Тёмный

Why I am not a liberal 

Taimur_Laal
Подписаться 236 тыс.
Просмотров 40 тыс.
50% 1

Why I am not a liberal.
It is not because it demands political and social equality that I oppose this liberalism but because it is blind to the fact that these goals cannot exist with capitalist exploitation that I oppose liberalism. Ultimately the goals of liberalism of the emancipation of the individual can only be achieved with the end of economic exploitation. Failure to recognise this is liberalism’s greatest failure.

Опубликовано:

 

11 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 202   
@DearZainOfficial
@DearZainOfficial 4 года назад
Sir i am from Rural punjab i am doing B.A privately but because of your lectures now i consider myself that i am studying in Lums Thanks God bless you
@Taimur_Laal
@Taimur_Laal 4 года назад
Ali Zain you made my day.
@mehreenbukahri6118
@mehreenbukahri6118 3 года назад
This is the beauty of social media.
@MusicLover-rv1uu
@MusicLover-rv1uu Год назад
How can you follow him when you are a thiest?
@auyoobmir9190
@auyoobmir9190 5 лет назад
Sir I'm visually impaired person I'm pursuing BA hons political science. Sir I'm taking much benefit from your lectures. Sir please upload lectures about political theory, modern political thought and other such topics That will be your most kindness
@Shakeelsway
@Shakeelsway 5 лет назад
Your lectures on philosophy are awesome. Your ideology is inspiring.
@CheMuru91
@CheMuru91 5 лет назад
Lala salam from Ladakh Kargil Jammu and Kashmir. I am proud of u sir.....
@rajvanshiaditya
@rajvanshiaditya 3 года назад
،کیا آپ ملحد ھیں؟
@mul-el3657
@mul-el3657 2 года назад
@@rajvanshiaditya Hai bhi toh kya problem hai?
@awaisahmed8095
@awaisahmed8095 Год назад
@@mul-el3657 communist revolutionary ki pic daikh ker bol raha hai
@muhammadnadeem3467
@muhammadnadeem3467 4 года назад
میں دینی مدرسے کا طالب علم ہوں اور آپ سے بہت کچھ سیکھنے کو ملتا ہے اللہ آپ کو سلامت رکھے آمین ثم آمین
@janmohammadabbasi7565
@janmohammadabbasi7565 2 года назад
Sir , you are living legend ... Much respect from Sindh
@talhasohrababbasi8314
@talhasohrababbasi8314 2 года назад
جب تک ہم کسی کو معاشی طور پر مظبوط نہیں کر یں گے اس وقت تک اور دوسرے حقوق کی بات ایک تصور سے زیادہ کچھ نہیں۔ آپ کا نقطہ ایک جاندار اور مستقیل تبدیلی کی ضمانت ہے ۔
@ghulambrohi8637
@ghulambrohi8637 5 лет назад
آپ کی رہنمائی ہمارے لئے موجودہ حالات میں انتہائی اہم ہے لال سلام سر
@Happify-hb4mr
@Happify-hb4mr 3 месяца назад
sir you are amazing .basically , I am doing BS computer but I really like to hear you.. God bless you sir.
@zman7874
@zman7874 3 года назад
Mr. Taimoor you sound like Dr. Richard Wolff. I like it. Proud of you. 👍👍👍
@shamsniazi6960
@shamsniazi6960 2 года назад
Thanku you sir..u have productive nd conceptual lectures...sir one video on Chinese political system which is a blending of socialism nd capitalism...my concepts are not cleared about it..kindly one video on it
@northlander222
@northlander222 4 года назад
Sir,pls upload video on Muslim Political Thought. I am a student of Political Science;your videos are the main source of my understanding of Pol Science.
@amritenduacharjee4578
@amritenduacharjee4578 3 года назад
Sir please make a video on Rosa Luxembourg and explain her difference in ideology with Lenin..I am a fan of you from India
@khatirbehlol1449
@khatirbehlol1449 4 года назад
Thank u doc sb, i had a great confusion of this liberal hypocracy before
@ISLAMIC_REELS-281
@ISLAMIC_REELS-281 3 года назад
Allah (SWT) bless you sir you explained liberalism very beautifully.
