Тёмный

What did the "unofficial" witnesses of the Book of Mormon plates experience? Ep. 99 

Saints Unscripted
Подписаться 84 тыс.
Просмотров 8 тыс.
50% 1

In this episode, David explores the accounts of additional witnesses to the Book of Mormon gold plates, who were NOT among the Three and Eight Witnesses. How do antagonists explain their experiences?? Let's find out!
Transcript and additional notes on our website: bit.ly/2VrEo2P
“5 Women Who Are Witnesses of the Physical Golden Plates,” by Chris Heimerdinger: bit.ly/2YYFPI9
“Hefted and handles: Tangible Interactions with Book of Mormon Objects,” by Anthony Sweat: bit.ly/3lIfoQH
“Empirical Witnesses of the Gold Plates,” by Larry E. Morris: bit.ly/2QNYH80
“How Witnesses Described the Gold Plates,” by Kirk B. Henrichsen: bit.ly/2F2flOY
Very informative video via “LDS Truth Claims”: bit.ly/2DmYeqq
Another informative video via “Latter-day Saint Q and A”: bit.ly/3lFymYa
Yet another informative video via “The Interpreter Foundation”: bit.ly/3lLM6R2
Notes:
-There are a few different accounts of Mary Whitmer’s experience seeing the plates. The account used in this video was chosen, frankly, because it was the shortest one. Other accounts may provide additional details and may be more contemporary to the experience itself. I highly encourage you to read those accounts here: bit.ly/2GmVqLj
-One of Joseph Smith’s employers, Josiah Stowell, was at the house in Palmyra when Joseph initially arrived with the plates. In a later court hearing that we talked about in the episode linked below, Josiah testified that when Joseph arrived with the plates, he “saw a corner of [the record], it resembled a stone of a greenish caste…” which was likely an oxidized corner of the sealed portion of the plates. Josiah later joined the Church and died a faithful member. Video link: bit.ly/2F27mB7 More info: bit.ly/3lIfoQH
-In an interview with William Smith, William is reported as saying about the plates, “I did not see them uncovered, but I handled them and hefted them while wrapped in a tow frock and judged them to have weighed about sixty pounds. I could tell they were plates of some kind and that they were fastened together by rings running through the back.” -Interview of William Smith with E. C. Briggs and J. W. Peterson, “Zion’s Ensign,” Jan 13. 1894, p. 6.
-The grandson of Katherine Smith (Katherine was Joseph Smith’s little sister) reported that Katherine had told him of a time when she had found the plates covered in a cloth resting on a table. She “rippled her fingers up the edge of the plates and felt that they were separate metal plates and heard the tinkle of sound that they made.” While this is certainly a possibility, it could also be that the grandson confused the experiences of Katherine Smith and Emma Smith, who described a similar experience. More info here: bit.ly/31OraRK
-At one point, the plates were placed in an “old Ontario glass-box.” A friend of the Smiths named Alvah Beaman was present, and “when they [the plates] went in he said he heard them jink, but he was not permitted to see them.” Source: bit.ly/2QNYH80
SUBSCRIBE:
saintsunscripted/subscribe
Follow Us:
Facebook: / saintsunscripted
Instagram: / saintsunscripted
Website: saintsunscripted.com/
Follow the Hosts:
Justin: / motioncoaster
Mimi: / mimi.bascom
David: / davidesnell
Taylor: / tsyorg
Samantha: / sam.iris.yello

Опубликовано:

 

