Whisper This Sudoku Secret

Подписаться 602 тыс.

Просмотров 43 тыс.

50% 1

** TODAY'S PUZZLE **
An old favourite on the channel, Florian Wortmann, has made this beautiful hybrid sudoku combining killer cages with German Whisper lines. This is a LOT of fun :) Play the puzzle at the link below:
tinyurl.com/535evc2x
Rules:
Normal sudoku rules apply. Digits in cages cannot repeat and must sum to the small clue in the top left corner of the cage. Neighbouring digits on a green line have a difference of at least 5.
▶ NEW PATREON CONTENT ◀
New Patreon monthly reward is OUT. It's called Three Times A Sudoku and it has something quite cool about it :)
Philip Newman's video explaining advanced classic sudoku techniques as well as how to solve his monster puzzle Palpatine's Design is OUT.
Also Simon's solve of the new Phistomefel logic puzzle, Slitherlink Liars, is also available now.
You can join us on Patreon for as little as $2/month here:
/ crackingthecryptic
▶ Contact Us ◀
Twitter: @Cracking The Cryptic
email: crackingthecryptic@gmail.com
Our PO Box address:
Simon Anthony & Mark Goodliffe
Box 102
56 Gloucester Road
London
SW7 4UB
(Please note to use our real names rather than 'Cracking The Cryptic'.)
▶ SUDOKU PAD - Our New App ◀
It's OUT on Windows (released yesterday!) via Steam here:
store.steampowered.com/app/17...
You can now input your own classic sudoku puzzles into our software using our new App! The app also comes with 12 handmade puzzles from us and we're also releasing occasional bonus puzzles too. Already available on IOS and Android.
**************************************************************
▶ OUR ARROW SUDOKU APP IS OUT ON ALL PLATFORMS!
Here are the links:
Steam:
store.steampowered.com/app/16...
App Store:
apps.apple.com/us/app/arrow-s...
Google Play:
play.google.com/store/apps/de...
▶ OUR KILLER SUDOKU APP IS OUT ON ALL PLATFORMS◀
apps.apple.com/us/app/killer-...
store.steampowered.com/app/14...
play.google.com/store/apps/de...
▶ SIMON REACTION BOARD (!) ◀
With thanks to Andrea for creating this :)
simonreacts.avris.it/
▶ CTC FAN DISCORD SERVER◀
/ discord
NEW: Guide To Our Discord Server:
tinyurl.com/CTCDiscordGuide
▶ OUR BACK CATALOGUE - ALL CATEGORISED WITH LINKS!◀
tinyurl.com/CTCCatalogue
▶ NEW CRACKING THE CRYPTIC MERCHANDISE◀
teespring.com/en-GB/stores/cr...
▶ OUR CHESS SUDOKU APP IS NOW OUT!◀
AppStore: apps.apple.com/us/app/chess-s...
Steam: store.steampowered.com/app/12...
Android: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
▶TRY OUR CLASSIC SUDOKU APP◀
AppStore: apps.apple.com/us/app/classic...
Steam: store.steampowered.com/app/11...
Android: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
▶TRY OUR SANDWICH SUDOKU APP◀
AppStore: apps.apple.com/us/app/sandwic...
Steam: store.steampowered.com/app/11...
Android: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
▶SEND US PUZZLES TO SOLVE/CONTACT US◀
crackingthecryptic@gmail.com
▶FOLLOW US◀
Twitter: #crypticcracking
@crypticcracking
Instagram (for how to solve daily clues from The Times): crackingthe...
▶Logo Design◀
Melvyn Mainini

Опубликовано:

15 апр 2022

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 142

@FlorianWortmann 2 года назад

Hey Simon, thanks for the feature! Glad to see you enjoyed the puzzle and I hope everyone watching does as well. I've had a bit of bad news this week, so this came just in the right moment to cheer me up again. Happy Easter to everyone 🙂

@kathyjohnson2043 2 года назад

Sorry you had a bad week. I hope this starts to turn things around

@davidrattner9 2 года назад

Love your puzzles florian ...admire your setting skills...and that your news /life/no matter what is going on continues to get better for you

@rontyson6118 2 года назад

What a really fun puzzle. :)

@Whoa-ex8er 2 года назад

Thank you for another excellent puzzle. This was the perfect difficulty for me, it kept me thinking and was very satisfying to solve. Really brightened my afternoon. I hope things start looking up for you! And happy Easter!

