Thoughts on todays video? I hope you enjoy, and have a great day!💚💙 Check the pinned comment! #anakinskywalker #ahsoka #anakin #clonewars #georgelucas #darthvader #starwars #whatif anakinskywalker #revengeofthesith #starwarswhatif
SABER GIVEAWAY DETAILS: -Step One: Subscribe to my channel “The Star Wars Galaxy” -Step 2: Click this link to fill out your information to be eligible for the Giveaway: docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScOX3xKxpcwj9vpYp3DqU9RoJNNbQRj2ki27s9VyckXBLnTfQ/viewform?usp=sharing -Our two Winners Announced on Monday, November 13th! -Ownasaber website (Check out their Black Friday deal!): ownasaber.com/
@@lottieparish1715 "bag of plan"? Nice to see I'm not the only person who over trusts voice to text.😁 (Once, while texting with a support agent for work, I realized I'd have to do a few things and then get back to them. So I told them I would just talk to the next agent. However, Google decided I was racist and that I meant to say I would talk to the next Asian.)
@@AustynSN I know it’s also possibly because I have fans on at the same time. By the way what time is it for you because for me it’s 11:51 I live in the UK where do you live?
Palpatine: Commander Cody.....The time has come......Execute Order 65....NO! I MEA- Commander Cody: It will be done, my Lord! Palpatine: ........I've got to get off of this planet!
It is easy to loose track of situational awareness in the middle of a fight. Especially since the sith channel strong emotion, even more-so when using dark side force attacks such as sith lightning, it is quite possible that Palpatine failed to notice.
@@user-vt2cr8qd1b The fact Sequel Trilogy FN2187 (Finn) could lift a lightsaber without the Force is still new, but what if every clone was force-sensitive?? That would mess up everything!!!
Except for one teeny tiny detail. With Palpatine gone, Padme wasn’t in danger of dying in child birth. That was his ploy to get Anakin to turn to the dark side.
@@TheRealMF_Kakashi Luke survived being shocked by lightning for a few seconds but to be fair Luke is force sensitive and force sensitive beings seem to be more physically resilient to being attacked in general
16:01 it would've been insanely funny if you referenced one of SLJ's lines. _"Windu Pointed his own lightsaber and yelled _*_"WASTE THE MOTHERF***ER!!"_*_ to the clones"_
I honestly think that Order 65 is one of those contingency orders that exists purely for the Senate to look at it and say, "well, that all makes sense." I don't think it was ever actually something that the Clones were taught to do. They were made because of the Sith, and I heavily doubt that Palpatine would let that one slide by, even if it would just be an inconvenience for him.
The Clones were created and taught as an army for the Jedi, by third party. Kamino was not in direct control of the Sith. There was no need for them to treat these two orders differently... If anything, order 66 was more questionable as it let their client destroy itself. If someone gave order 65 in meaningful way, it would be executed as clones would definitely be trained to do so.
Well, there's always the chance that a Jedi or someone else could've actually become the chancellor and Palpatine just wanted a way to screw anyone that wasn't him in power.
Do the clones need to be explicitly taught something that's hard wired* in a chip in their brain? (*Metaphorically hard-wired; I know it's an organic chip, which already doesn't make much sense so don't think too hard about literal hard wires...)
Except it was Darth Plagueis and not Palpatine who was the mastermind behind the Clones being built and it was he who give the codes to be programmed in through Dooku. Plagueis was grooming Dooku to be his Apprentice and it would totally make sense he would have made a plan to get rid of his Apprentice who had political authority over him. Plagueis had the wealth and influence were behind the scenes he could have bribed enough Senators to his side to actually initiate the order. I fully believe that was Plagueis' long game to have Palpatine be seen as power hungry where the only possibly way to get rid of him was through Order 65. Again most of Palpatine's successes in the Prequels are him running plays out of Plagueis' playbook and we see what happens to him and how long his Empire lasts when when his Coach isn't there making the plays. It's kinda like how successful or lack of success the Detroit Red Wings are minus Scotty Bowman. Plagueis was the Scotty Bowman to Palpatine's Steve Yzerman
pretty good story, and though I do think Palpatine would have sensed Rex, I was hoping it would be a clone that killed him (preferably Fox but I'm fine with Rex) so I'll accept it.
