Could you imagine Coco and Detox doing Shut Up and Drive? I think it would still be an AMAZING lip sync. Detox being the ultimate sex magnet while Coco busts out Janet Jackson moves like its nothing. (I know we already saw Coco vs Detox already, but this song is different lmao)
now i highkey wanna see this happen in a season! like a GENUINE comeback story -- not something painfully pushed by producers. A genuine comeback story to the extreme.
like what happened in Drag Race Thailand S2. The 2 returning queens earned their spot in the top 3, they didnt win tho, but that was gag worthy, given there were 13 episodes and 1 was eliminated by ep 4 and the other one was eliminated by ep 5.
The fact that Trixie Mattel, with her the over the top Dolly Parton Barbie doll aesthetic, has had the least work done out of the entire hall of fame is still hilarious to me.
@@Miguel-ki8wj I dont think so. Considering the fact that she has interupted Katya way before she won AS3. Its just the jokes would have been different.
It's amazing to think about how just one queen's presence (Alaska, Silky, Sherry, Abby OMG, Rita Baga, and so on...) can shake up the outcome of an entire season. Throw them out of the loop and the season gets turned over on its head.
Since S10, the producers have been tryi g to push a big gurl to win. It didn't work with Eureka and Silky, but they really set Sherry to win for S12. Could you imagine? Dodged a fat bullet on that one, Ru.
@@kahmorastimemanagement6096 It'd feel so organic and make so much sense for Darienne to be the first big girl winner on AS7 in 2022 (or whenever [if at all] she decides to grace our screens back with her presence, lol), maaaawma...All would be right in the world, lol. Here's hoping I can somehow come back to this comment once she is on D:
I think Katya would win, Detox was already eliminated and was abscent for two whole challenges. Also for storyline reasons, they would have builded up Katya's story the entire season, also the fact that she couldnt win any lip sync and finally "wins" the last one would be a great finale moment.
Katya wins the moment in her speech she says "Charisma, Uniqueness', Nervvvve and talent. What do these things have in common? I don't know, I'm not a scientist." Ru smiles and we have our winner.
I think Katya would win. gotta give the fan favorites what they want, ya know? Buuut I think Detox winning would be much more entertaining as a storyline, + she’s such an iconic queen. Could also be a double crowning?? Yes please... 👀
This such a interesting idea and this would be my perfect world also I'm shocked by the idea of rolaskatox going home in bottom 5 (I know detox comes back)
See its hard to say because I could see production picking either one. Detox because it would be a huge redemption arc to be eliminated so early then winning, but also Katya was so loveable and her arc was also incredible to watch so I could honestly see it going either way
What a convenient video! I just was rewatching her infamous tantrum because I had a small hysterical episode today myself ❤️ exactly what I needed P.s: of course I’m voting Katya for the crown 👑
Oh I think they would push even harder for her to win. To the point where anytime she was high I think they would have bumped her up to top 2 and probably give her one of the most impressive track records alongside Ben’s
katya is ultimately the better business decision in regards to a winner. she had a great verse, great routine and arguably won the last challenge, and also katya is just a better face for the drag race brand because of her internet success.
i've always thought the same thing abt alaska being one of the best singers from drag race, even tho she doesn't show it so much on her songs, but her live performances are amazing.
I kinda think the Battle would be between Adore and Katya since Adore took most of Alaska's spots in the top 2. For some reason in this scenario, I see Adore winning AS2. I think Adore would turn it in the _If I Was Your Woman_ lip sync. Her lip sync against Joslyn shows that she can perform well to a soul track and I can see her bearing her heart in this song without having to rely on smudging her makeup like Alaska did. I could even see her getting emotional during the song. It would be extremely close, Ru might even need to get up (but **not** talk to the producers) and compose himself... but eventually pick Adore.