@longwaytotipperary 2 года назад

I hope you are doing well and that everything is getting better!

@sambmortimer 2 года назад

74 minutes! When I first started following this channel I couldn't even begin most of these let alone make progress, but now I'm starting to solve some of the easier ones, albeit slowly.

@krtwood 2 года назад

85 minutes for me and I don't care if I'm at more than double what everybody else did. Still proud of getting it on my own.

@firnen_ 2 года назад

First time I solved one of these without looking anything up in the video. Took me 90 minutes but hey, it's a start and it was a lot of fun and really feels like an accomplishment having completed it.

@melscookin 2 года назад

69:41. I had to restart and watch the video twice and it still took me that long. We'll get better, I hope 🤣

@SnowTheJamMan 2 года назад

Wow i actually beat the video time, solved this one some weeks back and it took me 27 minutes. Granted i didn't have to do introductions or explain everything, but i'm still happy haha

@olivier2553 2 года назад

But that is one quality of Simon that he does so many explanations!

@SjorsHoukes 2 года назад

@@olivier2553 I think that’s what Snow means.

@olivier2553 2 года назад

@@SjorsHoukes Of course, but praising Simon is worth saying it twice :) It is because of Simon that I tried these new forms of Sudoku, because classic was not attractive to me.

@joelstevens5670 2 года назад

Wow, I was not expecting that! The interaction of the 5th row and column plus a few cages and whispers lines, a piece of logic revolving around the middle cell of the grid and the way it triggered the solve of the entire puzzle…that was sublime! Thank you to Florian for setting it and what a sudoku hybrid! :)

@andrewcook8093 2 года назад

The first time ever I’ve seen a break in before Simon. I noticed immediately that the central cell had to be 1 or 9 and either low or high digits in the middle cross. By doing maths on the middle row and central column you can work out that the digits at the edges can’t be high enough if the central square is 1 so it must be 9.

@Stinolez 2 года назад

Immediately when Simon marked the central box I was like - ok, so next he's gonna say - the central square needs to be either 1 or 9 ..

@Coyotek4 2 года назад

21:59 ... I very much enjoyed solving this one. Nice puzzle!

@nonyobisniss7928 2 года назад

After spending over an hour failing to do a puzzle that required set theory a week ago, today I thought I'd skip that and go straight to set theory, after having noted the grid looked suspiciously "boxy". I didn't waste an hour on it, but that false start cost mea good 10-15 minutes. Final time: 45 minutes. This puzzle gave me that baffling feeling of 'I have no idea how to start this', but it amazingly seemed to resolve quite methodically if you just keep chipping away at the possibilities. Great puzzle Florian!

@GuilhermeCarvalhoComposer 2 года назад

Oddly enough, I _did_ get the central 9 through SET. And it felt so neat that I thought it had to be the intended break-in... until Simon came along and solved it in an actually intelligent way. :D

@bristolrovers27 2 года назад

Nice puzzle Simon was going great guns until he had to resort to sudoku which slowed him down considerably.

@pelahnar4 2 года назад

16:10: the moment you realize that 5 does in fact _exist_, even if it doesn't exist on a whispers line

@Steelsky 2 года назад

I was putting the 9 year old boy to bed and he wasn't... motivated to sleep. To wind down I watched this solve with him as I know he's been doing Sudoku at school and while it didn't change his sleepiness any we did have an excellent time talking through the solve.

@OG29 2 года назад

Isn't it wonderful how sudoku and arithmetic get along with each other!?

@crystalgehrt8861 2 года назад

The 28 having such an impact in box 8 was my favorite part. It's a really neat idea for a puzzle and was a fun solve.

@mattinm 2 года назад

I finally beat Simon 🎉! 18:46. I’m honestly very surprised it took as long as it did for Simon to work out the middle digit had to be 9. If it was a 1, even maxing the other two digits in R5 as 4+5, it would require 19 in the outer two digits, which is impossible.

