Voice Teachers React to Seventeen | Rolling Stone In My Room 

Actually, performance unit is more onto the dancing. That’s actually why this video surprised so many fans, we didn’t expect the harmonies, but we loved it so much! I felt like vocal unit, who usually do the harmonies, did a simpler song for this set of performances because performances unit prepared the complex part.

Seungkwan and his vocal teacher actually mentioned that his voice is naturally husky/breathy so he had to work really hard on his technique and find work-arounds to expand his range. While DK's instrument is naturally very clear and bright, and also a bit more agile. And Woozi and Pledis make use of these different tones to bring out a certain kind of emotion when writing songs. They often put Seungkwan on parts that are supposed to sound really cozy or really sad/defeated, and they often use DK's voice to add dynamic change to the songs because his voice just jumps out at you.

i love how the "performance unit" is literally the dance unit but they're still such good singers that singing teachers think they're the "harmonies unit"🥰

Everytime someone acknowledges DK as a vocal a rainbow appears somewhere in the world. Just letting yall know that you made someone really happy.

they're obsessed with dokyeom's voice. i mean who wouldn't because i am obsess with his voice too(and personality). and thank you for describing minghao's voice as "lovely" because he sure has a lovely voice. and performance team actually focus more on dancing and choreos but they're all good at singing. jun and mingyu's voice are always like that. like mingyu has this raspy voice which i really like and jun's always slaying falsetto but thank you for pointing that out bcs there's this chinese show that he attended where his vocal chords got damaged because he was practicing nonstop. i'm no expert in these things. anyways, thank you so much for this. 🙌🏻 more seventeen content in the future. 🤸🏻‍♂️

Ngl I giggled a bit when you guys thought Performance Unit was responsible for the harmonies of the group. It also made me proud lol specially considering how far they've come with their unit songs. In my opinion, they're the most versatile unit, with all members venturing in vocals and raps constantly and seamlessly aside from the normal dance focus. They're like wildcards, you never know what you're gonna get from those 4, specially Dino.

One fact about DK is that he is also a musical actor. He debuted as King Arthur in Xcalibur . Also, thank you for reacting again to Seventeen. I hope you'll enjoy listening to their music.

If DK watches this, he will tear up for sure. When they were trainees, DK is always the one who didn't stand out. It was always Seungkwan who the trainers always complimented when it comes to vocals. With two of them being the main vocalists of the group, it kinda hurt both of them. DK, because he feel like he's not good enough to be a main vocalist. Seungkwan, because he wanted to be complimented alongside with DK. The two of you saying that DK stands out because of his voice made me so proud of him. To be honest, he really struggled a lot, vocal-wise and confidence. Now, he sounds so confident and that makes him stand-out and sing beautifully!

23:14 Performance unit actually focuses on dancing and choreos overall but yeah their harmonies are out of this world in this video

Seventeen's Hiphop team doesn't always do rap, they have super beautiful vocals too 🥰 If you can also listen and react to "I can't runaway" from their album Attacca, that would be really lovely. 💓

I don’t know if you watch compilations, but I feel like “dokyeom live vocals that bring me back from the grave” is a video you’d thoroughly enjoy, seeing as you love DK’s voice so much!

You’ve never really mentioned Woozi in both of your Seventeen videos, but I believe he’s one of the strongest vocalists in the industry. I hope you would react to his solos Simple and What Kind of Future. He produces all of the group’s songs and tend to let DK and Seungkwan take the reins vocally on team songs but that man can make you cry with his voice. It would be interesting to hear your thoughts on his technique. You’ve also got to hear the original version of Lilili Yabbay to really understand how amazing this Rolling Stones version is. And vocal team does do harmonies. Seventeen as a whole does harmonies. There are more vocal team songs that you may find interesting like Habit and Don’t Listen in Secret. I would also recommend watching any of their band version videos. All My Love is a personal favorite.

lol, so the performance unit is actually focused on Dance, they are just multi-talented, I'm glad you liked their vocal performance and harmonizations so much!

They’re actually called performance because they’re in charge of the dancing in the group. Hoshi (performance leader) named them the ‘Performance Unit’ instead of the ‘Dance Unit’ because he wanted to prove that dancers can also sing.

Everyone loves DK, who doesn't? i mean he's almost perfect. An ace.

