No video :(

Why did the world let India annex Goa? (Short Animated Documentary)

Подписаться 1,7 млн

Просмотров 2,2 млн

50% 1

In 1961 the Indian army marched into Portuguese Goa and after two days of fighting formally annexed it into the country. Given that the world largely believed that conquering foreign lands hadn't been cool since the end of the WW2 why was it allowed to stand? Why did the world let India annex Goa? To find out why watch this short and simple animated history documentary.
A special thanks to my Patreon supporters:
Joakim Idland
Jens Koch-Nommensen
Øystein Alsaker
Sergio M. Vela
khaki enthusiast
Eclipse
Gin Aldeguer
Brendan W
Dennis Vandeban
Hasmuffin
Michael Kram
CharÉTS
Ethan
Franco La Bruna
Don Bonnigan
Ian Whitcomb
Southside Mitch
Bradley chaulk
Justin Kubusch
John
Adam Barrett
Matthew Literovich
Heath Robertson
JakeBak0905
Person
Shane McKenna
Leonard Frank
Timmy
Christopher Godfrey
Phillip Gathright
Vance Christiaanse
sharpie660
Travis Mount
Joshua Schneider
Philip Yip
Harley Raptopoulos
Sean Uzar
Sean D.
Paul Munro
Mario Peshev
Shauna K
Joooooshhhhhh
Nathan Mendelsohn
Phoenix Fats
Piotr Wojnowski
Alex Teplyakov
Joshua Rackstraw
Jane Sumpter
Korix Riylo
Aaron Conaway
Adrian Marine
Emperor Kane
Martha Grondin
John Orr
Andreas Mosand
Steven Gibson
Jack Nelson
Dr. Schtnizel
Matthew Toles
Peter Marino
Jamie van Brewen
Bernardo Cavalcanti
Andrew F
zockotron
tegsirat
Nick Macarius
D. Mahlik
Nicholas Menghini
Erik Hare
Chris Winther
Manny F
Dana Spurgeon
Tony Belmonte
MGS2600
Ron Johnson
Konstantin Bredyuk
Zhao Liu
Tactical_Jackal
Andy McGehee
Evan Ellingson
Sahni
Joe DeVito
Allen Rines
Nolan Peale
Chach
Katie Flinn
Bradley Backoff
Roman Kynčl
Michael Galloway
HelloAgain
Andrew Patane
Chase Labiste
Contdoko12
Jacob Zachs
mgnesium.poetry
Ciege Engine
Zach Rust
Angel Aguiñaga
Thomas McGraw
Matt Reed
Jose Recinto
Dullis
Clayton Schuman
Chris Weisel
blaZzinG_FurY
Bernice
Keith A. Layton
Zachary Pascalar
Tino
Bartosz Zasada
Leena Al-Souki
Vilena5
Daniel J Miller
Tim Stone
Serius_Loyola
John Garcia
Bodo Nuber
Windischgraetz
Perry Gagne
Brian George
Matthew O'Connor
george tyler
Ben Drums 24
Patty Culp
Jason Vandeventer
Tyler Jenkins
Joseph Hutchins
William Adderholdt
No way
Ahmed Roshdi
Warren Rudkin
Hexapuma
Carl Blanton
ThePalestRose
Liquid Chief
Stefan Møller
Joseph Reinsch
Oliver Jenner
KNSTRKTVST
ARandomPaperClip
Justin Short
Blue Cardinal
Aaron Larrow
bas mensink
Curt Helmerich
Jason Gould
David van Reyk
Dexter_McAaron
Tim Stumbaugh
Joel Wasserman
Mr. Myoozik
Valentyn
kevinh
Anthony McCann
Tim Sweeney
James
Joel Cromwell
Juan Castillo
Ethan Harlow
Matthew Ward
Vegard Tønnessen
Clay Carroll
Andrew Niedbala
Nathan Ngumi
Logical Insanity
Ned Burke
Richard Wolfe
Magdalena Reinberg-Leibel
Geoffrey Sparrow
Burt Clothier
Jonny Minogue
Sethars
Yared Cristiano
BattleGoat Studios
Bren Ehnebuske
Ryan Lowe
Robin!
Steve Bonds
Andrei Listochkin
Romney Manassa
Colm Byrne
Alen
Rob Rollins
Matt Busch
nullptr
Thomas McGill
Brian Giordano
Yosef Waysman
George Buce
Little Ernu
anon
Colonel Oneill
Joseph Kerckhoff
sixbeforelunch
Melissa Prober
Mars Project
SketerK
pdswanfleet
Emily Glover-Wilson
luvrhino
David Spellmeyer
Alex G.
I'm Not In The Description
Anthony Uk
LambOfLeg
Thomas Wang
Yuichiro Kakutani
Donald Weaver
Dr. Howard Dr. Fine Dr. Howard
Tristan Kreller
Ryan Haber
hefcluba
Sara Birnbaum
Juan Benet
Mark Ploegstra
Moraxian
Zach Weakland
Tranier Bocaj
Charles Doolittle
Roko Lisica
Jeffrey Schneider
Sean Long
Hiro P
Kirk Hoffman
Eric Askins
Hunter Bayliss
Dustin Koellhoffer
Aeryn and Lisa Toland
Allen
Ian M
Colm Boyle
Igor Stavchanskiy
mohd
Oriki
Harrison Wiener
George Caponera
Tom Ebert
Kinfe85
Zachary Oertel
Wolf
Will Sullivan
YugiJitsu Games
Chasen Le Hara
0_DannyBoy
Isabel Harrison
Danny Anstess
Dutchball Animations
James R DeVries
Sophie Winter
Kevin Phoenix
Dan Reiher
Mik Scheper
Robert Brockway
Lech Duraj
Miky Hidalgo Morriss
John Gross-Whitaker
Barry
Seth Reeves
Doug MacLean
Rita Cragwall
Dr. Sarno
Peter Konieczny
AltHistoryConjectures
Ali Sadighian
Nathan Snyder
Shakira Graham
Heytun
Azul Bravestrong
Andrew Sever
William Clark
Christopher S Nelson
ConspiracyPizza
Brooks Woolson
JT96
Paul McGee
Lindorien
Abdallah Al-Ammari
João Santos
Daniel O'Reilly
Markus Lindström
Typhoon2401
Deadlock
Michael Corson
blei95
Robin_Col
M Scho
Kasi
Olaf
Jan Bart Verbist
Schwarzer Hai
Ploshtinska polyudnica
Tarsirrus
James
Rhys Little
Ash Elford
Jackarice26
Harrison Tatem-Wyatt
Twinny Hill
Gina Service
Phil Johnston
zemnmez
Roberticus1992
KingKyumber
Rhys Jackson
DarkLycan
Tom Pollard
Ben L
biohazardgamer

Опубликовано:

27 авг 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 12 тыс.

@Nv-yi1jh Год назад

I can't believe Portugal didn't leave when they were told to Goa way

@madshagen5849 Год назад

I saw what you did there...

@alanpennie8013 Год назад

@@madshagen5849 Groan.

@aldrintoscano Год назад

Well, they were there since 1509. The Republic of India wasn't in existence until 1950

@user-ur5yg3cx8t Год назад

@@aldrintoscano still they take it and Portuguese can't do anything till this day other than crying

@willevensen7130 Год назад

@@aldrintoscano sure but I think we all know who has a better claim to the territory. The overseas empire? Or the actual country which had its territory stolen?

@user-kt5it6ty9r Год назад

As an Indian, thank you for making a video on this, also one thing you forgot about is that Portugal did send their Navy to respond but Egypt blocked the Suez canal for them because India had supported Egypt in the 1956 Suez crisis

@vivekanand3189 Год назад

As an Indian you should be reporting this video because they are not using an accurate map of India Don't you see ?

@jesseinfinite Год назад

You're an Indian with a Russian name and a communist flag? Sounds really Indian to me

@jirachi-wishmaker9242 Год назад

@@vivekanand3189 . . . No as Indian I am happy that he is showing LoC & LAC

@vivekanand3189 Год назад

@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 showing or giving away there's a difference bro he gave it away and that's not right

@deiansalazar140 Год назад

@@vivekanand3189 It's prior to the annexation of the lands you're discussing so not inaccurate in fact it's great attention to historical detail.

@TonyStark-vx9qz 9 месяцев назад

It is astonishing how many European Colonisers were aiming for India couple of centuries ago just because of the enormous wealth India had.

@th3oryO 9 месяцев назад

Astonishing? Nah. The location as a sea link between europe, africa and china as well as (people) resources made it an obvious target. Add in pre-existing divisions and it was inevitable that someone was going to make an attempt. It had happened before, much of modern India itself had been colonised by Muslim rulers previously.

@TonyStark-vx9qz 9 месяцев назад

@@th3oryO bro learned history from WhatsApp

@knightsnight5929 9 месяцев назад

@@TonyStark-vx9qzJust remind us who built most of the best monuments in India, including the Taj Mahal..... The truth hurts.

@TonyStark-vx9qz 9 месяцев назад

@@knightsnight5929 lol, which monuments are you talking about? Ever heard of ancient Indian temples?

