Certainly better than the podcast that Muzamil Hasan, Junaid Akram and the guy from TCM did with Imran Khan who were too scared to ask tough questions and who only talked of vision and ideologies. I'm glad you guys at least addressed some practicalities.
Muzamil also did a podcast with Mifta Ismail, You might want to listen to that. Imran Khan has this aura it's really tough with him. Have you come across this big of a personality I bet not.
What makes you think I haven't watched it? Watched it when PTI was in power and Mifta wasn't even finance minister yet. Alhamdulillah have met many PTI members which is exactly why I believe IK is all vision, fudging with numbers, string social media marketing and no practicality
What an awesome host (knowledgeable, well articulated, courageous, and gives ample time to the guest) what an honest conversation and what fun to watch!!!
U called BJP a fascists and i think whole of the Pakistani are fascist because u have Blasphemy law.Its better if people see there home first rather others.
Pakistan should focus on creating more and more Madrasas and increase population. Once there are 1 billion muslims in Pakistan, they can do jihad against kafirs and do Gajwa-e-Hind. This is the shortest way to become superrich and developed as India would be a developed nation in next 20 years and including India would make Pakistan developed and super rich.
Shehzad you said domicile karachi ka hai hun me sindhi i would like to remind you karachi is a part of sindh and if you dont know the history of this city then let me tell you there are so manh sindhi village right in the middle of the city where sindhi people live since 1700s maybe more than that bhangoria goth is the example
@@JimNortonsAlcoholism tell this crap to someone who doesn’t belong here yes baloch were here as well but so were sindhis go and check older cemeteries of mango peer and even the famous yasinabad cemetery you see grave written in sindhi and they are way older than you think why its too hard to accept the reality we are not denying balochis being here you need to do proper research before conclusion go search how many goths are in karachi see who lives here since hundreds of years
@@JimNortonsAlcoholism baloch are brave people and the only one who are fighting for their land why would they gift anyone karachi the think is you just can’t separate sindhis from karachi yes you can be happy by just believing some nonsense but i am talking with facts i wont send you the articles or links i will invite you to the centre of karachi where you will find a masjid source since 1700s and it belongs to sindhi their cemetery is full of sindhis you won’t find a single grave of baloch before partition yes there are few but all are recent but you will definitely find my forefathers graves all were sindhi maybe the other side of karachi belonged to them but not in central
Miftah says that when he spoke about importing tomatoes and onions from India, India did not give a favourable response. What favourable response was he expecting? His own Prime Minister Shahbaz Sharif had already said that there would be no trade with India until article 370 was reinstated. Did you think that India should say that now that you are willing to import tomatoes in onions he will reinstate article 370. Indian never said it is unwilling to export to Pakistan but when Pakistani politicians keep saying no you cannot import from India why should India jump into this debate as though it somehow benefits India. The notion that Pakistani politicians have that somehow if they agree to trade with India they are doing India a favour and India should respond to the favour by giving some concessions on Kashmir is bizarre. You should trade if it benefits your own citizens - you are not doing India a favour by importing vegetables which reduce your own inflation. Separately he says he does not follow BJP much. Fine that is his choice. But without knowing BJP policies how can he blindly dub its government fascist? You run a great VLOG but you also make sweeping statements about Modi being a fascist. If you have a basis for your opinion, you have never shared it. Under PM Modi, there has been universaluzation of households having bank accounts, toilets, electrucity, cooking gas, health insurance, piped water. All schemes are means tested and no discrimination against anyone based on religion, language or caste. Under his government there has been huge empowerment of women and reduction in female foeticide. Miftah says PM Modi's politics is based on Muslim hatred so difficult to imrove relations with such a government. Can he explain why Nawaz waa invited to his swearing in ceremony in 2014 and he visited Lahore in 2015 to attend Maryam's daughter's wedding Why has his government resolved boundary disputes with Bangladesh? If