When Two Filmmakers Make the Same Movie

Подписаться 700 тыс.

Просмотров 835 тыс.

50% 1

Start exploring the riches of cinema with an extended free trial at mubi.com/likestoriesofold
Help me make more videos!
Support this channel: / likestoriesofold
Leave a One-Time Donation: www.paypal.me/TomvanderLinden
Facebook: / likestoriesofold
Instagram: / tom.vd.linden
Twitter: / tom_lsoo
About this video essay:
Last year, two filmmakers made the same documentary about volcanoes. One got nominated for an Oscar, the other one was made by Werner Herzog. Let’s talk about what his film, The Fire Within, reveals about the meaning of ecstatic truth, the deep humanism invoked by sublime wonder, and the inexplicable magic of cinema.
Content:
00:00 Introduction
02:10 In Search of Adequate Images
05:06 Competing Filmmaking Philosophies
09:04 What is Ecstatic Truth?
13:02 From Sublime Wonder to Humanism
17:07 The Inner Chronicle of What We Are
Listen to my podcast, Cinema of Meaning:
iTunes: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/4n6zZZQ...
RU-vid: / @cinemaofmeaning
Nebula: nebula.app/cinemaofmeaning
Further Reading:
Like Stories of Old - The Complete Reading List: kit.co/likestoriesofold/readi...
10 Books that changed my life: kit.co/likestoriesofold/10-bo...
10 More books that inspired my thinking: kit.co/likestoriesofold/10-mo...
My Camera Gear: kit.co/likestoriesofold/my-tr...
Music:
Canyon City - Simple (instrumental)
Benjamin Martins - Ether Sku
Alon Peretz - Shimmer
Take your films to the next level with music from Musicbed. Sign up for a free account to listen for yourself: fm.pxf.io/c/3532571/1347628/1...

Кино

Опубликовано:

22 май 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 659

@LikeStoriesofOld Год назад

If you want to support my work and get access to the LSOO Discord server, Q&A's and other fun extras, please consider donating to my Patreon page: www.patreon.com/LikeStoriesofOld Thanks!

@mairiamonitino6637 Год назад

where is the Herzog documentary streaming please?

@Mtl-zf9om Год назад

Those clips of Katia standing close to a lavafall is both scary and beautiful.

@calebchan314 Год назад

Great documentary/video essay!

@MCHammer79 Год назад

Hey man! If you happen upon reading this comment, then please consider doing a video on The Banshees of Inisherin. That movie was so beautifully written and has so many layers to it. It truly is both tragic and beautiful

@bathan901 11 месяцев назад

@@calebchan314 😮yes I’m😮th one who has tr🎉😢😢like 😢a 😢😢😢 10:45 m😅u

@jimjimgl3 Год назад

I can't think of anything worse than having my documentary premiere the same year as a documentary with the same subject matter by Herzog

@PanzerBuyer Год назад

I know right!?

@LordSesshaku Год назад

I can, that then your documentary gets more award attention than Herzog's due to being backed by National Geographic, but then, years later people talk about Herzog's and not yours.

@jimjimgl3 Год назад

@@LordSesshaku double whammy

@EggBastion Год назад

@@LordSesshaku psh Nat Geo is a brand and a buncha flim flam I can't believe I used to look up to it and it's readers as a kid

@DaveMeuleman Год назад

@@EggBastionBack in the day it was a cool magazine, and they made good documenteries. Now it's just a cash grab...

@griffredarmy Год назад

Those images are mind blowing. The shots of them in the protective suits with a river of lava coursing behind them seem unreal. It looks like something from a 50's sci-fi movie.

@AaaaNinja 11 месяцев назад

The camera is actually very very far away using a zoom, it flattens out the perspective so while the person in the suit may actually be miles from the fountain that you see in the background, the flattened perspective makes it look like they're almost touching it. Because perspective may be the only clue you have as to distance. It's an illusion. The heat is still incredible even at that distance. I was at an outdoor Disney show and I could still feel the heat radiating from the pyrotechnics a soccer field's distance away because I did not reserve a seat for the show.

@kristjanpeil 9 месяцев назад

Adequate images.

@EternamDoov 2 месяца назад

'50s

@meghbhavsar3968 2 месяца назад

the footmarks on the black sand...the blackness of the sand feels so ethereal.

@ConfusionPlus2 2 месяца назад

Its the one really stand out scene used in this video that really captured my imagination. It's excellent.

@dw5523 Год назад

I had a momentary existential crisis hearing that voice, THAT VOICE, come out of a younger man than I'm used to seeing. What a treasure this guy is.

@NullStaticVoid Год назад

you really have to watch Burden of Dreams and Aguirre Wrath of God as a double feature.

@filmnobelpreis Год назад

@@NullStaticVoid Fitzcarraldo*

@DarkAngelEU 9 месяцев назад

@@NullStaticVoid Burden of Dreams changed me from wanting to write fiction to simply describe and philosophize on the nature of reality. Easily the best thing I've ever seen in my life.