@QIKZBB
@QIKZBB 5 лет назад
Thanks! Please explain the government structure under socialist regime in next lecture. How we can check the power of government Offical in communism and what's the guarantee that they will not accumulate power and authority. Eg, Stalin ruled for more than 30 years please explain
@aliasadullah1000
@aliasadullah1000 Год назад
I came here from MTJ video your reply to people in comments and I feel that with all due respect we shall not criticize peace spreading scholars like MTJ. Rest I learnt more about liberalism from your video thank you for cleaning the point.
@planetamazing93
@planetamazing93 5 лет назад
Sir aap ki videos bohat informative hoti hain. Please Pakistan prison system k bary main videos banai. Criminology students k bohat acha rahega. Shukria
@moazzamshehzad715
@moazzamshehzad715 5 лет назад
Dear sir, you are infact great blessing on us ...thank u for accommodating us with best possible knowldge..
@vishal_halder
@vishal_halder 4 года назад
English subtitles please!!
@drmdsuhail3757
@drmdsuhail3757 4 года назад
بہت خوب سر! میں آپ کی اکثر وییڈیوسنتا ہوں ،کیونکہ اس میں صرف علمی نکات ہی ہوتے ہیں اور بہت ہی معتدل بھی۔ سر! آپ سے ایک طالب علمانہ درخواست ہے کہ آپ ویڈیوں کے اخیر میں اس موضوع سے متعلق کتابوں کا بھی تذکرہ کردیں ، خواہ وہ کتب اردومیں ہوں یا انگریزی میں ۔ تاکہ ہم طلبہ ان کتب سے مزید استفادہ کرسکیں ۔ کیونکہ تاریخ اور سیاسیات کے موضوع پر اردو میں عوامی کتابیں کم ہیں ۔ آپ کی نظر سے اردو میں جو کتابیں ہو ں ، ان کا تذکرہ ضرور کردیں۔ یہ ہم۔طلبہ کیلئے بہت ہی اچھا ہوگا
@GeorgeBletchly
@GeorgeBletchly 4 года назад
Any chance of doing an English version?. I discovered your videos quite recently and find them very informative and thought-provoking. Thank you for the work you've done so far.
@iranunsc2824
@iranunsc2824 4 года назад
He is basically saying that how socialists also believe in many same things which liberals also do like....Secularism and gender equality.... He says that liberals concepy of freedom for all is a masked form of capitalistic oppression.Like liberals also believe if workers should get parts of the profit by operating the factory then it is taking away the right of the entrepreneur...Liberalism basically supports individual rights to such an extent that indirectly it also supports oppression of workers....Hope it helped you this was what he meant
@subhabaskaran1849
@subhabaskaran1849 3 года назад
@@iranunsc2824 that doesn't mean conservatives is better both have their up and down I hate it when conservatives think their better
@ihx7
@ihx7 2 года назад
@@iranunsc2824 but thats literally liberatarian if companies have no regulation then they will just exploit people while the right liberal laws will prevent that while still giving entrepreneurs rights his argument is flawed
@daniyalkhan8443
@daniyalkhan8443 5 лет назад
khair i am from Karachi and i am a very big fan of urs
@ansari000000
@ansari000000 4 года назад
اپ کہتے ھیں کہ انسان اور اس کی سوچ وقت کے سا تھ ارتقاء پزیر ھو ئ ھیں۔ تو اب انسان کو اس کے خالق نے جو أخری ہدایت نامہ دیا اس میں واضح ہے کہ اب نظام صرف رب العالمین کا ھو گا ۔۔۔۔۔خود مسلمانوں اور اقلیتوں کو انصاف صرف ہہی نظام دیے سگتا ہے۔ نا کہ انسان کے بناۓ ہوۓ نظام۔ رب کے نظام حکومت ( خلافت ) کے فلسفہ کو سمجھنے کی ضرورت ھے
@QasimKehar
@QasimKehar 5 лет назад
Excellent justification. That's time to explain this question or situation. Lall Sallam
@mrhaks2043
@mrhaks2043 4 года назад
Dr Sahab. Please libralism pr aik separate lecture video bnain jis main libralism ki history aur mazeed malomat ho.
@ravimundawar5996
@ravimundawar5996 5 лет назад
Hi sir nice to hear u 🙏👍👌
@sarfrazsae9226
@sarfrazsae9226 11 месяцев назад
What is difference between man and women? It is like sun and earth. From sun you get all kind of energy while earth provide you material grounds what you need. So, although you have equality issue but what is reality behind the scene is more important. In further approach, this quality being woman (getting low pressure to let the others make you move) is not limited in woman but this is mother nature of every nan. It is beauty of this world if someone trying to understand this.