All conflicts revolve around one or more of three issues. 1. Resources 2. Communication 3. Fear No matter the conflict, if you dig deep enough, it always leads to one of these three issues.
I've been thinking about this a lot recently, but shouldn't Disney create a Star Wars 'What If...?' series like they did with the Marvel 'What If...?' series? Stories like this one would be pretty cool when they're animated, and I'm pretty sure that people would enjoy them.
I love this idea! Actually, I believe they have already done this, with episodes VII - IX. 😂😂 I am still waiting for Disney to give me a trilogy that actually concludes the Skywalker saga, and makes sense, canonically. “What if?” was a great comic series, and the MCU version was great as well. There are so many points in the Star Wars saga where things could go another way - some for the better, some for worse. Such as: . Luke missing the one-in-a-million shot, to destroy the Death Star; . The imperial gunner destroying the escape pod with R2 and Threepio on board; . Luke saving the lives of his aunt and uncle; . Obi-Wan hiring a different pilot in Mos Eisley; . Greedo shooting first, and killing Han; . Obi-Wan failing to deactivate the tractor beam; . Obi-Wan defeating Vader on the Death Star; . Biggs surviving the assault on the Death Star; . Someone else destroying the Death Star; . Somehow saving Alderaan; . Luke and Obi-Wan combining and defeating Vader; . Turning Vader back to the light on the Death Star - “Anakin, this is your son, Luke. Your daughter is over there, with your 3PO unit, and your R2 unit”. And so on. And this is all just in A New Hope! Cheers, Oh, one more thing, which has been bugging me lately: Obi-Wan knows Jango Fett is the template for the clone troopers. He also saw Jango Fett fighting, and dying, for Count Dooku on Geonosia - not to mention that he should know Jango was responsible for the attempted assassination of Padme. Why didn’t Obi-Wan suspect that something was amiss with the clone army at that point?
The 150 Orders were all very well known to the Senate and Jedi. The whole reason they exist is for the other 149 to mask Order 66, with Order 65 being the greatest mask as it makes it seem like they are just making every contingency plan they might need. Palpatine was incredibly clever like this, making his plan right under everyone’s nose and hidden in plain sight. The Senate and Jedi didn’t know, however, that the inhibitor chips enforced the 150 Orders if ever executed. Clones could not disobey the Order(s). Nobody except a very select few and the Kaminoans knew of the chips.
Excellent video nearly perfect. Only gripe is it should have been Thire not Thorn, as Commander Thorn died on Scipio a few months prior to Revenge of the Sith, but Thire he was on Coruscant and he actually shows up in Revenge of the Sith after the fight between Sidious and Yoda. That said perfect otherwise apart from that minor inconsistanty, the real question is what happens in the aftermath of the fight for the Republic in the long run, as there are a LOT of things that need to be addressed with Sidious dead in terms of corruption that needs to be addressed along with well what to do with the Clones, peace terms with the CIS, also there is a LOT of crime that needs to be wiped out as even with Maul imprisoned his followers are still out there and you of course have the Hutts, the Pykes the Black Sun and other crime syndicates that are causing issues. That said any timeline in which Sidious is killed before he can do lasting damage is a good one. Because I'm happy he's dead, also Rex killing him? Poetic justice if ever there was one and the follow up line of "That's for Fives" perfection.
Agreed, but I think it would actually be pretty easy to clean up after Palpatine. He had essentially rigged the whole system to collapse and allow for rebuilding when he made the call. On one hand, the Republic was reliant on him to hold itself up. On the other, without him, power returns to the Senate and separatists, and there's no one to suppress the voices crying for peace. I think Palpatine's efforts to mold and change the Republic into his own personal empire might actually make for an easy transition into a new Galactic Republic. Since Palps had a hand in every bit of senatorial corruption, you could feasibly retrace his steps or follow his transmissions and close circles to root out most of the biggest destabilizing forces in the Republic, stripping them of the power Sheev vested in them over his decade and a half long tenure
Matter of fact, with him being dead, there's every chance the Jedi have a new priority mission: tracking the actions of the Chancellor throughout his career as both leader of the Republic and leader of the CiS. Following through would essentially leave them at square one if it went well, not necessarily a purely just society, but at least free of the corruption of the last few generations of Sith. They'd be MUCH better off than the New Republic in canon. Those poor dudes had to rebuild the entire Republic almost from scratch and undo decades of indoctrination to the empire. This theoretical new Republic has a lot less to deal with, and they have the clones and the Jedi to help them achieve it. Hell, if they play it right, they could even rope the separatists in with some clever agreements.