@muadddib 20 дней назад

Everytime I hear Herzog now there is a tiny part of my mind that only hears _"I vant to see ze chaild"_

@icyearth Год назад

This slow type of documentary is very common, the standard I would say in German documentaries. Growing up seeing that type of filmmaking on TV, then later on watching the fast paced American style, made me appreciate the sense of calm and admiration created with each shot. It makes it feel more alive, organic and raw.

@ProfessorBoswell Год назад

Yeah, you hit on something important, his pace is thoughtful in every sense of the word

@squirlmy Год назад

Although, you get some of that feeling from comparing just about amything to American TV!!! Especially the commercials, of which there are ridiculous amounts to get through in normal american TV broadcasts.

@oakfat5178 Год назад

@@squirlmy Even classical music. US orchestras are inclined to play a piece at a faster tempo, slow and thoughtful suits me better.

@tessiepinkman Год назад

I feel the same way, growing up in Sweden. The documentaries from around here are paced (in my opinion) much better than the American _"3-seconds-then-switch"-style._ Okay, I may have exaggerated the American pacing, but you get what I mean. It's not the same. And I'm sad to say that the younger generation of filmmakers (and I'm not old, I'm born -90), are leaning more towards the American style - because they don't think that our _"native"_ style of editing will capture an audience. There are exceptions, of course, and I hope that the public will speak loud enough to show those in the business that the _"Swedish way"_ is the Swedish way for a reason.

@christianlingurar7085 Год назад

danke. jetzt fühle ich mich nicht mehr so allein.

@UATU. Год назад

Every time I need some existential perspective, I rewatch Cave of Forgotten Dreams and let Herzog hypnotize me with the enormity of deep time and fleeting sparks of human meaning.

@fdllicks Год назад

Im a long time Herzog fan and that was the only one i was lucky enough to catch in the theater for the full experience.

@UATU. Год назад

@@fdllicks I think watching on a big screen would have caused sensory overload, but I envy you.

@brianmiller1077 Год назад

@@fdllicks was it also in 3D?

@prime-mate Год назад

Hands down, my favorite documentary ever..

@davidhull1481 Год назад

I just watched the trailer for this, and I have a question. Does that music occur all throughout the movie? I ask because I found it irritating.

@brandonmorel2658 Год назад

Herzog's theory for art analysis has deeply changed how I look and engage with media in general. He taught me to never ignore this abstract gut feeling that tells me when something is true beyond the factual. It's a beautiful and elusive feeling, it has even happened with many of LSOO videos. Thank you for your videos.

@byucatch22 Год назад

In the words quoted in this video, there is something truly sublime about knowing a truth because you have felt it through your soul. Not a surface-level knowledge arrived at by a surface-level experience, but a life-altering knowledge gained through a life-altering feeling.

@Martschy 5 месяцев назад

gut feeling isnt that abstract. it can become very physical.

@johan8969 3 месяца назад

I am instantly reminded of the man who taped a banana to a wall. It gives me nothing. It provokes no feelings. I understand the intention, he wants to provoke an abstract discussion about art, but he does it with something that does not give a gut feeling. Which makes me believe that he doesnt understand this beautiful and elusive feeling art can provoke. It becomes a discussion instead of an experience.

@ZuhatzArt 3 месяца назад

@@johan8969🎯🎯🎯 yes all the 'banana tape' clone artists think the rational mind is Godless. without spirits. as if they're the dead talking but about life.

@mumblesbadly7708 Год назад

Werner Herzog is probably THE most important film director from to come out of Germany for the past 60 years. The guy is a living legend!

@RowieSundog Год назад

I never realised how massive those lava flows were until seeing a human figure suited up against the heat striding towards them

@chucklebutt4470 Год назад

You should learn more about pyroclastic flows/surges if you haven't already. They're terrifying and ultimately what took the lives of the Kraffts. The destructive power of them is hard to imagine. One minute you're standing there and the next a river of 1,000 °C gas and debris is coming down on you at 100-700 km/h. There's images of what used to be concrete buildings with just the support pillars left and the steel rebar at the top bent over like grass in the wind.

@RandallStephens397 Год назад

The Fire Within was my introduction to Herzog and boy howdy did it convince me that he's a brilliant documentarian right from the start; the way he opens it, it's as if to say "you're here to see volcanoes, so here: let's just look at some volcanoes, because they are awesome!" and the rest is just letting the subject speak for itself.

@lorenarcp Год назад

Hey, Randall! When you can, watch Werner's first docs -- I feel they hit different, more interestingly

@bobdhitman Год назад

Welcome to the Herzog fan club. Enjoy the rest of his work!