@alanclarke4646 2 года назад

Took me quite a long time but with no help from the video. Quite pleased 😊 Quite early, it can be seen that, as the corner squares of box 5 are all high, then they contain a 6, so the centre square is a 1, or if the corners are all low, they contain a 4, so the centre square is a 9. Therefore R5C5 can only be 1 or 9, which as consequences for the 10 cage, which then affects the 11 cage.

@Celvinbell 2 года назад

I clicked the puzzle link before watching the realized and the CTC software filled up automatically partially started. I must have started it when it came out on LMG, so I just resumed the solved and finished it. Thanks for reminding me to finish the puzzle!

@Tiger21us 2 года назад

32 minutes for me and I had a blast!

@davidhughes7174 2 года назад

I loved this puzzle Florian. I also enjoyed your solve Simon. Thank you to both of you.

@kevinmartin7760 2 года назад

15:20 R5C4 and R5C6 don't have to add up to 7 to disprove the central 1. Even if you max them as 4 and 5, the row totals up to 7 (left cage)+1+4+5+9(right cage) which is 26, leaving 19 to be distributed over the two end cells, which is impossible.

@christhecyclist5998 2 года назад

Thank you. Simon annoyingly spent a lot of time on why them adding up to 7 was huge, but never actually articulated why they had to.

@GregJonson 2 года назад

44 minutes for me. It was not easy to spot the initial few pieces of logic, but once you determine the middle digit, it slowly but surely topples. This is an adorable, if slightly tricky puzzle.

@ericobarrera6580 2 года назад

This was a great puzzle. 39 min for me and I'm proud of the time. Usually I go over double the time it takes for Simon to finish.

@kelv_kei 2 года назад

21:41!! very nice logic involving row 5 and col 5!! and using the 15 cage to disambiguate everything

@piarittersporn 2 года назад

Because there were only two possibilities for r5c5, I quickly found the right digit. Then everything went almost by itself. Towards the end, the overlapping cage helped to position the rest of the digits and it was clear to me why that cage was there. A nice puzzle that I was able to solve relatively quickly. I think I've learned a lot here in this channel.

@HunterJE 2 года назад

6:40 I think you can rule this out by noting the ONLY way to make a 7 cage work while putting a high digit in it is 1-6, but if orange is low it has to be the 1 (since it has to be german-whisper-compatible with all four of the high digits) :edit: Simon gets there by approximately the same logic around 15:00

@michaelholdowsky6386 2 года назад

another way to think about it is if 1 is in the centre then the 2534 quadruple which results precludes any low digits in 9. Here's a knowledge bomb - 9 cages need a low digit. You're welcome.

@MattYDdraig 2 месяца назад

26:49 Really clean design and some nice twists in the solve path.

@susanquig7245 2 года назад

Got it! Loved it! Thank you.

@AnnaVahtera 2 года назад

This has got to be one of the best examples of Stormtrooper Scanning. My goddess, there was so many missed pencilmarks. So. Many.

@AnnaVahtera 2 года назад

@@herrpausr7008 Yeah, yeah it does. I have had to stop watching a few times, because it's just too much. Usually it's just funny and it doesn't really affect anything, but sometimes....

@emilywilliams3237 2 года назад

Thanks for this video and this excellent puzzle, Florian. I enjoyed both. Vocabulary word of the day: recherché. I love it!

@Pokeminator 2 года назад

29:10 this three deserved a song, but Simon didn't give it one 😢

@andrewpalmer5189 2 года назад

64 minutes for me. Kicking myself that I didn't see the break in with row 5. Had to watch the vid. Smooth, even if slow, progress followed.

@sheepswarsmh9955 2 года назад

Thx CTC for the Puzzle. Been working on a few and did this one is 79:45 only needing 23:43 of the vid. Will be trying to do better on the next one.

@soulbound11 2 года назад

I beat the video time by 50 seconds! Yay. Eggcellent puzzle.

