What I Want From EVERY Mario Game For Super Mario Maker 3 

something i really wish they had is lift spawners so that levels like smb1 1-2 could be made more faithfully. It will default to spitting lifts in a specified direction, and can be added to tracks to rail on the lifts that spawn from them

5:03 Personally, I think that if, behind the scenes, Nintendo really did HAVE to chose *either* the Frog Suit or Hammer Suit, they chose the right power-up. Now, I wouldn't say I prefer the Frog Suit over the Hammer Suit, but I think it's a bit tunnel-visioned to think it doesn't deserve a spot at *all,* perhaps. The Frog Suit's land traversal IS certainly annoying to use, unless holding an item, but it's a radical change to Mario's moveset and mechanics, ESPECIALLY underwater; which was a style of gameplay that wasn't very fun before the Frog Suit's addition. If anything, the Frog Suit/something equivalent (like the Penguin Suit from NSMB) should be in ALL styles so that fun underwater controls aren't locked to just SMB3, in my opinion. I don't think the Hammer Suit would've shaken up the gameplay or mechanics anywhere NEAR as much as the Frog Suit, at least not without reworking some of it's mechanics. I personally like both powerups, and think they would both make good additions, but I do think the frog suit won fair and square, if we assume it has to be a competition. All that said, good vid!

14:25 rip Luigi he will forever be in our hearts.💚

15:05 I could see the ice flower item being replaced with the penguin suit on water/snow levels like how the dry bones are replaced with dry fish

I think having a full-on Bowser's Fury mode for 3D World that replaces the night mode in that style would be awesome, and maybe it could lead to some non-linear levels where the objective is to collect the Cat Shines instead of reaching the goal and other various gameplay elements from that expansion.

Honestly, I'd like to see whomps as added enemies in SMM3. They were in NSMB DS and I think NSMB2 as well, so it'd be nice to see them in 2D Mario again.

The mini mushroom would be awesome! That's one of my favorite power ups! You can walk on water and up walls! Plus, you can bounce on enemies! Like, there's so much creative potential here!

15:07 I think the penguin suit could be a variant of the ice flower, like the fire flower and the superball flower

Better idea than the Cosmic Clone: Cosmic Mario from SM3DL special levels, love the way it completely changes all the rules Also mini mushroom isn’t all that bad, it’s a high skill high reward power up and if we get it we’ll likely get the mega mushroom

This is probably some of the best jokes, timing and just over all quality on your whole channel! Keep it up you're awesome!

The frog suit makes underwater levels actually bearable. And theres already several powerups that throw projectiles, but none that make you swim easily besides the frog suit. So yeah I prefer the frog suit over the hammer suit.

6:58 aged very well.

How long until Nintendo adds fantastic Fuzzies? How will we rate levels without a scale of 1-5 fuzzies?

Honestly, for NSMB2, I'm surprised you didn't mention the dry bones versions of enemies. Dry goombas and dry piranha plants would be cool.

08:05 - BUT THERE IS A SPACE THEME IN SMM2: THE SKY NIGHT THEME!

15:01 an idea I've never heard is making the penguin suit a setting for the ice flower, like how you can make a goomba a goombrat, or a green koopa red

Ice flower would’ve made some amazing levels, I still think we were robbed of it in SMM2

I'd like to see level themes be changed so we can mix and match the background, block pallets, and special features like water or lava or wind. This would give so much more customizability to levels without even adding anything new.

I could totally see them bringing over Petey Piranha from Sunshine, it's even in a bunch of other games so there's precedent. And I would like to see the poison mushroom from smb2 just for the chaos.

One thing I want to see for the third game is a broader selection of music. Maybe let Creators choose from three tracks per game style or something. The thing is, I find it quite hard to make unique levels with the standard theme. If i want to make a haunted forest level, the theme for the forest music is just way too happy for that. A Tree Tower as a Miniboss level for the super world would also need a more hostile tune. Mario is known for its great music, zo let us choose from this library in the next Maker Game. Also this Way, Games without Game style could be featured.

15:16 I can definitely see where you are coming from and I kinda agree! The Ice Flower has only 1 power and that could be used for puzzle levels. But since the Penguin suit has 3 powers, like the Link Sword, it could be used for a level to showcase the powers and use them all in interesting ways. And could also be used for traditional levels as the main power up. 15:28 Also, I think the Mini Mushroom could make great gimmicks for levels. 15:39 They’re called Fake Walls.

