No video :(

Why Are Goblins Not Permitted To Carry Wands?

Подписаться 543 тыс.

Просмотров 389 тыс.

50% 1

Please watch: "The Life Of Marius de Romanus (Vampire Chronicles)"
• Video -~-
It’s no secret that Goblins and Wizards haven’t always seen eye to eye over years..or over the centuries really. Like Elves, Goblins have been relegated to second class citizens in comparison to their wizarding counter parts due to the possible threat they carry if allowed more freedom with magic. Despite the Ministry Of Magic having a tight grip on them, Goblins still are in no way permitted to use, own or carry a wand under penalty of a life sentence in Azkaban prison. The question is..Why? Why can’t a Goblin own a wand? Just how powerful could they be if they did? What’s this underlying tension the Goblin race feels against wizards? Don’t worry guys I’m going to answer all of those questions in todays video, so with that being said, stick around, grab a butter beer and let’s talk about why Goblins are not permitted to carry wands.
Lend your Patreon Support goo.gl/ZoHfRf
Follow me on Instagram goo.gl/jBAkX2
Merchandise Store TSHIRTS teespring.com/...
Subscribe to the channel goo.gl/anpK3E
Follow me on Instagram goo.gl/jBAkX2
Like Us On Facebook goo.gl/64LmGP
Follow Me On Twitter goo.gl/BjgbBi
Shop Amazon for everything Harry Potter: goo.gl/JAjC2g

Опубликовано:

15 дек 2019

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 1 тыс.

@robbielittlefield5317 4 года назад

Not to mention flitwick drastically got younger after the first film, scary magic the wizards couldn't seem to do

@YellowBear-kx1ff 4 года назад

Robbie Littlefield I think you mean after the 2nd film, he started being younger in the 3rd film. Despite that, in the 3rd video game, Flitwick still appeared as a mini Dumbledore.

@robbielittlefield5317 4 года назад

@@YellowBear-kx1ff shit yeah that's right, but he didn't have a main role in the second movie though right? Probably why I didn't notice

@holeinthehat 4 года назад

He's not a Goblin.

@YellowBear-kx1ff 4 года назад

Robert Bocking No, but he’s PART-goblin.

@brokenquill9277 4 года назад

Robert Bocking he’s like a quarter goblin. Which leads me to a question. How much human/wizard do you need to be to allowed a wand. Hagrid is half, a Flitwick and Fleur are three quarters. But what if you’re three quarters goblin, or Veela, are you human enough to use a wand?

@kektuss 4 года назад

[Sword literally has griffindor’s name on it] Goblins: “hE sTOle iT”

@luxaly9510 4 года назад

well in goblin beliefs a item they made is always owned by a goblin and the purchase is only a lifetime rental... so he basically didnt own it anymore when he died^^ in fact the goblins should not have used the term of purchase but lifetime rental then they would legally own the stuff they made even in human/wizard laws

@passingliaison 4 года назад

That's complete BS though. At least according to the video. Here's what the video tells us: 1. Gryffindor commissioned the sword to be made in the first place 2. The Goblins attacked Gryffindor while he was still alive 3. The Goblin King lied to his on people, claiming Gryffindor stole it(He didn't) The whole, "it belongs to the Goblin who made it" BS stims from a lie told to try and steal the sword from Gryffindor before he died. It also makes no sense when you take into account Gringotts, how it works, and how Goblins run it. Sending out "curse Breakers" like Bill Weasley to steal the treasures and fortunes of foreign wizards. Treasures their own views on ownership says they have no right to. They may see themselves as guardians of treasure, but not all treasures in Gringotts are Goblin made. I'd also be interested to know if this "the one who makes it owns it" bull applies within Goblin society itself, because I highly doubt it. Personally, I think the whole Goblin ownership situation stems from the idea that Goblins have that Wizards can't be trusted with treasures.

@xxx_jim_the_reaper_xxx 4 года назад

@@passingliaison In that point of view, Goblins aren't wrong though. They cannot trust us with treasures because they know that it will always be lost or worse, cannot be returned if the owner was killed or died. And even the fine collector of treasures will always lose their stash upon their deaths and they may or may not leave some clues as to where they've hidden the treasure, the Goblins may never know.

@xXSCDTXx 4 года назад

XxxJim_ the_ ReaperxxX doesn’t matter, if you make something for someone and they buy it then you don’t have a say anymore. Goblins are wrong.

@MycoCane 4 года назад

@@xXSCDTXx I think it's a problem of semantics. Everything that we call buying, goblins would call renting.

@waynesmith3908 4 года назад

Godrick Gryffindor rightfully placed a very special enchantment on his sword. I love that the sword can not be stolen and that it can come and go as needed

@christabelchan9757 4 года назад

Only when u have the sorting hat and you're a Gryffindor

@RosePierce. 3 года назад

@@christabelchan9757 I’m a slytherin SEE THE PROBLEM

@magicchannel2478 3 года назад

Godric*

@kenshingleton4176 4 года назад

As was pointed out in the Deathly Hallows, Goblins want us to share wand lore with them, but refuse to share their metal lore with us. So they want us to teach them how to make and use wands, but don't want to return in kind by teaching us how to work with metals and imbibing them with magic. A bit hypocritical aren't they.