@karimkhoshan1274
@karimkhoshan1274 2 года назад
Sir what ever ideology you belong and belief it's your personal decision but the way you are explaining every concept is just phenomenal,most sagacious man i have ever seen on youtube.Continue shining man
@MuhammadYounas-gl6sn
@MuhammadYounas-gl6sn 5 лет назад
Sir, we are hopefully waiting for your lectures on political philosophy
@rangeensindh4826
@rangeensindh4826 5 лет назад
Tamaam behtreen sir me ap ka har lecture sunti hon or me bhi Socialism se bohot mutasir hon or mazeed samjhne ki koshish kar rahi hon. Mujhe ye samjh me nahi aa raha k agar socialism awamunnas k liye itna hi faidemand hai to ku har riyasat is ko accept nahi karti or un par pabandi laga deti hai.
@daudkhan6198
@daudkhan6198 2 года назад
Sir also make a video on the consequences of liberalism on Pakistan economy.
@aroobsadiq3389
@aroobsadiq3389 3 года назад
Sir you are amazing.. I have no words to appreciate you.. Keep it up..
@ahsanaliahsanali2711
@ahsanaliahsanali2711 3 года назад
Kindly upload lecture on comparison of classical realism and classical liberalism
@nerdy4172
@nerdy4172 3 года назад
Sir I think it’s not fair to equalise outcomes. I also believe that everyone should be given equal opportunity like health care and education system should be free. And possession of capital must be limited. But we cannot diminish hierarchies completely. Hierarchies are inevitable for a competitive environment. And competitive environment is our only hope towards improvement of our future.
@piyariislamidunya7212
@piyariislamidunya7212 5 лет назад
اس وقت لے دے کر دنیا میں سچے کمیونسٹ یا سوشلٹ صرف دو ہی ملک رہ گئے ہیں ایک شمالی کوریا اور دوسرا وینزوویلا ۔۔۔ جبکہ سرمایہ دار ممالک اب بھی کافی ہیں کینیڈا امریکہ آسٹریلیاء نیوزی لینڈ جنوبی کوریا برطانیہ فرانس جاپان اور بھی بہت سے ہیں ۔۔۔۔ان تمام ممالک میں سوائے انڈیا کے سب جگہ عوام کی حالت بہت بہتر ہے ہر طرح کی عوامی آزادی حاصل ہے وہاں مزہبی آزادیاں بھی ہیں اور جنسی آزادیاں بھی ہیں ۔ معاشی آزادی بھی ہے اور سیاسی آزادی بھی ۔۔۔عوام خوشحال ہیں ہر جگہ آجا سکتے ہیں ۔۔۔انکی صحیت صفائی تعلیم سفری سہولیات خوراک کا معیار قابل رشک ہے ۔۔
@revolutionary1917
@revolutionary1917 5 лет назад
sajida saleem سوائے انڈیا کے باقی سب سامراجی دور سے گزر چکے ہیں اور پوری دنیا سے دولت ملٹی نیشنلز کے زریعہ اگھٹی کر رہے ہیں امریکہ کا Per capita income پینسٹھ ہزار ڈالر اسی وجہ سے ہے کیونکہ پاکستان کا سولہ ہزار ڈالر ہے کیا امریکہ والے چوبیس میں سے تیس گھنٹے کام کرتے ہیں اور پاکستان والے کرتے ہی نہیں ؟
@umroyaar
@umroyaar 5 лет назад
Hello sir how are you? Sir me ap se demand krta hun k please conspiracy theories k against videos bnaen jo hmari society k mind me poison ki tarah phail rhi hen
@A.SMotivation-ii1wk
@A.SMotivation-ii1wk 3 месяца назад
❤❤❤❤❤❤ great sir
@islamicspeech612
@islamicspeech612 3 года назад
Love u sir
@fawadkhan-xp6li
@fawadkhan-xp6li 3 года назад
it means sir you are against on the point of economic policy of liberalism.
@Taimur_Laal
@Taimur_Laal 3 года назад
Definitely. And much more.
