Why Are People Banning Books in Schools?

Подписаться 91 тыс.

Просмотров 41 тыс.

50% 1

A lot of books are getting BANNED lately, especially those that focus on LGBTQ youth or the impact of racism. We all know books can be powerful, but many parents and politicians argue we need to protect kids from content they think is too mature, or even harmful. But what if you are LGBTQ or a person of color and these books reflect your lived experiences?
For info on where to get free banned books or start your own banned books club, go to the Banned Books Book Club: www.bannedbooksbookclub.com/
SUBSCRIBE so you never miss a video!
bit.ly/3tNKzhV
And follow us on Instagram and Twitter!
/ abovethenoisepbs
/ atn_pbs
** What are book bans and where are they happening?
Books are being banned everywhere. A new American Library Association report says there were more than 330 “book challenges” in the fall of 2021. That's more than double the reports from 2020. Book challenges are basically when citizens request that it be banned from libraries and schools. Also, as it stands today there are a bunch of states that have introduced efforts to ban books, an Oklahoma state senator filed a bill to ban books that deal with really any aspect of sexuality, and in Texas, State Representative Matt Krause put over 800 books on a watch list. Also, it’s not just politicians; book bans are often organized by local chapters of conservative parent groups like Moms For Liberty and No Left Turn in Education. They argue that what students read about sexuality and race should be up to the parents, it's their right to choose how they raise their kids.
** What's the history of book bannings?
Taking a look back to 1852, Harriet Beecher Stowe’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin is probably the best-known example of banning a book in the U.S. The book shows the horrors of slavery, so it’s no surprise pro-slavery people called for the book to be banned and called it “pro-abolitionist propaganda.” Some historians point to it as one of the most influential books banned in the United States and some historians think the book was a catalyst for the civil war. Fast forward to the 1960s, folks were obsessed with banning what we now consider classics like J.D. Salinger’s “Catcher in the Rye” for things like language, sex, violence, and drugs, or Harper Lee’s “To Kill a Mockingbird” for its depictions of rape and language some even challenged it for being immoral, and even Maya Angelou’s “I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings” which was challenged for rape and molestation but also for being anti-white.
** Who’s impacted the most by banning books?
If a student identifies with the character or the story from a book that's being banned, how does that shape how they see themselves? People who disapprove of these books consistently point to explicit sexual content, language, or ideas that their kids can’t handle because they’re too young as the reason for trying to ban books. But in practice, does banning these types of books just end up silencing non-white and non-heteronormative voices? A lot of the books being banned focus on LGBTQ+ stories and characters or People of Color, and sometimes the intersections of those groups. How do we protect students and children while making sure they see themselves in books or can see experiences and cultures they may not otherwise be exposed to?
SOURCES
www.nytimes.com/2022/01/30/bo...
www.vox.com/policy-and-politi...
www.teenvogue.com/story/stude...
www.vox.com/culture/22918344/...
www.harrietbeecherstowecenter...
TEACHERS: Get your students in the discussion on KQED Learn, a safe place for middle and high school students to investigate controversial topics and share their voices. learn.kqed.org/discussions/
About KQED
KQED serves the people of Northern California with a public-supported alternative to commercial media. An NPR and PBS member station based in San Francisco, KQED is home to one of the most listened-to public radio stations in the nation, one of the highest-rated public television services, and an award-winning education program helping students and educators thrive in 21st-century classrooms. A trusted news source, leader, and innovator in interactive technology, KQED takes people of all ages on journeys of exploration - exposing them to new people, places, and ideas.
00:00 - 01:03 - Intro to topic
01:03 - 02:45 - What's going on with book bans today?
02:48 - 04:34 - What's the history of banning books?
04:58 - 08:12 - Who is most impacted by banning books?
#bannedbooks #bookbans

Опубликовано:

26 июл 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 218

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

What do you think about the movement to ban certain books from high school curriculum and libraries?