@ProfessorBoswell Год назад

Yes! Unlike most filmmakers he lets the subjects speak and truly listens, his images and even his use of other peoples' images are unparalleled. Watch everything he's made! His fictions and documentaries are so great. I don't like steering people but one fun thing to do is watch his 5 collaborations with Kinski, then watch Burden of Dreams and My Best Fiend. So great.

@comfykeegs Год назад

Little Dieter has a special place in my heart

@princequestly2218 Год назад

And filmmaker.

@marshaltito7232 Год назад

One of my favorite films of all time is Herzog's Lessons of Darkness. The way he doesn't focus on the war itself nor about heavy moralizations of war one way or the other. Instead, he just shows the aftermath and the cleanup in stark beauty, leaving a deep sense of melancholy that speaks for itself. He is truly a brilliant aesthetician.

@Leonorexplore Год назад

I met the Kraffts when they showed their documentary in my hometown. Both were very pleasant, humble and accessible. RIP Katia and Maurice.

@kaufjonas Год назад

I'm a young filmmaker studying philosophy with a special interest for Werner Herzog. Thanks for analyzing Werner's Philosophy so deeply, and to spread the word. It gives us the chance to re-enter an era of well-thought art.

@WaxPaper Год назад

Check out Demian, by Herman Hesse. It's a quick read, but it's great. I only bring it up because over the years, I keep hoping some young filmmaker will finally try to adapt it to film. I read it when I was 15, and it changed my life.

@puncherry Год назад

Theres a Herzog retrospective at the Deutsches Kinematek rn , but deepness is not for everyone, it never was

@classifiedtopsecret4664 Год назад

Jonas Kaufmann are you aware of the "leaked" Timothy Treadwell audio of the bear attack ? and thru studying Werner's work do you think it is the real audio or a reenactment of the actual audio?? Just curious 🤔 thanks.

@kaufjonas Год назад

@@classifiedtopsecret4664 it's a reenactment... but to a certain extend I agree on Werners approach to gain access to "ecstatic truth"

@classifiedtopsecret4664 Год назад

@Jonas Kaufmann i could never make my mind up if it was real or not.. .50/50. . But it is a very good reenactment. .it is haunting. When i first listened to it my heart died and i thort i would never forget the noise he made. .but got over it quicker than anticipated.

@TempusViator Год назад

"All these dreams are yours as well" is such a beautiful distillation of why we make art

@DawidUliczny-ro7eo Год назад

There is a beautiful shot from The Grizzly Man (4:55 in this video), where he disappears up the path into the bushes. The shot is framed so well you could be there for hours and not get it. You can hear the wind rustling, everything in the frame is moving, and yet the sequence instills a feeling of stillness and peacefulness with a slight hint of nostalgia

@LosBerkos Год назад

So in other words, you did not watch this video prior to commenting.

@LarryPanozzo Год назад

Wow, loving this. ‘Adequate’ by the standards of a film legend naturally helps everyone raise their standards.

@atomicsmith Год назад

I don’t think he means adequate in terms of film criticism. I think he means adequate in terms of conveying the enormity of nature and man’s place in it. In that case, “adequate” is a very high bar.

@ReynaSingh Год назад

9:39 ecstatic truth is what sets apart works of art. Anyone can repeat a series of facts, but even those facts are part of a grander narrative

@mrpawan969 Год назад

😮❤

@squirlmy Год назад

You might like vampire film "Only Lovers Left Alive" from Jim Jarmusch It symbolically turns art appreciation around. The vampires are art lovers, especially of things like underappreciated old rock songs. But their love of art gives them a rationalizion for feeding on humans! 😮😢😅

@kareliask Год назад

If anyone wants to see the greatest extent of the slow shot style of Herzog, do give Lessons of Darkness a try. Some truly otherworldly images that will never be captured again.

@ProfessorBoswell Год назад

Love that one! Something funnier is that festival audiences hated it, because he used the gulf war images for something deeper, they just wanted a "bad guys good guys" documentary

@pauld4628 Год назад

I think of those opening shots from Aguirre with the whole column marching over the mountains and jungle and you're just consumed by the imagery and music; the sheer scale of not just the movie but the actual subjugation of two continents.

@vashsunglasses Год назад

I watched both documentaries a couple months back and I highly preferred Werner Herzog's one. I'm surprized the other one won an award, it just seemed like an average documentary to me, nothing special. It just taught me the facts of those people's lives, but Herzog's expanded my understanding of human nature. Or, to be more precise, it gave me a few more tools that I can use to expand my understanding. A wider perspective of human experience.

@ProfessorBoswell Год назад

Average documentaries are always the ones that win awards

@comfykeegs Год назад

Precisely

@TheGotoGeek Год назад

@@ProfessorBoswell Hoop Dreams wasn’t even nominated, so I think you’re onto something.

@theawfullest Год назад

I couldn't get through Fire of Love. It spent too much time mythologizing how much this couple loved each other and how we should be in awe of volcanos. Like, both of those things can be true, but it felt really shallow and repetitive to me.