@johnrandolph1989 4 года назад

Take a penny, leave a penny. Give a cookie, get a cookie. Teach metal works to a wizard, teach wand building to a goblin, and then kill indiscriminately all goblins.

@pharaohkai1 4 года назад

Ken Plenge agreed

@PhenomResurrections08 4 года назад

You're not a wizard you weirdo

@dustin628 4 года назад

Yeah and you can't trust the Goblins, they could pretend to teach us metal lore when really it's just a bunch of nonsense while taking all the wand lore we teach them.

@kenshingleton4176 4 года назад

@@PhenomResurrections08 why are you on this site and commenting. This is for people who enjoy Harry Potter. If you don't like it don't watch and don't leave rude comments.

@fairlind 4 года назад

“There are no half-blood goblins”. Didn’t you just talk about Flintwick having goblin blood?

@ShivangiPrasad 4 года назад

Interesting. Maybe the Goblins dont consider him a 'true' Goblin because of being part human. He's a part wizard, part Goblin. I did check Harry Potter wiki, and you're right- he's half Goblin.

@fairlind 4 года назад

Shivee It was folklore who was right about him being half-human. And you may be right about his other statement being a matter of attitude.

@MountainFisher 4 года назад

No where in the books does it say Flitwick was part goblin that I know of If Rowling said so later then that's just nonsense. She wrote the books and then wants to be the center of attention afterwards?? She should have made the Magical Creatures movies more consistent or The Lost Child not a piece of crap.

@kargs5krun 4 года назад

@@MountainFisher tbh....there's one book/film i dont (most dont?) wanna read/see....re: the origins of half breed goblins with humans, be they wizards or muggles. Would be "gross"....dont you think? 😣 🤮

@TomasLonGo 4 года назад

what he meant was that there were no goblins that "mated" with non magical creatures, in comparison to wizards fucking muggles for example

@beatrixthegreat1138 4 года назад

Probably because wands are the only advantage humans have and goblins kicked a lot of butt in that uprising.

@s0lar.ecl1pse83 4 года назад

Nah i would test it by catching a goblin and then lock it in a room then give it a wand

@AnthonyWLeone 4 года назад

Yeah, I agree. I don't like the idea of goblins having that much power considering their vicious history and nature.

@arnowisp6244 4 года назад

@@AnthonyWLeone Even without wands they are already trouble. Giving them wands is like giving some tyranical african warlord tomahawk missles.

@nhiamoua5816 4 года назад

there's also the speculation that the wizards lost a war against the muggles and thus why their entire society is hidden and also why it's called "the ministry of magic" as if it's a branch ruled by a larger organization. point is, wizardry must not be as powerful as we might think them to be.

@AnthonyWLeone 4 года назад

@@nhiamoua5816 That is a good point. It might have also been considered that if goblins did get their little hands on wands, they would not care if they operated out in the open, causing further problems for the wizarding community trying to be hidden from muggles.

@VulKus117 4 года назад

I mean... theres a lot of racism in the Wizarding World Edit: I mean speciesism, not racism between human ethnicity

@thorzyan 4 года назад

VulKus hermione turned over umbridge to a pack of wild centaurs, knowing that according to mythology she would be brutally gang-banged. Then later on, Ron makes clip-clopping sounds near her at st mungos hospital for the insane and she screams in horror. Hermione is gangster.

@anthonybousquet3590 4 года назад

thorzyan I mean, Hermione didn’t know that a giant three-headed dog was called a Cerberus and that Cerberus was a guardian for Hades (guard dogs, anyone?), so I doubt she knew about that quite dark and not so well-known fact about Greek mythology.

@Js23187 4 года назад

thorzyan wait they were going to do what 😮

@moonwrath1067 4 года назад

I’d say that there’s 100% a Hierarchy going on there

@anthonybousquet3590 4 года назад

Genghis Chuan Yeah, Rowling did, that’s why she clearly specified how unarmed Umbridge had been when Dumbledore brought her back. Rowling’s centaurs aren’t mass rapers, that’s a myth, as in MYTHology.

@MovieFlame 4 года назад

Amazing as always Dean! Always such high quality content!

@HarryPotterFolklore 4 года назад

You’re goblet video essay was the best thing I’ve watched, stuck in traffic and listened to the whole thing, Mike really was so uninterested as a director

@theberrysquad8779 4 года назад

Both of yr harry potter videos are so good!!! You should do a video together!!

@failedhook7140 4 года назад

Still waiting on that crossover between your 2 channels

@mandyrobbins1041 4 года назад

@@theberrysquad8779 Agreed! I would LOVE to see a collab between them! A two part collab, with one half on either of their channels! :D It would be EPIC!

@rachelmilligan95 4 года назад

Love content creators praising each other 🥰

@evanloudon2970 4 года назад

You should do a history of House Elves

@a.t.8013 4 года назад

Evan Loudon YEEESSSS

@joshbostian640 4 года назад

There is no origin story.