DK and Seungkwan’s duo and harmonies are perfect, but I think they(vocal team) kinda wanted to shine the performance team so didn’t do it here. You’ll be surprised how much performance team rearranged this song if you listen to the original version. They are incredible dancers, but also they are able to sing well.

Yes!! More Seventeen! Saw them in Chicago last week and I’m still on a high from it. They are so incredible live with amazing energy and stage presence. I’m excited for this.

performance unit is actually dance unit they are doing the choreographies for seventeen but they are very good singers as well

oh, also the breathy/husky voice in the hip-hip unit, Mingyu, *maybe* he's doing it a little bit for effect but his natural speaking voice is just this husky. like, he kind of sounds like he's hoarse/sick all the time, it's just his voice. no idea how efficient it is, but it adds a very special color to Seventeen's songs in my opinion, and lots of people love his voice as it is :)

Mingyu's husky voice is natural and that's what makes it so special, both when he talks and when he sings. Personally his vocal timbre is my favorite. 😍 In general I have a preference for deep vocals and in a group with so many high voices I find those from the hip hop unit stand out particularly, because they're rounder, warmer and more scratchy. Of course I love all of them and they are absolutley amazing 🤩

i can't believe they will react again to seventeen, i'm very happy and looking forward to this video

performance unit are dancers, not primarily vocalists!! i'm sure they contribute to harmonies but that's not their main purpose in the group, some of them are actually choreographers

So, just out of curiosity, I wonder why Wonwoo’s part was completely skipped over. Yes, it’s all rap and he doesn’t sing, but it is an integral part of the rap unit’s performance. Am I the only one that noticed this?

Performance units song Lilili Yabbay is actually completely different with amazing choreography…they focused on performance…so when Carats watched it first time they amazed with different side of them, I know that all of them can sing but with their harmonization it’s just amazing! Thanks for checking this out !!

yall don't understand.. im so glad you guys are reacting to more seventeen 😭

You are going to love this!! Not sure how much you have learned about the members and the 3 units. That is the breakdown here. It was performance that really impressed me! It was so layered and well done!! Enjoy!!

Dk really is my fav vocalist in all the kpop industry. It’s so unique and clear and his high notes are out of this world. There are some other videos out there of DK’s singing parts and god they are insane. I’d recommend you to watch it and I’m more that sure that you’ll fall more in love with him.

the way she mention dk and smiled was so cute HAHAHAHAHAA

OMG more Seventeen yes ! I'm so glad !

OH MY GOSH, thank you so much for taking the time to react to this. I always enjoy seeing Seventeen vocal appreciation, but I love hearing your reasoning and expertise, why they sound the way they do. I'm pretty new to your Channel since I was brought in by the Killing Voice reaction. Is there a specific way you guys prefer to get recommendations? Is it mainly through the comment section? I would love to recommend some other live vocal performances for you: Full group: This is an acoustic performance video of their song "All my love," the arrangement is gorgeous, and has stellar vocals: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ov3NRyoIEQ4.html Smaller group (the vocal team): A live performance of their song "Same Dream, Same Mind, Same Night" from the Vocal team ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-N7gkI9nQK48.html A live performance from their 2018 tour of the vocal unit singing their song "Habit": ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-7zKlo5UOmRM.html Individuals: Live concert performance of an individual song called "What Kind Of Future" by Woozi (the one that was crossing his arms in the killing voice): ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-9v-MOJvobPM.html A song cover from DK (your guys' favorite): ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-v3UW6oTw_ks.html A song cover From Seungkwan (your second): ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-8ChktZQ6Ir8.html I tried to keep it manageable and vocal focused. All of these are one song. I would ABSOLUTELY LOVE it if you would do another seventeen video with these if your time allows!!!

the 3rd guy on the performance team who sang the rly high falsetto actually damaged his vocal chords from overuse while on a show before this was recorded :// his name is Jun and he is actually chinese (as well as the 2nd singer Minghao who u described as lovely) and i personally think he rly shines while singing in his native language so i recommend checking some of his solo songs in chinese! ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-N-zYdjCSMWQ.html

I also feel the same way with DK’s voice. Every time he sings, it sounds like an instrument. It’s just super super clear.