@danil8663 Год назад

The Krafft footage is just so good that I really liked Fire of Love, but still the narration added basically nothing.

@pterodactylpie8825 Год назад

Cave of Forgotten Dreams is a priceless treasure of a movie, the quietness you feel while watching, there’s just nothing else like it. I’m forever grateful to Werner Herzog for sharing that cave and it’s history with us.

@ProfessorBoswell Год назад

He brings those humans from so long ago alive in a way I've never seen. Some other filmmaker could spend millions on locations, costumes, makeup, research on paleolithic people, etc, and still not show them as deeply as he did.

@NullStaticVoid Год назад

Just wish it wasn't done with that damn 3D camera. My eyesight cannot work with those types of 3D. So I get a nice headache for trying.

@Godsen5 Год назад

I never really understood why people liked Herzog so much. Until 2020. In Italy we went full lock-down (one of the strictest in the world) and came out in May, cinemas were allowed to operate with weird rules in July and there was this place where they projected old films among one new titles each couple weeks, and I went for the first time since the pandemic hit in February to watch a movie. The movie was "Nomad" about Bruce Chatwin. And, apart from the motion of being in the theater, with the mask, one or two seats apart from my then girlfriend, with the door in the back open, etc. Apart from all the cinema-in-a-pandemic commotion, I finally got it. The way he traffics through Chatwin's bag finally gave me the right feeling. There was a sort of materiality and even a bit of awkwardness, and the attempt was to communicate a sort of truth through images, as if to prevent the images to transform Chatwin's life into spectacle. It did have a strong impression on me and from that I could understand (in the sense of tuning myself to the right feeling) also others of his movies.

@MISTERMANTICORE Год назад

Werner Herzog is one of the greatest filmmakers alive today.

@brandonmorel2658 Год назад

Herzog is really great and his work has illuminated and widened my limited human experience and soul. His philosophic approach and theory have put into words theses experiences and little flashes of "Sublime" I've felt when I have engaged with media like "My Dinner with Andre" or even "Disco Elysium".

@ProfessorBoswell Год назад

One of the greatest humans

@jablanbukvovski Год назад

Bad Lieutenant is my favorite movie

@TimeLordCraft Год назад

FREEDOMFOREVER

@rolanddutton Год назад

@@jablanbukvovski "his soul is still dancing" - a truly great scene

@burnitdwn 10 месяцев назад

Herzog is magic. Encounters at the end of the world. The sole penguin wandering away from the ocean. existential angst. so much power.

@Ajsandborg Год назад

Listening to Herzog talk about ecstatic truth and the poetic really reminds me of how i felt watching some films by Tarkovsky. Watching his films has been one of the most personal experiences i've ever had with cinema.

@squirlmy Год назад

I agree but i have a hard time convincing others to sit through the hours and hours his films last.

@Ajsandborg Год назад

@@squirlmy Yeah me too, and to be honest i can't blame them. As much as it breaks my heart that i can't share these feelings with them. I remember when i tried to watch Solaris with my family (which is maybe the "easiest" Tarkovsky film to watch) and my dad was really bored of the long shots and complained how the movie didn't even try to keep his attention. Which is fine of course, it's not that i was sad that he has a different taste in movies but i was sad that, as Herzog said about poetry, he didn't feel illuminated. Fortunately i have a few friends who do, immediately when i show them specific shots from Mirror or Stalker, they get it. They too realize that they have a brother and sharing that realization with someone is a beautiful thing.

@ElazarYershovFilms 10 месяцев назад

@@AjsandborgI prefer Kurosawa’s filmmaking or Bergman’s

@squamish4244 Год назад

What's just as extraordinary is that Treadwell managed to interact with grizzlies for 13 years and escaped harm. It was when he made a few critical errors (probably because he stayed too late in the season, until the bears were looking for food before they hibernated) that he got killed.

@davidanderson6055 Год назад

In my recollection, something was happening with Treadwell. It was late in the year, the winds were blowing, the weather stormy, and he was in the Grizzly Maze. Something was driving him to stay, and he talked about this "bad bear" that even tried to sneak up on him at one point. He was a kind of mad man. A great man, in some ways, but mad. Amazing documentary

@matanuskabutler7566 Год назад

Treadwell got lucky for 13 years and that was it. The only thing extraordinary was that it hadn't happened sooner. Late in the season here in Alaska, there are TONS of berries, spawning fish, young animals from spring still not fully grown, ect. It wasn't hunger that got him killed, at least not alone. Generally, spring is more dangerous because they haven't eaten in months, which is why we find so many in Anchorage all summer because of the trash, 40 resident Grizzlies and over 100 resident Black Bear. I get to chase one away at work. As the previous reply comment stated, even Treadwell admitted there was an overly aggressive bear and he should have known FULL well to leave the area, especially with his experience with bears. He's another person who anthropomorphized animals and began thinking of them as Human and he paid the full price for believing animals work like we do.

