Тёмный

Why does Starship belly flop? 

Everyday Astronaut
Подписаться 1,6 млн
Просмотров 1,7 млн
50% 1

Why is SpaceX doing the belly flop with Starship? Why are they going from belly flopping and then flipping to tail down and why are they doing that so close to the ground? Why don’t they just start the flip maneuver earlier and ensure there’s enough time to make corrections if something goes wrong?
We’ll also dive into the different options SpaceX has with lighting engines, how many engines can they run and at what altitude? Is running on more engines better? And can parachutes be a back up if the engines don’t work?
And of course, we’ll answer the ultimate question. Will this ever be safe enough for humans? Can you even survive the G forces?! Should SpaceX just give up on the belly flop and do a landing more like a Falcon 9, which has proven to be highly successful?
So today we’ll look at the wonders of terminal velocity, gravity drag, thrust to weight ratios, and engine throttling to see why SpaceX is trying this belly flop maneuver and see if we think it’s worth it or if SpaceX should go back to the drawing board.
Check out the article version of this video here! - everydayastronaut.com/starshi...
00:00 - Intro
03:15 - How The Flip Maneuver Works
06:00 - Why Belly Flop / Terminal Velocity
13:15 - Thrust to Weight Ratios / Engine Throttling
21:00 - Gravity Loss / Gravity Drag
26:25 - Why Flip So Late
33:45 - Can This Be Safe?
39:30 - Conclusion
Be sure and follow Cosmic Perspective on RU-vid too! / cosmicperspective
--------------------------
Want to support what I do? Consider becoming a Patreon supporter for access to exclusive livestreams, our discord channel and subreddit! - / everydayastronaut
Special thanks to our "Mission Directors" - Benjamin Holland, Dr Roy Jenevein & Dr Nahid Khazenie, Sylwester Ratowt, Scott Maley, Robin Haerens, Krystifer M.I. Colli-Biondi, Brock Barron, Casey Cheshire, Rob Nunn, James and Becky Carter, Tim Engle, Ian Marr, Taron Lexton, Chris Meleg, Corey Coddington, Chris LaClair, Peter F Maher, Steve Kemp, Vincent Argiro, Lars Nielsen (Denmark), IMAJIN, Derek Rowe, Nick , Jeff Hutchinson, Austin Murnane, Frans de Wet, Chad Souter, Sam Fisher, Jason Kelnhofer, Arthur Carty, Lawrence Mansour, DLB, Chris Dibbs, David Glover, Scott G Raderstorf, Max Haot, John Malkin, TTTA , Seth Pascale, Jared smith, Simon Pilkington, Héctor Ramos, Alejandro , Tomdmay , Mac Malkawi, Manalope , Tristan Edwards
Or become a RU-vid member for some bonus perks as well! - / @everydayastronaut
The best place for all your space merch needs!
everydayastronaut.com/shop/
All music is original! Check out my album "Maximum Aerodynamic Pressure" anywhere you listen to music (Spotify, iTunes, Google Play, Amazon, etc) or click here for easy links - everydayastronaut.com/music
I'm the cohost of an awesome podcast where we talk all about current technologies and how they shape our future! ourludicrousfuture.com or here on RU-vid / ourludicrousfuture

Наука

Опубликовано:

 

16 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 4,5 тыс.   
@miltonmiller
@miltonmiller 3 года назад
Nobody came up yet with "documentaries" about SpaceX so complete, well produced, and technically respectable like Tim Dodd does. Not Discovery channel, not BBC, not CNN, not Hollywood, not nobody.The technical quality of this channel, plus the cool sense of humor and lots of well expressed emotion, make this channel the very best. The very best. Yes I said it!
@omeraytekin7821
@omeraytekin7821 3 года назад
Agree a lot
@bluntly2165
@bluntly2165 3 года назад
Idk why you included the worst journalist organization (CNN) around when it comes to making a list of "best documentary" creators.... cnn doesn't do any kind of journalism
@f.w.1318
@f.w.1318 3 года назад
@ Bluntly, no kidding CNN lol!!! didnt they get busted by project veritas where they admitted they are just propaganda, CNN can’t make the news much less a docu series on space.
@FreeFlowNut
@FreeFlowNut 3 года назад
Well said Milton. Excellent video Tim. Enjoying the ride.
@user-zj2mb3sp3x
@user-zj2mb3sp3x 3 года назад
Tim would be a great contractor for NASA or spaceX. As a consultant, he could help produce video content for any space company that would be informative, down to earth for people of multiple ages to understand, and entertaining, while attracting new people to the world of space.
@remingtonjarvie5183
@remingtonjarvie5183 3 года назад
Everyday Astronaut videos are rare Thanksgivings dinners amongst all the youtube snacks we consume.
@georgeweed
@georgeweed 3 года назад
This is too real
@masterquacc
@masterquacc 3 года назад
Yes, I agree completely.
@adamrezabek9469
@adamrezabek9469 3 года назад
@@leafystreet9247 i think his main source of income is patreon
@jacobparks1
@jacobparks1 3 года назад
Lmao I was confused for a second but this makes perfect sense. They’re beefy and infrequent
@aloejamaica-ussemember7258
@aloejamaica-ussemember7258 3 года назад
Absolutely
@duderyandude9515
@duderyandude9515 3 года назад
I can’t even imagine how much goes into videos like this. The MASSIVE amount of research, the amount of scrolling through dry and boring articles and websites, and maybe books. Then the travelling, the filming, the editing, the script, the music, and the animations. You deserve every single subscriber you have, Tim.