@SomeshNayak-lr8ef 8 месяцев назад

Ancient India temples were much better than Taj Mahal Mughals were barbaric rulers They came from poor nations They killed many Hindus and destroyed many temples @@knightsnight5929

@dayanand570 4 месяца назад

Goa was never leased or sold to Portuguese but it invaded Goa state through force.Sameway India took it back by force.

@rdsc.455 4 месяца назад

India was also like today's Europe and the EU , constituted of many different independently ruled states always fighting against each other. It was during the period of Ashok, Akbar, Aurangzeb and finally Britishers this separate and vast Southern Asian geographical region turned into one and administrated by a single ruler with capital cities as Patna, Delhi, Agra, Calcutta and then finally at Delhi.

@IndibarDutta 25 дней назад

@@rdsc.455So the historical timeline u have given - is basically u wanted to mention that India was , is & will always be a United State!! We don't fight with each other, it's a family matter, but when we need to bash any other country we are extremely together - do you wanna see??

@brevitygreaves2321 21 день назад

India took it "back"?? The Portuguese territory of Goa existed for hundreds of years before the British Raj territory known today as "Republic of India" was formed by the British Parliament. RoIndia learnt from China in 1950 when the Chinese took Tibet by force, and learnt again in 1962 when the RoI lost a major part of Ladakh to the Chinese. And learnt again in 2020...abhi thali aur tali bajao.

@JEEVANMARATHE 12 дней назад

@@brevitygreaves2321goan people majorly speak indian language and they majorly wanted to join india. Portugese wasn't having democratic rule in Goa so just shut up. If you want non democratic place then find one. Don't teach other.

@anengineer152 11 дней назад

@@brevitygreaves2321ye last me what did you write Hindi😅😅

@lordbonney9779 Год назад

Goa: gets invaded Portugal: “Help” UK: “I already knew this would happen. I’m just that experienced.”

@eliteevildarkness5830 Год назад

You don't say invaded you say taken back

@ronanwaring3408 Год назад

To be honest due to the reaction if India had let the UK preside they probably would have gotten Goa anyway

@alexandrearaujo2877 Год назад

@@eliteevildarkness5830 It was still technically an invasion, regardless of whether or not you believe that India had the right to own Goa.

@idkatthispoint-s9s Год назад

@@alexandrearaujo2877 Invasion is taking over someone else's native territory. The Portuguese have never been native to the Indian subcontinent. It's the simple words that twist people's beliefs, India just took back what was rightfully hers. By your logic even India's freedom struggle would be invading British territory.

@TheOmegaXicor Год назад

@@idkatthispoint-s9s no, the disagreement is where India kicks out the invading Portuguese by invading itself, the territory belongs to Goa not India

@boombler4320 Год назад

this channel made me so paranoid about Napoleon appearing in historical events that have nothing to do with him that I half expected him to somehow show up in this episode

@oenrn Год назад

Portugal didn't have the military resources to keep Goa because its empire had started collapsing ever since Brazil went independent in the 1820s, which happened right after the Portuguese Royal Family fled to Brazil in order to escape... that's right, Napoleon! There you go!

@talha7309 Год назад

@oenr Thanks for fueling our paranoia, mate!

@alanpennie8013 Год назад

Napoleon actually commanded The Indian Army at the time.

@boombler4320 Год назад

@@oenrn I am going to paint the ceiling using shotgun

@Jerry-tg7zx Год назад

Ah, americans

@legendnaveendelu7209 3 месяца назад

Because Goa was rightfully ours.

@zanchiso1934 3 месяца назад

Finally could argue with Indian claiming something to them

@user-vb6qf7sg3h 3 месяца назад

If Goa belong to Mainland India then Taiwan belongs to Mainland China too. Just earn 1000 Social Credit. Lol 😂

@Surfer-vi1pm 3 месяца назад

@@user-vb6qf7sg3h Not even the same comparable scenario. Goa is important hindu land forcefully taken and converted Portuguese have no business in goa

@legendnaveendelu7209 2 месяца назад

Umm you're not Indian are you? @@user-vb6qf7sg3h

@user-vb6qf7sg3h 2 месяца назад

@@Surfer-vi1pm USA had no business in Taiwan either just like Portuguese had bo business in Goa. The USA itself identify Taiwan as a part of china . I'm not saying that i support the Communist Party but just to be fair both USA and Portugal and UK are Colonialist , invader and robbers.

@enriqueheredia5794 6 месяцев назад

As a Goan I am glad you covered this historical topic.

@samsmith2635 5 месяцев назад

How do you feel about being Robbed of EU benefits? Since Goa was considered an equal province to any of that back in Portugal?

@crichighlights2531 5 месяцев назад

@@samsmith2635 why Did Britain left EU then?? Secondly You don't have to be in EU to grow your economy. Look at china, South Korea,

@D402S 4 месяца назад

@@samsmith2635Portugal doesn't have any future. It's a stagnant economy. The Indian economy on the other hand is growing well under the leadership of BJP. Western media is too busy watching slumdog millionaire.

@dawn_alex 4 месяца назад

@@samsmith2635 You keep ur shit EU rights for yourself. Noone wants it here bro.

@amanrawat9741 3 месяца назад

@@crichighlights2531 Look at india too

@HDtothe8 Год назад

As a Goan, India invading us has been the best thing for us in more than 400 years. I would implore anyone reading this comment to read 'The Goa Inquisition' Book by Anant Priolkar. The horrific things the Portuguese did to my people in the name of Catholicism will never be forgotten nor forgiven.

@sanketmarkad6924 Год назад

India not invaded but reclaimed back

@Pihu523 Год назад

@@sanketmarkad6924 their dictionary is different.

@vinniche Год назад

It always was part of India. The culture of Goa was always clearly Indian. Invasions first began by Muslims and then Christians. Don't talk as if Goa was an independent country.

@parikshitneb6154 Год назад

India claimed back it's land not invaded Goa please take the reference through the maratha empire

@HDtothe8 Год назад

Don't sweat it guys. I meant "invading" not invading literally. Please read it as such. Cheers.

@heisenstein6392 Год назад

"In a twist that would shock exactly ZERO people, the Indian government wasn't willing to be lectured by their former colonial masters..." Bahaha, you're simply the best history narrator!

@TheVenge. Год назад

Also Because Portugal conducted genocides in Goa slaughtered Hindus destroyed temples, Raped and tortured women just because they were Hindus. Portuguese Christian missionaries and their evil Saint Xavier introduced this concept. Read about the famous goa inquisition holocaust It's horrific and the worst part is europeans knew about it...they let it happen.

@FactStorm Год назад

So true lol

@TheBf666 Год назад

But india can lecture sri lanka on what they should do with their ports? Hush clown.

@theemirofjaffa2266 Год назад

I was actually shocked, so I guess I'm the only one for that matter.

@gadoofy5850 10 месяцев назад

UK: "Hey India can you not invade Goa?" India: "Shut the fuck up"

@RollOnToVictory 9 месяцев назад

Goa is one of the reasons Argentina was sure the international community would force the UK to the negotiation table over the Falklands.

@_tsu_ Месяц назад

But i don't think it's the same thing. Argentina is also a settler colony, just like the Falklands. Just because they choose to be nominally part of the UK doesn't change much.

@diegorodrigovelasquezmeniz8026 2 дня назад

@@_tsu_las Malvinas son Argentinas. Ingleses piratas vayan a sus tierras que sus mujeres están siendo conquistadas por moros, subsaharianos e hindúes.

@vetiarvind 8 месяцев назад

Portugal: UK my old brother, come help me! UK: well young brother, we packed up and left in 1947 for a reason before we were forcibly kicked out, you should have taken some notes.

@ivanmacgar6447 2 месяца назад

Ironically enough Portugal is older than the UK.

@esequieltrindade9244 Месяц назад

Portugal did not started a famine and made a harsh caste system, a lot of goans would flee from goa and into Portugal, and even get their nationality as a portuguese citizen It's a myth that the majority wanted a integration with india, yes, a part of the native society had wanted to join india but they never said that they could not just go to india and have a indian citizenship

@mione12gft71 Месяц назад

@@esequieltrindade9244if the famine you are talking about is the one that happened in world war 2, then the Brits didn't make that one. They in fact helped them. There's Churchill's documents asking for US's help even to counter the famine

@esequieltrindade9244 Месяц назад

@@mione12gft71 they did not burned the crops and killed cattle/farmers, yes, but they indirectly made it happen by negligence and the use of indian resources to the war, yes, the war was important, but stalling the germans in the desert is really worth countless of lives? No. The british asked for all their allies for food, even the colonies, yes, but by the time they solved the issue, the damage had been done

@mione12gft71 Месяц назад

@@esequieltrindade9244 indirectly making something happen and then cutting the war budget (yes, they did that) to send more aid is nowhere as bad as directly working towards a goal whose aim is to genocide Indians

@battleofkursk50 Год назад

“Operation: Cry for Help” went down in military history as one of the most brilliant strategic plans ever.

@dimk735 Год назад

@@MimOzanTamamogullar or the turks for even better results.

