Тёмный

Why I keep changing my mind about how to educate my kids... 

Precious Stars Vlogs
Подписаться 140 тыс.
Просмотров 9 тыс.
50% 1

Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @preciousstarsvlogs
My "Buy me a coffee" link: ko-fi.com/prec...
My Facebook page: / preciousstarsyt
My instagram: @preciousstarsvlogs
My Tiktok: @precious.stars.vlogs

Опубликовано:

 

6 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 107   
@jennyanton3638
@jennyanton3638 Месяц назад
Just so you are aware, the Scottish schooling system is completely different to the English system so calling it the British schooling system is incorrect. We do not have reception year in Scotland and are in primary school for 7 years and then we move to high school where we stay until we are 18. We don’t do GCSEs or A levels but instead we do National 5s, Highers and Advanced Highers
@jadoreux
@jadoreux Месяц назад
This!! The school years work differently too. I had almost no idea until I moved to Scotland and I was trying to figure it all out when I was pregnant with my daughter. Weve since ended up moving to wales anyway but it was a lot of learning!
@mairi2693
@mairi2693 Месяц назад
Also, in Scotland, generally speaking, there's no real choice for a state school to be had. Your child will automatically qualify to go to the one nearest you. The only division is whether you want them to attend a non-denominational or Roman Catholic school. Also, the child has to have reached 4 years of age before the end of February that year for the Primary 1 intake for the academic year that starts in mid August.
@mairi2693
@mairi2693 Месяц назад
​@@jadoreux Yes! The school Summer holidays usually start the last week of June until mid -August.
@jadoreux
@jadoreux Месяц назад
@@mairi2693 yes! I meant the age thing - how the years are based on birthday January-December rather than September-August which is how they do it in England and Wales.
@Challanging_Expectations
@Challanging_Expectations Месяц назад
I think England and Wales are moving to something similar (for GCSEs and aLevels). But that was a tory thing so Labour may scrap it I don't know
@hayee
@hayee Месяц назад
When I was looking at schools for my son, i went for the best on paper academically. I pulled him out after three days; you do not force a 4 year old to wait until break times to have a wee and limit their fluids at dinner time to avoid afternoon accidents because they can’t use the toilet during classtime. This was after making a beeline for the teacher initially and then the head. On the third (and his last) day i walked away dejected after dropping him off and bumped into a mum from the nursery he’d been at from 5mths until school. She told me about the school she’d chosen for her daughter (his friend), a few minutes walk away from the one he was in. I popped in to that school on the off chance, all the teachers couldn’t do enough to show me around and how the children were learning through play, with no structure (in the infant section), the kids were so happy and interactive with their peers and their teachers - this was their third day too - night and day!! The head then came and met me, he’d asked if any teacher would mind staying late to show my son around after he finished school - they all volunteered! I counted down the hours til the bell and told my son we were going to see a different school - he absolutely loved it and the headmaster (who still to this day knows all of his pupils and former pupils by name and knows which child belongs to which parent) said he would push through the paperwork (was meant to take 3 weeks) and would meet me at reception on Monday at 8:45am if he wanted to join their school. We did, and true to his word, he was personally stood waiting, with two school jumpers for us! The rest is history, he’s now just finished his first year of uni and has has passed with 89%! The boy whos only homework was a reading book once a week or to bring basic ingredients in for cooking in his entire primary school years has just outperformed his private school friends in university. Gentle education is at very least, equal to a more academic and structured approach as there is no pressure and they enjoy learning. Also, definitely meet the headteacher, I truly believe you get a real feel for the school from the personality of the headteacher! I’m also still a governor of his old high school, and the headmistress there is just phenomenal! xx
@secai_i
@secai_i Месяц назад
thank you so much for sharing this
@user-xq8bb3wx5f
@user-xq8bb3wx5f Месяц назад
This was so beautiful to read, thank you for sharing.
@ralbynb158
@ralbynb158 Месяц назад
What a fantastic success story.
@Shayron1989
@Shayron1989 Месяц назад
Just to say this isn’t how it works in Scotland. We start usually when children are 5. Some go at 4 depending on when their birthday falls but they are the youngest in the year and usually turn 5 by Christmas (there is no reception year). We can also defer entry by a year, which means some children will be around 6 before they start school, and more and more people are doing that. We are guaranteed a place at the local school (we still have to register but you won’t be refused if you are in the catchment area). If you want to go to a different school than the catchment school then you submit a placing request and it is dependent on spaces available whether you get it. We don’t have 6th Form or 6th Form Colleges. College in Scotland can also include university level learning. Private schools up here are varied. Some follow the English model and qualifications, and some follow the Scottish model. “Independent schools” are private schools in Scotland. I didn’t realise there was so many differences til you went through all this tbh!
@beaohbea
@beaohbea Месяц назад
It’s so nice to hear someone really thinking about this, I don’t have kids yet and talk about it a lot, and people think I’m odd. Totally agree about the morals and wanting the system to change, but also acknowledging it’s still broken and wanting your kid/s to have the best opportunities! That’s exactly how I feel, and people judge me for even thinking about private
@luciedvorakova2167
@luciedvorakova2167 Месяц назад
Poland this year banned homework at primary schools and I think that's amazing! It should be banned everywhere. Yes I love London because of it's diversity and it's ability to actually integrate people from diverse cultures together. This level of diversity and integrity is almost nowhere else in the world! Brexit in this context is such a shame, but London did not vote for it.
