Тёмный

Whitewash? Unpacking Public Protector's Phala Phala Report on President Ramaphosa 

SMWX
Подписаться 132 тыс.
Просмотров 56 тыс.
50% 1

Welcome to our deep dive into the Phala Phala Scandal, a controversy that sent ripples through South Africa's political landscape. We closely examine Public Protector Kholeka Gcaleka's report on allegations of President Cyril Ramaphosa's involvement with an R8m stash found on his Phala Phala farm.
This video aims to dissect and critically analyze the report while providing context and background for a more comprehensive understanding. We delve into questions of conflict of interest, issues of paid work, and the mysteries surrounding Major General Rhoode's role.
From methodological scrutiny of Gcaleka's investigative procedures to a thorough analysis of the report's content and its conclusions, we challenge the findings and shed light on the discrepancies and potential inaccuracies.
In collaboration with legal experts, political analysts, and investigative professionals, we attempt to unearth the truth hidden beneath the surface of this convoluted scandal. This isn't just about questioning the verdict; it's about fostering informed discussions and critical thinking regarding the functioning of our political and legal systems.
Share your thoughts in the comments below. For those seeking deep dives into political events and insightful analyses, make sure to subscribe and hit the notification bell to stay updated. Stay tuned, as we continue to seek the truth, and nothing but the truth
Become a RU-vid Member of this channel to get access to perks:
/ @_smwx
Visit my website: sizwempofuwalsh.com
_______
CONTENTS
00:00 Intro
02:12 Background
06:29 Conflict?
23:54 VIP protection
_______
Credits: Edited by Tsholanang Rapoo
Directed by Muano Mangaladzi
Thumbnail: Tshepo Mosoeu
About me: Dr Sizwe Mpofu-Walsh is an author, scholar and founder of the Sizwe Mpofu-Walsh Xperience (SMWX), a digital, youth-centred current affairs platform. He holds a DPhil in International Relations from the University of Oxford and is a Lecturer in International Relations at Wits.

Опубликовано:

 

30 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 416   
@tsepom455
@tsepom455 Год назад
The owner of Shoprite is not always in the store, so according to Gcaleka, they don't sell. 🤦🏾‍♂️ This is ridiculous from her.
@GeniusLila
@GeniusLila Год назад
And according to you they do sell?
@tsepom455
@tsepom455 Год назад
@@GeniusLila They do sell. The acting PP got it wrong in my opinion.
@jongikhayangcebetsha6580
@jongikhayangcebetsha6580 Год назад
She didnt say CR doesnt sell game. Everybody knows he does that because he declared the business
@tsepom455
@tsepom455 Год назад
@@jongikhayangcebetsha6580 That means then in that regard there was a conflict of interest. 🤷🏾‍♂️ She said there wasn't.
@tebogov6517
@tebogov6517 Год назад
What is ridiculous is to believe that if the owner of ShopRite says 'I am in the business of selling food items' it therefore follows that he is involved in the day to day transactions that take place in the shop. You cannot conclude that by selling the owner means involvement in the daily transactions unless there is evidence to that effect. When an owner says i sell they might mean they are selling personally or they might mean someone selling on their behalf something which is ultimately theirs
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
Thanks for watching. Like, share and subscribe! 🙂
@brightonmukwindidza9627
@brightonmukwindidza9627 Год назад
Kindly explain the WALSH.
@nkanyezivilakati168
@nkanyezivilakati168 Год назад
Congratulations Sizwe Mpofu on your exceptional work breaking down the Phalaphala report of the public protector. Your dedication and attention to detail have helped shed light on crucial information and hold those in power accountable. Keep up the excellent work!🙏🏻
@smangankosi5124
@smangankosi5124 Год назад
Thank you for simplifying the report. When I listen to her I see why we are miles away from have a proper justice system
@eugenetshuma7470
@eugenetshuma7470 Год назад
So these (drug) merchants who are employing young boys to go stand and sell drugs on street corners are not committing any crime because they are not INTERACTING direct with the customers?
@mphomofokeng1837
@mphomofokeng1837 Год назад
Sizwe your analysis is spot on. The Public Prosecutor was applying for a permanent job at our expense for releasing such a shabby report.