1 дек 2020

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 84   
@DeanCLiddell
@DeanCLiddell 3 года назад
“Is there any proof” “Yes, we have eye witnesses of the Book of Mormon origins and we have found similar books” “You can’t trust eye witnesses” “People also tried to steal it, if it’s not real why would people try to steal them?” “You can’t trust everything” “So why would I trust you?” Is an actual conversation I had.
@seans5289
@seans5289 3 года назад
Can you elaborate on these “similar books?” Do you mean something like the Kinderhook plates?
@leem3299
@leem3299 3 года назад
If I'm recalling correctly, the ones intent on stealing them were old treasure seeking buddies who were mad that Joseph was not sharing the treasure. And weren't most of the witnesses treasure seekers as well? This was from Rough Stone Rolling from Richard Bushman. Hopefully I'm not remembering wrong. But alas, does that make the plates more or less believable? Growing up I only heard the faith promoting versions of things and so I pretty much had to believe. But now I see that honest people can believe either way.
@mikeschmit7125
@mikeschmit7125 3 года назад
I would just like to say I am a recent viewer of your channel and I really appreciate what you guys do. I used to be an athiest who bought heavily into the stigma of the Latter Day Saint movement being ridiculous, but your videos supply us with the other side that we don't get to see often, and it has really opened my eyes. Thanks to your videos, I have recently began pursuing converting to The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints! God bless you all! :)
@leem3299
@leem3299 3 года назад
I'm glad you've been able to see both sides. I grew up in the church, so the only side I saw of atheists was rediculous. I think I'm seeing a more balanced view as well now. My experience in the church hasn't been great, but any church is going to have all kinds. Seeing both sides, and doing what you think is best for you is commendable. And this is my favorite church friendly channel. I like it a lot.
@brettmajeske3525
@brettmajeske3525 3 года назад
Welcome Mike!
@davidsnell2605
@davidsnell2605 3 года назад
Welcome! Thanks for watching and I wish you all the best on your spiritual journey.
@rickyn.1567
@rickyn.1567 3 года назад
I grew up in the Church, then fell away and became more agnostic. I was never against the Church or anything, I just didn’t really believe it. I started coming back when I was 22 because friends nagged me to. I’m almost 26 now, and while I don’t regret my life because of everything I learned, I also wish I had God’s blessings through my entire life. Remember to pray about these important experiences and how you should proceed. It’s a special connection between you and God.
@terryv3780
@terryv3780 2 года назад
Welcome! I wish you all the best in our spiritual journey :). I am glad that you have kept a thirst to understand more! Best of wishes to you.
@timneji
@timneji 3 года назад
Just here to tell you that i love you all :)
@PapaKryptoss
@PapaKryptoss 3 года назад
Man it would be cool if they would have had cameras back in that day.
@Herosoulstone
@Herosoulstone 3 года назад
The cool part is that you don't have to look back then, president Nelson said we could have these same experiences.
@Herosoulstone
@Herosoulstone 3 года назад
And many are, but it's sacred.
@rogerchambers9575
@rogerchambers9575 3 года назад
She did not state that the man was Moroni. She stated that he was a nephite. Her grandson stated that the man was Moroni. You can read about this event in the Joseph Smith papers.
@joshuajaydan
@joshuajaydan 3 года назад
The Olan jump cut made me laugh out loud. Nice work.
@Herosoulstone
@Herosoulstone 3 года назад
I love this channel, and thankyou David, Love you all and I hope your all having a good day:)
@tawnyarasmussen1965
@tawnyarasmussen1965 Год назад
Thank you for these videos. I have been binge watching them.
@SaintsUnscripted
@SaintsUnscripted Год назад
Thanks for watching!
@mariodezert
@mariodezert 4 дня назад
GOT A SUGGESTION: a videa about the MYTH built aound that ELLIE WHITE was a former secretary do Joseph Smith and later founder the Adventists. Why so?
@Hamann9631
@Hamann9631 3 года назад
Great video. I know The Book of Mormon is true because of The Holy Ghost but there is also evidence. The Holy Ghost isn't telling me things contrary to evidence. Those who are claiming it is false have some explaining to do. We have no explaining to do.
@seans5289
@seans5289 3 года назад
How have you concluded that the Holy Ghost is anything other than your own thoughts and feelings?
@Hamann9631
@Hamann9631 3 года назад
@@seans5289 It is from outside of me.
@seans5289
@seans5289 3 года назад
@@Hamann9631: As in, you hear an audible voice?
@Hamann9631
@Hamann9631 3 года назад
@@seans5289 Sometimes it is a feeling. Sometimes it is an idea coming to mind. I can't think of a time I heard an audible voice.
@leem3299
@leem3299 3 года назад
If you're asking for explanation I'm sure there will be many happy to sway you one way or the other. But it sounds like your mind is made up for now, so best wishes for you. Thanks for sharing your testimony.
