Go to ground.news/caspian to stay fully informed on what’s happening in Israel and around the world. Check it out for free or subscribe through my link before November 1 for 30% off unlimited access.
Israel, Hamas, Hezbollah, ISIS, its all the same nut job religious zealots. They all think they are more important then the other, one is allowed to kill the other without consequence when IN REALITY, anyone killing women, children, and innocent civilians is WRONG. Israel is just as wrong as Hamas for killing innocent Palestinian children and civilians.
In before some imbecile says "Murican elites are detached, too!" Yeah... That's why American society is so politically polarized - because they don't rabidly support one or the other party and democracy isn't at all central to the very core of their culture... I swear, the amount of stupid among our species is just too much to handle. The only thing between our self-annihilation through stupidity are the systems we build, among which free market democracy is the best functioning. /e: Aaaaand predictably, all the imbecile comments are precisely this. Human stupidity is so precise and predictable it can be used for scientific measurement.
All governments on this planet dont serve the ppl they re there to keep you in line. The police really role is protecting the rich not the average citizen. Humans are and always will be primates just like our cousins in the jungles.
Man, after doing some research, you always end up finding that these wars are based on international trade corridors and always benefit someone who is not actually fighting. While people like me are just blaming either Jews or Arabs for how cruel they are by killing each other, once you see the insides, then you see how foolish we are and how easily people can be controlled. May God bring peace upon all of us
gods don't exist though Edit: damn lotta whiny religious fools getting upset by this revelation. Y'all better wake up to reality that gods are created by humans.
@@moonshot3159 I disagree, God exists. And you have no way of proving otherwise. Just like I have no way of proving my statement, regardless of what arguments I find.
thats like saying gravity doesnt exist. you atheists think a big boom just happened. if it happened it were did it come from? it has to come from somewhere.@@moonshot3159
As for statistics over countries hosting refugees per capita, this usually does not tell the whole picture. Only Western countries tend to have an automated process of naturalization while countries like Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan host multiple generations of "refugees" for political/stability reasons.
Very true, also the fact that countries like Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan seldom actually pay up front for them supporting and housing refugees in the thousands to hundreds of thousands since the EU, UN and several other organizations provide support for it do it's not in their interest to house diasporas on their territory while for many reasons European countries do like controlled immigration. The intangibles when it comes to support are always left by the wayside
@@marcofavayou say that yet there are thousands of Syrians in tents on turkeys borders treated as Kurds and get the bare minimum. Whilst Turkey and Israel bomb Syria.
Which is at the core of this issue. All the past refugee crises have been resolved one way or another through one of the three solutions: 1. Naturalization 2. Refugees returning back post-war 3. Redistribution with UN mediation to other countries willing to take them in. The only unique case is the Palestinian case. You will find no other people having been refugees for more than a generation, much less 3 or 4. I guess maintaining this anomaly was one of the ways with which the Arab world coped with its defeats in Israel, keeping the Palestinian refugees and their descendants locked perpetually in camps, without any possibility of integrating in their new host countries. They kept hoping that one day, Israel will be defeated and they will return back after the Jews are driven into the sea... which didn't happen.
This is what is missing in most mainstream media. They focus on the immediate conflict itself, and do not cover the wider geopolitical chess game of the region.
It would be convenient for the World and Media to ignore the atrocities of the Israeli government, and focus on the atrocities of Hamas. Meanwhile the millions of innocent Palestinian civilians are being systematically destroyed
Mainstream media is not a phrase you should use if you want people to take you seriously. It's more effective to use popular media or traditional media✌️
Enormous respect for how you have managed to illuminate such a challenging set of issues without alienating any of the primary antagonists. Extraordinary piece of work.
