Тёмный

Why do prime numbers make these spirals? | Dirichlet’s theorem and pi approximations 

3Blue1Brown
Подписаться 6 млн
Просмотров 6 млн
50% 1

A curious pattern, approximations for pi, and prime distributions.
Help fund future projects: / 3blue1brown
An equally valuable form of support is to simply share some of the videos.
Special thanks to these supporters: 3b1b.co/spiral-thanks
Based on this Math Stack Exchange post:
math.stackexchange.com/questi...
Want to learn more about rational approximations? See this Mathologer video.
• Infinite fractions and...
Also, if you haven't heard of Ulam Spirals, you may enjoy this Numberphile video:
• Prime Spirals - Number...
Dirichlet's paper:
arxiv.org/pdf/0808.1408.pdf
Timestamps:
0:00 - The spiral mystery
3:35 - Non-prime spirals
6:10 - Residue classes
7:20 - Why the galactic spirals
9:30 - Euler’s totient function
10:28 - The larger scale
14:45 - Dirichlet’s theorem
20:26 - Why care?
Corrections:
18:30: In the video, I say that Dirichlet showed that the primes are equally distributed among allowable residue classes, but this is not historically accurate. (By "allowable", here, I mean a residue class whose elements are coprime to the modulus, as described in the video). What he actually showed is that the sum of the reciprocals of all primes in a given allowable residue class diverges, which proves that there are infinitely many primes in such a sequence.
Dirichlet observed this equal distribution numerically and noted this in his paper, but it wasn't until decades later that this fact was properly proved, as it required building on some of the work of Riemann in his famous 1859 paper. If I'm not mistaken, I think it wasn't until Vallée Poussin in (1899), with a version of the prime number theorem for residue classes like this, but I could be wrong there.
In many ways, this was a very silly error for me to have let through. It is true that this result was proven with heavy use of complex analysis, and in fact, it's in a complex analysis lecture that I remember first learning about it. But of course, this would have to have happened after Dirichlet because it would have to have happened after Riemann!
My apologies for the mistake. If you notice factual errors in videos that are not already mentioned in the video's description or pinned comment, don't hesitate to let me know.
Thanks to these viewers for their contributions to translations
Hebrew: Omer Tuchfeld
------------------
These animations are largely made using manim, a scrappy open-source python library: github.com/3b1b/manim
If you want to check it out, I feel compelled to warn you that it's not the most well-documented tool, and it has many other quirks you might expect in a library someone wrote with only their own use in mind.
Music by Vincent Rubinetti.
Download the music on Bandcamp:
vincerubinetti.bandcamp.com/a...
Stream the music on Spotify:
open.spotify.com/album/1dVyjw...
If you want to contribute translated subtitles or to help review those that have already been made by others and need approval, you can click the gear icon in the video and go to subtitles/cc, then "add subtitles/cc". I really appreciate those who do this, as it helps make the lessons accessible to more people.
------------------
3blue1brown is a channel about animating math, in all senses of the word animate. And you know the drill with RU-vid, if you want to stay posted on new videos, subscribe: 3b1b.co/subscribe
Various social media stuffs:
Website: www.3blue1brown.com
Twitter: / 3blue1brown
Reddit: / 3blue1brown
Instagram: / 3blue1brown_animations
Patreon: / 3blue1brown
Facebook: / 3blue1brown

Опубликовано:

 

19 май 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 6 тыс.   
@Supertimegamingify
@Supertimegamingify 3 года назад
It's clearly not pointless, I mean, look at all of those dots!
@samuelbarham8483
@samuelbarham8483 3 года назад
I feel this comment is underrated.
@aryankumarprasad1574
@aryankumarprasad1574 3 года назад
@@juhonuorala3512 That's a nice line.
@user-oc7mk7qe6k
@user-oc7mk7qe6k 3 года назад
lmfao
@cordongrouch9323
@cordongrouch9323 3 года назад
But even a dot has an inside and an outside. Of course, that is not the point of zero dimensions.
@minecrafting_il
@minecrafting_il 3 года назад
you now have 0 likes in 8 bit systems.
@ktu6133
@ktu6133 4 года назад
At this point, the word “beautiful” isn’t even enough to describe the sheer elegance and clarity of these videos. Amazing as always.
@petemurphy7164
@petemurphy7164 4 года назад
Yep!!!
@DoloresUmbridgeairsoft
@DoloresUmbridgeairsoft 4 года назад
i was just about to say beautiful
@shitalsavekar7757
@shitalsavekar7757 4 года назад
Couldn't agree more!!!
@STriderFIN77
@STriderFIN77 4 года назад
also Amazingk!!
@jalilcompaore
@jalilcompaore 4 года назад
How about bootyful?
@bendahou3778
@bendahou3778 2 года назад
As a maths lover, proving a theorem before you knew it existed is undeniably the best feeling I would ever experience
@DonkoXI
@DonkoXI 10 месяцев назад
It's funny how the things you enjoy change when they become your job. For me as a mathematician, proving a theorem only to find out it's already been proven is frustrating. It's not entirely bad, because at least the fact that it's been done already means your proof (probably) isn't wrong. You also walk out of it understanding things very well, so it's not a waste of time. It's just frustrating that you can't turn your work into a paper (unless your proof is very different, in which case it's sometimes still worth publishing).
@aureliontroll2341
@aureliontroll2341 10 месяцев назад
I remenber when i make the area formula for the diagonal of a square based on its side ( diagonal = sqrt of 2 Side) when i was at high school learning sen and cos , i was so freaking happy that i made a formula that give the awnser for common problems. Only to discover a year (?)later that that formula already exists.
@AwakeAgainAtLast
@AwakeAgainAtLast 10 месяцев назад
Math is already plural. You don't need to add an s to say "maths", it's redundant.
@DonkoXI
@DonkoXI 10 месяцев назад
@@AwakeAgainAtLast This is true in American English, but the convention is different in other countries. It's not a mistake, it's just a regional difference.
@Solutra
@Solutra 9 месяцев назад
@@AwakeAgainAtLast woke up on the wrong side of the bed?
@ralphengland8559
@ralphengland8559 2 года назад
My favorite approximation for pi is 977/311 because both numbers are themselves prime and have analogous locations when typed out on a standard number pad.
@lucasb.bahadir7433
@lucasb.bahadir7433 9 месяцев назад
That's actually really cool
@guilhermeottoni1367
@guilhermeottoni1367 5 месяцев назад
Mine is always when you calculate (355+22)/(113+7) = 377/120 = 3.14166666... The repeating part has only one digit.
@semen_tv8478
@semen_tv8478 5 месяцев назад
977-311=666
@JrgenHelland00
@JrgenHelland00 5 месяцев назад
@@guilhermeottoni1367 at that point, why not just write 3.1416? The rest of the sixes only take you further from the true constant while also being more key presses and a division.
@baukepoelsma
@baukepoelsma 5 месяцев назад
That's the most nerdy thing i ever heard anyone say, and i like it. The 977-311=666 makes it even better xD
@arpandhatt6011
@arpandhatt6011 4 года назад
3Blue1Brown: Zooming out RU-vid Compression: Dies
@SARGAMESH
@SARGAMESH 4 года назад
@3blue1brown What an amazing video would it be if you found out how the nature of these primes shown on screen interact with the compression algorithm meta-ly to the video causing the algo to glitch out like that
@arpandhatt6011
@arpandhatt6011 4 года назад
@@SARGAMESH The reason why the video “glitches” when he zooms is that the video has a certain maximum bitrate. RU-vid’s compression algorithm will not update pixels that don’t change. That saves bandwidth. However, when too much stuff is changing it has to reduce the resolution. There’s an amazing video on this. Google “tom scott youtube compression”. His video title is something about snow/confetti.