@gormauslander
@gormauslander 3 года назад
7:27 When he said "Well how 'bout that" Humans are adorable
@ratemisia
@ratemisia 3 года назад
you can basically hear the smile on his face
@JZFeser
@JZFeser 3 года назад
He sounds so happy
@small_SHOT
@small_SHOT 4 месяца назад
you say that like you’re not a human
@gormauslander
@gormauslander 4 месяца назад
I say that like an anthropologist who, despite being human, finds humans interesting@@small_SHOT
@small_SHOT
@small_SHOT 4 месяца назад
@@gormauslander understandable
@Gregnier
@Gregnier 3 года назад
"Hi, it's me Tim Dodd, the Everyday Astronaut" *SLAMS the Like Button*
@martattacks
@martattacks 3 года назад
😆 same here
@blerimshakiri2614
@blerimshakiri2614 3 года назад
Hahahahaha nice
@NathanKliem
@NathanKliem 3 года назад
@Ojas Finally someone who reacts exactly like I do 🤣 *SLAM*
@iitzfizz
@iitzfizz 3 года назад
More like Every-now and then-Astronaut lol
@ChrisLarsson85
@ChrisLarsson85 3 года назад
@@iitzfizz 🤣
@Myrddnn
@Myrddnn 3 года назад
Gotta thank you, Tim. I'm a 66 year old retired engineer and I still learn something when you do one of these deep dives. Thank you much.
@charlielyth1982
@charlielyth1982 3 года назад
You're almost 69. nice
@nukedukem6
@nukedukem6 3 года назад
Get there and I'll congratulate you
@Myrddnn
@Myrddnn 3 года назад
@@nukedukem6 Huh?
@mr.mysteriousyt6118
@mr.mysteriousyt6118 3 года назад
@@Myrddnn i think he's drunk or misread maybe?
@ozonepat
@ozonepat 3 года назад
@@charlielyth1982 Are you @Davie504 in disguise?
@Grig9700
@Grig9700 3 года назад
It always shocks me just how high your production quality is, this is like a proper well done documentary, detailed, easy to understand, and explains it's topic thoroughly. Massive kudos and just as massive thanks to everyone whom has helped to make this in some form of way, your hard work is greatly appreciated!
@HarryMollyNut
@HarryMollyNut 3 года назад
Why is it a shock ? He is a documentary maker. The bigger shock is the misconception that all content produced for you tube is filmed on iphone. Come on.
@Grig9700
@Grig9700 3 года назад
@@HarryMollyNut It's not about me not believing youtubers to be capable of great things. This channel is a great example of just how high you can reach when you dedicate yourself to something. The shock, or surprise I suppose, comes from the reminder that it can be done so consistently at such a high quality. Multi million dollar studios with high budgets and teams with dozens of people don't always succeed in making good educational content. Everyday Astronaut though? I've only seen one knock out of the park after the other. Which is surprising, because it's *hard*. The surprise is not for a lack of expectations, it's for how they keep reaching and surpassing them every single time when doing something this difficult so incredibly well. The amount of effort that has to go into it is incredible to me, that's all ^^ I do wish you a wonderful day dear denizen of the internet, hope this little rant could clarify my comment a bit more.
@mgabrysSF
@mgabrysSF 2 года назад
@@HarryMollyNut What misconception? He almost lost some expensive cameras on one of the Starship launch failures.
@RickOAA
@RickOAA 3 года назад
RU-vid has suggested in conjunction to this "Why McDonald's Icecream Machines are Always Broken," a true mystery of our times.
@Andromedon777
@Andromedon777 3 года назад
Mine is Isaac Arthur 😛
@isaacnewton5364
@isaacnewton5364 3 года назад
I got the ice cream machine next to this too XD
@JG-yk6ny
@JG-yk6ny 3 года назад
Awesome Video too!
@WesleyDeGrooteAalst
@WesleyDeGrooteAalst 3 года назад
Haha, same here.
@emoney5367
@emoney5367 3 года назад
Dito,
@mohammedshaik9647
@mohammedshaik9647 3 года назад
It's been so long since Tim made an actual video like this. He's been so busy with livestreams and interviews. Huge respects!
@longboardfella5306
@longboardfella5306 3 года назад
Just yesterday I was thinking maybe Tim had stopped making vids and then this pops up. Magic!
@jefdamen2977
@jefdamen2977 3 года назад
Yes great show
@Verdigo76
@Verdigo76 3 года назад
Livestreams, interviews and this video!
@supersonic3675
@supersonic3675 3 года назад
2 smart ppl one thought on the profile pic 👍
@whitehatstudios3616
@whitehatstudios3616 3 года назад
hi its me your skin, I CRAVE hydration
@Petteri82
@Petteri82 3 года назад
Me: *has fun for 13 minutes* Tim: "Here's where the fun begins" It's an Everyday Astronaut video all right.
@jamesogle8421
@jamesogle8421 3 года назад
great line
@gatmguru1
@gatmguru1 3 года назад
Thank you for making this very complex issue simple to understand. This was a great video! Awesome job with all of your content and great job with your entire support team.
@Motorhead938
@Motorhead938 3 года назад
This did not feel like a 45 minute video at all. Love your channel thank you for all you do.
@chrisbotos
@chrisbotos 3 года назад
An american using SI units understanding that this is science we are talking about ,you have my respect sir.
@craigphd7844
@craigphd7844 3 года назад
He also has my respect. An American teacher I know, sometimes refers to Imperial measurement as the , 'American Measurement system'. (She did know that was not a correct statement, and apologises to Liberia and Myanmar).
@captainahab5522
@captainahab5522 3 года назад
As a British person who uses primarily SI units it is nice to be able to understand the video in units I understand I have no clue how Americans do calculations
@WireWhiz
@WireWhiz 3 года назад
@@captainahab5522 We use SI units. (At least I do for coding and 3D printing)
@otterylexa4499
@otterylexa4499 3 года назад
You may not be aware that American Customary Measures are subtly different from Imperial Measures, for example American pint is 473 ml versus 568 or 83% of the Imperial pint.