@sayyednavidchannel-5928
@sayyednavidchannel-5928 4 года назад
Ye musalmaan hai jinhe Dekh ke sharmaye yahood Hegle aor Karl Marx samajhne se koi Salim ya ilm wala Nahi hojata hai. Jab Deen ko siyasat se alag hone Ka tasawwur Diya Jata hai to ye baat Tai hai ke insaan ye kah Raha hai ke aap Ka mazhab ek na mukammal mazhab hai aor masjide sirf ek mazhab Ka adda hai jaha Chand daqyanoosi log jama hote hai Jo dunya ki samajh se bahot door hai inke haatho me mulk Nahi Diya ja Sakta Nahi in me qaabiliyat hai k ye mulk ka Baar utha sakte hai Isi ko narrow thinking Kaha jaata hai aor yahi mazhabi bezari ki pahli seedhi hai jaha se insaan musalmaan kahlaya ja Sakta hai sirf uske naam ki bunyaad par na ke uske amal se
@naseer5424
@naseer5424 5 лет назад
...Dear Sir! You could have given some socialist & liberal countries examples.
@fazeelurrehmanghumman5768
@fazeelurrehmanghumman5768 5 лет назад
Sir Islam has a proper political system.How can you say that religion has nothing to do with politics??With Islamic political system ,Umar ibn khattab (R.A) conquered the two super powers Roman and Persian empire ##we want Islamic political system in Pakistan##
@enlightenmentlearning3372
@enlightenmentlearning3372 3 года назад
Conquering isn't politics or being political. It is being power hungry and expansionism.
@IrfanKhan-resistance
@IrfanKhan-resistance 3 года назад
Islamic political system pathar ke zamanay ka qabza group ki ideology. Difa krny ka haq hae islam mein. Mulk mulk taskheer aur fatohat ka nae. Jarhiat krna, qabzay krna, zameeno ki hawas geeri. Loot maar krna aur logo ko majbor krna mazhab tabdeel krny par. Islam sirf daawat ka naam tha. Musalmano ne zaati mafaad ke lya hadees banaen aur apni marzi ka islam banaya ke woh apne mafaadat ko islam ka rang desaken aur usko qanooni ijazat mil sakay. Islam ka political system aj ke Democratic zamanay ka nae. Na he agsr usko hum follow nae kren to koy burai nae. Koy es se kafir nae hojata. Hum democracy ko pasand krty hn jo asal islam hae. Aur Pakistan mein badshahat he yha haqeeqi democracy nae rahi. Yeh sub zia ul haq aur ayub khan ke laye hwe log hen.
@muazamhanif6079
@muazamhanif6079 Год назад
Oh There's an inherent contradiction in the philosophy of Liberalism
@umroyaar
@umroyaar 5 лет назад
Sir me ap se poochna chahta hun k ap keh rhe hen k socialist society me individually religion pe koi pabandi nai hoti to phir Soviet Union me buht se Churches aur Mosques ko kyun bnd kr dia gya tha! Please is ka answer de den.
@dilshadimon4402
@dilshadimon4402 4 года назад
www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1905/dec/03.htm request you to read this
@ahmedvanya8840
@ahmedvanya8840 4 года назад
I recently discovered your RU-vid channel. You are very learned and very good at explaining difficult concepts both in Urdu and in English. However, I have some problem with your view in this video. I do not think any society can have complete economic equality as you are idealistically suggesting. Your example where 10% are capitalists and the rest are workers is just an extreme example and a straw man that just proves your point. What about a society where most people are middle class and you have extremes at both ends? That is more realistic and better achievable. Do a better job at explaining why you are a socialist and NOT a liberal. Thank you.
@factsoftheworld4297
@factsoftheworld4297 3 года назад
I agree you sir because classical liberalism is the best ideology implemented in a state , and it has less flaws then the socialism . But when the gap between poor and the rich is so much then the poor people would want a socialist state and rich a liberal state. And being a Muslim the very first point in the liberal ideology government will only interfere when it comes to human rights violating ...... But in islam (Amar bin mahroof wah nhi anil munkiir) when you see a person doing wrong act then do an action against him. Like drinking a wine ...... Either this act has no affect on the society until he get involves in some bad act but what about the codes given by the teaching of islam.
@maybepriyansh9193
@maybepriyansh9193 3 года назад
But thats not the case in reality and in a capitalist structure it will always be so.
@maratheom
@maratheom 4 года назад
Sir, your opposition to liberalism is only based on problems related to the right to property. Is it fair to discredit liberalism in its entirety and the basket of freedoms it brings just on this one point. After all, Thinking and writing about communism was only possible for Marx when he was living in liberal Britain.