@mikedonnan6541 2 года назад

Thank you to S&M (😆) and all the amazing puzzle setters for making sudoku even more indulgent than chocolate this Easter. Simply wonderful channel 🐣

@jacobcombs1106 2 года назад

Took me a little over an hour to do this one because I had figured out the 3/4 in the 14 cage then somehow decided to put an 8 in it and got pretty deep into it before I realized what I had done.

@Terabiel 2 года назад

Once you had the 12 pair in the top line, and 3 in the top center and 4 in the upper right corner, the upper left corner had to be high. I kept waiting for you to notice. AAARGH.

@jdyerjdyer 2 года назад

Yes. I filled that color much earlier and it also helped me figure out that it had to be 6 because of the 14 cage. Once it had a 78 cell, the other two had to be low forcing the other high digit in box 1 into column 1 where there were now virtually 4 high cells with R1C1 being the only one with the possibility of being the 6.

@wanderlustwarrior 2 года назад

33:52 for me, including realizing and fixing a mistake. pretty good time!

@jimbeauchamp2144 2 года назад

Wow this break in was wild

@balkthor 2 года назад

Took a slightly different path to begin. I started by deducing that the Box 2 cage only had one option because any other combination would have broken the cage on Box 8, thanks to the 7 and 9 cages in row 5. From there it was fairly similar to Simon's path.

@hacatu 2 года назад

I found another way to deal with the central column/box: We know that the three cells in the central column in the central box are either all high/five or low/five, and eventually we can discover that each cage in the central box has 1 high and 1 low. But this means that whether the central cell is 1 or 9 we would end up with 5 low/high digits unless we put 5 in the central box in the central column. I used high/low pairs in a couple other places too

@jdyerjdyer 2 года назад

Where Simon got stuck a minute I used box 1 and column 1 to place a 6 in R1C1 as the 14 cage could not have the other high digit because of the 78 cell. So the other high cell (the other 78) had to be in column 1 in box 1 making 4 high cells already in column 1, but more importantly R1C1 is the only one that could be a 6. Also, when using the 15 cage I looked at the other end, with those two cells being at most 9+4=13 preventing a 1 in the other cell making it a 3, putting a 1 two cells below it and bing bada boom, the puzzle unravels. :)

@TurquoizeGoldscraper 2 года назад

38:02 for me - took me 20 minutes to figure out the center digit, I knew it had to be 1 or 9 right from the start, but took me way to long to figure out which is was.

@kevinyoung796 2 года назад

23:05, not difficult but still required a lot of thinking. Nice puzzle.

@AndreAy1975 2 года назад

Solved it with some help from the video.

@thezanycat 2 года назад

I spent about an hour fiddling with SET (you can make a nice checkerboard pattern involving all cages and the 'tips' of every whisper line) - very annoyed this wasn't the way to go lol

@th.nd.r 2 года назад

Beautiful setting and solving! You missed the 3 in the corner though!

@Escviitash 2 года назад

I am partially colorblind and can therefore say that yellow and purple are just as good as blue and orange, as they are also contrasting colors, and IMO yellow and purple is the better choice as the blue gets to close to the color of non-given/inserted digits, making it much harder to scan the puzzle. Another thing is that colorblind people often rely on brightness to distinguish colors and blue and orange are in that perspective closer to each other than purple and yellow. And if you are completely colorblind brighness is the only difference.

@Gonzalo_Garcia_ 2 года назад

16:53 for me. Wow, I love the design of this puzzle so much, it looks fantastic. The logic is great as well, all in all an awesome puzzle.

@markp7262 2 года назад

21:32 finish. I just went ahead and color-coded the entire grid with high-low-5 (am I playing Pitch/Pedro now?). Very nice puzzle!