@ronmka8931 Год назад

Ukraine is doing that with plenty of success

@thesummergamer7245 Год назад

@@dimk735 bro deleted his comment 💀

@danzoom Год назад

@@ronmka8931 tbf tbe first time it didn't go well for them in 2014. Everybody just kinda forgot.

@thunderbird1921 Год назад

@@ronmka8931 Question is for how long and to what extent though. There's already division among Ukraine's partners about letting Russia have Crimea or not, among other stuff. South Korea in 1950 would be a much better example, since the world apart from the Communists overwhelmingly condemned North Korea's invasion and the UN authorized a large intervention force led by the United States.

@joshuazelinsky5213 Год назад

Worth noting that the response to the invasion of Goa is one of the things that leads to the Falkkands war, because the Argentinian government sees this as evidence that governments would not intervene in situations like this. Of course, the situations were very different. Britain had a large, navy, Argentina was a much weaker country than India, and it was clear to everyone from the start that the population wanted to be British, but Argentina did not realize how serious these differences were until it was too late.

@Iamalemonwhy Год назад

But now Argentina can try

@Progamermove_2003 Год назад

While all of them are valid points, the last point is the most important one. People in Goa wanted to join India, while people in Falkland wanted to stay British.

@South_Asian.Fascist-98 Год назад

@@Iamalemonwhy BRUH 💀

@εγεω Год назад

@@Progamermove_2003 It reminds me a lot of the 2014 Crimea situation and referendum.

@Progamermove_2003 Год назад

@@εγεω You're very clearly applying false analogy. Unlike Ukraine, Portugal was NOT a democracy back then, and not to forget the *brutal* colonial past where thousands of Goans had died in the inquisition among other things. False analogy doesn't work.

@swapnil988 10 месяцев назад

You didn't mention one very important part. There was a resolution in UNSC against Indias military action and the majority voted in favour of the resolution but thanks to Russia that they vetore it and we finally become part of india.

@PeruvianPotato 9 месяцев назад

Just kinda proves how useless the UN is in retrospect

@looinrims 23 дня назад

That resolution wouldn’t have changed anything

@narutoshipuden2440 7 дней назад

Well it was proven again that USA is not an ally, as they are always the first to backstab if you have less value than others

@cinnamonbuns4404 3 месяца назад

You missed the fact that India didn’t just simply randomly decided to use military force. India being India was using negotiations and diplomacy all the way until an Indian fishing boat/trawler was attacked/shot at by the Portuguese in Goa and Indian fishermen died. This was the last straw for India (naturally) of a bunch of Europeans killing Indians on their own soil.

@youtubeuserxix 2 дня назад

They would have attacked at some point, even if no fishermen were shot. Elections were near and Nehru had to do something to become an overnight hero to the Indian people. Look it up.

@AmodShindeDev Год назад

I am from Goa. Goa was a colonized territory and was under the oppression of the Portuguese. There were several revolts within Goa which were later supported by people from all over India. Goa had been part of the Indian subcontinent and hence Indian govt liberated Goa. Later the Portuguese sent Army back to Goa to recapture it, but our good friend Egypt closed the Suez canal and blocked their entry into the eastern oceans

@abygorsonabor7982 Год назад

Hope Goa will be liberated again from Indianization and be it's own state!

@AmodShindeDev Год назад

@@abygorsonabor7982 it's Called liberation when local people are opressed. We aren't opressed under india. India is ours and today Portuguese army won't be able to stand Indian army for even more than 1 day 😂😂

@abygorsonabor7982 Год назад

@@AmodShindeDev yeah, yeah, go Indianize somehwere else

@AmodShindeDev Год назад

@@abygorsonabor7982 yeha sure, but we don't opress people even if we indianize, your UK is already indianized indirectly 😂😂😂

@kyara1835 Год назад

@@abygorsonabor7982 u can keep hoping but we goans are indians.

@YourVintageStick Год назад

“They’d be happy to do that after the heat death of the universe” I love this channels humor

@Lightning7112 Год назад

Same, i love this joke

@thatonejoey1847 Год назад

This channel has the best jokes in its videos, like they are never awful or cringe worthy

@South_Asian.Fascist-98 Год назад

@@thatonejoey1847 true

@Lightning7112 Год назад

@@thatonejoey1847 very true

@YourVintageStick Год назад

@@thatonejoey1847 you right

@meanmachine6173 9 месяцев назад

India behaved like a true chad after getting independence, showed the middle finger to USA and conducted Nuclear tests despite the whole of the west against it. Beat USA's ally Pakistan blue and black in the 1971 war despite threats of attack by the US. Despite being sucked dry by the Britishers, we have come to such a great position today by our resolute decisions of favouring our own Nation rather than trying to please any superpower.

@FelipeJaquez 6 месяцев назад

It only took centuries of foreign rule by literally anyone else with a half decent army since the time of the Indo-Aryans but finally India is a free nation capable of selling itself dry to anyone with money. Beautiful!

@DhruvChanda-vq3hx 4 месяца назад

@@bruhbruh-us6gl jeet means victory so i don't know what you are trying to say

@bruhbruh-us6gl 4 месяца назад

@@DhruvChanda-vq3hx Jeet means you don’t know how to use a toilet

@DhruvChanda-vq3hx 3 месяца назад

@@bruhbruh-us6gl says the guy who wipes his ass with toilet paper and walks around the rest of the day with a crusty ass

@bruhbruh-us6gl 3 месяца назад

@@DhruvChanda-vq3hx LMAO "You clean you ass bro? What a loser, just use your hand lol"

@Tommy_shelby717 9 месяцев назад

I am from goa , I am happy that indian government took back goa

@vastoaspecto 28 дней назад

What language Goa people speak nowadays? I heard that some people in Goa still spoke Portuguese.

@adityapatro4228 22 дня назад

@@vastoaspecto they speak the native language Konkan

@voldebean6055 15 дней назад

Obrigado

@jp_skywalker 9 дней назад

What was the best thing the Indian government did after the Portuguese left? Goa was a barren costal land. It was so barren that even the previous Indian monarchs didn't even bother about this piece of land. It's only after the Portuguese made Goa, an international trade zone that the British and even the Indian's monarchies wanted to take over. Portugal didn't just build a port, they built and layed the foundations of Goan society. They established a bloody civilization. You got to respect and give the Portuguese some merit.

@oddneighbour 2 дня назад

The only thing Portuguese did for goa was religious genocide, there were already forts and naval bases in Goa before the Portugrease came in @@jp_skywalker

@maiholiaw4927 Год назад

Trivia: The Portuguese Prime Minister then, Antonio Salazar, was so upset with his country's surrender that the offered a reward of US$10,000 for the capture of an Indian Brigade commander, Brigadier (Later Lt. General) Sagat Singh, who led the Airborne forces. His photo was posted everywhere in Lisbon, but nobody seemed to care.

@surajpanditexe Год назад

He was member of parachute regiment and he landed first troops in panji (goa capital)

@TheVenge. Год назад

@DurgeshYadav-ip1zr Год назад

Sagat also mogged the Chinese during the 1967 Battle.

@bhavinvasavada4562 Год назад

Interesting....is this the same Sagat Singh who led the airborne heli drop operations in the 1971 Bangladesh liberation war?

@maiholiaw4927 Год назад

@@bhavinvasavada4562 The one and only.

@Guns_Blazin Год назад

Portugal to NATO: “They just invaded our territory. Time to trigger Article 5 right?” NATO: (*read)

@Iamalemonwhy Год назад

What could NATO do lets be real it was India and Soviet Union was friends with India

@nikhilshetty007 Год назад

@@cuddlestsq2730 Read the article 5 again

@braziliantsar Год назад

@@cuddlestsq2730 In the end, NATO works with it's smaller members like CSTO works with Armenia

@okayy6780 Год назад

@@cuddlestsq2730 As a matter of fact, UK and France did send their warships to India, but Egypt blocked them from entering the Suez Canal as Egypt was a friend of India in the NAM.

@brandonlyon730 Год назад

@@okayy6780Why not just go around South Africa then? Sure it's a longer route, but I doubt blocking the suez canal would’ve really stopped their navies from traveling anywhere.

@sagark9427 Месяц назад

Using the words ‘India Annexed Goa’ is by itself western hypocrisy.

@looinrims 23 дня назад

Was it not a separate political entity? (Yes it was, for centuries, a united India isn’t even 100 years old)

@SouradiptaPlays 22 дня назад

@@looinrims true, a united india is not even 100 years old even now.

@RajSingh-yd8ue 21 день назад

@@looinrimsby that logic entire USA is annexed And UK also annexed whales

@looinrims 21 день назад

@@RajSingh-yd8ue …no it’s a verb silly We still use it today in the US for when areas annex land

@CokeFan-ql6vx 18 дней назад

Annex - append or add as an extra or subordinate part

@abps9947 Год назад

Egypt also played a major role by blocking Suez canal for Portugal naval forces

@whitewhite4462 Год назад

Prasant dhawann???

@TheVenge. Год назад

@pranjalpandey2167 Год назад

@@whitewhite4462 I was looking for this comment "

@dibyaraj108 Год назад

I didn't knew that, the present day growing relations with egypt comes more naturally then.

@iteltab8822 Год назад

Also don't forget that indian navy Aircraft carrier was waiting over Goa cost!

