I know this is a very casual, not serious video, but this is also the perfect example of how to take feedback from fans. Listen to valid criticisms, but then be able to pick and choose which you actually agree with while still acknowledging the reasoning behind those you disagree with. And then actually doing something based on the feedback. Besides that, excellent video dude!
Grian killed Solidarity because he kept punching him and pressing his buttons. Grian eventually had enough of it, and killed Solidarity in return. Mumbo shot at Grian to avenge Solidarity, but Grian was already annoyed enough to kill. That led to him also killing Mumbo in the same minute.
It doesn't feel right to have Scott ranked as meaner than Grian. Especially considering that once Grian turned red, he was basically glued to Joel and participating eagerly with all the carnage. As well as Scott being the most loyal one of the series, even sacrificing his own chance of getting a boogie kill and staying on yellow. Not once did he betray his alliance. Grian on the other hand almost instantly tried to get Mumbo killed once he turned red, no hesitation.
Great argument! I’m convinced. Honestly tho, I did give Scott a couple of joke points like how he just said “bye” and stuff. And he’s only a few points ahead of Grian. I don’t regret any points I gave Scott, but I agree with you.
@@JayADonut i think part of it is the fact that since scott placed ahead of grian, so he got a lot more final kills than him, if grian had survived longer he definitely would’ve been the meanest
Joel absolutely needs to see this one too. I'm sure he'll also get a laugh when he learns he's still the meanest. P.S. So excited to see another video from you!
Didn’t see this till now, but to be fair, I never watched her perspective, so I really could’ve gotten stuff wrong. Same can be said for quite a few others
Grian and Joel should have had 2 extra points for killing ren when he was picking apples lol (also forgot to give points for that kill in the other video)
The Good: Impulse - Chaotic Good Skizz - Neutral good Tango - Decent guy, just a bit unhinged Etho - He's Etho The Grey: Jimmy - Your average idiot Bigb - Likable Chaotic Neutral Martyn - Unlikable True Neutral Mumbo - Just your average petty person Cleo - Barely missing bad, we got cleo. She's just a jerk. Bad: Lizzie - Traitor Ren - A jerk Scar - Just missing out on evil, it's Scar. The lovable, yet chaotic immoral bastard that we see trying to steal stuff. He died too early to be evil tho... Love you Scar! Evil: Pearl - She's pure evil, except for her and Scott's relationship Bdubs - Bastard Grian - Chaotic evil cod boi. Scott - Traitorous bastard Joel - Ruthless Killer
Ahh I was very happy to see your comment saying that this video is out! Great work, definitely think this accounted for each member's meanness a lot better than the first one :] Not surprised by the top 3 whatsoever though, bahaha
5:52 well they discussed that one right after it happened - Joel attacked both of them and they hadn't specified that defense must stop once the Boogeyman is cured. If he had attacked only Scott it would be different. (I disagree with what they agreed on - but it's their series and they didn't prepare for that possibility) Also my previous comment got deleted (I moved accounts), TLDR it said if accident kills don't count (due to not being mean) then you wrote yourself into a corner with self-kills there lol This is a fun video to return to and watch again
I feel like a lot of people greatly exaggerate how bad releasing a wither is. Yeah, it’s pretty powerful, but with just how many super skilled Minecrafters were playing, it really didn’t stand a chance from the get go. I agree it’s worthy of something, but I don’t think it’s the big power move people say it it.
Late comment, but I don't think Scott made Martyn panic. I'm pretty sure the events went like this, judging by the footage. Martyn was trying to deceive Scott by walking into the hole, so he could lure him into being blown up by his end crystal. Here's why I'm pretty sure it was deception: 1. He got the obsidian out before entering the hole 2. He could've easily escaped the hole The problem here was actually the zombies getting in the way, preventing him from placing the crystal in time. I also believe Etho should receive an extra point for not giving a life to Bdubs, because in episode 1, Etho owed Bdubs a "half life" since Bdubs decided not to kill Etho, and instead chose Grian.
good video, honestly I see nothing wrong with the point system. also I know you took a long time on this and taking away points would add more time so I don't wanna be pain, and honestly I don't really have a problem with anything.
I really think you didn't have a valid point for keeping the self-kills. Especially skizzes. He wasn't being mean to himself, or other people, he was just tryna run away and accidentally died. Jesus Christ, man.
This video is great but there are 2 changes I would make. Grain was a menance with Joel so I think he is a bit meaner, and I feel like people buying hits on others should count as being mean.
@@icemouse9 This whole video is just a joke. Don’t take it so seriously. I gave him a point for that because I thought it was funny and no other reason. :)
Bruh a lot is kinda stupid like Scott getting 3 points for I don’t even know and not taking away Skizz point and although I would count self kills to they aren’t really self kills they are accidents so they technically aren’t trying to kill themselves. Like murders they are trying to kill them they want them dead while people like Joel he didn’t mean to fall down he wasn’t trying to be mean to himself. There’s more annoying stuff to
I’m hopefully not giving offense, but you skipped 15th, 14th, 13th, 12th, 11th, 8th, 7th, and 5th place. I know, you won’t change it. But I just wanna put that out there 😉
This one’s kinda tricky, but I stand by what I said in the video. Joel was already cured after killing Scott, so Pearl had no real reason to kill Joel anymore. Yeah, it was completely in the rules and in Pearl’s rights to kill him, but it was definitely still unnecessary violence for violence sake, so I think she’d deserved it. You made a good point tho.
