Which salt mix is best for my saltwater aquarium or reef tank? | BRStv

BRStv - Saltwater Aquariums & Reef Tanks

Подписаться 305 тыс.

Просмотров 62 тыс.

50% 1

Who makes the best salt mix for your reef tank? Instant Ocean, Reef Crystals, Red Sea, HW, Brightwell, Tropic Marin Pro ? Actually, we don't plan to answer that question directly, but rather help explain why there is such a large debate over which is best and how all reefers may be right about their own choice. This one is sure to stir up some conversation!
#BRStv #AskBRStv #BRStvInvestigates
Reef2Reefers have a lot to say about the best salt!
brs.li/R2R_Bes...
See what the #AskBRStv community on Facebook thinks of best salt1
brs.li/AskBRSt...
Need your reefing questions answered? Join #AskBRStv Facebook
brs.li/AskBRSt...
Legal Stuff
The purpose and content of this video is to provide general information regarding the products and their applications as presented in the video. Aquatic Sales Solutions, Inc. and its officers, directors, employees and agents disclaim all express or implied warranties, in any way, related to the products and their application as presented in this video, make no representation or warranty regarding the products and the application as presented in this video and shall not be liable for any direct or indirect losses or damages of any type, including but not limited to punitive damages, or from personal injury or death resulting from or in any manner related to the video, and the products in and contents of the video. The viewer expressly agrees that Aquatic Sales Solutions, Inc. and its officers, directors, employees and agents shall not be liable for any damages or losses related to the products in and content of the video and hereby agrees to hold the foregoing harmless from any such losses or damages.

Животные

Опубликовано:

10 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 99

@tidalgardens 5 лет назад

Great video guys. I appreciate the effort and resources you put into doing comparisons. When it came to choosing salt for my systems, it really came down to our ability to buy it in pallet quantities sent on a box truck with a lift gate because big trucks can't make it up my driveway. Luckily I've been happy with the salt itself.

@gabesreef 5 лет назад

I love the way Ryan answers the likely question of if we didnt test your salt... that was the nicest way to say, if you want to know, do it yourself A++

@jerryebner7582 5 лет назад

I started with Instant ocean by Local fish store suggestion then switched by online views to Reef Crystals By Instant Ocean. I clean my mixing bucket every two times I make water. Note I make 10 gallons at a time so Its easy for me to do so. And my tank looks great.

@dansheets7200 5 лет назад

Literally spent the last 24 hours looking for a video exactly like this...

@mermaidsreef8034 5 лет назад

I'd love to see a salt testing group B! Esv, Aquaforest, 2littlefishies & Fritz.

@bckey1440 5 лет назад

I think one of the most important things with reef salt is consistency. When you find a salt that you like and it produces the numbers you are looking for, you want to be confident that it is consistent from batch to batch.

@richardnation3379 4 года назад

I would have like to have seen Fritz in that group. I had read reviews on wikipedia that put instant ocean # 1. I was surprised since its the cheapest and available at petco so I bought it and planned on using it, but then I found out my LFS used Fritz and I read high personal reviews about Fritz (which I suppose like you said every salt, can likely have good reviews by people that swear by that brand) Anyway since my lfs had fritz onsale on tuesdays for a buck a gallon I have been using that, so far so good but I have never used anything else to compare it with! So easy to buy it premixed as well!

@atfinthehouse8631 5 лет назад

When you guys do comparatives, it is really valuable.

@carlosbarajas382 6 месяцев назад

I got a serious question when I do a water change and I take out 5 gallons. Do I make sure the 5 gallons I put back in or the same salinity as the tank because somebody told me just to add freshwater so confused, please help.

@Pontiuspilate666 2 месяца назад

If you take out saltwater you put the same amount in at the same salinity as the tank. You account for evaporation with freshwater bc salt doesn't evaporate out of the tank. Always test your salinity to make sure you're maintaining a stable level!

@bigsalty3661 5 лет назад

What's bulk reef supplies findings on Fritz RPM salt that you guys won't stock it or mention it either?

@CalebChapman12 5 лет назад

Same

@fordsvtmfl 5 лет назад

Fritz has been all over the place for me and generally has much higher ca and mg than advertised. I’m also not a fan of their customer “service” at all.