@the.abhiram.r
@the.abhiram.r 4 года назад
Arpan Dhatt mkbhd proved it with his 1000 upload test
@Gabriel-sq6vy
@Gabriel-sq6vy 4 года назад
@@arpandhatt6011 Not to mention aliasing, which you'll unavoidably have at that kind of graphics
@HermanWillems
@HermanWillems 4 года назад
They should make the compression based on prime numbers, maybe that will specificly make this video better. But anyway, C++ is better than Rust. Just want to let you know aswell.
@avimohan6594
@avimohan6594 4 года назад
"I had never heard this before but I find it too delightful not to tell." This dude's love for teaching is *SO OBVIOUS* and deep and genuine. Every video is made with special care and I won't be surprised if he edits each lesson about 20 times before uploading to get it just right. The *delight* is *ours,* Sensei.
@chuksjr.1440
@chuksjr.1440 4 года назад
Your reply is so apt and true. I want to teach like him.
@CptPatch
@CptPatch 4 года назад
I've been working through the lectures he did for Khan Academy for multivariable calculus and he just has an amazing method of conveying the intuition of a concept visually before teaching the proof. It isn't as refined as his more recent work on RU-vid, but I really appreciate what Grant does.
@ancbi
@ancbi 4 года назад
When I find something to delightful not to tell, some people around me just say "does it sell?".
@lordx4641
@lordx4641 4 года назад
I always thought spirals r underrated hemchandra nos (popularly known as fibonacci no) himself showed the unique characteristics of spirals in nature let it be galaxies or flowers thats why the cholas had temples arranged according to golden ratio and golden mean
@amusa8448
@amusa8448 4 года назад
totally agree... subscribed right a way
@DelandaBaudLacanian
@DelandaBaudLacanian 2 года назад
3:22 "If you patiently went through each ray" I can hear it in your voice, thank you 3Blue1Brown for your meticulous work in counting each ray
@teenyfroog6851
@teenyfroog6851 4 месяца назад
Well he can just use the theorem to see that theres 280
@Nick12_45
@Nick12_45 6 дней назад
it's 3:15 but nice comment
@EngRMP
@EngRMP 5 месяцев назад
OMG, mankind is so lucky to have these two things: someone who can clearly explain some of the most complex subjects in math; and a simple means of making that knowledge accessible (RU-vid). I don't mean to imply that producing these videos is "simple".... no, it takes A LOT of time and effort to produce a video this wonderfully clear. Who ever thought that when RU-vid started, we would get to this point... we are so lucky.
@3blue1brown
@3blue1brown 4 года назад
Important error correction: In the video, I say that Dirichlet showed that the primes are equally distributed among allowable residue classes, but this is not historically accurate. (By "allowable", here, I mean a residue class whose elements are coprime to the modulus, as described in the video). What he actually showed is that the sum of the reciprocals of all primes in a given allowable residue class diverges, which proves that there are infinitely many primes in such a sequence. Incidentally, his tactics also show that these residue classes have the same "density", but for an alternate formulation of density than the one shown in the video. Dirichlet observed this equal distribution numerically and noted this in his paper, but it wasn't until decades later that this fact was properly proved, as it required building on some of the work of Riemann in his famous 1859 paper. If I'm not mistaken, I think it wasn't until Vallée Poussin in (1899), with a version of the prime number theorem for residue classes like this. In many ways, this was a very silly error for me to have let through. It is true that this result was proven with heavy use of complex analysis, and in fact, it's in a complex analysis lecture that I remember first learning about it. But of course, this would have to have happened after Dirichlet because it would have to have happened after Riemann! My apologies for the mistake. If you notice factual errors in videos that are not already mentioned in the video's description or pinned comment, don't hesitate to let me know.
@vari1535
@vari1535 4 года назад
(first) How do you even make the visuals and graphs on your computer? Probably some programming or something :P
@ArnaudMEURET
@ArnaudMEURET 4 года назад
Variety of Everything Our host spent a lot of time putting together his own rendering and animation platform. I hope he’ll give us a comprehensive tour one day.
@juanluisclaure6485
@juanluisclaure6485 4 года назад
an important erratum and I surprise to myself get it in the second read. It is too specific information that is hard to google it and find some Wikipedia about it, well I don't research enough is true too. cheers!
@Suav58
@Suav58 4 года назад
@@wizedivine First, let's make it clear between ourselves, that plane is a surface of a 2-sphere with an infinite radius. Secondly: S1 sphere is a boundary of a 2d disc, S2 sphere is a surface of a 3d ball and S3 sphere is a surface of a 4d ball (neither of the latter two you can see, or, to remain on a side of caution, most of us can't see them). This goes on. I think, then, that you wanted to see something where spiral is drawn in 3 d space and coordinates are (r, α, β), where α and β are angles from the x and y positive axes. Pity we don't enjoy true 3d vision, but only a binocular ("stereographic"? - where did Riemann got his idea from) projection of such onto a part of a sphere. I guess, you can go on from here on your own. I think it would be doable in GeoGebra. (I think 3Blue1Brown should use the standard terminology for spheres in his other videos. Moreover, geometric algebra and a proper torus are waiting.)
@LucaS-tf2sj
@LucaS-tf2sj 4 года назад
3Blue1Brown I’m a German ninth grader and I like maths and ur vid but now my brain makes weird noises and smokes.
@rayahdesu1251
@rayahdesu1251 4 года назад
Hello! I'm currently taking a Mathematics course in college, and I'm kind of questioning myself why did I even enter this course. This video made me realize why I love math, and why I entered a Math course in the first place. Thank you very much for these super high quality videos!
@_cytosine
@_cytosine 4 года назад
@@dsdsspp7130 ?! That's not math at all and college math isn't that either. Math at the university level is seldom about memorizing formulas but rather about finding the right solutions to diverse problems and showing how.
@somedude4122
@somedude4122 4 года назад
@@_cytosine Depends on the country.
@haku1145
@haku1145 4 года назад
@@dsdsspp7130 In my case it's all about demonstrations as of now. Knowing things like integrating or multiplying matrices is taught very quickly and isn't given much importance in homeworks/exams (most times, at least) compared to knowing how to demonstrate stuff.
@MrMctastics
@MrMctastics 4 года назад
unite perry at least take a proofs class. That's where math gets fun
@thebluegaming7706
@thebluegaming7706 4 года назад
Keep going!! Math is pretty cool.
@SechristCircus
@SechristCircus 5 месяцев назад
Hands down one of the best "math-y" videos I've seen. One of the best concept breakdowns as well. Everything is clearly described in an easy-to-understand way, yet you don't shy from all the "overly pretentious" (lol) jargon. Finally, the call to study and understand interesting concepts ("be playful") where you may connect the dots later down the road is the best. Thank you
@GetIntoItDuhh
@GetIntoItDuhh Год назад
I don't even LIKE math, but this was amazing.... and I wasn't completely lost for most of the video! You're a brilliant communicator.
@shardator
@shardator Год назад
Math is like beer. You won't like it to begin with, but drink some good... And you are lost to it :)
@GetIntoItDuhh
@GetIntoItDuhh Год назад
@@shardator ive worked in a math-focused field for almost a decade; still hate it.
@shardator
@shardator Год назад
@@GetIntoItDuhh applied math is not that fun. It needs you to focus on things you are not interested in. I'm a SWE, but hate programming, when I have to work on shit someone else wrote 15 years ago, probably drunk.