Main reason I want the Penguin suit over the ice flower is it would kill 2 birds with one stone. You get the ice flower and better swimming wrapped into one powerup. Because I really wish there was a frogsuit-like powerup in every style to make water level more bearable.

10:49 my nostalgia filled heart sunk

I feel like the hammer suit wasn't chosen over the frog suit simply because it would cause too many issues with off screen set ups. Remember it can damage everything(including Thwamps) and goes through walls and more importantly the ceiling/floor. So just imagine how many levels that rely on off screen mechanisms would soft lock from the hammer suit and how hard it would be to build around.

I think the rotating circular platforms from 1-3 in nsmb wij would be great

I LOVE SMM2 I really hope SMM3 happens

10:37 FLUDD Powerup. There was a flash game that was a 2d recreation of one of 3d Mario games and it had a FLUDD powerup, so it could work well with 2d. Basically, imagine Mario having a jetpack that can also kill enemies. It would refill when going into water or collecting the new FLUDD powerup, so it would be great for levels that are partially submerged, like we can do in SMM1.

There are sooo many things I’d want from Mario 2 • Vegetables you can pick up and throw • Birdo miniboss • Any/All of the bosses from SMB2 • Panser • Magic potion you can use to hide items in Sub Space • Being able to put any item or enemy in the ground as a vegetable leaf just like you can put anything in an item block Just give us the whole game as its own style, really

"If we were concerned about bad level creators the only item in the game would be ground blocks" THANK YOU

a lot of these ideas would be amazing additions to the mario maker series. jus watching videos like these is making me even more hyped for when the direct with smm3 is shown(hopefully sometime in the next year or two!)

I wish they had a boss map and more bosses, also making tracks invisible/speed settings, shy guys, waterfall's/sand geysers, and music options.

The ability to replay levels is a must, which I guess is implied if you have secret exits. Also, running out of lives should actually, you know... matter. Allowing for navigation between individual worlds would also be nice. I want power ups to carry over between levels, but that gets into a separate list of wants I have, regarding different types of levels.

I have a couple ideas of how Star Coins can be useful, maybe if you get enough of them, you can get in-game achievement or they can be used as a new category on leaderboards so people can grind levels for star coins

Let’s hope SMM3 happens! It would be hype if it does get announced! :)

I‘m curious what Nintendo plans to do with 2D Marios in the future. Releasing a regular Mario game, even if there is some innovation on the level of one or two new power-ups, would feel redundant after the Mario Maker games so I feel like they would need something big if they want to continue the series at all.

The double cherry is similar to what happens when you scan a yarn amiibo into yoshi’s woolly world. They already know how to implement it

Something I want is to have a pipe that can also change the game style, imagine going from Mario bros 3 to Mario bros U. I feel like this could be really fun and creative

I think they should add a gimic where if the clown car touches water it does an epic transformation into a submarine. Not just if you place it in water. Edit: or maybe you just hold down on it and choose transform, clown car, or clown sub.

The carrot power up. It's similar to the cape, but you can only float. Could be useful for a SMB only power up.

10:10 what do you mean, strollin stews are the best things to ever appear in a mario game and the only thing stopping mario sunshine from being an absolutely terrible game.

Good video! I would also include the blue hexagonal invisible blocks from 3d world and bowser's fury where the creator in the editor can see the platform exactly but the player in-game can't see it until they step on it. (Also fixing the 3d beep blocks exactly to the beat of the music and/or adding them to the other game styles, or potentially add the rhythm stage from 3d land or 3d world. Won't that be fun?)

A mario odyssey theme in mm3 would be goated

that last idea was so perfect, I'm amazed no one had that idea yet

The 2 things I want are more bosses and placeable water and lava so it’s not the whole level and I can add it to rooms with it being a forest or castle

I think the ice flower is a better power up than fire flower and it most definitely should be in MM3 Anyone who disagrees can cope, seethe, or even mald🔥🔥

Secret exits would be such a boon for traditional levels and super worlds. Great suggestion.

10:38 odyssey probably had a lot of fun making this transition

The only problem with the Hammer Suit being added is the overlaps with the New hammer power up

I think the carrot power up would be really fun in SMM3. If you are a good enough spammer you can essentially fly infinitely.

I think Mario Sunshine could work as it's game-style. Or atleast the F.L.U.D.D could be added as really cool power-up

I'm surprised there still hasn't been a beach theme. It's iconic and yet overlooked.

“The most iconic enemy in the game: Shy Guy” Birdo: *Dies of emotional damage*

Something I’ve always wanted was a Super Paper Mario game style. This way, you wouldn’t rely on power ups as health and you would actually have an HP system. You could also use you hammer, which I think that alone is enough to make this style distinct.

