Same it was so iconic and would’ve definitely been her era I’m so sad they took her hardwork away from her just bc of a bullying scandal that wasn’t even proofed right 😢
That's why so many kpop stans wanted her out lol that and she was beautiful. would have guaranteed bigger fanbase and success for le sserafim. was obvious from the start how fake ppl were iwth her
@@LucyPlop she had to give up her idol dream, but hopefully she can still fight for a career later. people are very cruel. if she debuts as an actress, then let her, there's no other members she will affect if she works alone.
@@user-wt5ow4nh7li dont know ALOT about them but from a video I saw it seems eunchae is more stable and therefore a better vocalist than garam, yes garam had a pretty voice color
@@notminghao Eunchae does have a nice voice, she's been taught how to sing. Do I prefer her voice? Not at all. Garam, however, I loved the tone of her voice since debut. It was so good to my ears that I would get her confused with Chaewon's vocals.
@@notminghao I just don't think Eunchae is a natural singer, I believe anyone can be taught HOW to sing, but some people are just born with the perfect, angelic tone that we all love. P.s. I am NOT one of those people 😂 but I don't get that from Eunchae's voice either..
That was a skit , it is a show called idol human theater where the skit is all about Controversies Mopping the floor with your own members by Enhypen Did not like their members Hate their members Want the members part This is all a skit written by KBS production teams, not only Lesserafim even Twice Straykids, Enhypen, TXT and other group they all are in the same show
Honestly this is double standard, why do y’all take this too personally when they were just correcting Garam of how to do the move but y’all bash the members and this was a skit from what people say when in fact, during when the bullying controversy happens, y’all were literally hating on Garam and even bullying her
When Garam is gone. that part was given to Eunchae. not before This is from the “Idol Human Theater” show everything is scenario Other groups also have videos on this show and its content is like this. It's a joke and Garam knows it. They're all in this together. If you watch a few episodes of this series you will understand what is happening.
Fr when she dances it's always like she was born to be there especially when she's at the center, she has such huge potential of being one of them it girls 😢
Please be informed that this is a scene from idol theatre where idols ad-libs scenarios given to them by the production staff of the show and often make 'controversial scenes' as a skit or part of the show.
@@huongho6302 Its concept of variety “idol human theater”, you can see all video of variety, this concept its so weird cuz member must did something bad each other (example:txt skz etc. yeah all its role-play)
@@debb7 Its concept of variety “idol human theater”, you can see all video of variety, this concept its so weird cuz member must did something bad each other (example:txt skz etc. yeah all its role-play)
@@viankacarrias no shes not 1.garam and eunchae were freinds 2. its a skit 3. what your doing to eunchae is the same thing people did to garam make her look like she was mean
Blue Flame was truly Garam’s song fr I can never get over how great her vocals sound in that song which is y Blue Flame is my most favourite by Lsrfm. Eunchae did her part rly well and fits her well too Missing Garam very much whenever I see the old videos girlie deserved so much more I hope she’s doing better now
Eunchae probably does this choreography in the antifragile era, Garam did it during the group's first performances. You could say that Garam may have been more stressed than Eunchae back then, that's why they both danced the choreography differently in comparison based on time that passed @@aqs_A_Tree
BRO I WOULD BE SO ANNOYED IF THAT WAS ME GUYS I DON'T WANT TO START DRAMA ALL I'M SAYING IS THAT I WOULD BE ANNOYED IF THAT WAS ME LIKE IDC IF IT'S A SKIT
It is a skit written by the production team of KBS, have you even the watch shows If you don't, you don't have the right to judge someone just because you saw one clip
@@cignaturestanz are you an idiot, have you ever watch the shows??? Not only Garam every other group also has this kind of skit. Please go and watch not only Lesserafim but other groups video also only then you will understand
Its concept of variety “idol human theater”, you can see all video of variety, this concept its so weird cuz member must did something bad each other (example:txt skz etc. yeah all its role-play)
When Garam is gone. that part was given to Eunchae. not before This is from the “Idol Human Theater” show everything is scenario Other groups also have videos on this show and its content is like this. It's a joke and Garam knows it. They're all in this together. If you watch a few episodes of this series you will understand what is happening.