Thank you for the reacting for the Rolling Stone In My Room performance! I think you got it right on Jun (the performance team whose vocal technique you were concerned over). He was singing by himself (solo) and duet in a reality show series once, where he damaged vocal chord there from singing/practicing too much. I am glad this video gave a hint on one of the possibilities why it had happened.

14:15 Mingyu's voice is kinda raspy and has natural lisps in it.. Even being a rapper he sings really too well!! (all of 'em actually)

love the way you guys point out joshua's and dk's skills because both of them are my favorite seventeen vocalists. Joshua's technique might not be the safest but it allows him to have great versatility. And dk is just doing the absolute most and not even trying

mingyu's voice does have that breathy / huskiness naturally! he sings in a few other songs, and it's always there. it's something that really drew me to mingyu as a performer in the first place! it's so addictive to listen to because it immediately catches your ear as something different

Yes! We all love DK! His voice is definitely one of a kind. Thank you for appreciating his voice. He really worked hard to be one of the best vocalist in this industry.

DK is also a musical actor, he is part of Excalibur. He really did great in the performance 🙂

PERFECT IS THE RIGHT WORD 😂😭 DK literally has the best vocal in the industry!!

I’m so happy that DK’s voice is recognized by many listeners outside their fandom and he deserves all these praises throughout his hard work and his new release FT. KAI his senior musical Arthur is so good we have to admit that he’s so talented

I was waiting for wonwoo's part to see if maybe they have something to comment on his voice but they skipped it 🥲

As a big fan of DK I highly appreciate your professional as the voice teachers to explain and point out of how his voice is amazing and I love your reaction so much you guys are best reactors the way you talk so attractive and easy to understand

I love DK’s voice so much as well! He has such a clear and powerful voice. He was actually part of a musical called Xcalibur where he played the main role of King Arthur! My favorite number of his is “What it Means to be King”

Yes DK’s voice is amazing and absolutely different the clarity and the effortless I love and obsessed with his voice so much. Thank you so much and I love how you guys explain you even have a tool to show us how incredible his voice is? You guys got my respect and my hug I love your reaction so much.

Seungkwan is my favorite, but that is definitely a preference thing - I just love the timbre. But DK is undeniably an amazing technical singer and a great performer as well. You hear just how many of them are really great singers when they aren't the main focus on vocals, this group has such a depth of talent.

I relate to you guys so much about DK....you said everything I feel about his voice

Dk is honestly so beautiful everything about him, his voice makes me emotional all the time and his personality is like the cherry on top he’s everythingg😭

19:39 I agree with the comments about Jun's singing! I thought I was the only one thinking that. It doesn't feel like his range, so I feel like it gets strained. His voice sounds a lot better when he sings in a lower range, but that's a rare occurrence. (I think some parts of this "Yakimochi" cover is an example.ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-gG63zVEnpWw.html Another one I can think of is when he sang in the GoSe rice paddy episode, really nice. That's his range!) I actually don't know why vocal professionals around him keep making him sing high parts. In fact, I feel like a lot of them are made to sing high but actually they sound better singing low notes. My guess is because they got used to that range because they debuted younger so their voices were still higher and can take it. But now that they've grown up, their voices have matured and lowered more. I really feel like there needs to be an adjustment to be made about the keys most of them sing in.

I recommend you guys watch their performance " all my love" acoustic ver, "rock with you" band ver.

I love how your eyes change when dk starts singing! It's obvious you both love him ☺️

I hope DK sees all this appreciation

So bummed Wonwoo’s verse got cut out of Trauma in your video. I was looking forward to what you’d all have to say 😢

I hope dk watches this because honestly he deserves the love 💗💎 he’s such an amazing and hardworking person. If ya’ll can’t get enough of DK, he recently sang the OST for a kdrama and the song highlights all of dk power vocals 💎✨

I love how the "performance unit" became a "harmony unit" 🤣

Love to see more people appreciating Dokyeom’s voice!

wonwoo’s verse in “trauma” is about his fear of being forgotten, so seeing his part cut out of the video with no explanation feels extremely upsetting.

