Eldrazi Winters vs 12 Post 

I cannot express enough how great these paper gameplay videos are. There is just something special about live gameplay with paper magic.

Evetime Seth had glimmerpost enter tapped I died a little inside

Glimmerpost doesn't ETB tapped, which could have really changed a lot of plays...

These are quickly becoming my favorite goldfish videos! I would love to see 2006 legacy vs 2024 modern!

The play/draw disparity is so amplified at these power levels; so gross that every game was pretty clearly decided by who went first.

It was exciting seeing this match-up in Card Market's "Best Modern Deck Ever" series, and I am excited to see it again here! Interested to see how 12-Post will hold up this time without Amulet of Vigor to speed it up and Scapeshift to really cheat all the Locus in play.

I think reimagining old modern decks with 2024 cardpool like Seth said for 12 post is a fantastic idea and I wholeheartedly support it

“If you built modern cloudpost in 2024, how much stronger would it be” Very interested in seeing this as a video!

The forest rip off the top after the See'er just shows there is no thoughtseize bug, the universe just has a sense of humor.

The folks over at Cardmarket did a "best deck ever" series for modern. The finals of the entire tournament ended up being Eldrazi Winter vs. 12 Post, with 12 Post winning it all.

39:05 correct play here is to dismember the oblivion sower in response to the mimic triggers. Sower would be a 0/3 so Mimic's would not become 5/8s

i love these classic deck face-off, I have only heard about these crazy decks but actually never see a live breakdown of these decks

Would like to see a last game where you both play a 2024 version of the deck with the new tech that has been released. IE amuletpost vs MH3winter

I really enjoyed the GOAT magic you guys a few years back. Glad to see a paper variant since it was fun to watch the first time.

"Kill me from 27 Richard, or face your demise next turn, Emrakul is coming" Danm that was a badass line xD Love you guys for doing these kind of content. I always wanted to see a full match of 12 post vs Eldrazi Winter

Best MTG content creators!! Love you guys so much! Goals this year....listen to every podcast and every RU-vid video! Keep it going guys the community really loves you!

20:00 Dryad Arbor is in every GSZ-Deck since you can Zenith it with X=0 on t1

Oof. The Glimmerposts entering tapped hurts my heart. Also, game 3 - Richard didn't sacrifice Ghost Quarter. He just tapped it. Sure, Richard won right after, but still...

Love, love, love seeing actual cardboard games here. Please keep this style of video coming guys. Much love.

These are my FAVORITE! I hope that these videos do well/keep making them. Thanks

Love seeing both paper gameplay and these dives into broken decks 😮😮 though it is weird that 12-Post wasn't running Amulet b/c the version Cardmarket played in the Best of Modern tournament did run 4 Amulet :O Would you ever show us how you're able to get recordings that look this good, for those who want to also improve their spelltable setup?

I just realized the icons in upper left corner on Futuresight frames are the same icons used in MTG Arena card filter for card types. I just now put those two together.

Maybe one day we can get Memory Jar versus Mirrodin Affinity.

Not usually a fan of webcam magic but seeing you both collect or rent old banned decks to play out possible feature match ups is nice.

Some post video thoughts : 1. Did you guys both forget you played this match in GOAT magic and 12 post absolutely ruined eldrazi winter...? 2. Amulet was played in 12 post in a slightly later version, considered the better version but the defenders of this version might be actually better vs winter. 3. Would be very interesting to see a modern interpretation of those decks, using the core ideas with all avaliable banned or not banned cards in modern.

Eye of Ugin definitely is the card which made eldrazi winter work. Sure eldrazi temple is good, but the mana cheating was what enabled the incredible fast starts that coud kill on turn 3. Almost every other card in the deck feels like it has been crept by other cards which do the same thing but with less restriction to archetype. I think a good point was made that cloudpost has a better matchup against newer decks since almost no deck can beat a turn 5 emrakul. Post's biggest weakness was always dedicated land destruction which is kind of rare, or aggro that can get under it, which this matchup really showed. If richard went second and just didn't draw enough aggro then post won consistently.

OMG YOU ARE DOING IT! These straight up make my day!

I love these modern playoff games. Keep it up guys!

I love 12 post and would love to see what it would look like now if not banned because of some of the new cards.

Love these videos! Now do one with 2024 updated versions!

Commenting before watching just because I love that paper play content. This matchup was one of the best games in Cardmarkets best deck in Modern video, so my hype is real^^

Fun matchup as always! Would be cool to see other banned decks like Splinter Twin, or Eggs compete against a top modern deck of today (as they have been compared to Nadu - Splinter Twin comboing one turn later than Nadu and Eggs having a similar experience for the opponent). A Dark Depths or Lantern deck would also be cool to see if they'd hold up against the MH3 meta!

I love this series! Keep up the great work!

Legit best series ever. Get to see nostalgia decks plus how broken/unfair some decks were prior to bans

I would love to see a tournament of all of the banned decks rebuilt with 2024 cards. 12 post from 2024 sounds scary

Thank you for posting more paper magic I love this series! Commenting and liking to show my support! Also Seth please re-do some upgraded budget modern decks!

Love 12 post. One of my all-time favorite decks.

Love the best decks against themselves series. Always make sure to come back and watch. Like, comment. Keep them coming.

LETS GOOO, love these GOAT magic style videos, so much fun!!

This was a great video of a battle between two classic decks. Hey Richard sir!

These vids are just amazing, would love to see more on similar theme!

I would love to see this match up again but with updated deck list like they would be legal today in modern.

These "then vs now" gameplay videos are pretty fun to watch! and really shows how much the game has shifted, but stayed the same over all this time.

Love the commentary and this idea of a video and execution. Great job!

Love these paper 1v1 vids!!!! Keep it up

I would love to see someone build 12 Post in essentially current modern with only Cloudpost unbanned.