@1900intz
@1900intz 3 года назад
Informative. Thx.
@strongtower9237
@strongtower9237 3 года назад
There is none who seeks after God.
@BrendonKing
@BrendonKing 3 года назад
Romans 3: 11 yes.
@kenhilker2507
@kenhilker2507 3 года назад
Your Hypothesis: The existence of a stack of metal plates could prove Joseph Smith's account was correct. My Hypothesis: The existence of a stack of metal plates could prove that Joseph Smith made the himself. Does anything from the official or unofficial witness descriptions of the plates help us determine which hypothesis is closer to the truth?
@DynamicGracer
@DynamicGracer 3 года назад
For what it's worth, I have seen the Golden Plates and still deny the church
@leem3299
@leem3299 3 года назад
Ok I'll bite. What are you talking about?
@DynamicGracer
@DynamicGracer 3 года назад
​@@leem3299 I have signs, wonders, visions, dreams, miracles and feelings that surpass all understanding, all in favor of the church from my 1,700 hours of prayer... and I still deny the church in favor of Jesus Christ. If I saw the plates myself, but didn't have my testimony, my testimony would be weaker. This basically means I have "seen the plates", since I literally have a testimony that is stronger than the golden plates alone. In other words, I have more supernatural evidence of Joseph and the church than Martin Harris did (facts) Seeing the plates is akin to having an absurdly strong testimony of the church in a supernatural way. Saying "I have seen the golden plates" is like saying, "I have a supernatural testimony of Joseph." According to church history, a lot of people saw the plates and left later anyways, but never denied seeing the golden plates. What this means to a Mormon is that the golden plates must of been for real, but what this means to an anti-mormon is that Joseph Smith was SO wicked that one can see the plates and still deny him. The problem with my testimony is that the demons can mimic every supernatural experience I had. The problem with the Golden Plates is that they can exist and be demonic. Sure, South Park was wrong (not a con)... but Galatians 1:8 wasn't.
@leem3299
@leem3299 3 года назад
@@DynamicGracer Wow, at first I thought you were exaggerating for effect, but sounds like you have had some interesting experiences. The only thing in that direction I've experienced is when I was young, one day I heard my name, plain as day. But no one was around. It wasn't sarry but was strange. I listened for more message but that's all the voice said. So when you say "in favor of Christ" what do you mean?
@DynamicGracer
@DynamicGracer 3 года назад
@@leem3299 In favor of the Jesus Christ of Christianity The God of Mormonism is some dude playing a dude disguised as another dude from a parallel universe who sinned and was redeemed by a sinless savior, and was a Mormon who had a hot wife. That wife is our Heavenly Mother. Another way to explain it is like this Christians believe in Santa Clause, and Mormons believe in the Easter Bunny as well. I was down to believe in the Easter Bunny, and even many of his Rabbit Holes were okay as well. I went along with the Hare-I-sees for years, but then the Bunny Rabbit said "We believe in a different Santa Clause. His name is Kris Kringle." I had to dismiss the Bunny Rabbit and the Book of Mormon at that point, for I believe in a different cosmic Santa Clause. There are people smarter than me that believe that God was a man who became God, but if you start with Christianity and try to add on the Book of Mormon story, it won't make sense. The God and Jesus Christ that Joseph Smith worships is not the God and Jesus Christ that I believe in.
@leem3299
@leem3299 3 года назад
@@DynamicGracer I caught some of that, but what is the God and Jesus you believe in? Christianity is kind of a broad spectrum, God can be anywhere from stern and violent to merciful.
@brazenbunnies
@brazenbunnies 3 года назад
I am a Mormon...and a Mormom just believes!
@exbrotherbryce5029
@exbrotherbryce5029 3 года назад
Most the witnesses said they saw the plates only with their spiritual eyes...
@timneji
@timneji 3 года назад
But some saw them with there eyes
@brettmajeske3525
@brettmajeske3525 3 года назад
Where are you getting that from. Having read as much of the original accounts as I can find, that just isn't true at all. I only know of a single witness who used that specific phraseology. If you are going to make a claim like that, you need to better explain that position.
@randonymous2793
@randonymous2793 3 года назад
“Spiritual eyes” or not, that’s a good amount of people who saw it.
@Hamann9631
@Hamann9631 3 года назад
Ex Brother Bryce. We only have 1 non-believer claiming that. It is a lie. I hope you repent before Final Judgement.
@Hamann9631
@Hamann9631 3 года назад
@Ralph Wigguhm Brett Majeske doesn't need to read more. You do. They said they saw the plates with their own eyes!
Далее
Ranking The Most Painful Crashes
00:19
Просмотров 2 млн
Why is Nemo STILL a Mormon?
1:07:44
Просмотров 31 тыс.
Episode 8: What was the Cost of Being a Witness?
10:27
Просмотров 2,8 тыс.
Episode 29: Women Witnesses-Why and Why Not?
11:11
Просмотров 1,1 тыс.