Why Pakistan Lost the Space Race? | India’s Mission to Moon Chandryan-3 | Syed Muzammil Official 

India is NOT Pakistan's enemy. Pakistan's ideology is its own enemy. Let there be peace and prosperity everywhere!

If Abdus Salam was indian trust me he would have been celebrated every year and trust me more Hindus would have worship him than muslim itself. Same with kalam saab. Man the amount of influence he would have created

As an Indian I could mock but I won't --- hats off to your courage at analysing your country end criticizing constructively. I wish you folks well

I heard Mr. Syed Muzammil for the first time, and I couldn’t believe my ears, that such a rational mind exists in Pakistan. His intellect, knowledge, clarity of thought, scientific bent of mind is superb. He is like a rare plant in a dreary desert. But will Pakistan ruling elite listen to him ? No way ! The country is on a free fall and neither the ruling elite nor the ignorant masses care. Such is the tragedy of Pakistan. I feel sad for them.

India’s space research program started as INCOSPAR in 1962 and renamed as ISRO in 1969.. Dr. Abdul Kalam was an employee of INCOSPAR and Vikram Sarabai the chairman..

When i graduated from IIT Chennai in 1998, the total money i spent for the 4 years program was around Rs 50,000. This money was reimbursed as my Dad was a central government employee. World Class education given free of cost!!! Unimaginable even in countries like USA. where there are multiple universities, lesser population and Government is rich.

My friend's daughter scored 96% in 2nd yr of Aeronautical Engineering. I feel so proud of her😍😘 We see our future ISRO Scientist in her😊❤️

As a kashmiri i love india 🇮🇳 from shrinagar india

I am not kidding, I had a Pakistani friend during my grad school and he told me that In his undergrad, the professor asked him to research on the speed of Jinn. And he wasn’t joking, he was dead serious while the rest of us Indians saw each other with utter disbelief with what we just heard!!

2:18 After winning the Nobel Prize in 1979, Dr Abdus Salam had requested the Indian government to find Professon *Anilendra Ganguly* who taught him mathematics in the pre-partition era at the *Sanatan Dharma College* in Lahore. Salam had credited Ganguly for instilling the interest towards mathematics in him, which, he believed, led him to become a scientist.

Big achievement by India. We would be at this level too but instead of educating our children we handed them guns and told them to do Jihad meanwhile India invested in world class Universities. Thanks Zia Ul Haq!

Indians deserve more achievements coz they have got sincere leadership... heartiest congratulations to them on the success of chandaryan❤

Two very key achievements of ISRO you forgot : 1) Chandrayaan 1 - 2009 gave proof of water on moon. 2) Mission Mars (2015).

Thank god we had visionary people like Homi Bhabha, APJ Abdul Kalam and Vikram Sarabhai. This dream came true because of their dedication and patriotism towards our country.

Thank god Dr. APJ Abdul Kalam was an Indian Scientist and President of India and isro . We Indians love and respect him , he is genuinely a man with 0 haters .. he is immortal 😇

I request my fellow Indians to be restrained in their comments. Some are downright abhorrent. Sad. Sayed Muzammil is a brilliant and courageous individual who speaks his mind. I have heard many of his videos.He deserves our respect.

Two mistakes in the video. Firstly, Indian space program was started in 1962 named as INCOSPAR. It was renamed as ISRO in 1969. Secondly, India has already reached on the Moon way back in 2008 under Chandrayan 1. So, India is already the 4th nation to reach the Moon. The difference this time is that Chandrayan 3 is trying for soft landing on lunar surface which is different from impact landing. Also it will be the first mission on South Pole of moon, 70 * south.

Respect to Homi bhabha and CV raman ,those who teaches Vikram sarabhai,who founded ISRO ,and thnx to APJ abdul kalam carrying this legacy with scientists like Nambi Narayan ,Satish Dhawan 😊

Undoubtedly the most unbiased , transparent and logical person I have come across .From philosophy to history, from woman rights to pashteen movement ,from politics to religious arguments the way He explains & sum up things is bloody brilliant . You are such a gem, a masterman and an intellectual .

This is the only Pakistani I have seen on Pak media nowadays who talks on sound logic, sane reasoning and able to assess and depict current situation very well, That’s why I have great respect for him ! Well done ! Keep up Good work !

As a kashmiri I proud to be indian. Mission chandrayan 3 is successful 👍

For the first time, I did not rejoice even though a Pakistani rationalist is giving India credit. I can literally see the angst and his burning desire to see his country prosper. Need more folks like this who can dissociate facts from jingoism.