@joshbostian640 4 года назад

I believe the most popular theory is they were successfully bred like that

@kimvara7152 4 года назад

Yes

@kimvara7152 4 года назад

Evan Loudon yes

@Castor586 4 года назад

I'm honestly surprised that goblins didn't simply figure out how to make wands or some equivalent over the course of centuries

@thesunnyleo Год назад

@@alphashaitan65 wtf is wrong with you?

@alphashaitan65 Год назад

@@thesunnyleo I'm awake their destructive backstabbing treachery.

@weylandyutani9622 4 года назад

War between goblins and wizards and elves would make a good HP sequel

@xxx_jim_the_reaper_xxx 4 года назад

No, its just another Lord of the Rings.

@prernadumka7701 4 года назад

Can we take a moment to appreciate- how this guy has always got amazingly interesting, creative and bewitching ideas for the video. Love them all.

@Axhole11 4 года назад

I think you missed the mark with this video. The goblins are greedy. It's in their nature. They want information while refusing to share their own. That is the core of it with the goblins. The house elf's are a different topic, their magic is tied to servitude. But this video isn't about them

@kaylintegen275 4 года назад

House elves and goblins are depicted (at least in the movie, i know, i know not 100%cannon)as being quite similar in size, nose/ears. Both capable of magic that is equal/ stronger/ different than human. How about a video about them. More info, details and how life spans, breeding, works with them and any other info comparing/ contrasting them.

@tokutickler 4 года назад

Wizard: No full auto in the building! Goblin: That's not full auto. Wizard: That's not full auto?? Goblin: This is. *Blows up building* And that's why goblins are not allowed to use wands.

@Dankargonaut 4 года назад

TokuTickler lol a good classic

@coribakescakes4279 4 года назад

😂

@thecinere4323 4 года назад

Ah a person of culturr

@thewhitelbj4843 4 года назад

TokuTickler I literally just watched that then clicked on this on RU-vid

@dieguitoskullito 4 года назад

I see you are all men of culture as well..

@elisepinter2099 4 года назад

My favorite part of these videos are consistently “and most importantly, be happy.” Love that vibe.

@dustin628 4 года назад

Ooh will you do a vid on Flitwick then?! His life sounds really really interesting!

@grig8310 4 года назад

Why can’t goblins just make all their creations cheaper and stress the point that they are renting it not buying it.

@AmPhilH3O 4 года назад

That would be better for relations. People need to understand those expectations. I think they dont tell people because they see it as so obvious. Just like we see it as obvious that if we purchase an item, we can then gift or bequeath it as we please (and stores dont need to clarify that) they see it as equally obvious.

@hathawyn 4 года назад

Mythologically speaking, because goblins are traditionally greedy and don't play fair.

@Jenacide 4 года назад

Perhaps that’s what they do in modern times, lol. The sword was a very old very well made item that caused the war in the first place I can see why they would still be after it and still consider it theirs. But we really don’t get to see in the movies or books that I recall any dealings with the goblins over purchasing anything in modern times. Perhaps they make them sign contracts now XD

@Beregorn88 4 года назад

Replace "goblins" with "EA" and "goblin creations" with "videogames" to better understand what the problem is Sword as a service...

@PhilBagels 4 года назад

Yeah, the whole idea makes no sense (like many things in the HP world). If a certain amount of money is sufficient for a lifetime rental, then why can't they set a price for permanent ownership? If the goblin wants the item back, do they give the money back? No! It's not a sufficient justification to say, "That's just the goblins' way." Why should I give you back something I paid money for, if you're not going to give me the money back? And what happens if the goblin who made the item dies? Does he get to pass the ownership on to his next of kin? That's rather hypocritical. And unfair by any standard. Do goblins give back everything they ever purchase from non-goblins?

@beatrixthegreat1138 4 года назад

If goblins give up ownership of things they created but sold then I can see a concession of saying “yeah you can buy a wand bro” Look at it like a cultural exchange. Goblin belief vrs human belief. Flitwick is proof we can set aside our differences and do something amazing.

@TheBacknblack92 4 года назад

One individual isnt proof of anything. Look at the two rebellions and the goblin king lying, which every goblin believed. Those things are better proof than some half breed being okay. No reason to create a potential threat if you do not have to. It would be stupid of the government to allow a threat like that to grow in power. Governments that allow people who dont share a culture and value to grow stronger are not governments for very long, and the people with those values will suffer under the new regime This video is also biased in the goblins favor. Theyre lying, and stealing cheaters who also will not share their knowledge of metal working. So fuck em.

@beatrixthegreat1138 4 года назад

Stopreadingmyusername what about all the Voldemort’s over the centuries? You can’t trust humans either.