@aidenharmston402
@aidenharmston402 Месяц назад
You also don’t know if your child will be artsy, academic, sporty, etc or a mix of these. Once he’s a little older, you can see what his interests and strengths are, and get him into a more pressure (or less pressure) school. My point is at this stage, you don’t know what he’ll need flashing forward 5 years.
@emmaphillips7063
@emmaphillips7063 Месяц назад
Hey just to let you know; as I was also very interested in Steiner Waldrof, I've recently learned it is connected to a religion/spirituality named "antroposophy". The french government recently had to close a few due to its undisclosed link to this spiritual orientation/religious movement, and has published very compelling evidence about its cult like characteristics. I am not at all critical of child guided pedagogies, so was very surprised to learn this. Thought it was worth mentioning!
@chelseajane9626
@chelseajane9626 Месяц назад
As a waldorf early years educator, Anthroposophy is not a cult its a spiritual practice Rudolf Steiner says in his work time and time again "take what resonates with you and your spirit" he never intended his work to be followed dogmaticly. It can be a beautiful education when done right, I have chosen to home educate my children in Steiner pedagogy because I truly belive the education has been desinged to meet the growing consciousness of the child each year. 100% worth looking into it outside of formal education settings.
@emmaphillips7063
@emmaphillips7063 Месяц назад
@@chelseajane9626 sure but you have to admit few people are aware of the connection between the school and the spiritual practice, which is an issue in itself. The lack of transparency is precisely why some of the schools were closed in France. I myself had no clue there was any sort of spiritual element before that, and it’s never advertised on the school websites
@bilong92
@bilong92 Месяц назад
Honestly if my parents were offering to pay for my kids to go to private school, I’d take it in a heartbeat even if I don’t really believe in putting a price on a basic education. Sadly the private system isn’t going anywhere any time soon
@lilyloveponies
@lilyloveponies Месяц назад
I attended a public school and then changed to a private school and the opportunities at the private school were so amazing compared to the public school. I'd 100% take that offer!
@chelseajane9626
@chelseajane9626 Месяц назад
Honestly, I went to private school and hated it bullying is a big issue and not just from the teachers, a LOT of pressure is put on children even if they are not academic and if they fall behind the school don't care. I blindly sent my son to private school and have just removed him to home educate as he fell behind and was being poorly treated in school.
@rideremii
@rideremii Месяц назад
I totally agree! My girls are only 6 and 4 the youngest hasn’t even started primary yet and our village primary is wonderful but they will be going private for secondary, there’s no good secondary schools near us id want them to go to they’re awful! I grew up with many private school friends, their experience and education is a whole world better than state school!!
@ThatRomyKate
@ThatRomyKate Месяц назад
It annoys me that homework has become so ubiquitous in primary school. My niece and nephew are year 2 and 4 and they have lots of homework to do. When I was at school we only had reading and a spellings sheet until year 6, when we started getting a few more worksheets each week to prepare us for secondary school, and we all managed. It shows how much more academic pressure there is to learn things earlier than even 20 years ago when I was at school
@emmap1458
@emmap1458 Месяц назад
I went to a private primary school and based on that experience I would choose a state school for my daughter. In my experience private schools lack diversity and that is important to me. I want her to experience diversity from the start - children of different backgrounds /nationalities/ special needs etc
@TheGeorgieiscool
@TheGeorgieiscool Месяц назад
If you are planning on having another child would your parents be able to comfortably afford the private fees all the way through until they are both 18? Taking into account large increases in future years as well. Private school is a massive financial commitment as it is very difficult to take them out once they have started.
@christinemackie6976
@christinemackie6976 Месяц назад
I hate the social aspect argument of being against home education. People say this all the time and i say "What there are other children???" To think that our children don't socialise just as much actually more is ridiculous because our children interact with all age groups not just the ones they are allowed to
@TessaAvonlea
@TessaAvonlea Месяц назад
You're not correct to say that secondary school is never split. Some parts of england have middle schools. And then as other people gave mentioned, scotland is different. A bit more research might have been good to make yourself aware of how things work in different places in the UK outside your personal experience. Or just acknowledge that you are speaking about your specific area, not the entire country.
@eleanormaddocks1834
@eleanormaddocks1834 Месяц назад
Yes some parts of the uk do have middle schools, (and private prep schools which are a whole other beast that also go up to year 8 instead of the traditional year 6 cutoff) but those schools mostly follow the same structure as normal state primary/secondary education where children have a class teacher for most things until year 6 and then move between subject specialist teachers from year 7. The only real difference is that the transition between year 6 and 7 is gentler as they don’t have to get used to a new environment and will know a lot of the teachers already.
@MsFlamingFlamer
@MsFlamingFlamer 4 дня назад
I’m American, went to Montessori school for preschool and kindergarten (ages 3-5) and loved it. I hope to send my own future child to go to Montessori. I feel like other educational routes can be decided later.