he is as anti-Muslim as Mftah says, why did he give wheat, medicines and vaccines to Afghanistan? Why doea his government have excellent relations with Bangladesh and Maldives and Iran and Afghanistan and.GCC nations and central asian nations and Indonesia - all mualim majority nations? BJP wins some state elections and loses others. Is that fascism? There were 6 IITs until 2014. Now there are 23. Same thing with IIMs and AIIMs. Nor has he invested simply in tertiary education which benefits few. He has invested big time in skills develipment. Modi haa invested big time in public education and healrh. Also in financial inclusion, last mile delivery of service, e-governance (to reduce corruption for access to government services), in improving ease of doung business and in dramatically improving the startup ecosystem. Thousands of Indian kids from lower middle class background have become dollar millionaires through startups. Major reforms in taxation (not just in tax rates but also simplifying administratuon) has meant much greater formalization and higher tax collwction without punitive rates. Huge investments in renewable energy and reforms in policies surrounding foreign direct investments. There were 33 million retail accounts investing in Indian stock exchange in 2014 when Modi came to power which has tripled to over 100 million by improving regulations and reducing insider trading and manipulation. By contrast barely 0.25 million retail accounts exist in Pakiatani stock exchange. There have also been major real estate reforms in India making housing more affordable and reducing the speculative bubble. People investing in stock market instead of real estate makes the economy competitive. It also broadens beneficiaries of corporate profits. Please explain why not learning from India is a matter of pride for Miftah and something that you endorse?
Nah, i don't want him to do that. Because after that you have more pressure from media house and pemra. He can talk freely here without any hesitation. So keep up the content. Best of luck, Shehzad.
He said modi govt is neo fascist,😂😂😂😂😂 Jab tak ye bat na sun lu ,yakin hu nhi hota ki samne wala pakistani h 😝😝🤣🤣 Great guys (pakistani) keep it up . Proud of your knowledge about India 😂😂
@@abhaypatel4292 We never claimed to be secular states. The states which are secular on paper are killing their minorities every single day, but you are andh-bakht Modi Neo-Fascist BJP supporter, of course you are blind and can't see that.
Modi facist ?😂 Islamic republic of Pakistan wale ye baat kr rahe he jaha constitution ke hisab se ahmadia muslim nhi he minority community se koi army chief president prime minister chief minister nhi bn sakta iss hisab se Pakistan ko humanphobia he and sare Pakistani facist he sirf ek statement modi ki dikha do anti Islam and Muslim modi ka goal economic development he foreign direct investment dekho economic reforms dekho sabse jyada AIIMS medical colleges modi ne hi banaye he ha ab woh madarsa nhi bana raha iss liye wo facist he babri masjid giri iss liye sb hindu facist he lekin 350 years se bhi jyada Ram temple ke liye ladna Britishers ke time se court me ladna till2019 hindu facist he lekin sirf 20 temple he Pakistan me heaven he indian muslim india me prosucate ho rahe he lekin Pakistan me refuge nhi le rahe he itna badtar he Pakistan aur india itna facist he toh rohingya or bangladeshi muslims ko india me hi kyo aana he ? Shayad india ko bhi islamic country banana he Europe me asia ke baki country me modi Rss nhi he fir muslim islamic terrorism kyo kr rahe he ?
Miftah you legend ! Great podcast. Fills me with hope, also with a bit of rage as again a karachite is not utilized for the betterment of pak. We have so much to give, just give us a shot and a free hand
The knowledge of this man combined with his honesty with the country that led him to make decisions that were opposed to his party, really is a strong evidence of his true patriotism.
It is extremely unfortunate that even such a highly educated pakistani uses words like fascism to refer to Modi Government in India. It is beyond common sense, rationality and logic that any pakistani has the audacity to call anyone outside Pakistan fascist. Pakistanis should look inside first. Please pay attention to how various sects( Hindus, Sikhs, Ahmediyas etc.)of the pakistani society are dealt with. Having said that, I think politicians in Pakistan feel obligated to say derogatory things about India. Very sad.
relax bro pakistan is a dying nation anyways , 1/2 of the nation is under water and they are still busy barking about India chillax they are digging their own grave
You have no response other than whataboutery. Pakistani state is discriminatory by nature ,the problem as far as I am concerned is that modi is taking our nation in the same direction.