@Z1atk0 2 года назад

3:00 No, it does not break the symmetry. The symmetry runs along the diagonal from r1c1 to r9c9, and not along an x/y axis through r5 & c5.☝🤓 😉

@benjaminrealy5661 2 года назад

45:50. Got hung up not realizing the cage in box 7 could be x,2,y. So erroneously assumed it had to have digit "z" which got me going a few minutes until the puzzle broke, then backtracking to find where the error occurred without sacrificing the progress I'd already made. (But not knowing when and where the error occured)

@inspiringsand123 2 года назад

Rules: 02:33 Let's Get Cracking: 03:31 Simon's time: 28m30s Puzzle Solved: 32:01 What about this video's Top Tier Simarkisms?! The Secret: 3x (17:18, 17:24, 17:29) Phistomefel: 2x (00:51, 01:33) Bobbins: 1x (09:55) And how about this video's Simarkisms?! Beautiful: 6x (11:35, 15:16, 18:15, 18:17, 21:56, 32:11) Ah: 6x (10:51, 11:35, 15:06, 15:11, 18:15, 27:11) By Sudoku: 5x (23:34, 26:17, 27:25, 31:05, 31:21) In Fact: 3x (02:44, 08:22, 18:42) Obviously: 3x (03:20, 08:15, 20:21) Sorry: 2x (05:41, 21:49) Surely: 2x (08:53, 19:02) That's Huge: 2x (15:38, 15:54) Clever: 1x (15:11) Missing Something: 1x (28:02) I Have no Clue: 1x (03:34) Lovely: 1x (16:03) Elegant: 1x (32:21) Famous Last Words: 1x (03:57) Of All Things: 1x (22:46) Hang On: 1x (16:12) I've Got It!: 1x (01:08) Disappointing: 1x (10:27) On the Cusp: 1x (26:57) Most popular number(>9), digit and colour this video: Ten (7 mentions) Two (71 mentions) Blue (11 mentions) Antithesis Battles: Low (35) - High (27) Higher (2) - Lower (1) FAQ: Q1: You missed something! A1: That could very well be the case! Human speech can be hard to understand for computers like me! Point out the ones that I missed and maybe I'll learn! Q2: Can you do this for another channel? A2: I've been thinking about that and wrote some code to make that possible. Let me know which channel you think would be a good fit!

@Censeo 2 года назад

Is "that is a something" in the list?

@cbear7996 2 года назад

Howabout the Try Guys?

@expic3954 2 года назад

Do you get paid to do this or

@cbear7996 2 года назад

It’s a bot that some very nice human made

@expic3954 2 года назад

@@cbear7996 I see. Very complex bot

@daniellucas5522 2 года назад

Huh, this is interesting. I used the cross pattern of the 4 cages to figure out that the middle cell couldn't be low, because it would need to be 4 (and the outermost digits be 9/8 in both c5 and row 5) for that to work, and since 4 can't go in the middle of a german whisper line I was able to say that it was a high digit early on. I'm surprised to see that this wasn't necessary to the break-in. EDIT: Looking back, all you need is row 5 and the realisation that the middle digit is 1 or 9. if it's 1 then the maximum total of r5c4-6 is 10. 10+7+9 is 26 which you can't make with 7 digits.

@Paolo_De_Leva 2 года назад

Also, at playback time 14:36: 1) Either *{2-5}* or *{3-4}* is forced into the *7-cage* 2) This creates a *{2-3-4-5}* quadruple in *row 5.* 3) That quadruple, together with the 1 in the central cell, rule 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 out of the *9-cage,* making it impossible to fill (its minimum value would be 6+7 =13)‼ This is probably less elegant than your method, but it does not require you to think about *triangular numbers.*

@michaelhoffman2011 2 года назад

I solved it slightly differently to Simon, if 1 was in the middle then all of the edges of the horizontal whisper would have to be high, and since you could not use 1 6 for the 7 cage, there is no place to put 4 high numbers along line 5... sorry if that sounds confusing.... but great puzzle =)

@Kinada 2 года назад

Took me a bit to see the way though but overall it didn't seem to be that hard of a puzzle once I did. Lots of fun.

@bibliopolist 2 года назад

One of the rare examples where I beat the video time, at 21:15.

@joelstevens5670 2 года назад

Interesting how Simon determined the middle cell. I went a different route using the 9 cage in box 6, having previously worked out that a) the central cell of the box could either be 1, 2, 3 or 8 and b) there could not be a 6 on the whispers line in box 4 (it would cause a repeated 6 or 1). If the central cell of box 6 was a 2 or a 3 (i.e. if the middle cell was a 1, which would rule out 1 and 8), it would force high digits on both ends of the whispers line but this would form two quadruples in rows 4 and 6, with the 6 in each having to appear in box 5 and this would cause a repeated 6 in the box. Therefore the middle cell is a 9. I can say that I really enjoyed both ways. Thanks Simon for the solve video.