@gacherumburu9958
@gacherumburu9958 3 года назад
At least he ain't clinging on "freedom units".
@ethanreichard4658
@ethanreichard4658 3 года назад
WE HAVE BEEN BLESSED WITH A UPLOAD
@suchirghuwalewala
@suchirghuwalewala 3 года назад
Yes this is a dream
@suchirghuwalewala
@suchirghuwalewala 3 года назад
69 please
@suchirghuwalewala
@suchirghuwalewala 3 года назад
Why did u ruin it people i wanted a 69
@Jimmy_Jones
@Jimmy_Jones 3 года назад
@@TubbyJ420 English is great.
@jasonaustin2072
@jasonaustin2072 3 года назад
Next idea for SpaceX, turning Starship's hull into an electromagnet, then dropping it into a huge copper tube to scrub off speed!
@DistracticusPrime
@DistracticusPrime 3 года назад
In the time it takes the nay-sayers to laugh and prove how it's impossible, SpaceX would build five prototypes and the last two would work perfectly.
@Andromedon777
@Andromedon777 3 года назад
Lmao yes please
@esmenhamaire6398
@esmenhamaire6398 3 года назад
I like your kind of crazy! I wonder what the power requirements for such and the forces involved would be? Probably be eaier to hve teh electromagnet bit on the launchtower, too, so Starship doesnt have to haul extra gubbins around... hmmm
@kurtanddebbieveltre1375
@kurtanddebbieveltre1375 3 года назад
Yes. Yes. A comment from someone with Intellect! Lenz law in this matter is not gonna happen. You know that cause you were joking. The thing is your comment shows your brain is active! Awesome.
@TruthSeeker8717
@TruthSeeker8717 3 года назад
@@DistracticusPrime - Wishful thinking there buddy, but I suppose there's no harm in dreaming lol...
@mcctravel
@mcctravel 2 года назад
Tim, I’ve watched this before, when it first came out, then again today (Aug.17,’21). You’ve done an outstanding job explaining everything. Thanks for being an Everyday Astronaut for the rest of us.
@kworkshop
@kworkshop 3 года назад
Tim, the amount of effort you pour into your videos is insane, and I think I speak for the whole space community when I say we appreciate you more than imaginable! Thank you!
@TheFlickenbacke
@TheFlickenbacke 3 года назад
Totally agree to that.
@KevDreck
@KevDreck 3 года назад
I don't think so. Most of a time He's just a fanboy who made it past the cordon and pretends journalistic curiousity.
@flyingpugs3678
@flyingpugs3678 3 года назад
Ya
@timster5
@timster5 3 года назад
100%
@kworkshop
@kworkshop 3 года назад
@@KevDreck Are you kidding? His videos are incredibly detailed and informative, and his excitement in his streams is awesome for getting people hyped. Perfect combination in my opinion!
@chalklaterain6163
@chalklaterain6163 3 года назад
Get this man to 1 million subs! After this video specifically he is the undisputed best person documenting SpaceX and space related things, not even the actual professionals get this detailed.
@alanrickett2537
@alanrickett2537 3 года назад
The only improvement needed is to get him more help so we can have the videos and the launch live streams
@rogerfreeman6787
@rogerfreeman6787 3 года назад
He's the best for explaining technical details, and Angry Astronaut is the best at explaining the social and political aspects of space exploration.
@alanrickett2537
@alanrickett2537 3 года назад
@@rogerfreeman6787 AA is fun but you have to filter for his mistakes, Tim does a lot of fact checking , what about it and Marcus House filling the middle ground nicely
@rogerfreeman6787
@rogerfreeman6787 3 года назад
He's not perfect, and there is nobody else including Marcus House, (who I love to watch) who questions the status quo of space exploration in a meaningful way.
@alanrickett2537
@alanrickett2537 3 года назад
@@rogerfreeman6787 2 the future have ago but they are not a all space channel I think the issue is the traditional space fans are just so used to the grift they don't report it.
@MichaelBehrnsMiller
@MichaelBehrnsMiller 3 года назад
It's amazing that with the bellyflop, we are actually watching spaceflight fundamentally change in front of our eyes.
@jamesjanes7936
@jamesjanes7936 2 года назад
no we’re not. all these designs were thought of before
@zhongxina9420
@zhongxina9420 Год назад
@@jamesjanes7936 not the bellyflop tho
@edbrackin
@edbrackin 3 года назад
It's been a while since I watched one of your deep dive videos. Tim, you and your team really did a great job on this video.
@mathieuf.2430
@mathieuf.2430 3 года назад
I feel guilty of watching this video for free. I learnt in 45mins what I’ve learnt in 1 year of school. Thanks you Tim !
@rogerfreeman6787
@rogerfreeman6787 3 года назад
There are ways to alleviate your guilt in the description, I'm guessing.
@Gr8Success
@Gr8Success 3 года назад
stop farting around ...
@MajorPickleSwag
@MajorPickleSwag 3 года назад
Watch at 2x speed and youll learn more in 22.5 min than in 1 year of school 🤣
@rogerfreeman6787
@rogerfreeman6787 3 года назад
@@MajorPickleSwag That's objectively true.
@pendragnx
@pendragnx 3 года назад
man, if only we had videos as cool as this during physics class in school
@doodleboi7034
@doodleboi7034 3 года назад
"Right,Joe Barnard?" I died here. I mean,you're not wrong.
@artdonovandesign
@artdonovandesign 3 года назад
A man so thoroughly knowledgeable in his subject that he communicates it's complexities with perfect, clear ease. Thank you, Tim! A Fantastic video.