@Vdeez 5 лет назад

Preston Renfrow yup. Fritz puts all their money into marketing not QAQC.

@jodia7435 4 года назад

Brian, when I prepare fresh saltwater for a water change and I need to adjust the KH level... Can I put the KH additive immediately after mixing the RODI water with the salt?? Or I gotta leave the fresh saltwater rest for a while before doing KH or CA approximations??

@aquapuncture 5 лет назад

Thanks for doing this BRS. Opening Pandora's salt bucket, for sure!

@That_Bender 5 лет назад

UV stability, ORP levels (initial and sustained) and DOC levels. Those are my questions.

@ChrisAquatics 5 лет назад

I'm definitely looking forward to this. Great videos BRS

@velodim 9 месяцев назад

I've been ocean crystals guy for a while. And my last bucket mixing 1050 magnesium. I even got another test kit and it's the same. Dosing magnesium until I finish the salt and than switching to something else

@karennation3580 10 месяцев назад

How do I find randys video on results? I use Fritz and am fixing to switch because they dont deliver on what they say! I have to use double the almout almost so thats 1 cup per gallon almost when they say 1/2 cup plus the alk is through the roof at 12%! Could storing unopened salt mix in a hot garage affect results? Once I open the bag I keep it indoors! I heat water add waver maker, heater and slowly poor in salt into 0 tds water! Is there something I am doing wrong? How often should you clean the bin from precipitant? I mixed small batch in clean container and still get around 12 so don think thats the reason! I used to use reef crystal but it get moist and clumps after opening! I want an inexpensive salt mix with about 9.5 alk. Can you name one?

@gabe5476 5 лет назад

I know a lot of people who use fritz RPM. I have personally used this salt for the last 1.5 years would love if you guys test it so I could see how it compares.

@MythicalMasterpieces 5 лет назад

I would love to see aqua forest in that set as well. They are one of the few (maybe only) that gives you the ability to get the ICP test results for your batch of salt but if there is no real benefit to the higher price then that would be useful to know as well.

@KimKim-on2ct 5 лет назад

Mike Cooper Red Sea blue bucket also had/have icp test

@johnmarcinski7924 5 лет назад

Tropic Marin is the best salt in terms of quality. Nothing else compares to it, and I've been a SW aquarist for over 40 years. I've tried most of them, and Tropic Marin is superior to them all.

@marcelrodriguez2067 4 года назад

Only bad thing about tropic marin is the low alk that it has.

@johnmarcinski7924 4 года назад

@@marcelrodriguez2067 Not a problem in fowlr or fish only aquaria, and it's infinitely easier to adjust alkalinity upward to an ideal level for coral than it is to reduce dangerously high alkalinity. In any case, I think Tropic Marin sells a salt version with that issue fully addressed.

@brocklowe118 5 лет назад

Great topics and I will be waiting on fridays to learn a little bit more about reefing. Thank you!

@joevillavicencio6548 5 лет назад

Thank you for this Video. It really opened my eyes

@reeftheseaforever 5 лет назад

I always use instant ocean now I’m thinking of switching thanks

@gdoggie368 5 лет назад

Is there a benefit to using the same brand salt and supplements? For example, if you use Red Sea 2 part, trace elements, etc is there a benefit to using Red Sea salt? Or will I get a similar result with Tropic Marin salt with Red Sea supplements?

@kurth6027 5 лет назад

Timely. I am looking to switch from Red Sea Pro to something more stable and less likely to precipitate out and leave a mess.

@BlueCarbonReefing 5 лет назад

I use liveaquaria.com salt for a few reasons. One it mixes clear fast and does not leave any Brown residue inside my mixing container . Two, it's very very close to the tank parameters that I like to keep my reef tank at. 3, it's definitely in the mid range for cost.

@user-hr5if8ij5z 4 года назад

2019년 가장 인상깊게 본 영상이였어요 다섯번은 봤습니다

@kenhickey4730 5 лет назад

outstanding thanks for testing salt mixes...

@robertscott667 5 лет назад

Great effort!...What is the "so what" of the brown residue in your mixing tank? Something real like leaching (increased calcium) or just a bad feeling.

@frankcava8073 5 лет назад

I love this site, watch it every single day. But I think we have discussed this haven't we?