@laurencimorellibow
@laurencimorellibow Месяц назад
The amount of homework in a state primary vs private academic ‘prep’ school isn’t even comparable
@user-xx6ud8iq7g
@user-xx6ud8iq7g Месяц назад
Up North, especially in more disadvantaged areas, every child starts at 3, they look so tiny in their little uniforms. I was a young Mum, mine went through school and college in the state system. I didn’t have a choice, or any support. I worked in a Primary school as a TA and went to uni and became a secondary school teacher when my daughter was 13/14. I have worked in about 7 schools and they vary a lot. I would go and visit many and look at the children’s behaviour. I didn’t have the option to do anything other than state school. I was very young with no guidance on this either. As a teacher, I think if you’re against homework, you need to find a school that is also against that, because most schools don’t really like to make exceptions for children unless it’s medical. Otherwise there are lots of unique demands and requests and it’s hard to get anyone to follow any rules. Homework in the younger years is an attempt to get families to engage with their kids, at least where I come from, they won’t be given anything too academic. I work at a secondary now where our boss doesn’t like homework, so there are options out there. I’d just recommend finding the one that fits best and sticking with how they do it, rather than finding one you like a lot of and then trying to make it work for you, as you usually sign something to say you will support the school and help support your child to follow the rules and if you don’t like a certain rule, they are likely not to support you with it.
@iluvgzus2.981
@iluvgzus2.981 Месяц назад
We really liked the Waldorf school the only reason we left was the administration! I loved they DO NOT talk politics or religion in the classroom.
@hayleycox5475
@hayleycox5475 Месяц назад
I would love to hear more about your own experiences with home schooling/ unschooling. How was it structured? What kinds of experiences did you do that helped you learn and what advantages/ disadvantages did it bring?
@tonyaboyer4547
@tonyaboyer4547 Месяц назад
I’m an SMBC in the US, and I’m planning to apply for a placement at the local Montessori school for my 4-year old this winter. It’s charter, so funded by the local public school district, and therefore free. They choose placements via lottery. I’ve gone back and forth about whether, if he’s not selected, I’ll send him to the private church-based school (where he does preschool now) or the public school. It’s so nice that your parents are willing to help with school costs! But I’d be conflicted, too. It’s hard not to feel like I’m taking too much help from them that I maybe wouldn’t be if I had a partner (and second income). But I know my parents desperately want to help in any way they can. It’s tough!
@themagicalcupcakeunicorn5755
@themagicalcupcakeunicorn5755 Месяц назад
As a public school child who now goes to college, I will say it depends on the area and school you send your child to. I went to public school in the ghetto but it was in a ritzy area so I got my normal education, plus my mom also helped me learn a bit more at home. I also know that another school in the same district, select few kids are able to read, and parents there don’t usually tend to want to be involved in their kids education. I know you also talked about other options, but I just wanted to give my experience if it helps you😊.
@hobbiton64
@hobbiton64 Месяц назад
I'm from a county in England with a 3 tier system, we do up to year 4 in lower, 4-8 in middle and 9 onwards in upper.
@user-xq8bb3wx5f
@user-xq8bb3wx5f Месяц назад
Lot's of great thinking happening here, but I've noticed a few times recently that you tend to speak in an authoritative way on topics specific to your personal experience as though they broadly apply to England/UK/Britain when they often don't.
@aimslovell3351
@aimslovell3351 Месяц назад
In Wales, UK, children have the option to start school when they are 3 (the term after they have their third birthday). The majority of 3 year olds do start school, in my opinion, mainly due to it being free childcare for parents! Having worked in these environments, I can confidently say three year olds are too young to be attending school. Some schools do it well and create a more relaxed environment, however in many schools, there is still such a high level of expectation for children who ultimately have JUST left their toddler stage. “Sit on the carpet, cross your legs and be quiet”. You see this regimented style of teaching running up the school. Some schools are doing really well at making the early years more child led, with far more focus on outdoor learning and a child’s holistic development; but, ultimately higher up the school years, children still have to fall in line for the tick box ‘knowledge’ based learning, of sitting and regurgitating information. I don’t yet have my own children, however I will definitely be considering Montessori or Steiner schools as their curriculums are far more focused on supporting the WHOLE development of the child, not just academic abilities.
@charlottesinclair9354
@charlottesinclair9354 Месяц назад
I think the diversity of public schools is such an important consideration, particularly at primary age. You could then look at swapping to private for high school if your parents are able to support it, since that tends to be smaller class sizes etc that can be quite beneficial. Nice to see someone seriously thinking about all the options though, and hopefully by the time it comes to actually applying you can be happy and confident with whichever route you have chosen!
@SustainableSierra
@SustainableSierra Месяц назад
I taught for ten years and as a result, I chose to Home Educate my child. He loves choosing his subjects and HomeEd group activities while we enjoy the flexibility of taking field trips whenever we want.
@christinemackie6976
@christinemackie6976 Месяц назад
I don't blame you. I would never advise someone to send their child to a state school The children are bullies and the staff are far too underpaid
@brionyhall4250
@brionyhall4250 Месяц назад
Although less now, there are middle schools (I was in one), from year 4 to year 7. So I started secondary in year 8. I went to college instead of a-levels, but I also went to a college for my degree, as it was a rural college for rural courses. It was partnered with a city university.