@SimphiweZwane-rw2jy
@SimphiweZwane-rw2jy Год назад
Well she won't get it now
@victormolapo902
@victormolapo902 Год назад
This is a first bold step, simplifying and bringing this information to the public. Next step is action by the people. What are we doing /going to do? It can't end here
@xolintusi966
@xolintusi966 Год назад
We're fucked! Not a single person in power today has the balls to say - "siyanyeleka ngoku" Nditsho nenxila lelali would say: "if they found those dollars in your house, you would be in jail." And this is when you buy him another round. And we have people in SA thinking that the judiciary is not captured. Emotions aside...what if this money was found at Zuma's house? Again, because some of us have no ability to think...i am not defending anyone here (trust me, they are all the same) the so-called break in was not reported, instead someone else was called in to have a "look at it". why would you not inform the police about such?
@njabulomsweli5057
@njabulomsweli5057 Год назад
My brother don't fear to say it that we have judged the former president harshly yes he has his mistakes like everyone but the current one is a devil....
@gdewyg
@gdewyg Год назад
It doesn't need legal expertise to come to conclusion that this public protector is wrong. She is indeed suspicious
@annahkhechane5239
@annahkhechane5239 Год назад
😳😳
@carolinejeanallincarolj
@carolinejeanallincarolj Год назад
How much did Cyril pay this protector to cover her whitewashing his part in the part of his farm, his part in it, don't trust this whole report
@mogamatyusufmartin9171
@mogamatyusufmartin9171 Год назад
True ....in the way in which she answers the questions put to her shows she is protecting him Sorry Mzansi she should not be all means become our next public protector because then she will really be protecting anc instead of protecting our interests from their corruption and wrongdoings
@kopanokhumalo4344
@kopanokhumalo4344 Год назад
I just realized ramaphosa has the judiciary ,parliament and private companies ...this man is powerful
@zenzonxele9509
@zenzonxele9509 Год назад
Bro that is only one arbiter is next year vote. you forgot 2 critical things he has also captured: The media and those stupid NGOs who were always in Zumas tail. Not even a single NGO is talking about this toilet roll report.
@sihlemkhize5857
@sihlemkhize5857 Год назад
Mbulazi only now you realize this is the real state capture jacob zuma was in the way and they just had to paint him
@mphomangole3768
@mphomangole3768 Год назад
All I say about this phala phala issue is that. Murder wills out.
@notyetuhuru
@notyetuhuru Год назад
Matamela is the epitome of what Msholozi was accused of perpetuating during his tenure as president.
@Courts220
@Courts220 Год назад
My favourite guy when it comes to breaking down complicated matters for ordinary South Africans. Keep up the good work brother! 👏
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
🙌🏽
@mhlonishwavilane6197
@mhlonishwavilane6197 Год назад
Are Dali Mpofu's son or u are just sharing surname, I really like yo analysis n the way of questioning
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
Yes I am 🙂
@mhlonishwavilane6197
@mhlonishwavilane6197 Год назад
U are both my favorite
@siphodlamini1624
@siphodlamini1624 Год назад
Baba Advocate Mpofu is the Lion, hate or like him but that does not change his greatness.
@sjaymabaso9391
@sjaymabaso9391 Год назад
Adv Gcaleka risked her career and credibility to protect Cyril. She gave us a rubbish report 🚮🚮. Zondo and his crew will definitely defend Cyril, Mogoeng warned us about the capture the judiciary and Cyril has won, Ledwaba, Mlambo and Zondo must be commended for working to protect Cyril 👏👏👏
@andilebrunososibo4126
@andilebrunososibo4126 Год назад
She was appointed for that very reason, to protect cyril's interest in all cost
@siyandathabede4382
@siyandathabede4382 Год назад
I love this analysis. He had a conflict of interest in that he took money that was for the sale of livestock, his mind was on the sale and he derived a financial benefit from that sale. He took money after the sale, according to him he had it stored. It not like he waits for a financial year end to take his share of profits but because he take proceeds right there and then makes him to be directly involved.
@zolisazolisa9734
@zolisazolisa9734 Год назад
Wally acted on an owner’s instruction ,yet the owner is exonerated.
@lallganasram8924
@lallganasram8924 Год назад
One can fool all the people some of the time, and some of the people all the time, but cannot fool all the people all the time.
