WATCH THIS before buying Callaway ROGUE irons! 

Thanks for watching the video! The first 1000 comments will be entered into a draw to win a prize! Also like the video if you have entered!

I just got these irons and I'm already in love they feel amazing on course 😍🙏

I purchased these irons last week and got them fitted. Just received them from the golf shop yesterday and had a long session in TrackMan as I live in Iceland and it´s too cold to play outside. I just love them and I´m looking forward to being able to test them on the golf course.

I rented these clubs at a course in Vegas and let me tell you it’s much harder to come home to my older less forgiving irons. I hit these Rogues so well I wish I could get a set. Can’t afford them but man did they feel good to me as a brand new golfer

Bought a set of these yesterday. Hit the 7 iron at the shop and loved thebfeel and flight of the ball. I play off 21.5 and was getting a consistent carry of 160 yards playing my first full round with them today.

Very informative, so thank you! I’m currently playing 22 and aiming to going down to 18hcp by summer and I really liked hitting the standard rogue with the graphite shaft. Very comfortable weight, good contact and very forgiving with good distance. It’s comforting you found them apt on the course, not rolling forever. They’re going for just over 400 pounds right now (5i to pw, which suits me as I’ll go with my trusted hybrid 4 or wood 5 from the tee or the fairway for longer distances). At this price, I can’t see any reason not to get them

Enjoying the revised reviewing procedure with less time spent watching range bay shots, more explanation to the GC numbers and how that relates to that particular club, and your ideas on what that club should/shouldn't do. Followed up with some on course play and overall feels. Keep up the commentary on loft strengths and gapping, I think it's important we remember that it's about hitting a distance consistently- what number club you're hitting is irrelevant.

I know this is a year late Rick, but I'm in the process of changing my irons. I've got Callaway x20's which I love, but are getting a bit worn. Your review of the rogue irons has given me food for thought. Love the vids you produce. Thank you.

Always appreciate your reviews and like that you're on the course as well as indoors. One thing you should do when reviewing clubs that are made for higher handicappers is work with several of us. I love your feedback but we all knew at then end you were not going to game these as you're simply way too good to play clubs like these. I'm not. I had rental Rogue irons and a hybrid at St. Andrews 2 weeks ago and absolutely loved them both (I've already purchased a Rogue hybrid...if you're hybrid shopping people, give the Rogue a try on the course). I found the Rogue irons easy to hit and longer than my TM M2's and as a higher handicap player I would give them consideration if I was in the market for irons.

Loved the shots of seeing the 7 irons coming into the green. No other club reviewer has done this. Super helpful to see how the balls stick/don’t stick green, especially with these stronger, lower lofted clubs. Thanks Rick

Love the reviews! The rogue irons seem very appealing to me after your review. I’m picking up the game of golf as I’m finishing up my college tennis career and have fell in love with the game. Do you guys think I could play with these? My score has been dropping a lot over the past few months and I’m using a set of clubs from goodwill 😂

Again great full reviews. Absolutely love these. Best club reviews on RU-vid right now

Your new club reviews are so much more informative. Love the fact that you get the clubs on course and play a few holes and different types of shots with them. Keep the good content coming Rick.

This video was so helpful! I watch all your content anyway but going back to find this helped me decide to buy these irons! Thanks rick!

Great review format Rick. Glad to see you are discussing price now. Not always relevant but Rogue vs Epic seems a perfect example of where price is a serious factor.

Thanks Rick. As usual you provide helpful food for thought. I'm in the market for a set of game improvement irons with the Callaway Rogue X high on the list as well as the current Callaway Big Bertha. I have a testing session booked with my local AG so am interested which I feel most comfortable with. Just to confuse matters, Titliest AP1 is on my list as well.

Thaks for video, I just decided to finally replace my 20 yr old pIng Blue dots and I went to a Callaway fitting. Hit these Rogues very well. I Ordered a 6iron thru PW, with a 4, wood and 5 hybrid. I did not use my old 3-5 irons very much other than punch and runs or from a tee so it will be interesting to see how I play this set up on the course. I also ordered an approach and sand wedge. I stll intend on carrying my old steel shafted Nike 3w and will compare that to the 4w at the range to see if it is still worth carrying around.