Very good points and excellent comparison Syed, few more points I would like to add- 1- Working in ISRO is considered very respectable in Indian society, almost equal to army. 2- Acceptance rate of ISRO is equivalent to IITs 3- ISRO didn't blew up in just one day or one mission,they worked , failed , learnt from mistakes and improved over the time.

Mr Syed is a rationalist and a realist. Very wise , intelligent and an eloquent speaker. Always refreshing to hear him.😊

Pakistan ka sbse samajdar insan jo sochta he or smjta he fir bat krta he .... Courageous man ✅❤️

Pakistani people priorities: Islam,Musalman,Jihad,Kafir, Inshallah, Zazba, Kashmir,Phalistin.

Unlike Pakistan, india 🇮🇳 has always respected and idolized Genius Minds irrespective of cast, creed or religion. Knowledge has always been put on higher pedestal than anything! This is the main reason behind India's success!!

What the Pak Govt did to Dr. Salam is absolutely heartbreaking. A Nobel Prize winner was treated with so much disrespect. Really goes to show how scientific reform cannot come under the shadow of religious fanaticism.

ISRO's journey was started with no launch vehicles we used cycles had budget constraints always but this institution efffected every indian as when chandrayan was going to launch i was in my class and class of 400 students requested our respected Teacher to show the launch of chandrayan and we all 400 students watched live on youtube . All i mean to say is the level of craze has increased manifolds. Respect from My beloved motherland India 🇮🇳

SUPARCO - Administrator - Major General Amer Nadeem ISRO - Director - S Somnath 1985: B Tech degree in mechanical engineering from TKM College of Engineering, Kollam. 1995: Master's degree in aerospace engineering and dynamics control from IISc, Bangalore. Worked in various companies to gain professional experience and earn money. 2008: Ph.D. degree in mechanical engineering from IIT Madras.

Mr. Syed, Please note that Indian Space Agency was previously known as INCOSPAR which was set up by the Government of India in 1962, and was renamed as ISRO on August 15, 1969.

It’s an interesting question - Why Pakistan lost the space race ? The follow up pertinent question is - when was Pakistan ever in race to space, moon or mars ??

Jhande pe Chand🇵🇰 hona aur Chand pe Jhanda🌔🇮🇳 hone me bas aukat ka farak hota hai ~ Kumar Vishwas

In Pakistan, Agriculture university Faisalabad didn't allow people (I'm not talking about men instead of women) to enter into the campus wearing shorts like soccer players do even in summers and this is for all including visitors. How can we progress and become open minded on choosing clothes for someone else. Vice Chancellors introducing such policies should have learned something from international higher education institutions.

Interesting story- Dr Abdus Salam was taught mathematics by an Indian teacher Prof. Anilendra Ganguly, who instilled in Salam the passion for mathematics. Post winning the Nobel prize, Dr Salam went to India after many bureaucratic difficulties in search of his beloved teacher. He finally met him at his residence. The teacher had grown very feeble and old. Dr Salam put his Nobel prize medal around his neck and told him that the medal belonged to Prof. Ganguly who instilled in Salam the passion for mathematics when he was in college. It’s so intriguing how the destinies of the two nations are intertwined. An Indian prof inspired a Pakistani to pursue sciences who later played a pivotal role in the development of Pakistan’s nuclear programme.

After attempting for three years to obtain an internship in Pakistan as an aeronautical engineer, I gave up on my ambition and travelled to another country to study. Aerospace in Pakistan is a disaster

The main difference in everything that Pakistan does is it's lack of genuine intent. This has plagued Pakistan in all walks of life. India has moved ahead with honest intent. It does what it says!!

Generals have 70 years experience of conducting experiments. They are the most qualified to head any scientific institution 😃

This gives a lot of depression when I hear that how other countries are progressing and developing and how we are still 100 years behind from rest of the world. I just want to leave this shit hole at this point and never wanna come back.

If Pakistani wants why ISRO has become a brand then search Homi Jahangir Bhabha , Satish Dhawan and Abdul Kalam all headed ISRO for many and many years and all belonged to different religion , some were Muslims and Parsis and they all are worshipped in india specially among Hindu community. Abdul Kalam later on became president and supported by BJP and still every young Hindu student wants to become like Abdul Kalam .

I can understand your pain. You are not the only one going through this suffering. Good job, and keep it up.

No issue if our counterpart india is thriving in space technology there are more countries like the UK, Australia, Germany and other major European countries also haven't launched any moon mission. We should be happy and proud as our neighbour has achieved this feat.