@Lukas-jo5jg 5 лет назад

I have to say that I've tried all of the salts being tested but I've stuck with the Red sea Blue Bucket. Why? After trying elevated elements and cheap I decided to go with what most closely matched NSW and wasn't the most expensive. That having been said I've been eyeballing TLF Accurasea1 with more than a passing interest but I'm through with being a trailblazer. It would be nice to have a single bag sold in "200 gallon box" bulk that I could mix the full bag in a brute trashcan. I wish it had made the cut so my curiosity could be sated, but I'm happy where I am for now.

@tsurro8086 5 лет назад

What about that bio-activ tropics Marin salt? I think the alk level is spot on but not sure about the bacteria it adds, does it really affect the tank? Or how about adding it to an existing tank? Thx

@kylesappington9661 5 лет назад

Very insightful setting up a 120 gal right now

@skookumchuckreefer978 5 лет назад

I got 20% off. When I bought a skid of reef crystals Sooo. Guess I’m going to use it up before I change brands.

@SeekoGT 5 лет назад

Just in time. I need to resupply today

@jonathanchristian9776 5 лет назад

I thought I was seeing things on Facebook when I saw Costco under the BRS logo and then you showed up lol.

@melachitrujillo2339 Год назад

So cosco sells sea salt or you said it as like a sponsor type thing

@aaroncgodwin 5 лет назад

Would love to see fritz

@javiersreeftank6212 5 лет назад

Your videos are always great. Have you done one on how to plumb a skimmer to a manifold?

@Ammar_23 4 месяца назад

What about waterbox salt

@skyfsa 5 лет назад

Informative thanks, I'm starting to lean towards DIY salt recipes, as I come to the same conclusion it's about care and maintenance.

@shybrencessa6848 3 года назад

I think balling then dosing. Either so low, or way high at what the tank is needing

@shybrencessa6848 3 года назад

I am curious. I have done so well not checking pars for two years almost three. Now that I do it seems all crazy, can't get it perfect. Way high, no dosing and the change slowly and so low still can regulate. What's the deal here? Me?

@Botzz28 3 года назад

I am preety much done with waiting for tropic marin to come into stock sadly...if you had to choose a second best that mixes clean and clear like pro reeeef which one would it be ?

@BRStv 3 года назад

If you can't wait for more Tropic Marin salt, the HW salt is probably your next best option. Mixes clean, parameters similar to TM Pro (slightly higher alk), and is even less expensive. www.bulkreefsupply.com/hw-marinemix-reefer-salt-mix.html

@Botzz28 3 года назад

@@BRStv do you like HW better than fritz?

@nealenns7869 5 лет назад

@BRS You really should included Fritz RPM salt mix in this. Its a high quality low cost salt that mixes fast and clean. Many reefs are using it and I know I would like to see some testing done on it. I switched from HW to Fritz and am very happy with the similarities betwe3n the 2 salts.

@Vdeez 5 лет назад

Neal Enns Fritz’s quality control is garbage.

@karennation3580 10 месяцев назад

@@Vdeez agreed! Plus it mixes at 12 % alk and have to double the amout they say at 1 cup per gallon to get 1026! My LFS switched for same reason! It would actually be cheaper to go through the hassle to get from her!

@devisissy1 5 лет назад

Going right back to Kent.

@RuneyBoy99Videos 5 лет назад

Idk about that no salt mixes that are toxic comment. I realize any good hobbyist wouldnt use a petsmart brand mix but they were my only local option and they got rid of their reef Crystal's in favor of their new salt concentrate with conditioner, figured wth, I'll give it a shot. I would never put that stuff near anything living. I left it mixing for over 4 days and it didnt clear at all, and my blue bucket is still white and that was over 2 months ago.

@rsgfhfdhh1362 5 лет назад

Jay was In-Salted.......I'll get my coat..

@Botzz28 3 года назад

seems like tropic marin salt is going to die off because of unreliable availablity issues… what is the next best salt similar to tropic marin pro reef ?

@BRStv 3 года назад

We expect a big improvement to availability this summer. If you need an alternative in the meantime, the HW reefer is a great salt choice. www.bulkreefsupply.com/hw-marinemix-reefer-salt-mix.html

@jackwhitetron 5 лет назад

Kudos to whoever wrote this script.