@Taimur_Laal
@Taimur_Laal 4 года назад
maratheom yes it’s fair because the other conceptions of liberalism are derived from this core principle. And that is why the other principles leave much to be desired. Yes liberal societies are better than monarchies. No doubt about that.
@ashfaqkhan5630
@ashfaqkhan5630 4 года назад
sir aap ney liberalism ko bohut achy tarah explain keya awr capitalism ko be...sir mere opinion , mazhab sirf ebadat ka name nahi .mazhb may seyast awr aw maesht bhi hy.
@roadtosuccess5408
@roadtosuccess5408 5 лет назад
Will you upload a vedio on IS MORAL FREEDOM GOOD FOR EVERY INDIVIDUAL BY immanual kant .plzzz
@AmjadKhan-xs1kf
@AmjadKhan-xs1kf 3 года назад
Facts
@amarjyotiroychowdhury3307
@amarjyotiroychowdhury3307 3 года назад
Sir, in a liberal thought, what if an industry is owned privately but around 49 percent of the shares are distributed among the workers. Will this system work on the theory of equality?
@zafarjaved907
@zafarjaved907 5 лет назад
What should be a viable electoral system in Pakistan based on social Democracy? Can you give a detailed system on the basis of your education & experience????? hopefully looking for
@renedescartes7540
@renedescartes7540 5 лет назад
Combine liberal democracy with socialism just like in Nordic countries where they have social democratic model.
@salmanpsd262
@salmanpsd262 5 лет назад
LAAL SALAM 🙌
@fazeelurrehmanghumman5768
@fazeelurrehmanghumman5768 5 лет назад
In islamic political system,minorities have there right.They have fully freedom to worship and practice there religion.It is the responsibility of Islamic government to protect there life,wealth and dignity
@mul-el3657
@mul-el3657 2 года назад
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-LajSmnUmz9A.html
@mul-el3657
@mul-el3657 2 года назад
Do Ahmadis have the right? Do Jews have the right? Do Buddhists have the right?
@atheist4174
@atheist4174 2 года назад
@@mul-el3657 Fazeel ur Rehman Guman is lying
@tankseverywhere1492
@tankseverywhere1492 2 года назад
What right does an average peasant have? what right does an average labourer have? they make the majority of our society, the run our society. What do they own? Nothing, the rulling elites own everything, who leads Pakistan? The military combined with the parliament that represents those elites. Islam has nothing to do with it, they use Islam to fool you, to control your little mind in the name of this backward dogma to justify the existence of their state.
@respectinfinity6130
@respectinfinity6130 Год назад
@@mul-el3657 Jews have there right in Islam ofcourse, real Riyast e madia Constitutions written by Hazrat Muhammad but our govt doesn't gave the basic facilities to Muslims themselves so mionrities ki tou bat hi khatm hogai I am Muslim and totally against religious in Politics because just because of this we just humilat Islam in whole world we just need to realize that islam is not a key of taking votes in the name Islam. Islam is a religion not a business Religious should separate from politics example Indonesia Malaysia Turkey etc they are 90%+ Muslim population but there govt are secular that the reason they are developing because they are not using Islam as business I am Muslim and proud to be an Muslim but I don't want my religion used for in dirty politics
@saeedajamal2866
@saeedajamal2866 Год назад
❤️
@shariqzaman4791
@shariqzaman4791 3 года назад
Jalali badshahi ho ki jamhoori tamasha kho Juda ho din siyasat si to rih jati hain changizi
@salmanchandio
@salmanchandio 2 года назад
Isn't it equally justifiable and right that if a person, with his innovation, starts a business and then earns a lot of fame and wealth solely because of his hard work and his brilliant mind and that other "90%" people keep buying from him? Just like the case of Bill Gates and Steve Jobs. They didn't rob money from the poor. Just a curious mind, Professor Taimur.
@Taimur_Laal
@Taimur_Laal 2 года назад
Socialism rewards those who work hard. Capitalism rewards those who work hard to exploit the poor.
@salmanchandio
@salmanchandio 2 года назад
@@Taimur_Laal Can you suggest how can I study the difference between socialism and capitalism in a more comprehensive way?
@rajarshisen7925
@rajarshisen7925 2 года назад
Dr Taimur , but in Socialism Bill Gates could not have owned the company ...
@hudayousafzai2824
@hudayousafzai2824 4 года назад
sir which strategy and approach is best to be adopted in the state then?