@@71espn sorry do not agree. Modi's approach is nothing more than to rectify the injustice of the past. So get your head freed of any propaganda of the leftists. The excesses of the past 1000 years in favour of certain ideology needs to be corrected. Assuming he succeeds, it would in every Indian's interest. When one side continues to praise Aurangzeb, for example, they are not willing to reconcile and live amicably. Please think harder and analyze better. Good Luck. Remember India is and continue to be a secular society till Hindus are in control. Look elsewhere where muslims are in control. Even where they are not (Sweden, UK, France) Got it?
@@71espn 😂😂 sach me kya Bengal kerla me rss bjp workers ko toh bacha nhi pa raha modi islamic extremist ne nupur incident ke baad 7 murders kiye USS pr toh kuch nhi kr paya 2014 se more than 150 Hindus ki lynching killing ki muslims ne uss pr toh kuch nhi kr paya modi
Miftah Ismail jeesy lacturar khn milaingy🙂 Hamary professor to economy KY lacture m loriyan dy rahy hoty h🙄 Etni informative or intrusting podcast h ak second bhi skip ni hopara😍
This is the first time I came across your channel and I am seriously hooked to it !! Samjh Nahi arahi kun kun se podcasts dekho !! Brilliant Stuff Man !! Keep it Up and hopefully the channel grows !
@The Pakistan Experience Pakistani is an azeem kaum, Pakistani have jazba, Pakistani have iman as Muslims have iman, ISI No 1 in world, Pak Army no 1 in world. Pakistan is made for kalma. Even Saudi Arabia is not made for kalma.Insha Pakistan will rule the world. Islam will rule the world. Allah o akbar and boommm is not fascism, killing non muslims in Pakistan is not facist, Pakistan made for Muslims is not fascism. A party whose name is Muslims league is not fascist. BJP( Bharatiya Janta Party) is a facist. Good joke by madsara chap jihadis of Pakistan. Pakistanis can have a country for Muslims, but Hindus can not have Hindustan for Hindus. Islamic terrorists are preaching on fascism.
4:40 Dear miftaf, the one who you are calling fasict has made india 5th largest economy today. Improved international image, Make in India & digital revolution, Vaccine diplomacy, Today India has 5g network, National Education Policy, National logistics policy,GST & UPI payment,The extreme poverty count fell from 22.5% in 2011 to 10.2% in 2019 under central schemes. Various revolutionary schemes like Pradhan Mantri Garib Kalyan Anna Yojana, Pradhan Mantri Kisan Samman Nidhi, Pradhan Mantri Awaas Yojana.
Well china is ahead of India in every aspect of economy does it mean XI isn't a dictator?....what type of logic is this and after Modi India's economy has actually hit because of the disaster decisions like demonetisation nd pathetic way of unplanned gst...
@Kraken Thunder problem with modi govt is their ideology.. With this mejority they could've really change india but they choose the dirty way to get votes...hate has really really increased in India after BJP govt...on prime time shows 90 ℅ of shows are on hindu Muslim...
Instead of intelectual discussion there are only hate mongering.. I agree on one side india is developing Indias are in working in all over the world in top companies but that segments is very low... Majority of the population is forced to stay in past either hate mughals Or blame Nehru.. How can new generation progress when they will only believe that all the problems are because of Muslims... And dominating Muslims is the only solution..India is diverse country and that is the strength of India but if you don't take care of it then it can bacome the biggest weakness also...
Current account deficit of financial year 2021 is 2.8 billion dollars and that of 2022 is 17.4 billion dollars, how would miftah sahab justify these numbers?