@Thomasvanos
@Thomasvanos 3 года назад
Watching starship explode whilst on tune with music is one of the most satisfying things i've ever seen
@chaus2358
@chaus2358 3 года назад
"nobody is riding a falcon 9 booster when it lands" me with a saddle, 3 ratchet straps, o2 tank, and a whole lot of ambition: "YET"
@msmyrk
@msmyrk 3 года назад
"Nothing that is physically possible is impossible"
@michaelbeee3801
@michaelbeee3801 3 года назад
Gironimoooooo
@ahamay2012
@ahamay2012 3 года назад
*Dr. Strangelove enters the chat*
@tonym480
@tonym480 3 года назад
@@ahamay2012 Yeeee Haaaa
@JanBruunAndersen
@JanBruunAndersen 3 года назад
@@ahamay2012 - that would be major Kong I believe.
@bigfish8280
@bigfish8280 3 года назад
I'm glad I found your Channel! Thanks for doing what you do. Thank you especially for the extremely viewer friendly experience you provide to us.
@RightWingNutter
@RightWingNutter 3 года назад
I pretty much knew this stuff, but this is the clearest exposition I've ever seen in one place. Very well done!
@matyastorok8624
@matyastorok8624 3 года назад
When an ad popped up during the video, I felt like, I was interrupted while watching a high quality movie. The amount of effort put into this video is just unbelievable. Thanks Tim for this, huge respect!
@joshuacheung6518
@joshuacheung6518 3 года назад
That's why i try to scrub through to get rid of the ads first
@aloejamaica-ussemember7258
@aloejamaica-ussemember7258 3 года назад
I felt the same way as well
@derekleiro
@derekleiro 3 года назад
As I was just about to sleep, Tim drops a 45 min video. Welp, postponing the sleep
@BALDO3
@BALDO3 3 года назад
Lol
@andreapan6667
@andreapan6667 3 года назад
scrubbing the sleep
@johns8065
@johns8065 3 года назад
@@andreapan6667 lol
@adamrezabek9469
@adamrezabek9469 3 года назад
@@karlwest437 you can watch it multiple times
@adamrezabek9469
@adamrezabek9469 3 года назад
@@andreapan6667 sleep is on hold
@popstardust1
@popstardust1 3 года назад
Tremendous effort to explain simply yet accurately the reasons why choosing belly flop...Amazing video delivered. Tim you rock!
@macromo
@macromo 3 года назад
You're the best rocket RU-vidr... You explain things with the right balance of technical knowledge and simple examples. Keep at it Tim! You rock!
@amoltandon2900
@amoltandon2900 3 года назад
Starship gives a whole new meaning to "pointy end up and flamey end down"
@garywiseman5080
@garywiseman5080 3 года назад
I wonder: Tim makes the longest RU-vid videos I watch, and they are way too short. How does he do that? Ultimately, he combines human passion, scientific rigor and curiosity. How cool is that?
@carljohan9265
@carljohan9265 3 года назад
How does he do that? Simple. Quality.
@jonahsgang8830
@jonahsgang8830 3 года назад
And he adds humour
@thomasgrimm1664
@thomasgrimm1664 3 года назад
Awesome graphics, Tim! It's hard to imagine how much work went into this video. Love your work!
@PeterArnold1969
@PeterArnold1969 3 года назад
Thank you so much, Prof. Dodd. This was a very enjoyable "lecture". You really did your homework on this video.
@carlosrivas5522
@carlosrivas5522 3 года назад
New t-shirt coming from Everyday Astronaut: "Nothing that is physically possible, is imposible"
@alexbrown4116
@alexbrown4116 3 года назад
I cant imagine the sheer amount of effort that went into this, well done Tim!
@Bitfire31337
@Bitfire31337 3 года назад
A review on a 45-minute video only seconds after release? That's some quick viewing right there 😄.
@bigpoop3073
@bigpoop3073 3 года назад
@@Bitfire31337 he viewed it in 60x speed
@alexbrown4116
@alexbrown4116 3 года назад
After following the rendering saga yesterday, I was commenting on the effort it took to make and get premiere to export not the content directly
@Bitfire31337
@Bitfire31337 3 года назад
@@alexbrown4116 Ah, didn't know of that "behind the scenes" stuff. Subscriber content?
@nextlaunch1
@nextlaunch1 3 года назад
@@Bitfire31337 on his Instagram and probably more detail in Patreon
@PedroRafael
@PedroRafael 3 года назад
Awesome dive into the big WHY bellyflop. Very good. I saw this yesterday, and as I was driving I remembered your analogy about breaking just enough to stop at the right time/place. Great analogy by the way! Thank you for this!
@vishutdhar
@vishutdhar 2 года назад
The quality of these videos is crazy I can’t believe it’s free
@markusd7619
@markusd7619 3 года назад
This is where you shine. Nobody does these type of videos better than you. Livestreams are good, but everyone does those, your documentary/ informative videos are unique and definitely separates you from others. I would focus more on these type of videos and then livestreams. This is your brand, this is why you have almost 1 million subscribers. Keep up the good work. Do what's best from your heart, not from the pressures of other people. “Never limit yourself because of others’ limited imagination; never limit others because of your own limited imagination.”
@sebastienmcgrath6077
@sebastienmcgrath6077 3 года назад
Just realized that Tim actually has a fighting chance at dear moon. He ticks all the boxes.
@Kevin-hb7yq
@Kevin-hb7yq 3 года назад
YES! He's learning on his own, kick him off the planet!
@timlawlor1184
@timlawlor1184 3 года назад
:)
@hououinkyouma5372
@hououinkyouma5372 3 года назад
If I remember correctly, didn't Maezawa say he wants artists or something aboard on the trip? How does Tim qualify for that?