@Taimur_Laal
@Taimur_Laal 4 года назад
huda yousafzai socialism.
@rajarshisen7925
@rajarshisen7925 2 года назад
Sir , don't you think proper Taxation and distribution of such tax ( collected ) with right to own a property should be the way to go rather than Socialism where in the state will decide what one should own
@azizahmedaazad6037
@azizahmedaazad6037 2 года назад
Nice
@debajhaider8153
@debajhaider8153 4 года назад
Kindly explain the socialist economic model in contrast with capitalism. I think private ownership of property concept is realistic and near to the nature of human beings.
@imranfarooqi6747
@imranfarooqi6747 3 года назад
Exactly, Islam also gives the concept of private ownership which is quite realistic
@ourangzebkhan6516
@ourangzebkhan6516 3 года назад
mera apsy kuch baton pa different point of view hai . But I have no right to label you any thing or associate you with any thing. stay bless.
@khurramawan4559
@khurramawan4559 5 лет назад
We should take the pros of both and combine them, we cannot reject the capitalism at all nor reject the socialism at all. Both are two extremes. You cannot neglect the divisions of God.
@muneebkhan8397
@muneebkhan8397 2 года назад
u r great sir i like u very much
@tameshewolf
@tameshewolf 4 года назад
Sir, i think I need to hear your thoughts on anarchism and why you don't identify as one too! (Or do you?)
@digitalcommuneeconomicsphi6149
@digitalcommuneeconomicsphi6149 3 года назад
True marxism never follow the path of An
@shoaibriz
@shoaibriz 4 года назад
I am not a liberal or socialist but i like ur lectures, at least u talk on real foundations of the principles ur trying to promote. the marxist experiment has already been tested and failed. so if you have something new please enlighten us. but even if ur able to redistribute wealth, there is not gurantee that there will be no exploitation.
@heyyo6050
@heyyo6050 3 года назад
He is a communist
@MuhammadSabir-vi9qf
@MuhammadSabir-vi9qf 3 года назад
Which system is workable in the presant systems with affordable human rights or ever green.Evev democracy is not liked.
@SenseiKreese
@SenseiKreese 3 года назад
Can you do an English version of this?
@Taimur_Laal
@Taimur_Laal 3 года назад
Yes. Why not. In fact, need to do a series on it. Because liberalism is not a brief theory.
@ZIQ665
@ZIQ665 2 года назад
Dr. Is it not that we humane beings are hirarchy mind...Even ur own mind grades urself and put in a relative hirarchy...If this is fundamental to psychy then removing competition and structure will remove motivation and shift humane pychy to un natural mode....
@Muneyr
@Muneyr 5 лет назад
#lalSalam *from Indian occupied Kashmir*
@aagantuk7370
@aagantuk7370 5 лет назад
Bhai aap secular state nahi chahte kya
@floodland80s
@floodland80s 3 года назад
lol fuck off mehn
@tahreemzahra7
@tahreemzahra7 3 года назад
Ye terms English main e smjh ati hain, liberal azadian, infaradi, sarmaya darri nzam, musbat pehlu, samaaj, maashi haqooq, qanooni brabri
@user-pl1ve7xy6o
@user-pl1ve7xy6o 10 месяцев назад
I am lebral ❤❤❤❤ but i am fans your ❤❤❤❤❤
@haleemkhankakar5638
@haleemkhankakar5638 5 лет назад
lub u sir
@iqranaeem3923
@iqranaeem3923 5 лет назад
Salam, how we can contact u sir? Need your contact regarding research ۔
@NoorMuhammadSofi
@NoorMuhammadSofi 4 года назад
Sir plzz make a video on #Hindutva plzz
@NaveedJan834
@NaveedJan834 3 года назад
Sir how can I join your political party?
@financialSchool-fm7de
@financialSchool-fm7de 2 года назад
sir, 1400 saal pehle madina m kon sa system tha jo hamare aj k systems k aligned ha.. cpitalism socialism or communism etc,,,plz answer
@albelaarecords2467
@albelaarecords2467 2 года назад
Jahilana
@shahzaibali4630
@shahzaibali4630 Год назад
Bhai us time ek simple barter system huta tha Aur Capitalism ka Idea wealth of nations main 1776 main Aya hai uske baad communism ka Idea Marx ne 1867 main Das Capital men diya aur Socialism ka Idea Bhi Communism main se hi nikla hai aur iske ilawa yeh sare systems DR Sahab ne Islamic sharia wali videos main diye Hain in specific sharia in terms of economics
@aftabnaveed
@aftabnaveed 3 года назад
I humbly disagree with your opinion on capitalism, every indivisual in a liberal society is free to generate wealth even the working class. The question however is how much effort a working class is willing put to do that? What do they sacrifice to get there? A billioniare sacrifise his time, goes under tremandous amount of stress, spends alot of energy in reading and learning. In western countries an enterpenure reads about 60 books on average every year, how much research a working class do? And please, do not compare pakistani capitalists who are corrupt to the core and uses unfair means to get unfair adavantage, but that does not mean capitalism is bad.