@ErikB605 Год назад

@@matanuskabutler7566 To be fair. An agressive individual being his downfall doesn't really make a case against anthropomorphizing. He might as well have talked about a man with a knife stalking him before dieing.

@silvesby Год назад

@@ErikB605 Indeed. But it's important as naturalists to understand that though we see ourselves in animals, as we are too, they are not us. We can never really know how or what they think. I feel the more people are around animals, the more they perhaps personify them. It should be noted I see myself doing this as well, even unintentionally.

@Sam-lm8gi Год назад

A Limerick for Werner Herzog: A soldier of cinema extreme. Driven by strange fever dreams. He looks like a sleuth, For ecstatic truth, And in wildest landscapes it teems.

@karl_3885 Год назад

Werner is so good at what he does, it's unbelievable. National treasure.

@MeettheMaker Год назад

International treasure!

@TomGraham-mk2wl 6 месяцев назад

@@MeettheMaker Intergalactic treasure!!

@whatsthatnoise5955 5 месяцев назад

@@TomGraham-mk2wl Pan-dimensional treasure

@lorenzodicapo6305 Год назад

One of my favorite moments is from the documentary 'My Best Fiend', where Herzog is giving his estimation of the Amazonian jungle and claiming, 'the birds here do not sing, they cry out in pain.'

@Killerbee_McTitties Год назад

As a kid I used to watch a documentary with Katja and Maurice by national geographic over and over, i was obsessed with it. I think it's called Volcanoe: Nature's Inferno. In recent weeks I remembered them after reading something about volcanoes and now this video. coincidences are crazy sometimes. I might have to watch that Werner Herzog movie.

@jackquinn9535 8 месяцев назад

Then again are there (room left for) coincidences in our time of vast piles of data accumulated non-stop on every frigging soul lost in cyberspace, processed and analyzed by faceless monster algorithms gone berserk ("intelligent").

@benedickdanganan420 Год назад

I was waiting for someone to compare these films together. It's about time.

@bobbyologun1517 Год назад

i thought i was going to be Fires of Kuwait vs Lessons In Darkness

@puppable Год назад

I thought it was about volcanos

@jablanbukvovski Год назад

Maybe we could compare Abel Ferrara and Herzog as well, that sounds fun

@benedickdanganan420 Год назад

@@jablanbukvovski Bad Lieutenant

@jablanbukvovski Год назад

@@benedickdanganan420 yeah, guy loves to reload things

@pectenmaximus231 Год назад

Herzog is one of the greatest artists in the history of humanity. Im not a film student or cinephile or something but that just seems an obvious point on reflection.

@murrayr7703 Год назад

Do you often lead with hyperbole

@PanzerBuyer Год назад

I was happy to see him in the Mandalorian too.

@avrelo_south 7 месяцев назад

My strongest memory of experiencing the sublime was ironically in my home province, Saskatchewan. Most of were I’ve lived is a massive prairie and I often travel to and from Saskatoon sand Regina. When near Saskatoon you’ll drive up a hill. It’s not crazy big, but it is high enough you can see a bit more of the land in front of you. You can see how big the land is. Unlike mountains, and deep valleys though, this was different. Yes these mountain, and the ocean are huge, certainly, but when I looked out across the prairie, it felt infinite. It’s like I could see the how large the earths crust was. I can see how small I am.

@aleksoctop Год назад

Wonderful video, and while I think Mubi is great, using Werner’s own words to sell the service at the end was a slap in the face of everything that came before it.

@dosesandmimoses 11 месяцев назад

Werner is such a beautiful storyteller- combining words and images with poetic justice. Gratitude

@projectstoicism Год назад

I just watched a clip of Nicolas Cage in Bad Lieutenant yesterday and found out Warner Herzog made that and someone else had made that same movie too. Thought "how fitting that LSOO makes the video about that at the same time I found out this fact" but it turns out Warner Herzog made the same movie as someone else TWICE ?

@Zeitgeist6 Год назад

Herzog is fantastic. From his fictional works like Nosferatu or Aguirre: Wrath Of God to his documentaries like My Best Fiend and Into the Abyss. They always have a certain feel to it. It has this kind of hypnotic quality to it.

@Susie_Floozie Год назад

I am so grateful that Werner Hertzog exists and used his talents to brand our zeitgeist with his ecstatic truths. As a culture, we are so much richer for his shared visions.

@bouncycow3010 Год назад

I happened to accidentally stumble across the herzog documentary on tv the other day, and oh wow, I was in a trance for the whole run time, it was incredible. How the music, images, and voice over all brings it together was just beautiful. Fantastic video, I’ll certainly be watching more from herzog!

@violinsinthevoid4579 Год назад

Cave of Forgotten Dreams is another great one! Wheel of Time is also a good, underrated documentary by him! His fictional films from the 70s are also incredible.