@flamable2596
@flamable2596 3 месяца назад
Me: *a math disliker* (20-1 kicked my ass cus my teacher sucked) Also me: PATTERNSSS PATTERNS PATTERNS!!
@aubreystewart3772
@aubreystewart3772 4 года назад
I wasn't ready for how beautiful the "zoom out" was going to be
@freewyvern707
@freewyvern707 4 года назад
it loses so much after first viewing but is still brilliant
@Lit_NightSky
@Lit_NightSky 4 года назад
When he zoomed out all I could do was to stare at it, fascinated with my mouth open.
@TheHwiwonKim
@TheHwiwonKim 4 года назад
Check the original answer from the link above. Once zoom out will shock you more. Because the beams are actually spiral again.
@nikey2110
@nikey2110 4 года назад
@@TheHwiwonKim do they turen abck into beams?
@danielwanger5919
@danielwanger5919 4 года назад
Time Stamp?
@aeiouaeiouaeiou
@aeiouaeiouaeiou 3 года назад
i just thought to myself: "wow this is fascinating. i cant believe i didnt know" but then saw that i actually already liked this video. it fucking sucks to be stupid
@evelynwang2225
@evelynwang2225 3 года назад
LMFAO
@Uyhn26
@Uyhn26 3 года назад
LMAO RIP.
@aeiouaeiouaeiou
@aeiouaeiouaeiou 3 года назад
@@hybmnzz2658 heroin or hero in? x)
@minecrafting_il
@minecrafting_il 3 года назад
@@aeiouaeiouaeiou hero(br)in(e)?
@travisperry4515
@travisperry4515 3 года назад
@@aeiouaeiouaeiou clever junkie
@sorio99
@sorio99 2 года назад
I’ll be real, seeing the switch of the spiral from clockwise to counter clockwise when we move from mod 6 to mod 44 is super satisfying.
@nunyabidness6323
@nunyabidness6323 2 года назад
What you said toward the end about accidentally rediscovering things people learned in the past bringing an intrinsic value to them that simply being taught lacks was...completely true. It reminds me of this time once in which I tried to use multidimensional arrays to represent the possible results of a series of coinflips and accidentally discovered that the number of heads has pascal's triangle embedded into it.
@WobblycogsUk
@WobblycogsUk 4 года назад
As someone who understand only a little maths it's very easy to see a diagram like that and think there's some deeper truth to it. The way you explained that there isn't was absolutely brilliant, thanks.
@sunnylilacs
@sunnylilacs 4 года назад
Wobblycogs Workshop Why does learning the explanation behind it make you think there isn’t deeper truth?
@wasd____
@wasd____ 4 года назад
@@sunnylilacs Same reason nobody believes in unicorns - they don't _need_ to exist because there is no evidence requiring unicorns as an explanation.
@dopaminecloud
@dopaminecloud 4 года назад
@@sunnylilacs it's very easy to get swept up in patterns and start making broken logic leaps, consequence of the brain liking them so much there's an entire mental condition based on an extreme version of this tendency to get stuck to patterns
@hermanubis96
@hermanubis96 4 года назад
Dopamine Cloud so why are there patterns at all?
@wasd____
@wasd____ 4 года назад
@@hermanubis96 Because pattern recognition was adaptive and beneficial, therefore it was selected for during human evolution.
@valasfar1557
@valasfar1557 4 года назад
The number theory ones are always so interesting!
@erikkonstas
@erikkonstas 4 года назад
I feel like number theory is more useless than other branches but it poses some interesting and often difficult problems.
@mironhunia300
@mironhunia300 4 года назад
@@erikkonstas Number theory is the basis for cryptography, so it's pretty much one of the most useful branches of mathematics right now.
@erikkonstas
@erikkonstas 4 года назад
@@mironhunia300 Although it compares less in usefulness to e.g. calculus. I agree that every branch of mathematics which potentially has an application is very useful, I'm just doing a comparison. Personal opinions might differ, but eh.
@osolomons
@osolomons 4 года назад
All the ones are always so interesting!
@99bits46
@99bits46 4 года назад
number theory is bs
@umaer009
@umaer009 9 месяцев назад
The excitement in your voice reflects the love you've got for mathematics. Hence, your videos are truly labour of love. KEEP IT UP!
@lindsay3917
@lindsay3917 2 года назад
This was awesome! Have you considered doing a follow-up on Dirichlet's theorem about Chebyshev's bias? For example, when you showed the histogram of primes 1, 3, 7, and 9 mod 10, there is a bias towards 3 and 7 mod 10 (because these are non-squares). Even though the categories all have 25% in the limit, there is quantitatively more primes 3 and 7 mod 10. The primes race is really compelling and not too hard to understand.
@SilverMustang920
@SilverMustang920 3 года назад
To begin with, I just can't even image how you even managed to make these stunning animations at such a large scale. ABSOLUTELY FANTASTIC!! Easily one of my favorite channels on RU-vid.
@katech6020
@katech6020 2 года назад
He is using manim, which is a python library that he created to make this video. you can check it out in Github
@TheRiverwolford
@TheRiverwolford 2 года назад
@@katech6020 I knew he programmed these demonstrations, but I didn't know exactly what he used to do so, so thanks for that! I'll have to check it out at some point.
@marinanikolaou4585
@marinanikolaou4585 Год назад
I took number theory the previous semester in uni and now i can see the point of it. Brilliant job! The visualization of such theoretical problems is so helpful
@martins.1584
@martins.1584 Год назад
This is where it started for me. A recommendation of this video is how I found your channel and it let to sth important, at least for me. I am going to start teaching theoretical computer science soon and, although it is not really the topic of your channel, I will try to use as many of your tips on conveying ideas visually as I can. Thanks and keep up the great work!
@TraceyIsNotMaryGrace
@TraceyIsNotMaryGrace 3 месяца назад
Awesome !!
@2ndOfficerCHL
@2ndOfficerCHL 3 года назад
"Euler's totient function." I swear, Euler had a hand in everything.
@gizmodobaggins7040
@gizmodobaggins7040 3 года назад
Euler, the madlad of math.
@jdawggghg
@jdawggghg 3 года назад
euler’s hoarding problem
@Crumbling_Vortex
@Crumbling_Vortex 3 года назад
Soo... you're telling me I need to look up Euler
@BobStBubba
@BobStBubba 3 года назад
Euler was overcompensating for for the non-phonetic pronunciation of the spelling of his name. First class, every semester of math, teacher calls his name, "Leonard Yuler." "That's pronounced LeonHard Oiler." "Well, it looks like Yuler to me." "I can't help what it looks like to you...." and over time, decides to write 800-plus mathematical treatises just to make math teachers' lives everywhere miserable. And also, ours.
@BobStBubba
@BobStBubba 3 года назад
"Euler's totient function" sounds like something discovered not by Euler himself, but by his mother, during his toilet training, during the years he was studying enuresis. "He's got to get control of his totient function, or he'll never leave home"
@richardcarnegie777
@richardcarnegie777 3 года назад
It’s always been amazing to me that early mathematicians could find the time to focus so deeply (without computers) on these abstract topics in number theory. Life then was generally shorter and rougher so they must have been incredibly dedicated.
@WhyBhanshu
@WhyBhanshu 3 года назад
On the contrary, one had a lot fewer distractions to lure them away from the thing that interested them. In this day and age of internet, it's very hard to keep yourself dedicated to one thing, there's always something else that demands your attention, that makes you feel like you're missing out on something.