@ForumArcade 2 года назад

I think it can be approached as an economics issue. If the books are not particularly good or can't find an audience in schools, then the school libraries won't keep them. But if children are already seeking out to read them, then they obviously possess some meaningful interest to that demographic, and the notion of banning them to prevent those ideas from reaching young minds seems an exercise in futility. Ironically, the same political forces arguing for this limitation on the dissemination of thoughts and ideas are the same forces that frequently decry what they perceive as violations of free speech and free expression, AND that ostensibly favour a free and unregulated economic system driven by the fundamental forces of supply and demand.

@martin_bolha 2 года назад

@@ForumArcade Watch out so only books on how to be a succesffull ticktocer are not left :D

@RhizometricReality 2 года назад

I think nothing makes teens willing to push the boundaries of unreasonable authority then being told they can't learn about something. The tyranny of the state shows its gross hand when it reduces people into subjugate demographics, a "we know what's good for you" enforced by the logiced conclusion of police violence. After all what happens when you disobey the state? It's Terror operatives come to your home.

@likebot. 2 года назад

What do I think? It's about power. It's not as bad as NK but that direction is where this is headed, keeping people from being exposed to concepts, controlling their minds by giving them their opinions instead of letting them make their own educated opinions. And I think it's political, a line-drawing taunt by conservative authoritarians. I think a lot more about it, but it gets ranty and conspiracy theoryey from here. ;)

@bookgirlny8511 2 года назад

I am lucky as a teacher in NYS. We are supported by our district. I am doing five new books with my middle-level readers, including some of those appearing on those lists. This is also true k-12. There’s a little pushback, but the vast majority is supportive.

@jim4859 2 года назад

Banned book lists are must reads (I've never seen the list so long). Controversial songs have been songs I've gone out of my way to listen to. I guess narrow minds fear breadth and depth. We'll always be struggling against them.

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

A lot of the books on the most challenged book lists are YA best sellers. We can't claim it's a causational relationship and not correlative, but...makes ya wonder.

@curiousKuro16 2 года назад

I work at a library and we just had information go out on how to inform patrons that the goal of the library is to offer any and all information possible.

@blackgirlmagician 2 года назад

Thank you for including me in this important conversation!

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

Our pleasure! We are so grateful you gave us your time and perspective.

@colinyim5177 2 года назад

This reminds me of the Parental Advisory stickers on music when i was a teen in the 90s. I sought out the label!

@smariegalski3641 10 месяцев назад

Hhmmm... That's so true. The label made them desirable for sure.

@CarlosBunn 2 года назад

There's a difference between banning and "not available on the school library" Usually it has the opposite effect, as rhe book looks more interesting, and it's a google search away

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

True that this is an important distinction. Also true that making a book unavailable tends to increase the desire to read it.

@curiousKuro16 2 года назад

The Streisand Effect

@qawamity 2 года назад

One of the positive things of living in the Information Age is that if someone wants a banned book they can usually find it. Before, if a book was forbidden to local libraries and bookstores refused to carry it (or were intimidated into not carrying it), there was somewhere between jack and shit that could be done to get it by most folks. What are you going to do, take time away from the rest of your life to travel two states over for novel? That's an inconvenient expense even after the mass adoption of the automobile, and impossible for most teens; and a hundred years ago no one was going to do that for a single copy of a recently written book. (Though I wager there were some "black market" shops that carried banned books all the same.)

@mavywavy801 Год назад

Well there’s been public libraries that are also on fire for having banned books as well. They’re trying to make it unavailable for those who are poor and can’t afford simple luxuries like buying new books.

@bobbobbington3615 8 месяцев назад

@AboveTheNoise not a single, elementary kid cares about the ban; no one is looking for these books except for pervy parents.

@loup754 2 года назад

Never ceases to amaze me that the land of the free is only free from a narrow perspective.

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

One person's freedom is another person's attack on freedom, it seems. you especially see that around the whole free speech debate.