@sebastienmcgrath6077
@sebastienmcgrath6077 3 года назад
@@hououinkyouma5372 All the music in his videos, he made. He is also a photographer. Check out his website.
@hououinkyouma5372
@hououinkyouma5372 3 года назад
@@sebastienmcgrath6077 Yea I have, and it's amazing content. But I'm skeptical that it's enough to be chosen among less than a dozen artists over the world. Idk man, the comment made me think there was something I didn't know lol
@rolandb.1866
@rolandb.1866 3 года назад
I like how I watched the whole video but already knew all of the answers to the questions mentioned. Great video!
@rorymiskimen5221
@rorymiskimen5221 3 года назад
Great job of explaining a very complicated maneuver. When I first heard about this I thought it was crazy, but it makes good sense when you break it down. Arguably the major issue so far hasn’t been the maneuver itself, it’s been getting the engines to reliably restart, I would assume they’ll get this to work. Have enjoyed watching your videos, I’m a PhD physicist, and keep doing what you’re doing!
@nickfosterxx
@nickfosterxx 3 года назад
40:00 "We need to fail down here, so we don't fail up there." Armstrong, N.
@goflex3304
@goflex3304 3 года назад
That guy broke Elon's heart tho.
@leafboye33
@leafboye33 3 года назад
@@goflex3304 i don't know what it'd be like to have my hero tell me to stop
@309Blink
@309Blink 3 года назад
If Neil were alive today to see NASA astronauts riding a falcon 9 into space, I feel he would have a very different opinion.
@rorykeegan1895
@rorykeegan1895 3 года назад
@@goflex3304 Armstrong got played ...
@JK-ci8uq
@JK-ci8uq 3 года назад
Imagine videos in school would be produced and explained at this quality.
@ramslade
@ramslade 3 года назад
Would be less boring and more educational and fun, compared to schools at this time.
@bigcountry908
@bigcountry908 3 года назад
I might have actually paid attention
@smartpmark
@smartpmark 3 года назад
@@bigcountry908 We watch this kind of videos in highschool a couple of years back(not everyday ofcourse). Believe me, it still gets boring asf. The only reason you like it now is because you are watching it at your leisure, but when it is sandwiched between your history class and going home, your butt will be itching to get out. No amount of quality videos will make school interesting for uninterested people like us.
@bigcountry908
@bigcountry908 3 года назад
@@smartpmark Truer words have never been spoken we got to watch the original planet earth docuflic when It came out in theaters as a biology class field trip still mostly just made fun of the penguins
@Sennahoj_DE_RLP
@Sennahoj_DE_RLP 3 года назад
When it wouldn't be school it would be very cool
@Darlan_SFS
@Darlan_SFS Год назад
bruh , i had no words to describe how good this guy is at telling us about starship or any rockets at all ,simply incredible
@gabrielesabbatino2460
@gabrielesabbatino2460 3 года назад
Thank you Tim! A huge tribute to your work! You make such complicate topics so easy to understand! Keep up the good work! Ciao from Italy!
@charlesgagne9691
@charlesgagne9691 3 года назад
I know for a fact if Tim had been teaching in my highschool about this subject, there would have been lineups of Engineers and Astronauts graduating every year. Respect!
@jathins6809
@jathins6809 3 года назад
Which school are you studying in?
@OldSonyMan
@OldSonyMan 3 года назад
Please define "fact" and state the relevant "facts" involved with this statement !
@brojay4387
@brojay4387 3 года назад
@@OldSonyMan I bet you’re fun at parties
@leevibyman2053
@leevibyman2053 3 года назад
@@brojay4387 lol
@leevibyman2053
@leevibyman2053 3 года назад
I agree that he's an excellent teacher.
@gabrielmalek7575
@gabrielmalek7575 3 года назад
I’m so glad we have Tim Dodd, who else would make videos like this man.
@DubFocus89
@DubFocus89 3 года назад
scott manley?
@dannydd6554
@dannydd6554 3 года назад
@@DubFocus89 Scott munley is good but everyday astronaut has a consistent fell and quality that I don’t think he could match
@snwendland
@snwendland 3 года назад
@@dannydd6554 The feel of his content is also wholly different by design. His is of a man that has a passion for space but only has the time of someone who has a different full-time job (which, of course not surprisingly, is exactly the case). The two wonderfully fill different complementary niches within the space content sector.
@drewlovely2668
@drewlovely2668 3 года назад
@@snwendland great way to describe the differences between the too, couldn't agree more
@adamrezabek9469
@adamrezabek9469 3 года назад
@@DubFocus89 my favourite analogy is that Scott Manley's video is like normal dinner, while Tim Dodd's video is like Christmas dinner.
@jameshammons2354
@jameshammons2354 3 года назад
I’ve always been enchanted about terminal velocity in a physic way and the feed back from my family and friends
@donsmith717
@donsmith717 2 года назад
Tim, you and Scott Manley do marvelous work. And without politics. Please don't stop -- ever.
@michaelhammond8215
@michaelhammond8215 3 года назад
When I saw how long this was I almost didn’t click. So glad I did. 45 minutes went by fast and answered all my layman’s questions. Thanks!
@stauber44
@stauber44 3 года назад
No space news from you as you said on Twitter. There are enough space news channels. You are our educator. And we love you for this. Awesome video!
@theFirstAidKit
@theFirstAidKit 3 года назад
I've seen this video at my recommendations a dozen times now so I had to click it. I figured I won't watch this 45 minute video because I know the answer. It's just about drag, air density, terminal velocity, fuel efficiency, costs and weight. It's simple really. I ended up watching the whole video and realized there was some stuff there that I didn't think about. But my conclusion is that your videos are so well made, I actually watched a 45 minute video that explained something I already knew.