@TheNuyorker 4 года назад

beatrix the great the evil wizards are one in each lifetime but goblins are all the same. Griphook saw that Harry wasn’t a bad wizard and still did him dirty. Even let his own boss burn. He did it for his own desires

@ChristmasCarolyn 4 года назад

I guess u can say that goblin and human cultures are like oil and water. They cannot, and will never, be able to mix. Not one to disregard a different set of beliefs, but you can see that goblins work in a more self serving manner. It's like dealing with a cutthroat businessman. They're dangerous to make any kind of deals with because they will ensure that they will not come out on the bad side of the deal. Maybe there might be goblins who are more cooperative and behave differently from the rest (like Flitwick), but they're rare. While not all humans are helpful, it is generally accepted that it is beneficial to be cooperative.

@numberonerookieninja 4 года назад

"Those who gain power, are afraid to lose it" okay Emperor Palpatine XD

@Xehanort10 4 года назад

Palpatine had "UNLIMITED POWERRRRRRRRRR" though.

@chrismiksworld 4 года назад

I think to Solve that issue somewhat There should be a Wand License that Everyone needs to get in order to have a Wand and if you Break any of the Wand or Spell Laws you will either have your License suspended or Revoked completely Then if you are caught Wanding without a license there would be a consequence. And I think Certain Spells should be illegal under the influence of drugs or alcohol So if you are caught Wanding under the Influence You would be hit with a W.U.I. Ticket

@fitrianhidayat 4 года назад

There will be rage against it. 4th amendment or some shit

@MountainFisher 4 года назад

@@fitrianhidayat Run! Run! Drunken wizard flying down the road! Run!!!!

@curtyct5389 4 года назад

To be honest the goblins always seemed like a stand-in for Jews and the stereotypes & prejudices held against them

@Seanonyoutube 4 года назад

curtyct {ct yep. It’s hard not to see the similarities.

@christinacody5845 4 года назад

That was my thought, too.

@oxfordeducatedhighschoolhe6989 4 года назад

Jews are the exact inspiration for the Goblins. The "stereotypes" as you call them are factually accurate.

@rachelmilligan95 4 года назад

It’s crazy, because Voldemort was kinda based on hitler... the guy had Jewish in him and tried to kill them off... Voldemort hates mixed blood yet he is himself.

@oxfordeducatedhighschoolhe6989 4 года назад

Hitler was opposed to Marxists. Jewish is a religion not a race, its important people understand this.

@kaitoshmaito 4 года назад

I was just watching another one of your videos when i got this notification lol. Just subscribed today too!!

@tner5538 4 года назад

Frick you

@kaitoshmaito 4 года назад

Tner i- I’m sorry I’m not sure what I did to upset you but I hope you have a nice day

@moonwrath1067 4 года назад

Just thinking about this when I got the notification. Now that’s the Magic if Harry Potter Folklore

@collinp7824 4 года назад

Can’t believe the professer was a master juuler... juules at hogwarts are not permitted

@birdiec 4 года назад

Yeah remember in HBP when draco broke harrys juul and harry almost killed him?

@zachmesser7627 4 года назад

You joke about grabbing a butterbeer but i work at universal in the diagon alley section most of the time

@nerdofalltrades1738 4 года назад

Lucky! Mix some fire whiskey in with it and it's awesome! At least that's what I did when I went to universal

@melaniekelso6609 4 года назад

My dream side job!

@Jenacide 4 года назад

Nerd of all trades Probably not the best plan while on the job though, lol

@nerdofalltrades1738 4 года назад

@@Jenacide eh... depends on how badly you need the job lol

@royalpain9281 3 года назад

Can you reveal the recipe here?

@goldensperm4435 4 года назад

Goblin and elf are extremely powerful even without a wand. See Dobby

@stephaniep5458 4 года назад

Wow I can't believe I didn't know that about Professors Flitwick! Thank you for your videos Dean always learning something new!

@michelhammack5889 4 года назад

I'm not sure what the power of goblins is, but if it is closer to the house elf they don't need one, look at how effortless Dobby's attack on Lucius Malfoy was, or how he saved not one but five people by teleporting them all away from the deatheater.

@earendurvoneinzbern7585 4 года назад

Goblin Slayer: Did someone say goblins?

@user-sk8dr6zt2q 4 года назад

Go.away

@Mr-Ad-196 4 года назад

Wuh........

@tmarrow 4 года назад

Could you do a vid about the first war Like so he can see and do it

@SeanSinclair821 4 года назад

Flitwick is only supposed to be about 1/16 or 1/32 goblin, which would mean he only has one great-great-(great-)grandparent who was a goblin. I don't think you can judge much about what a goblin with a wand would be like based on him, since the great majority of his ancestry is human wizards.

@jonwoodhouse1444 4 года назад

If Goblins had wands, they'd be the ones calling the shots.

@ingapinga8079 4 года назад

Fltwick’s hair turned from gray to brown as he aged (in the movie)... so his melanin just turned back to life, haha!

@holeinthehat 4 года назад

Not a Goblin

@dylanrich69 4 года назад

@@holeinthehat He is PART goblin which technically makes him a goblin

@holeinthehat 4 года назад

@@dylanrich69 there is no verifiable cannon to prove this.

@holeinthehat 4 года назад

@@dylanrich69 If this was true why would Volemort have allowed him to continue teaching at Hogwarts during the regime when all other half blood or part blood wizards and muggle borns were fleeing.