@kpwxx
@kpwxx Месяц назад
I don't have kids or plans for them, but I am a former teacher (EYFS and KS1) so am very interested in education! I think my views align really closely with yours. It must be so difficult to navigate, and partly because so much depends on your local schools. I've experienced some truly wonderful state schools doing amazing work - child led curriculums, structures and timetables that centre play and the individual and allow flexibility, immersive and flexible environments using strong theory based study of pedagogy from the teachers. But I've also seen horrific ones where children are treated like worksheet filling robots, talked to so disrespectfully and where fun is essentially outlawed. Also with secondaries especially, ones which are just unsafe... I wouldn't send a child to my local secondary in a million years. Fwiw, I think there's a difference between sending your child to private school because you view private as better, Vs because you prefer a specific style of education which is only available there, or there are specific problems that make the state options not good learning environments for your child. I don't think you should feel bad if you do end up choosing private for the reasons you discussed; though honestly the local school that's a bit further sounds really promising, I hope it ends up being a good fit. Not having to plan and prep meals is also a massive bonus honestly, I think people underestimate that sometimes. I think my advice as a former teacher would be 1. Definitely visit as you mentioned. You can really get a feeling a lot of the time, more than what you can see on paper. 2. As well as homework policy, ask about how children can access outside and how much of the day is specific lessons at what ages Vs more free choices. 3. Don't be afraid to say to the teacher that you like elements of Steiner, democratic, Montessori etc and ask if the school incorporates any of those principles or anything similar. Good teachers (particularly early years ones) should be able to talk about the principles they follow as a school and know enough to make links with those when they exist. 4. Most importantly remember that you are Oryn's mum so he already has that massive positive on his side! Yes, schools are important so it's right to think about them deeply. But also having you on his side to support him, advocate for him, and support his learning outside of school through everything he does will make such a huge impact. If he ends up in a non-ideal school, I'm confident he'll still flourish with your support. Oh also since you mentioned phonics I can't miss a chance to recommend the excellent Sold A Story podcast!!!
@ameliasmart119
@ameliasmart119 Месяц назад
Loved the video!! So many good considerations and I’m happy you are spending the time to decide what type of education and experience you want for your son! I think a lot of parents go on autopilot and choose local schools or the “best known schools “ but don’t consider what the child’s experience would be.
@Albags38
@Albags38 Месяц назад
Also adding that Northern Ireland is different again to England, Wales and Scotland. We have 7 years in Primary School, called Years/Primary 1-7, we don’t have Infants or Juniors. At the end of primary school, in year 7, pupils can sit an optional exam (SEAG) if they wish to attend a Grammar school. The secondary school options are Grammar schools (using academic selection from the SEAG exam) or a non-selective Secondary School. Secondary schools offer another 7 years (Years 8-14), but you can leave after 5 years. We don’t have separate 6 form schools. Our exams are GCSEs and A-Levels.
@lucyytee29
@lucyytee29 Месяц назад
Hi 😊 i can see in the comments lots of discussion about different education set ups throughout the UK. I notice Bryony often explains British terminology and structures, so I'm assuming her videos reach far and wide across the globe which is a wonderful achievement 😊 i live in Wales, which even though is part of britian, we have our own goverment who make their own policies on matters like education. In wales we have the 'foundation phase' within our governent schools as the statutory curriculum for 3-7yr olds. Its heavily play focused to allow children to learn through being creative and imaginative and is a more holistic approach to their development - i believe this may be what Bryony was referring too about reception age for schools in England as this only goes up to age 5 in england i believe (or so the goverment website tells me). From the comments and video, I think this highlights the inequalities within Britian based on where you live, as all our areas are run so differently and private education is extortionate, so choice on education for parents is limited based on subscription of gov schools and economical privilege of families.
@Maggie.can.hug.every.cat.
@Maggie.can.hug.every.cat. Месяц назад
More relating to the later years of education but my parents sent all 3 of us kids to different schools. My brother went to a science/tech focused private school because that was his interest. I went to a generally very academic public school (select entry if you have similar in the UK, I had to pass an exam to get offered a place, only the top % were accepted). My younger sibling went to a private school with a great music program. Neither of my parents finished high school, so they were really lead by our interests and we are all so different in our interests that one school would not be right for all of us.
@schaynegeorge4793
@schaynegeorge4793 Месяц назад
I'm in Australia and my daughter is starting 3yo kindy (preschool play based learning, mostly to familiarise them with the structure of school) next year. We were discussing enrollments at playgroup the other month and one of the mums asked what HIGH SCHOOLS we were looking at for our 2yos! Like that's bananas! Our public system works on a zoning method, you are basically guaranteed a place in the school you are physically closest school and if you want to go to a school further away you need sound logic for why that school is better suited. I have 9yos and realised I do need to look into high schools anyway and realised that there are 8 high schools near me and only one of them has physical technology and home ec facilities which is awful, I want my kids to be able to hammer nails into wood without committing to a two year TAFE qualification program. I'm privileged in that there are tradies in the family who are willing to share their skills with my kids but it really shows that the government is discouraging kids from learning labour skills despite them being much needed in society.
@DeepinIngo
@DeepinIngo Месяц назад
I think it's great that you are aware of the different options and not 100% set on one. My friend is one of three siblings. They were in normal german public school and the eldest struggled so they moved all three kids to a Waldorf/Steiner school. The eldest really flourished there but after a few years it turned out the younger two wanted more structure and were more sciencey so those two moved back to a state school. It just shows the need to adapt to the children and the situations at the time.