@jdyerjdyer 2 года назад

I have a third easier way for you. All those four cages have to have at least one low digit, therefore if you make R5C5 low, forcing the corners high and the edges in box 5 three low digits and a single 5, then either column 5 or row 5 (the one that doesn't have the 5 on it) will have five low digits and last time I checked, there are only four digits below 5 in sudoku. :)

@jdyerjdyer 2 года назад

(This does require one extra step as the 11 cage could have a high digit of 6 with the 5, but the whispers line prevents that combination, thankfully.)

@dontmindme2844 2 года назад

The 6 staring at 2 digits of the 3 cell cage doesn't place the 6...no, we have wait until we eliminate the 1 and 2 from the third cell...

@jdyerjdyer 2 года назад

Have to build up the tension before one can have the 6.

@HeroDarkStorn 2 года назад

15:34 Haha, I found completely different way to get the same: Following the coloring of middle box (center orange, corners blue), look at column 5. The 11-cage must be blue/orange = high/low pair (since 56 option is gone). The 10-cage has to be that too, as anyone who solved whisper+cages puzzles knows. Now the four "central" cells of box four have to be almost all orange (with one of them being a 5). So how do you finish column 5? You have two highs and lows in cages, and you have three or two orange cells in box 5. But you can't actually have three orange cells, because 2+3=5 and you can't have five high/low cells in a column (remember, orange cells are all high or all low). This puts one orange and a 5 in box 5 col 5, and means that row 5 of box 5 is all orange. At this point, I had some logic done in row 5 and its 9-cage. Notice, that it cannot contain a 5. 5 cannot go on whisper, and 5 in the other cell puts 4 on whisper, which would need two 9's in a box. This makes the 9-cage high/low pair, and therefore orange/blue pair. We now have all 4 orange cells of row 5 placed, and we can finish with Simon's logic that you need a low cell in the 7-cage, so orange must be high. Who says Simon always find the most roundabout logic? :D :D

@jdyerjdyer 2 года назад

Simply say: All four cages have to have at least one low cell (as the 11 cage can't be 56), so making R5C5 low would force either column 5 or row 5 to have 5 low digits, of which there can only be 4, so R5C5 is high and 9 since it needs four unique digits at least 5 away from it.

@GirGir183 2 года назад

Those two german whispers lines in box 5 might not be two straight lines. The could be a downward pointing arrow in the top half of the box and an upward pointing arrow in the bottom half.

@alienrenders 2 года назад

23:23 for me. A little on the simple side, but enjoyable.

@TMThesaurus 2 года назад

14:40 I'm probably being thick, but why do they need to add up to 7?

@perhenrikhuss3461 2 года назад

It’s because the seven sum box can’t be 1+6 as the 1 would already be in the row. It then would need to be either 2+5 or 3+4, which leave the other two for the middle box and they will also sum up to seven. Adding the rest of the logic it became impossible to have the 1 in the middle of the grid.

@TMThesaurus 2 года назад

@@perhenrikhuss3461 Oh, of course. I was going about it backwards

@richarddavy-smith6626 2 года назад

The new bond film has just turned up on Amazon prime, which I was really looking forward to, but I just had to finish this video first. #priorities

@Ray-iu7hg 2 года назад

22:40 very cool

@kilograham5 2 года назад

i got a little set happy, and selected column 5 and row 5 in one set, and box 5 in the other, leaving the four corners in box 5 adding up to 45 less than quite a lot of things elsewhere. knowing that r5c5 was 1 or 9 according to the polarity, the low-ness of the box 5 corners was forced

@dannstarrjp 2 года назад

Took me about 5 seconds to put a 1-9 pair in the central cell of box5 (I remembered that from puzzles I did before). But took me over half an hour to figure out that it can’t be a 1 (that Simon proved in first couple of minutes and then forgot about 😅).

@Sam_on_YouTube 2 года назад

Took me 90 minutes, but I got it.