@AroundTheBlockAgain
@AroundTheBlockAgain 3 года назад
Yeah they usually had other people to do their cooking, cleaning, and errands for them. Life was shorter and rougher for their cooks, their maids, and other house staff, not them so much. ;)
@General12th
@General12th 3 года назад
@@AroundTheBlockAgain Yes, this is true. The folks who figured this stuff out tended to be men of leisure, for whom day-to-day finances weren't a concern. Aside from the lack of modern amenities like electricity and running water, their lives were probably _easier_ than most of ours, not harder.
@harshitkatiyar2250
@harshitkatiyar2250 2 года назад
@@WhyBhanshu That's exactly what I was thinking last evening.
@anarchodin
@anarchodin 2 года назад
"Life was shorter" is largely a myth, caused by interpreting the "average lifespan" too narrowly. If you exclude those who died before reaching five years of age, the figure jumps up. By a _lot_. The fact that infant and toddler mortality was high enough to have such a substantial impact on the average can be taken as an indicator that the second part of that statement is broadly correct, though.
@scottleung9587
@scottleung9587 Год назад
This was beautiful to watch - and as a Math major, I learned more than you could possibly imagine. Thanks a million!
@GrandAdmiralMitthrawnuruodo
@GrandAdmiralMitthrawnuruodo 7 месяцев назад
Thank you so much for that video! You once again showed how beautiful mathematics is and how it can help us understand the world! Your videos always give me chills. But the good ones of course.
@rianby64
@rianby64 4 года назад
And I almost cried after reading "Be playful". Really amazing conclusions you gave us here!
@Damathematician
@Damathematician 4 года назад
I feel yah, me too man.
@rianby64
@rianby64 4 года назад
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-iFuR97YcSLM.html - slightly similar concept, but not. Conclusions are totally different.
@johnchessant3012
@johnchessant3012 4 года назад
"in case this is too clear for the reader" lmao Also, I absolutely love the ending. 3b1b, I wouldn't be half as enthusiastic about maths without your videos. Thanks so much!
@henryg.8762
@henryg.8762 4 года назад
who would
@odedzrubavel874
@odedzrubavel874 4 года назад
@@henryg.8762 I would, and many others as well, but we sure do appreciate 3b1b for making amazing videos. It's people like him who make people that don't like math much at first, like it.
@yto6095
@yto6095 4 года назад
@@henryg.8762 i mean, i love math since i was 4 years old, and for the next 3 years i didn't even understand english enough to be able to understand any of this except that there's cool spirals and gaps between them. love for math is the kind of thing that you just need to start somehow, and then it grows on its own. it can grow faster, when you find things like googology or good math videos, or other stuff that is very enjoyable, but doesn't seem too useful at first, but even if you don't find these kinds of things, you can get just as far.
@MrHailstorm00
@MrHailstorm00 11 месяцев назад
Whenever I feel discouraged by humanity, I come to this channel and get courage from knowing this video still can amass millions of views
@19Szabolcs91
@19Szabolcs91 2 года назад
This is amazing, all of this. From the original spiral shape to the explanation to the conclusion about learning at the end.
@potatok123
@potatok123 4 года назад
*The ultimate connect the dots game*
@flanbenflen9069
@flanbenflen9069 4 года назад
300 likes comment-less?? Don't think so.
@AnarchoAmericium
@AnarchoAmericium 4 года назад
*takes a deep breath* Let me take the time to talk to you about category theory.
@josephdestaubin7426
@josephdestaubin7426 4 года назад
Indeed, and on so many levels. ☺
@potato457
@potato457 4 года назад
IMPOSTER
@potato457
@potato457 4 года назад
I AM THE TRUE POTATO
@sirsholar
@sirsholar 4 года назад
When you discover math before you learn the math theorem, then the theorem becomes your friend instead of an arbitrary inconvenience.
@minebloxgx1780
@minebloxgx1780 4 года назад
Well said
@n_x1891
@n_x1891 4 года назад
You're a fucking genius.
@BladeOfLight16
@BladeOfLight16 4 года назад
I think this is an expression of the fact that math is typically motivated by the goal of explaining some particular phenomenon. For the Greeks, the were trying to explain and model the properties of geometry. For Newton, he was trying to explain motion. For Einstein, he was trying to explain weird things about gravity (although he took the math of general relativity from others). As math has grown increasingly complex over the centuries, it developed its own, non-physical phenomenons of interest. It's this sense of discovering patterns and relationships and being able to describe and explain them relatively simply that motivates us as humans to do math, and playing with problems on your own leads you to that sense in a way that memorizing and practicing a set of theorems can't.
@heroricspiritfreinen38
@heroricspiritfreinen38 4 года назад
@@BladeOfLight16 waffle
@yuvanmarimuthu4909
@yuvanmarimuthu4909 4 года назад
@@heroricspiritfreinen38 not really
@debojitsikdar2046
@debojitsikdar2046 2 года назад
This is pure Mathematical bliss. Thank you so much for this, as you said, now I will be more familiar with these concepts when I go into them more deeply!
@krishna25MO
@krishna25MO 5 месяцев назад
Even if I don't understand all technical aspects of your videos I really appreciate the visualization that give me an deeper understanding of mathematical problems. Thanks!
@PiercingSight
@PiercingSight 4 года назад
"If you effectively reinvent ... before you've seen it defined... then when you do learn those topics, you'll see them as familiar friends, not as arbitrary definitions." This is my favorite thing about messing around with math and numbers, finding patterns, testing different ways of measuring their properties and more. I didn't know what integrals were before high school, but I knew that if I added up all the space underneath a graphed line or curve, then that would be useful for say... adding up the total distance a car travels while only knowing it's speed over time. When I finally learned about integrals, it made the topic so much more exciting for me. Thank you for continuing to make math fun and interesting for everyone who sees your videos!
@jasonbellmusic3091
@jasonbellmusic3091 4 года назад
Same... That really hit me right in the face when I heard it. I'd been looking at a number pattern thingy (the description isn't clear whenever I try to explain it so feel free to skip to the next paragraph) where I try to see how soon a digit repeats itself when raising a number to an integer power which I increase, and I found various patterns which seemed almost arbitrary. In the end, I spoke about it with my brother, and he told me how it was related to this very totient function, and gave me a brief explanation. So once I saw it even in this video, I felt more familiar and certain with myself.
@BorniWolf
@BorniWolf 3 года назад
Hi, I'm a mathematician, and have to say, WOW, I enjoy your videos a lot, have just recommended your channel to a friend of mine who teaches in high school to show your vids to his students, perhaps, with your help, more young talented students will be "lured" to study mathematics:) thank you very much for your work!!
@RipRoaringGarage
@RipRoaringGarage Год назад
What field are you? I was doing Representation Theory and Number Theory, with a dash of Hyperbolic Geom....I wish I could get back to that. Its just that there is no way for me to return...and when youre sitting on an important proof, it is maddening.
@trixylizard6970
@trixylizard6970 Год назад
I'm 43 and it made me pick up the books!
@SupaJay2
@SupaJay2 7 месяцев назад
True! Also I wonder if perfect numbers would do something...
@opticandersonopticanderson3364
@opticandersonopticanderson3364 5 месяцев назад
​@@RipRoaringGarage😂 anyone can claim to be a mathetician online.
@gaanasonata6582
@gaanasonata6582 Год назад
Hi 3Blue1Brown, I love your content... as a high school student and ‘mathlete’ I was extremely excited when watching this video! You mentioned that the proof of Dirichlet’s was quite complex... can you explain it on your channel? Your visual style of explanation would be amazing to learn that!
