I watched this video 4 years ago and thought "Wow this is different. Such a strange and unusual understanding of faith. I think I still disagree with it." Now I'm just crying thinking about how much it makes sense to me, how true it all is. I don't want to pick and choose what I believe, but I have to just live this contradictory life. I have no choice. This is my test from Allah.
@@lanabanana9583there’s a lot of love in it. It’s a religion of peace 🎉 You came to fight people in the comments I think you just need to love yourself a little more
" so you don't have to leave a part of yourself at the door" I was a Christian but renounced my faith. I had to pause this video when he spoke this sentence. To summarize the abuse in such a simple sentence. So many conversations where i was playing a role i wasnt. I understand the need for actors to have mental health, and how it truly is a job.
Remember, we are not Allah. We cannot judge one another in the same way Allah does. It is not our place nor responsibility. We have to be good to one another regardless. Being kind does not jeopardize your place in heaven. Being bad to one another for this only reason will. Remember that, we have to be good to one another.
Yes my brother but we also have to provide knowledge when it is obvious. The Prophet SAW made it clear that innovation of the deen is a major sin and all innovation will end up in the fire. As a Muslim we all want the best for our dear brothers and sisters, so sometimes the truth needs to be told instead of being yes men.
Right there where you say how we see God merciful, all understanding, all knowing, loving, etc how then is he thought limited to loving some type of people. It doesn't add up
I am totally against targeting viloence against LGBT but the description of LGBT as sinners is very clear in Quran. Whatever this guy here is promoting this is a new religion.
Stan Ethereal Figures If allah didn’t make us witnesses to our own sin, we would say that allah is lying and is unjust However, the fact that we live our lives and see what we do,he makes us witnesses to ourselves on the day of judgement
Asalamu alikum brothers and sisters. A muslim is one who submits their will to Allah, we are all sinners and no matter how much we try, we will always be. Some are better in character and deeds than others. They are people, people aren't haram. They should always have a place in islam and any masjid. It's wrong to show your sins. Although we as muslims shouldn't tear people down with our words, try to give them dawah and encouragement to submit their will to Allah for the sake of Allah and their deen/akhira in the way our beloved prophet (PBUH) did. We don't know how much these people are battling so just be kind while spreading the word of Allah. Shukran brothers and sisters. Edit: I’m not justifying his actions by the way, we must know and understand that it is undoubtedly haraam. Being angry for the sake of Allah is what we should be. What I’m saying is: Is our reaction in line with the Qur’an and the sunnah?
"...Today I have perfected your faith for you, completed My favour upon you, and chosen Islam as your way. But whoever is compelled by extreme hunger-not intending to sin-then surely Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful." Chapter 5: verse 3 (last part of the verse) Emphasis on "perfected your faith" So basically it is perfect, not to be changed or added to nor subtracted from. No room for progressiveness or modernising or any of that. Now next "Indeed, you approach men with desire, instead of women. Rather, you are a transgressing people." Chapter 7: verse 81 These 2 verse are enough to convince anyone with doubts about ANY wiggle room for homosexuality in Islam. May Allah have mercy on us all.
@@halfvolley11 ‘If God has taken love out of your heart, there’s nothing I can do for you’ - Hadith Get your law interpretations out of my face and work on your nafs.
@A Lee El-Farouk Khaki is my brother in Islam and I’m warning him because it’s my obligation to look out for my brothers and sisters. Nevertheless, it needs to be clear that anyone who tries to mold our perfect religion will end up breaking their fingers trying.
@@NurulPuteriAisya lots of things are haram and halal, but it is not our thing to label them, in the end, it’s about person’s personal relationship with Allah. Commenting on that is making ‘As-salamu alaykum’ ‘Al-haramu alaykum’, if you know what I mean…
Not the best lecture at all. The speaker did not give any Islamic sources that support his claims. The "Mukhannathun" he mentioned is a term that was referred to effminite men usually in the arts of singing, dancing, and entertainment. He did expound on this when mentioning and there's no foot note or sources shared to further fact check it. Books and quotes mentioned by some writers and poets is mere opinion and not resources we can depend on for theological and logical arguments.
Mukhannathun aren't even that, they were actually eunuchs, so it makes sense why there was a ruling that they were allowed around the women because they didn't have their private parts
@@ami.crafts.and.charms It exists and still, it's condemned through Lut's story, the Zina verse, and the surah verses. Also, give out the verse that says intersex people exists in islam.