@ingapinga8079 4 года назад

Why is it important if he’s part-goblin/human? His hair is still turning from gray to brown - That’s odd.

@SuperCrabCraft 4 года назад

Yeah je stole my sword, that with his name on it.

@davidcov90 4 года назад

Great video, and great question, but I could argue the point for both sides, because both do have valid points.

@timonandpumba6981 4 года назад

The thing about house elves is that they like their enslavement When Hermione did S.P.E.W none of the house elves took the clothing and refused to clean grifyndor common room.(except Dobby)

@tompadfoot3065 4 года назад

and most likely that attitude was magically beaten into their species over hundreds of years, because elves are absurdly powerful magic users in their own right. Which terrifies the wizarding community.

@JorgePicco 4 года назад

I would like the theme of the "self fulfulling prophesy" analized from the example of the Dark Lord /Harry Potter.

@saeidk736 4 года назад

“The wand chooses the wizard Harry” Maybe cause no wand ever chooses a goblin or other creature

@fairlind 4 года назад

Or maybe no wand gets an opportunity to choose a wizard

@jkxss 4 года назад

@@fairlind reread your comment, it doesn't make any sense.

@fairlind 4 года назад

Jason Lee Doesn’t it to you? Jake says no wand chooses a goblin. I say maybe it would if a goblin had an opportunity to handle one. What am I missing?

@anthonybousquet3590 4 года назад

fairlind I think you mistook the term goblin for wizard. Reread your comment.

@fairlind 4 года назад

Sapphire Diadem I sure did. :)

@pablorodriguez2325 4 года назад

You should make a video about the events of the Hogwartz school year of 97-98 and the reformation of Dumbledores army. Apologies if you have already, just obsessed over your content and channel

@stoiphenbaker88 4 года назад

If they can't have wands, wizards shouldn't have goblin made items!

@codename495 4 года назад

Stoiphen Baker Goblins freely sell their creations, as well as expecting additional payment after a transaction which is insane. Goblin made armor and metallurgy is a fantastic wealth of knowledge that they are unwilling to share, so why should humans share wand lore?

@stoiphenbaker88 4 года назад

@@codename495 not the point, when something has gone on for so long, some decisions need to be made

@Jenacide 4 года назад

Stoiphen Baker That’s utterly nonsensical

@stoiphenbaker88 4 года назад

It's about keeping the peace with other races and being fair to them

@Jenacide 4 года назад

@@stoiphenbaker88 They seem to be keeping the peace just fine as they are now. It's your "being fair" that will disrupt the peace and potentially cause another war.

@Crashbmaster0 4 года назад

As a great man once said, The only good goblins are ones that never come out of their stinking holes.

@DarthJarJar23 4 года назад

Nice Goblin Slayer

@eliasroos7185 4 года назад

I wish I was innocent like you, but I’m not. I’m full of rage, and beans, SPIRIT, PRIDE, AND HEART, AND SOUL, AND RAGE, AND BEANS! SPICY BEANS! The only good goblin’s a dead goblin! NOW LET’S MAKE THESE GOBLINS GOOOOD!"

@Nnnmmmkkk 3 года назад

Racist...

@healinggrounds19 4 года назад

The Goblins of Harry Potter world remind me quite a bit of the Ferengi of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. Their obsession with money, unwillingness to share information, seen as untrustworthy allies. I wonder if J.K.R watched Star Trek at any point and subliminally picked up on this.

@lianrodriguez1408 4 года назад

wands were made by the wizards for the wizards, wizards dont want to share their secrets the same way goblins wont share theirs secrets of working with iron, this was mention on book 7

@bon.mp4 4 года назад

"There's no half blood goblin" * cough * Flitwick is half goblin * cough *

@remuslazar2033 4 года назад

I watched the whole video with a wand in my hand

@oppacheco9389 4 года назад

I LOVE these videos! It's awesome to see the culture that is embedded in the stories. I really feel that HP has so many correlations to real life scenarios and culture that it just makes me appreciate the the story more!

@jnew42 4 года назад

I will answer with, if you show me yours... They have powerful wandless magic and may not be able to teach that but they could share their metal working. I do agree it is partially about power but the goblins have also on occasion shown themselves to be rather despicable, hence I would argue they do not deserve wands as they would just cause further problems, after numerous rebellions and who knows how much back stabbing and what not I would say they are lucky to just be a species and not a lesson of a dead civilization that crossed blades with the wizarding world one to many times.

@joshbostian640 4 года назад

You know what. If the goblins refuse to teach us the secrets of how they work metal simply because we are not goblins, why should we give them an advantage over us?

@RJV-s3l 4 года назад

This reminds me that someone was making a HP game set during the goblin wars and it would’ve been super interesting to witness those events unfold. Alas the footage is hard to find but it would be so cool if that was real

@xPantsMcGeex 4 года назад

SO what we are saying is, EA games and Activivision are run by goblins.

@litchtheshinigami8936 4 года назад

Evan Riddell either that or EA and activision are being run by Ferenghi..