8:47 : *silent* 8:49 : "DK is my favourite" SO DO IIIII:))))))))❤❤❤❤❤

I love it when professional vocal teachers react to SEVENTEEN because they can (both of you!!) identify the differences in the members' vocals and describe them accurately. I agree with everything you guys said about DK's voice, not just because I bias him, but because his voice is so impressive. I love his voice so much, it gives life to a song, and I think that's beautiful. Honestly, I'm a sucker for DK compliments when it comes to singing because not everyone appreciates his voice like the two of you did. Not everyone highlights his singing skills whenever they react to one of their videos (their singing videos), and that's fine because it's their reaction, it's what they perceive to hear and see, but not saying anything about DK (and Seungkwan) doesn't sit right to me! So thank you so much for loving DK's voice and having Seungkwan as your second favorite. They're my favorite main vocals.

It’s fun seeing you two falling harder and harder for DK. Seventeen is having tour on US so if you guys have time please consider seeing them live you’ll be blown away literally. Their live singing is 100% more fun and such an amazing experience. P.S: I see you’re trying very hard to not offend everybody, I appreciate it 🥹

Performance team is responsible for choreographies and dancing. That unit consists of some of the most talented dancers who can also sing as well as rap. Seventeen is ranked number 1 for performing their songs with 100% synchronization tested by AI. I really wish you would also see their performances either live or their MV as it only seems respectful.

Please do listen more of Jun’s vocals! He has improved so SO MUCH, and I think compared to his earlier years, he’s really done so much coaching and it was very evident in this video. As a singer, I’ve also observed his tongue problem while singing (because most of the time it blocks the air and sound from coming out, making it a bit nasal as well), but I promise he has improved A LOT. I felt so proud while watching this whole thing. 🥹🫶🏼 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-N-zYdjCSMWQ.html

I love how smitten you guys are with DK

i like it how when dk sings and they just pause it right after hearing him sing for a few seconds and then proceed to comment on how good he sounds

I really love both of you for appreciating dk’s voice / talent, a lot of fans / people don’t or can’t appreciate his talents and just focus on visual 😭 they’re singers so they should appreciate their talents not visual 😭. Visual or looks is just a bonus

Mingyu (the one who's singing in the 2nd song) even if he's part of the hip hop unit often sing in Seventeen's songs. He naturally have a breathy voice even when he's talking, he doesn't add anything ! Yes the vocals of the performance unit are no joke (last one) ! Usually, the song they performed don't sound like this at all lmao 😂 I mean, all seventeen members can sing, rap and dance perfectly in sync. Love your reaction ! Hope you will react to more Seventeen songs 😊

After hearing you guys talking about harmonies I NEED a reaction to "Habit", which is a song by Seventeen's Vocal Unit and which, for me at least, has one of their best harmonies. This song is just BEAUTIFUL and it would be very interesting for you to react to any performance of it (especially the 2018 performance of the Japan Arena Tour).

Finally DK getting the appreciation he deserves

so to simply describe all three units of seventeen: first unit - vocal team - vocals second unit - hiphop team - rap third unit - performance team - dance (that version is so different to the original one since it has a choreo) not sure if you have watched any of their performances yet but.. it's safe to say that all members can sing, rap and dance. they are amazing!!!

OH MY GOD THIS VID 😭😭 LOVE IT! I hope that in the future you will react to "Same Dream Same Mind Same Night" from seventeen's vocal unit.

DK once said that he thinks his voice is not good enough, but we all know that IT IS. Dokyeom baby you're doing so well!🥺🤍🫶🏼✨

Thank you for loving Dokyeom

Performance Unit's focus is actually the dancing.

and oh, the performance unit is more into dance, stages and choreographies, not necessarily doing everything in chorus^^ so we have vocal (singing) unit + hiphop (rap) unit + performance (dance) unit

It's so cute how Melia visibly brightens whenever DK sings/speaks XDDD I MEAN, SAME ME TOO LOL, WE ALL DO!