Another great review Rick! Really appreciate your candid feedback and the how you marry the indoor data with actual on course playability. Looks like Callaway nerds to clarify their marketing strategy with how they are positioning Epic vs. Rogue. Appears that the story on Rogue is value vs. premium for the Epic line for irons, though it is not that ckear on the driver side.

I’m newer to golf and this review was educational and understandable. Really appreciate the review and the comparison..

Thanks man been using the same set of irons my whole life looking to finally buy some new ones these really help

Hey Rick, Thanks for all the awesome videos !!!! Love the new version of reviews.

Big fan of Rick Shields review. Always very informative and my go to place before purchasing clubs.

Another great review! Kinda wishing manufacturers would start labeling irons with just lofts - the standard numbering is getting a vague as they all chase perceived distance

This model of Rogue is a terrific golf club. The feel and sound are solid and workable. Nicest clubs I've ever owned.

Great video as always but you never mentioned what shafts are installed on the irons. I have noticed in my own testing a huge difference between say a True Temper Dynamic Gold X100 to a KBS Tour 105 X.

I love the way you tell it as it is. No crawling around manufacturers. Great review. How many pensioners would be prepared to pay out the prices being asked ?.

Just picked up the callaway apex blacks today! So pumped to have new irons in the bag! I considered the rogues, but I already had taylormade clubs with similar feel and lofts. Already in love with the smaller look of the apex clubs.

I really like this review format, gives a lot more information in decision making of what to try.

Just got my set of these in. First properly fitted set ever, and that’s just a revelation. These are good clubs. Similar to the Ping G400. Great performance on toe missed. Honestly, they’re basically just the steelhead XRs with a new paint job. The urethane doesn’t improve the feel at all from the steelheads, but they are definitely somewhat quieter than the steelheads or ping gs, though they’re still a louder club. Good club for me as a high mid handicapper, would recommend

Rogue Pro irons are working out great for me, great look and feel. Very long and stop well on the greens.

Rick, I’m a mid to high handicapped so sounds like these are up my alley. I hit them in a simulator and they feel really comfortable. I’m only curious about one thing: are these improved over the XR OS? The price difference for a set is only $100. Thanks

Loving the Full Review approach! Very helpful. It's not hard to imagine that in the future the "speak" on the course will be what loft did you hit, not what #.

I have recently taken delivery of a set of these irons and for me they are absolutely outstanding. Just shows that it is all down to personal preference.

Always impressed how the quality of this channel continues to improve. And as always, content that I thoroughly enjoy!

Thanks for your content as a guy who doesnt have a golf coach u provide a lot of help to my game!

Thanks for the great review Rick, I will continue playing my steelhead XR irons.

Love the review style and the amount of work your putting in is impressive! Not a fan of the Click bait title though lol

Thank you Rick I enjoyed your review of the Rogue Irons, I followed your advice as I am coming back to golf after a long lay off and tested these and others at a fitting session. There were clubs I tried that felt wonderful to hit but I either struggled with accuracy for where I am at the moment or I struggled to get one or two airborne, the best were certainly the Mizuno JPX919 for feel but they were, in my current circumstance just pipped by the Callaway Rogue. Not only could I get very good accuracy from them they were the longest for my swing speed (80 - 84 mph) and I got enough feedback to tell me whether I had hit them Toe, heel bottom or center. They are away having some adjustments made to the lie angle, I should have them soon and I can't wait to get out there and play again... Love your content, keep up the good work... Many Thanks

Always love to watch your reviews. Keep it up Rick!

I absolutely love the new style of review videos!!! I’m curious to see the Rogue Pro review, so keep up the great work!

Thanks for all the great club reviews. Love watching them!

Nice informative video, however you said that in your opinion these clubs are for mid to high handicapper. My concern is that you swing the 7 iron at 90+mph and get the hight to stop on the green with the lower spin. Do you think this would be the case for your average club golfer who swings the club at 70mph?