@Oblivionator100
@Oblivionator100 Год назад
I really like how this visualization shows the principles of emergent properties. Given a set of rules, any system, complex or simple, will have properties emerge that are non-obvious from the inception of the system. This is one of my favorite observations of universal principles.
@ano2math5
@ano2math5 4 года назад
Oh, truly a piece of art. I’ve never seen a movie which expresses the cliché that “math is beautiful” better than this video!!! I love this!
@ianwalker6546
@ianwalker6546 3 года назад
I love your final point. I remember when I was at school, adding up the number of spots on a normal six-sided die, and then independently asking myself, and coming up with, the formula for "how many spots on a die on any number of sides?" - a question that was probably helped due to my D&D hobby making me familiar with the idea of dice with different numbers of sides." So I independently "invented" the formula for the triangle numbers, which is not a particularly great mathematical feat, but did allow me to stun a teacher who set the classic "Add up the numbers from 1 to 100" by answering it within a few seconds. Great video!
@jakefromstatefarm6969
@jakefromstatefarm6969 2 года назад
You gaussed them!
@mcmonkey26
@mcmonkey26 Год назад
same
@yuraje4k348
@yuraje4k348 Год назад
i loved the first point too. "How pretty but pointless patterns in polar plots of primes prompt pretty important ponderings on properties of those primes"
@Adventurin_hobbit
@Adventurin_hobbit Год назад
Yeah exactly 💯
@yuraje4k348
@yuraje4k348 Год назад
@@Adventurin_hobbit yo sir give more formulaes
@Kloiyd
@Kloiyd 4 месяца назад
The video explained amazingly how this spiral came to be and made me understand a concept I previously thought I wouldn’t be able to understand.
@thebrownmalcolm9498
@thebrownmalcolm9498 2 года назад
A buddy sent this to me a few minutes ago. This is fantastic. Liked and subscribed. I’m glad something like this has 3.5 million views.
@douglasthompson9070
@douglasthompson9070 4 года назад
Humans love to find patterns so they can figure out why a pattern exists.
@smilelikeUmeanit90
@smilelikeUmeanit90 4 года назад
Patterns love to find humans. Oops.
@glaswasser
@glaswasser 4 года назад
do we find patterns beautiful because everything is in a pattern - or do we find patterns beautiful because we were "programmed" to like patterns, or both?
@hanguyenthu9691
@hanguyenthu9691 4 года назад
@@glaswasser Now silly as this question/joke might seem, the answer is quite worth it to look into. You see, pattern give us an important ability: to predict. Then of course, creatures that are programed to see patterns might predict things better, and be better at living at a whole. And what is a better reason to look for patterns, than its beauty?
@whitechocolate4384
@whitechocolate4384 4 года назад
Patterns exist. Humans are keen towards them because our brains allow us to recognize them. Patterns are caused by stimuli. We are intelligent enough to domesticate those stimuli if we comprehend them.
@venkatbabu186
@venkatbabu186 4 года назад
Patterns are sequence to follow for direction and routing and assessment of speed and vectors.
@kiiometric
@kiiometric 4 года назад
This was so entertaining I didn't even realize that was 22 minutes long, I love this♥️
@fnalley1761
@fnalley1761 4 года назад
I didn't look at the time of the video before starting, and kind of assumed it was about 10 minutes. Then at the end, I thought...wow, that must have been only 5 minutes. LOL
@isabellaegan5051
@isabellaegan5051 4 года назад
Same, you were the one that made me look at the time stamp for the first time
@TheDentrassi
@TheDentrassi 2 года назад
This is great. I've stumbled into maths from archaeology and art. Wanting to reproduce various neolithic and la tene designs and monuments on paper and mucking around with a compass and rule. I've found learning mathematics from this visual, geometric perspective has made a lot of things click in a way it wouldn't before. I really appreciate seeing mathematical concepts visualised like this.
@dawislv
@dawislv 2 года назад
This is simply amazing video and clarity level. Personally for me this way of thinking is a striking resemblance of "when you eliminate whatever is impossible, whatever remains, however incredible, must be true" and reminded me of very old days when I was thinking about way of defining set all primes myself which lead me to a c++ program which ( how I later learned) was a bad implementation of Sieve of Eratosthenes. The formula for distribution 1/Fi(N) makes total sense when explained so clearly like that.
@jaredgarbo3679
@jaredgarbo3679 4 года назад
"3 is slightly less than Pi" You have angered the engineers.
@gabor6259
@gabor6259 4 года назад
"Pi is 1." /a physicist/
@SuperPol1981
@SuperPol1981 4 года назад
Engineers would be the first to simplify pi to 3. You're thinking about mathematicians. Or school teachers or lawyers.
@bledlbledlbledl
@bledlbledlbledl 4 года назад
The engineers aren't the ones you have to watch out for on this one. It's the slapstick comedians. (lemon-meringue pi)
@tdiaz5555
@tdiaz5555 4 года назад
@@SuperPol1981 The (running) joke is that an engineer would say that pi = 3, while the statement here is pi > 3.
@17lvlham
@17lvlham 4 года назад
Even during desinging of simple DSP for my radio amateur transceiver, I've been taking pi to about 9 decimal places to have enough frequency accuracy (nearly 10 Hz) in my "narrow" working band (30 MHz). And I wouldn't be surprised, if serious engineers take pi much more accurate. E.g. in automatic control theory, while estimaing safety margin of some closed-loop control system.
@shrimpchem
@shrimpchem 4 года назад
This is analogous to showing a meme to your parent and instead of saying “oh cool”, they give you a piece of life advice
@DillsArtThing
@DillsArtThing 4 года назад
._.
@johnnyswatts
@johnnyswatts 4 года назад
It's more like showing a meme to your parents and they say "oh, cool" and then share a really deep story from their lives that relates to that meme, showing you worlds beyond and making you feel really good and loved.
@NortheastGamer
@NortheastGamer 4 года назад
@@johnnyswatts There are two types of people, those who listened to their parents' stories and those who rolled their eyes.
@shatterdpixel
@shatterdpixel 4 года назад
NortheastGamer Or a mystical third kind where their parents just yelled at them
@Jonesybabie
@Jonesybabie 4 года назад
Shatterdpixel And a random fourth whose parents didn't say anything at all... But the children still heard everything that needed to be said and eventually learned why primes form spirals. Clearly it's used in the flex capacitor to initialize time travel 🤓
@Shuizid
@Shuizid 5 месяцев назад
Great video! Also great way of showing how things look in scales when zooming out and one set of spirals transitions into another one with the implication that we could zoom more and more only to find now sets of more and more spirals.
@derekmz
@derekmz 2 месяца назад
The way you seamlessly explained the jargon for modulo was perfect
@syedarslanalishah6905
@syedarslanalishah6905 4 года назад
I'm smiling before even the video is started :)
@blackcat5771
@blackcat5771 4 года назад
Same :)
@anandsuralkar2947
@anandsuralkar2947 4 года назад
Samea
@heest2876
@heest2876 4 года назад
First you click on the video, then thumbsup, then it loads :D
@see_conspiracy_inevery_tri6991
@see_conspiracy_inevery_tri6991 4 года назад
Why? Something is wrong with you guys? Maybe you need professional help?
@The_Rising_Dragon
@The_Rising_Dragon 4 года назад
(.❛ ᴗ ❛.)
@smallbar2012
@smallbar2012 4 года назад
When I was in sixth grade, I realized that the difference between any two consecutive squares was equal to the sum of their square roots. I was blown away by this fact, presented it to my teacher, and was ecstatic to learn that that tidbit generalized to the Difference of Two Squares. I then spent the next three years telling people I had discovered a theorem on my own, and I was so proud of what I had discovered by playing around and chasing patterns.