What If Qui-Gon Jinn's ghost trained Luke SkyWalker What If Obi-Wan saved Anakin on MustaFar before he burned assuming Kenobi only cut off both of Vader's arms and not his legs What If Dooku was elected Chancellor instead of Palpatine What If the Jedi joined the Separatists
Fox would hesitate to attack Palpatine like Rex did when he attack Ahsoka because he kisses Palpatines ass Crosshair would be in the adjacent tower adjusting his rifile saying "Good Soilders Follow Orders"
@@mreggs3731 Thire: Commander Fox ur in Violation of Order 65 I accuse u of treason against the Republic you will be demoted and rank of commander and subject to execution along with the traitor Sheev Palpatine Fox: I didn't much like being a Commander anyway
I like how Anakin was still forced to make a decision in the end, taking only one mistake by one of the combatants to decide his path. Same as the movie yet so much different. What if Luke was "too much like his father," in the way that his uncle feared? More aggressive, unstable, sociopathic, or the like. Like he stays in the light yet his behavior is highly problematic. Or something like that.
What if Padme, in Revenge of the Sith, comes to Palpatine's office and tries to convince Anakin that Palpatine will not save her life after all the assassinations before he can kill Windu? What if Anakin discovers, before the Clone Wars break out, that Padme has abilities in the Force and trains her secretly or as his Padawan? What if Padme had only been a few weeks pregnant? What if Obi-Wan and Sabe had fallen in love and Obi-Wan learned of Anakin's marriage as a result? What if Anakin had saved his mother using Force healing without knowing about this ability beforehand? What if, while Anakin and Obi-Wan are at war, Padme tries to find out if Palpatine is corrupt, develops a very close relationship with him, and later offers to shadow him in Anakin's place and shares her findings directly with Anakin? What if Shmi never remarried and survives and tells Anakin in Attack of the Clones that Dooku is his father, whereupon Padme and Anakin try to get him back on their side? What if Dooku was just a separatist and apprentice to Sidious without becoming an assassin, and Sidious went through with everything (like the assassinations of Padme) on his own?
I have some suggestions: 1) What if the full potential+ Anakin that we see in Ahsoka as keeper of the World Between Worlds decided to go back to the beginning of Revenge of the Sith events and taking over his own past body but with all the knowledge and power he has now? Maybe he saw Palpatine surviving up to Episode 9 and decided he should do this. Its also possible that from his balanced perspective he sees that Order 66 is necessary to shake up the stagnant Jedi Order and corrupt Republic but a Sith Galactic Empire lasting 20 years whose defeat didnt even fully restored the Republic isnt. It would be so cool to see Anakin join Padme as the leader of this early new rebel alliance and defeat Sidious for good. An important data to consider, according to Imperial Law the one true power the Imperial Senate held was to crown the new Emperor should Palpatine die, this never happened because Palpatine dissolved the Senate with the Death Star complete, which broke the chain of command and led to a fractured New Republic. Here if he is defeated quickly enough the Senate can crown a new emperor who can then dissolve the Empire back into the Republic without having splintered factions like the First Order. But these are just my ideas I leave the story up to you the central premise is: Ahsoka's show Anakin goes back to his early ROTS body with the knowledge, wisdom and power he now has. 2) Same as before but this time rather than going personally he instead appears to end of Clone Wars Ahsoka. He will finish her training and she will do the job of the Chosen One being trained in both light and dark and lead an early rebellion to defeat Sidious. Remember Ahsoka has the life force of the Daughter and with WBW Anakin as her master she could certainly grow to defeat Sidious. When she is ready Anakin could even direct her to Bath on the Pool of Knowledge and Font of power, but because of Anakin overseeing the process and Ahsoka already having the Daughter's life and her training, she will not twist like Abeloth, but become a being of balance, ready to lay the smackdown on Sidious and lead the rebel seemingly impossible assault on Coruscant. Makes way more sense than Rey anyway. 