@PufferLover 5 лет назад

Cant wait ✌🏻

@halosawz 5 лет назад

Fritz RPM for me

@claudiadavies8786 4 года назад

What salt do you use

@BRStv 4 года назад

In the BRS office, we use Tropic Marin Pro Reef

@trureef2319 5 лет назад

Beluga whales are white haha. Had to add that. By the way I am a Instant ocean type guy. Using both purple and orange buckets. Do great for me.

@longjohndingel 5 лет назад

Absolut ocean from ati. What else?

@UBWR2022 4 года назад

It’s disappointing not having Fritz salt there. It’s even a local American product !

@BRStv 4 года назад

Definitely understand, but in the end these tests are pretty expensive to run and we're just not able to test them all.(Time, effort, products, video production, etc.)

@acanskywalker5631 5 лет назад

IO always sends me $10 off coupons, whenever theres a sale I buy a 200 gal box of their Reef Crystals, cost is usually about $43. Before use empty a bag into a 5 gallon bucket, cover tightly & shake the shit out of it for a minute or two!

@anonymousm5805 4 года назад

Read my post bro... Get some other salt...

@sylvester7800 5 лет назад

Aquaforest hands down is best.

@JCSReefing 5 лет назад

Too bad TLF accurasea wasn't tested. Individual bags is hard to fool how much it takes to mix a 5g bucket. Oh, and it is also Pharma grade. :-)

@JCSReefing 5 лет назад

Completely understandable! Thanks for all y’all do!

@MicrobiusBlue 5 лет назад

Well the baby Rowan Atkinson is something i can't unsee...that's just wrong 🙃

@SkyHigghReef 5 лет назад

Aquaforest probiotic salt is the best by far!

@SkyHigghReef 5 лет назад

BulkReefSupplyCom yea I love it. Trace elements, 10min mix, low levels to start big three, nice purple bucket and probiotic Bactria that basically is nopox! Works great for me!

@jasepoag8930 5 лет назад

When BRS Pharma Grade sea salt? haha

@jasepoag8930 5 лет назад

@@BRStv True, with the economy of scale and all that, it would probably just be a rebranded version of an existing salt like what LA did.

@patterdalezipsuzilil 4 года назад

Well you lost 5mins of my life and the answer was DON'T KNOW😂😂😂😂

@allanc7654 2 года назад

after six minutes of saying nothing of use I called it a day......

@brikbravo 2 года назад

you talk too much... 👎🏼 incomplete message🤷🏻‍♂️

@bigrazzer 5 лет назад

please try fritz salt in your test

@devisissy1 5 лет назад

It's garbage.

@bigrazzer 5 лет назад

@@devisissy1 why you think fritz is garbage for. when its most stable salt out there. I have tested lot different salt and none them keep same level like fritz. And instance ocean had lot problems and gave me super high alk and kill my corals i had over 15 years. I had my friend store test my salt from instance ocean came back with same results.

@bigrazzer 5 лет назад

way i look if going to do a test of best salt out there then do them all or do not do test for us. Because make you look prejudiced of different companies.

@lordraptor11 4 года назад

13 minute vid that didnt really say anythign. chalk it up to desperate for attention click bait

@BRStv 4 года назад

The point is, there really isn't a "best salt" and the debates we see on the forums and Facebook groups on this subject can get a little silly sometimes.

@lordraptor11 4 года назад

@@BRStv again click bait, a 13 minute vid for somethign that could have been said in less than 1. anyone with common sense knows there is no "best" salt mix, i think your vid could have been MUCH better. i can tell you the best salt mix and that is one that mimics natural seawater exactly without any extra additives, after all natural seawater isnt dosed. with that having been said i have been looking at salt mixes for several days online and comparing them and i have to say that the fritz RPM seems to be the best choice in regards to its comparablility to natural seawater and price for 200 gallon mix, IO and IO reef crystals are cheap but are also the worst as they would require some form of additives

@yurigumatay3152 5 лет назад

Use table salt jk

@anonymousm5805 4 года назад

Do not buy Instant Ocean salt EVER....was battling ammonia issue and turned out that my RO water test 0.0ppm and after mixing 1.5 day or week after doesn't matter. Now I know why can't lower ammonia and Nitrate. Shitty shitty salt.