Great video as always! I’ve just had my first fitting for a set of irons. I’ve got the Titleist AP3 on order. Would love to see a video of you comparing these to some other similar irons!

Those are the actual clubs I'm looking to put in my bag. Thanks for the very detailed review !

Enjoying the new review style, Rick. On the fence about purchasing new sticks this year; I'm appreciating all the recent reviews based on your findings, including this one. Great stuff!

144 yards with a pitching wedge? I only hit the pitching wedge like 90 yards, that is discouraging, like feels defeating. Maybe I should give this up.

Great review as always Shielsy. It drives me crazy that the gap between the Pitching Wedge and my 52 is so large. But these are amazing looking clubs.

I was fit into these a year ago, hit a bunch of different irons, a LOT, and they fit me better than even the Rogue Pros, and all of the Taylormades ( even though i like TM a lot ). C130 tapers in there and now I just need to fix the rest of my game :)

Love the level of detail provided in the review. Thanks Rick.

I just tried the 7 iron at PGA Superstore. Very forgiving, nice look at address and lighter than my XR irons. I like it!

Interesting to hear about the difference between the rogue and epic finish. I would have expected the same since it seems to be a replacement of the epic, but now I think the rogue is just a taylormade-like "m2 to the m1" kind of marketing stance from Callaway.

Great vid & analysis. Don't think I can take my Apex Pro's out of the bag for these, but interested to see your vid on the Rogue Pros!

just tested out a few of the rogue irons. absolutely fell in love! too bad i cant afford them lol

buddy of mine just got a set and he loves them. he's really been hitting them well.

Rick, help! I’m a mid handicapper. Typically shoot in the 80’s. I know I need to test swing both clubs, but would you recommend the Callaway Rogue Irons (or Rogue X) OR the Taylormade M4’s!?

Great video Rick! I have theses clubs and in short they are Power bats!!! And currently working very well for me!

Excellent review Mr. Shiels, loving the new format. Keep up the good work.

Love this way of reviewing clubs mate. Very thorough

Rick, what do you think about Callaway Rogue #3 Iron? I'm evaluate to buy instead of Woods.

Hey Rick you’ve released this review about 10 days too late. I’ve just had a fitting with my pro and after trailing them for 2 full rounds during comps, I’ve committed to buy then. After all during my first round I ended up with 47 points and won the comp. I reckon you’re right these suit a player like me high handicapper. I found these suited me better than the AP1’s and very close to the G400’s. Looking forward to your next review on the rogue X. What would be nice would be having a player say mid to high handicapper giving these game improvement clubs a go. What are the chances?

Just got my Rogue irons. After two rounds, I agree with Rick's assesment. The feel of these clubs is good, not great but they do perform well.

Hi Rick, great review I've had the same set of clubs for the past 29 years ( Mizuno Faldo id) I still play well with them but I now find that I not getting the same distance as I use too from them. Probably to do more with me getting older and swing speed a bit slower then the club I play off 13 handicap and wondered, do you think these new Calaway clubs could help me gain the yardage and still control of the ball.

Nice review. Just what you need when looking at new clubs. Thanks Rick. I would be interested to know how do the stats of the rogue compare to your ‘normal’ stats. When is the next Rick Shiels v Me and My Golf challenge happening?

Always appreciate the honest reviews Rick. Cheers!

Love the new style of videos rick!!😄👏🏻

Biggest point made is the gaping issue in the short irons! Still a very good product but something that absolutely needs testing prior to purchase. Good job Rick!

Excellent review Rick. Question, when will you be doing a full review of the Ping G700?

Hi Rick, I had a hit of the Rogue Pro irons a couple of weeks ago on a demo day. I really loved the flight and the feel. How long before you have that review out? I’ll also be testing Mizuno irons this coming week on another demo day. Would love to know your preference?