@bouncycow3010 Год назад

@@violinsinthevoid4579 Awesome, thanks! Ill certainly be checking out some more stuff by him

@OlYables Год назад

I like the one where he’s in McMurdo. Because I love hearing him say “McMurdo.”

@lordofchaosinc.261 Год назад

Herzog is a legend, check out the footage where he's arguing with Klaus Kinski in the jungle.

@SeismoTechs Год назад

and here I am, fanboying over the wonderful tale of the Kraffts, true explorers who lived and died the way they wanted, leaving behind important work for the benefit of all of us ❤ I'm really curious about Herzog's version, tho I absolutely loved Fire of Love. to me it only goes to show how fascinating their story was; it's great that there are these different approaches existing of how to tell it.

@lowe-quay-shush Год назад

I love the tone of Hertzog's voice. Whatever he says over images. He could read from Mc Donald's menu list & sound profound.

@Ice12287 Год назад

The script you made for this video was incredibly well done! Thank you for the opportunity to learn about these amazing works!

@hermannretzlaff1070 Год назад

I’m not even gonna holdu this shit got me mad emotional. Mr. Like stories of old, I’m sure you have some idea, but I’d say the way you communicate the ideas you’ve explored, through your videos, is so eloquent and coherently effective that I’m overwhelmed by emotion because of it. I think you oughta be congratulated and deeply thanked for continuing the cycle, and so effectively passing on the message to us that we truly “aren’t alone” as Herzog says. This video was sublime

@dambaek. Год назад

This is my first time watching one of your videos @LikeStoriesofOld and I want to express my admiration and gratitude for a well-written, well-told and well-edited film on a beautiful subject.

@TheLacedaemonian300 Год назад

Another wonderful piece of art that has the ability of reaching out of the screen and touching a part me in a novel and still nostalgic way. I love Herzog's work, his images and voice are a large contributor to the narration of my own life story. I think that this video is an adequate distillation of the spirit of his work. Very nicely done.

@XanderShiller Год назад

Herzog describes Treadwell like an unintentional savant of cinematography. Even ready to unknowingly die for it.

@stevesmith4901 Год назад

Ironically, there is something sublime in the way Werner Herzog describes and expresses himself in his movies.

@brandonmorel2658 Год назад

His beautiful german accent and persona add a grandeur and heaviness to his documentaries.

@canobenitez Год назад

@@brandonmorel2658 add his old voice from nowadays and you have the winner combo

@cameleopard42 Год назад

Is that ironic?

@stevesmith4901 Год назад

@@cameleopard42 In a way yes, because he is searching for the sublime in nature, while his own voice is sublime.

@bygmesterfinnegan6938 Год назад

@@stevesmith4901 it would be ironic if he didnt search for it

@pankajsingh-bw8op Год назад

Ive watched both films and found both of them to be equally moving. It never occurred that i must compare the two films. The narratives are from different stand points. One is deeply personal and another is typical of herzog's brilliance. I think this is the beauty of storytelling..and thay expression is what must be celebrated here, not compared.

@glassjaw2007 11 месяцев назад

one was made by a conventional filmmaker, the other was made by a GREAT uncompromised artist not bound to an agenda or company like National Geographic

@hand.2 7 месяцев назад

i think they both serve very different functions. fire of love is about the lives of the kraffts, while fire within is an ode to their work

@juletaurus Год назад

As always, a great one, Tom. Loved that Herzog embraced this amazing couple and brought them to the mainstream for so many who did not know them. He certainly does film like no other.

@AnyoneCanSee Год назад

This was wonderfully thoughtful and excellently produced. Informative as well as contemplative. It was even emotionally moving. Thank you for the time and effort in creating this.

@vonsopas Год назад

Man your stories in video always reach to the level of sublime. Beautifully crafted as always

@Tunda2 Год назад

Every word becomes more profound when spoken by Werner Herzog

@michaelbond4807 Год назад

Absolutely brilliant - you have excelled even your high standard of insightfulness, fluency, dramatic structuring of your argument, and dare we acknowledge, beauty! thank you again.

@enotdetcelfer Год назад

Fantastic thank you. I will say one thing about the shot of the bushes and branches waving in the wind, and herzog's statement about it's own stardom. To me, it was about how we naturally fixate on the human as one deserving of our full attention as a character, whom we expect to express some message or action, and for whom we give a higher weight as the subject of a scene, but that the unexpected leaving of the person can leave our still active expectations to be turned to the other characters remaining, and that the message we can receive from them when we don't immediately switch to our assumptions of viewing an environment, can be elevated to a level where we realize that in our absence they have their own lives and their own character, maybe more than we give them credit for in our endless chasing of more human interaction and engagement.