“To insinuate that the majority, if not entirety, of Islamic scholarship was misguided and that we only realized wassup in the 21st century, is a claim that any sincere soul will see the fault in. “
This is a beautiful, intellectual approach to the problem of incorprating religious values into contemporary life. It's incredibly refreshing to me as a person inundated by and disgusted with the evangelical nationalism currently sweeping the USA.
“You lustfully go towards men, instead of women! In fact, you have transgressed the limits.” Quran(7:81) Shame on such people who go against Qur'an for their own desires.
@George ᚨᛊᚲᛖᛚᚨᛞᛞ Or they could stay single for life worshipping Allah ﷻ just as he pretended to be so religious that he mentioned a verse before starting his nuisance.
"Indeed, you approach men with lust, INSTEAD of women"- Quruan 7:81. Doing acts of homosexuality is not allowed in islam. We can't change the laws of islam. If we could, what is the purpose of following islam in the first place?
@@natancardoso8051 It wasn't my intention to judge anyone.Please understand. All I am saying is, homosexuality is a sin in islam and if a person follows islam that person should not try to justify that sin. I was only trying to clear a misconception.
Ma Man, I just Choked from how amazing it is to read something like this from a person with Septimus prime on avatar. Thank you so much for making me smile
To those in this comment section confused about your orientation and at a loss listen, If your sole purpose is to serve Allah you will know, he knows you better than you yourself. These feelings you may have are a test from Allah swt, thoughts are *not* *SIN* but *ACTIONS* are *sins*. Control ur urges and your desires, this is your jihad. Your reward will be equal. May Allah swt guide us all and forgive us Ameen. You can be a good Muslim, you do not have to condone or celebrate ur sins!!! You must work on other things to better yourself and not obsess over this one aspect of your life Brothers and sisters if I have made any mistakes may Allah SWT forgive me, Allah knows best. Please feel free to let me know if I have made any mistakes by your account brothers and sisters. Jkz
@@applesauce6166 Being queer is not a sin, since it's not your choice, *acting* on your feelings is haram. It is a big test from Allah, to see if you either choose to act upon it or choose the halal way and accept the fact that you are not allowed to act on your feelings. I am pansexual and I'm a muslim, but I don't date girls (neither guys, since dating is haram anyway), so, I'm fine. I'm not doing anything haram because it wasn't my choice, I didn't choose to be pan, but dating/marrying a woman is definitely my choice, and I choose not to. Many muslims say that *being* queer is haram, but you cannot be punished for something you have no control over, I have no control over my feelings, but over my actions? Yes, I can control those. Those muslims usually are straight muslims, they don't know what it's like to be queer, but I do and I know that I cannot control it.
Wow ! Great presentation ! I love that he acknowledge the first people's (indigenous peoples ) of Turtle island. I'm Native American woman and I read the Quran.
If lgbtq isn't forbidden in islam..then being mushrik isn't forbidden too? Or is there a law that written in QURAN about you can marry the same gender now.. bible has their new testament..now QURAN has new chapters and verses too? I dont want to judge lgbtq community but if u know it isnt anywhere in QURAN and SUNNAH.. why bother so hard to twist it? Your sins only ALLAH should judge ..but you shouldn't follow your ego by twisting the words of ALLAH. i shouldn't speak or tell lgbtq to leave islam but this is too much for misleading other Muslims..astaghfirullah hal 'adzim
Lol, you said "I don't want to judge..." but clearly mentioning "..this is too much for misleading other Muslims" as if the lgbtq Muslims are doing harm to others. As if by saying "too much" in this context doesn't mean being judgmental 🤣🤣. Now don't even come at me being a linguistic student. Sadar nggak, ironis sekali perkataanmu tu💅
@@Yuqideqiko what she meant do whatever you want to, but do not twist the ideologies of Islam to fit your own desires. Do not sin and call it halal. Do what you want, because in the end ALLAH WILL JUDGE YOU, but do not do the wrong things and say it is right. THAT is misleading.
Afiza, they just don't know their religion and want to change it, as Christians did it. But there are less than 0,000001% of such muslims. Don't worry and keep your religion, educate your kids in right way. There were communist "muslims", capitalist "muslims", nationalist "muslims", modern "muslims" and know we learn and see how they tried to destroy ummah. Salam from Russia
@@841-zainabshanafarook7 you're clearly missing out my point here. I was only criticizing what she said is contradicted with what her initial intention supposed to be. I didn't give any implication that lgbt is wrong or right??