Like yea eunchae did the choreo better but garams voice is the one that completes the group. Idk it always felt so empty after her and idc if it’s been a year, i still want garam back
I’m glad we all still agree…so many haters were so quick to be “it’s better as OT5” but I felt the group is not lacking because of Garam leaving and it’s kind of exposed how bad Kazua and Sakura’s vocals are because they’ve had to take more vocal lines bc Garam was vocalist with Yunjin and Chaewon. I do think that Garam provided more charisma to this choreo too than Eunchae
@@Itsdustybunzthey ARE better as 5. They standout more as a group that way and there’s a reason they’re doing far better without her success wise. As for Garam’s vocals she could not sing live at all and had she stayed y’all would’ve been dragging her alongside the other members y’all consider bad vocalists.
@@ffion4278 that’s your opinion, some people think they’re better as 5 and many think they’re better as 6. :p as for her vocals. Her vocals are way more stable than Eunchae, Sakura, and Kazua. Her stage presence was great. And the only reason it was ever seen other wise was because the scandal. To say the group got more popular after she left is dumb cause they literally had just debuted obviously they can only go up from debut. And it’s not dragging other members down. They simply are not strong vocalist. That’s why each member has their own role. Sakura herself even asks for less lines because she knows she can’t sing. It’s been a year now stop jumping on the blind hate train 💀
@@Itsdustybunz it’s a borderline fact tbh because they were a 6 member group for all of 5 minutes. But in comparison to the very few ot6 performances we got it’s clear that as a 5 member group their formations are better, their performances are stronger, their group dynamic seems to work better, and to top it off they’re far more successful now. Which wouldn’t have happened if they stayed 6 because they would not have stood out the way they do now especially not with IVE being a top group since that’s who they were heavily compared to. I say the group is more popular now because when her level 5 punishment was revealed fearless began dropping on every kchart there was. As soon as she was put on hiatus it started rising again. Had she stayed they would’ve struggled to chart. There’s no guarantee for growth post debut look at groups like Kep1er. Lol it’s been a year stop clinging to a fantasy of Garam because you feel bad she got kicked out and start looking at things as they were. Her stage presence was fine but in no way was it big enough for her to feel like a major loss to their performances. Now if someone like Chaewon left you would instantly see a sharp decline in their performances. Her vocals were not more stable than Eunchae’s she proved that when they sang a line from sour grapes live together and Garam was the main one having pitch issues. I’m not dragging Garam down she simply was not the vocalist you people claim she was based on their heavily edited debut EP.
Garams voice suit well, but Eunchae did a great job to cover my beloved garam's line😢 december 25, 2023 this day and how many days left before year 2024 but I still missed garam so much, I still love her even if there is a bullying accusations or not she's my no. 1 bias🎉❤
@@LillyLixieThey aren’t, her live vocals are well below where anyone with training should be. Not her fault, mostly hypes, but she can’t sign well live at all.
Uhh brother uhhh being completely honest eunchae's voice can't be compared with garam's y'all fr?? Garam's voice is wayyyy tooo good to be compared with HER!?🤨🤨
@@-navrattann uhh and I was comparing their vocals? Bc her getting the part out if everyone is ridiculous bruh they're singers for the sake of god not dancers and making someone with better vocals take that part would have been better since eunchae's voices is the flattest out if everyone and on top of that it's garam's part that she'll be taking like brother WHAT-👴
@@bangtanlove3586 HELPP😭😭 there singers and dancers that what an idol is.. it’s common sense bro, and also they were agreeing on the dancing part because garam was getting it on beat not the singing part. So calm down like😹 also Eunchae voice is very unique your just mad that you can’t sing so that’s why you go hating on idols that aren’t your biases
this is variety name “idol human theater”, everything is role play, i really hate this concept of variety cuz other group must say something bad each other.
Except Eunchae was the one member closest to Garam. Y’all are just bitter towards Eunchae now and making up narratives because she’s thriving while Garam is a civilian.
@@ffion4278 right??? Eunchae and Garam was closest with each other and now that they can’t see Garam, they are starting to hate Eunchae over a fucking skit
Blue flame and sour grapes were Garams songs and will always be. Her dream lasted for 2 weeks before getting kicked out. We will never forget her or her amazing voice
Eunchae definitely danced to it more powerfully, but honestly Garam’s voice just fits that part better. I also feel sorta bad for Garam during that interview clip 😭
why i always feel like eunchae is so spoiled, she never admit that she's not enough as a singer but instead of practicing more she just crying and want people to understand her lol😂
Well at least garam knows how to sing, i don't think so any of the le sserafim member can sing and giving the excuse that not everyone is same is just dont make any sense, because they are idol.