@Alice-gx5yr
@Alice-gx5yr Месяц назад
Great summary of the education system, but we always called secondary school, 'high school' in East Anglia! Don't know if it's a regional thing?
@bestofbethan5792
@bestofbethan5792 Месяц назад
I'm in East Anglia and have always called it Secondary school, I think it varies more by school than region :)
@Shayron1989
@Shayron1989 Месяц назад
Think it is a geographical thing but on a really local level. I’m in Scotland and in Renfrewshire most of the secondary schools are called ‘High Schools’ so most people say High School, but in Glasgow (literally the next local authority over) most are called Secondary or Academy so people tend to say ‘secondary school’. So you go 10mins down the road and people say it different lol
@charr441
@charr441 Месяц назад
In Wales vast majority of secondary schools are called High Schools 🤷‍♀️
@elliekinzz1
@elliekinzz1 Месяц назад
I’m from east Anglia too! And yes, me and everyone else I know from here says high school! I found it so weird when I moved to uni and my friends from other cities in the UK said I was wrong for saying high school. Must be regional :)
@SparklyBelle
@SparklyBelle Месяц назад
Also from East Anglia and never heard it called High School - it’s always secondary. I have a friend from Sussex who called it High School though.
@amydurani
@amydurani Месяц назад
We are in the Northumberland, North East of England and we still have the three tear system with first school,(reception to year 4) middle school(year 5 to year 8) and high school (year 9-sixth form) They are all completely separate schools as well. I really love this system.
@Natasha-tu5qs
@Natasha-tu5qs Месяц назад
Great video. It's fantastic that you have so many options for school. The Montessori school sounds like a great option to have. I went through the state system in a small, very white seaside town in NE England. It was fine and I did end up going to a good university. But things do change a lot when you hit secondary school. Your peer group can have a large influence on you. I suppose that goes for any school though, to a degree. Anyway, suffice to say at my school I had to be very focused to make sure I got through the other end ok. And this was at a supposedly good state school. I think, regarding academic vs more free flow education, a lot depends on the child. Some might really thrive off a more formal, academic atmosphere, others the latter. Love your videos. All the best from another ther toddler mum 😊
@kahri8488
@kahri8488 Месяц назад
My 5 year old does get homework. I’d MUCH prefer no homework. But so far it’s been ok. It’s one task per week, for example ‘draw a picture of something kind you’ve done this week’, ‘measure yourself using an object from your house’ etc etc plus a home reader every week. I’m ok with it so far.
@HMEBT
@HMEBT Месяц назад
It's now free school meals for all untill secondary school here in London 👍
@rachaelbrzezinski9695
@rachaelbrzezinski9695 Месяц назад
My children go to a Sudbury School. It is a democratic school. My oldest has been there since he was 4 and just graduated. We love it so much!
@ChristinaH2190
@ChristinaH2190 Месяц назад
As a secondary English teacher in America who is *fingers crossed* trying to move to England for Sept 2025, this is such an important conversation!
@hayee
@hayee Месяц назад
Thank you!! We desperately need good teachers (not that they’re not good here, they’re just in short supply, well they certainly are in Wales). Good luck with all of your paperwork and hopefully you’ll be teaching our next generation soon 🤞
@ChristinaH2190
@ChristinaH2190 Месяц назад
@@hayee That's so kind! I have 16+ years of teaching experience and my dream is to work in an alternative provision school or something similar. I love helping pupils (and families) find success in areas where they had previously struggled.
@meganann_2213
@meganann_2213 Месяц назад
I’m in America and I would 100% homeschool or alternative school my child if I could afford it. Private schools are typically religious and public schools are often a disaster here 😬
@Samantha-jw7el
@Samantha-jw7el Месяц назад
I was so pleased to hear everything in this video! I am struggling so much with this at present and actually leaning towards homeschool, we have 0 options in our area that aren't extortionate prices for private school or just going for a standard state school, we have even considered moving to have our little one go to a school I'd be happy with, I just know I'd be the teachers most hated parent at a state school because I'd refuse all homework (other than reading) and homeschool seems to be the only way to go (but has MASSIVE lifestyle consequences which may affect our income)
@kahri8488
@kahri8488 Месяц назад
I never in my life thought choosing a school for my kids would be a consideration for me. I’m in Australia and my state in particular has really good public schools. I went to public schools the whole way through. Never even considered I wouldn’t send my kids public. And lo and behold I have ended up sending my 5 year old to a catholic school (we are not at all religious). I would LOVE to have sent her to the Steiner school here or another alternative school which I worked at briefly. But I have three kids and cannot afford to pay 10k+ a year per child. So middle ground was our local Catholic school and so far I’m surprised with how much I’m okay with it. Personally we chose against our local public school because of recent shut downs due to kids being violent with knives etc etc. This is 5-12 year olds 😮 times have changed since I went to school apparently. It’s been SUCH a headache and stressor for me trying to decide where to send my eldest I tell you! Best of luck with your decision!
@iulia1985
@iulia1985 Месяц назад
I would make sure to look at the difference between Waldorf (Steiner) and Montessori! They have the similarities, but quite a lot of differences in the basic ideas!