The History of the imaginary Palestinian state: 1. Before Israel there was a British Mandate, not a Palestinian state 2. Before the British Mandate, it was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 3. Before the Ottoman Empire Was the Islamic State of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state. 4. Before the Islamic State of the Mamluks from Egypt, the Arab-Kurdish Empire was the Ayyubid, not a Palestinian state. 5. Before the Ayyubid Empire was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state. 6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem was the Umayyad and Fatimid empire, not a Palestinian state. 7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, the Byzantine Empire was not a Palestinian state. 8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were Sassanids, not a Palestinian state. 9. Before the Sassanid Empire was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state. 10. Before the Byzantine Empire was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 11. Before the Roman Empire it was a Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state. 12. Before the Hasmonean state was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state. 13. Before the Seleucid Empire was the Empire of Alexander, not a Palestinian state. 14. Before Alexander's empire it was the Persian Empire, not a Palestinian state. 15. Before the Persian Empire was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state. 16. Before the Babylonian Empire were the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state. 17. Before the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was no kingdom of Israel in the kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 18. Before the Kingdom of Israel, the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel was not a Palestinian state. 19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an accumulation of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state. 20. In fact, in this plot of land kingdoms fell and fell .. But there was never a Palestinian state or a people.!@## The Palestinians are Arabs and Arabs came from the Arabian Peninsula, they are indigenous to the Arabian Peninsula . It is pure propaganda to claim that Arabs are native to Palestine or that the Palestinians are not Arabs.!@#mmm!!
@@yuval1716 Well if all your points are valid, does that not apply the same to Israel? Also, your first point is wrong, it was known as Mandatory Palestine
Iran and its allies in the region undoubtedly will win this conflict, eventually the US will be evicted for good from the middle east and the demise of Israel will simultaneously take place. US puppet Persian Gulf ruling families like the House of Saud will be overthrown soon after the departure of the US from the region. A new Middle East like 100 years ago will be formed, without Israel, without the presence of the US and without traitor puppet royal dynasties and regimes that serve the interests of foreign colonialist hegemonic powers like the US.
@@yuval1716 You can easily find maps from the 1930s and 40s that explicitly say "Palestine" on it. They people living there for centuries are called Palestinians. A history of imperialism no more justifies colonialism than the British colonialism in India.
I am a Chinese in my 50s. My university classmates’ WeChat group hold two different views on the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. I have been studying English, studying English humor and Western culture for many years. I have watched a lot about religions and Palestinian-Israeli conflict. Everyone has their own attitude. The problem seems unsolvable. I hope people of different cultures can communicate with each other and achieve world peace. Naive? but sincere. I just wrote a little comparison between Chinese and English, which should be helpful for learning Chinese. Discussions, criticisms, and corrections are welcome. I want to contribute something to the world peace.
thank you for your honest comment .. you are one of the few honest and good people still alive , almost all people don't even listen to both party they hear fake news and believe it right away So thank you
The only way for peace is to relocate Palestinians to another country. They are useless just like most Muslims and will fit in anywhere that is muslim.
Iran and its allies in the region undoubtedly will win this conflict, eventually the US will be evicted for good from the middle east and the demise of Israel will simultaneously take place. US puppet Persian Gulf ruling families like the House of Saud will be overthrown soon after the departure of the US from the region. A new Middle East like 100 years ago will be formed, without Israel, without the presence of the US and without traitor puppet royal dynasties and regimes that serve the interests of foreign colonialist hegemonic powers like the US.
It's definitely naive, but it's still a good sentiment. Humans will never truly hold hands and sing koombai ya. Leftists want to force consume everything, including people, into one mass while the right wing wants complete separation even through violent means.
9:20 It's important that UAE and Egypt are Western Left-Wing controlled Authoritarian States (no right-winger or Western people support these governments), so the "public" data is not as freely given as in Saudi-Arabia for example. It's the same with Putin and his oligarchs, who control the public, while the public is not in favor of Oligarchs but their expulsion.
Salam, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace. Netanyahu & Mossad Aided And Funded Hamas, They Had Inside Help, That's Why The Border Was Left For 4 Hours On The Sabbath.
That's why politics will eventually lead to massacres and dehumanising of human. While people are arguing on the morality of such conflict which is irrelevant to the political point of view. For example the political approval of allowing Israel to occupy Palestine to begin with is morally unacceptable and it will never be. This is pure common sense. The political approval of Any kind of ideal doesn't change the core fact of it's morally acceptance as an example (The political approval of LGPT). Almost all of this century's conflicts are based on political point of view that is forced upon people. Then people find themselves in a dire situation wether it is war or the fear of allowing your precious daughter to use the female bathroom, because she might find a politically allowed male who "thinks he is a woman" using the same female area.
Tldr Global did a fairly unbiased video on another aspect of this conflict that isn't covered in this video - demographics, and its impact on the politics in the region. Pretty nice added info to accompany this video imo.