@wowman542 2 года назад

I don't think Nicole Cardoza summarized the conservative viewpoint in good faith here, she didn't acknowledge the possibility that there might be genuinely inappropriate depictions of sex or violence within any of these texts and I don't think them having a marginalized author should give them carte blanche to write whatever they want and have it taught in schools. I agree with the idea that students should be faced with hard ideas like the history of racism and prejudice within this country but that doesn't mean I think every school should show graphic footage of Rodney King being beaten to death to kids. I think the banning of any books from libraries is a step too far from any political viewpoint, conservative or progressive. Classes and their curriculum should be led by the teachers and their expertise but to ban lgbtq+ literature or books exploring different political viewpoints from school libraries is too far and that's where I draw the line since technically kids could go online and find a pdf but I'd rather have it be more accessible for them to explore on their own terms away from the judgement of their parents, communities or even classmates.

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

Thanks for watching and leaving this comment. You bring up some really good points! In the video, we did try to represent the valid concerns of many parents that they want the right to protest when they feel books their kids are reading for school are too sexually graphic or contain violence that isn’t age-appropriate. Our main point is that politically motivated legislation to BAN books is deeply problematic - but there SHOULD be an opportunity for meaningful debate and discussion about what kinds of content belong in classrooms and school libraries. Cutting off access to books is never going to be in the best interest of young people, especially those who rarely see their own experience represented in the books they read in school. But yes - we agree 100% that we should presume trust in teachers’ expertise when it comes to deciding what content is most relevant and appropriate for their students. In the words of @vlogbrothers Hank Green, "Efforts to restrict stories are often efforts to restrict empathy." We recommend his video on this topic: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-MrS-46e59V4.html

@bookgirlny8511 2 года назад

@@AboveTheNoise That’s part of the problem: disingenuous politicians trying to stoke rage in order to generate votes by demonizing us teachers.

@johnnyrepine937 2 года назад

A couple years ago I distributed about a dozen copies of Fahrenheit 451 to little library projects here around Akron, Ohio.

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

That’s awesome! Thanks for doing that!

@draegore 2 года назад

Banned books are an endorsement.

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

And banning books is all too often a political endorsement for candidates in certain voting districts.

@qawamity 2 года назад

My copy of The Complete Maus, which I ordered back in February when places were talking about banning it, finally came in yesterday. Ironically, some of the efforts to ban books instead acts as advertising for them.

@janto58 Год назад

It took months for my copy to arrive because they were backlogged.

@hatimhusai8920 2 года назад

As a current high school student, I often asked for books about police brutality and different culture and LBTQIA story’s to find out about the world around me So many of the topics I asked for had books written by a white heteronormativive person It’s just scary to hear teachers praise reading and see school librarians show me a list of book I CAN’T read longer than the list I CAN In conclusion- banned books are an internet search away, and always worth findibg

@bookgirlny8511 2 года назад

This is why I appreciate all the support I am getting for teaching King and the Dragonflies. 🥰

@ericapelz260 10 месяцев назад

LGBTQIA not LHBTQIA the "H" word is seen as a slur by many.

@inyobill 9 месяцев назад

You sounfd intelligent enough and appear to have a good enough basic education to be able to parse the information you will be reading, making you a more well-rounded and informed citizen.

@deepdragon2 9 месяцев назад

@@ericapelz260 Please stop abusing the alphabet it is offence to people.

@TickleMeElmo55 8 месяцев назад

lol kid, you're basically listed topics that are high on MSM and left-wing minds. I mean, you used "white heteronormative" in a serious manner.

@nicks1451 2 года назад

Back in the early 90s I got in big trouble for reading a highly controversial book called…. Jurassic Park… you know, because it taught the evils of evolution. Long story short, I got ahold of the book again and read it anyway lol

@user-hw1db1vd4y Год назад

Of course you did. The only students who didn't were the ones who weren't very smart.

@I.____.....__...__ 2 года назад

Don't those people realize hat by banning them, all they're doing is making them more alluring to the kids who will now want to read them all the more? 🤨 If you really don't want them to read them, just give the kids a list of all the books and tell them you think they should read them all. The kids will sigh, throw the list away, and pull out their phones to watch TikTok. duh. 😒

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

Um, yes. But what about getting those fearful parents votes in conservative districts? We gotta ask what the real objectives behind these bans are.

@gloomyscribbles 2 года назад

maybe that's the intention, kind of like a reverse psychology thing

@frillylily8005 Год назад

That doesn’t always work many would read what you tell them too while others won’t.