@leagesoffen5764
@leagesoffen5764 Месяц назад
I currently study to become a (special needs) teacher, and you just described the school of my dreams! I hope I find a place to work like that! ❤
@mch1811
@mch1811 Месяц назад
I change my mind about education every other week. Still got another year before I get to applying for my eldest as I have autumn babies, yet it goes round in my head constantly! Glad I'm not the only one. I think if I could afford it, I'd go private. But I'm a single mum of two with no guaranteed support from their dad, so it's realistically going to be the local public all-the-way-through school (4-16 years) if we can get in! *fingers crossed*
@drawyourbook876
@drawyourbook876 Месяц назад
When deciding a school for my daughter I realized that what it is more important than what I like, is what the kid will fit into best. So I would also say, wait a little bit more so that Oryn develops a personality a bit more and you have a better basis on what he might fit and enjoy more. I know my husband would have absolutely benefited from a Montessori type school, but I would not, and I know other people that went to Montessori that resent the fact that were not forced to gain skills that they were not interested in at the time. For my daughter, she is a loud social happy kid, so for example homeschooling will not be for her. We are instead planning to send her into a more play base school, which still some structure into it.
@alibob1986
@alibob1986 Месяц назад
If it is any consolation, I felt exactly the same about homework in primary and never forced my now 15 year old to do homework. School never pushed it and she was never in trouble for not doing it
@ingridhelmeczi6041
@ingridhelmeczi6041 Месяц назад
My daughter isn't school aged, but I live in Saskatchewan, Canada. Our school system has an optional beginning, you can send your kids to preschool-Kindergarten-1st grade - grade 12. Or you can skip preschool and Kindergarten and have your child start in Grade 1. Children aren't legally required to go to school until age 6. Kindergarten kids are usually 5 years old or about to turn 5 when they start. Most schools don't have a homework policy and it is up to the teacher. Most of the time if your kid has homework it's because they didn't finish in the class time. I never had much for homework growing up. It's not common for elementary kids to get much homework. Personally I would never send my child to a private school, I am way to socialist for that. I will be sending her to public school, but I would home school if need be. I have 2 Bachelors degrees and I teach music lessons, so if I had to I would feel comfortable home schooling.
@laurencimorellibow
@laurencimorellibow Месяц назад
Would it be hard to get him into the Steiner school?
@vonnykeatch7956
@vonnykeatch7956 Месяц назад
Here in nz we do kindergarten 3 to 4 then primary year 1 to 6 5years to 11then intermediate year 7 to 8 age 11 to 13 then collage or high year 9 to 13 13 or 14 to 18 then university don't have to start until 6 but they always start at 5
@kjh888
@kjh888 Месяц назад
I have two children in primary school. They get given homework but it is up to you if you want to do it or not. It’s a very nurturing school but all state schools are struggling with increasing numbers of children with a wide range of additional needs. If your parents are offering to pay for a private school of your choosing, I’d do it!
@christinemackie6976
@christinemackie6976 Месяц назад
Also state schools require hours of homework you know
@StitchingJoanne
@StitchingJoanne Месяц назад
Would it be safest to get him into a state school and then if it isn't working out, to go private? Just wondering if private is more likely to take someone on mid-term compared to an over subscribed state school.
@sarahpreston1478
@sarahpreston1478 Месяц назад
Go and look around the schools and trust your gut, also, don't be afraid to pull him out of a certain school if it is making him unhappy at any time. You never want his thirst for knowledge to be squashed and that can happen in certain schools. I did lots of different schooling with my daughter, from private, mainstream and eventually special school as my daughter is disabled. I eventually learnt to trust my gut and it has never let me down.
@tamatisk
@tamatisk Месяц назад
There's some misinformation here. There are different systems in the different nations and in different countries. Some schools are Yr7-13, some have middle schools. Lots of private schools only start in Year 9. In any case, research and visit your local schools.
@Kimberley42
@Kimberley42 Месяц назад
I don't have children but I know I would have a similar mindset to you if I did. I'm interested in creativity in education and the arts, so that's something that I would be keenly looking at.
@nancyjohnson7147
@nancyjohnson7147 29 дней назад
You mentioned changing schopls multiple times yourself. In theory you can do the same for Oryn yes? Whats the harm in putting him in state school so start and then deciding 'yeah no I dont like this or he dosent like this' and then changing to the private route after? Edit: to say this is like a geniune question not me attempting to like push your descesion or undermine your worry about it. I'm personaly not a parent yet, nor do I have experince with the UK school system. Where I live in the US the parent can do that, literally pull a kid from main stream educarion (state schools) and put them in alternative education at any time. Jusy wondeding if thats a choice you really get or not
@karinseaman4060
@karinseaman4060 Месяц назад
In South Africa we don't have a 'middle school' or in between school.. Only primary school and high school... Grade R, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 in primary school and grade 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12 in high school 🤷🏻‍♀️ Before primary school there's obviously daycare and nursery.. But actual schools, we only have 2 types.. You have to turn 6 in grade R.. And 7 in grade 1..not sure if your child was born before June, but they might accept them earlier. Our school years are Jan-Dec. Here your only real choice is public school unfortunately... I don't even know if the town where we live has a private school, but it's very expensive. I know in the US sometimes you don't pay for public school I think... Here you pay every year.. And grade R is more expensive as they get no funds from the government for grade R. But I think grade R might be compulsory now. We get no free school in South Africa.... I'm actually glad we don't have many options... They basically can only go to public school (around here at least), you just have to decide which one... And we also have to pack meals.. There aren't cafeterias, so they either take food or buy food... At nursery my son's food is included, I love that! But from primary school onwards, it's not included.