He is matured person, spreading good and progressive thought for humanity..

First time listening to this man and must say that I'm impressed ! Rarely come across any knowledgeable Pakistani young man ! Keep up the good work for your country...your country badly needs people like you!

झण्डे पर चाँद होना और चाँद पर झंडे होने में बहुत अंतर होता है😅😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

FYI, INCOSPAR (1962) was renamed in 1969 as ISRO. The space programs started in 3rd five year plan i.e in late 50s itself but official recognition and HQs were established in 1962.

Brother small correction, Nerhu is not the initiated the interest of science common people indian, it is swami veikananda when he visit west and meet Tesla, and latter he planted the seed inspiring Dadabhai Norajee Tata to sponsor the research program so it was before independence also people were interested on science

This guy is a gem of Pakistan...

Most of the views are from India , Pakistanis won't see this channel , they will not learn anything from this great person Muzammil sir , Indians always respect good minds like you sir , we Indians value and reapect your beautiful thoughts .

Well said Mr Muzammil. I am an NRI Indian in US and impressed with your monologue. Few more people like you at the helm of Pakistan is a must for its right place in the world. Good luck Syed

As an Indian Muslim medical student,,,,,,i appreciate your ideology , share this good positive vibe with light of knowledge...❤

True intellectual that I have come accross till date from Pak. You will find very few like these. Well spoken, Entirely logical.

YOU DIDNT MENTION HIS TEACHER, He was a Hindu Bengali teacher who first spotted him a taught him. After his Noble prize Salam when to Kolkata and gave his medal 🏅 to his Hindu teacher who was bedridden by that time. Search this out…

I completely agree with your point of view that Pakistan is not a scientific and rational society. The best decision I made was to leave Pakistan, as I would never be appreciated there. Now, I'm happily pursuing my Master's degree in data science in Germany. Conducting research on various topics to understand the use of social media, why and how humans behave online, and how it translates into offline/real life. Hopefully, if all goes according to plan, I'll start my PhD in AI soon. It broke my heart and soul when I left Pakistan, but now, looking back, I would say that I made the best decision of my life. I was always ridiculed for my critical, logical, and rational thinking in Pakistan. People here appreciate me for my logical, rational, and scientific thinking. I'm one of the few lucky ones for whom the education system wasn't able to conform to their standards, and my critical thinking stayed intact. I was beaten up by most teachers in my school years. Once, my Islamait teacher hit me so hard on the side of my head that my left ear had a ringing sound for two weeks and I wasn't able to hear. The reason for that horrible abuse from my teacher was that I asked some very critical questions about Islam, and I wanted to attempt the exam of Islamait in 9th grade in English. In 9th grade, we were taught how genes work and how males are responsible for determining the sex of the fetus in biology class. On the other hand, a hardcore extremist and consecutive teacher of Urdu said this is all bullshit, and it is the female who determines the sex of the fetus. This is the reality of the education system in Pakistan. I didn't do well in matriculation and the FSC system as I can't memorize text and then produce it in the exams as I think logically. In bachelor’s university, my peers would memorize the answers to the mathematical questions so they could answer them in their exams. Favoritism and brown nosing were two of the reasons I didn't want to pursue further education in Pakistan. In my 4th year of a bachelor’s degree, when I started working on my thesis, my group was rejected, and I was put in another group to do research and thesis work. I didn't want to work with those peers as I didn't get along with them for personal reasons, and when I approached my teachers and said that either I would like to make another group of mine to do my thesis or to do it alone, I was told by my teachers to worry about my death as both of them said that no one would come to my funeral if I kept behaving like this (being logical, rational, scientific, and standing up for my values and ethics). I gave them a lecture that I can easily tell you they will remember for the rest of their lives. Any layered argument I had about any topic that was being discussed, and I was told to shut up with my 'philosophy'. Reminded me of Plato's allegory of the cave. These are just a few instances I mentioned, and there are hundreds more in the past that I can recall. Pakistan will never prosper, as this is how you behave with logical, rational, and scientific people. India has prospered as they have had a functional democracy since 1947, and their government has focused on education. While Pakistan only focused on becoming a security and rentier state. Pakistan's education budget is a joke! Most university graduates only get degrees for the sake of getting a degree and not for knowledge, as there is no thirst for or desire for knowledge among the people of Pakistan. There isn't much rational, logical, and scientific thinking in the universities of Pakistan. The ones who could have changed the future of Pakistan have left the country and are doing great in their respective fields around the world.

Muzzamil you did Superb job. So encouraging.... It's motivational vlog. Thank you.... I am sharing it on my social media pages. We can try to spread awareness, it can be beginning.