@DangerDAmmo
@DangerDAmmo 2 года назад
It's not about sacrifice it's all about inheritance or you can say most of the time it is due to inheritance. Name me any famous capitalist who didn't inherited a lot of money from his parents, who was unable to get good education, was unable to buy books for his research. You say working class is lazy and not ready to sacrifice to get upper position in the society. We say that working class is most hard working and exploited class of all. Asking working class to read books and learn and go to universities is just braindead. Working class does not got the means to buy this stuff. The stuff that should be free, knowledge, education, healthcare, security are bought by money in capitalism which can only be afforded by the rich who have inherited lots.
@user-px9zb5lt2f
@user-px9zb5lt2f 5 лет назад
As always,full of pragmatism..
@alamzaib6783
@alamzaib6783 2 года назад
Burtrand Russell nay aik essay kia likh dia log uski jan hi ni chir rahay.ab ap nay apnay faith btana shuro kr diay.dont try to bracket with Russell please.
@tahreemzahra7
@tahreemzahra7 3 года назад
Apke e lectures sunnay hote wo b smj nhi atay 😢
@tahreemzahra7
@tahreemzahra7 3 года назад
Yar itni thossss urdu mt bola kren please 😢😢😢
@yogeshkumar-md3pk
@yogeshkumar-md3pk 5 лет назад
Kya communist liberal ho sakte hai? Plzz explain sir..
@Taimur_Laal
@Taimur_Laal 5 лет назад
yogesh kumar honay ko tu kuch bhi ho sakta hai :)
@bharathc5326
@bharathc5326 2 года назад
I was socialist until I started earning money.
@abdullahimranafridi
@abdullahimranafridi 24 дня назад
Which dehumanized you...
@adilali3808
@adilali3808 3 года назад
First time you speak honestly.
@shahidsardar1058
@shahidsardar1058 4 года назад
Wa ji wa
@yusrarana6913
@yusrarana6913 3 года назад
Juda ho deen Syasat se to reh jati hai Changazi ???!
@IrfanKhan-resistance
@IrfanKhan-resistance 3 года назад
Yeh sirf shayari hae aur zaroori nae such hoe. Iqbal ka Europe jaanay sprhlay ki shayari he. Iqbal jab wapas aye to woh bilkul alag iqbal thy. Pehlay ka iqbal jo tha woh mutasib tha, shidat pasand, tang nazar, brainwashed. Wapas jo iqbal aya woh tajurba kaar tha, aqal aur mantaq par chalny wala. Jazbaati jahalat se paak aur fehem aur soch wala iqbal.
@MrKamranhaider0
@MrKamranhaider0 5 лет назад
Asal mien Pakistani ku parhi lakhi bat pasand NHI ATI. I LEARNED A LOT FROM UR VIDEO . THOUGH VERY RELIGIOUS PERSON BY THOUGHT AND FOLLOWER OF INQILAB E IRAN
@aman_insaan
@aman_insaan 3 года назад
Aisi baat agar aap krte hai to yeh kafi gairjimmedarana baat hogi. Main khud Bharat se hu aur nations k mit jane me yaqin krta hoon bt phir bhi yeh disrespect hai bhaijaan. Ghalat hai. Aap ek badi aawam ke baare me bol rahe hai.
@tamoorqadri6051
@tamoorqadri6051 3 года назад
Deen syasat sy judda ho jaiy to reh jati ha changazii
@TenthofD
@TenthofD 2 года назад
Capitalism: Earn it! Vs Communism: Snatch it!
@SydAliHsn
@SydAliHsn 2 года назад
Capitalism: Try to earn it but only the one who was born to a privileged family will be able to earn it due to better education etc. and you will probably die poor because you never got the right education and had to work to support your family from a young age. Communism: Everyone will get the same chance of trying to earn something and the one who has more passion and determination will earn it not the one born with a silver spoon.