Reduce religion to a private matter, take army out of politics, reduce the elite to 10% of current size,, do peace with neighbouring countries, prioritise health, education and exports. Pakistan will become a normal country
Too good! U need huge applause to put up this wonderful podcast! I think, if Miftah is given 4-5 years with powerful backing, we can see real change here in Pakistan.. but that's not happening 😑
Ah yes, that ‘powerful backing’ of those fascist who brought the Importeds to power and crushed public opinion - poor Miftah doing his best to save us all while minting millions through corruption :)
I think it is one of the poorest podcast.. also reading all the comments from Indian fellows seems like there are lots of benefits in kinds involved before airing it
If anti Muslim policy is the reason then why only Pakistan bear all burden, why not Bangladesh, Maldives, Iran, Saudi Arabia, UAE. We have excellent relations with them and how he justified China relationship (uyighur atrocities next level ). By listening to podcast, I came to the conclusion that biggest problem of pakistan is mediocrity wrapped in elitism and disconnect from root. But love the podcast ❤️👍😎 through discussion may be one day we resolve our differences, and visit one another country.
Agree, bjp government might not be ideal but Pakistan needs to understand it’s own actions that have resulted in anti Muslim feelings within India. By this, I mean the three wars that pakistan has started and also the hundreds of small and large terror attacks that have taken place.. the final straw being 26/11. It is Pakistans responsibility to come to the table and make the first move. That’s the least pakistan can do, although my opinion is that Pakistan should apologise to India. And then we can all move on.
@@haroon420 1971 war wasnt started by Pakistan, India sensed an opportunity and intervened. AntiMuslim feelings in India predate Pakistan. Its because of those Anti-Muslim sentiments that there is a Pakistan today. RSS and Hindutva nationalism weren't created by Pakistan. It is because of those Anti-Muslims sentiment that there is a Kashmir issue. Pakistan went to war because of Indian actions in Kashmir. India too, where it suits its interest, has chosen armed intervention. For example, India basically overthrew the Nizam of Hyderabad, who unlike the Hindu ruler of Kashmir, wasnt given the privilege of choosing the fate of his state... If apologies are in order, then India too owes Pakistan, as well as the Kashmiri people an apology.
@@AAmed1980 this isn’t a pak studies exam. And yes, I said 3 wars. I intentionally left out the war of 71. I am talking about ‘48, ‘65 and ‘99. The track record of pakistan is terrible and they should acknowledge this.
@@AAmed1980 bro your pick and choose theories have too many holes, read any international scholar book on these issues istiyaq Ahmad a pakistani read his book and read pakistani judge hamoodur commission report on 1971, acquire some basic understanding.... Read multiple authors or sources analyse and then make up your mind to who did what. Critical thinking is must.
Miftah Sahab has a Kejriwal manifesto. Education, health citizenry....Pension reforms by BJP needs to be read...conventional pensions schemes as Miftah sahab talked about can ruin countries.
Best strategy, sab politicians ko bulao, yehi sawal pocho chun chun key … key bhai what was your thinking behind your decision, phir awaam can decide better to elect or not elect them next time. I think this provided clarity and would elect Mifta next time bcs you can resonate with them
Absolutely love your content. I've stayed away from Pakistani media for so long because of 'reasons' and the only content I actually enjoy is you and syed muzammil. You're a damn gem. Also, please get him back on the show soon!
Lots of first person usage. Maine, Humne, etc. While he sounds eloquent, this interview sounds more like a power brag, and dekho humne kya kya kiya hai bit.
We all know what the problems are and even what the solutions are, to make the economy healthy. But the issue is, Mifta, Shabbar, Asad Umer won't tell you the reality. As we have a state within the state politically, we have an economy with in economy in Pakistan. If you touch their economic interest, they will let you go. Who will bell the cat?
until early 90s Pakistan was ahead of India in economy or gdp, then came in Nawaz Sharif and Benazir bhutto - tab se aj tak musibaat hi musibaat ai hai hum pe.. ye baat tou bata ni rahe, chezain kis ne thek karni thi? nawaz sharif aur ppp 35 saal se govt me guusey we hen unho ne hi theek karni thi..
forget about PTI forget about PMLN, aese logon ko jama kar k jo mulk k sath sincere hn ek team bana lo mulk chalany k liye yeh akhri chance he warna phir kch ni ho payega
@@maisondusavoir3600 no listen again carefully and interpret it. And he still doesn't know what makes one fascist, we call tipu sultan freedom fighter, if we would have read meaning and history correctly we would knowodi is not hitler Or mughals.