@shellyballard8316 4 года назад

Goblins, I feel for you but you really should have used CONTRACTS to explain ownership. Totally think y’all should have wands AND go to wizard schools, though.

@Jenacide 4 года назад

Shelly Ballard ok, perhaps once they hire a goblin professor to teach goblin crafts to students goblins may start attending and using wands, seems fair.

@xxx_jim_the_reaper_xxx 4 года назад

@@Jenacide Uhhh no. They won't do that. They can do wandless magic anyways.

@theberrysquad8779 4 года назад

Amazing video!!!

@pyjamacritic1171 4 года назад

Centaurs, elves, goblins, leprechauns and many more Creatures can all make powerful magic without wands, wizards are totally helpless without their wands, wizards are clearly the weakest race in their world. x

@SuperCrabCraft 4 года назад

Like in real life, without wepaons we are useless. But we have the power of craftmanship.

@Jenacide 4 года назад

Well not totally helpless. I mean there’s even a school in Africa where they apparently primarily teach wandless magic, but I get the point you’re making XD

@zonk3835 4 года назад

Weakest species...

@Noobie2k7 4 года назад

I mean it is possible for human wizards/witches to learn wandless magic and even become quite powerful in it. Same as things like flying without a broom. I just think some magic is easier or harder to learn without a wand. I mean summoning spells are technically wandless magic. Since you see Harry summon the port key in Goblet of Fire without his wand and Wizards summon their own wands back to them if disarmed sometimes.

@alfredocruz123426 4 года назад

Noobie2k7 yeah if you seen Harry summon something without a wand in a movie it doesn’t matter because it’s not canon. You definitely need your wand for summoning charms, in fact wizards need their wand for all their magic. Harry wasn’t even sure the woman would be able to apparate alongside her husband when they escaped the ministry because she didn’t have her own wand.

@anthonybousquet3590 4 года назад

Anyone else thinking how the sense of property for goblins is straight up feudal and Medieval? They were literally asking for trouble by making a different definition for property than *everyone else*. And no, goblins shouldn’t be permitted to have wands or know about wandlore when they won’t even tell wizards about their crafting and handling of metals and stones.

@oxfordeducatedhighschoolhe6989 4 года назад

Jews....

@niknikky 4 года назад

Who are you to say that goblins have a different definition of property than everyone else? Do we know property rules for centaurs? House-elves? Why is wizardkind's notion of property and ownership more valid than goblins?

@anthonybousquet3590 4 года назад

niknikky did you see the video? Go tell me they don’t. The elves don’t have property, and centaurs are half-human with a tribal society. So yeah, I can make the very educated guess that goblins have a different definition for property, and theirs is feudal.

@ryanli1235 4 года назад

Do a video for life of Professor Flitwick

@EvanzZx 4 года назад

Wow this has made me really intrigued to hear some stories on some rogue goblins who got a wand and caused chaos 😂

@frizb9034 4 года назад

Aaahhhhhh earlyyy love you so much 🏰💚💚💚🐍🐍

@nancyclow9281 4 года назад

Hi dearest Dean. Thank you so much for another amazing masterpiece. I never knew very much about the goblins. Thank you for sharing your wonderful knowledge. Can't wait for your next masterpiece. Sending lots of 🥰💋 and ❤🤗. You are a 😎.

@coribakescakes4279 4 года назад

Personally, I think the fact that thier grudge is a lie, and that they are so intent on it, that they could be dangerous, its probably not safe to give them wands, but it probably isn't exactly fair either. idk..... Idk....

@TheBacknblack92 4 года назад

Fair is something for elementary school children. Fairness doesnt exist in the real world. Theyll kill you and take all your family heirlooms, but at least it was "fair".

@coribakescakes4279 4 года назад

@@TheBacknblack92I guess ur right, I just don't know how to feel then...

@TheNuyorker 4 года назад

It is only fair because they aren’t fair. Centaurs don’t want wands. Most other magical creatures don’t want wands so why does the most conniving species. They are fine and respected in their positions. That’s fair

@Jenacide 4 года назад

Ya I agree, maybe it’s not fair, but considering the risks it’s necessary

@optidalfprime3904 4 года назад

@@Jenacide No it's pretty fair actually. They don't want to teach about their Metalwork? Humans won't teach about their Wandlore then. Seems pretty fair to me

@yassrymustapha9659 4 года назад

Never miss a video love his vids

@TheseUseless 4 года назад

cuz they have a higher magical potential. if a human , a barely magical being, can kill someone with a single curse, imagine what a more magical creature could do.

@echtoon 4 года назад

What if goblins are so talented with non-wand magic BECAUSE they’re unable to ever use wands, so their skills are developed in non-wand magic.

@hatsuharuboi 2 года назад

This is just the view of the British Ministry, we don't know how goblins are treated in other countries (MACUSA seems to have goblins employees), so, maybe goblins could use wands in other countries... also, wands are a European invention, and it is told that other continents not every wizard/witch uses a wand, but only Africans are told of being particular adept of wandless magic. So, what about chinese or indian? if they don't all use wands, there must be other objects of similar function, a focus. I always thought that could be magical rings, with a whole lore of magical stones/gems, just like magical woods...