@falkjericke Год назад

I want to express my deep gratitude to your work and you personally as a human being. For me, out of the countless channels I watched on RU-vid for over a decade now, you are in a league of your own (with only jonna jinton in it too, for everything I saw yet). What you both are achieving is something that transcends the mind itself. Your videos, that are pure art for me, overcome the limited truth of my thoughts and connect me with a deeper part of my being. Everything you do, from your voice, to the visuals, to the narrative radiates beauty and love. Thank you for everything you created so far and I am looking forward for everything yet to come. (And if someone knows other channels in this league I would gladly hear your recommendations)

@astro3213 Год назад

I find it so funny that this guy guest starred as himsef in the boondocks.. his voice is so recognizable.. 4:20

@belllerofont Год назад

It's always such a special day, when I get to watch your video. There's nothing like that on a platform, your insight, perspective is quite unique and truly beautiful.

@Quicksilver_Cookie 3 месяца назад

Some of those shots are absolutely breathtaking. Quite literally made me hold my breath momentarily.

@mpc1mil Год назад

It still blows my mind when I see him in the mandalorian. I almost fell out my chair the first time

@ralph_bernhardt Год назад

I am so glad you created another video about Werner Herzog. This is one of the best RU-vid channels ever!

@jamesg2382 Год назад

What a great video. A really beautiful analysis and very thoughtful. Thank you.

@meisterslx Год назад

I watched this movie in a cinema in Munich, Germany last year in a pre-screening, and Mr. Herzog was present. The lava images literally blew my mind. Krafft shot this on 16mm film (at one point you can see his Arri 16SR camera here), the footage therefore has great quality, it's shot professionally from a almost suicidal distance (or rather non-distance). A must-watch for everyone who is fascinated by volcanoes. After watching this video, I must admit what an incredible job Herzog did when putting the footage together. He said after the screening there were hundreds of hours of material to deal with. His cutter preselected first, then Herzog made the decisions, he also decided what to talk about in the voiceover, quite quickly, as he described. The music is superbly chosen, it elevates the absurd, mind-twisting images into something metapgisical, yet as real as nothing else. At one point he points out that the pictures and sounds of the Kraffts show us nothing less than the origin of life, the abyss where we all came from (the original sounds recorded by Mrs. Krafft are also very impressive and play an important part that cannnot be missed). The locations around the globe are chosen wisely. This movie is also really entertaining! A true masterpiece. I still remember every single magma shot shown here as if I saw them yesterday! Thank you for this great review!

@balzize Год назад

The momentary illumination I got to follow my deepest passions after watching this video and having had the change to meet some extraordinary individuals through your video, is inexplicable. Thank you.

@osmark90 Год назад

Thank you for this. I am presently writing my master's thesis on Herzog and these concepts along with how these spaces (Deleuzian "any-space-whatever") as perhaps threatened by the hegemony of ontic/factual metaphysics that obscures the distinction. I feel like there is a real need for a phenomenological distinction in the plurality of truth and I am discussing its possible integration within a philosophical framework of politics. I am a fan of your videos and it felt like it was a lovely chance occurence when I saw that you posted this video. Keep up the good work. Best, Oliver

@SilojensenDK Год назад

Contemplation is such a rare treat in the sea of narrative.

@crinklecut3790 11 месяцев назад

This is the best thing I’ve watched on YT in a very long time. Well done! 👍

@r.w.bottorff7735 5 месяцев назад

This is a beautifully rendered video. Thank you.

@dripworks6659 Год назад

Werner Herzog is one of the most intellegence filmmakers of all time. Such surreal insights not many others (or any others) ever express so profoundly as Herzog. The accent helps too lmao.

@iankelly5797 11 месяцев назад

That was a fantastic presentation. Well done.

@jacksonkingsley7414 Год назад

Loved this, thanks for making it!

@monkeywizard7919 11 месяцев назад

Absolutely beautiful video. I had chills throughout.

@liltick102 Год назад

I recommend reading every novel by Herzog, watching all his film’s & documentaries, watching all of his interviews and videos pertinent to him ~~ Also this is an excellent video that does his wonderful work great justice.

@nhmooytis7058 Год назад

I wasn’t aware he wrote novels.

@liltick102 6 месяцев назад

@@nhmooytis7058for years, yeah - he just put out a new one weeks ago - a guide for the perplexed is my favourite but it’s rly just a 600 pg interview.

@user-ex5eo7vv9l 3 месяца назад

nice job pal, really moving

@furisado4396 Год назад

I hope you feel fulfilled and proud making these videos, im very grateful to have you making them, discussing and articulating various works. They feed people`s soul, ty

@pagefilms Год назад

Great study! I’m a filmmaker from Hawaii chasing all our eruptions here. My first volcano film in 2014 is called The Fire Within and the experience changed my life. Herzog and the Kraffts are heroes of mine!

@Suelenedeoliveira 5 месяцев назад

Beautifull images and commentary... Thank you for this moment of dream!