@TenthofD
@TenthofD 2 года назад
Meanwhile Elon Musk: Where have you been my silver spoon for the last 30 yrs of my struggle???! Actually the real silver spoon every child is born with in a capitalist society is the freedom(which by some very weird reason commies are immune to observe and appreciate as a virtue) to earn and capitalize on that earning (provided that people are liberated by super rich from the radical impediments of social mobility like health, schooling etc). The ideology which suggests that a worker in the giga factory deserves to share equal stake in the Tesla as it's founder Elon(which btw was born with a 'silver spoon' of hard work before him/her) is an insane idea.
@allrounder0095
@allrounder0095 2 года назад
Everything u say it give there right by Islam then why we need separation from islam bc Islam is not religion not it define Islam by qura is religion it deen a complete system and yes Islam have the idea of liberal communism but not the extreme level it middle way.
@umairahmad3668
@umairahmad3668 3 года назад
You are not a liberal ok i got, but for God sake please Buy a good Mike.
@modoodfareed5874
@modoodfareed5874 5 лет назад
Sir g ma to kahti hon k humin ladies ko jo hoqoq islam ne dey hn on par amal karwany ki koshash karni chahy humin Ksi socialists ya camnists chahty hn hum jab Muslims hein to humin liberalism waghera ki kon c mohtaji he???
@salmanpsd262
@salmanpsd262 5 лет назад
Audio ka kuch karein
@Taimur_Laal
@Taimur_Laal 5 лет назад
SALMAN HUSSAIN it’s not clear?
@usamaahmad6552
@usamaahmad6552 5 лет назад
90 percent abdi ko hud prh likh k age ana chie
@samidkhan101
@samidkhan101 3 года назад
Mujhe pata nahi me kya ho? But Critical thinker.
@Umerrasheedkhan123
@Umerrasheedkhan123 3 года назад
Explantion good but Raab ki zameen Raab ka Nizam Islamic system k baray m b paran
@IrfanKhan-resistance
@IrfanKhan-resistance 3 года назад
Rab ne apse khud akar kaha ke yeh meea nizam ha? Brainwashed admi. Tmne sirf logo se baaten suni hn. Aur suni sunai baaten lekar yha laye hoe. Tmne na rab dekha, na us se milay aur na us se milay jisko yeh nizam mila. Bus hawa hawai baaten. Dakyanosi, pasmanda, gawar logo wali zehniat.
@raheelakhtar1789
@raheelakhtar1789 4 года назад
اس بندے نے کبھی بندہ بن کر اسلام پڑھا ہی نہیں۔ انسان بھٹکتا ہی اُس وقت ہے جب اپنی عقل کو کامل سمجھتا ہے ، اور شیطان کے وسوسوں سے غافل ہو جاتا ہے۔ ہدایت ایک نور ہے جو اللہ کی خاص رحمت سے ہی ملتا ہے۔ اللہ سب مسلمانوں کو سیدھے راستے پر چلنے کی توفیق دے۔
@respectinfinity6130
@respectinfinity6130 Год назад
AP seedhy rasty par chal rhy ho isliye Pakistan superpower banny laga hai
@respectinfinity6130
@respectinfinity6130 Год назад
I am Muslim and proud to be socialist
@tahreemzahra7
@tahreemzahra7 3 года назад
Bunyadi shehri haqooq, infraaadi azaadiaan, zraye paida war, niji mulkiyat, moashi aitbar Don't do this please please please please 😢
@Anjumsohail0
@Anjumsohail0 3 месяца назад
It's our national language dude.😅
@hussaintariq973
@hussaintariq973 4 года назад
desi liberal
Далее
Why I am not a Postmodernist | Part 2 (Urdu)
17:59
Просмотров 20 тыс.
First Wave Feminism | What is Feminism?
29:57
Просмотров 82 тыс.
A Marxist response to Jordan Peterson
47:07
Просмотров 76 тыс.
What is liberalism?
22:42
Просмотров 213 тыс.
Is socialism against human nature?
10:37
Просмотров 15 тыс.
What is Fascism?
13:17
Просмотров 156 тыс.
Why Secularism?
8:18
Просмотров 60 тыс.
Defeat of Socialism in the USSR (Urdu)
1:19:48
Просмотров 30 тыс.
Dialectical Materialism & the Class Struggle (Urdu)
48:21