"Akal ka dakal nai" is the reason why Pakistan is behind rocket science 😂

Whatever political situation unfolded in Pakistan and establishment got exposed Pakistanis have realised k unko 70 saal Chay banaya gaya, lekin ab bohat dair ho chukky hai. Is saari soorat e haal k baad ab mujhay India aur Indians se koi nafrat koi gilla ya shikwa nahi bal k mujhay india acha lagnay lag gaya hai Ghussa hai to khud par hai , kudos to India and its people for upholding true democratic values in their country.

This video should reach each and every family in pakistan for their learning where they stand. Great muzzamil.

🇮🇳 ISRO was previously the Indian National Committee for Space Research (INCOSPAR), set up by the Government of India in 1962, as envisioned by Dr. VikramA Sarabhai.💪🏻 Jai Hind🇮🇳

I am from India and I will say you are a very thoughtful person. I hope that such a logical person like you might be able to live in a better place. Thank you for the video. The world needs mind like you. God bless brother

al beruni spent 16 years in india learning sanskrit , maths and astronomy . he wrote this in his own book .

Well educated person you are I love my India thanks God for giving me motherland like India 🇮🇳❤️‍🔥

I've came across your channel some days earlier, and I'm in love with your knowledge heavy content sir. Lots of love from INDIA sir...❤️🇮🇳❤️

Brother, we youngsters want u as our leader. U r truly an inspiration. I hope u will submit your papers for general election as independent candidate and we will vote you... Your videos are changing minds so keep uploading

Jai Hind! I am from India. Wishing that knowledge prevails.

My favorite pak youtubers ho aap .....aap hamesha fact par bina fear ke baat karte ho....i love my india ❤❤🇮🇳🇮🇳

Just another thought provoking video of this man. The most potent way of influence in 21st century is science and political power. If Pakistan wants to thrive, grasp these two.

The Indian National Committee for Space Research (INCOSPAR) was set up in 1962 by Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru on the urging of Vikram Sarabha. In 1950, the Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) was founded with Bhabha as its secretary. It provided funding for space research.

Fun fact: India 🇮🇳was the first country in the world to introduce a family planning program in 1952 but kind of failed in it due to political will.. Same with Pakistan's🇵🇰 space program all talks and no implementation.. ISRO is a unique example which shows what happens when you let scientists do their work without political interference!! 🔥🔥

Correction: India already has top-notch remote sensing capabilities and indigenous satellite navigation system called NAVIC.

I had a coworker in US from Karachi Pakistan. Her father was Professor in Pakistan n she is a Physician in US. One day I had normal discussion with her and she said "Quran is written by Farishtas and they brought it to earth from Jannat". I was like mmmm Let me walk out from here 😂😂😂

Good job,...❤❤❤ Love from. India.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

Bro I am an Indian and you have earned a huge respect in our hearts on the grounds of your scientific temper and rationality

Syed sahab I see you from india. This is first time to see your vedio. Really you speak the reality. मैं ही पूरा भारत चाहता है कि पाकिस्तान स्टेबल हो, शिक्षा और विज्ञान की तरफ जाए। धार्मिक कट्टरवाद से आगे निकले। हालांकि धार्मिक कट्टरता सब जगह होती है। एक बात बहुत अच्छी लगी मुझे की पीठ पर बम्ब फोड़ने को आगे बढ़ाया शासकों ने। जबकि अगर वही पैसा शिक्षा पर लगाया होता तो आज दोनो देश अपनी अपनी सुरक्षा पर कम खर्च कर रहे होते और एक सभ्य समाज की और बढ़ रहे होते सहयोग के साथ। हमारे जवान, निर्दोष नागरिक असमय मौत के मुंह में न जाते।

Who is the chairman of SUPARCO from 2010 to present all names start with major general in same contrast all the chairmans of ISRO is scientist. This is the priority

You nailed it bro ..Pakistan has to learn how to keep religion out of education...but unfortunately it appears distant dream....Pakistan needs whole lot of ppl like you...very good analysis..keep it up😊

7:10 Zakir Nalaik popularized such thinking, thanks to people like him

Bro, the first person of Pakistan who is making rational of how things happened and what the new vision next ought to be.. people in charge take note 👏

I’m so addicted by now I literally wait for every update/ next video… be it a discussion or short video! @SyedMuzammil no matter what pakistan says, you have won! 🙌

Good job muzammil Bhai, great comparison, this is why we are on the descend to chsoz

The pain and frustration that this man feels for his country is palpable in his voice. Unfortunately, the trajectory of last 75 years since Independence has resulted in the current situation. Unless and until the religious element and reactionary element is brought to heed, I do not see a way forward. In India, I can feel the nationalism when I visit. Nationalism can be a source of good in developing pride and a sense of purpose. However, gone un checked it can be toxic also. I hope we Indians avoid that fate.

