What if Twilight Sparkle was a Villain? 

Nightmare Shining Armor to round out the family. EDIT: Thought of a name - Shattered Shield

Twilight Sparkle is suffering everyone's worst nightmare: being a college student

Literally the first episode of MLP Celestia basically told Twilight to touch grass

Ooh I'm imagining that after Luna becomes de-nightmarififed she's look horrified as to what happened and she decides that she needs to take down Twilight with the rest of the main six!

Please give us a good evil Fluttershy! I can’t even imagine what would cause her, maybe the land becoming barren due to the Eternal Night (tying into this AU? Oh how cool if there was a way to make a full evil Mane 6!) Or, the opposite, where she goes full swamp pony, OR maybe she leans into The Stare and becomes some mind controlling overlord?? The possibilities are endless! (Can you tell she’s my favorite? 😂)

I have seen many people asking for a Nightmare Shining Armor… And although I like it, I’ll throw a Monkey Wrench…. How about a Nightmare Spike?!! 😂

So if SHE is a friendless nerd she gets to have a cool shadow form but ME? NOTHING!

Divorce horse is just funny. Cadence as the pony of distaste is just funny and great 😂

Honestly there are not enough 'evil Twilight' concepts out there that aren't Midnight. Either that, or she gets corrupted by Sombra. I always prefered the idea of a Nightmare-ified Twilight than dark magic-ified Twilight.

Nightmare Big Mac!

Valley girl Twilight Sparkle isn't real she can't hurt you Valley Girl Twilight: *2:56*

I always imagined her nightmare being more like a version of cozy glow, seeing friendship as a way to control and be an empress.

i always feel that twilight was meant to be a villain, but only because she met her friends in season 1, was she able to actually grow out of her own vision of the world and move on to become a princess. otherwise, she could easily have been a crazed scientist

She's Moondancer now! 😂 (Maybe she could team up with her, actually.)

For story I think a sort of evil/misguided clown nightmare Pinkie would be amazing - like she wants everyone to smile so bad that she ends up hurting them

Your twilight voice in this video is so damn funny

Evil, alicorn Starlight Glimmer.

honestly evil twilight is something that i subscribe to. but specifically with twilight being the g5 villain. before watching this we just saw a video ON that and it was really cool

Do Rainbow Dash! I think her whole like "Oh I'm so cool I'm the best" personality that I can best describe as a Roxanne Wolf-like personality, would make her a very funky evil alicorn! Brain wash people >:3 Also maybe Pinkie Pie could get corrupted and Alicorn-ified and just be insane and make every pony party until they die-

I want to see Fluttershy or pinkie. I think they would look cool

I would really love to see your vision for an evil Moon Dancer. I love all the evil twilight theories and considering Moon Dancer is supposed to represent who Twilight used to be and where she could have ended up had she not made friends, I think she's a valid character to consider for a downfall.

super cool design! i love the idea of her hair losing any pink hue due to stress lol. honestly would love to see a midnight sunset. might be interesting with the fact that she's already associated with sun imagery

Love the backstory makes the name and this "evilfied" twilight really work! i wonder if through destiny the other main five eventually become twilight's friends and accidentally bring Celestia and the day back?

Nightmarify fluttershy! I say lean into flutterbat but also someone else said Kelpie and thatd be cool

Nightmare Derpy Hooves

"stinky bad sister" LMAO i love you

it would be cool to see a nightmare Starlight, Trixie or Sunset! Like twilight, sunset also got a form in the first movie, but it would be cool to see your interpretation!

Flames as always Jane, just flames. It’s so cool you went through the trouble of creating new stories for these designs. I’m still shooting for Shining Armor or even Spike the boys would like awesome in this style!

I stopped paying attention to the show before those Beautiful Kirin designs showed but I adore them SO Much! a nightmare-fied version of one of those guys in your style I know would look absolutely ballin. Also that zebra character..? Zeva? idk I just love a background character/creature variation XP

God she looks so cool!! Love the concept! Said something like this already but would love to see a nightmare fluttershy or even a nightmare spike!

Love the slay voices for the ponies, lol

i know the drawing is finished already but it would be so cool if her alicorn form had bookpages in her wings to really solidify her being overcome by knowlege

‘So then twilight’s sad because she couldn’t save Equestria by reading books’ goddamn u didn’t have to do her like that 😭😭😭

I feel like it would be cool if her cutie mark lost the white stars. They represent her friends, so because she went against destiny, and never met them, her cutie mark could change. Maybe over time the surrounding stars fade or change color.