I really appreciated the larger context of how the state actors trying to acquire or prevent others from acquiring military technology is such a big factor. It really is a big arms race for nukes.
he knows nothing. he thinks Iranians are Arab, yet they are Persian. Iran is Persia why anyone should believe a word from this propagandist i say propagandist because if he himself had been the one that did the research for the things he say, he would know that Iranians are Persian, so he just been told what to say without knowing the first thing about what he is talking about. give me even one other scenario that he could be independent who research the topic but still that much ignorance would be possible other than being a legit propagandist literally.
The Gaza Strip is fast changing from being the biggest open-air prison in the world to becoming the biggest death camp in the world, courtesy of Israel's total and indiscriminate bombing. (And before there's any what-about-isms response let me state, I categorically condemn the Gaza massacre on Israeli civilians by HAMAS terrorist, not militants.)
@@wahyuindrastoyeah indiscriminate bro there’s video of them dropping massive amounts of leaflets warning civilians to leave and texting and calling them. Hamas wants dead’s bodies so they’ve told the civilians to stay and die
@@ckthegreat100When you make claims about Isreal you give explanations, but when you make claims about a country you already consider as the ultimate evil and the biggest enemy you can say whatever you want, that doesn't seem unbiased to me.
Salam, Shlomo, Shalom, Peace. Netanyahu & Mossad Aided And Funded Hamas, They Had Inside Help, That's Why The Border Was Left For 4 Hours On The Sabbath.
It's surprising how most YT channels I followed years and years ago have fizzled out and barely get suggested to me. But this channel has gotten far more professional (not that it wasn't when I first started watching). But still love the effort that goes into these deep dives into areas of the world I've never really thought about.
"How can you trap 2.3 million people in Gaza, half of whom are unemployed, in one of the most densely populated spots on the planet for 16 years, reduce the lives of its residents, half of whom are children, to a subsistence level, deprive them of basic medical supplies, food, water and electricity, use attack aircraft, artillery, mechanized units, missiles, naval guns and infantry units to randomly slaughter unarmed civilians and not expect a violent response?"
Here s how you do it. When the state of Israel was formed the Muslim world reacted immediately. 6 countries in the area of the new formed state declared war on Israel. Israel asked the Muslims most of whom were unrepatriated Egyptian workers admitted by the British to perform labor building infrastructure especially railroads in the Palestinian Mandate and TransJordan area. Egypt would not take these workers back. They numbered about 750 000. Israel asked these Muslims to remain in place and not enter the war. Instead the Muslims fled to Jordan Lebanon and Syria and some joined the attack on Israel . At that time the UN had partitioned the former Mandate into an Israeli portion and a Muslim portion . The Israelis accepted the UN partition the Muslims in the affected area did not. After thec1948 war the Muslim refugees tried to return but found their land and property confiscated by the Israeli ggovernment.. They settled in refugee camps. Israel annexed some additional land after defeating its attackers. 3 more wars ensued over the next 25 years. Israel won them all. The muslims remained in refugee camps some of the land assigned by the UN bred more muslims with various hostile factions attacking Israel. And israel settling Various por
@@JoeFreeman-y2dwith great help from US military and Saudi leaders! And the UN state that territory can’t be gained by conquering/invasion it’s illegal . Isreal was founded on a lie and will remain a lying state that can never be honest.
Iran and its allies in the region undoubtedly will win this conflict, eventually the US will be evicted for good from the middle east and the demise of Israel will simultaneously take place. US puppet Persian Gulf ruling families like the House of Saud will be overthrown soon after the departure of the US from the region. A new Middle East like 100 years ago will be formed, without Israel, without the presence of the US and without traitor puppet royal dynasties and regimes that serve the interests of foreign colonialist hegemonic powers like the US.
@@dsxa918For real. I turned on cable news for a second to hear about what was going on, and then caught myself and went straight to RU-vid. Way better.
Are you KIDDING?! Islam has hated Jews since Mohammed (he committed genocide because they wouldn't convert to worshiping him), it is literally the goal of Islam to take over the planet through conquest and to murder all Jews, homosexuals, anyone who resists Islam, anyone who LEAVES Islam. It is a cult, plain and simple, and it replaces culture, religion, ideology, the legal system, EVERYTHING. That's why Israel was attacked, and it's why Islam does most of the terrorism worldwide. They can't win through military force, so they try to intimidate the world.