@sandysutherland2182 Год назад

If I was an author, I would just LOVE IT if they banned my book. It just about GAURENTEE some decent sales!

@cestlavegan5793 2 года назад

Censorship of purely literary works in school libraries seems like a horrible idea, especially for high schoolers. Give them the freedom to explore any and all topics to their heart’s content. Allow them to form their own opinions and thoughts. So long as the titles don’t contain graphic images of violence or sex, I’d vote to allow them all.

@XXLSSBBW 10 месяцев назад

Let these idiots ban books from their libraries. Kids today can just download the book they want on their kindle.

@hihowareyou6195 7 месяцев назад

In Florida they are only banned in elementary school libraries in public schools.

@stefanjakubowski8222 2 года назад

I played and ran lots of dystopian ttrpg, we felt they were so over the top sometimes, now looking back they seem tame

@RhizometricReality 2 года назад

"The moms and the pops, you all are the cops"

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

Catchy. And often true -- for better or for worse.

@RhizometricReality 2 года назад

@@AboveTheNoise lyrics from a song, Pop that Pretty Thirty by Rabbit Junk About how much of our control society is self inflicted by a manipuled population.

@rioliega 15 дней назад

I genuinely feel like parents having TOO much control over what their children learn causes more harm to everyone in the long run. Teenagers are beginning to navigate the world around them, and we need to give them the freedom to experience it at a young age so they dont grow up and figure out how much of the world was hidden from them.

@VTimmoni 2 года назад

Very insightful. Thank you.

@thomasr.jackson2940 2 года назад

Another good video. Politicians banning books, or facilitating such bans, is a pretty clear cut wrong to be opposed. More difficult is that local pressure does influence decisions of administrators and even librarians at the local level who have to work with the parents of their students. Building community in institutions is hard. These discussions and videos help.

@inyobill 9 месяцев назад

Makes one wonder what they so afraid of?

@thomasr.jackson2940 9 месяцев назад

@@inyobillthat is one way to approach it. Another is that we want community and parental engagement in local institutions and schools. That is a critical good for good government. And engagement can be messy, and might not align with the perspective of the institutional leadership or others in the community. All book collections are curated in some ways. One man’s editorial judgement is another’s ban.

@eileensmiller8041 18 часов назад

@@inyobillPeople who think and question the choices of those in charge.

@pamelanred5053 2 года назад

Most kids wouldn’t read these or even pay attention to banned books if some radical parents didn’t make a big deal of them. If you want kids to read something tell them not to read them and they will sneak around and read it anyway.

@user-qo8ko5sx3e 6 месяцев назад

With social media, kids don’t read or don’t know how…reality

@quicksilvuhh 2 года назад

If schools were pushing books that made claims such as racism never existed and explicitly taught there are only two genders pushback would be understandable. The same pushback is understandable if books are teaching we are all racist and must be anti-racist or there are limitless genders. Ideology tends to move toward extremes, and parents will understandably oppose indoctrination into certain schools of thought. Teach academia not activism.

@SecretSquirrelFun 2 года назад

Fahrenheit 451 had the same effect on me in high school, we read it in my first year of high school along with Shakespeare, Mockingbird and several others. 451 totally transport me into its world and I just couldn’t put it down. Thanks for the memories 🙂🐿🌈

@mr.e2962 6 месяцев назад

What are we to do when kids want to read husler magazines?

@kaysaudiobooks 2 года назад

There's book bans on both sides actually... Remember "When Harry Became Sally"? Or "A Birthday Cake for George Washington"? Or some of the Dr. Seuss books?

@yeetman4953 11 месяцев назад

source?

@kaysaudiobooks 11 месяцев назад

@@yeetman4953 Just look up the titles I mentioned

@RuiizRuined Месяц назад

Ray Bradbury and George Orwell books, as well as every other political dystopian book got banned in my school which is really sad because i dream to be a politician one day and you can learn about the horrors of the fictional governments, and see how they compare to the real ones.

@GMax17 2 года назад

Don't ban the books. It's extremely important to know the contents of the book before reading though.