@elkraftaren245
@elkraftaren245 4 года назад
This is the exact same thing I discovered, litterally exact same story. mind blowing
@seesaw41
@seesaw41 4 года назад
In 6th grade?
@smallbar2012
@smallbar2012 4 года назад
Yep! I got bored a lot in school. Haha.
@Nawakooo0
@Nawakooo0 6 дней назад
OMG I DID THE EXACT SAME THING WHEN I WAS A KID TOO
@r50142
@r50142 2 года назад
I love the little PI buddies you're making. Honestly keeps me motivated to keep coding.
@forrest11
@forrest11 5 месяцев назад
This channel is absolutely phenomenal, you deserve much more viewers
@arnbrandy
@arnbrandy 4 года назад
"How pretty but pointless patterns on polar plots of primes prompt pretty important ponderings on properties of those primes." C'mon man, let me just watch a minute or two of the video before forcing me to like it.
@vieuxnez
@vieuxnez 4 года назад
P'shaw.
@echozero8213
@echozero8213 4 года назад
Plliteration
@Jlouise95
@Jlouise95 4 года назад
important-->purposeful
@funkysagancat3295
@funkysagancat3295 4 года назад
Also the patterns cannot be pointless when they are clearly coming from a bunch of points
@PandemoniumMeltDown
@PandemoniumMeltDown 4 года назад
There is beauty in innocence
@luistorh
@luistorh 4 года назад
The last minute of your talk was profound, enlightening and valuable: the connections of deep math concepts to many manifestations of reality. Thanks.
@SporkleBM
@SporkleBM 2 года назад
The last bit? about these topics coming back as familiar subjects instead of arbitrary definitions, really solidified my love of youtube education. for channels especially like this, minutephysics, etc
@therealzilch
@therealzilch Год назад
Simply wow. To my credit, I did see how the patterns must have something to do with how polar coordinates work. But this went way beyond that. Thanks, from someone who plays around with prime and coprime polyrhythms and polymeters, Scott
@worzo1284
@worzo1284 3 года назад
Aside from the astonishingly clear explanation of this problem, this is a great insight into why many people find maths difficult. Effective learning is about making connections between things. We often teach maths as "learn this set of rules", which has very few connections. Exploring patterns and then explaining them as this video does is much more powerful.
@shahirkazi8766
@shahirkazi8766 4 года назад
This video made me... feel emotions that I can't quite put into words.
@programaths
@programaths 4 года назад
Forty Two.
@romanpfarrhofer
@romanpfarrhofer 4 года назад
try to put it in numbers instead :)
@electronicmusicwave7459
@electronicmusicwave7459 4 года назад
i know what u mean. me too...
@chasebender7473
@chasebender7473 4 года назад
@seba cea Andre Weil once said that understanding a problem that you have been working on endlessly can lead to a feeling of ecstasy for weeks at a time
@Damathematician
@Damathematician 4 года назад
The end of this video took me to such an emotional high. Its nice to see others who care so deeply about a subject you also care so deeply about. In a way it was like our spirits became one ... although philosophically I am not sold on 'spirits', that's the language I have to use to describe this feeling.
@roguelegend4945
@roguelegend4945 6 месяцев назад
thank you ' for all the videos' i love to watch them and find them very interesting, it brightens my days...
@GregL-zt4xf
@GregL-zt4xf Год назад
You, sir, are one of the most effective teachers on the planet.
@LoUiSvsMiKu
@LoUiSvsMiKu 4 года назад
1am: i have to sleep *3b1b uploads*
@green0563
@green0563 4 года назад
Same.
@sundaralingams8083
@sundaralingams8083 4 года назад
Exactly same. 😂
@alphaexpress6881
@alphaexpress6881 4 года назад
Same.
@AnkitSingh-wq2rk
@AnkitSingh-wq2rk 4 года назад
For me currently 12 am but same
@ishaanparikh485
@ishaanparikh485 4 года назад
Same
@Ironpecker
@Ironpecker 3 года назад
I cant wrap around how math can be so beatiful, it's like reading a really good novel that has many intresting characters and plots that are always more deep and connected that they lead you on at the start. Sometimes it requires more work to piece all the parts together but man the result is incredible
@jamesr2936
@jamesr2936 2 года назад
Nice analogy well said! And in the case of our universe, math is the language in which the novel is written. As Kepler said :)
@kevinpruett6424
@kevinpruett6424 5 месяцев назад
​​@@jamesr2936it's not as fancy as an entire novel filled with gestures... It's more like musiComposition. (It repeatStatic loops when charted, but cannot "break the mold" via willpower. It is the environmental medium, the reflecTensor allowing language). Language, on the other hand, is not exact or predictable, for having synonym varianTone stretching.
@void-qh8uc
@void-qh8uc Год назад
I love this channel so much! Using my free time to study mathematics (also other sciences) is awesome :)
@linklegends22
@linklegends22 4 года назад
This is such a beautifully clear video. I've seen this prime spiral meme before and like you said thought it was due to some mysterious property of primes. Thank you for demystifying this and somehow leaving me even more amazed by the simplicity of the mathematics causing it and the more interesting topic that it brushes up against.
@gregmartin6341
@gregmartin6341 4 года назад
Note that you might be thinking of the "Ulam spiral", which is a different spiral- and prime-related picture...!
@foooooooont4679
@foooooooont4679 4 года назад
"Why do prime numbers make these spirals?" me before the video: how tf should i know that me after the video: *what are prime numbers*
@FeedEgg
@FeedEgg 4 года назад
They are portals into and out of our minds simultaneously....yea pretty nuts i know.
@foooooooont4679
@foooooooont4679 4 года назад
@@FeedEgg god, is that you?
@FeedEgg
@FeedEgg 4 года назад
@@foooooooont4679 one of them...shh
@foooooooont4679
@foooooooont4679 4 года назад
@@FeedEgg ok i will keep my mouth shut
@FeedEgg
@FeedEgg 4 года назад
@@foooooooont4679 lol do not be afraid, they exist just not in the way you think, agnostic, all i know is that i know nothing at all.
@tomcox1983
@tomcox1983 Год назад
A beautiful production with a beautiful message. Thank you!
@pikasfed
@pikasfed 4 года назад
2:25 that animation and change of music was utterly beautiful, that type of beauty you wouldn't expect to find, yet still it's there, waiting to be discovered.
@ayushbhardwas
@ayushbhardwas 4 года назад
When mathematicians get inspired by chemistry, remainders become residues.
@Allangulon
@Allangulon 4 года назад
They're looking for a Solution!
@ayushbhardwas
@ayushbhardwas 4 года назад
@@Allangulon 😂😂😂
@jagtan13
@jagtan13 4 года назад
@@Allangulon hey carefull you wouldn't want a Suspension!
@MahendraSingh-nb7ui
@MahendraSingh-nb7ui 4 года назад
Haha 🤣
@Anvilshock
@Anvilshock 4 года назад
@@jagtan13 Suspensions are pure physics, though. They work without chemistry, mind.