The History of the imaginary Palestinian state: 1. Before Israel there was a British Mandate, not a Palestinian state 2. Before the British Mandate, it was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 3. Before the Ottoman Empire Was the Islamic State of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state. 4. Before the Islamic State of the Mamluks from Egypt, the Arab-Kurdish Empire was the Ayyubid, not a Palestinian state. 5. Before the Ayyubid Empire was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state. 6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem was the Umayyad and Fatimid empire, not a Palestinian state. 7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, the Byzantine Empire was not a Palestinian state. 8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were Sassanids, not a Palestinian state. 9. Before the Sassanid Empire was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state. 10. Before the Byzantine Empire was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 11. Before the Roman Empire it was a Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state. 12. Before the Hasmonean state was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state. 13. Before the Seleucid Empire was the Empire of Alexander, not a Palestinian state. 14. Before Alexander's empire it was the Persian Empire, not a Palestinian state. 15. Before the Persian Empire was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state. 16. Before the Babylonian Empire were the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state. 17. Before the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was no kingdom of Israel in the kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 18. Before the Kingdom of Israel, the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel was not a Palestinian state. 19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an accumulation of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state. 20. In fact, in this plot of land kingdoms fell and fell .. But there was never a Palestinian state or a people.!@## The Palestinians are Arabs and Arabs came from the Arabian Peninsula, they are indigenous to the Arabian Peninsula . It is pure propaganda to claim that Arabs are native to Palestine or that the Palestinians are not Arabs.!@#mmm!!!@
Correct. However, Islam hates Judaism as their founder committed genocide against them because they wouldn't convert to worshiping Mohammed (Muslims actually worship Mo, not Allah, given the tenets of murdering all who mock Mo but not Allah, and the numerous "revelations" of Mo which only deal with his own stupid problems). Palestine is not the issue, Muslims would still attempt to murder all of Israel even if there were no Palestinians. @@yuval1716
Well, this is the kind of stuff that I grew up watching. After 50+ years it is still predictable that if peace is approached, some section of the equation pulls a spoiler move.
It may be the main reason why all of this is happening, yet almost no one knows. As always, there's business behind every war and the US is always involved
You clearly have a gift for teaching! Turnning difficult to understand topics (in this case exeptionally difficult) into an easily digestible format is so hard to do
And in many ways simple wrong 😂 as it puts no historical background, only recent developments that tells nothing of intentional of actions , but that is predictable, since he doesn’t want to reveal it .
Why wasn't the colonization of Palestine discussed? When Israel created Gaza in 1967 and has since run the Gaza strip as an open-air prison...this is not new and questionable information. It is fact and is a major part of this genocide...I don't think this video tells the whole story and that's very unfortunate to see.
The Gaza Strip was administered by Egypt from 1948 to 1967 because Israel didn't include its national project. But Gaza didn't become an open air prison until Hamas violently took over in 2007. That's when Israel and Egypt closed their border crossings with Gaza (turning it into the open air prison that it is today.)
I understand that but there is some informatjon missing...In 1947 the UN announced the Palestine Partition Plan that would divide then Palestine into two states, one for Jewish people and one for the Arab people who have already inhabited the region for centuries. The Arab nations, including Egypt, were very much against this but they had no vote. At that time Britain had control over Palestine and once the resolution was passed, they abandoned Palestine for the partition to take place. This is when the zionist world organization initiated their invasion of Palestine aka the Israeli- Arab War. During that co fiction Israel advanced far out of the bounds that we're set by the resolution and the Arab states were able to maintain two sections of territory. One being the West Bank and the other being the Gaza strip. Many of the Palestinians who fled the Israeli forces ended up in the Gaza strip where they existed as a part of Egypt until 1967..when Israel attacked and then took over control of the borders and resources of Gaza. They control who and what could leave and when... then they proposed the Oslo accords that spit in the face of the native Palestinians and led to further strife. In 2005 the last elections of Gaza were held and that is where Hamas took control. Hamasaki was a group built for the liberation of their people. Once Hamas took control of Gaza, Egypt and Israel locked down the borders making it the open air prison it is today...
@@BarryAllen__1A23Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
Barely 10 minutes in and this topic is 100x more complex than the Silmarillion. I love the breakdown, this is the first time I feel like the complex relationships in the Middle East are approachable.
he knows nothing. he thinks Iranians are Arab, yet they are Persian. Iran is Persia why anyone should believe a word from this propagandist i say propagandist because if he himself had been the one that did the research for the things he say, he would know that Iranians are Persian, so he just been told what to say without knowing the first thing about what he is talking about. give me even one other scenario that he could be independent who research the topic but still that much ignorance would be possible other than being a legit propagandist literally.