@lucasthsepang3968
@lucasthsepang3968 Год назад
True that🧠💪🏿
@bubu345
@bubu345 Год назад
Public are fools anyway 😅
@sonwabilemadikizela3601
@sonwabilemadikizela3601 Год назад
Whether the president neither nor physically deals with the selling.The question is where does the profit go to ultimately ?
@SimphiweZwane-rw2jy
@SimphiweZwane-rw2jy Год назад
I mean isn't that common sense
@mzwandilemgweba360
@mzwandilemgweba360 Год назад
You have done a great job, investigative journalism at it's best!!!
@kgaogeloraolane696
@kgaogeloraolane696 Год назад
Now that the report is released I won't be surprised if the concourt gives judgement very soon
@melvinlephale9345
@melvinlephale9345 Год назад
As long as Ramaphalaphala is still seating as our president there is no way we gon see him found guilty of any wrongdoings🤞
@ziphelelekhumalo9429
@ziphelelekhumalo9429 Год назад
Especially with a President Protector like Gcaleka. She blatantly ignored the risk of conflict of interest, using VIP public protection services to investigate a personal matter without proper procedures and authorization. Gcaleka is as guilty as Ramaphosa
@InvestmentLefutswe-zf6qy
@InvestmentLefutswe-zf6qy Год назад
True
@mbulelohoyiya7993
@mbulelohoyiya7993 Год назад
Good point sitting president may not be found guilty and we have seen it before with previous presidents
@ntetesemela9345
@ntetesemela9345 Год назад
Sisi, if you sell and buy don't you make negotiations and deals? Don't the seller receive the money?🌞
@sifisodube4686
@sifisodube4686 Год назад
His a powerful man he has proven that all his enemies he kicked them out. Phala Phala it’s history people must focussed on more important things that the country it’s facing Cyril will remained as president weather people like it or not you can’t fight the establishment no way
@mhlabuthinisibiya8454
@mhlabuthinisibiya8454 Год назад
I love the sound quality, graphics and of course you are the greatest in breaking down topics and presenting your arguments. 🎉
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
🙌🏽
@tshidisomabitle7373
@tshidisomabitle7373 Год назад
Great analysis as usual..the timing of the suspension of the pp..? The courts delay in regarding the appeal by the presi? The delay with Sars..? Delay with srbs report? All this read together with the firt delayed report being released in favour of the president seems to indicate a pattern aligned wit protecting the president..!... Are the courts comprised regarding this president?
@marabunya
@marabunya Год назад
Exactly, the suspension of Adv. Mkhwebane was a strategic move from the higher ups.
@sifisomhlongo2546
@sifisomhlongo2546 Год назад
Thank You Doc, great analysis, and thanks for your bravery, as for me, I think this case is a serious test of our democracy and state institutions, can state employees really find against their employer? I think that even if it goes to court, Chief Justice Zondo was appointed by Cyril against the recommendation of the panel, so Cyril Ramaphosa should have stepped aside until these investigations are concluded, but as long as he still holds so much power, no one will risk their career and challenge the president, no wonder SARS is quiet, it is waiting for national elections next year, ask Busisiwe, she will tell you
@sandilemrfridge4943
@sandilemrfridge4943 Год назад
I was waiting and hoping that my brother " Sizwe" will dive deep to enlighten us as always. Thanks and bless you Sizwe.
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
🙌🏽
@thabangsimelane7730
@thabangsimelane7730 Год назад
PP's interpretation of 'conflict of interest' 100% incorrect. Shocking.
@SiyandaQoto
@SiyandaQoto Год назад
Great video, Sizwe! 🙌 You make compelling arguments. Can't wait to have the matter heard in court; it should be fascinating. Keep it up, Doc. Ayeye!🚀
@Loadedopinions
@Loadedopinions Год назад
Thank you Sizwe for improving the sound. The content as always is top notch
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
Thanks, we continue to improve. Thanks for your comments.
@molwakapelolekalakala373
@molwakapelolekalakala373 Год назад
It wil be silly for a reasonable person to believe that Wally Roodte acted without the knowledge of his boss.