With her becoming Midnight Sparkle I think it'd be cool if she had decided she was destined to be a princess and learned everything there is to know of it (like yours), but she realized she couldn't make it work on her own. Through the clouded veil of her self righteous mind she somehow manages to convince herself that she is better than everyone, INCLUDING Nightmare Moon. She then challenges Nightmare Moon for the throne, she either manages to win the fight (killing or banishing Nightmare Moon), or Nightmare Moon gives the throne up to her (perhaps she sees Twilight as a worthy successor?). Yeah anyways, diggin the idea and lovin the art as always!

If I may, I have an idea for evil Fluttershy. In the show, Discord couldn't use her insecurities to corrupt her, and the 2 of them eventually became friends. What if Discord tried to save her from death by making her an Alicorn, but it didn't work as intended and she becomes corrupt. I even have a name idea for her, "Fluttercrazy"

The ANGST QUEEN OF EQUESTRIA✨

i feel like we need fluttershy next!!, that would be so cool! or maybe rainbow dash idk

The godamn valley girl ascent I swear to god, I feel it

Nightmare CMC. I can see them doing a combination of Tirek and Starlight's shticks, but also with a downfall. So, obviously this is blank flank cmc, and they steal the cutiemarks of ponies, ending in them stealing their magic and their talent. They grow stronger with each talent they steal, and occasionally squabble amongst themselves if both share an interest in a specific cutiemark. But, it has a cutiepox-like effect, which is the slight nerf. Some of the talents may be useless or not needed to them in that moment, and will weigh them down, because their abilites are solely based on the cutiemarks they stole. Also, fun addition, i can see them standing on each others backs like a totem pole, to give the illusion that they're an alicorn, and therefore more powerful. Sweetie on top for the horn, Scoots in the middle for the wings, and Applebloom on the bottom

please expand on this AU 😭😭 I really wanna see the other characters on this!!

I love AUs that aren’t too dark horror-g0re! My favorite episode was the one where they saw all the alternate villain-winning worlds Not that I have a problem with either I just don’t like mixing it with mlp because it’s my safe space. This video made me happy, good job!!

This looks amazing! I'm glad you referenced the equestria girls evil twilight! Honestly I am loving this 'what if evil' series! Keep up the lovely work!

Do you think you could do Moondancer? I know she’s not really important but she’s my favorite I found really relatable when I was younger :]

Nightmare Trixie 😊

For those curious about HumanTwi/scitwi; She had this amulet to help detect equestrian magic and it accidentally started to absorb the magic of the Humain 6 when they would pony up. At a certain point she uses the magic to help her team win and it corrupts her

I would've liked to see her as the villain of G5, kinda like Luna's backstory, but twilight turns mad when her friends are gone, seeing other ponies having friendships and she can't connect to other ponies like she did with her own friends so now she destroys friendships. Thousands of years past an she snaps an Sunny and her own friends need to help an defeat twilight from bringing chaos an disorder.

I would love to see you make a tutorial for stylizes art. Your style makes me sooo happy.

No sleep Twilight damn. Saw your last video with cadence! Very excited and fun to see twilight💕

Valley girl voiced twilight is the perfect villain omg

Lmao the voices you did for nightmare moon and twilight

I love evil twilight stuff a lot so this was an awesome surprise!

I think that maybe Discord? I always liked his Crazy design..could be Fun?

The cutie mark star helmet hole is such a cool idea! Love your videos ❤❤ become a solid part of my schedule now haha

Her name; twilight sparkle, would make a lot of sense in this context, dark but a tiny glimmer of light in that darkness.

Evil breezies called dark winds

Yooo this is amazing!!! What would Villian Rainbow Dash be? Prisma Storm? Would you make it

i am in love with the voice you did LMAOO

01:45 [Acktually]: The term "sci!Twi" is NOT a fandom creation, but an official (internal) designation used by the original creator of the character [Meghan McCarthy] that the entire staff at Decode HalifaX Media (DHX) adopted for the rest of the production of the franchise. It works like this: 1a) Magician, Twilight Sparkle, The Unicorn

does midnight sparkle count as a nightmare form for twilight? 🤔

I really like that you made Nightmare Twilight is my favorite, but I would also like to make Nightmare Shining armor which is also my favorite to.

