panasonic 1980p ag and a pinnacle 710 but I’m just about to start putting out videos. I’m learning hybrid and figuring out some of the software side better.
Далее
I Thought My Childhood was LOST
23:24
Просмотров 1,6 млн
LD-Decode - LaserDisc Conversion Tools
22:20
Просмотров 50 тыс.
Как мы играем в игры 😂
00:20
Просмотров 169 тыс.
What Are The Best TBCs For Digitizing VHS?
40:18
Просмотров 14 тыс.
HSW adj - video & audio test (vhs-decode)
4:54
Просмотров 2,6 тыс.
INTERCEPT ANY RADIO SIGNAL!!!!
10:04
Просмотров 707 тыс.
How does a VCR work?
15:00
Просмотров 6 млн
Как мы играем в игры 😂
00:20
Просмотров 169 тыс.