Would love, love, love to see a comparison of old Hawkeye vft irons head to head vs Rougue

Good review Rick as always; I shan't be looking to buy or try these clubs but always like hearing your views and thoughts. Have to say the Epic irons look so much better than the Rogues; the Rogues' pricing is quite frankly crazy in my opinion. Cheers!

My steelhead xr pros are phenomenal. I’ve always loved the steelhead family of clubs.

It nice to see a honest club reveiw thanks Rick

Great video! Thanks for always giving us honest reviews and great course vlogs

Great review Rick, interesting whether your average club golfer (with their swing speed) would get the same height on shots, and so stopping power on the greens. Even at the cheaper price point these clubs are still too expensive for your average golfer, and really do nothing Ben Ross type R's didn't do a few years back with their low spin, low loft clubs.

Nice vid Rick. I do like the mix of range and course testing. Got some custom fit XR Steelheads last November which now seem out dated after 4 months!

Great video, really liking the new format of your testing videos.

I really like the review format. Lot of time taken to give as much feedback as possible.

Loving your new approach to reviews...keep up the great work Shielzy

Rick... or anyone that can answer this for me? Quick two part question regarding loft. 1. Tour pros use a “standard” loft setting?!?! I say they customize their lofts as well as lie, shaft etc?!?! 2. If you like the iron and you don’t want the strong loft, just have the clubs set to a more traditional/standard loft? I understand a cast iron is going to be more difficult to adjust, but I also know it can be done. Thoughts... please and thanks?

Just love all you're review Rick! Good work

Good balanced video. If I could hit the ball as far as you, Rick, I would stick to 'traditional' lofts. As with most seniors, longer, stronger irons would help me reach more greens in regulation (assuming I don't duff it). Having played with some forged McGregor irons in the past, I would agree they feel much nicer when you hit the sweet spot.

Great info Rick...Keep up the awesome testing to further peoples game.

I am only looking to play a 5, 7, and 9 irons. I just can't decide between the sim2 max OS or do I save a couple bucks and go with the Callaway Rogue. my current irons are the 2004 Big Bertha's which is the first and only irons I have ever owned/played. any feedback??

Rick, In your opinion, what is the best iron in this class? Thanks!

Thanks Rick, really enjoying the detailed reviews that you are doing, top class ,👍👍🍺

Great comprehensive review Rick. Loving the new format!

Great stuff again rick! One tip, it’s urethane not utherane 😊

Another great video Rick got to ask how do they compare with the Xr or the steel head no way I can afford new clubs but I enjoyed the xr and can’t wait for you and finch to get back out on the course

Wilson C300 and D300 are longer and have better feel then Rogue. Try it, it will save you some money. Wilson Staff came with utherane Slot before Callaway and Taylormade . Thank you Rick for reviews.

How workable and consistent are they? It would be nice to hit low trajectory high spin shots in windy conditions.

Great review Rick. Like the different club carry distance summary

Is there a significant difference between the original Callaway Rogue and Rogue ST Max? If so, what's the biggest difference?

Really good review and very useful comparison with the Epic irons.

Great vid as always Rick! When does the third second hand video come out?

I’ve been seeing things regarding club head speed that imply that these “hotter” irons can only get the the ball height you’d expect from a 7 iron with faster club head speeds. Would the golfer who needs the kind of distance gains these offer get the performance with average club head speeds?

Thanks for the review... really appreciate the clear review and thoughts

For me the title of the video is ok. It is just that it seems a bit cklickbaity. But it is not missundunderstandig.

Great video Rick... I`ve had my clubs for over 20 years and now feel the need to upgrade to clubs made with metal shafts instead of wood... LOL I love the look of the Rogue irons and 4 years down the line I think they will be a great replacement price wise (golfbidder) for my style of golf (Which is Shit) I`m probably a mid to late 20`s handicap old money. On my best round I`ve dropped into the 80`s though usually into the low 90`s or another brand or product you could suggest would be very much appreciated.

You like Rogue for. A 15 HC that needs help with loft and distance? Playing X22s right now.

Good review, club looks nice not to sure about having that much offset.