@carolinejeanallincarolj
@carolinejeanallincarolj Год назад
Me thinks they were both on the dirty deal without a deal
@carolinejeanallincarolj
@carolinejeanallincarolj Год назад
Doubt
@picassocube3521
@picassocube3521 Год назад
What's interesting about Ramaphosa fans, you won't hear them commenting and defending him or his Gcaleka, because Phala Phala issue is not defendable, that's why the owner himself decided to shut up about it! You only see fans celebrating his questionable victories!
@jitterycursor8823
@jitterycursor8823 Год назад
This is the most comprehensive deep dive into this complex web. Thanks for doing the painstaking work of reading and unpacking this messy saga Sizwe. This is quite refreshing from the shallow and mudslinging ad-hominem critiques of the PPs report bandied about in the mainstream media. I've been watching SMWX since 2019, and this is some of your best work.👏👏👏 This type of journalism/analysis reminded me of Eusebius. Please keep shining this torch. ❤❤❤
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
Thanks, much appreciated. 🙏🏽
@wisangobeni4256
@wisangobeni4256 Год назад
I used to see @sizweMpofuWalshOfficial as impartial, no more. Your analysis on the DPP's Phala Phala report is negative. She has not got any point correct??? Her every reasoning is flawed??? Where is the analysis of Mkhwebani'reports?? Her four reports are failing at the application of law, found to be incompetent, including lying under oath; where is the analysis of stylingrad by your grand dad Zuma?
@MrPoliteAgain
@MrPoliteAgain Год назад
Bro you make it so easy for us to understand complicated issues. Thank you! And the Buffalo names 😂😂😂😂
@user-hc5xz6nw6p
@user-hc5xz6nw6p Год назад
Keep up the good work SMWX team.
@emmanuelshangase6790
@emmanuelshangase6790 Год назад
hahahaha Kimberly and Leyla. thank you Sizwe for the thus analysis.Thus report has left many people asking many questions. There is a snippet where the president is confirming that he is a farmer...and makes his money by selling games. was this not enough to confirm that he still has control of the farm?
@nandivanqa-mgijima646
@nandivanqa-mgijima646 Год назад
Thank you for the mañer in which unpack these developments. Great insights Sizwe
@hallaback2010
@hallaback2010 Год назад
😂😂😂. This Phala Phala thing is worth a movie. Kimberley? ?😂😂😂
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
😂😂😂
@kopanomofokeng5939
@kopanomofokeng5939 Год назад
I have been waiting for this analysis. Thank You Sizwe 🙏
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
🙏🏽🙌🏽
@tumeloseadira8224
@tumeloseadira8224 Год назад
I think you should've invited Adv Sikhakhane for this episode. The reason being, while have our opinion as public, we don't have legal merits to support such an opinion. Therefore, Adv would've given us a proper explanation since it is his field of work.
@mzolisikolweni707
@mzolisikolweni707 Год назад
Indeed
@mandisatiti27
@mandisatiti27 Год назад
Thanks Sizwe, great work as usual 🙏
@alexemergineer3202
@alexemergineer3202 Год назад
Please do video on Paul Mashatile VIP Protection in the assault of private citizens ❤
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
Check my SABC show on that last week.
@user-jf8zr5nc3y
@user-jf8zr5nc3y Год назад
Good day SMWX thank you for this unpacking video, coming from your number 1 fan. I have about 10 questions i would like to ask you about all the videos i've been watching of you.
@bonelelamene7918
@bonelelamene7918 Год назад
Great analysis Sizwe as always Mnr, . How peculiar she can arrive at such conclusion. Infect kicking the can to the captured judiciary to make the final determination on the phala phala matter, sad state of affairs in sa. Black people we must free ourselves from this nonsensical corrupt government.
@ellishaindobo1794
@ellishaindobo1794 Год назад
This for clearing this whole mess up, Doc.
@derickarendse9546
@derickarendse9546 Год назад
Sizwe your analyze is always fair. I couldn't help to laugh for the names of the animals. These powerful politicians operates like mafias. The $'s was never declared. Why was the money not in the bank. Why was the case not reported to Saps. Imagine was it you or I the law would have been different. South Africa is a failed State because of our leaders. Keep up the good work my brother. You asked the questions that the people really wants to know.
@normanpule4278
@normanpule4278 Год назад
This PP is desperate for the job. However, her day will come never undermine the public...