@@Yuqideqiko lol in Islam, the existence of LGBTQA+ is not a sin. Them ACTING on their desires is. What she means is, she will not personally condemn anyone for their actions, because at the end of the day, no one else has to live with it but them, but she will if they do Harami business and call it halal. THAT is misleading for those who want to learn about the true Islam. Technically, what she said is not self contradicting at all. The way she said it made it confusing ig. She is not telling to stop what you are doing. She is telling that people should stop twisting the existing rules to fit their ideologies. No one's stopping them from leaving the religion. It is more convenient for both parties that way.
Since he's so into quoting Sahi Bukhari, i thought I'll share some bukhari hadiths too. Narrated Abdullah ibn Abbas: The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: If you find anyone doing as Lot’s people did(lusting after men, mentioned in Quran) k*ll the one who does it, and the one to whom it is done. Narrated Jabir ibn Abdullah: Allah’s Messenger (peace be upon him) said, “The thing I fear most for my people is what Lot’s people did.” Tirmidhi and Ibn Majah transmitted it. 🤷🏻♀️
@@katiem.3109 don’t even need to go to sahih al-bukhari for this. It’s in the Quran (7:81) : “You lust after men instead of women! You are certainly transgressors” It’s clearly in the Quran and no verse is weak so take that argument somewhere else.
@@electro639 don’t even need to go to sahih al-bukhari for this. It’s in the Quran (7:81) : “You lust after men instead of women! You are certainly transgressors” I guess you need to go back to kindergarten 😂
The story of Lut has long been debunked as being about homosexuality. In the Bible, the book of Ezekiel clarifies why the people of Lut were destroyed. Peel the laters back and allow yourself to read deeper.
@@muhammadsiddiqmuhiddinov1590 PLEASEE YES THERES THIS GACHA KID IM ARGUING WITH WHO CLAIMS TO BE MUSLIM AND QUEER AND THEY SENT THIS VIDEO AS REFERENCE.
We ain't suppose to struggle on things that God has created on and in us. Live fully that way cause none should struggle anything that has already there.
The beauty about religion is that its consistency about morality. so even tomorrow if a guy want to sleep with his dad or with his mom and the west accepted it, we won't twist the Quran clear teachings for it
@@IO-bs9st We judge their outwardly sins and deeds, and leave their inner ones to Allah. This has been coined by the Rashidun Caliph Umar, one of the rightly-guided successors to the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Also, how would I know that if I'd advise them and judge them by what sins they commit and how they do them?
when i c muslim give talk in this channel they always seems misleading n have opinion themself not from al-quran n hadith sahith word regarding the topic. if tex is really want to know muslim rules invite ulama cuz they are the professors like pope the professors regarding bible.
Seeing as how LGBTQ has been around since the beginning of time... And described in the quran over 1,000 years ago... Seems like you'll still be waiting a while for that end, honey. And I'm a straight muslim girl.... But lots of things in islam don't add up. I will openly admit that half of my religion is B.S.
Thanks for advocating for the voiceless and the discriminated. Your information is loud and clear and i hope it reaches far corners of the world where this topic is unheard or untold of.
@Rafael Schneider What verse and what chapter? In Islam, Christianity, and Judaism, you are taught to judge the wrongdoer by what they do, and tell them right from wrong. We advise others in the best way we can. Judgement on people who do wrong against religion is not bad.
Thank you El-Farouk. I've always admired your wit and eloquence. May Allah bless you and keep you safe. Do continue the beautiful work in the ways and spaces you find yourself doing it.
@@gamingdespair Open to sin. All you think is about opening up yet you regret it. People don't have to agree with you. Why kind of person are you that any wind can carry you. Don't be double minded.
@@celinamilian I'm open minded. If god needs to judge me then I'll let the entity do that. I won't be judged by any of you anyways since you're nothing just like I am. Nothing but a crumb in this universe.
Homosexiality and any kind of act that goes against (the fitra) the innate is forbidden in Islam, it is a SIN and you cannot change that, people should read more about dinn from the original sources, which are the sunnah and Quraan, and do not mislead people because this is a serious matter, if you are a muslim you must know what happened to the people of sodom when the prophet Lot(PBUH) went to invite them to the true religion. He noticed that they are commiting a sin that is unprecedented in history ﴾ And Lot, when he said to his people, ‘What! Do you commit an outrage none in the world ever committed before you?!Indeed you come to men with desire instead of women! Indeed, you are a profligate lot.’ ﴿ after that God punished the people of Sodom, the punishment was not only for the sinners but also for those who supported and accepted them like the wife of Lot -Peace be upon him- she got the same punishment of sodom . I pray for you may Allah open your heart and guide you to the right path, our Islam is not changable for people's desires, and if you do sins do not show them off or convince others that they are not . and do not forget that as long as you are breathing you can always go back to Allah, to his right path.
