WE NEED AN MV (ASTRO 아스트로 - 붙잡았어야 해(Again) DANCE PRACTICE Reaction) 

also the reason we don't have an mv is because the company was trying to stick to a really cute vibe for them and the mv was too mature so they just switched to know mv and called the winter album a "special album" and moved on. It sucks

They won their first win with All night. This is the second one

Mj and jinjin are the shortest members and are CONSTANTLY teased for it lol

So, so true, this one really does deserve to have an MV - it would be devastating! And they really incredibly smooth and controlled, graceful dancers, they were then and they still are now.

It’s on Spotify!!! But it’s under the title “SHOULD’VE HELD ON”

This dance is freaking awesome and your reaction was perfect! They are so talented! Love them! Stan Astro!

Yes, MJ is the second shortest in Astro. We have Astor Toll(Moonbin, Eunwoo and Sanha), and Astro Smol(JinJin, Rocky and MJ) 😂😂😂😂

their formation and synchronization .... *ooofffff* hits hard

Thank you for this reaction! More reaction for ASTRO Vids please:)

ASTRO is the best 💜

3:42 "Quiet with your footsteps" LOL😂 You Should *React To The KNOCK Dance Practice* It Was Literally An *Earthquake* 😂

This is one of the coolest dance of astro. I swear.

All the Astro’s songs are great 👍

Thank you very much Dev and Ben😁😁😁😁

still so sad we don't have an mv for this :(

Really love your reaction and the way you called their names!!😍😍

We love your reacts to ASTRO

Honestly love tge fact that you really dig up info. Thumbs up!

Thank you so much ben for reacting and dev for sponsoring. Hope this will helps to brings some exposure to astro ❤

This song is like an enigma. It’s out there to be seen but so mysterious at the same time Side note, did you mean to leave in the first intro? Just curious lolol

Yas, an ASTRO reaction

thank you dev!

Yea, it's our 2nd win, but #KNOCK1stwin Thank you so much♡ you know our boys cried so much~ they are so happy!! They are Dance Kings! And you know Rocky is incharge of most of the Choreo

Thankyou dev for requesting astro's content! Love u💙

I just stopped reacting to video and was going to close ut then ur video came out of nowhere😂 i can’t ignore ur reaction to ASTRO💖 I love all it reaction to ASTRO💝

this is one of my favourite astro songs solely because of the sheer emotion and vulnerability expressed in both the song and the dancing. Glad that you reacted to it! I'd love to see more astro content on your account!!

Ben! Thanks for the Astro reaction's video as always. And please react to When You Call My Name performance by Astro also! You'll see Astro in a cute dance and cute look. You'll love them! You have my word 💜

knock first win!

Oooh thank you so much ☺️ for the reaction proud to that handsome boys

Astro are so good!! Also you DEFINITELY have to watch Pentagon’s send-off stage for Jinho that premiered on RTK earlier, it’s heartbreaking, I love them sm.

I love them all but Rocky has my heart. He is such a cutie🤗

I LOVE WHEN YOU REACT TO ASTRO!!!!!

fiNalllY

when you said Jinjin is precious, i felt that,,,

The song is such a masterpiece👀💜

Yes this is what im waiting for

wow, im happy that a win bring some recognitiion to our boys! lets keep fighting aroha

Thank you Dev.. Thank you for reacting.. This is my 2nd fave ASTRO song.. I love the lyrics and the song really is amazing, plus the dance moves.. Wow.. Too bad they did not promote this song and there's no MV for it.. I don't know, maybe we should ask Fantagio to release an MV..

This will remain my forever fav astro dance practice......

Yeah! Finally!

Pls react knock and when you call my name dance practice you will amazed too, 😘😘😘 thank you!!

FanMu has an MV hidden in a vault. Also, 2nd win of all time! We're really excited. We got 2nd on MCountdown, too, and even OMG were surprised.

One of my fav Astro song and wish there was a music vid to it but choreography is so good

Omg....thank you so much for this reaction...we missed the boys, 1 week already.. this video made me felt better...love your reaction as usual...PEACE OUT, ONE LOVE..GoD BLESS

at the time moobin was the tallest now it's sanha if I remember correctly

😂😂lol, MJ short Jinjin is the shortest And sanha is the tallest

i love these boyssss

I really love your reaction!! Thank you for your video 💜💜 and that "low the volume" LMAOOO it is to be expected from them to scream at the end of the video 😂😂 and yeah! Its their second win!!

Dev my twitter moot ! i love him so much ! every time Ben says 'this one was requested by Dev' I GET SO HAPPY

It was from a special mini album, that might be the reason why we didn't have mv for that song

Sanha is currently the tallest, followed by Eunwoo and Moonbin, but at the time this video was made Eunwoo might have been the tallest. Baby Sanha hit a growth spurt and kind of became a giant during "All Night" era.

Yeah, it's impossible to not love them :") I remember the day I became their loyal fans is bc of this video...

Fantagio Music (FanMu) sent out an official statement about the MV of Again (Should’ve Held On). This song was the last part of the Season Series that Astro was promoting. With their previous 3 albums being “cute” (officially refreshing) concept, FanMu said that this music video did not match their concept at the time and felt that they shouldn’t release that MV. The MV was completed and edited. To this day Arohas are waiting for it to be released from the files of FanMu.