@davidhansen5067 Год назад

It's a rare episode that ends like this with "and then everybody got over it and went on with their lives." Edit: LOKI'S DARTS, I'VE NEVER GOTTEN THIS MANY LIKES BEFORE

@Snix121 Год назад

*for now, don't discount the second portugese empire just yet

@NamanSachdeva12 Год назад

Cute

@everettatwater2939 Год назад

@@Snix121 soon the new demographics of Portugal will be Indian.

@feuerwerkisttoll2935 Год назад

You mean like the video why did the world let russia annex ukraine well see in 10-15 years here

@E5rael Год назад

With statements such as these, I always expect him to follow up with the phrase "Fun fact, NO".

@vinayakpatil355 8 месяцев назад

Those who say Portuguese were in Goa to liberate the common, they should learn about it, for instance 'Hatkatro Khaamb in Goa'. There are many such inhumane things about Inquisition of Goa under Portuguese rule.

@bigbulk688 10 месяцев назад

I am Goan, watching this from Goa. Nice summary of things.

@Dendarang Год назад

The reason why NATO didn't respond, btw, isn't just that no one cared, the members are obliged to defend each other to the death regardless of how much they care or not. It was because NATO only applies to member's territories in Europe and North Atlantic and *nowhere else*, so attacking French posessions in the Pacfic, for example, wouldn't trigger NATO Article 5 even today. The one exception to that was French Algeria which was specifically covered by NATO as NATO was drawn up when Algeria was part of France but that's all null and void now since Algerian independence.

@delfinenteddyson9865 Год назад

I wouldn't sat to the death tho: "[...] such action as it deems necessary, including the use of armed force, to restore and maintain the security of the North Atlantic area" good point otherwise

@ElanElanElan Год назад

So if French Guyana was attacked today, Nato wouldn't respond?

@aeroblitzt9561 Год назад

I read somewhere that the territories need to be above the Ecuatorial Line for the treaty to take effect. For example in 1982 when the Argentines invaded the Falklands which were a core British territory the treaty couldn't take effect since it happened below the Ecuator, but when 9/11 happened the treaty took effect cuz NYC is above the Ecautor. Another little tidbit is that if Hawaii is struck by a foreign attack NATO Article 5 doesn't take effect cuz when the alliance was formed in 1949 Hawaii was a U.S. territory and below the Ecuator. EDIT:It appears I have made a mistake. For a country or territory of a member country to be under coverage of NATO article 5 they must be located in Europe and North America and above the Tropic of Cancer.

@drakron Год назад

Nay, NATO sit that out because ... NATO was entirely anti-Soviet no matter what its written on the paper. India was a non-aligned nation, that was game they played so neither block wanted to throw then into the other arms (as Pakistan found out ). Decolonization was still never much in the agenda and it would been very unpopular to aid Portugal to keep a overseas territory that as far people saw it was India (funny enough the current PM of Portugal grandfather is Goan). If India was under the Soviet sphere you can bet NATO response would be different but at it stood what it seem politically as India reclaiming their lands from a colonial power and Portugal being under the Estado Novo dictatorship didnt exactly help, that why the Colonial War was a bit different as NATO looked the other way because of Soviet backed independent movements even if there were western backed.

@Iamalemonwhy Год назад

@@ElanElanElan No.... lets annex french guyana into guyana

@pescavelho6151 Год назад

My mom's former father-in-law was deployed to Goa, he ended up spending some half-a-year in an Indian prison. He made it out of there pretty unscathed, and even brought some curry recipes back to Portugal, so no hard feelings. Also interesting to note that Brazil heavily condemned India's actions in an act of "Lusophone solidarity", but then proceeded to back the rebels in Portugal's African colonies under the same logic. Edit: People seem to think that I am Portugal's spokesperson for some reason. When I say "no hard feelings" I am speaking about how my family doesn't have any resentment towards India due to his imprisonment, I am not implying the Portuguese nation was "wronged" by India or something.

@utkarshchoudhary3870 Год назад

ah yes, Brazil when Portugal

@adamesd3699 Год назад

@@salciano What are you talking about “sole survivors”? This was one of the least bloody invasions in history.

@UnwiseWords Год назад

@@adamesd3699 Least Bloody doesn't mean completly bloodless, it lasted for 2 days after all

@JohnSmith-sl2qc Год назад

@@UnwiseWords only 30 Portuguese soldiers actually died

@kingofcards9516 Год назад

@@JohnSmith-sl2qc quite dismissive of human life there.

@nehagc 6 месяцев назад

Goa was historically belonged to India ...we have thousands year old temples and structures which portugese left while destroying some other.

@jp_skywalker 9 дней назад

😂😂😂 When did the temples pop up? The Portuguese were to first to claim the land. Goa inhabitants were illiterate and didn't belong under an ruling kingdom of India. The potuguese created and built Goa from nothing. Default religion is catholicism. Now don't say forced conversions - cuz many were happy that they got converted plus Portuguese gave them education, religion and culture. temples were built after the Indian Army conquered Goa.

@youtubeuserxix 2 дня назад

@@jp_skywalker Goa was conquered by the Portuguese in 1510 from the Muslim rulers.

@RanjanIsEvil 7 месяцев назад

India just took it back.

@daroraa 17 дней назад

Yay India reclaimed it This video is sooooo misguiding Stilll endless likes shows how unaware or misinformed are people at large

@moblinmajorgeneral Год назад

Britain, wiping a tear from its eye: "Finally, he understands!"

@felicitys3621 Год назад

They grow up so fast… his first invasion…

@dominicguye8058 Год назад

@@felicitys3621 'They grow up so fast'? 'First invasion'? You may want to brush up on your history of European colonialism. . .

@ls200076 Год назад

@@dominicguye8058 you deserve to get smacked by a handsome body builder

@noistivmuestiliv3300 Год назад

@@felicitys3621 Lol! I laughed irl

@karandullet380 Год назад

@@felicitys3621 🤣🤣🤣🤣

@mehularora3234 Год назад

You forgot to mention one thing, During this liberation of Goa Portuguese did sent their Navy but our Egyptian friends blocked them at Suez Canal. Kudos Egyptian boys!

@aniket385 Год назад

Suez Canal is open during Times of War as it is open in times of peace .

@mehularora3234 Год назад

@@aniket385 check it thoroughly what I said.

@godoflight558 Год назад

Yeah egypt did it to return the favour when india helped them during the 50s suez crisis

@FactStorm Год назад

Nice piece of history, thanks for sharing I genuinely didn't know that specific bit.

@ranjittyagi9354 Год назад

Very good. Must remember Egyptians. ❤️

@vishalpachpande5921 Месяц назад

Bro didnt mentioned how the Portuguese killed some of the fishermen of India that the final blow when India invaded

@daroraa 17 дней назад

I would reword it India reclaimed it instead of mentioned by you India invaded

@vishalpachpande5921 17 дней назад

@@daroraa India formed on 15 August 1947. That's why I have written invaded

@dharshdanube6911 16 дней назад

@@daroraaThere was no 'India' when goa was under the Portuguese rule. That's why we use 'invade' and 'annexation'.

@gtanj 9 месяцев назад

India reclaimed Goa.

@shan4680 Год назад

India to Portugal: "Goa way."

@sahilsingh6048 Год назад

This was nice

@TheVenge. Год назад

Also Because Portugal conducted genocides in Goa slaughtered Hindus destroyed temples, Raped and tortured women for centuries just because they were Hindus. Portuguese Christian missionaries and their evil Saint Xavier introduced this concept. Read about the famous goa inquisition holocaust It's horrific and the worst part is europeans knew about it...they let it happen.

@JadesFitnessBucketList 10 месяцев назад

My Dad is one of the last generations of indians to be born and brought up in Goa and speak portuguese as his first language. Born in 1951, number 3 of 11 children. The children born before 1961 (including my dad) were never given an indian passport, but the siblings born after did. Ive been back to Goa to see my family many times and always have fond memories

@hardtrailrider 10 месяцев назад

"The children born before 1961 (including my dad) were never given an indian passport," I guess this is only becuase they were holding Portugese passports. As per Indian law, you cannot have dual citizenship. So people refused to surrender Portugese citizenship were denied Indian passports. Thats all.

@JadesFitnessBucketList 10 месяцев назад

@@hardtrailrider no they didn’t have any passports. At 18 my dad was forced to the Portuguese army because Salazar said anyone who fought would be given Portuguese nationality. That’s how he managed to leave.

@hardtrailrider 10 месяцев назад

@@JadesFitnessBucketListI wonder on what reason he was denied Indian passport.

@mahatmagandhi2434 10 месяцев назад

Old hag

@sanatan_dip 10 месяцев назад

@@hardtrailriderwell they were not given indian passport because they were allowed to have Portugal passport. As many people leaving india today from goa are those people.

@crichighlights2531 4 месяца назад

Love from Goa, India

@phonecianguy 2 месяца назад

india: invade goa portugal: let`s start operation cry for help

@amitabhabhattacharya4051 10 месяцев назад

My father was part of the Indian forces that entered Goa to liberate it. He was in the Indian Air Force. He had just joined 3 years earlier in 1958.