This is only my opinion: I feel like Gen Z muslims would have more open minds for lgbt and more things, im not telling that every muslim is conservative, but im trying to say is this year has been like an evolution idk wut do yall think
I feel more millennials, especially 1st generation muslims, are more often progressive and "open minded". Gen Z muslims are kinda conflicted but seems like majority are more conservative.
Amine these people are onlyy muslim to spite the right wing ideologies in their countries, if white people were muslim they would be christian, they know very little about islam and the things they do know they like to twist and mistranslate/misinterpret them based on western ideals and values
Wonderful talk, especially the part about how when you walk into unity mosque, you don't have to leave a part of you at the door. How many mosques I've been to that made me feel I must censor so many parts of myself.
Zamu 273 the person being vegan yet eating chicken won’t be vegan, the person being Muslim yet being lgbtq+ won’t be a Muslim. Islam has rules and we need to follow all.
@Rocky so if someone commits a sin you wont tell him that he is wrong. If I kill someone a true Muslim won't judge me by your logic as they can't judge anyones life.
This man is absalutely confirming that prophet s.a.w said 1400 years ago. 72 sects in islam, division amongst Muslims, innovation in the religion !!! And how he’s quoting that honour ur parents in old age and be honourable to them. But if they are no upon tawheed or a pagan then don’t follow their religion! Not that the father has wronged her daughter! Yes it’s right that he shouldn’t have been violent to he’s daughter but to advise her and encourage her to be how God made the sons and daughters of Adam man and woman made in pairs.
@Rafael Schneider God is the most of judges, but in that context we would be judged in the Day of Resurrection. For the time being, for whatever wrong people do against themselves (i.e. not praying, not fasting, not making efforts to follow the Five Pillars of Islam) allows us to judge people based on what they do. This has been said from a Hadith that is authentic. How is this blasphemy? Giv eme the verse and the book.
Wonderful. I have always enjoyed your speeches and presentations. Thank you for all that you continue to do. Blessings, guidance and protection for you and your family. 🙏🙏🙏
D7 al=thee, lay=God, thee God meaning thee one true God, the word God can be pluralized Gods, and can be genderized god, goddess, the word Allah depicts the only one god, not more than one God and not a depiction of being male or female. Good question! Don't be afraid to ask .
Brother right now you talk against the Gods word that’s very clear! Spreading this false talks just for you to fit in and feel that you are not transgressing it’s another bigger act of transgressions. May Allah forgive you!
YOu are Muslim yes? If so, why can I see your hair? Isn't it wrong for those who aren't your family or lover to see your hair? YEt I see Muslim woman show their hair when they're not supposed to? BC it's their choice and as long as they understand what they're doing, their god will forgive them as long as they're kind and pure
And may Allah help guide and protect him and make sure that he is and will be surrounded by people who will love accept and support him no matter what Amen🙏
@Demonic Soul Astaghfirullah with that name I'm disappointed that you're here cursing on something you don't know about. sorry but you people failed the vibe check ✋
Funny how non muslims love to show their support for things like this. But when they hear about good acts in islam such as charity, family ties, not oppressing others, not stepping on others rights, ect they never show support or condone this. As soon as a muslim says anything that is controversial or not accepted in Islam they come to condone it and defend it. This itself says it all
The only one who judges what people do in their private lives (as long as they do no harm to others) is their God. If your not God, mind your own business!
You cant change the rule to suit you brother. You suppose the pray for guidance and repent for your sins and nit try to look for loopholes and dont speak about the Prophet Moghammad (pbuh)[ you did not even say those word when you mentioned him ..] like he accept your lifestyle. And you mixing to much subjects in one
Islam Condemns Homosexuality! “165. Of all the creatures in the world, will ye approach males” 166. and leave your wives whom your Lord has created for you? No, but you are a transgressing nation.” Quran 26:165-166
I never understood, why will God ever says women to not enter mosques ..when women are allowed equally to enter mecca which is most holy place in Islam , alhamdulillah...
His confusion really scares me. The fact that hes a "legal" lawyer yet he cant even understand what he really is LIKE SUCH OBVIOUS THINGS, then how come he is in the position to give sort of we called "justice". O Allah, world is too old already. Please send us HELP.
G-d given heart, intellect & intuition > dogmatic approach. Btw, let’s not forget G-d gave each one freedom - but that’s something hard for one man to give to another. They have religion grafted upon ignorance & intolerance. Thank G-d we’re not judged by blind men…in the final analysis.