@NikhilBhatta07
@NikhilBhatta07 3 года назад
I'm really a everyday person no knowledge of rockets engineering but your video hold me 45mins straight and had given lot's of knowledge thanks 😊 keep going
@AbiNubli
@AbiNubli 3 года назад
Imagine being inside while belly-flopping. And if the seat really does rotate and has its own stabilizer it's gonna be the coolest cockpit experience ever
@Mity_Mo
@Mity_Mo 3 года назад
Knott's Berry Farm, the swinging pirate ship. Same experience.
@Veldtian1
@Veldtian1 3 года назад
Yeah and what would you think the actual chances of surviving such ridiculously complex and structurally taxing maneuvers on a routine basis, basically this video was a perfect argument for a horizontal landing and take off SSTO like SKYLON, everyone's just so idiotically invested in the techno-cult of ELON and believe he is the only path to our salvation. It's nauseating.
@epiccollision
@epiccollision 3 года назад
@@Veldtian1 what? I’m no fan of Elon, but this seems like a lot of FUD because you don’t like him...do better loser.
@MikeC2K10
@MikeC2K10 3 года назад
Will they call it the Vomit Comet? Or maybe Tilt-a-Hurl?
@BootyWarrior80892
@BootyWarrior80892 3 года назад
@@Veldtian1 I’m pretty sure Elon isn’t the one solely advising/directing the engineering portion of this project. He has a smart time of physicists and engineers that have many ideas for landing, aerodynamics etc so if they want to try a belly flop and it works out who are you to critique it unless you have a better idea then by all means join the team and give advise instead of being a Debbie downer 😒🙄
@BigCar2
@BigCar2 3 года назад
This is the best video you've yet made.
@cy-one
@cy-one 3 года назад
I've just started the video. I'll measure it against his Raptor-engine-video :D
@jaakkopontinen
@jaakkopontinen 3 года назад
Starting here as well.
@myentertainment55
@myentertainment55 3 года назад
Video about raptor could be my favorite. And I have a suspicion that video about family of russian/soviet rockets will take the prize eventually. But yes - this video amongst his best work. Top two top three easily. I watched this video one time and I am going to rewatch it right away:) To suck up all the knowledge :D :D :D
@j-j-jingles4797
@j-j-jingles4797 3 года назад
I'll take your word for it. Just beginning
@MattH-wg7ou
@MattH-wg7ou 3 года назад
Yea that engine breakdown one was epic. THE definitive rocket engine video on the internet IMHO.
@davida6806
@davida6806 3 года назад
Wow Tim, that was the fastest 45 munutes I've experienced in a long long time and certainly the most interesting one I might ever have seen on RU-vid. I could have happily sat through another hour of the physics without any problems. If only it had been that rewarding at school I might well have followed that path instead of the electronics one. You have an admirable knack for explaining things and captivating your audience at the same time. I'm now going to try to watch everything you've produced to satisfy my quest for knowledge. It might be a little late for me as my career has now come to an end and instead I can watch the next generation of engineers like yourself, push the boundaries. Thank you for a thoroughly enjoyable 45 minutes, I am a little wiser for it now as well. 😃😂👍👍
@k.sullivan6303
@k.sullivan6303 2 года назад
This guy is the GOAT with Rocket videos that explain thing clearly, and in laymen's terms.
@SRFriso94
@SRFriso94 3 года назад
"Today, we're going to be covering the wonders of terminal velocity, thrust to weight ratio, and engine throttling..." Hold on there, tiger, RU-vid might consider this too sexy for their platform.
@adamrezabek9469
@adamrezabek9469 3 года назад
the fact that this comment has 69 likes...
@Swaggerswine
@Swaggerswine 3 года назад
I want to like so bad, but the # of likes...
@adamrezabek9469
@adamrezabek9469 3 года назад
@@Swaggerswine someone ruined it, time to remove my like
@miltonmiller
@miltonmiller 3 года назад
Imagine the day some engineer at SpaceX, attending a meeting, took a water bottle and explained the entire insane idea to everyone, including Elon Musk, and then when done they look around and nobody was laughing....
@aljon5947
@aljon5947 3 года назад
Imagine the day spaceX doesnt explode their rocket 15times before getting a single good landing.
@mertkocogullar6485
@mertkocogullar6485 3 года назад
Water bottles make sense
@TheBest14184
@TheBest14184 3 года назад
@@aljon5947 hmm you mean yesterday?
@2KOOLURATOOLGaming
@2KOOLURATOOLGaming 3 года назад
@@aljon5947 huh? That's just how they do it. Can you tell me about another company that has rockets which have been flown seven times??
@johndododoe1411
@johndododoe1411 3 года назад
@@2KOOLURATOOLGaming Don't forget the STS Shuttles.
@BenMossWoodward
@BenMossWoodward 3 года назад
Thank you Tim, I love your long form content, explaining ALL THE THINGS
@mikeb1013
@mikeb1013 3 года назад
Your explanation videos are just fantastic. You have a great talent for explaining this stuff. Thanks for keep producing these.
@CyberSamurai4Life
@CyberSamurai4Life 3 года назад
Nobody else has such quality content on TY as Tim. This video sets a new standard. WOW! I’m blown away how good this one was. As a long time fan, of you and the space community on TY, Bravo Tim. Standing Ovation.
@aloejamaica-ussemember7258
@aloejamaica-ussemember7258 3 года назад
Can't wait to see some more in the near future
@user-zj2mb3sp3x
@user-zj2mb3sp3x 3 года назад
I REALLY LIKE HOW YOU'RE FOCUSING ON QUALITY VIDEOS RATHER THAN QUANTITY OF VIDEOS. MOST RU-vidRS WANT MORE CONTENT SO THEY CAN MAKE MORE MONEY, INSTEAD YOU'RE FOCUSED ON INFORMATION AND QUALITY. I APPRECIATE YOU.