Thanks 🙏🏻

We all are still waiting for the mv

Thank you

One of the many amazing things about Astro choreo is that they have formations that make it seem like everyone is about the same height. They really do a great job with perception and it shows because many people are surprised by the height difference when they aren't dancing.

I remember waiting for the MV to drop and the fantagio saying something along the lines of "after editing we came to the conclusion that the MV was not of the best quality and we will not be posting it" thats why we had no MV. They said that they didn't like how it came out in terms of quality and therefore decided not to release it. I saw the comments saying it was because of the concept but i don't remember them mentioning anything like that on their official statement. Anyways thank u for the reaction! 💜💜🥺 and yes it was Astro's 2nd All time win but 1st win for knock 💜💜 im so proud of them

My FAVORITE song of theirs (Always You a close second.) I was so upset it never got an MV.

mj

Omg why I didn't know that you have a reaction for this also 😍

I cried with them. It really sends joy to see them crying with happy tears. 😭😍

THANK YOU DEV IM PRETTY SURE WE’RE MOOTS ON TWT IDK BUT THANK YOU BLESS THIS MADE MY DAYYYYY

also wow thank you Ben, it always makes me so happy when you react to Astro! 🥺💜 I don’t know if you saw the video of them getting their win for Knock but if you haven’t you should because I reckon it would totally make you cry aodjhdjdk

Deb, I LOVE YOU! 💜

PogChamp

Oh my god I was waiting for this!!! ♡♡♡♡

I read somewhere that they actually film an MV for this song, but fanmu is not satisfied with it, so they decided not to release it

In 2017 Jin Jin grew another 1 cm which made him the same as MJ - 175 cm 5' 9". He took it as a matter of fact that Aroha knew that at the time. The others joked about his growing plates when he mentioned it. Which one looks taller may depend on what kind of insoles and/or shoes they're wearing. I twigged today that many of NCT are the same height as our shawties but they don't have a giant maknae and 2 other tall timbers. I think only 1 is 6'. Not up with NCT but I know that Ten is shortest at 5' 7" 170 cm I believe. I thought they'd all grow taller. Their heights seemed uniform to me while watching an M/V so looked them up at the time. MJ & Jin Jin would fit right in. Maybe at a fanmeet Astro should have a shoeless measure up - fans guess their heights I like Astro's choreo in it's entirety so much but in Again especially there are many parts that are aaaah moments. Very satisfying, Thx for this rxn. Your hair? You froze the frame on Rocky's sea urchin look.

Ben you gotta react to 'when you call my name' stage performance.

With you astro please❤️

Ben your reactions are precious, I am hooked🙏💜

Thank you for you reaction to Astro !! Yes all those sleepless nights just to see Astro ugly crying from happiness on stage !! Worth it ! I don't know if you already saw but, you should watch Astro knock 1st win video, too much emotions !!!

This is my fav dance practice of theirs. Thank you for reacting!

2:19 i thought you said Sana !! Bro Twice are in my head 24/7😂😂 it shows how much i love them

Very happy for Astro and Aroha!!! ♡ and yes, this needs an MV. One of their best songs~

Thank you for reaction ASTRO.. please reaction other song of astro again

All night : i only know eunwoo & moonbin Blue flame : only know eunwoo & moonbin,other members names i know but confused which one they are Knock : Now i know the name of the members 😅

Thank you for always supporting them!! I always love your reaction. 🥰

Yeah 2nd win

i'm so happy about their second win,they deserve it so much

MJ's high note is higher than his height..haha..but Jinjin is the shortest. Mj and Jinjin are always argueing who's the shortest until now actually.

ASTRO

It is on Spotify!

OMOOO! THAT WAS ONE OF THE BEST SONG AND CHOREO OF ASTRO💖💖 THANK YOUUU!!!

Please react to “when you call my name” live show.

Ben & Dev, thank you so muuuuuch for this. ❤️ Please do You & Me next. We need major uwu reactions from Ben. 😂

queen should've held on deserves the world 😔✌🏻

Dev, react when you call my name stage... Every stage.. Hahaahaha You will love it...

Yes, Sanha, Moonbin, & Eunwoo are in the tall line, Sanha being the tallest overall. Rn JinJin is actually the shortest, but I think MJ was shorter then JinJin for a bit. And yes, it was their 2nd win overall, but this win was more emotional then their first

Have you seen Astro's Knock Dance practice? You should react to it, its awesome. As always looking forward to your reaction. Thankyou for this

This song is one of my favorites ❤️

@deacs I have read about a rumor that an MV was actually shot, and remains buried in a vault in Fantagio. Such a wasted opportunity that they decided not to invest in this fantastic song.

Please reaction to astro dance practice - baby and knock 🙏🙏🙏

Thanks for this video! SANHA is the tallest and. JINJIN is the shortest hihihi

Jinjin precious yes he's😅😅

please look and reaction to the appearance of the Pentagon in "road to kingdom "

Thank you very much for reacting to this beautiful song, I recommend that you see innoccent love live since here you can see the great singers who are. (sorry i'm not very good at english)

Tallest to shortest is Sanha (he outgrew Eun-Woo), Eun-Woo, Moonbin, Rocky, MJ and JinJin respectively. 🥰

sanha a whole giant at 1.84 m, eunwoo and moonbin, rocky and then mj and jinjin are the shortest