@boydegg 2 года назад

Ye Gods, I found that tough. Finally cracked it in 63:04

@Archik4 2 года назад

I have solved it.

@user-jp7tw3sd3x 2 года назад

Simon, may I ask you to increase the audio volume of the videos. Keep the talk in the yellow zone.

@0Clewi0 2 года назад

24:13 I got a bit the hang of it mid way, realative approachable, just look for doubles

@martinepstein9826 2 года назад

I'm surprised Simon got orange = high without using column 5 at all. I did it completely differently. The two cages in column 5 consist of a high digit and a low digit each. That means they each contain an orange digit, so in box 5 those orange digits have to go in row 5. That means box 5 row 5 is all orange, and since we already have at least two low digits in row 5 orange must be high.

@nhutang433 2 года назад

37:59 for me, it was a fun and approachable puzzle :)

@LednacekZ 2 года назад

20:59 for me. Quite a good time i think.

@samueldeandrade8535 4 месяца назад

27:28 there is no way, NO WAY!, that Simon finds a horizontal 35 pair and don't use it with the vertical 39 pair in box 9. There is simply no way, man. That's impossible.

@adrianhead6272 2 года назад

Completed in 19m12s

@PathOfShrines 2 года назад

Fun! 33:08

@teresagg9809 2 года назад

I could not finish and had to watch to figure out my mistake. I messed up 5 in box 9. had to go half way back. My time 102:47

@Lantalia 2 года назад

... amusing that it took so long to worki out r5c5, since the most the alternate can be pushed to is 43, without even considering conflicts between the 7 and 9 cages [17+16+_10_]

@srwapo 2 года назад

Felt like I solved this in 35 minutes, but I put 7,3 in the 11 cage in box 2 very early on and got the wrong solution (and it had two valid solutions, which is how I found out it was wrong!). I could redo it, but my logic was on point execpt for the mistake, so I wouldn't have a new experience. :(

@johnwiles5905 2 года назад

I did the same thing. 7+3 does not equal 11!

@notdetails 2 года назад

solved in 19:55 :D

@timdorr 2 года назад

It turns out yelLOW is a good choice for low digits 😀

@jdyerjdyer 2 года назад

I prefer orange for low and blue for high. Oranges are near the ground and the sky is blue, so you get low oranges and sky highs. :)

@erickehr4475 2 года назад

17:30 for me.

@dwarfigplays9806 2 года назад

That was hard for me! 1:10:23.

@_-_-Sipita-_-_ 2 года назад

27:10 for me.

@anybrody 2 года назад

done

@toxicara 2 года назад

Once you knew the central square had to be a 1 or a 9. You could then look at how many low numbers you could fit in row 5. Then you would have known the central square would been a 9.

@toxicara 2 года назад

I'm glad you found it early on😎

@jdyerjdyer 2 года назад

You don't need to know that it is a 1 or a 9. Just how it interacts with the lines and the cages in rows 4 and 5 is enough. If you make it low, then you end up with 5 lows in either row 5 or column 5 because the 11 cage can't be the 56 combo, all four cages must have at least 1 low in them, so no matter where you place the 5 in box 5, either the column or the row ends up with too many lows. That tells you R5C5 is high. Then realizing that you have to have 4 different digits that are at least 5 away then tells you it is the 9.

@Paolo_De_Leva 2 года назад

There is a third way to rule *1* out of the central cell *(r5c5),* without using triangular numbers: 1) As shown by Simon at playback time 14:36, If the central cell is *1,* then *blue cells* = high digits (6-7-8-9), the remaining cells in box 5 are from *{2, 3, 4, 5}* and either *{2-5}* or *{3-4}* is forced into the *7-cage* 2) This creates a *{2-3-4-5}* quadruple in *row 5* 3) That quadruple, together with the 1 in the central cell, rule 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 out of the *9-cage,* making it impossible to fill (its minimum value would be 6+7 =13)‼ QED

@Paolo_De_Leva 2 года назад

In a previous comment, *Daniel Lucas* describes the most elegant method to reach the same conclusion using the triangular number for 7 (i.e. 1+2+3+4+5+6+7 = 28). Simon used a similar method at playback time 15:00.