@InfinityExt
@InfinityExt Год назад
when you realize that if this was assigned by a teacher, it would probably be boring as hell but willingly watching these videos on your own time suddenly makes it feel so much more interesting
@circuit10
@circuit10 Год назад
I sometimes watch these to procrastinate from doing maths homework
@davidpederson2905
@davidpederson2905 Год назад
This video has had me thinking about this for a long, long time. I love how it is so easy for the mind to "see" the rays. But the "spirals" are just discontinuous dots that happen to be near each other, and the human brain is compelled to connect the dots. I wonder how often we get fooled by things like sub atomic particle data or astrophysics data that is really discontinuous, and assign some kind of relation that might not really be there, but "kind of" explains the data so we stop looking for other explanations. Fine job on the whole idea, and the presentation. Many thanks.
@Paroxysm80
@Paroxysm80 3 года назад
I just randomly stumbled upon this, and it has me absolutely fascinated (from both the resulting math and the lucidity of the video/explanation itself). Amongst my other playlists for memes, drumming, etc., I now have one titled "Beautiful Math". I feel compelled to fill it with others and take the time to understand it all! Thank you so much for creating this incredible lesson! :)
@FacultyofKhan
@FacultyofKhan 4 года назад
Oh yes, waited such a long time for this! Quick Request: since you're doing Number Theory, can you prove Fermat's Last Theorem? I believe the proof is quite trivial, so it shouldn't be too bad :P
@runningcrocodile8051
@runningcrocodile8051 4 года назад
Yeah, Fermat's last theorem is an easy one.. definitely should be a video. In fact, I just found a nice proof for it, but I'm afraid it won't fit in this youtube comment.
@chumbucket6989
@chumbucket6989 4 года назад
He's addressed this: www.reddit.com/r/3Blue1Brown/comments/7aubxv/fermats_last_theorem/
@FacultyofKhan
@FacultyofKhan 4 года назад
@@chumbucket6989 Aww nooo, is the project too big to fit on the margin of his paper?
@nchoosekmath
@nchoosekmath 4 года назад
@@runningcrocodile8051 lol nice one.
@chumbucket6989
@chumbucket6989 4 года назад
@@FacultyofKhan This is what he said: "I'm not saying no, but let's just say this would be a very big project :) Certainly some special cases might be doable and interesting."
@tastydolphinbrain
@tastydolphinbrain 15 дней назад
I love good explainer videos like this because I get to briefly feel what it must be like to be very intelligent.
@madsjakobsen9824
@madsjakobsen9824 5 месяцев назад
I am writing a big school paper on RSA encryption, and wanted to watch some 3b1b videos so i just took one i hadnt watched. And boy does it feel satisfying when you started talking about eulers totient and coprime numbers because i have been learning so much about that stuff. Great video
@luminous2585
@luminous2585 5 месяцев назад
I remember learning about reside classes in school. We had this little experiment going on where the computer science and math teachers tag teamed us for a couple lessons to teach us about RSA. Honestly, that was a cool idea and I wish more students got to experience something like it. Seeing how different subjects connect with each other is really special.
@AapoJoki
@AapoJoki 3 года назад
This video in a nutshell: "That was a pretty dumb question, but here's a _really_ good answer to it"
@brokkrep
@brokkrep 3 года назад
I also thought why to ask that, because this graph is completely man-made so it is no wonder such thing happens.
@Fralexion
@Fralexion 3 года назад
"...and that retroactively means it _wasn't_ dumb, because curiosity lead to learning something"
@portaadonai
@portaadonai 3 года назад
Design: ...>>>oooOOOooo
@Fralexion
@Fralexion 3 года назад
​@@portaadonai Your reply has nothing to do with the comments above it, and is very clearly an attempt to derail the conversation into a tiresome debate about intelligent design theory. Please put your digression somewhere else.
@callahans44
@callahans44 3 года назад
@@portaadonai I'm pretty sure one gets a straight line with nos, but he got a spiral using pi and radians such as 2 pi. Of course you a spiral no matter what unless you get a near circle. So no randomness. It's how these guys saw patterns within them w/o drugs is the lesson here. I think.
@MindMathMoney
@MindMathMoney 4 года назад
🕊️ *The beauty of mathematics only shows itself to more patient followers.* 🕊️
@jaredt5127
@jaredt5127 4 года назад
Math teachers be takin notes on this channel. Superb
@ancbi
@ancbi 4 года назад
Or to those follower of 3B1B even if they are less patient.
@abuzabid6473
@abuzabid6473 2 года назад
This shows even simple things in mathematics can lead to something stunningly beautiful things, this just amazes me more that how beautiful mathematics is!
@moothecow6908
@moothecow6908 5 месяцев назад
Ok i relate so much to the end of this video because im in high school and i just learned derivatives this year but ive been doing simple derivatives forever. I thought the fact that there was a specific ratio of the slopes of like whole number values of x^2 was really interesting and that each had a specific relationship to the previous and only now do i realize that that was derivatives the whole time and its an amazing feeling
@Traagst
@Traagst 4 года назад
That spiraled out of control quickly..
@mikedamacenos
@mikedamacenos 3 года назад
Underated comment
@davidherz9968
@davidherz9968 3 года назад
@@mikedamacenos why is it out of control? Since when has infinity been out of control? Just out of reach, out of sight, out of mind.
@wolfelkan8183
@wolfelkan8183 4 года назад
One implication he didn't go into: When plotting the numbers in whole number radians, each new number was 1/2pi rotations from the last one. So, the numbers made a spiral arm every time they encountered a number that was close to the denominator of a rational approximation of 1/2pi (that is to say, close to twice the numerator of a rational approximation of pi itself). But what if we didn't want to make spirals? What if we wanted all of our points to be as far away from other points as possible, *in every direction*? (Why we would need to do this is a point I'll come back to later.) If you're making spiral arms, there's a lot of space in between the arms that's wasted, and much less space between two neighbors on the same arm. Is there a way to avoid this? Well, if we want to find a number that gives us no spirals, we need it to have as few rational approximations as possible, (some of you might see where I'm going with this) we can look at continued fractions, since as explained in that Mathologer video, every time you encounter a large number in a number's continued fraction, you can truncate the sequence there and get a pretty good approximation. Thus, the ultimate not-close-to-any-rational-number number would have a continued fraction with numbers as low as possible. Ideally, made up of all 1's. This number happens to be (sqrt(5)+1)/2, known as the Golden Ratio. But getting back to why we would need to find points as far away from each other as possible: Well, what if we were a plant putting out seeds? We have a chemical process that rotates by a certain amount and then makes a seed. And we want those seeds to be spread out as efficiently as possible so that they don't have to compete for resources. If you've heard that the Golden Ratio shows up in nature, this is why.
@nichtrichtigrum
@nichtrichtigrum 4 года назад
I really appreciate your comment pointing towards the connections between math and nature and I think it would make another great video (I hope @3blue1brown reads this)! Do you maybe have a source for this that I can go to?
@legacykevin
@legacykevin 4 года назад
Awesome!
@JordanMetroidManiac
@JordanMetroidManiac 4 года назад
Yes, people should give the golden ratio more attention! It's got some crazy (cool) things too! Try this out: Find the line that connects the two inflection points of a quartic polynomial curve. Then, measure the distance between the outer intersections (the rightmost point and the leftmost point) and the inner intersections (the inflection points). It turns out that, provided that four distinct intersections exist, the ratio of the inner segment (the distance between the inflection points) to the outer segments (the distance between each of the outer intersections and the nearest inner intersection) is exactly the golden ratio. Furthermore, the two smaller areas enclosed (on the left and right) by the inflection line and the quartic curve are each exactly half the size of the larger area (in the middle). Why this happens probably comes down to a nasty algebraic nightmare with calculus, and things simplify to the golden ratio and whatnot. I'm sure it's possible to prove it. I tried to do it myself but got lost in the awfully complicated algebra (trust me, it's ridiculous). Maybe there's a neater and more elegant proof than that, though. 3Blue1Brown? Care to tackle this one?