@veronicaharwick9013 Год назад

Why are people banning books? Fear of ideas. Laziness in making a personal list of books you would prefer your child not to read & to schedule a meeting with the school librarian to discuss the matter. The desire to maintain control & power over others.

@raymondgstanleyjr Год назад

The Ignorance here is blatant.

@AboveTheNoise Год назад

Care to elaborate?

@likebot. 2 года назад

Is The Bible among those banned?

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

Now there’s a question

@Affluent-Ghetto-Blackman 2 года назад

The one true indoctrination.

@TheWesternLady844 2 года назад

Such a great episode. Banning books is horrible. America of the free? Freedom of speech? There are limits to American "freedoms".

@dominickdambrosio783 2 месяца назад

Bro, your beard is epic

@FOLKEN1979 3 месяца назад

This is, of course, horrible, and something that everyone should be vigilant and vocal in opposing and denouncing. But if you are from another country. Know that you still have the freedom to buy them in stores. Unlike many populations with no such freedom. Now, that in no way justify any form of intellectual censoring, yet still important to point out.

@naturalistmind 2 года назад

I love banned books more than unbanned books most of the time. As with most forms of censorship it's just a giant case of thou dost protest to much, though to be fair I'm just ace but I do consider myself a part of the LGBTQ community

@bookgirlny8511 2 года назад

I agree. This is why I have a lot of support in my district offering a choice book with LGBTQ characters at the middle school level. 😁

@sandysutherland2182 Год назад

If I was an author, I wold LOVE it if they banned my book. It would just about GARENTWEE

@kailawkamo1568 2 года назад

I see banned books, I see tbr material

@tyrelldennis3156 5 месяцев назад

Books that are banned usually have the best information and knowledge, but of course, these books will always face criticism because of the ignorance of society who are afraid to question the norm.

@llamallama3007 Год назад

that's what happens when you take away dr.seuss

@saumitrachakravarty 2 года назад

No book should be banned. Regardless of what it says. It doesn't matter if it's for or against my ideology. No to book ban everywhere. Period.

@Sirgacha_ 2 года назад

What if the book actively encourages murder and racism?

@ralphdempsey2874 11 месяцев назад

I'd be curious to know how she'd feel about books like Huckelberry Finn or the works of Enid Blyton being removed for their discussions or depictions of race (especially use racial slurs or racist imagery)? Everyone talks about the book bans from their own perspective but the reality is that groups from across the spectrum have called for bans (abeit for different reasons). Personally I think we should trust our young people a little more and mollycoddle a little less...creeping censorship and the chilling effect around "awkward" discussions is going to do far more damage long term to their sense of self.

@AboveTheNoise 11 месяцев назад

You raise a good point, but if you analyze the book banning policies and laws being passed (and we did) - the vast majority of them focus on issues around gender identity, LBGTQ themes, and racial justice. While there are definitely attempts to raise critiques - and in limited cases, bans - of books like the ones you mention, there is not a widespread movement that is using legislation or district policy to remove the books from library shelves.

@sirlagsalot101 2 года назад

Im against book baning and cancel culture in general as its like a crud form of mind control that is designed to prevent critical thinking i disagree with books on critical race theory but i believe in the right to write and read them and to try and show the other side and challenge people's opinions

@cecilia08yeah 2 года назад

Great video

@abigailhubbard1055 8 месяцев назад

It's not just school libraries. They are also trying to ban them in public libraries. Some public libraries are being defunded because they refuse to ban the books.

@lettersandwordsandstuffs 7 месяцев назад

Good...they are trying to indoctrinate children

@Danplays3000 6 месяцев назад

Didn't the nazis also use a simular tactic

@tyrelldennis3156 5 месяцев назад

Yes, they did! History is only repeating itself.

@supadavie Год назад

To kill a mockingbird was banned by progressives in a California county. Florida, governed by conservatives, still encourages this book in their 8 grade curriculums.

@Duraputer 2 года назад

I think that no books should be banned, however if parents don't want their children to learn about a certain topic in class, that goes against their religion or political views, then they should not be required to learn that material.

@bookgirlny8511 2 года назад

Not necessarily. They may still need to learn the material if it’s part of the curriculum. They may request a choice as to the particular material or text.