@sayeedalsifat1308 10 месяцев назад

Imagine your dad brought 'Merican "liberty" to Goa 💀

@AoptimisticNihilist 10 месяцев назад

My grandfather( a freedom fighter, I'm a Goan) told me it was the most casual peaceful war. As soon as the British army saw the sheer strength(no of personals) of Indian army they dumped their arms and surrendered and left.

@amitabhabhattacharya4051 10 месяцев назад

Yes. Matches with what my father said. It was more of a stroll in the park with the Indian military encountering little resistance. But a year later came the horrific Chinese aggression. @@AoptimisticNihilist

@jayK914 10 месяцев назад

My Grandfather was also there for Goa liberation. Who knows, Maybe they both were together and were also even friends

@amitabhabhattacharya4051 10 месяцев назад

It was a small military then. Highly possible. He was 24.@@jayK914

@AchyutChaudhary Год назад

0:13 just one error here - the state of Sikkim between 🇳🇵Nepal & 🇧🇹Bhutan (that you’ve made a video about as well) didn’t fully join 🇮🇳India until 1975 - over a decade later.

@South_Asian.Fascist-98 Год назад

It was not a sovereign nation bro

@hanswoast7 Год назад

@@South_Asian.Fascist-98 That sound like another video idea :)

@pranavtripathi791 Год назад

It was still a protectorate

@ashutoshaditya1564 Год назад

1972??

@Senzotan Год назад

Oh, there's a lot more than one.

@jakej2680 5 месяцев назад

When I heard about this I thought "Why in the world would anyone have helped Portugal keep Goa? Why did they even bother asking?". It's hard for me to think of this as some sort of invasion when decolonization had been in full swing for a while at that point. Much stronger countries had relinquished much more valuable possessions to much weaker adversaries, either because of necessity or coercion from the US and the broader global community. Maybe I am getting too realpolitik but it's just ridiculous they expected those same nations to see them as the last straw and start a major war with India. Sorry, Portugal, but decolonization had to happen and to be honest, it's kind of unbelievable your empire held on as long as it did.

@brucelee148 Месяц назад

India was never exist before the British people went there.The British invaded South Asia and make it a country:India.

@pulpinfinity4611 Месяц назад

shut up, you dont know anything about my countries history

@its_jay4357 Месяц назад

How stupid you would be, 🙄 india exists before your Jesus came to life, before 200 bc we had great rulers

@vladof_putler Месяц назад

Greeks called India "India" 3000 years ago.

@learningagain4094 Месяц назад

@@vladof_putler They called it because it was the name of the region. However, the region wasn't united and remained a bunch of separate states. It'd be akin to saying "Africa" is one nation because it has a name.

@909sid Год назад

You forgot to mention Portugal Navi fired at an Indian fishing boat and killed Indian fishermen in response India launched military operation Vijay(victory). Goa was not invaded it was liberated as the local population was already protesting against the colonial suppression and when the Indians army was about to enter Goa PM António de Oliveira Salazar asked Manuel António Vassalo e Silva (Portuguese general in Goa) to burn down everything so India has a hollow victory but Silva loved Goa and decided to not follow orders he was court marshall and sent into exile on his return to Portugal. (Edited: I do not wish to engage in comment wars with anyone be it nationalistic my statement is simple the title Annexation is wrong Goa is a part of land mass that's called Indian subcontinent and a country that is half world away has no right to control/ govern/ colonize it, assimilate sure but calling it their territory no. Same for US, UK France etc I condemn it thanks)

@Xyz04 Год назад

🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓

@Mendaxxx Год назад

From a white mans point of view, if they're invading it's good. If others reclaim it it's bad.

@shubham_the__legend Год назад

Repliers above me are gay

@aaaaaaaa2008-h8z Год назад

nice

@Joesolo13 Год назад

@Chicken Fujiwara 🤡

@yeeet1910 Год назад

All of this could've been prevented if Portugal had asked James Bissionette for help instead

@raestera Год назад

Was looking for this comment not disappointed

@jimtaylor294 Год назад

The Mugwopper would have provided a fleet too ~_^

@ecurewitz Год назад

And Spinning 3 Plates would have most certainly joined in

@haplon33 Год назад

this never would have happened back when boogleywoogley was running things

@AlphaSections Год назад

@@haplon33 God bless boogleywoogley, he knew how to save us from a bad crisis.

@diogofernandes5940 7 месяцев назад

Goa didn't have oil like Kuwait!

@Aneeshh-sy8fz Месяц назад

India reclaimed goa and it was the indian forces who freed goa

@chaoticdays 10 месяцев назад

Many people from Goa wrongly think that the Portuguese weren't as cruel to Indians as the British were. Portugal occupied Indian territory 2 centuries before Britain did and carried out a horrific program called "the Goa Inquisition" for centuries. But by the 1900s, the Portuguese realized that they had very little control over the people of Goa because the rest of the country was strongly revolting against British rule and the Portuguese knew that they would face the same in Goa if they tried to assert their control over the people.

@AoptimisticNihilist 10 месяцев назад

Why are you contradicting yourself! Yes as they absolutely weren't as horrific as British were, on that scale. Of course there were barbaric in early days just like rest of the rulers during 16-17th century

@jayK914 10 месяцев назад

Portugese were even more cruel than British. They committed several atrocities in kerala. They didn't even spare the native Christians (syrian Christians of kerala) and tried to force their european influence on them. They attacked and tortured muslim traders and they blackmailed and tricked and bribed the Hindu rulers of Kerala to be their puppets. Portugese were much worse.

@vatsal7640 10 месяцев назад

Many people also think that previous mughal or hindu rulers weren't cruel. Honestly,even talking about the Indian history is so controversial .

@anisenpai507 10 месяцев назад

@@vatsal7640yeh there were cruel Hindu kings difference os we don't celebrate them Even Ravana was Hindu and Duryodhana was hindu doesn't make them good people we still hate them.

@Bryse0405 9 месяцев назад

I'd disagree. I'm from vasai, also a Portuguese colony with Goa in Mumbai. I've heard from my grandparents, who know it from theirs, that Portuguese were the people who actually helped us. Yes they converted because they thought it was the right religion for the people. But it wasn't forced here, my family was a Hindu at first but most of vasai was converted voluntarily. After the Portuguese were driven out till late 1960s, a certain descendant of Shivaji came here and looted. Well, it was always like this but the Portuguese were helping us. The Marathi king had sent his men over here who looted from us our own lands and made us work in those fields just for us to pay taxes on the crops grown and what not. I'm not making any of this up nor I want to spread hate, just saying what I heard from my grandparents who were actually alive at the time.

@ANIGALYE Год назад

To Foreign European invaders it was only a colony but for India it were their own people & for Goans India was their country. Every 19 December is called as Liberation day in our state and celebrated by all people as remembrance of unification with homeland.

@luisfilipe2023 Год назад

The only invaders were the Indians they were the ones who were foreign. Don’t forget that India wasn’t a country before 1947 so they had no historical claim there or anywhere really. India is an artificial country

@tiagogomes3807 Год назад

Brainwashing works incredibly well. Goanese were healthier and had more rights in the 50s than today. And obviously didn't want to join India.

@gold3084 Год назад

Goa Indians different religion and culture to rest of India ?

@ANIGALYE Год назад

@@gold3084 goan people have same culture as India & its similar to that of Maharashtra

@ANIGALYE Год назад

@@tiagogomes3807 Really it was idea of those who came and settled in goa from Portuguese regime to not let goa join India. Goans were treated as slaves here and by the way not like citizens of their homeland. Many temples were destroyed and people were forced to change religion but it was over when we got freedom.

@kuma.r 3 месяца назад

Portugal- can you help me britain Britain - hey listen india India - SHUT UP Britain - this is on you portugal

@basharmuhammed9550 3 дня назад

All love to the struggling Indian people from the Arab Republic of Egypt We support our brothers in the struggle 🇪🇬🇮🇳

@loading9110 Год назад

I can only imagine Portugal asked for Britain's help in sorting out the problem due to our historic alliance....Because that was a really stupid idea. As if India would care what we had to say about it after what we had done.

@jarzz3601 Год назад

yeah I feel like literally anyone would of made a better mediator unless portugal's objective was just to piss off the Indians

@Progamermove_2003 Год назад

Thanks but don't use the word "we". I am sure that you weren't personally responsible for any of that stuff. Love from India bro.

@miguelpadeiro762 Год назад

That alliance was a joke anyway, remember that one time Britain threatened war on Portugal to get colonial territories in Africa? It kinda did throw us in the rabbit hole that ended up in the backwards dictatorship that clinged to our colonies all the way to 1974

@daeron767 Год назад

Problem was somebody had assassinated Hammarskjold and installed India's buddy the Soviet loving U Thant as the new UN Secretary General ; on top of that the 'Non-Align' bloc that India & Indonesia had just co-sponsored used it's effective veto power to block the attempt by US, UK and France to pass their Security Council motion denouncing India's invasion. Goa was the first and smaller of two nations that got sacrificed in the US/Soviet collaboration to pretend nobody had hi-jacked the UN despite the rather obvious Asian take over.