As an Indian I advice everyone that we should all be not coming on these kind of channel to just massage our ego,if you want real competition we should compare ourselves to atleast countries like Indonesia,Brazil,China etc which gives us tought competition.

the plus point with India is that s Hinduism is so deep with philosophical sciences .. you can't even imagine .. its so great that western countries has been researching for so long,, Rishi Kanaad statue is there outside cern laboratory ... pls do R&D on this

I actually love Syed Muzammil..his vouce, the way he speaks, the way he presents ..he is good unbiased journalist , very rational and objective..❤

We are waiting for your vedio from this topic you are amazing sir ❤❤❤

Hats off to India.From Bangladesh.But we still have no self reliance on space at all.At least Pakistan had good beginning.But we neither started nor tried.

Jb tk Pakistani Army me reforms ni hoti tb tk Pakistan 🇵🇰 ka yahi hall rahe ga, Pakistani Army is the ultimate ruler of Pakistan 🇵🇰 😢

Ho gya land 🌙🇮🇳💪

Well explained. You told the truth. Pakistan has to go for complete overhaul of education policy as soon as possible.

bigfan from india . Sir aapke videos search kar kar k dekhta ho . Respect 💜 We need more intellectuals like you in india . State k upper aap vht acha analysis karte ho . Aapka bolne ka tarika v vht sahi hain .

People : Beggars can't be choosers! Pak Army: Who said we can't choose? We choose Humiliation!😁😆🤪😝🤑

Suparco made the 1st Paratha making machine in 1962. Then they made Roti making machine in 1974. Both machine still working in Pak Darbar restuaren in Karachi....next mission is Khattora making machine...

Actually Indian Space Programme was first launched in 1962 as The Indian National Committee for Space Research (INCOSPAR). ISRO superseded it in 1969

سیّد مُزّمّل صاحب!! آپ کی صداقت بیانی، سچ گوئی ،حقیقت پسندی، قولِ سدید اور جرأت مندانہ بیان کو سلیوٹ ہے

This journalist is too logical in his approach... He is at risk of being branded as kafir.. .. Take care bhai..

Pakistan never lost the space race. Because Pakistan never participated in this. It's like saying India lost Football World Cup.

One of the only three persons whose videos you can like even without watching, the others are Barister Hamid Bashani and Professor Ishtiaq Ahmed.

धन्यवाद आपका! बहुत कुछ जानने को मिला। 1. हमे लगता है पाकिस्तान को आप जैसे व्यक्तियों की ज्यादा जरूरत है जो बताए कि हमारे लिए एजुकेशन कितना जरूरी है। अभी भी हम भारतीय एजुकेशन सिस्टम में सुधार चाहते है इसलिए की अभी भी बहुत सारी एजुकेशन में कमियां है जिसमे सुधार की जरूरत है। 2. हमे हमेशा ध्यान रखना चाहिए कि देश के नेता का सही चयन हो/करें अगर हमारी चुनाउ सही नहीं रहा तो आने वाले समय में हमारा देश जरूर दूसरे मुल्क के तुलना में बहुत ज्यादा विकास नही करेगा। 3. हमे हमेशा दूसरे से सीखना चाहिए न कि उसके नीचे दिखना चाहिए। (पाक इस मामले में शायद बहुत पीछे रह गए।) 4. बहुत सारे फैक्टर्स होते है एक चीज के डेवलप करने के और बहुत कम कारण होते है एक चीज को न करने का ( हमें लगता है पाक ने कुछ ऐसा ही किया अपने Sci. & Tech को न विकसित करने के लिए)

Why 90% of the audience are indian? 😊😅. Big message for rational people. I met an indian guy in Seoul city. We had just polite and rough discussions about our countries. He was giving a reference to Muzammil in each talk. I said, "Who is muzammil? I only know mainstream anchors in pakistan. Later on, I found that mostly Indians take Muzammil and his constructive criticism on pakistan as a tool against pakistan 😅😅😅

India's upcoming Missions.. Aditya L1 Venus mission Chandrayan 04(lupex with🇯🇵) Nisar (🇮🇳🇺🇲) Chandrayan -05 (2030) And many more small mission And reusable Rockets by 2028-29