@christinemackie6976
@christinemackie6976 Месяц назад
I would never subject my children to a staye school ever again. They are rife with bullying and the teachers say they are taught in how to teach children with different needs but this is stretching the truth to say the least. Then there is the gact that they send the child in with a water bottle that is supposed to be sat with them to drink freely BUT they collect them up and take them away when lessons start. Also factor in the fact that they are nor allowed to go to tje toilet during lessons and you have yourself some very unhappy children. They wonder why record numbers of parents ate choosing to home educate year on year. I,d just like to point outthat very few home educating parents "Unschool" and it is infact illegal. I myself structure our learning and my thirteen year old just sat his first lot of GCSE's. He has very high aspirations and will definitely achieve them as i need a dictionary just to converse with him 😂
@janer4095
@janer4095 Месяц назад
"Secondary is never split" 😂 If you're going to create a video on the education system, please get your facts correct. Many high schools are split, in the area I live in you do year's 7-9 at one school and then go to another to do your GCSE'S. I may have misheard you but did you say "we don't call secondary school high school". Yes we do, many people do, in fact 'high school' was part of the name of the school I attended🤣. As someone else has said you tend talk about topics based on your own personal experience as though they apply to everyone in the country and in reality they really dont. You come across very privileged.
@bestofbethan5792
@bestofbethan5792 Месяц назад
I don't have kids yet, but I'm already having the same dilemma! I feel I was very privileged to go to the schools I went to, all state schools, but I worry that the education system has changed so much even just in the decade since I've left. My primary school was a high-performing, non-uniform, very easygoing state school, but I lived in a very affluent village - which I'm sure influenced the school policies - and a village like that is totally unaffordable in my future. I was lucky to be in a feeder secondary school for the best state sixth form in the country (at the time) and it was full of private school children that used it to get into universities via a 'state school' after 14 years in very elite private schools - because in universities high performing state school students are selected for over high performing private school students. Ultimately, those that want an elite education will always find a way to rule the system - it needs a complete overhaul! I am also most aligned to Steiner education, but after being state educated and left-wing I really recognise the immorality of private education. Plus, I agree the cultural and socioeconomic diversity of state schools is so important for children to understand and engage with in society. It's still a tough decision for me, but it's nice to hear of others having the same thoughts! Perhaps there would be a lot of parents at a Steiner school that equally oppose the concept of private education.
@zeub78
@zeub78 Месяц назад
Lovely video you gave me a lot to think about as a follow single mum
@kalavicena8711
@kalavicena8711 Месяц назад
I'm from America. What's smart clothing
@SidneyRanger1138
@SidneyRanger1138 Месяц назад
I believe it's similar to business casual
@kringlekeep4821
@kringlekeep4821 Месяц назад
Go with the stiner school for sure. Ps we have very similar parenting beliefs
@beckster3388
@beckster3388 Месяц назад
i am asking this questions for personal reasons, i dont have an kid but i went to dulwich college in shanghai. i want to know ur opinion on what you think of that school. i lpve the school and had great memory. i went in the founding year so i don know how academic the year was because i did the test but that was for them to gain where i was. i was in year four and was meant o be in year five but i was in year three so skipping an year wasnt an an optino for me because i had learning issues., p.s i am fansitiated by this and went to an private girl school here and it was defentetlu not academic.
@TessaAvonlea
@TessaAvonlea Месяц назад
@@beckster3388 I don't mean to be rude, but is there a reason you expect someone to have an opinion on a specific school on the other side of the world to where they live? Is it supposed to be famous? I've certainly never heard of it.
@zoecooke1680
@zoecooke1680 Месяц назад
So the research is telling us that the state school system is based on the 19th century and is broken; it was designed to produce factory workers and that’s where those systems e.g. going to the bathroom etc come from. You’re therefore right to consider the Montessori etc style schools. You’d need to consider very carefully next steps; where does he go in Y7, for example, and is he behind on the “national curriculum”? How is this going to affect him? It’s lovely having life skills etc but if you’re shoved in the bottom set because you can’t do algebra, you’re going to feel stupid, and the 11 year old brain isn’t typically developed enough to develop those skills of justifying your own type of intelligence. re. Homework - again research tells us it’s academically ineffective but the education system is acting on this with “interleaved retrieval” so it keeps things ticking when we don’t have time to teach it in class. It also promotes the valuable life skill of time management and working from home - your mum’s policy of time at home was a good one. Going to war with your school re homework is likely to exhaust you and not really get you anywhere. Your kid is special to you, but one of 30 to the teacher, so it’s likely that you’ll (and worst case scenario, he’ll) be seen as considering yourself “above” homework and what the other kids do. It’s not likely to be a fruitful conversation. There is also something to be said for teaching your child that sometimes you have to do things you don’t want to!! Hope this helps!!
@laurencimorellibow
@laurencimorellibow Месяц назад
Did you go to Tring?