Dude adding the strolling stu to mario maker 3 would be hella based

The hate for the frog suit tells me you don't play much Mario Maker. SMB3 is probably the least popular gamestyle because there''s so little to make it stand out compared to the others. Frog suit provided *exactly* that: a more dynamic way to play water levels. It was a great addition. Being able to throw hammers around doesn't elevate gameplay nearly as much.

I really appreciate how you actually clarify "mainline" Mario games. You have no idea how many people will just say "Mario game" like that's enough information.

I feel like a great implementation for Mario galaxy is the game as a whole. Similar to what they did for 3-D world, I feel like it would be an amazing game mode to play. It could look something like at the 12:50 minute mark on your video.

Probably my most anticipated game. I didn’t even think about Mario maker 2 being announced but when it was I was so excited. If this happens my mind will be blown.

For a more interesting nsmb2 addition, you could add the really unique backgrounds nsmb2 levels have. Alternate backgrounds in general would be pretty rad

hammer suit probably needs a nerf before it gets added since in they got the same damage-code as the star power-up (killing everything) it could get the damage-code as the cannon box to make it more balanced

There should be a variation for the Themes. Ex: NSMBU Castle theme rn is kinda ugly imo, so a variation can be the gray brick, bluish or the green-ish variation. Also being able to add elements with having to be night mode, like wind. And one million more things 🤩

For SMB1 and Lost Levels, I’d definitely like to see the platform that acts like a single scale platform, sinking when you stand on it and stopping when you jump off, and the Poison Mushroom (not the rotten mushroom). Also, from SMB3, I really want to see Grab Blocks, especially since SMB1 is technically the only one that didn’t have anything of that sort, (Okay, NSMBU didn’t technically have anything like that, but it had the light blocks, which act basically the same)

Something that I really want to see added are yellow and blue Koopa Troopas... not only because of more visual variety for all the game styles, but also because they could implement all their behaviors in the smw and the sm3Dw game styles.

For all stars: they could easily be skins. Something you set per style where you also choose your character. You can choose per style if it should override the original skin.

YOU MAKE GREAT VIDS!

star coins are honestly so integral to traditional level design feeling good that im really surprised they still don't have them lmao. the Penguin Suit is honestly just such a cool power up that I really wanna see in a mario maker game lol, it improves your swimming controls, provides a faster movement option, lets you stop slipping on ice, has all the benefits of the ice flower, and most importantly looks *adorable*. the only noticeable negative to it's inclusion would be if it came at the *cost* of the ice flower not being put in the game, but frankly? i kinda doubt they'd ever do that? the ice flower is literally just the penguin suit but with less features lol, it's not like adding the ice flower while you have the penguin suit would add much dev time. the question is more in reverse, is it worth adding when you just have the ice flower made? and even then my answer is still yes, because fast movement at 1 tile high that can also break through gaps and has you mostly immune to damage while performing it? it's basically just a functional remake of the blue shell but with more interesting elements added rather than *just* having a limited movement mode that's hard to control. (also the fact that the penguin suit's sliding is an active input you have to make by pressing down while running, whereas the blue shell just automatically does it after you've ran to full speed for a bit lol) that said, i simply *cannot* agree about mini-mushrooms as they simply add *so many* interesting physics changes without you having to be locked to night theme on very specific stages to get similar things from, while also allowing you to use them to give players access to optional difficulty runs of the same level. mini-mushrooms are honestly just super fun and cool and especially if they come with the mini-mushroom mini-blocks that only a mini mario can run under, that'd be so cool (especially in tandem with star coins or extra lives which you could hide behind the mini's alternate path)

14:41 They had us in the first half not gonna lie.

I genuinely don't know how you manage to be one of the most engaging and funniest Nintendo creators, but you do. Keep up the good work, I like all of the ideas presented here as well!

I have an idea for how to implement both the ice flower *and* the penguin suit. You could change the ice flower into the penguin suit, just like how you can do that with a few enemies, blocks, semi-solids, and power-ups. Easiest thing to do, really.

For the 3D Mario Games addition of possible tools/assets, I found a fan made flash game (actually really good with its own level editor) incorporated a lot of the items fairly well and was overall pretty fun to play. It was called Super Mario 63 (2D "loose" replicated version of Mario 64 with additional of Mario sunshine and Mario galaxy tools).

this is kinda weird but i would love to see the odyssey costumes come to mario maker, and the ability to customise mario, and maybe certain costumes would be given out through an achievement system

I'd also like to see a tower theme. These are very different then castle theme or volcano theme, because theyre more green and don't have lava. This'd be cool to see in addition to beach, volcano, and mountain themes.