@jdyerjdyer 2 года назад

I simply used the fact that you can't have 5 low digits in a column or row and putting a 1 in R5C5 forces 5 low digits either in the column or the row since the 11 cage can't be 56.

@Paolo_De_Leva 2 года назад

@@jdyerjdyer How did you *"simply"* prove that a *1* in r5c5 forces 5 low digits either in r5 or c5? I can prove it only for *row 5* by using my steps 1 and 2 (see above), and rewriting step 3. But that is not simple and does not apply to column 5.

@jdyerjdyer 2 года назад

@@Paolo_De_Leva All of the four cages in row 5 and column 5 have to have a low digit (as the 11 cage can't be the 56 combo because of the whisper line), so that is two in each and if you put a 1 in R5C5 then even placing the 5 in either the column or the row will force the other to have the other two low digits and with the 1 that gives 5 low digits. (The whispers lines in box 5 force the corners to all be high if R5C5 is low, which forces the other squares in the 3x3 to be low or 5.)

@jdyerjdyer 2 года назад

@@Paolo_De_Leva You can actually even see that R5C5 has to be high before recognizing that it is limited to the extremes of 1 and 9 through this logic.

@MariaVlasiou 2 года назад

I am tired. I saw that 15 cage between boxes 2 and 5 as a 2-cell cage and had a simple constructive proof why this is unsolvable. 5 minutes in, proving a result and never noticing it is a 3-cell cage.

@Raven-Creations 2 года назад

Having just worked out that the whispers cell in the 9 cage is low, you proceed to colour it yellow "until we work out whether it's high or low". Is your short term memory really that bad? The key thing to notice is that the centre cell can only be 19 (they are the only digits which can whisper to four other digits), if it's 1, that means you need a low digit of 23 in each of the 7 & 9 cages, with a 45 pair on the horizontal bar of the + in box 5, but you'd also need a 4 or 5 in the 7 cage. Therefore, the centre must be 9 with 1234 in the corners. This gives you so much information that it very quickly solves. Once again, your pencil-marking was sloppy. You'd just put 346 on the bottom of box 7, and correctly deduced that the corner couldn't be 6, but failed to look up where there was a 4. Even so, you still put 123 into R7C3, when not ten seconds earlier you'd put a 346 triple in the box. You put a 35 pair in R7, but still failed to remove the 3 from R7C3, and worse, you failed to resolve the 39 pair right next to the 35 pair. Then you ask "what am I missing here?" Discipline, that's what. At the top, you had a 569 triple, where the corner couldn't be 5, but neither could the third if you'd only looked. Your deliberations on the 14 had you put a 23 in a cell in a column containing a 2. For the 17 cage, you had 12, which had to go with 15 or16, the 15 couldn't be 69, so either way it needed a 7, which only had one place to go, and the other digit was an 89, forming a pair in the box. This lovely puzzle could have been resolved very quickly if you'd only been disciplined, and checked your placements both before putting inappropriate pencil-marks, and after placing pencil-marks to check what they resolve. This is so simple, and takes almost no time, I really don't understand why you steadfastly refuse to correct this. You're so keen on teaching beginners, but why are you teaching them bad habits?

@lewisgray1453 2 года назад

pov you only watch Simon

@haydenwolf935 Год назад

*** 3 in the corner ***

@libromaniatic 2 года назад

At 27:32 he gets the clue on box 8 that could make everything easier(Where the 9 go in box 9) He then proceeds to ignore that clue and ignore its existence until he solves the puzzle. Poor ignored clue

@jdyerjdyer 2 года назад

He also ignored the 6 pointing at the cage in box 3. He still got there though, which is all that counts...I think. lol

@jimbeauchamp2144 2 года назад

28:10 “what am I missing” 4 giving you R9C9, row 7 being totally done, 5 in box 1, should I go on lmao

@mirekchytil903 2 года назад

I needed a poke - disambiguating polarity in the central box, all else went quite well... I see Simon did the same mistake and filled the remaining cells with 6789 instead of 5678, though he noticed it a bit earlier :D