@kyokoyumi 2 года назад

Book banning/burning is a direct violation of freedom of speech and should not be allowed. Period. If you have a problem with a book, don't read it. If someone else wants to read it, your child or not, you don't have the right to stop them. That child is a human. It's own human with it's own thoughts and feelings and desires. Start respecting your kids or you'll be sorry once it's time for them to take care of you in turn. *Children are human too.* It'd be great if we started a hashtag called that. #childrenarehumantoo (if there's not one already. I don't do twitter which is where I know the hashtag thing originates from) Make it a place for children of all ages to be heard and seen and respected as the smoll humans they are.

@liampatrick3110 Год назад

Cause most of them are not age appropriate?🤷‍♂️😐

@azazel166 3 месяца назад

Not an excuse.

@OctobersOwnHorrorLover Год назад

That’s horrible! Double standards. Access to information should be banned. Why.

@annamo6927 Год назад

Why is Dr. Seuss being banned?

@GeneralDonato 10 месяцев назад

There's just one issue: It isn't banned. It stopped being produced because it wasn't making revenues, and racism is just a secondary concern.

@robboots3440 5 месяцев назад

Search: manufacturing consent. I'd start there. Then read '1984', and compare it to your society. Have a strong drink. Forge on.

@bwolff7364 2 года назад

New goal: write a book that would be banned in Texas

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

Would be sure to drive sales!

@ginnyjollykidd 2 года назад

Google is your friend. And like you said, there are websites dedicated to banned books, and you can Google everyone of them. I've said and I'll say it again: banning books is the best way to get them read.

@hb9149 Год назад

You know, a book isn't really banned if it is available in the public library, online and at bookstores. Parents simply want K-12 schools to curate age-appropriate materials for children.

@teresalee467 Год назад

You know if a book is banned at the school that means a student can't use it as a book report, term paper etc. It's fkd up what they are doing . Books that have been available for years are now suddenly controversial. Wonder why??

@ashthrice6s Год назад

@@teresalee467yeah, like Dr Seuss!

@azazel166 3 месяца назад

Parents and their moral panics can eff off.

@alwaysv 7 месяцев назад

i love banned books! not sure what those parents are worried about, they're kids don't read books anyways 😂

@ianalvord3903 2 года назад

Just think of these books as "misinformation" and then maybe you will understand why parents don't want them endorsed by the schools.

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

Seems like an overly broad description of all the books that are being banned. How are books like “The Bluest Eye” and “The Hate U Give” equivalent to “misinformation,” which means intentional falsehoods?

@ianalvord3903 2 года назад

@@AboveTheNoise The phrase "misinformation" is used arbitrarily these days to refer to anything that someone wants to censor. It's a blatant double standard. When it comes to propaganda that someone wants to see, they call it "the free flow of information." But for the things they don't want to see, they call it misinformation.

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

@@ianalvord3903 it's unfortunately true that this term has become manipulated and politicized. That's why it's crucial to try always to ground critical debate over controversial issues in evidence and data. We can disagree over which evidence we find most persuasive, but we need to keep asking questions and investigating different perspectives or we are doomed as a society.

@ianalvord3903 2 года назад

@@AboveTheNoise It's hard to use evidence and data when it comes to questions regarding age appropriateness though. How old should a child be before they can watch Deadpool, read Lovecraft, listen to Metallica, etc? It's a matter of opinion typically left to the parents. I can't read each of these books and give an opinion on each one. But I can say that if parents find a book inappropriate for the children's section, it should be moved to another section.

@colinleat8309 7 месяцев назад

Just discovered your channel, along with 8000 other PBS one's. My brain is exploding 🤣🤣. As a life long lover of books, I think banning is just about one of the most dispicable things we can do as a culture/society. What's next, burning! ( Bradbury 😉). Lord of the Rings best books ever!! Thanks for your channel 👍. Hopefully you'll read this 🤞. 🖖😁🤘🇨🇦✌️

@kenives6548 Год назад

The banning of these books make people want to read them

@davidwilson8800 2 года назад

It doesn't make sense we teach kids to read then take away their books let the kids read teach them about their Right to Read and speak

@quatreunhuit Год назад

instead of banning books, why not promote the ones that you like?