I feel like hangerback walker would be an all star in cloudpost😊

Dryad Arbor is in the deck to tutor with Green Sun's Zenith as 1 mana ramp.

Idk if Seth wins game 3 but Glimmerpost tapped not played off of Primetime hurt a lot of plays.

fun to see the more aggro Eldrazi Winter against cloudpost compared to the UW version from the cardmarket series

Seening those old decks back in action is definitely fun, but as mentioned, it might also be nice to see an updated version of them with all the current cards which would improve the decks

12-Post in 2024 would have access to so many tools that didn't even exist when it was banned that I doubt it would be healthy for the format. Scam would probably be its hardest matchup but 12-Post can go the distance and out-grind decks that can't close out a game quick.

Great content! Love your attitudes and commentary!

I used to have a locus commander deck where I would make the land into a creature then use copy effects on the creature lands. A cloudpost with a helm of the host on it is a ton of fun.

On magiccardmarkets best modern card tournament these decks met in the finals but with them 12-post came out on top so I guess the match-up is really close.

This reminds me of the awesome tournament videos you made with Crim :) the best deck bracket thingee

Card market also had a similar video that’s also fun to watch

This was really fun to see, but I feel like seth's list for 12 post wasn't as powerful as ones I've seen before. The list that took the cardmarket championship for best modern deck of all time seemed to be even faster and more consistent. Eldrazi winter deck was suprisingly disruptive though for being essentially an aggro deck. Also to me the decks seemed very equal. Whoever went first won.

I would love to see you all take these banned decklists and update them with current cards to see how much stronger they would become.

I would love to see a follow-up on this with "no banlist" versions using the current card pool

It would be awesome to seeing Legacy 12 post vs Eldrazi next time 😊

I'm loving these non-Arena, non-EDH gameplay videos! When are we getting some legacy content, new or old?

I LOVE these videos. Great stuff guys, would love to see more.

This takes me back when Conley Woods and Travis Woo used to absolutely dominate og modern with magical Christmas land decks

I dunno if it's feasible, but I would love to see historical versions of these decks face off alongside "modern" versions of what they would be and see if the match up still ends the same way

You should do a tournament of banned OP decks like this. I saw the Nadu v Hogaak and watching this I'm just left wonder "how would either of those decks do against either of these decks?"

As a commander player, this was fun and interesting to watch!

Rules check: Can generic mana be used to cast a spell with a colorless symbol?

Thank you for making this type of video I'm commenting for the algorithm!

Love this style of video! Keep up the good work guys.

I really need Seth to read glimmerpost. It doesn't come into play tapped

I don't know why dryad arbor is in the deck. You do know green sun's zenith for 0 gets the arbor right? Also glimmerpost doesn't come in tapped.

i love that Richard found a way to play and enjoy modern while avoiding the Nadu meta (even though he and Seth literally played Nadu last time)

I'd love to see these decks with no bans attempt to with upgraded sideboards/removal to fight current modern decks. Then maybe update them fully to see if they are still a menace in the metagame.

Love the series. Would love to see with some banned legacy or vintage decks

I kinda want you guys to do a runback on this episode and come up with a version (or multiple versions) of these decks but with more recent cards.

I would love to see this series expanded on and see these decks fight 2024 decks. Then, see them upgraded to fight against 2024.

which is better between cloudpost and any modern deck is answered by looking at the fact that its the deck that still exists in legacy, so if those decks dont its probably a big sign

Would love to see your take on the same matchup anno 2024 instead of the old decklists

Both these decks look like a blast to play... Kinda makes me wanna turn my Hazel deck into Eldrazi Squirrels XD

I genuinely love these videos.

Dudeeee I love this series!

Can we see a rematch where the cores of the decks are the same, but you both make some modern updates?

Love these Seth vs Richard Modern Videos. What about playing the current meta too? Say boros energy vs mardu energy or boros energy vs 2024 eldrazi?

I’d love to see you bring out High Tide or the Tolarian Academy deck.

I like the content. Personally I think this would be more interesting with decklists updated with new cards.

Can we get an updated 2024 version of these decks with the banned cards too just to see the power up

28:15 take one of the eldrazi to make Seth shuffle away his prime time

I would like to see what these two decks look like in a no-ban Modern build.

why slow roll game 2 Seth had 15 mana even without the Vesuva in hand

Its killing me that Seth keeps putting Glimmerpost into pkay tapped from his hand. Wonder how much it would have changed the games if it was played right.

Anyone else think they stacked Richard's deck to make it not suck as much? The same T1, T2 4 out of 5 games? Seth needs to grab the hypergeometric calculator! I thinka few more games would have shown 12-post better cus Richard was running hot.

Is there any plans to play this decks but updated with modern cards? it would be great to see how this decks would work with power creep in mind

Would love to see the strongest Legacy deck of all time vs the strongest Modern deck of all time

Would love to see these decks with 2024 updates. Maybe keeping it to no more than 10 - 12 cards so they stay somewhat the same and not just becoming whole new decks.

Just to note, IIRC Richard had turn 2 Thought Knot every single game. He definitely high rolled that.

I remember playing Bogles during Eldrazi Winter. It was one of the only decks that *could* beat it. Hilariously, 2024 Bogles would wreck Eldrazi Winter. Audacity, Lion Umbra, and Ram Through flip the matchup completely.

I love these videos, I hope you do one with pioneer inverter

I'm not convinced that Eldrazi was better than 12 post. Each game was won by who went first. I think the matchup is very close. And I don't know that either decklist was optimal, even from the cardpool of their era. I also would like to see a rematch, maybe with both trying to optimize with current cardpools (plus their banned cards).

I'm glad both decks had a chance to demonstrate how gross they can be.