Vocal Coach Reacts! BTS! Tear! Live! 

This song is a masterpiece

I agree. J Hope raps exactly as you described. He’s so unique to me.

Get's me too.

why are you spreading misinfo? All three members have writing/composing credits on this song. All of them wrote their respective verses and the main instrumental theme of this song was composed by Shin Myung-Soo. Most of ARMYS just don't read official credits at all and write whatever they have heard on social media. They think Suga wrote the whole song just because in one interview he said: "this song was written", he didn't say "I wrote it". People are really disrespectful and say lots of misleading stuff. Credits are: writing/composing: Shin Myung-Soo, DOCSKIM, Suga, RM, j-hope producing: DOCSKIM the rap line also has credits as recording engineers. In that interview Suga also talked he made melody for Outro: Tear, but he didn't tell specifically for which part of the song, and again people assumed he composed everything which is not true. As I said the main composer is Shin Myung-Soo. Earlier he made instrumental track to BTS Highlight Reel, a long piece for their Bangtan Universe storyline (a fictional storyline that has all the BTS members playing their own character). And in that instrumental piece, there is a fragment almost identical to this song, with piano notes at the start and orchestration ect. So idk why people never mention him when he is credited 1st (in order) in official credits. Anyway RM in his vlive talked about members' involvement ans said Suga's version of melody line used in chorus (and maybe a bridge part too) was chosen by the producer so that's why Suga said he made melody to this song. But for sure he didn't mean the whole song and for sure he didn't make instrumental track.

@@uvayakone9281 yes, that right

all 3 wrote it . none of the rapline rap on smth somoene else wrote

@@mono-mq2ph Exatly. There are some seldom cases in their ot7 songs though, like j-hope doesn't have credits in Anpanman or SUGA in Mic Drop , and both don't have credits in Fake Love, but in their subunit songs, the rap line always have songwriting credits at least for their rap verses, all three members.

@@uvayakone9281 im just pertaining to this ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-wFNmiUSJg4I.html thanks for the clarifications.

I can’t stop laughing at your first paragraph🤣 Facts!

100% right you are they’re incredible with words it’s ridiculous

I think what happens is that people who are not familiar with the mechanics of song production hear "So-and-so (Suga in this case) brought the song to us..." and think it means the complete song. It really means that he brought something that *became* the song -- a verse, a hook, a beat, some combination -- and then many other hands touched it, added to it, and helped shape it.

@@sarahy1680 one more reason to react and correct them, educate them. Finding excuses for their behavior and turn a blind eye when armys misinform everyone around and spread fake stuff is the worst thing you can do.

@@ninecats5814 I think there's a difference between "fake" information and "incomplete" or "misinterpreted" information. It isn't "finding excuses" to pinpoint *why* people might not understand something and thus pass it on incorrectly. Most people not knowledgeable about the mechanics of music production aren't going to hear the simple quote "Suga brought us the song" and realize that that's just the beginning of a process.

@@sarahy1680 they should never teach others about songwriting not knowing official credits. Credits are the most important and accurate source. You all are just too lazy to read them but spend hours on reading bts fanfics and checking out dating/shipper rumors. If someone is claiming that Suga wrote the whole song by his own it is not a "half truth" it is called discrediting several other people involved including two other BTS members. it is a lie.

@@ninecats5814 For heaven's sake, they're repeating a quote from the members themselves. Members who didn't then clarify how the whole songwriting process works either. This is neither discrediting nor lying. It is how normal people talk and share information. Every interaction need not be a lecture.

All of them wrote it, the rapline writes their own verses

why are you spreading misinfo? All three members have writing/composing credits on this song. All of them wrote their respective verses and the main instrumental theme of this song was composed by Shin Myung-Soo. Most of ARMYS just don't read official credits at all and write whatever they have heard on social media. They think Suga wrote the whole song just because in one interview he said: "this song was written", not "I wrote it". People are really disrespectful and say lots of misleading stuff. Credits are: writing/composing: Shin Myung-Soo, DOCSKIM, Suga, RM, j-hope producing: DOCSKIM the rap line also has credits as recording engineers. In that interview Suga also talked he made melody for Outro: Tear, but he didn't tell specifically for which part of the song, and again people assumed he composed everything which is not true. As I said the main composer is Shin Myung-Soo. Earlier he made instrumental track to BTS Highlight Reel, a long piece for their Bangtan Universe storyline (a fictional storyline that has all the BTS members playing their own character). And in that instrumental piece, there is a fragment almost identical to this song, with piano notes at the start and orchestration ect. So idk why people never mention him when he is credited 1st (in order) in official credits. Anyway RM in his vlive talked about members' involvement ans said Suga's version of melody line used in chorus (and maybe a bridge part too) was chosen by the producer so that's why Suga said he made melody to this song. But for sure he didn't mean the whole song and for sure he didn't make instrumental track

@@LynnHermione fandom is so disrespectful, always tell reactors that SUGA wrote the whole song. It's been like that since Suga's interview. They never read official credits and spread bullsh1t on social media. Never cite RM who talked so much about the writing process of this song after Tear album was released, RM always talk about all people involvement, he is thoughtful to give credits to all members and in-home producers/composers, and then two years later SUGA said some stuff about Tear, he talked only about himself (didn't mention anybody else) and suddenly he is the main and only songwriter glorified by the whole fandom. I just cant with those fakers.... they all love to teach others, new fans and reactors but are too lazy to even read official credits.