Garam’s voice is so…yk? The song is so complete with her voice. Everyday i’m gonna pray that Garam comes back to le sserafim even tho it’s problaby not gonna happen 😔
Nothing wrong with praying…I do wish she could return although very unlikely. The group could have been so much more with her in it still. Especially vocal wise
@@Itsdustybunz Definitely agree. I think she did say her dream is now to pursue acting so I will support her new dream😊 I miss her voice in sour grapes though:(
You can see the disappointment in Garam's face when Eunchae was doing her part. Garam already performed it, she just needed more practice that time. I mean Eunchae is good but no one will ever beat Garam.
что ты несешь? участницы сами любят ынчэ, а ынчэ над ними шутит иногда. Она это говорила на звездном дневнике, про гарам вообще молчу, они были лучшими подругами, лол
If Garam was still here, le sserafim would have been way more balanced since garam's vocals are do good, which compensate in a way enchae sakura et zuha
Garam hits better in blue flame and sour grapes. I can never get over the song bc of Garam’s presence. Like she only got 2 weeks of being a kpop idol and now it’s gone💔
Its concept of variety “idol human theater”, you can see all video of variety, this concept its so weird cuz member must did something bad each other (example:txt skz etc. yeah all its role-play)
@gumishii i think it’s right to spam something that is a fact? Why would they stop if this clip has been took out of context and spreading misinformation that causing a hate train for Eunchae?
i don’t want to listen to the 2023 ver of blue flame cuz garam‘s voice suited it so well!! 😭😭 not saying it doesn’t suit manchae cuz her voice is really beautiful as well, but that part was made for garam
It's just better with all six. Garam was thrown to the wolves, and the behavior both before and after of the company and some of the other members makes me side eye the whole situation.
@@LucyPlopthen how do you think should the members react? As if it’s your first time to encounter a member was removed from the group and the members were not talking about the former member. Jessica? Soojin? Stray kids? Exo? The company cannot use any picture, video, or any info of garam as they no longer have contract with each other. Because it will be like selling a private individual’s information. The scandal during debut was so heavy that the members have no choice but to bounce back immediately from that. Bullying was a very very negative scandal since the recent years. The company decided to give hiatus to garam to remove the spotlight of her ‘bullying issue’ but knetizens were still angry about that saying maybe the reason why hybe can’t remove garam was because she have a powerful backup from hybe.
@@LucyPlopoh get over it. It’s her own fault she’s no longer in the group it’s not Lesserafim’s job to keep her name in the spotlight when her very existence in the group harmed their success and ruined their debut.
@ffion4278 I'm sorry her own fault😂, anyways...the reason she was let go is because crazy ass fans wouldn't stop harassing hybe about her still being in the group , and then SAME FANS got mad when hybe was trying to defend her of allegations that caused the hate, but they also get mad when the company doesn't defend there idols and call them lazy? Like it's not making since 🤨, and let's not forget the fact that fans blindly believed said allegations with very little evidence and started sending death threats and hate to a 16-17 yro , only to find out 5 months later after she's officially left the group that she was innocent the whole time, and that she was only defending her friend. It's not garams fault honestly it's the person who made up the fake allegations and the fans fault that garams overall image was ruined.
@@Sweet.home3333 I don't even think that you are an Engene. You must know better abt hate trains that used to exist in Enhypen just because of misunderstanding and how the said people suffered because of it. You are an bringing shame to your own fandom.
Garam had such a pretty voice, like she was in the top 3 alongside Chaewon and Yunjin.... Le Sserafirm really lost a beautiful voice. She was perfect within the group and I can still imagine how well she would have done in all their other songs. Eunchae does a great job covering her.
I agree. Without Garam there’s only two vocalist in the group and it’s really exposed how low the singing abilities are of Sakura and Kazua. The group was made for 6 in mind…it just doesn’t work anymore for me, especially missing her vocals
@dustylee21 Yeah, Kazuha and Eunchae are slowly working on their vocals, but without Garam it's just going to slowly. And Sakura needs lots of time to work with her vocaltraining, considering all the bad habits she has to unlearn and how she has to work on her damaged vocals.
“It’s always eunchae” so i guess you follow them or a fan since debut, right? How come you don’t know that this video was just a mere skit for some show💀💀💀
Garam, she has that different vibe from the other girls, when she gets to the center.. it suits her more! Even her voice makes a difference within the group.
@@briananana4545 maybe it is good that Garam doesn’t have to live with people who don’t like her now she is studying to become an actress and we will see her on the big screen again
Please be informed that this is a rehearsal scene from idol human theatre where idols ad-libs scenarios given to them by the production staff of the show and often make 'controversial scenes' as a skit or part of the show. Please watch the whole video here to know the whole scenario.