@ab8jeh
@ab8jeh 3 года назад
Your caps lock is on.
@user-zj2mb3sp3x
@user-zj2mb3sp3x 3 года назад
@@ab8jeh yes, CAPSLOCK GETS PEOPLES ATTENTION IN A SEA OF COMMENTS. Learn how to stand out in a cRoWd It'Ll Do YoU gReAt.
@nooneno12
@nooneno12 3 года назад
@@user-zj2mb3sp3x or get skipped over for trying to get attention. In this forum people skim over the comments to look for ones worth reading - going all caps to get noticed, just gets you noticed as a 'do not bother reading this comment' - for instance even commentating over this baiting i couldn't be bothered to read your comment.
@defenestrated23
@defenestrated23 3 года назад
@@ab8jeh CAPS LOCK IS CRUISE CONTROL FOR COOL.
@ab8jeh
@ab8jeh 3 года назад
@@defenestrated23 AMEN TO THAT
@aBagOfHair
@aBagOfHair 3 года назад
First time watching one of your videos. Really enjoyed it; brought back some old information from university I had long since forgotten. Going to sift through your other vids now! Love it..
@bockenfels2021
@bockenfels2021 3 года назад
Everyday Astronauts, you have transcended, raised the bar, characteristic of a mature/seasoned Public Affairs organization. Your abilities to inform/teach using plainspoken language is truely a gift. Thank you all for your work, tenacity towards communication excellence! V/R Beeman of truely
@sloma111
@sloma111 3 года назад
11:07 I love how the "VELOCITY" changes to "VELCOTIY" there. So human ;)
@TusharGoyal1997
@TusharGoyal1997 3 года назад
It is midnight local time, and this is a 45 minute video. Friday FTW. Thanks Tim, for timing it perfectly!
@kamikaz1k
@kamikaz1k 2 года назад
Just found you, and man, this is some of the best content on RU-vid. You're an excellent explainator.
@kenreed5154
@kenreed5154 3 года назад
Such an AWESOME video! You do a fantastic job of explaining this! I am sharing it with my engineering friends.
@codycoker7176
@codycoker7176 3 года назад
These longer videos are a real gift. Thank you for all your hard work, Tim!
@myfavoritemartian1
@myfavoritemartian1 3 года назад
Although I studied this area in college back in the 1960's, Tim covered 6 months in 45 minutes. Proof that our educational system is not world class. He presented the subject in a linear manner and assembled it like building an onion, layer by layer. Another hit Tim!
@majoromg449
@majoromg449 3 года назад
Yeah, but you didn't gain any new skills. Understandably, Tim didn't go into the maths, therefore you're not able to reproduce those intricate landing profiles, for instance. So no, Tim didn't cover six months in 45 minutes, but it's still a great video giving insights in this topic.
@myfavoritemartian1
@myfavoritemartian1 3 года назад
@@majoromg449 I find it sad when you can not even complement someone without a negative commenter.
@majoromg449
@majoromg449 3 года назад
@@myfavoritemartian1I find it sad when you can not complement somebody without exaggeration.
@myfavoritemartian1
@myfavoritemartian1 3 года назад
@@majoromg449 Careful, your O.C is showing.....(Ask your doctor) I grant you the last word, I know you need it.
@karlkarlsson9126
@karlkarlsson9126 3 года назад
Ahhh, humanity in a nutshell
@kenwhitfield219
@kenwhitfield219 3 года назад
EXCELLENT!! Explaining a concept so that anyone can understand it is very helpful effort! You explained this with concepts and words that even a layman or laywoman should be able to understand. The braking car example was very effective. Also your explanation of rapid prototyping is right on point. Great job.
@ritasseremba6435
@ritasseremba6435 Год назад
Fantastic viewing and listening..can’t understand everything but I love the choreography of the starship ..it’s magic!
@nancybrady3033
@nancybrady3033 3 года назад
Thanks so much! Love that you gave us a transcript as well. My husband and I literally were having this discussion earlier in the day, then found your video. Great minds....😊
@rocketsocks
@rocketsocks 3 года назад
This is the first science youtube video I've ever seen that has used newtons for weight. I salute you sir.
@gehtdichnixan4704
@gehtdichnixan4704 3 года назад
Yeah, big shoutout for using metric 100%! Wake up, America.
@77gravity
@77gravity 3 года назад
AND just giving us the Metric values, without also saying the archaic ones.
@thiago_oliv
@thiago_oliv 3 года назад
This is the first video I'm watching on this channel. Made me subscribe. Amazing content!
@harryburnett7086
@harryburnett7086 3 года назад
Man love this channel, just wish i was more mathematical i love your presentation and its the best ive seen so far , but i really want to thank you for the graphics and illustrations it makes me understand a smidgen more
@TheArtofCraftsmanship
@TheArtofCraftsmanship 3 года назад
Great deep dive! Like every great pursuit, the more you learn... the more exciting it is. Thank you for this!
@goodboionly4075
@goodboionly4075 3 года назад
helo
@pnwlife8593
@pnwlife8593 3 года назад
@@goodboionly4075 ahlo
@XBlueBeam
@XBlueBeam 3 года назад
@@pnwlife8593 elo
@hunterkudo9832
@hunterkudo9832 3 года назад
I like how people are underestimating Blue Origin, just like they did SpaceX. They will soon be proven wrong.
@shawndouglass2939
@shawndouglass2939 3 года назад
@@hunterkudo9832 what will they be proven wrong about?
@digit975
@digit975 3 года назад
Man I’ve been waiting a long time for this video. You’re a legend, Tim!