@twistedice138 4 года назад

What if Voldemort give the goblins wands to help him in the war. Who do you think would have one or what would be different

@methuselah8885 4 года назад

That seems like a very weird thing to do to say the least. His view on muggle borns was kill on sight, why on earth would he raise non humans closer to wizard status?

@LZ2SM 4 года назад

that would have backfired eventually

@xxx_jim_the_reaper_xxx 4 года назад

@@LZ2SM Tom isn't that stupid.

@dankthegank1742 4 года назад

"...and what is his underline tension that goblins feel against wizards? " Ummm them not being treated equal to wizards?

@Gunplabro 4 года назад

They don't treat wizards right either.

@trex1233 4 года назад

there would need to be a lot of contracts written between the two sides first forgiving past misunderstandings of ownership and redefining what it means to buy a good from one another, then agreeing to teach metal lore while being taught wand lore till both sides where on equal footing along with some clauses that neither side will attack the other and defining what that means.

@Jenacide 3 года назад

I like to think that Flitwick was just naturally talented, like Hermione, and it had nothing to do with his magical bloodline.

@johnrandolph1989 4 года назад

I'm pretty sure there's a show that depicts the true nature of the goblins. Of course I'm referring to Goblin Slayer.

@Otakulifeforme 4 года назад

This literally so much racism in the wizarding world it kinda sucks

@shaytemplar6662 4 года назад

After I watched Goblin slayer I see Goblins as a threat now

@luigi2891 4 года назад

I hate the goblins, seriously. Like the thing about the Gryffindor sword, they think it's theirs no matter. If they sell it, they call it stolen. Once the purchaser has it, it's no longer theirs. I know they make stuff, but it's only theirs until they sell it. And they want fair bargains, what hypocrites.

@lahlybird895 4 года назад

WAIT, WAIT, WAIT! FLITWICK IS PART GOBLIN!? =O :O :o

@zeldaconnection9945 4 года назад

who says, they could really use a wand? As you said, they are different,, and have a different magic! A wand may don´t make them more powerful!

@roanjorna4698 4 года назад

Flitwick

@thescottishhufflepuff2768 4 года назад

Roan Jorna Flitwick isn’t a goblin. He’s a human with Goblin ancestry but he himself is human/half breed

@roanjorna4698 4 года назад

@@thescottishhufflepuff2768 Yeah, you're right. I suppose that if humans and goblins can get magical children their magical gene has to be somewhat the same right? Or does Flitwick have some human and some goblin magical properties?

@thescottishhufflepuff2768 4 года назад

Roan Jorna Not much is known about his roots or origins but i’m assuming he practises more human magic as he did attend hogwarts

@zeldaconnection9945 4 года назад

@@roanjorna4698 As Edenian Kitana seid, he is human!

@kvothe2008 4 года назад

Are goblins perhaps better at wandless magic because they've had centuries at practicing and creating a system they can teach their kids?

@ryanmccants8590 4 года назад

Goblins are so good at enchanting so why not make an item (a dagger for example) that Harnesses magic in a similar way? Like a witches athame.

@alexandriamaguire8224 4 года назад

It seems that goblins get younger. So the one at the bank was old then later younger. Same as flickwick going from old to young... Am i right?!

@mohammednurul9380 4 года назад

Could an elf be a master of the elder wand ? Since they can easily disarm Wizards and Witches. What if an Elf disarmed The master of the elder wand, could he become the new master ?

@rivenoak 4 года назад

yes; the rule of the wand itself says so.

@holohulolo 4 года назад

I think they can, but itxs just illegal. The ones who did probably got caught. What I'm bot so sure is how selfish are goblins amongst themselves, are they only cunning to wards other races to benefit their own race or are they ultimately just out for themselvesn it would hinder and real progress if they fight amongst themselves.

@datathreadsorceress8624 4 года назад

I hope there would be a 'Life of Filus Flipwick' vid or movie soon

@rickkhemai1443 4 года назад

a bank run by Goblins ??. *Goblin Slayer wants to know the location*

@keiradean1728 4 года назад

Why are house elves so loyal to their masters, when they aren't treated humanely?

@Nobodyss21 4 года назад

Because we live in society

@optidalfprime3904 4 года назад

They like the enslavement for some reason. No joke

@tompadfoot3065 4 года назад

Having that loyalty complex beaten into their entire species over centuries? Possible species-wide curse to prevent them from rising up against their xenophobic masters? Because the Wizarding World is largely based in colonialism and Human supremacy? Take your pick

@coreyposthuma447 4 года назад

If goblins are allowed then why not house elves, centaurs, fairies, merpeople.

@anthonybousquet3590 4 года назад

Fairies are more like pixies the world of Harry Potter. Not like the fairy godmothers in Disney films. They’re more like insects (literally) than humans. And I think wand magic works less effectively underwater(?) because they were made by and for surface dwelling humans.

@AmPhilH3O 4 года назад

@@anthonybousquet3590 It worked decently when Harry was in the lake.

@litchtheshinigami8936 4 года назад

T'Shara yeah but i can imagine that the wood might rot away underwater..