The Gaza Strip is fast changing from being the biggest open-air prison in the world to becoming the biggest death camp in the world, courtesy of Israel's total and indiscriminate bombing. (And before there's any what-about-isms response let me state, I categorically condemn the Gaza massacre on Israeli civilians by HAMAS terrorist, not militants.)
How is it unbiased if he doesn't mention that Israel is a literal apartheid state cutting off access to clean water, electricity, and many other basic needs? Just because everything he said seems unbiased it doesn't mean there weren't things he avoided mentioning.
Before this war, Gaza had access to electricity for 4 hours a day (completely regulated by Israel.) Also the average age in Gaza is 18 years old, 60% of the population (300000) are displaced because of Isreal's attacks. This isn't a counter-offensive from Israel, they will kill as many people as they can before the UN steps in and tells them to not murder thousands of civilians for 200th time.
@@simonjohansson3242 He's unbiased because he used highly factual resources to discuss the topic at hand. Israel being an apartheid state is a commonsense fact...
I find this "trade corridor" -thing very unbelieveable. All the goods from India to Europe travel by maritime transports through Suez canal. Nobody in their right mind would involve land transports through UAE, Saudi Arabia, Jordan and Israel into that. There is absolutely no benefit. Only cost and complications. All these countries already have trade relations.
India - I believe this is proposed to be in parallel with the India-Moscow - North-South Corridor... but it never takes off because of issues with each country that needs to be involved... we are on board Saudi - We want the Neom City project going... international participation can only add to our investment Israel - We need normalization with Saudi to an extent as already spoken in the Video UAE - hmm I don't know what changes for me... I am gaining some brownie points from Uncle Sam Jordan - Whatever the US, Israel, and Saudi say... we follow Greece and EU - I guess it is different somehow, if the US invests some money we can counter Chinese influence to an extent US - !!BAM!! lets call it a corridor
Given how sensitive the Suez Canal is to events like the Evergreen ship and how much tonnage of goods it delays, I think this trade corridor will only further expand and increase the traffic of goods flowing from India to Europe. which means less money wasted on delays
@@saud892Maritime route is still way faster. Also, it will require loading/unloading on at least three/four different places instead of just two. This is just a hillarious counter to Belt and Road initiative (which quite frankly is stupid too) just like build back better.
It’s not as much a trade corridor as a “relations” corridor, in which the new relation is each other expanding militarily without freaking each other out
This just popped up in my recommendations - top notch graphics with factual analysis and objective presentation - this is why fighting to keep the internet free, alternative media alive and promote open source are crucial battles in this era of biased, agenda driven and cui bono media dominance. Thank you!
no, it wasn't. he knows nothing. he thinks Iranians are Arab, yet they are Persian. Iran is Persia why anyone should believe a word from this propagandist i say propagandist because if he himself had been the one that did the research for the things he say, he would know that Iranians are Persian, so he just been told what to say without knowing the first thing about what he is talking about. give me even one other scenario that he could be independent who research the topic but still that much ignorance would be possible other than being a legit propagandist literally.
The powers that be have been using channels exactly like this to pick up where msm left off. "Alternative media" is still controlled and paid for messaging, its just harder to tell whos pulling the strings now.
Iran and its allies in the region undoubtedly will win this conflict, eventually the US will be evicted for good from the middle east and the demise of Israel will simultaneously take place. US puppet Persian Gulf ruling families like the House of Saud will be overthrown soon after the departure of the US from the region. A new Middle East like 100 years ago will be formed, without Israel, without the presence of the US and without traitor puppet royal dynasties and regimes that serve the interests of foreign colonialist hegemonic powers like the US.
@@CoverBydAn I mainly meant the amount of information being reported that, at least I, had been unaware of prior. Diving deeper behind subjects and reporting on their geopolitical nature is still a form of journalism
@@CoverBydAn Yu ish propaganda mixed with watered down information. Any channel with coverage unfavorable to Israel is D mo.n.e.t.i.zed and or b.a.n.n.e.d.. For a more accurate analysis start with t wit' now know as X jackson h inklle, Sprinter99800, HistoryLegends_
@@CoverBydAn What, do you want to hear only the immediate reason and damn the context? Well in that case Hamas itself gave it on Day 1 - it's called operation Al-Aqsa Flood in response to earlier Israeli provocations at the Al-Aqsa Mosque. There, does that teach you anything? If so, you don't think very hard. There's more to this than proximate events.
