Which Woman is SECRETLY Lesbian?! 

as a bisexual girl I knew right away because of the cottagecore vibes, and then her reaction at 6:30 when the straight girlie said she flirts with girl sometimes lol SIDE EYE

Poor Amanda she’s “a stereotype” of a lesbian and that’s what got her out😭

As a lesbian, the girl in the dress was giving me strong like STRONGGG lesbian vibes

Charlotte's face at around 6:30 when Madison said "I even flirt with girls sometimes" made me howl 😂

the whole time i was hoping it was her. she has such a charming personality

As a woman who’s lgbt, I knew immediately it was the girl in the dress. It was just the vibes of her. I’ve met so many queer women like her

I was 90% sure it wasn't Charotte but then I was obsessed with her throughout the whole video so maybe that's a sign

Charlotte and Sarah had some serious chemistry like sheeeesh 👀😂

"are you an actress?" "I am but also 19 years in the closet😅"

As a bisexual, something about her describing she had a thing for dudes with green/blue eyes and a shaved face did it for me.

Damn Charlotte played very well, I literally would have not known how to answer any of these questions without immediately revealing that I'm a lesbian lol. I would have not guessed her.

As a lesbian, it was obvious. Body language always gives it away.

This was such a good group and I honestly had no idea it was her!!

it was the sneaker dress combo that gave me lesbian vibes but also the "also 19 years in the closet" was such a mood lmao

That Claire girl was truly the only one with any perception skills, everyone else was like "no she gives straight vibes" how does she give straight vibes?

The sound effect of Amanda walking away 😂

As a lesbian, my gaydar has officially gone haywire. 😹

Claire knew it!!! Y’all shoulda listened to her. Her gaydar was on POINT

I was torn between her and Charlotte. I couldn't decide whether it was Charlotte as a soft lesbian or Amanda as a stereotypical goth/punk lesbian.

“Babe, I’m just wild” 😂😂😂😂

I'd bet my life that Claire has some lesbian friends and they've educated her well.

im so confused why everyone was pretending like super femme lesbians don't exist. i knew it was charlotte from the start

Honestly immediately thought it was Charlotte but her answers convinced me otherwise! 😂

She definitely gave cottagecore extreme fem vibes AND the thing that was ticking me was how she was in a dress BUT couldn't really close her legs. 😂 I've observed that mostly more straight women stand with closed or crossed legs in dresses to show off their dress or figure or whatever AND LGBTQIA+ women CANNOT for the love of god, stand "like a women" 😂. (That's y as a closeted Bi, I always check myself to "stand like a women" 💀)

Lol as a lesbian I guessed right away but toward the end when she was talking about girth and stuff I thought I was wrong. She has such a nice laugh and expression and I love her hair so it made sense she was the only one I was attracted too.

I knew it was her the whole time. The red hair, dress, and converse was all I needed.

Why did I read this as “secret librarian” the first time?! 😂 lmao

“Babe I’m just wild” 😂

Honestly the thing that gave it away for me was her checking Sarah B > out and the touching lol

I thought it was AMANDAAAAA. BUT STILL GO OFF QUEEN WITH THE NICK STORY

as a lesbian I knew it right away

The girl in the dress really said "who said I can't wear my cOnVErSe with my drEsS"

Deadass clicked on this thinking it was a cut vid. Not Joey inserting himself in the cut format 😂

Charlotte was also the only one who closed her eyes when she introduced herself as straight which usually means the persons probably lying😭 0:07

Okay but when he asked " Nichol " and she immediately said "Nicholas" that just gave it away 🤣

“you hide it so well” “thank you!! 😄” LMFAO

as a lesbian i knew right when i saw the whole group. her strong femininity was very lesbian to me and i didn’t doubt myself once 😭

I don’t know why they voted out both Sarah B-s, they gave me 100% straight vibes the second I saw them

i didnt know until i noticed the STAND, the stance just gave it ALL away

as a lesbian, i knew it was charlotte bc i own the exact same dress

i lke this group of girls...personalities were thoroughly entertaining

honestly the converse with the dress did it for me

@ 6:00 not them spicing up the music for Amanda's story😂😂

At first intro, I thought it was Amanda, then after a short while I though maybe it was the girl in the green top - just going by some of her answers then when Sarah B (in brown) asked what Joey meant by size, I thought it must be her! Never picked the actual lesbian!