3) What if Darth Tenebrous took Anakin's body? This was actually Tenebrous's ultimate plan and I have never seen a WI on it. He just failed because when he entered Plagueis's body he saw a futufe vision of Plagueis being killed by Palpatine, assumed he would never get to meet the Chosen One and panicked shooting himself out of Plagueis prematurely and getting trapped in a time loop. So, what if he didnt panicked and waited until the time Plageuis atually saw Anakin in the distance and shot himself at him? Plagueis's possession was not Essence Transfer, it was more insidious, moving his midichlorians (who he modified into "maxchlorians") like a virus. So rather than taking over Anakin by force like in your Plagueis video, he starts by increasing Anakin's power when he use the darkside and allows Sidious to do the heavy lifting forming his Empire, Anakin is way more powerful during the assault on the temple and Mustafar using, to the worry of Sidious, powers only advanced Sith can use like lighting. Then finally on Mustafar he hears a whisper telling him to open himself to the darkside fully so he can finally save Padme, Anankin does believing it to be his own darkside and Tebebrous finally takes him over. 4) What if Maul rather than sulking or just limiting himself to the underworld after the formation of the Galactic Empire spent his time training, went to Dathomir to learn from the Nightsisters (his potential was greater than Talzin) and he finally one day he shows up to overthrow Sidious? 5) What if after defeating Anakin, Obi-Wan realizing where he was reactivated the Droid Army on Mustafar but making it fully loyal to the Jedi like the Clones are loyal to Sidious? The Clone Wars continue with the Jedi remaining joining the seppies now without the influence of the Sith or the corrupt corporate council. Now Palpatine is in trouble because he has no puppet leading them and has been blocked from the command codes by Kenobi. And unlike Dooku the Jedi will not gimp the droid army's potential, like the fact it takes minutes to fabricate droids as opposed to years or months to train a clone or conscript. Leaders like Mon Mothma and Bail could also join on the condition that rather than secede they will restore the Republic on more fair terms, the Separatist Senate agrees. 6) What if rather than destroying it, Vader used Momin's portal to regain his uninjured body like Momin himself did?
This is a really creative way to make use of all the plot elements. It's more just an alternate take on events than a What-if, something that's just as likely to happen
You know how things cross your mind and then you forget about them this happened a lot with Star Wars and you’re writing about a lot of things I forgot I appreciate that
You know, I have always thought General Grievous's death in 'Revenge of the Sith' was too "well-timed." That said, I'm curious in a theory of what'd happen if Grievous survived his battle with Obi-Wan on Utapau? This could happen in one of two ways: 1. He escaped, or 2. He defeats Obi-wan I'd say the former is a lot more realistic of a scenario, considering both Grievous's character and Obi-Wan's experience with Grievous, specifically. Now at some point, the Sith will still turn against the Separatist Alliance. So would Grievous's long-term allegiance be with the Sith or with the waning Separatists? (I'd say probably with the Sith, because his primary goal is to destroy the Jedi, a goal for which the Sith provides a better means, and I don't think he'd REALLY care about the Separatist cause.) Would he assist Vader in killing the Jedi at the Jedi Temple or the Separatist leaders on Mustafar? Would he and Vader be able to settle their past differences, or would there still be tension? Would he become absorbed into the Imperial Army, or would Sidious still want him discarded due to his menacing nature and initial purpose in the Clone Wars? Would he fall rogue, just as Maul did after the events of 'The Phantom Menace?' The thing is, I don't think Grievous's survival would affect Palpatine's plan to destroy the Jedi and form the Republic into a Empire, but I'm curious what his fate, role, and impact would be had he survived past the rise of the Empire. I'm sure he'd have LOVED to witness Order 66.