Another thing is that the penguin suit would make for some fun underwater levels

Gravity changing might very well be on its way. The 2D sections of Odyssey sometimes have it. Secret exits could lead to one of those smb3 minigame houses, allowing for even more 1-ups to be collected.

Hear me out: not Mario Maker 3... Mario Maker 3d

When it comes to the Bullet Blaster, I think it would be cool if you could put it in pipes like in Mario Land.

I love your content it makes me laugh and also puts great ideas in my head. Keep of the great work

If they keep endless mode, a change I would like to see is requiring creators have 3 one ups when beating their level. I find is frustrating how inconsistent it is, that some levels will give you one ups, coins, etc. while others you have no way to gain lives.

17:35 maybe the double cherry can act like the toads from story mode, I mean they mimic your exact movements but when they get hit they get in a bubble, kinda like the double cherry

My two favorite things I would like to see in Mario maker 2 or even maybe 3 is the waddlewing and the Monty tank. Both of them are very unique, the waddlewing has the gliding ability and can cling on to walls, also they are very cute. And the Monty tank would be a super fun boss to battle. The mountain theme would be amazing to have also just because Monty moles and waddlewings fit in the most there.

I feel like each level should have an individual life counter, because unless you're playing the endless challenge you have no reason to go out of your way for 1-ups and coins.

For some reason, I just love hearing ideas for a potential Mario Maker 3! Great video!

My idea for Sunshine would be Fludd. It works, see Super Mario 63. Amazing fangame, and it works wonders.

I like the frog suit more than the hammer suit, but that’s because I’m a weirdo who likes water levels. I also would love to hear your thoughts on Super Mario Land 2 at some point in the future because it’s one of my favorite Mario games because I love how unique it is Edit: I also love the mini mushroom. As I kid I would try to beat the whole game as mini Mario. I’m a really weird Mario fan lol

Spot on, man. If these things were to come out with a SMM3, then I'd be all over it!

I've been wanting blue coins added to Mario Maker since before the prequel to this video, super excited that we share that idea!

I actually love the frog suit,.. it makes for fun rage worthy platforming

I hope SMM3 has some sort of 3D editor that would kinda work like Minecraft.

8:07 SO TRUE

Odyssey, you’re so close to 100K! Congratulations man, I’m so happy to see your channel grow!!! :)

For me the must-needs for mario maker 3 is the "Secret Walls" you can pass through, Coin Rings, and moving walls. I recently remade NSMBW 1-Tower and it was a living hell trying to recreate something as simple as a moving wall

One thing I really want to see if they make a Super Mario Maker 3 is the tower/fort theme. They even added verticle subareas, which is a perfect fit!

3:20 actually, Doki Doki Panic was built off of a Mario game IIRC

8:10 my favourite part in the whole video is seeing all the youtubers that i am subbed to appear on screen (all of them)

you’re so close to 100k, looking forward to seeing the ranking every moon in mario odyssey, I don’t know if you will read this, but have you already made the video or you will start working on it when you reach 100k? btw love your videos❤️

My most wanted features include: Being able to exit levels, and save your progress at checkpoints. People grind levels now and it would be nice to take a break from a hard level you’ve reached a checkpoint at, and come back to it later Allow us to throw shells up in all game styles you can hold a shell. I have no idea why Nintendo dropped it after SMW. Allow multiple game styles per level. Go in a pipe in SMW, come out in SMB3. Would be pretty awesome. Color pallets for the characters. If we can’t have special mushrooms anymore, let us change the colors. Yellow Mario, purple toad, pink Luigi…etc

I think that fludd, all of the power ups from super Mario galaxy 1 and two, super carrot and the penguin suits would be perfect

SML 2 had a bunch of really cool overworld designs that could be incorporated into the superworld system. Getting eaten by a giant turtle to go to the next level, or climbing into a rocket, worlds biomes themed around areas like the macro zone, the haunted house.

I would absolutely love a music changer feature, like, being able to activate the NSMBW Final Boss theme for the final boss of your super world would be HYPE

I agree with everything here, especially the “add Game Boy games to NSO” thing, as I just want to play Shrek: Hassle at the Castle come on Nintendo mAKE IT HAPPEN All jokes aside, I really hope they get added, I really want to play the first WarioWare game.