There are two songs that I think showcase everybody's vocals well, it's Kidult and All My Love! Here are the links to the performance versions: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-UkFmCKjPLyc.html (0:00 - 3:11) & ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ov3NRyoIEQ4.html

thank yall sm for appreciating DK's vocals❤ he deserves it

in the process of the reaction of seventeen, like you see in the video, they were divided in units, in which each person's skill fit more: - the first one is vocal unit, like the name they are more specialised in vocals - the second is the hip hop unit, which is more specialised in rapping - the last one is the performance unit, which is more specialised in dancing but they all-rounders so they each have their own role in the group, so for example the vocal can rap or dance and so on... (+) they always perform together, but some times they create sub units song or for special stages

AGAIN as a carat who bais dk your reaction videos to seventeen make me so happy and satisfied Thank you for another seventeen video 💙

@8:15 I'd love to hear more of your thoughts on Woozi's voice and techniques.... He literally wrote 99% of all their music since they were trainees till now and has won Best Producer last year, and he's been a full-time member of the Korea Music Assoc (which is hard to be a full member of) since 2019.. He basically writes the parts for the different voices of SVT and knows and supports all the different music and styles the members want to try in their music... There's practically no music genre/style he has not written and composed music in (ofc you get what I mean) and he is the most well-rounded member... He has such a beautiful voice, and would be main vocalist for any other Kpop boy group, but for SVT he happily left those titles to DK and Seungkwan, but he also does majority of the harmonizing and backup vocals for the other members (he adds his voice in during his post recording and production process).

Thank you for giving an effort to get to know them. They are really multi talented and adorable persons. Same with you two, DK is my bias because of his talent and personality. Always having a goosebumps whenever I listen to him. He's so underrated but he is one of the best vocals in kpop industry alongside with Seungkwan. Please listen to Kidult please please!!!! You will love DK even more and the whole group!

I wish DK see this video, he is so hard on himself 🥺 my baby, he deserve everything ❤❤

since yall love dk so much i recommend yall listen to kidult hehe

I think they should react to Seventeen's presentation with the song "to you" for the comeback show of attacca. The voice of dk is out of this world in that performance, also you can appreciate the voice of the other members in a better way in that performance.

To be honest, I'm so happy you guys commented on Dino's vocal techniques because I feel like he's had a lot of vocal improvements. I'm not saying the other guys aren't as good, but Dino's vocal's growth is insane! As someone who sings, I think he's one of the top singers in Seventeen, especially when performing live.

Thank u so much for all praise to their vocals especially to DK

Some more recommendation : - DK & Seungkwan : Say Yes - DK : She Doesn't Love Me (Cover) - Hip Hop Unit : I can't Run away (they sing in this song) - Performance Unit : 247 - Vocal Unit : Imperfect Love / Habit / Hug / Don't listen secretly - Seventeen : All my Love, Kidult, Together, If You leave me.

mingyu and wonwoo (hip hop unit) actually released a unit song called bittersweet featuring a singer called lee hi (who has amazing vocals). considering your comments on mingyu’s voice, it would be interesting to hear your thoughts on the song.

I love that you talk about DK.

Many people are requesting it already, and I will be one of them... Please please React to Dk's cover of "She didn't love me". The original singer Yang dal hee liked his cover so much that he asked Dk to collab with him And they even have a song collaboration , I think the title is " Cinematic love". I'm so glad, that you guys are loving Dk's voice because although us seventeen fans " Carats" appreciate the vocalists a lot, people outside of the fandom, even general kpop fans don't even mention Dk and Seungkwan when talking /discussing about Great vocalists in kpop, when both of them are some of the best singers in kpop.

17:22 Performance unit is more into dancing, imagine the shock we had when they sang this version. You guys should check out the original version of this on your spare time, you will be amazed!

i think the way jun sings has a lot of breathy voice and i think it's the way he sings (the style) that;s also why i feel like his lines are usually at the climax of the songs because it really suits well around those parts

i love how genuinely excited Melia is whenever they're reacting to Seventeen!

thank you for another seventeen reaction! if you’re still interested in reacting to them again, i’d be interested in hearing your opinions on solos by dk and seungkwan (seventeen’s main vocals). i’d suggest seungkwan’s ‘forsake’ and dokyeom’s ‘she didn’t love me’, which are both from four or five years ago so they’ve both improved since then, but i’m a little biased because they’re my favs haha :D

Dk's amazing. We can't blame you.

This couple is really into DK...well me too ☺️

I’m obsessed with DK’s voice too🥰

Performance unit is more to dancing but yeah they all got the vocals ✨

Joshua's voice when singing is also his exact voice when talking..it sounds so cool and calming and a little husky too..

I want them to listen to kidult so bad, omg, I wonder what they'd say, It's like one of the best song's of seventeen, and the vocals, especially the high note.

Was Wonwoo’s part cut out? T___T why thooo he did so great on this live