@@rakshit8570 Modi is a Fascist. RSS is Fascist. It is a hard truth. If you're a Bhakt then you're blind to facts, and if you're not, read up on History of RSS and see what happened in 2002 Gujrat.
I would like to know the source of data of Mr. Miftah. I hav checked the stats of Pakistan's imports and exports for last year, which according to him r $80B & $31B, but it's all wrong, and its not wrong by a small value, the actual values that i can see on the net has the variance of 20% to 30%, so Sir, please also share the source. If u r an Ex-Minister, it doesn't make u an exception & dont think that every word u say will be considered holly just cz u hav a degree in economics. As far as Pakistan's never increasing exports r considered, i think the reason is very simple and these ppl who will only do a gimic of numbers will not focus on the key issue. Even a student of economics knows that the issue with Pakistan is its industrial growth which is completely stagnant for decades. There is absolutely no industrial policy that Pakistan seems to be pursuing for the last 40 years. Our industries hav stopped growing after the times of Ayub Khan or even Bhutto, Musharaf is a minor exception in the last 40 years. How Miftah sb. can expect a jump in our exports without having any industry at all? Wat u produce man!!!!??? daal, chawal, gandum, cotton!!??? Wen u ppl will come out of these old-school economic growth prospects??? it's not doing any gud to our economy. U hav no value-added industry except those which meet our local needs (partially). Which value-added products u r exporting? where u stand in IT in the next 5 to 10 years?? For how long u will rely on raw products to increase exports?? wen u will be able to find solutions for our energy needs?? Just playing with numbers will not resolve our issues. I see no intention whatsoever from any of the guys, handling our finance & related ministries, for the last 40 years. Their policies r always ad hoc, they don't even think of the coming year, its so foolish to expect a long-term agenda from them. V r left behind to an extent that it seems impossible for us to compete even with the developing world.
The guest said that Pakistan cannot talk to present (Modi) govt. because of this and that. How naive is that for a so-called intellectual person of Pakistan. It is deplorable and sad. A rational and realistic person should understand that any govt. in India would take care of India's interests first. I think India is difficult topic to deal with for Pakistani politicians, so they just use some well-known over-used rhetoric to get out of that discussion fast. Just a cope out. I think kismet hi kharab hai pakistanis (and sub-continent as a whole) ki.
پاکستان کو ڈیفالٹ سے بچانا ملک کو تباہ کرنے کے مترادف ہے۔ ڈیفالٹ کا نقصان صرف سرکاری ملازمین کو ہو گا اور یہی اصل مجرم ہیں۔ ڈیفالٹ کی صورت میں غیر ضروری اور غیر فعال ادارے بند کئے جائیں گے۔ تمام سرکاری اداروں میں ملازمین کی تعداد میں کمی کی جائے گی پینشن اور مراعات کا خاتمہ ہو گا یہ سب تو بہترین کام ہیں۔ وہ کام جو حکومتوں کے بس کی بات نہیں۔
In it's 75 Years of existance, Pakistan has excelled in the art of bagging and borrowing, some how it knew the art of surviving, but how far will it go? That's million dollar question
the day India crosses the margin of 3rd largest economy pakistan's day will be countable India is just getting ready for POK for that Economic and Military might is needed to tackle the world and right now we cannot do this We are 5th largest currently as our Economic might increases pakistan will be forced to give up POK or wait for repercussions
@@zh1148 sorry but u missed my point the goal is not exactly POK the ultimate goal is to fragment pakistan , otherwise it will can be used against us by foreign powers The whole goal is to take back POK help BLA to gain Balochistan and support Taliban to exploit the durand line
@@zh1148 for the last 75 yrs we have been hearing this BS , that a prosperous Pakistan is good for India what we got 26/11 , Pulwama, Kashmir Hindu Genocide We honestly dont have any hard feelings for a common Pakistani but your army and elite basically sells this anti India hate and that has harmed us time affer time , secondly the only way to end Kashmir obsession is disintegration of Pakistan
Don't you worry we survived in the past and will come out of it. Think about your trade deficit which is highest in South Asia. And even in these worst times our quality of life is still better than india.