The word Propaganda found it's meaning through this pep talk. The utter misguidance and misleading nature of this pep talk is going to haunt the up and coming young muslims if they stumble upon this content before reading the Quran in its true sense and meaning. La Hawla wala Quwwata Illah Billah.
I personally think that LGBT people can be Muslims, Of course that doesn't change the fact that LGBT is Haram no doubt about it, but Islam is a religion for everyone, No one should be denied from being a Muslim and submitting to Allah, We should always learn from our mistakes and try to not repeat them, LGBT Muslims are sinning but we all sometimes sin too, If we see someone doing a sin then we should educate them about it and stop them from doing it again, Not insult them and dehumanize them.
Mmmh, i considere people who eat pork and drink alcohol and identify themself as "muslims" ain't muslims but just moumin (beleiver) so the same way it should be considering the gays. They ain't muslims only mouminin since they beleive Allah is God and that mohammed pubh is his messanger
but idk bc Allah makes no mistakes when making us and being LGBT is something u can not change, so that confuses me?? Can someone explain if they could?
My understanding is that we were created with free will and in that the ability to make mistakes. A mistake implies that something wasn't intentional, so we can judge by that, that Allah intended for us to be imperfect. We seek forgiveness from him because we are the ones who make mistakes.
@George ᚨᛊᚲᛖᛚᚨᛞᛞ if you can go through Gods tests with faith and perseverance you'll be rewarded in the afterlife. This world was not meant for us to enjoy. (Don't get me wrong, we allowed to enjoy it) but it's as a test to us which will get us to heaven. Also if a religion has rules that people don't like, they should leave the religion, not try to change it to benefit them in my opinion.
@George ᚨᛊᚲᛖᛚᚨᛞᛞ yeah I 100% agree with you, that would be depressing in the least. But we Muslims believe in the afterlife and we have proof that Islam is the truth, so we know that this life is a waste and that it's the afterlife we strive for. All in all I can see why you sympathize with the guy giving the Ted talk. Any good person would feel that way. The problem is that he is promoting something thats not allowed and making it seem like it is allowed. If he had to take responsibility and say it's something that isn't allowed but he still continues then Muslims wouldn't be so upset by him. Sorry for the long read, I really hope this makes sense. Btw AoT fan too?
What’s happening to the world, men are not men anymore women are not women anymore, people trying to change the word of god for their own conveniency . Islam is against a man lying with an other one , it doesn’t matter how you try to lie to your self and others about it but it is what it is.
And as for the two of you men who are guilty of lewdness, punish them both. And if they repent and improve, then let them be. Lo! Allah is Merciful. Qur'an 4:16 Abusing the divine mercy of God is selfish, appalling and deserving of a harsh punishment in the hereafter. Ameen
@@cxarhomell5867 If your talking about him respecting fire your talking about ablis who is just a little piece of fire waking around wispering in people's ears telling them what to do. Edit ooops I meant the other person
@Riyadh Uddin The 3 fires are the representative of the 3 Nations that existed before we Settled in the Great Lakes region. The 3 Natalie nation's were here long before us, so disrespecting that, as you are, Is a foolish mistake only people with a Dark Heart make. Take your dark heart elsewhere, and make others more miserable than you feel about yourself. Not here. We do not want your self loathing here.
This thing has some screws loose. Islam means submitting to God and not submitting to your desires. Yes, you can have those thoughts as does a married man when he sees a beautiful woman or vice versa, this does not mean you can act upon what your mind desires. That’s the whole point of our religion, freeing yourself from materialism, hedonism and all other “instant pleasures” (which enslave you more than anything) so that you can be rewarded in the hereafter. I can go on for days as to why everything said here is wrong. You are not a muslim until you realise these simple fact
Hmmmm .??where does it say in the noble Quran explicit homosexuality is haram???nowhere .I give you a example in sure 30 vers 21 it says Allah created for every person a Partner .When you look at the grammar you can notice that the word Partner in arabic doesn’t have a gender.Therefore you can understand that Allah created for everybody someone it doesn’t mean necessarily a woman or a man .
Khyber you are really funny.the only thing you say that I should read it carefully...ahhh really then you can ofc tell me where it is saying explicitly Homosexuality is haram/a sin I am now really curious..
@@cdgg53 And [We had sent] Lot when he said to his people, "Do you commit such immorality as no one has preceded you with from among the worlds? Indeed, you approach men with desire, instead of women. Rather, you are a transgressing people." The holy quran 7:80-7:81