@VishalSingh-jn6qw
@VishalSingh-jn6qw 4 года назад
Pheww!!!!! So long thst i couldn't help liking!!
@Kashish290695
@Kashish290695 4 года назад
m.ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-sj8Sg8qnjOg.html
@AdrianHereToHelp
@AdrianHereToHelp 2 года назад
My mind is blown. What a phenomenal and beautiful video; thank you for making this.
@RaoufAthar
@RaoufAthar 2 месяца назад
This is a wonderful video. The amount of effort gone into making the video and the knowledge are praiseworthy.
@tusharshaily
@tusharshaily 4 года назад
I wish someone could have taught me like this in my school
@dantethunderstone5766
@dantethunderstone5766 4 года назад
TUSHAR SHAILY as far as I can see, all schools everywhere rush to the ‘answer’ when really it is the question that is really interesting.
@JustinLockwood44
@JustinLockwood44 4 года назад
I'm thankful to be taught this now. I feel for all the people now gone (or still alive but nevertheless will never have the opportunity) who may have been completely enamored by this privilege. But yes, I do wish this was available during school. No doubt there are some lucky students out there with splendid teachers at this moment
@XxStuart96xX
@XxStuart96xX 4 года назад
Schools are forced to ensure kids can pass tests more than anything else. In the UK the benchmark for GCSE exams (sat when you're 15/16) is (well, was) a C grade. Getting a D-grade kid to a C meant a lot to the school, so way more effort was expended by teachers in that area. The high flying kids, those that could get an A without too much trouble, weren't pushed anywhere near as much. Not the fault of the teachers, I might add. The school doesn't care if an A* possible kid only gets an A, that won't really affect stuff like funding. It's all about getting kids to pass. I'm not saying the struggling kids shouldn't be helped, but it shouldn't be that schools have to prioritise them any more than kids with a high potential in that subject. They recently changed the grading from letters (A* to F) to numbers (9 to 1). Why? No doubt there are 'reasons' but it does not seem a priority to me. But that shows the nature of schools nowadays.
@verdoemme
@verdoemme 4 года назад
I was lucky enough to have a math teacher who showed us the beauty of math (in the 80’s, no youtube just chalk but he did it). This guy even gave up his pauses if anyone didn’t grasp anything and would explain again or explain more (out of scope for the exams) for those who were interested. My wife didn’t have this luck and always thought she was bad at everything math until I started explaining things I remembered after we got married. Long story short, she went back to university while working full time (didn’t attend most classes), did every year in half the time and has since become top of the field in her profession and gives guest colleges at several universities. She’s the perfect example of how the spark was not lit up because her teachers failed. This is why youtube is such an important tool right now where capable and driven people can enlighten the people who are interested and hopefully light many sparks!
@longleaf1217
@longleaf1217 4 года назад
I think i may have learned more maths from youtubers at this point then i did in college. and i minored in mathematics.
@STAWBsOrio
@STAWBsOrio 4 года назад
Absolutely stunning. I am a part-time mathematics teacher myself and the epilogue was truly inspirational. Thank you.
@SabrinaXe
@SabrinaXe Год назад
The end was so cute and touching. I love your bravery for not getting too caught up with arbitrary patterns and seeing beyond them
@Adam-jo3tr
@Adam-jo3tr 3 года назад
I love the way you take the time to teach math jargon and other tidbits in these videos. So well done. I wish every single lecture was like this
@carlquitter4987
@carlquitter4987 4 года назад
Hey I’m going through a very tough and stressful times and I wanted to say that seeing your video in my feed just made me smile and actually really excited me. Thank you
@hugoehhh
@hugoehhh 4 года назад
Hope the times are doing you better my friend
@Bbb78651
@Bbb78651 2 месяца назад
"So be playful!" Brilliant words, and brilliant, brilliant video. Thank you Grant.
@azrael5648
@azrael5648 5 месяцев назад
Absolutely love your videos mate. This was amazing.
@billymcnutt116
@billymcnutt116 4 года назад
I commend all the mathematicians who made these discoveries before computers were invented. 👏👏
@alapanbera8259
@alapanbera8259 4 года назад
Seriouly , i never realized there is so much beauty hidden in math before watching your videos..thank you 3blue1brown❤️❤️❤️
@Cardgames4children
@Cardgames4children 4 года назад
Math has a lot of subtle patterns, often too convoluted to see the whole picture and beauty all at once. But with each careful step, you can get closer to seeing how various things and ideas/concepts fit together, and that, in the end, can give you a deep appreciation for how it all works. It's really cool just how abundant patterns can seem around us.
@epaulander2268
@epaulander2268 2 года назад
This is amazing. It's so deep and so simple at the same time.
@balachdanish9963
@balachdanish9963 6 месяцев назад
Amazing video. Increased by already ever-growing love for math! Subscribed.
@gofigglo
@gofigglo 4 года назад
dude amazing video. one question though: how on earth did you animate those histograms??? that seems like it would've taken forever!! amazing work
@Epicvampire800
@Epicvampire800 4 года назад
he didn't do any of this by hand, he codes the animations in a custom python library. so it would probably be something like he creates a list of primes and then feeds that list into a function that sorts it into the categories for the histogram.
@tylerbreisacher5841
@tylerbreisacher5841 4 года назад
The code for those histograms in particular will probably be up on github.com/3b1b/manim soon.
@jakel7213
@jakel7213 4 года назад
@@tylerbreisacher5841 Oh goddamn thank you. Every time I watch his videos, I find myself really wanting to animate other formulae/functions. You just made my week.
@sudheernaidu6646
@sudheernaidu6646 4 года назад
@@tylerbreisacher5841 does he actually upload the code of his videos on manim repository? I doubt so? because he once mentioned that it is more like a work in progress. please give me a heads up if you find something he did in the videos on the repository, I'll be super motivated to recreate or create new animations
@tylerbreisacher5841
@tylerbreisacher5841 4 года назад
@@sudheernaidu6646 at least some of it. For example here's some of the code for the colliding blocks. github.com/3b1b/manim/tree/master/old_projects/clacks
@neelamverma8167
@neelamverma8167 4 года назад
Ok now i want a 20 minutes video of the prime numbers plotted in the graph zooming out ...
@swapnil3990
@swapnil3990 4 года назад
Wild Abra used teleport.
@meta04
@meta04 4 года назад
…4 4 used TM55!
@palmberry5576
@palmberry5576 3 года назад
Poor computer
@soouG.
@soouG. 3 года назад
A wild Abra appeared Go, 1 Wild Abra used 1 is not a prime number It's super effective 1 commited suicide Go, 0 Wild Abra used Teleport Wild Abra fled
@rockysmith6105
@rockysmith6105 Год назад
That intro was already spectacular, that alitteration was immense
@wailingalen
@wailingalen 5 месяцев назад
I am not a mathematical phenom or engineer, but ai do find immense beauty in the visualizations of mathematical concepts! Like this, visualizing Fourier transform, visualizing how to turn a circle inside out, mathematical proofs, etc!
Далее
But why would light "slow down"? | Optics puzzles 3
29:24
Power breaking fail will have you weak 🤣😭
00:19
Solving Wordle using information theory
30:38
Просмотров 10 млн
Researchers thought this was a bug (Borwein integrals)
17:26
The Oldest Unsolved Problem in Math
31:33
Просмотров 8 млн
How to lie using visual proofs
18:49
Просмотров 3,1 млн
An Exact Formula for the Primes: Willans' Formula
14:47