I was and am still totally in support of Miftah's fiscal and monetary policy. Pakistan is at the point where the sour pill must be swallowed in order to see a better economic tomorrow. Unfortunately the associated political suicide is not palatable to ANY Pakistani politician. I don't think Ishaq Dar will do anything other than implement a politically convenient yet economically debilitating policy. Good podcast nonetheless! I'm glad he was straightforward and shrewd in his responses at the same time.
It's so surprising that very small minded people start calling PM Modi as fascist. I doubt if these people even understand what fascist means. One can differ with the policies of Mr Modi, he rated as the best PM had ever had. He had been a very successful Chief Minister( very long tenure)before being a very successful and popular PM. I rate him even better than Atal Bihari Bajpayee, Narsingha Rao, who knew 11 different languages, Indira Gandhi who broke up Pakistan and Pt Nehru. I will rate him the best and most popular. Pakistanis are so pretty minded as to tag PM of largest and successful democracy a fascist, a country 20 lakes of its own people, a country who has gone IMF 10 odd times, who's almost all PM and president died unnatural deaths who drove out ot killed/converted 99% of its minorities. The list is endless. I also know it is useless to tell these small minded people the truth.
One thing I like about your podcast is that you didn't throw just googly and Yorkers like those TCM and junaid akram etc did with imran khan unlike you literally asked miftah ismail some tough and straight forward questions.
They may have saved Pakistan from the default but honestly they made this situation of uncertainty by removing IK. This whole scenario was deliberately imposed by them in the name of betterment of financial condition but they made the stable financial condition worse than ever.
The best guest one could've had in current circumstances. I'm your follower since the start and it's very refreshing to see you finally getting the recognition you always deserved. This podcast was a great one, you asked many confrontational yet justified questions, always a treat to watch it. Homeopathic conversations don't cut it no more. Keep doing the great work bro.
@Babar Ali course we can but China and Taiwan have products to offer to the world that's a must have for them? What can Pakistan offer to the world that they must trade with you? And there is your answer unfortunately, we got no leverage here... 😏
@@azmatseharEven better is India and China. We are in passive standoff at border for a long time with some duration of active engagement. Still we do trade with each other. I do not know why Pakistan is so much stubborn for refusing trade with India.
Bilkul sahi kaha ha. Government job is not to run businesses, its inly duty is to create laws, ecosystem level playing field, provide security and justice
The only issue is that he uses the word fascist for an elected Prime Minister, and, I think that the Pakistanis were under the impression that only they had the monopoly on being difficult to deal with, I think they need a reality check with the thought you can fool some people some times not all people all......
@@babkamath true. Their subsequent governments have been more or less fascist in nature. Shehzad has himself made on video on how previous imran khan govt satisfies the criteria of a fascist govt
I am Indian watching Pakistani media closely, very intelligent conversation, I think Pakistani politicians army don’t want to take country’s responsibility, Miftah Ismael is a intelligent guy, in ppp hina rabani khar.Both are die hart party workers Party uses Miftah Ismael as a pawn, even though he still satisfy.
Thank you for the excellent and informative interview. Miftah Sahib is indeed a rarity among politicians who calls the spade a spade and does not try to pull the wool over the eyes of people. Well said and well done. We wish you all that is best.
Even sane personalities like Miftah Ismail, in Pakistan keep labeling Indian establishment as 'Facist' every chance they get and then are surprised when their tweets don't get responses from Indian officials. I don't understand this thinking.