@heyabowa1871 Год назад

England is the oldest ally of Portugal yet it's also one of the counties that has screwed over Portugal the most.

@lukaszslowakiewicz9395 Год назад

According to Article 6 of NATO an armed attack on one or more of the Parties is deemed to include an armed attack: on the territory of any of the Parties in Europe or North America , on the territory of Turkey or on the Islands under the jurisdiction of any of the Parties in the North Atlantic area north of the Tropic of Cancer. So an attack on Goa or Falkland Islands was not a NATO issue.

@alejandrosotomartin9720 Год назад

It´s not about Article 6. It´s about NATO won´t declare war to a country like India and the UK can defeat Argentina by its own.

@albertoswald8461 Год назад

I believe that you mean Article V. That's where an attack on one country is considered an attack on the whole Alliance. The US is so far the only country to successfully invoke Article V for the September 11th terrorist attacks.

@cyan_oxy6734 Год назад

The territory of turkey sounds like quite the loophole. Turkey could annex Armenia making it territory of turkey and then have it protected by nato, no?

@maxf9291 Год назад

@@cyan_oxy6734Turkey could probably get away with that and a lot more, since all NATO will ever give it is a strongly worded letter. NATO values Turkey way too much for its own good

@taoliu3949 Год назад

@@cyan_oxy6734Its written that way because most of Turkey is not in Europe. That said, the loophole would not work because other articles assumes the parties to abide by the UN Charter. And even if theres still a loophole, there are roundabout ways to say "no". And its highly unlikely any country is going to defend a Turkish act of aggression except maybe against Syria.

@segundacontado_pixel 9 месяцев назад

Egypt: I'm blocking the Suez for my friend India! Vasco Da Game: do you look like i care?

@silverghost5752 9 месяцев назад

Vasco da Gama: Goa is ours.😢 India: OH yeah...come and get it!😅😅

@segundacontado_pixel 9 месяцев назад

you clearly doesnt know vasco da game history.@@silverghost5752

@vms_kt 10 месяцев назад

Yes I did enjoy the video. 😂 the presentation is so good!

@klx6265 Год назад

As far as invasions and invaders go, that was the most polite invasion I've ever heard of. India: "Hey... Listen, can I have a minute? So.. About that piece of land you have colonized.. Yeah, can you give that back please? It would mean a lot." Portugal: "No." India: "Please?" 😢 Portugal: "No." ** India: "Hey, it's been two years, can we please have it back now?" Portugal: "No." India: "Sigh... You KNOW I hate doing this right? Jfc no good deed goes unpunished huh?" ** Portugal: "A'ight imma head out." 😒

@SpiderSid007 Год назад

I'm still surprised that they waited two years.

@anantamohanty1035 Год назад

@@SpiderSid007 we like to take our time

@SpiderSid007 Год назад

@@anantamohanty1035 Sad but true. 😔

@M1551NGN0 Год назад

People really be exploiting someone's docility

@irenerayne7332 Год назад

Not invades it's rightfully taken back Would u talk the same bout India's freedom struggle cmon

@satoshiketchump Год назад

Not only Goa but there were smaller territories called Diu & Daman and Dadra & Nagar Haveli. These still exist as Union Territories while the much larger Goa, understandably, became a State.

@induchopra3014 Год назад

Indias land hijacked by Portuguese. How are these Portuguese. Is Portugal in asia?

@dhruvmakwana8560 Год назад

Yep,I live in daman

@lobo981 Год назад

I wish we were a different country ...small and beautiful one ..

@JEEVANMARATHE Год назад

@@lobo981 only because of india, goans are independent and out of brutal prortugal regime... that's why having one great nation is important... India take over by Europeans in first place because of this mentality only.

@utkarshtiwari5584 Год назад

@@lobo981 wo hindi mei ek kahawat hai, jisko jitna zyada mil jata hai, usko wo utna hi kam laga rahta hai, 10 doge to 100 chahiye, 100 to hazaar, aapka wahi haal hai...

@Harutayuuso 2 месяца назад

They just killed 2 fishermen and this was the last nail in the coffin

@pradyumnbhatt6187 10 месяцев назад

The Portuguese were the first Europeans to take land in India by firing their cannons from their ships in the 1500s and were the last Europeans to leave India in the 1960s being fired upon by Indian Navy ships.

@StevenEveral Год назад

The Portuguese idea of "Pluricontinentalism" definitely was a strange one. It was an attempt by the Estado Novo regime to incorporate its overseas colonies like Angola, Mozambique, Macau, Goa, and even East Timor as "essential" parts of the nation of Portugal. This idea mostly died off with the Carnation Revolution of 1975.

@alanpennie Год назад

France did the same with some though not all of its colonies and still has nearly 1 million citizens in overseas departments.

@dominicguye8058 Год назад

I don't think it was strange for that reason at least

@heyabowa1871 Год назад

It isn't strange at all. What is strange is to treat your citizens differently depending on what part of your country they live in. I guess those are just the differences between a Catholic empire and a predatory Protestant empire.

@harrypadarri6349 Год назад

@@heyabowa1871 Well, it is weird if you consider that Portugal was an colonial empire with a rather small population. And it was a far-right dictatorship. So you had all power centralised in the capital of a small country that ruled over colonies around the globe. It is far from treating all citizens equally when all the political decisions are made by a small group of people in Europe. The people in the colonies had no say in what their future would be. French Algeria was similar in that the French empire tried to forcefully assimilate the country. That’s also a huge difference if you compare it to French-Guyana. If the people in an overseas territory overwhelmingly demand to decide their own fate it would simply be subjugation. Where that’s not the case making everyone citizens is actually a step towards equality. Don’t get me wrong: I think that nowadays in most cases solutions based on compromises and autonomy are better. But when looking at that time period we’re talking about the age of decolonisation.

@heyabowa1871 Год назад

@@harrypadarri6349 The european parts of these empires didn't have any more power than the "colonies" you speak of. A citizen born in Lima was as Spanish as one born in Sevilla, regardless of ethnic origin. Portugal's capital was once Rio de Janeiro, even. And we didn't wipe out the original population for ethnic and political reasons like the English did.

@connorgolden4 Год назад

A question I’ve occasionally asked but never gotten an answer for.

@chevyjd2007 Год назад

The question I've never gotten was why did the coalition exile Napoleon twice instead of just killing him?

@GJMEGA1 Год назад

@@chevyjd2007 Back then, seemingly no matter what, you just didn't kill heads of state. That's partly, I think, due to the fact that everyone in power knew that one disastrous war would be all it took for THEM to go to the chopping block so it was best just to settle everything with a nice cozy exile. Just in case. Also, part of the reason the Coalitions formed was because the French killed Louis XVI so there was a bit of a public image to uphold. Although nations usually don't care too much about being proven hypocrites this plus the other reason I gave probably tipped the scales. Finally, after his second defeat he was pretty much done in French politics, so even if he somehow came back, which since they put him much farther away wasn't going to happen, he wouldn't be able to rally enough support to threaten the status quo again.

@Progamermove_2003 Год назад

@@GJMEGA1 And not to forget that a living person does not make a good martyr.

@GJMEGA1 Год назад

@@Progamermove_2003 True, very true.

@shapexon3322 Год назад

@@chevyjd2007 Didn't want to make a martyr

@ItsVasl 9 месяцев назад

really good video, thanks!

@vidyutdevam9204 10 месяцев назад

Excuse me. India didn’t annex Goa. Portugal annexed goa. India liberated Goa and since then Goa is part of India as it used to be since eons.

@InquisitiveYouTube Год назад

If I were Portugal, I would have packed up and left in 1947 with at least some of my dignity intact instead of being thrown out. Lol. Love present day Portugal... beautiful country. I hope to Goa there to visit some day. ;)

@MikoyanGurevichMiG21 Год назад

At least they were less stubborn for Goa than Angola

@thechosenone1533 Год назад

@@MikoyanGurevichMiG21 They were equally stubborn for both. Goa was over quickly because the Indian army had such numerical supremacy that even thinking about fighting was suicide. The local garrison surrendered quickly.

@MikoyanGurevichMiG21 Год назад

@@thechosenone1533 yeah, that's true

@yakov95000 Год назад

If there is a thing you can undoubtedly say on the Iberians(both Spanish and Portuguese)is they are probably(historically atleast)the most stubborn people on this earth(just watch the Portuguese/Ottoman wars),I mean they had 700 year old total war against the Muslims on their land if I remember correctly.

@brendonfernandes2877 Год назад

@@MikoyanGurevichMiG21 They knew they couldn't win a war with India so the government in Portugal commanded the governer in Goa to scorch earth and destroy everything so there would be nothing much left for India. He was to blow up the churches and destroy all the big infrastructure. However he decided not to obey the order and on his return to Portugal he was arrested, stripped of all his titles and lands and was exiled from Portugal. He was finally pardoned after the fall of the regime. He visited Goa later on and he was given a warm welcome for disobeying his orders to fight till the last man standing.

@aagamshah4720 Год назад

India still wanted to go diplomatically on the Goa topic, until the Portugese opened fire on an Indian Boat and a fisherman died because of that. After that India took the initiative of the Annexation.