@kgjaqe1169
@kgjaqe1169 Год назад
Thank you kindly for such a great articulation on this matter.
@Sticknbkid
@Sticknbkid Год назад
I don’t want to be protected by this lady. What a spinner.
@user-mh6rb1hp6p
@user-mh6rb1hp6p Год назад
Well said indeed my brother ❤
@joecruiser
@joecruiser Год назад
The Chief Buffalo of the SA Banana Republic is whining about being "challenged".... Maybe he does not need, or want to be the Chief in Charge. He already has Bieljons!
@viwembelekane4900
@viwembelekane4900 Год назад
The example of the farmer and the worker is easy to understand. I wish law could be this simple.
@cherylgoldsmith8133
@cherylgoldsmith8133 11 месяцев назад
Very informative, thank you for clarity, excellent!
@MegaDiva1999
@MegaDiva1999 11 месяцев назад
What is she even saying this incoming PP ?Now we are stuck with her for 5 more years.We need more talent pliz. Thanks Sizwe for keepng us sane and informed
@mzwakhemsimango4459
@mzwakhemsimango4459 Год назад
These people wanna tell us what to think and that’s that. The real state capture in real time.
@realmaake5988
@realmaake5988 Год назад
Animal farm: All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal😂
@patricknkosi5412
@patricknkosi5412 Год назад
Its a combination between animal farm and 1984!!😢
@Nzeenzi
@Nzeenzi Год назад
26:30 that link between Ramaphosa VIP & Mashatile VIP does paint a clear picture.
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
Indeed.
@motsamaimokoena2604
@motsamaimokoena2604 Год назад
Eh Sizwe mun!!! you are indeed your father's son, you should consider to be a lawyer. Your analysis is on point and supported by case law and judgements. nice one bro
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
🙏🏽
@LeoSunAquarianMoon
@LeoSunAquarianMoon Год назад
Thanks Sizwe
@brianmagopa3872
@brianmagopa3872 Год назад
Sizwe your analysis of the report is on point. There was no risk of conflict of interest but definite conflict of interest on the part of Ramaphosa. As for the definition of paid work by acting PP that's 🐂 shit. The finding against Wally Roodte, that's a big joke. This is one report that can't be defended in any court of law
@takalani3367
@takalani3367 Год назад
The director of Exxaro mine, does not go down mine to extract mineral and do not get the sellers to buy them. He does not get a payslip at the end of the month. Effectively it is not paid work as defined by DPP. Effectively President was a volunteer at Phalaphala Farm
@bridges5659
@bridges5659 Год назад
Great stuff , son. The paid work should be seen as ' Income ' , and the president is earning an income from that farm. His declaration of conflict of interest (original physical copy of documents ) should be made available readily as this should have been done upon his designation as president and a copy of every year in his term as president. Declaration of conflict of interest is signed every year by employees and members of a group/organisation or government , where that person receives a remuneration from for his designated job functions and descriptions. The illegal dollars found in his sofas is answerable by the president . He is an apparent thief and money launderer . Any other ordinary citizen would be jailed by these acts. As for conflict of interest , the president is in breach of it and guilty as hell. As for the public protector , she is a foolish person , grabbing at straws and nitty-gritty excuses to make the president look ' not guilty ' . I would love to boot her hard up her ass. As a public protector , she is actually breaking the law with the use of petty and silly excuses for Ramapinocchio. As for Kimberly and Layla , hulle ma se poes. Many thanks.
@zakhelemazibuko5468
@zakhelemazibuko5468 Год назад
Mr Phala Phala and his PP are so reckless and taking people for granted and destroying ANC in the process.
@thulanigamede7652
@thulanigamede7652 Год назад
This makes me think of why is Cyril so obssessed about 'state capture' every time he opens his mouth he mentions something about 'state capture'. Is it because he knows that he is the real master of state capture and he's always trying divert attention away from himself.
@bisabop976
@bisabop976 Год назад
As Im opening this breaking news just confirmed the validity of the PP's suspension. We're really living in interesting times.