1:21:38 real estate is the only safe place for middle-class Pakistanis to store their wealth. More taxes s not the answer. The government needs to encourage people to invest in bussiness.
Youthia or Patwari, being both is bad, I guess patwari could be more gruesome😁. I've seen your entire interview with Mr. Atif Mian and Miftah sb, as a matter of fact Atif sb being a seasoned economist remained neutral and criticised both for their wrong doings which was fair enough. You just simply can't blame PTI, when these political parties have ruled decades more than PTI. Funniest thing is to see their joint venture (Grandyyy Alliance) against a single political party which is literally squandering all 14 of them ALONE 😁🤣 I Love your enthusiasm but I also do understand economics and what is being tried to imply over here, making a sweeping statement about right or wrong side, calling names wouldn't work, you can't rule out or undermine the single most economic indicator CA and thats what Atif Mian kept on emphasising, education >> efficient Labor >>mass production>> exports with minimal imports thats the most important aspect and thats the only way you could strengthen rupee. Miftah himself criticised daronomics with his dollar fiasco before 2018, REER was skyrocketing whereas the market value was kept at 100 criminally, a massive blow to Pakistan more than the cheaper fuel prices Imran was selling for over a month what noon keep on whining all the time and which is also true.
Bhai Baat into si hai k Miftah Sahab knew his limits as a foreign minister yeh political gain k liye economic stunts nahi kiye ab Ishaaq Dar ay hain woh kaam karny k liye kisi Party ko parwa nahi hai genuinely like Miftah said State of Pakistan is not working for people of Pakistan but only for that 1%. 🎉
I am an Indian, and I can tell you one thing which actually surprises me is the low tax rate and I am not saying coverage it's the rate. Highest bracket is too low municipal taxes are almost none on top of it there are no special economic zones that can boost exports. But I really appreciate the honesty of former minister and host did a great job to keep the discussion light thoroughly enjoyed it.
مفتاح اسماعیل♥️ کی جرآت ایمانی اور حب الوطنی 🇵🇰کو سلام پیش کرتے ہیں۔۔۔بہت محنت کی اور پاکستان کو ڈیفالٹ ہونے سے اللہ تعالٰی کے فضل و کرم سے بچانے میں بھرپور کوشش کی اور کامیابیاں عطاء فرمائی اللہ تعالٰی نے ۔۔ الحمداللہ 🕋🤲
Imagine listening to a 2 times finance minister and he says: "Sab tax de rahy hain😂", "banks tax de rahy hain😂", companies tax de rahi hain😂 BHAIII, MAI BATATA HU KON TAX NAI DE RAHA, 1) 40% employed workforce is in agriculture, wo tax nai de rahy 2) All of the agricultural production pe tax nai hai (jo zameendar kama rahy hain, wo tax nai de rahy) 3) Property investors tax nai de rahy, property brokers nai de rahy, real estate mai koi b nai de raha 4) Retailers nai de rahy Miftah sahab, apse sawal ye tha k tax net Q nai barh raha? Already tax dene walo pe Q tax laga rahy? Banks tax dete hain, companies tax deti hain, inki tax percentages barhanay se kuch nai hoga.
Just finished listening to all of it, my perception of the major issues of Pakistan has been significantly altered. It was so refreshing hearing about an actual plan on tackling the balance of payment deficit from a former finance minister, not to mention his emphasis on bettering education and health in Pakistan. Despite all the backlash he faced from others and within the party, he stood by what he deemed correct, and that did ultimately prevent Pakistan from defaulting. 👏👏 I've also always been on edge as to whether I should declare Pakistan a hopeless state or attempt to reform the system by working within it with whatever capacity I can; Miftah sahab's entire talk made me consider the latter. Absolutely enlightening 1 hr 40 mins, where I was hooked on every word of this discussion. Shehzad thank you for moderating it so well, especially giving Miftah sahab space to derail the convo for a bit so that he could say what he wanted. Excellent content as always, keep going dude, can't wait to see this sort of gem reach more and more people ♥♥