@noscopesnaughti6240 9 месяцев назад

Mabey parents dont want thier kids to become slaves to the system. they dont want submisiveness and vulnerability to be rewarded or encouraged. look at the military right now.

@dragonfoxsolid1308 Год назад

These books aren't banned by society but curated for age. Do a video on the protocols of zion, or books you can't order from Amazon.

@yeetman4953 11 месяцев назад

protocols of zion is a propaganda piece. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Protocols_of_the_Elders_of_Zion

@chwondearth4531 Год назад

Banned books are top sellers! Hand basket days 😈👍

@johndonaldson8979 10 месяцев назад

Banning books? How bout banning CELL PHONES in schools to protect the kids..

@Nguyen12121 Год назад

What is this need to groom kids with sexualized contents? If a book is not allowed to be read or shown in public, it shouldn’t be allowed in schools for kids.

@ppbuttfart2215 Год назад

While it’s terrible that these books have been banned, I love how it’s back-firing on them by potentially making these books more widely known than they otherwise would have been. Reminds me of the Streisand effect lol

@williamwoolcock Год назад

I think they re going after the wrong people! Who sold these books to the district? They probably came through a procurement process where book sales companies send an allotment to schools, sight unseen. Perhaps to get rid of unprofitable books. No one reviewed the books coming in as the procurement contracts just continue from year to year. In a regular public library the librarian may order books according to popularity, necessity of content, and they can avoid unnecessary books.

@XXLSSBBW 10 месяцев назад

Fahrenheit 451 & 1984 Once great pieces of literature. Now becoming reality.

@lisacox8109 Год назад

I don't, do not believe in baning books. 451...

@ginnyjollykidd 2 года назад

"Pro- abolitionist propaganda." Yeah, and...?

@cestlavegan5793 2 года назад

I was confused by this quote as well. If all disseminated ideas are generated by human beings, and therefore intrinsically biased to some extent, are they not all propagandistic as well? When you think about it, it’s actually difficult to imagine a book completely free of propaganda. Perhaps some just have more than others.

@ADTillion 2 года назад

@@cestlavegan5793 The word itself has just become a buzzword to invalidate any conflicting narrative. In reality, it’s all just “conditioning”. No living being born is free from conditioning. It’s a survival mechanism. It affects us on a biological level to degrees we are still researching about. Being “objective” is an ideal, mostly pursued in spiritualism, but since majority of us are laymen, we will forever be subjective according to our conditioning, as you also put forth. Disagreement inevitably arises when one’s conditioning contradicts that of another. It’s why we create lawful systems for debate, compromise and negotiation.

@cestlavegan5793 2 года назад

@@ADTillion That’s interesting. I like the way you related our conditioning to our disagreements. The differences in our conditioning (as well as our genetics I would add) seem to fundamentally cause disagreement between one another. Which I would argue isn’t necessarily a bad thing until it leads to violence.

@ADTillion 2 года назад

@@cestlavegan5793 Indeed. Every conditioned behaviour/response develops to help navigate a particular lifestyle, regardless of whether it is right or wrong. Diverse viewpoints lead to more possible adaptations when lifestyles inevitably experience new environmental stresses. For example, the ability to try new clothes, foods, physical exercises, and invent new words and languages etc., are what enabled us to build communities all over the world. If all lived by the same conditioning, then that spells disaster. It’s why the quickest species to go extinct are usually specialists and not generalists. Being generalist is what leads to different lifestyles and attitudes that constantly evolve. Similar logic with businesses. If there is no diversity in viewpoint, then it is impossible to compete and advance in a free market because you will just keep rejecting whatever innovation a rival comes up with, leading you to become obsolete.

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

@@ADTillion Gotta say, I love this whole exchange happening here. Thanks for being such thoughtful viewers of our content, and raising those provocative points and questions. That's honestly our main goal for this show...just to see that happen in a respectful way in our comments!