The people that don't understand Detox's 5th element reference. Which, not only a sci fi movie, aka future, but also based on a design by Jean Paul Gaultier. A major designer and the one behind a LOT of Madonna's iconic looks, including THE cone bra. Who is also known for his use of metallics in his runways (and in some of the Madonna designs), hence Detox doing the look in the metallic silver. Or the fucking skill to paint your body THAT well and THAT smoothly, in as short of time as they apparently had? When especially metallic paint loves to smudge and smear, yet you look at all the places where her skin naturally moves and rubs as you move and especially walk, and it's still all perfectly smooth and flawless and even. Like it may not be your personal favorite look, but to say it's garbage? With the thought put into it and the execution? Like dude I love your videos even if I don't always agree, but I usually do, but the way you shit on that look is a choice.
Ok so, Detox winning does fulfill the storyline of being underappreciated in the season and in general as a queen, but at the same time we have an all-time fan favorite with Katya that wanted to prove, to quote Katya, "a total fucking monster". Which she did. The final decision fall on who the producers want to get out of the winner, either someone who thrives with WOW or someone who walks out with the money and god knows what happens. Either way, the only reason why I wanna lean towards Katya is the ties she had with WOW before the season and because Detox already got eliminated.
I think Katya, just because we could see the fact that I could see her being even more iconic in the finale, specially since with neither alaska or roxxxy to have iconic verses for different reasons.
i mean ru loved detox looks, but katya was soo good too. this one is for sure a hard one. but i think maybe this one was the first double win? cuz seriously unlike monet and trinity where trinity was the clear winner. this time, both were really good and deserving of the crown! so i am going for BOTH win!
I mean the Detox's ' returning queen comes back and does really well so she is the winner' storyline is so good, but the second queen that could win in this scenario is Katya. I think it explains itself.
Great video, interesting watch, I wish we got to see more Coco lipsyncs. One thing, for the fish tank episode, Detox would be in the bottom 3 with Coco and Tatianna, so her score would be somewhat lower. I say that would happen because originally it was a bottom 3 (I think)
It’s interesting to think about how opinions of Alaska would change on this timeline. I wonder if the fanbase would have been disappointed with her performance, and if there would have been other moments for the producers to use to create drama featuring Adore.
I think Katya would win in this scenario, but I think if that did happen, Trixie wouldn't have won AS3 (she would have made it to top 4 but I think Shangela would have won instead and they would've done something different to the jury vote)
I think the winner would be based almost completely on the fan response to Katya. If she's liked by the fans (like she was in our reality) she would be the best pick. HOWEVER I think that the storyline of a returning queen winning would be a great one, expecially considered the whole redemption theme of as2. So I think that the producers - if Katya isn't liked - would give Detox a winner/robbed edit in the first half of the season to give her the crown.
Me parece algo curioso que en ambos "What if" de All stars 2, Katya y Detox resultan como las finalistas. Y en ambos escenarios pienso que ganaría Katya, sería una buena conclusión de su historia, y aparte complacería a varios fans del show, en mi opinión
A día de hoy llevo meses pensando diferentes formas en las que AS2 pudo suceder, y no logre figurar ninguna en la que Katya, Alaska o Detox no sean las ganadoras. Top 3 be that
Just a quick question. Are we going to not use the rule where a queen can only be up for elimination one time or less for upcoming All Stars seasons? I do think (but really do not hope) that they're gonna use that "you're either top or up for elimination" thing.
I think Katya would win just because her ru-demption story is slightly stronger. In this scenario Katya still has her whole "overcoming her anxieties" arc, where as Detox doesn't really have the "breaking away from rolaskatox" gig going for her.
I love to think about Alyssa being a front runner 😂😂 I would have loved to see her in the finale because she could have won. Little question: am I dumb or did you do a little mistake in the scoring of Ginger and Coco? You put 2.667 but shouldn’t it be 1.667? Sry if in wrong I’m just asking myself.😅😅
Detox is by far the all star definition. She is funny, SHE is glam, SHE has her own remarkable style of lipsync and she shouldn't have been eliminated in the snatch game episode so the fact that she returns and excell in the last 2 challenges and do her verse and read u wrote it makes sense with my fantasy. Instead Katya is a likeable queen so as Adore, but Detox is a legend
Katya wins this season she has the better track record after we take out the mini challenge points. But I will say detox’s failed to winner story line as a returning queen would be good. I still think Katya however