Wow, this was the most comprehensive, factual, and unbiased analysis of this geopolitical issue; on top of that, great visual stats, and maps. You’ve done an Amazing job, sir!
he knows nothing. he thinks Iranians are Arab, yet they are Persian. Iran is Persia why anyone should believe a word from this propagandist i say propagandist because if he himself had been the one that did the research for the things he say, he would know that Iranians are Persian, so he just been told what to say without knowing the first thing about what he is talking about. give me even one other scenario that he could be independent who research the topic but still that much ignorance would be possible other than being a legit propagandist literally.
The Gaza Strip is fast changing from being the biggest open-air prison in the world to becoming the biggest death camp in the world, courtesy of Israel's total and indiscriminate bombing. (And before there's any what-about-isms response let me state, I categorically condemn the Gaza massacre on Israeli civilians by HAMAS terrorist, not militants.)
Shirvon, you're accent when speaking English has become more subtle, excellent improved pronunciation. I've loved your channel for years. Keep up the good work.
@@lioralk9after the Ottoman collapse there was a 2 year governing Palestine sovereign state I know this for a fact and I have family that still have their government documents from the government of Palestine for things like wills and deeds. But that isn't even the point , it's against international law to drive people out of their homes regardless of the name of the governing body of that 'home' , not sure how you zionists think erasing Palestine statehood history helps justify the implementation of an apartheid state and ethnic cleansing. Palestinians have a right to return and you can't deny that
no, it wasn't. he knows nothing. he thinks Iranians are Arab, yet they are Persian. Iran is Persia why anyone should believe a word from this propagandist i say propagandist because if he himself had been the one that did the research for the things he say, he would know that Iranians are Persian, so he just been told what to say without knowing the first thing about what he is talking about. give me even one other scenario that he could be independent who research the topic but still that much ignorance would be possible other than being a legit propagandist literally.
Thank you for all your videos over the years. This one I’ve been waiting for since the day this happened. I was waiting for your take. I always feel like I’m being professionally debriefed in a situation room. You’re the best.
Appreciate your actual journalism and breakdown of information that sadly isn’t mainstream. This was an amazing experience, I feel like I’ve learned so much. Thank you.
I believe we should call for a referendum. The most rightful thing is a referendum made by true original land owners (Palestineans, including native Palestinean jews) and they decide the state they want. Simple. Very simple. It's not a thousands of years matter. Otherwise, the immigrants who stole the land should go back to where they came from.
Wow 😮! You totally outdid Peter Zeihan with this report. This is the best lay out of the middle eastern crisis happening to date some nice the Hamas attack. Will be able to share this with anyone who wants to know what’s going on 💪🏻🙏👍🏻
Hey Shirvan, nice English plugin you got there :). I was like I'm missing my favorite Caspian reporter to later realize it was actually you. Thanks for giving your perspective in this matter and for keeping us informed about the world we are living. It's amaizing how one guy can beat the news establishment in actually presenting the news not their stupid opinions. Un abrazo amigo!
@@rowdyduterte8476 Yes, it was him. I always dislike when he used an English lector in the past. To me the accent is part of the charm of the channel. Keep it up Shirvan!
Respect so much for not taking sides in any of this. For presenting objective info, objective analysis and objective perspective. We need more of this. It’s time to look for solutions rather than guilty parties, everyone in this conflict is dirty some what. Sadly, the recipients are always the citizens on both sides, specially in Gaza which have to choose between evil leaders and fierce enemies. It’s time to find a total agreement.
There can be no peace in the region as long as there is an autonomous zionist state. Thats the uncomfortable truth, that deep down, every israeli knows.
Hamas officials in video interviews here on YT first said that there were no civilian kidnappings, then admitted it due to the overwhelming evidence, and in another interview, a separate Hamas representative referred to a 3 year old girl kidnapped for use as a human shield as a “Prisoner of War.”
Lol they posted videos of them taking civilian prisoneres, Its a war thats what they have to do to negotiate prisoner exchange, Israel has thousands and thousands of Civilian prisoners including children as young as 10 years old.