@robinfrady5257 Год назад

I am only going to have enough strength to be able to say this once. I have absolutely had the shit beat out of me about this. It is all about not having Bible in public schools. Bible in our government officials, Gods word in our daily lives. I know for a fact everything living and breathing needs God and please come home.

@rampartranger7749 Год назад

Oh!! This guy is for bringing the Bible back into school! And other Christian books! ……or maybe not. Maybe he is not for openness ……He seems confused.

@SariennMusic73 Год назад

Religious books are absolutely allowed in all private religious schools since everyone attending is a member of that particular religion. Public schools are a different story since they aren't religion based. Besides, the Christian Bible is far more obscene and grotesque than any of the books people are wanting to ban. If anything should be banned, it's that book.

@williamgregory1848 4 месяца назад

I promise you there is not a single person that went to school for library science because they wanted to be on the front lines of America's march towards headassery... we are living in ridiculous times

@AboveTheNoise 4 месяца назад

Indeed. And thank you librarians for your service - whether you intended it or not, it is very much appreciated!

@inyobill 9 месяцев назад

Clearly they believe that they have done a good job teaching their children ethics. Or they are afraid their children are going to learn that there is more to be ethical then they have been taught.

@BannedBooksUS Год назад

They're getting banned because people are afraid of the "others". If they had more exposure to these oppressed groups, it would enlighten their minds, but they're too afraid of things that are different than them. Anyway, very informative. Left a like for a job well done :D

@richardbeckmann6720 2 года назад

None of those people said anything about the band dr. Seuss book? The same could be said about social media posts and videos. Some of those defending the band books are also complaining about Elon Musk buying Twitter and allowing for free speech

@korimcentire5367 Год назад

Then they should band the bible. Have you read how much horrible stuff is in there? Hmmmm....

@lifeisaadventure9948 9 месяцев назад

🕊🪧🎗

@wellingred1 7 месяцев назад

This is cute

@InformationIsTheEdge 2 года назад

"People of color." Could someone help me with this? It was my impression that this was just saying, colored people again. Did I miss something?

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

You can easily find information about the difference in meanings and the history behind why “colored people” is offensive to most Black Americans and why “people of color” has a very different context and meaning. Here is one place you can start learning more: www.chicagotribune.com/columns/dahleen-glanton/ct-dahleen-glanton-colored-email-reading-list-20200304-utx7geiwm5hupa3t7w6xr3xqn4-story.html

@InformationIsTheEdge 2 года назад

@@AboveTheNoise Wow! Thank you! Good article and informative. The ever evolving struggle of African Americans and other marginalized groups, to define their identity. I appreciate the effort and the information!

@warriorsorb1111 3 месяца назад

Banning books is ridiculous. If anyone should be telling the kids what they can or can't read, it's their parents.

@mr.gigagod9736 11 месяцев назад

Tbh not that big of a deal. No kid wants to read this. When i was in school i was reading Diary of the Wimpy kid. No that's some quality

@summervibes9931 2 года назад

that's not banning books. that's picking age appropriate topics and approaches. the books are still available, just not part of a curriculum. pretty disingenuous to conflate those. lucky youtube took off dislike button to protect silly ideas

@AboveTheNoise 2 года назад

Many of the laws currently proposed or put into effect demand that the books be removed not only from curricula, but from school library shelves - and in some cases including the youth sections of general public libraries. And if a school or teacher deems a book appropriate for their students when it’s on the list, they can be fired.

@miriamrosemary9110 2 года назад

They didn't say that they're burning books, or banning them out of the country, they said that they're banning them in schools and libraries, making them less available in certain circles. That doesn't sound disingenuous to me.

@summervibes9931 2 года назад

@@AboveTheNoise again, that age restricting certain books. That’s like saying putting an R rating on Team America is banning movies. No, the movie is available to be found, just won’t be offered on platforms meant for kids like Kids RU-vid

@ryoshockwave 2 года назад

Did you know you can get a plugin to add the dislikes back? I have it and, as of this comment, there are over 200 likes on this video and only a single dislike. Probably yours.

@stefanjakubowski8222 2 года назад

@@summervibes9931 age appropriate, like math?? Or physics or.....keep your kids in home and homeschool