@Xyz04 Год назад

Another 🤓

@prodigyy505 Год назад

@@Xyz04 you nerd reacting to everything that is dissenting your views. Choid demeanour , instead of shitting around give a coherent rebuttal.

@Xyz04 Год назад

@@prodigyy505 you're the only guy 💩💩 here 🤣🤣 your reaction is two ruppee

@prodigyy505 Год назад

@@Xyz04 replied under 2 minutes, I can deduce how lonely and unemployed you are. Augmenting to that if my reactions are making ₹2 then im up for money making.

@Xyz04 Год назад

@@prodigyy505 you also reply under 2 min you also unemployed you also lonely 🤣🤣🤣🤣 I make $5 more than you every second . 🤣🤣

@NirajSopariwala 10 месяцев назад

Good informative video. Only one correction needed: India did not invade Goa. It claimed back the territory which was colonized by a European country.

@shubhamtiwari6608 2 дня назад

India didn't annexed the Goa, we just took it back

@dkpandey1996 Год назад

We see it more as reclaiming a piece of our territory that had been colonised by an overseas power for over 400 years, thank you very much.

@marcelldavis4809 Год назад

I think this is one of the reasons why nobody wanted to react to the invasion. Everyone knew that Goa actually belonged to India, even though they might not have admitted it for diplomatic reasons. It's similar to the international lack of support for Rhodesia when it declared independence from Britain. Most People in Europe realised that the age of colonialism was over that it was wrong to keep the land taken from the natives.

@dkpandey1996 Год назад

@robertolang9684 I should point out that there was not a war but rather a political struggle, and it hardly fazed the British in my opinion. The aftermath of WW2 was the main reason why Britain gave up it's colonies in Africa and Asia over the next 10-15 years. It was becoming economically and militarily difficult to keep control over most of the colonies.

@adityamuley87 Год назад

@@dkpandey1996 you are forgetting the Indian national army and the very real threat of british Indian army mutiny at the end of world War 2 that prompted the british to yeet out of India

@TheVenge. Год назад

@paradoxaddict8978 Год назад

and now goans want to become portugese citizens because portugal is better

@Theology.101 Год назад

“Hey! Don’t change the Borders! Ever!” “I mean maybe sometimes…”

@TheWaynester101 Год назад

just a litte bit… like … maybe a nibble…. *nibbles territory* mmmmm yeah mmm just like that mmmmm let me nibble your territory

@DrewPicklesTheDark Год назад

Due to human nature, I can't see a world where borders stop changing/are removed.

@TheVenge. Год назад

@ankughosh553 Месяц назад

The content creator ignorantly showd wrong map of India throughout the video.

@SouradiptaPlays 22 дня назад

It is 100% correct from a neutral point of view.

@nompuehuenu 6 месяцев назад

it still shocks me that some countries [cough cough united states] would lecture India because of their so-called "hypocrisy" of wanting to free the indian colonies after, you know, they decided colonialism was bad. portugal wasn't budging, pacifism wouldn't do anything. so freedom is only valid for certain people?

@sudhanshudhatrak7928 Год назад

India literally went against NATO without any plan to counter ! This needs some serious balls ! I've been to Goa atleast 3 times it's an absolute paradise ! Love Goa - Live Long India PS : Use the correct map of India next time

@praveendixit.parambhattaraka Год назад

Nehru’s idealism hardly had any plans for International relations of India… he always wished “it would happen”… in rare cases he was right

@vaskarghosh8543 Год назад

Not any plan ?? did you miss that part about statement of kruschev? Nehru had the backing of soviets

@unitycatalog Год назад

Goa is a $hithole😂

@indianlad23 Год назад

@@praveendixit.parambhattaraka True. Goa was a fluke.

@cijoykjose Год назад

Because then we had Soviet Union. If it was today, the scenario would have been different.

@miketacos9034 Год назад

Portugal: “I’m gonna lose my empire in India!” Britain: “Ya don’t say.”

@TheBluePhoenix008 22 дня назад

I didn't even know we annexed Goa. It's literally not even mentioned in our books.

@shivrajgujar1 27 дней назад

Portuguese from Europe occupied Indian Goa from the Adilshah of Bijapur, Bhonsles of Sawantwadi and Nayakas of Sonda. "India liberated Indian Goa from Portugal"✅

@nirmalpai 10 месяцев назад

I'm Goan and my grandfather was a freedom fighter who fought for Goa liberation so that it could join India. The brutalities and disgusting stories of conversions has left deep impact on the people. Infact the indo-portugal relations were sour until few years ago which was because of the fact the Portugal considered Goa to be their own territory. The forced conversions and looting led to a dark phase in Goan history. To give a historical background, Goa was majorly populated my Hindus. When the Portugese destruction was beyond humanity, the Hindus took their idols of lords and moved to Mangalore(city in neighbouring state)to protect themselves from forced conversions and in the process they left everything else behind. The Portuguese imposed heavy taxes and made their own people flee away. My cousin once told me that one day there were 100+ conversions done overnight where the newly wed Hindu grooms were killed and their brides were forced to remarry a catholic. Goa has always been a part of India even before British, Dutch and the Portugese invasion. It was just a matter of time and anger of goans that It would be reunited with India again. Edit: To this day, 19 December is celebrated every year as 'Goa Liberation Day'.

@karthiknaik3944 10 месяцев назад

@nirmalpai Nice to see a fellow Mangalorean GSB on here. This video ought to be reported

@karthiknaik3944 10 месяцев назад

@@nirmalpai exactly! History talks about everyone except us GSBs

@JayK47a 9 месяцев назад

Idk why christianity and islam are like this , they forcfully want to convert everyone :((( . Theres no humanity left anymore , ive lost faith .

@jpb2366 9 месяцев назад

indians are very susceptible to propaganda..

@NativeVsColonial 9 месяцев назад

The Goa Inquisition was brutally barbaric

@scott3017 Год назад

If I remember correctly, the mutual defense clause of NATO only applies to territories in the North Atlantic region, so they were only under obligation to defend portugal proper and it's Atlantic islands.

@SundarSrinivasHarish Год назад

As explained in the video, Portugal at the time did not distinguish between Portugal proper and its overseas territories. Of course, NATO was not obligated to take the same view as Portugal.

@user-uy2dp1dh4h Год назад

Hey I had a question, so why did Nato back the USA in Iraq and Afghanastin if their not in the European continent? Wouldn't that be a breach in the treaty or do they just bend the rules as they see fit as usual.

@scott3017 Год назад

@@user-uy2dp1dh4h good question. First, nato intervened in Afghanistan as a direct result of the September 11th terrorist attacks. North America is covered under the treaty. In fact its the only time article 5 guaranteeing collective defense was invoked. Nato, however, was not involved in Iraq. That was just the US, UK, and a couple other nations acting in their own defensive interests.

@GuyAWhite-rk3se Год назад

NATO only exists to antagonize Russia and now China

@aralbrec Год назад

@@user-uy2dp1dh4h No one breaks the rules. In fact a lot of the world seems to think actions by states who happen to be members of NATO are NATO actions. They are not. The only time article 5 was invoked is after the terrorist attack on the US on Sep 11. That led to the invasion of Afghanistan and the follow up UN-endorsed mission to establish a stable democratic state in Afghanistan. (As an aside for the particular case of GOA, NATO article 5 is worded in a way that excludes colonial territories because most of the alliance was not interested in defending colonialism which was a dying remnant of the 19th century). The first Iraq War to expel Iraq from Kuwait was widely supported and included demands by the UN for Iraq to withdraw. Again, nothing to do with NATO although many NATO member states were involved. The second Iraq War also had nothing to do with NATO and this time the majority of NATO countries opposed it. This led to politics in the US which talked about the "new Europe" and the "old Europe" -- the old meaning NATO members opposed to the war and the new meaning countries (following the collapse of the USSR) seeking to join NATO for protection from Russia which the US tried to portray as the future of Europe. The new were oft motivated by proving their readiness for membership.

@surudog4929 9 месяцев назад

India didn’t annex Goa. They kicked out the occupier colonialist.

@user-rb2zb8tx3k 28 дней назад

exactly

@jayantsolao4281 3 месяца назад

let me give a clarification , GOA was an Indian territory before it was taken by Portugal army .

@sanketk3155 Год назад

I am amazed, even after losing battle westerns be like "It's we who allowed you to win against us, you couldn't've done it on own".

@विचित्रलड़का Год назад

Everything starts from them and end at them

@HighAdmiral Год назад

That's because you couldn't. Think about it while we eat cow beef.

@titanpredator9806 Год назад

@The Admiral oh no u didnt-

@dubstepXpower Год назад

I mean it's not wrong. India wasn't really a superpower at the time.

@deepaparakkal4241 Год назад

@@HighAdmiral ?

@Sail0rIo Год назад

I had a friend whose parents were young adults during the annexation and his father told the story that his family had packed up to leave during the invasion to get on the boats the Portuguese provided but they heard of a plan to blow up the bridges so they just went back home and it was basically over the next day. The jewel of the Portuguese empire for 450 years gone in a whimper.