As a lesbian myself I’ve got to applaud my gaydar because I thought that it was the woman in the dress right away💅🏻

as a lesbian i already knew it was charlotte who else wears shoes with a dress AND she was being touchy touchy with the other girl

I really thought it was going to be the women in red😭

She was giving me strong cottagecore lesbian vibes! Slay for her

I'd love to see one with finding either ace or a straight in a group of ace people. Idk but as someone in the ace spectrum this would be amazing

After watching this video, I now understand why people get confused by me when it comes to pinpointing my sexuality 😂

It’s the dress sneakers combo. That’s what gave it all away.

i’m shocked they didn’t check the nails at all

pleased to know that my gaydar works very well. i can see why you would think it’s amanda but she just doesn’t give off those vibes.

Wow I cant believe Everyone EXCEPT Claire looked at the Femme and said "Nah she Str8"

I had to repeat this just to observe Charlotte because she was so good 😂

I knew they would have missed the actual lesbian bc they guessed based on stereotypes and it was so dumb. It was like reading music by physically feeling a page. They could have asked questions and gotten more detailed answers instead

Y'ALL HAVE NO IDEA HOW HAPPY I WAS!! I knew RIGHT AWAY that the red head (Charlotte) was the Lesbian, my Gaydar went crazy I thought it was either her or Claire (sorry I'm just so hyped that I got that right not going to lie! 🤣😂) But yes she was definitely giving off Lesbian vibes and she was a little too I guess "Straight looking" I mean the safe one was Amanda but I know quite a lot of girls like her same with the girl in the green shirt (also can someone tell me why Straight girls kiss each other and flirt with other girls, like seriously it's very confusing- 😆) anyways can't wait for more Content from you and I hope that you are doing well and staying safe and healthy Joey!

“It’s like 2 in the morning, why are you wet?” 🤣🤣🤣

I misunderstood the video and pointed out one straight person, clocked in on what it actually was and immediately was like ok if we can only one we’re taking the dress

amanda looks like emily from pll ….😂😂😂 **shay michell**

as a bi girl, i knew it right away. i also hesitated with amanda but it's just because i found her attractive i think lmao

i love that madison girl, she slays and she’s so cute

yessss these videos are back!! i love these videos

They are all so pretty !!

Dude that was DIFFICULT. Props

As a lesbian I should’ve been able to guess that I think my gaydar needs recalibration 😭

I love these type of vids Joey!!

Amanda “maybe I’m just a hot girl” 🤣

19yrs in the closet had me😂 too relateable

10:46 He’s so cute lol “WHOS NICK?”

SHES LIKE LITERALLY A COTTAGE CORE LESBIAN

Joey: *gaslights them into lesbianism* 😭😭

I wasn’t trying to guess, I was wishful thinking who I wished would be 😅

I knew it . She was so nice to girls and treat them so gentle

For me it was between Madison and Charlotte from the start. Triggered the radar almost instantly.

i didn't think it was her, but i'm glad it was 😉😅

My ex was a cottagecore ginger, sooo it was hard to not immediately choose her. 😅

Joey's gotcha attempts are hilarious.

Incredible job Joey and you are amazing and did ur best ❤

I knew it was the girl in the dress because of the hair tie on her wrist

I knew it! As a lesbian myself, immediately after the video started I was like its either Charlotte because she's giving cottagecore lesbian vibes or its Amanda because of the makeup lol

As a lesbian/sapphic omnisexual I immediately knew it was her XD

as a lesbian i feel so vindicated 😭 i saw the dress and converse and got taylor swift lesbian vibes INSTANTLY

Bi guy here and it was so obviously charolette, just everything ab her was giving me wlw vibes

She couldn’t give eye contact to the camera when she said she was straight

“I kiss girls when I’m drunk lol” shut up 🙄

As a probably lesbian i knew it was her by the thumb nail for no specific reason and ive never been prouder

clocked her as soon as i saw the thumbnail 😭

my personal favorite out of all of these so far

I knew it was her from the start as a lesbiannnnn myself

Charlotte was a choice but my love for her dress blinded me to the truth, i was bamboozle once again lol

I love these! ❤️

I think the guy should try the girl pool instead of tellin them to.

As a Lesbian, I definitely thought it was Charlotte or Amanda

as someone with a great gaydar i was SHOCKED

She’s so pretty. The redhead

Claire was so dead right about Charlotte being lesbian!

I knew it wasn't Sarah from the start cuz on jubilee she was on the episode "who lost there Virginity first?" 😂

i literally knew it was her from the “i am straight” intro 😭😭😭😭😭😭

I called it instantly 😂 Though I realise that being a lesbian woman myself may have given me some insight there lol