"I must say, I'm not sure if it was the way you told the story or because I know the real story so well, but there was a time in this video when I was at the edge of my seat. The suspense and the emotions were all there. I love it! I would have loved to see a live-action version. The humility on Master Mace Windu's face at the end, the look of real fear on Chancellor Palpatine's face, and finally, the conflict of Anakin because he displays them so well in the movie. Even in the Obi-Wan show, he is still conflicted, and you can feel it in your heart. To see that conflict wash away and see the light come back would be awesome to see in live action."
Bravo, sir. I could nitpick this to pieces, but choose to just roll with it, and enjoy it for what it is - a best-case scenario that stops the Dark Times. It is a much happier resolution than what we got in canon. Thank you for sharing this. Cheers,
Palpatine: “Commander Cody. The time has come. Execute Order 65.” Cody: “Yes my lord.” Palpatine five seconds after ending the transmission: “Wait. Aw shi…”
Great story! Very entertaining. I always love stories where Anakin goes the different route, and we see what would’ve happened if order 66 was not given. A couple things though, I’m not sure Sidious would have waited after Anakin knew the truth and left him. Yes, there was a period of time where Anakin left the office to the Jedi Temple, but, the whole communication to for codes, etc. I’m not sure if there was time for that… Also resolution of him and Padmes relationship behind the Jedis back… that needed to be in there. I do love the vindication of fives with Rex. That was awesome! Oh, and one more thing, I think what a lot of people miss, is that the visions of Padme dying or being put in Anakin‘s head by Sidious…. I can’t remember where I saw that or read that, but it’s all one big manipulation. So once he died danger of her death, and even the visions go away…
I'll start off with an apology, I should have commented the first time I listened to this story, but this is several times afterwards. I love the setup, of how the two groups, senators and Jedi both came to the same conclusion, then in a manner that flowed instead of coming across contrived, they came together and made competent decisions. The action following also went well, to Thorn's decision to fire to ultimately Rex giving the finishing shots (nice conflict with Anakin btw). What led me to comment this time was listening yet again to how you read certain lines, the stress, the emotion, without coming across over-the-top, "That was for Fives." Thank you for another story I will (and have) returned to for repeat listening.
Jeez... I loved this story! You sir just earned yourself a new subscriber. I was really kind of excited since I just expected a straight forward explaination but instead got an emotional journey! Thank you very much and oh.... Merry Christmas^^
That story really has me wishing Star Wars had a multiverse so we could see Star Wars movies where Anakin never turned to the Dark Side and perhaps fought alongside his Jedi children. It would have been interesting to hear the council's reaction to Anakin's secret marriage. Were the rules changed for all? Or just for him?
i love your reference to the clone wars episode where yoda and palpatine are fighting on a bridge and yoda gets force shocked while trying to rescue anakin from falling
Order 65 is probably in case the Senate got wise and voted palpy out. Get rid of the other guy, replace him :P The clone order was put in way before palpy was given emergency powers
Enjoyed it very much..especially since this time ANNAKIN, survives..no longer secret wife in tow.. Also, nice to have the Jedi council surviving as well..in the process, the vast majority of the order.
Okay this is a very good story I did enjoy it I don't see how anything during the movie did that thing to do that because of the Clone Wars cartoon the obviously knows about the inhibitor chips but he does not do that but I like how you did this I do wish it was a lot longer and I hope you come back and make it part 2 to it and keep up the good work and May the force be with you
In a different channel i posted this idea. Glad you were able to see it through. Day 11: What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?
Love Your Videos keep it up but i wanted to ask how do you post a 20 minute what if every other day how long does it take do you have any tips? because i make what ifs but i don't even make 1 a week.
Well for me, this is basically my full time job. In making these i spend 3-4 hours writing, 20-30 minutes recording, and at least 2-3 hours editing. So I treat it like a full time job and put 7-8 hours into making these! It’s not easy and if you have school/another job then that should come first. Go at your own pace and make content you’re proud of
the Star Wars Galaxy did you get my comments on the community about the other what ifs I told you what if the Clone Army was force sensitive what if sifo dyas never died what if quinlan vos trained Anakin Skywalker, what if the Jedi Council trained Anakin Skywalker and lastly what if Anakin Skywalker went to both the Wellspring of life & ahch to please if anyone can do these what ifs along with many more is you man we believe in you we trust you always and forever 🤝👍👋