Gosh i love this au! And her design is lovely. I adore the sheet of her slowly turning blue and such too. I'd love to see any of the main six in future parts!

Yooooo love this and how you imagined twilight would sound

She got that gaming pc led wings. Very suiting for a nerd

I love the idea of evil versions of MLP characters just bc of either how goofy or how scary they are. I'd love to see an evil Shining Armor or Rainbow Dash (like the one we see in that one Episode where Pinkie finds out RD hates her pies and makes up an evil version of RD in her head lol).

Those are some cute pins! too bad I don't have any money :(( (My pupper had to get fixed so he could stay in my apartment) Lol I love how your 'evil' voice is just valley girl.

this drawing is absolutely magnificent

I really love how the glasses echo the magic flames around EQG Evil Twilight's eyes! Beautiful design work.

i'm obsessed with the voices u do for them

I was thinking... what if you draw a Nightmare version of Cozy Glow next? You know... it's like what if she, Chrysalis and Lord Tirek succeed with all friendship failing and staff? 😅

god, i love your shapes and how you draw the ponies so funky like

u sound pike that one girl from an animatic where she takes a cig then a girl steals hr bench and she dies and stuff and she haunts them when ur talking for twili. in a good way i love that animatic

I like the idea of an ASTV type encounter between the characters you design and the original characters, I know there was an arc like that in the comics somewhere but I just think it'd be funny.

Another comment has already said this, but do An evil shining armor to round out the evil family. And his name will be shattered Shield.

How about if there was a role swap, like what if Celestia was jealous of Luna and turned into a villain instead?

i had a very similar fic idea to this that i scrawled obsessively in my notebook in the middle of my shift at the grocery store lmaoo i just love evil fucked up girlies you have good taste!!!

5:15 you shall now be my faithful student. I’ll give you a new name: Darth Dusk

HELP FRIENDLESS NERD?? FIRST WE HAVE DIVORCE HORSE NOW FRIENDLESS NERD??💀💀😭

YEEEEEAAAAASSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!! I feel my cells powering up like a Godzilla charge beam!

I think we should do Fluttershy and how she turned because everyone always called her a pushover and a doormat and so she snaps

Hey I saw this art on tumblr!! This art and AU are both fantastic, so glad to see your thoughts on it!

Such a great work with colors

Do Pinkie Pie as a Nightmare villain next, please.

WOW IM STUPID?? I've been following your insta and saw the post and then saw this video and was like... how did I not know the spyro mlp designer was also nightmare ponies designer 💀

Twilight is so sassy in here

While human twighlight doesn’t stay in her evil form for very long, I’m pretty sure she spends the final equestria girls movie dealing with the aftermath of it all just how Sunset had to face the consequences of her actions during Rainbow Rocks (and in the RU-vid special “Most Likely to be Forgotten”) so at least it had an actual effect on her. (I have not seen all the RU-vid specials so idk if they explore this any further but I do feel like they made the most out of their doll quotas.)

DAUM!That desingn looks great!

Your color is always so impressive, I love it

It's super cool how you made that connection! Now I'm picturing that "free the magic" musical number but if it were ponies and not freaky humanoid but not human pony man things. That would be cool

oh my gosh! i think saw this on tumblr earlier!

Could you do a video of what life is like for Celsetia on the sun? Thankssss

The sassy accent was all it needed😂😂

You missed coloring in part of evil twilights wing, and now I can never not see it in my brain. It lives rent free 😂😂😭

friendless nerd😭🤣

HUGE fan of the voices you chose LMAO

Not a complaint, just somethin' I've noticed but, you've been drawin' a lot of horses lately 🤟🤟 They all look tremendous though fr

If Twilight was a villain she’d be far more interesting so I’m very into this idea

Gosh! I love all of your designs you have made so far, little disappointed that the shop only delivers in USA and not internationally but won't stop me from supporting your RU-vid channel!!! 💕💕

Starlight Glimmer would be a great candidate. Though idk how the Journey would differ from this Twilight since they're very very similar in these ways.

id love a nightmare rainbow dash!!!! you could use all the colors like a nebula or galaxy