@carlkamuti Год назад

A beautiful analysis of a beautiful film, The Fire Within blew me away when I saw it: it was my favourite film of last year, and you've done it justice here with some amazing insights. 👍👍

@OldBluesChapterandVerse Год назад

I love Herzog more often than not, but I can’t imagine his film will surpass Fire of Love, my second favorite film of 2022.

@dilanrajapaksha Год назад

Let me guess your favourite was Everything Everywhere all at once

@OldBluesChapterandVerse Год назад

@@dilanrajapaksha EEAAO fell at around #40 on my list of 2022 movies. I think it was the most overrated film of the year by some distance. My #1 film of the year was After Yang.

@dilanrajapaksha Год назад

@@OldBluesChapterandVerse I do remember hearing about Aftar Yang but didn't even have it on my radar till now. Honestly if you have a 40+ movie list and this is #1 then I'll make sure to check it out. Btw my favourite of 2022 was Tar, and EEAAO I'd say around 5th.

@OldBluesChapterandVerse Год назад

@@dilanrajapaksha I’ve seen 75 films from 2022. I loved Tar up until its ending, which, for me, complicated the film in the worst possible way.

@dilanrajapaksha Год назад

@@OldBluesChapterandVerse Complicated is probably the best way to describe it. But for me it worked in the films favour since it stuck in my mind ages after watching/rewatching it.

@ProfessorBoswell Год назад

Thank you for this, you've made a great essay on Herzog, and nicely stated what makes him special. To me there's no one who has reached his level, calling him a filmmaker is almost reductive. He's a storyteller, a poet, a philosopher, and more. He reveals so much about humanity. I loved seeing clips from Fata Morgana and Signs of Life, two favorites. Anyone interested in him should get the book Herzog on Herzog, great set of interviews. (Small point, a truth of accountants, but if you're talking about Happy People when you say he went to the Taiga, he didn't actually go, that one was made from existing footage he edited.)

@Daniel_Ilyich Год назад

This was a brilliant film essay! Thank you!

@hassanchoudhary4140 3 месяца назад

This is my favourite video on youtube! Thank you!

@dundeedolphin Год назад

Some profound and stimulating observations. Thank you.

@zakkziegler111 Год назад

*Huge* Herzog fan. Own nearly his entire filmography. Awesome work!

@nicolebogda1482 Год назад

Hertzog has always been a brilliant inspiration. I think something else not noticed is the breath. As the viewer notice: a deep inhale? A forced exhale? Are you holding your breath? A pause…

@roberth9814 Год назад

Incredible essay, thank you for this.

@ifyouthinkthisworldisbad Год назад

What a great video. Thanks for always posting awesome content, very inspiring. Thank you

@Lord_Baphomet_ 2 месяца назад

I just watched The Fire Within and honestly… I can’t think of a better documentary about volcanoes, love, and passion.

@DThron Год назад

Wonderful video as always, and really encapsulates what is truly brilliant and beautiful about Herzog. I loved Fire Within, and Grizzly Man is my favorite documentary of all time - a landmark in empathic cinema, to me. He sees Treadwell as a tragic example of how we so desperately wish to experience meaning that we block ourselves from that experience by creating stories about it and our relationship to it instead of opening ourselves up to it directly. Fire Within is the perfect bookend to this film; filmmakers as example instead of cautionary tale.

@alexoffthewall4237 Год назад

This is a work of beautiful truth itself. Really, really well done.

@totchrome Год назад

Your videos…are the best! Best RU-vid you’ll ever find! Thank you, thank you, thank you!

@DarkAngelEU 9 месяцев назад

I still remember that part of Tokyo-Ga where Herzog complains about no virgin images being there anymore. I never really understood what he meant, but the fascination for human passions as you describe in this video essay sheds some new light on that particular scene. It is a city without poetry, there's no muse in the wind, as are so many places these days.

@Prodigy68 Год назад

Grew up with Werner Herzog, will watch anything by and about him. Great stuff, thanks!

@kikielfriki 6 месяцев назад

This felt like one of your older videos. I really enjoyed it

@dhwanishah3079 Год назад

Your insights perfectly complement Herzog's genius, such a delightful watch

@dr1eleven1 Год назад

I needed this reminder of the power of filmmaking, thank you. I plan to watch and rewatch his adequate imagery,

@michaldobrzyn Год назад

I happened upon this and thought it was fantastic. It really awakened my emotions in a way that I'm not used to but appreciate.

@zenmail42 Год назад

The most wonderful channel on RU-vid? An impossible question to answer, however every video is a meditation that deepens and enriches our lives. Thank you for this ❤

@zeropluslessthan5126 Год назад

You have made a wonderful film here; thank you so much. So helpful to me and the highlight of my day.

@0cer0 Год назад

THANKS! You have performed a miracle. I have encountered Werner Herzog again and again for decades when dealing with German film, and I have never liked him, never understood him. I lacked the lightness in him, the playfulness, even the philanthropy. In fact, this essay has now managed to bring him closer to me, to make him more understandable and also more sympathetic.