@catman6089 4 года назад

PSA: The "Flitwick Change" in the movies is NOT cannon and has NOTHING to do with him being part goblin!!! Flitwick never appeared in the script for Prisoner of Azkaban, but they decided to cast Warwick Davis as "the choir director" because they'd already worked with him in the first two movies. This was intended to be a completely different character, but after production, the director decided he preferred the image of the "choir director" and decided to keep it for Flitwick in the future, especially since the two characters were played by the same actor.

@Dorafran86 3 года назад

Yes! Thanks for explaining this. I remember that sudden change in appearance confiding me for quite a time. I wish they had any on-screen explanation for this, at least. Like Flitwick, taking a de-aging potion or such. They had presented us with none, thus speculations.

@WitchHunter93 4 года назад

I would've loved to see a sequel where Goblins start a new war, taking wands and showing how powerful a Goblin with a wand can be. I imagine a really sinister Goblin as the lead antagonist, with power superior even to Voldemort. Maybe he invents a 4th unforgivable curse.

@coopercrowley793 4 года назад

Does anyone know what a goblins life expectancy is? I assume they live longer than humans but obviously Dumbledore was like 150+ so I was just pondering the subject. If they are so magically gifted it has to be pretty long

@alvar4547 4 года назад

dumbledore was 117 beforehe died.

@tarstakars 4 года назад

And yet apparently goblins are permitted to carry wands in the United States.

@earendurvoneinzbern7585 4 года назад

Nani?

@trog7986 2 года назад

The moment the goblin king sent his minions after Griffindoor, he should have been given a death sentence. The goblin king had no qualms about attacking a STILL ALIVE Griffindoor. "Ownership" my foot. I'd have killed the goblin king and all the other goblins who sided with him.

@ThatDangerousWolf 4 года назад

Lol the goblin’s view of what should happen with stuff/credit of a dead person is eerily reminiscent of credit companies and/or banks

@sifilore9462 4 года назад

It is unfair for goblins as this is the same reason for multiple supernatural pop culture, people always look at supernatural abilities instead of the person’s character and letting choices dictate their future. If goblins were given knowledge in wandlore combined with their metalsmith, they could make metal wands. Plus it could possibly POSSIBLY b the first step in peace ☮️ and putting the past behind them both: humans and goblins.

@Jenacide 4 года назад

Or they could turn around and wipe out wizards entirely, it’s a toss up, but hey why not take that risk right? It’s worth it to feel good about ourselves.

@dustingaethje1332 2 года назад

Right and if we give every country on earth nukes, that would definately not end the world and would totally bring world peace

@claireconolly8355 2 года назад

Where are the female goblins?? Haven't seen one 🙈

@candicecarter5763 4 года назад

Yes. They should allow to carry ward. Please do life of death eater video. Good work.

@dragonweyr44 4 года назад

Why couldn't goblins simply steal wands and hide them? Ollivanders is just a few hundred feet from Gringotts and I'm sure that there are other wandmakers that they can steal from as well as wizards too.

@sherrylhenning5630 4 года назад

Goblins are masters of wandless magic. The goblin wars were over ethics and rights. What if the unspoken secret of the goblins is that wands actually hamper their ability to do magic? The wizards see a wand as a symbol of superiority and power. The clever goblins realize that allowing the wizards to deny them the use of wands makes the wizards think they are crippling the goblins, when the truth is, goblins do much stronger magic without wands, and wands just interfere with their abilities and hamper them. Oh those clever, clever, goblins! No wonder they run the financial affairs of the wizarding world! (House Ravenclaw)

@YourWaywardDestiny 4 года назад

There's so much animosity that before they could even dream of having wands, they have to go through some major social and political hoops first. It's not fair, but it is the way the wizzarding world works.

@kinghoenn3478 2 года назад

The answer is a big NO. Goblins have adamantly refused to teach there metalcraft techniques yet demanding that wizards give up there secrets of wandlore. They can keep there methods and we can keep our own because as a whole Goblins can never be trusted to take any advantage they can get and use it against wizards as shown when they attempted to kill a still living Godric for his sword despite there so called laws of business. They have control of Gringotts and they have influence in the world but when the time comes they turn there claws back to wizards they should be brought to hill once more to a point they learn from their folly and greed.

@bellicosepariah6609 4 года назад

"Its not a very large magic wand for a little goblin, It's a magical staff... completely legal."

@matttastic3920 4 года назад

- Flitwick has a strong goblin ancestry. - There are no halfblood goblins, only pureblood. - goblins aren’t allowed to have wands. Did I miss something?

@kingrn7King 4 года назад

"Because of JK Rowling"

@slingshotssss 4 года назад

hi i just wanted to comment to say i was a massive fan of your channel around 3 years i remember you from before you had 10k subscribers watching your videos was one of my favourite things to do for ages i’d watch them all as soon as they came out and rewatch them again and again i stopped watching a couple years ago i don’t really know why and i just recently rediscovered your channel and it is just as good as i remember it (by the way if you ever got some random view from rwanda that was probably me)