@Mr300568
@Mr300568 Год назад
Thanks so much Sizwe for this scientific and thorough analysis on this very important matter
@antoinemuskat5557
@antoinemuskat5557 Год назад
Thank you for the summary
@sisandatech
@sisandatech Год назад
Layman explanation 🎉 are key for us to understand
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
👍🏽
@sandilezulu3973
@sandilezulu3973 Год назад
I like the analysis, very detailed
@sikhumbuzolukashe4431
@sikhumbuzolukashe4431 Год назад
From as early as page 10 (paragraph hh), the APP discovered that CR was not forthcoming with all truth on his submission. But, even then failed to find him as a untrustworthy witness. On finding Rhode breaking the law was just fascinating, as if he acted on his own instincts. Yet, CR is the one who put Rhode to deal with breaking in at his farm. Maar, the APP exonerates CR on any conflict regarding his affidavit on reporting the farm theft to Rhode. Precca says, he is suppose to have reported the matter to prosecutorial agencies. Any review on her report will really demonstrate her shallow understanding of legal framework (Adv Zikalala). It is worrisome that, She will be appointed to be PP soon.
@phopolomorolo5657
@phopolomorolo5657 Год назад
We were always taught that a successful business doesn't need you to be physically present to operate. Just get your system right, then money start flowing through "the sofa" without your presence. 😨😨😨
@MK_Thirty
@MK_Thirty Год назад
Great analysis Dr.
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
🙌🏽
@nathanielkgobe427
@nathanielkgobe427 Год назад
Aoxam, this young girl is captured and very disgracefully the poor power hungry lady, it is crystal clear that she is not only captured for the powerful position she has been promised to occupy, but also on the side of her vulnerability, and is very disgusting. Young as she is with the education she acquired to stoop so low especially morally is a great embarrassment and disappointment to many educated young people her age in SAFRICA. Most of her age especially ladies are the most very shattered by her weakness, they asked themselves many questions expecting no answer, is it hunger, or rife unemployment in SAFRICA or perhaps she is doing what she is doing to be rich, so many questions they asked themselves, my question to her is about her parents if they are still alive, how dare do they respond seeing their daughter having stooped so low and being prepared to lie in order for her to survive? Bcs honestly speaking this is very shameful, one would even think of how far can she go protecting the wrongs that would unfold and lose her own soul, i lack better words to emphasize what I'm actually saying, Lastly to us as parents of Mzanzi please let us not desist from teaching our children good morals, even when we've taken them to school and are educated. Sometimes we sort of scared to reprimand them bcs we find them to be more educated than us as their parents. The Bible says :TEACH A CHILD THE WAY HE/SHE SHOULD GO, AND WHEN HE/SHE IS OLD HE/SHE WILL NOT DEPART FROM IT.
@Ken-dr4fz
@Ken-dr4fz Год назад
Passive income is taxed as well...... oh wait .... This is "under the counter" income ..... which isn't taxed ..... which they seem to be promoting........
@shabangu1234
@shabangu1234 Год назад
Well said, Sizwe!
@bongumusakowa5452
@bongumusakowa5452 Год назад
Keep up the good work 😊
@BhongoNgcwangu
@BhongoNgcwangu Год назад
Great job brother👌
@njabulomajola8398
@njabulomajola8398 Год назад
All clear and simplified. The acting PP really threw herself under the bus. Her report will definitely be scrapped off. Such a disgrace, full or ego and pride.
@lehlohonolowa-makhakhe8798
@lehlohonolowa-makhakhe8798 Год назад
This is excellent Sir.. 👌
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
🙏🏽
@chadalexander8722
@chadalexander8722 Год назад
Ppl united we r more pwrfl than CR/ANC.Remove them 2024 election then proper investigation when found guilty jail(accountability) - Gary here.
@mutshidzirambau4285
@mutshidzirambau4285 Год назад
I can't believe as a country we had to have argument around this😭😭
@zenzocliffordhlazo6122
@zenzocliffordhlazo6122 Год назад
You are brilliant
@MrP_4u
@MrP_4u 6 месяцев назад
Thank you for this 👌🏽🫶🏼
@mandlacele8627
@mandlacele8627 Год назад
IS THIS NOT ANOTHER KIND OF STATE CAPTURE ? THIS GIRL THINKS KUYAJOLWA LA. You cant give such important and serious matters of the country to a girl who cannot handle even her own private matters. I agree she was just pushing in her corruption CV to be considered for PP 's job. We are fedup withv ANC playing corrupt tricks with us South Africans.