@@nassimhaiouani3772 When did Israel run into Gaza and kidnap kids, to use as human shields? When did Israel troops run into a wedding and kill hundreds of fleeing, unarmed party goers? When has Israel parade the naked, tortured bodies of young women through the streets of Israel, as the Israel populace danced in glee at the suffering? There are wrongs on both, but you can’t say it’s fine if your side targets civilians deliberately, but it’s wrong if the other side might harm civilians unintentionally during air strikes. Or say it’s fine for your side do sneak attacks with no warning to civilians, but wrong if the other side gives civilians “only” 1-5 days warning to move from the area. And EVERY country has true, unavenged wrongs against them, especially if you go back to the 1940s. But should China and the Philippines still be attacking and bombing Japan, and vice versa, due to Japanese atrocities in WW2? Should Israel be regularly attacking preschools in Germany today as payback for the Holocaust? Should Russia and Germany still be at war due to the many war crimes each committed against the other? The rest of the world has figured how to not just keep adding to the body count. Plus, doesn’t basic common sense say that if you are mad at an Israeli guard for shooting at peaceful Gaza protestors…and you get “revenge” or justice, it needs to be on the person who actually did the crime? Not just, “well, we can’t get that murderer, so…let# grab a neighbors kid and maybe a teen girl and execute them…close enough.” No matter what the prior act, deliberately targeting toddlers and kidnapping them as “POWs” is wrong, on every level (morally, by rules of war it’s a war crime, and even Muslim scholars note that passages in the Koran forbids deliberately harming non-combatants).
Exquisite presentation - the level of detailed information, graphics, and narration is second to none. Well done sir. I look forward to more, on a broad range of topics.
I hate Israel, but the actions of Hamas were barbaric. Then again Israel really has never been much better at all. I pray for the innocent Israeli and Palestinian citizens that are caught in the middle.
The only Innocent Israelis are Children and Haredim, the rest are/were soldiers and vote to their criminal government, not innocent at all even if they were wearing civilian clothes, they will be turned into soldiers in 24 hours.
This was the most well researched, well explained video describing the conflict. The explanation of the other potential players was extremely interesting. Well done
Must say as an Israeli tho experienced some scrutiny during the video this is very accurate description…thanks for your unbiased analysis on the subject 👏🏻
Man, where have you been because I needed you to help make sense of what was going & now that I have a clearer picture of what's going on.. I find myself at a loss for words because I had no idea of the other issues going on behind the scenes. Plus, I don't like how things got to this point & it's going to get even more difficult if things don't change or stop & renegotiate for a better peace.
we had the pleasure of tasting American/Nato Freedom in Libya and Iraq. we lerned the hard way ! "But they plan, and Allah plans. And Allah is the best of planners. [Surah Al-Anfal | Ayah 30]@@Morty143
@@mansari7310he is Azeri. He knows Iranians are not Arabs. He included it ln the map which he falsely labeled as the Arab world because Iran is a major player in the Arab world despite not being in it per se. It's a small mistake for an otherwise pretty phenomenal video.
So, as a neutral party that has empathy for both sides, and would appreciate not being attacked, I would recommend those interested to continue watching videos and learn from multiple sources. Although a great video, all have some sort of bias, and the best thing we can all do if we are truly interested in learning and understanding is to remember that we will have a flawed understanding if we only take one source of truth. Prayers and love to all of you including Israel, Palestine, and the rest of the world.
What a great great job as always. My only suggestion would be to add subtitles to your amazing videos. Wish I could send this vid to my spanish speaking relatives and friends
As much as I like the analysis you provided and the effort you put in this video I still think its missing crucial details. Why not mention the root cause of the Palestinian conflict which is the Palestinian Nakba in 1948 and the fact that 750,000 palestinians got kicked out of their lands and 450 villages were razed and destroyed? Why have the Palestinians been under military occupation for the past decades?
Who started the war that lead to the Nakba? Also why did they declare war? Spoiler Alert. It was the Palestinians in reaction to the proposed 2 State solution by the UN. And this sadly is just how it went back then. The India Pakistan solution saw huge population displacements. So did the end of WW2
Maybe you can mention that Muslims built a mosque *on top of* the holiest site in Judaism, after they colonized Jerusalem. Arabs are invaders and colonizers, and they project this image that they’re indigenous - which is pretty clever of them to use time machines to construct the Jewish Temple Mount under their mosque
Seeing the “whole” green area for West Bank Palestine shows your bias. The Israelíes are occupying more and more of this area. It easy to agree that Hamas attack was heinous but we must also agree that Israel is an apartheid rule that is looking to minimize if not ethnically cleanse Palestinians in Israel.