@ashleyelizabeth90
@ashleyelizabeth90 Месяц назад
you sound very privileged you're lucky you didn't go to school in the states 😂
@laurakinsella1692
@laurakinsella1692 Месяц назад
Couldn't you home school for a bit till year three
@samanthawhiting7962
@samanthawhiting7962 Месяц назад
Personally I love private school. I love the small classes and the extra attention my child gets in school. I started with my first in mainstream and actually there was lots of problems with the school. The teachers are overworked and the class sizes are bigger. The great thing about private school is you can choose a school to suite your family. I feel my children are very lucky however, we work hard and have studied all our lives, we have also saved and got our first house at 20(I had a job at 16). I think there is no right answer for everyone and that’s why there is choice. Also the ingredients in the school meals are shocking… I don’t think it’s healthy in anyway, but I guess that depends on your view. Even inches that’s say it is good, it’s cheap alternatives processed packed stuff. I think have to go with your heart and head.
@SherrisPlace
@SherrisPlace Месяц назад
I wonder if being that you have a son, and males quite often excel in the maths and sciences, if you could just watch his interests as he plays. Not that he’ll do equations by the time he’s 3 … lol, but you may see if his mind is more inclined to the analytical type toys etc. This could possibly influence your choice as to where to place him when he’s a bit older. Do you know anything about the father’s IQ, or work, or where he excels mentally, interests? It may be that Orin may like mental challenges. I hear you mentioning your preferences based on your experiences, but perhaps Orin’s biological father’s genes may begin to show up and need fulfilment as well. - ( Ive had 4 sons myself and they do lean towards the father’s interests) (Interestingly enough Chinese children are watched closely as to their natural strengths, and placed at a young age (2-3) in areas they will excel in. Food for thought.) Thank you for sharing your life’s journey with us. ☺️
@rebekah3483
@rebekah3483 Месяц назад
Are you saying sixth form? Since I'm ignorant on this I'm not sure if I'm understanding you correctly. Are 6th form and college used interchangeably? Do kids live at college? Do kids have to go to 6th form or college? If not, they're done by age 15 or 16 basically? Can they go straight to University from year 11 or do they have to do the other first? Edit: why is it called 6th form or whatever it is that you're saying?
@_Claire_Louise_
@_Claire_Louise_ Месяц назад
Yeah it's 6th form which is the same as college (age wise 16-18) for us. 6th form tends to be more for academic subjects and college more vocational focused but you can do a levels at college and vocational at some 6th forms. Most colleges kids don't live at, but there are some residential (one near me is very highly regarded for sport and people come from all round the country so they obviously do stay) I think the rules now are kids have to be in either 6th form, college or an apprenticeship from 16-18 (maybe full time job as well but not sure on that one, might be under special circumstances) but we used to be able to finish at 16 if we wanted For university you need to have some sort of post 16 qualification to be able to get in so either a levels or btec normally It's called 6th form because years 7-11 of secondary (age 11-16) were called 1st to 5th form and for some reason when it changed over 6th form stuck around, although we do also say year 12 and 13 in some places Hopefully that answered your questions and you don't mind that it's from some random person instead of Bryony 😊
@TessaAvonlea
@TessaAvonlea Месяц назад
Sixth form is sort of interchangeable with college. Sixth form is usually attached to a secondary school, while college is usually a completely separate organisation. As a very broad generalisation, sixth forms are usually more academically focused (more traditional subjects like maths, English, history), while colleges often offer a wider range of courses, including vocational subjects (e.g you could study brick laying at college, but it would be very unusual/unheard of to study it at sixth form). But you can also go for the traditional academic options at college. Almost all college/sixth form students continue to live with their family and then move away when they go to university. It used to be true that you could leave education at age 16, but now the rules have changed and some form of education is required until age 18, although this may be an apprenticeship or vocational qualification - it doesn't necessarily need to be in a sixth form or college.
@rebekah3483
@rebekah3483 Месяц назад
​@@_Claire_Louise_Oh thanks so much for all of this! Very interesting! There's no way I minded you answering vs her! I was just wanting the information! Lol! Again, thank you for helping me understand it all a bit better!
@rebekah3483
@rebekah3483 Месяц назад
​@@TessaAvonleaThank you so much for this information! I appreciate youb taking the time to help me understand it better!
@Shayron1989
@Shayron1989 Месяц назад
Just to add to the confusion 😅 This only applies in England (and possibly Wales). Scotland doesn’t have a 6th form, kids stay on at high school til 18 if they want. We have no 6th form colleges, but we do have colleges. These are very varied and can serve young people from about 14ish (usually on day release from school) and can deliver university-level education as well, on a mix of vocational and academic subjects. UK education is wildly diverse considering we are a small country 😅😅
Далее
Why I'm NOT gentle parenting...
23:11
Просмотров 14 тыс.
Why I quit fostering
38:11
Просмотров 23 тыс.
How I saved my first $100,000 (my formula)
8:52
Просмотров 715 тыс.
So our holiday was a bit of a disaster
27:57
Просмотров 11 тыс.
Why I Live a Simple Life - My Story
16:17
Просмотров 395 тыс.
Real Talk About Unschooling Teens (Part 1 of 4)
16:52
My MUST have solo parenting products!
18:35
Просмотров 6 тыс.