@SELLOMALESA
@SELLOMALESA Год назад
Salute Salute Salute
@zakzack2222
@zakzack2222 Год назад
A very sober analysis!👏🏾
@vovobani1708
@vovobani1708 Год назад
the conflict of interest can only arise with those who own or can at least make decisions as a manager on what can be brought or leave the farm, a work can in no means direct someone to stash some money under the carpet without any instructions from the owner of that money.
@asandalamba7055
@asandalamba7055 Год назад
Con-court has not released judgement in 8 months, the review will take 2 years if not more - Tina (courts are with him)
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
That delay is really shocking.
@tommyg7418
@tommyg7418 Год назад
We need a part 2 Sizwe let's go into foreign currency hidden in couches and not cleared let's go into the President dismissing the public protector for those questions she sent him, what are those questions and why is our president using State protection for private investigations .The new public protector isn't ethical but is under command to protect Cryil Ramaphosa
@HRHSiyathokozaMweli
@HRHSiyathokozaMweli Год назад
Hi Sizwe. Thought I’d share opinion as I’m listening. For starters, there is lots of cases that come before the Constitutional Court hence the delayed response. Pertaining to Ngcobo CJ emeritus’ report, I find it interesting how Acting PP did not see it as persuasive in writing her report. Acting PP might have used the lense of what would be admissible should the matter be set before the courts.
@omword70
@omword70 Год назад
Well ConCourt has now ruled...Please do a follow up..Interesting to hear your introductory comment.
@lekgwarengsehlodimela572
@lekgwarengsehlodimela572 Год назад
Please bring Mcebo Dlamini to canvas this point
@moviemav
@moviemav Год назад
😂😂😂some humor, nyana ka Kimberly. In the midst of some serious situation. I like
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
We can only laugh at times.
@NikileCuba-xc7tg
@NikileCuba-xc7tg Год назад
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@carolinejeanallincarolj
@carolinejeanallincarolj Год назад
No surprises at all I knew it was a fiddle all along as there was no buffalo sold at all! The money was a payoff for something not legal
@user-fm9cu1sn8y
@user-fm9cu1sn8y Год назад
The question i wanted answered is, does the law allow presidents to have private financial interest and in what capacity?
@optimusctts
@optimusctts Год назад
Big shout out Kimberly & Layla
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
😂
@pagekunene2053
@pagekunene2053 Год назад
I'm afraid you are missing the point Mr analyst, you can't compare Nkandla and Phalaphala, you are basically comparing bananas and apples I first thought the same way you are thinking until Kholeka explained it, a lega guru. The problem with people is that, once a finding does not go their way that finding is wrong without looking into the merits of the case, The way l see it, those who will challenge this report will lose
@_SMWX
@_SMWX Год назад
Let’s see what the courts decide.
@zintlenjoli2981
@zintlenjoli2981 Год назад
We are taken for a ride. We are lied to blatantly, daily by these thugs. Nagana!
@thembanimgenu190
@thembanimgenu190 Год назад
Very succinct doc.
@mathieuwn.muyenga3141
@mathieuwn.muyenga3141 Год назад
GUYS ... As a sensible human being .... The poor small girl got stuck on the cross road ... money or public ... In which case she lost her game .... fame .... name in shame .... Shameful time at full time ... The game is over ... ANC leadership .... This is paid work at work ....
@ashwinmark1849
@ashwinmark1849 Год назад
to a definition, A financial interest is basically the monetary reward for a service rendered, a monetary gain for commercial dealings, or the ownership of shares with the potential for monetary profit
@raymondsepheu581
@raymondsepheu581 Год назад
Honestly speaking i have never been more offended like i am now with this girl. Corruption annoys me, but this is pure disrespect. I do not know who told this girl that she is smarter than South Africans.
@onlyeverydaysa5029
@onlyeverydaysa5029 8 месяцев назад
Lol not the shout out to the buffalo 😂
@lwaziglobal
@lwaziglobal Год назад
This is so eye opening 🔥
Далее
Документы для озокомления😂
00:24
EFF DOCUMENTARY: THE CLARION CALL
1:25:51
Просмотров 376 тыс.
Acting PP Adv Gcaleka explains Phala Phala report
33:43