"Every time there is a conflict, Israel mows the lawn. That is the expression they use, mowing the lawn. By which they mean the mass murder of Palestinians... I could go on and on and on. Except I'll say that the disproportion of power and responsibility and oppression is so markedly on one side that you take the worst thing you can say about Hamas, multiply it by a thousand times, and it still will not meet the Israeli repression and killing and dispossessed of Palestinians. If after 2000 years we can look for liberation and freedom, why can't the Palestinians?" -Dr. Gabor Maté, a holocaust survivor
The "apartheid" that doesn't exist? The one that has no laws against arabs? That arabs are 1/5 of Israel population and their numbers are actually growing? The same country with arab doctors, lawyers, parliament members and so on?
Don't EVER blend the border between content and advertisement in your field of education. Your advertisement needs to be CLEARLY separated from the content. You are not a "top 10 cats" channel.
Finally. I have been wondering when an analysis of this attack in the media would explain the SA/Israel/US accord that was so close to finalization. I would only add that such an accord would disrupt the work of Russia and China -including arms deliveries to SA - were engaged in to take US influence in the region away. Russia and China must be looking on closely. Also, the action of Hamas was to the ultimate detriment not only to Iran, but also to Palestinians in the W Bank and elsewhere. Thanks as usual to Caspian Report for about the most valuable and useful analysis on YT (or anywhere).
Long story short, because Israel has been doing the same thing for decades, so, without ever getting sanctionned. Justice didn't do its job, laws were applied to everyone but them, so a group got radicalized and wanted to make justice on its own.
I was impressed with your command of the English language from the moment I first stumbled upon your channel. Although the substance of your commentary is obviously the primary draw, I was struck while watching this video in particular by the syntactic elegance of your expression and crispness of your pronunciation. I don't know if this is attributable to a new writer or editor or to your own constant and continuous improvement, but it is no small feat. Both stylistically and substantively, you've become a real standout among RU-vid's geopolitical commentators. Kudos!
@@ualaw77 That is what I think because when he is Shirvan speaking he always says "I'm your host Shirvan" Also the voice is quite similar, but not exactly the same. It has slight differences.
@@ualaw77 Actually I just checked his previous video "Why Ukraine joining Nato would crush russian power" and he doesn't say that anymore. But if you compare and pay attention you can clearly notice the voice and pronunciation differences.
@@rodri1030 You've got a good ear! I noticed the difference, but I didn't realize it was a totally different person. Who the heck is THIS guy? 😆 Do you suppose it could be an AI imitation of Shirvan?
I appreciate getting decent unbiased, rational explanations of these important events. Much better than just watching current news shows that mainly report and describe them. Thank you!
I believe we should call for a referendum. The most rightful thing is a referendum made by true original land owners (Palestineans, including native Palestinean jews) and they decide the state they want. Simple. Very simple. It's not a thousands of years matter. Otherwise, the immigrants who stole the land should go back to where they came from.
While your analysis might be reasonable from a geopolitical point of view involving outside players, you really do not answer the headline of the video; why was Israel attacked by militant Palstinians (Hamas)? The attack has certainly affected geopolitical dilemmas, but the reason Hamas attacked Israel is due to the Palestinian struggle and opression. I wish that you spent more time on what has led to the attack.
While waiting for this video, today I saw your video from 12 years ago on Israel/Palestine. Really puts perspective on this everlasting issue. Thanks for amazing unbiased insight
The Gaza Strip is fast changing from being the biggest open-air prison in the world to becoming the biggest death camp in the world, courtesy of Israel's total and indiscriminate bombing. (And before there's any what-about-isms response let me state, I categorically condemn the Gaza massacre on Israeli civilians by HAMAS terrorist, not militants.)
@@wahyuindrasto nothing says indiscriminate bombing like using high precision missiles instead of artillery and mortars. You've been blinded by propaganda my friend
Iran is not an arab country. Not sure why you painted them green when you mention "arab world" Please educate yourself on the choice of words. none the less, great video.