@airl10 Год назад

Wouldn't the jewel of the Portuguese empire be Angola, Mozambique, or those two as a whole?

@nm7358 Год назад

@@airl10 No, it was Goa, Diu, and Macao.

@bebedor_de_cafe3272 Год назад

@@airl10 Brazil

@bebedor_de_cafe3272 Год назад

@@nm7358 the jewel was Brazil

@B3RyL Год назад

It's like it had just... goaned away. I'll see myself out.

@cccc2740 10 месяцев назад

By that logic, why india annexed India from britain

@amratanshsaini1591 6 месяцев назад

India didn't annex goa it liberated goa from 450 years of brutal colonial rule... please change the title of your video

@prateeksharma6706 4 месяца назад

Annex is a nuetral term

@zap3231 Год назад

Portugal: The first, last, and longest colonial empire in history. From 1415 to 1999.

@genghiskhansbabymomma5649 Год назад

France is pretty far from tahiti ngl

@Bibbedibob Год назад

Not last since France still has colonies

@Maia_Cyclist Год назад

@@Bibbedibob they still need a century to overtake us

@cazwalt9013 Год назад

@@Bibbedibob all those places are part of France and aren't colonies

@ilovebatata19 Год назад

@@Bibbedibob french overseas territories aren't to be considered colonies as of now

@DodoLP Год назад

"india marched their army in the territory of western european nation" -> territory on the other side of the world lmao

@domenicosilva9074 9 месяцев назад

During the internment of the Portuguese prisoners of war at various camps around Goa, the prisoners were visited by large numbers of Goans-described by Captain Azeredo as "Goan friends, acquaintances, or simply anonymous persons"-who offered the internees cigarettes, biscuits, tea, medicines and money. This surprised the Indian military authorities, who first limited the visits to twice a week, and then only to representatives of the Red Cross.

@rajeevajgaonkar4152 3 месяца назад

Apparently they had blood relations. The one bad aspect of imperial colonisation.

@faisalkhan0158 10 месяцев назад

It was not an annexation it was the liberation of Goa

@WorldWide_Dom Год назад

India: Invades Goa without any major consequences Argentina: .....Is it possible to learn this power!! Falkland Island: ...........

@alessandrocerioli2151 Год назад

It is juat a matter of balance of powers: the Argentinian army could not compete with the British Army, and Goa could not be defended by the weak Portuguese empire in front of hundred of thousand Indian soldiers.

@realzhella6817 Год назад

How do u even compare the argentine army with the indian army? There's levels to this and they ain't even on the same playing field. Britian was going to run right through argentina at falklands but Britain nor Portugal would not stand a chance against the Indians in goa

@vaibhavgupta9934 Год назад

Definitely India will support Argentina in future...currently India is going through major reforms in every sector..once we reach 10 tillion$ mark..geopolitics will change lot after it

@alessandrocerioli2151 Год назад

@@vaibhavgupta9934 i like fanatism of Indian fascio-nationalists and their wet dreams

@chrismathewjoseph1283 Год назад

Bruh, the problem is the Falklands r occupied by Bri'ish settlers.... Goa is basically Indian in every definition, except many Portuguese settlers did mix with the locals, but the sheer size of the population made that very irrelevant.... The inhabitants play a big role in such circumstances...

@harishk2947 2 дня назад

Goa is an integral part of Bharath. Portuguese illegally occupied it which they had to leave

@saurabhchauhan4392 18 часов назад

Why the hell is always shown a wrong map of India in almost everywhere?

@kingace6186 Год назад

At least, India went through the diplomatic route for as long as it could before conquering it back. I didn't know about this historical event. Little-known-history matters!

@tiagogomes3807 Год назад

Invading. You conquer back what was yours and Goa had never been parte of India until they invaded.

@YinYanUzumaki Год назад

@@tiagogomes3807 So Goa was part of Portugal then ? By your logic India was never a part of India since they were actually British colony ? White people dont get understand logic ,do they ?

@prodigyy505 Год назад

@@tiagogomes3807 Goa was not a part of India?

@tiagogomes3807 Год назад

@@prodigyy505 no. India was only a country, a single entity after the independence from Britain. So Goa was never part of India until they invaded it in the 60s.

@prodigyy505 Год назад

@@tiagogomes3807 Sorry but later to the India’s independence Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel managed to reunify and amalgamate all the 550 princely states and the states under the British colonial rule to form a distinct nation.

@dr.batman2530 Год назад

You missed Dadra and Nagar Haveli. They were tiny Portuguese enclaves surrounded by Indian state of Gujarat. Being landlocked, they were in a dire situation when India imposed the blockade of Estado Português da Índia. The case went to International Court of Justice and they implicitly recognised Portuguese claim while declaring that Portugal had the right of passage between it's territories. But they did rule that India had not broken any law by blocking military movements between territories. Soon, in 1954, a co-ordinated group of Left wing communists and Right wing Hindu nationalists (yes, they worked together) stormed the Portuguese police station, assassinated the Police inspector, and hoised the Indian flag. Dadra and Nagar Haveli became a de-facto Indian territory. But funny enough, India herself did not recognise the annexation de jure, owing to the ICJ verdict, and subsequently officially annexed it only in 1961 after making a Constitutional amendment. Indian constitution makes annexations legal and requires amendments before annexing any territory. In 1961 such amendment was made. Till then Dadra and Nagar Haveli was a de jure unrecognised independent state, while being de-facto run by Indians. The last time such a constitutional amendment to add a territory to India was made in 1975 when Kingdom of Sikkim was annexed after a Referendum.

@lxportugal9343 Год назад

" *The last time such a constitutional amendment to add a territory to India was made in 1975 when Kingdom of Sikkim was annexed after a Referendum* " I wonder why India didn't make a referendum in Goa??? He says Goans wanted to join India so what would be the problem? Mmmmh I'm very curious to know

@dr.batman2530 Год назад

@@lxportugal9343 there was a referendum BTW in 1967. But on the status of Goa whether they wanted to stay as a Union territory (federal subjects directly ruled by Indian Central government) or join adjacent State of Maharashtra. Goans voted to stay as a seperate Union territory. Goa was made a state in 1980s. Voter turnout was 81%. So yes, Goans, by implication voted to stay in India, going by voter turnout itself. They literally chose for 2 decades to stay under the rule of India's federal/central government. Go ahead. Cry some more.

@no_more_spamplease5121 Год назад

What happened to the king of Sikkim after annexation?

@dr.batman2530 Год назад

@@no_more_spamplease5121 He attempted suicide but was airlifted to Kolkata. Few years later, he soon died of cancer nonetheless. His American wife, the last Queen of Sikkim, now lives in US.

@dr.batman2530 Год назад

@@no_more_spamplease5121 A fun fact about the monarch. He had funded the Academy award winning Indian director Satyajit Ray to make a documentary on Sikkim in early 1970s. India had banned the documentary after annexation and it was lifted only like 10 years back.

@huskaroar6869 21 день назад

And thats not the proper map of india. Kashmir is part of india . Cutting out a large part of India is just so wrong

@piyushwinner 22 дня назад

The map is wrong wtf

@PearlHarbor1941 4 месяца назад

Contemporary historians at this point has pretty much come to the conclusion that India only went through with the invasion because James bizonete refused Portuguese monetary aid, if they had received that aid then the invasion would have been far more difficult

@nandanparalikar3043 Год назад

In India we celebrate 19 December every year as 'Goa Liberation Day'

@footballfan7023 Год назад

lol no one celebrates.dont talk out of your ass

@TheVenge. Год назад

@DatBoi_TheGudBIAS Год назад

Can u invade us and let us take u as well? I want a free holiday too :(

@historicallegends3702 Год назад

Based

@manny2themaxxx333 Год назад

India: "Get out of our country" Portugal: "Excuse me? this is Portugal" India: "My army says it's ours so leave" Portugal: "Yeah well we have NATO" NATO: *Crickets*

@mysticondeflamme Год назад

Pamjeets go brrr

@sahilsingh6048 Год назад

@@mysticondeflamme Peshawar💥💥💥💥💥

@Iamalemonwhy Год назад

@@mysticondeflamme Ola uber boom

@Progamermove_2003 Год назад

Portugal: "Excuse me? This is Portugal" Goans: "But we consider ourselves as Indians, and you are the brutal colonial oppressers who killed thousands of our people in the inquisition among other things!" Portuguese leadership:"But the facts doesn't matter!"

@jimtaylor294 Год назад

^ ""facts""

@dineshkamath7461 21 день назад

Dont display wrong map of India

@MrGrey2727 7 месяцев назад

So India decided to end imperialism… by being imperialists themselves. Interesting

@prateeksharma6706 4 месяца назад

We goans fought of our freedom

@HimanshuThakuria-FunLife Месяц назад

do you think every military action is an imperialism.

@PurooRoy Год назад

Goa is the living proof that Jawaharlal Nehru could have easily saved Kashmir from Pakistan if UN hadn't intervened.

@muditragrawal Год назад

Goa was liberated in 2 days whereas Indian army fought in Kashmir for 15 months before the ceasefire was declared .. POK was more easily accessible from Pakistan's side than Indian, and they had dug in defensive positions, which were not easy to uproot.