@2atalkandpolitics422
@2atalkandpolitics422 3 года назад
still a bit over my head especially the plumbing but i get some of it. Thank you so much tim for what you do! Go SpaceX!
@jupiter2142
@jupiter2142 3 года назад
We were waiting this for so long I saw on olf and it was worth waiting
@NicholasRehm
@NicholasRehm 3 года назад
Don't have the time to watch now, but saving this to watch later before bed :) P.S. Tim, have you seen my RC starship that can bellyflop?
@dunneincrewgear
@dunneincrewgear 3 года назад
We demand to see your RC Starship!!!
@small_SHOT
@small_SHOT 3 года назад
@@dunneincrewgear yus
@FrancescoSpace
@FrancescoSpace 3 года назад
*Why does Starship bellyflop? Very simple, because Elon is a madlad.* 🤣
@zyansheep
@zyansheep 3 года назад
Absolute madlad
@kjorndogg3244
@kjorndogg3244 3 года назад
The maddest lad
@FrancescoSpace
@FrancescoSpace 3 года назад
Maddest of the maddest.
@Jason-gq8fo
@Jason-gq8fo 3 года назад
hes such a madlad hes already bored of the flip and wants to catch both stages
@thesteaksaignant
@thesteaksaignant 3 года назад
The laddest mad
@dekaysparda8149
@dekaysparda8149 3 года назад
Your Videos are just awesome, they really have the quality and structure of a big scientific paper, and you really make it easy to understand for everyone, you really stay true to bringing space and science "down to earth" for everybody, , thank you ! I usually dont watch much livestreams, but your Live coverage of Starship tests and spacex missions is really well done, i always look forward for the streams , and even take a day off work because im here in germany and sometimes the launches are in the middle of the night for me, i even got my whole Family hyped for Starship and Space missions in general with your videos .
@gregmihran8616
@gregmihran8616 3 года назад
Dude, u will get to 1M subscribers with this amazing video! CONGRATULATIONS in advance of that :)
@saraag6632
@saraag6632 3 года назад
These deep-dive videos keep getting better and better, can't wait for future deep-dives like this.
@AquaFish_stachooo
@AquaFish_stachooo 3 года назад
Sooo much quality in this video! Have a nice evening everyone
@PetterBruland
@PetterBruland 3 года назад
This was a pure joy to watch! Thank you so much for making a great entertaining educational video.
@conlethbyrne4809
@conlethbyrne4809 3 года назад
That video was awesome, only thing is I will need to watch it again & again 😅👍LOL Great stuff man.
@ryanqualley8143
@ryanqualley8143 3 года назад
Thank you for all that you do. I’ve been following starship for a while and I think I know a decent but about it and this maneuver but nonetheless I’m still learning. I love everything you do, I always learn so so much and all of us appreciate it more than you’ll ever know.
@Fs13900
@Fs13900 3 года назад
I passed on this video to a friend’s kids who are in high school and they’ve said you got them hooked to physics! Great work Tim, love these deep dives.
@jasoncarto
@jasoncarto 3 года назад
I still have to remind myself that easy ideas such as gravity, drag, and terminal velocity are completely new subjects to many youtube's who SHOULD be past the age where they were supposed to have learned this.
@cpufreak101
@cpufreak101 3 года назад
Ball Earth is too much for some people to grasp after all
@iandennis1
@iandennis1 3 года назад
Great documentary Tim. Well worth the wait
@amoltandon2900
@amoltandon2900 3 года назад
You know Tim is doing something right when the video has 0 dislikes.
@kjorndogg3244
@kjorndogg3244 3 года назад
2K likes and no dislikes, the best ratio i’ve ever seen
@amoltandon2900
@amoltandon2900 3 года назад
@iksdegosciu Obviously mis-clicks, since no one in the right mind would dislike such an informative, fun video. Or they're the corpses of SN8, 9, 10, and 11, wondering why their bellyflops didn't go to plan.
@atemoc
@atemoc 3 года назад
@@amoltandon2900 But all the bellyflops were 100% successful... Only the final landings weren't :p
@amoltandon2900
@amoltandon2900 3 года назад
​@@atemoc Well, SN11 experienced a RUD right before its bellyflop; and the landings have been 100% unsuccessful. Basically, SpaceX has a lot of stuff to figure out.
@Anonymous-ee8ef
@Anonymous-ee8ef 3 года назад
@@amoltandon2900 right before the flip the bellyflop was good
@ivantimofeev2233
@ivantimofeev2233 3 года назад
I have seen no one explaining SpaceX where abouts sooo technically accurate as you do Tim I think this might be the reason Elon feels so comfortable speaking to you (he usually stutters a lot and pauses very frequently) and is so passionate about it THANK YOU TIM, your videos are not just for every day people, but also very enjoyable by people from the industry like me, thanks for your excitement and hard work
@JoeyLutes
@JoeyLutes 3 года назад
I came to find the music you used and.. it's you?? WOW, you're amazing!!
@TheArtyBartfast
@TheArtyBartfast 3 года назад
This is the deep content that I crave!!! Tim is offering something so unique and amazing - like James Burke for rockets.
Далее
SLS VS Starship: Why does SLS still exist?!
49:21
Просмотров 3,3 млн
What Should Be Next? 👀🤯
00:56
Просмотров 8 млн
Самый надежный автомобиль
01:00
Просмотров 636 тыс.
The Insane Engineering of the F-117 Nighthawk
27:37
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Are Aerospikes Better Than Bell Nozzles?
1:01:31
Просмотров 3,8 млн
Why won’t Starship have an abort system? Should it?!
48:44
The Biggest BOOMS in Rocket History
33:46
Просмотров 2,8 млн
iPhone 12 socket cleaning #fixit
0:30
Просмотров 38 млн
solve bubbling fan issue
0:24
Просмотров 2,6 млн