Some people in comment section need to understand that a podcast is always a platform to discuss different ideas throughout the spectrum. Thank you for inviting devdutt ji.
The host itself is so uneducated that he is calling Sanatan a dharma as mythology Sanatan Dharma is not mythology, Sanatan Dharma is the reality and Devdutt Pattanaik is a Hindu phobic person.
Ha voh Abhijit baap hai na tumhara ,jo bolega voh sach hai.. fake news batata hai aur tum gobar bhakt sab sach Maan lete hai.. 🤣🤣 Thoda khud se bhi research karlo.. FYI devdutt bhi koi bahut bhaari nahi hai
@@8saroj7 Sorry to burst your bubble but they do exact opposite to what you have mentioned. Pattnaik doesn’t know Sanskrit whereas Atri and Malhotra are well versed in Sanskrit. The latter despite their linguistic knowledge quote the Gita Press Gorakhpur’s translation. Pattnaik just gives his version of the scriptures which may or may not have any reference.
@@ashoe2show Han that guy. Aside from that and onion retweet, his work is well researched and referenced. Just read, watch or listen to him for the references he provides.
People with little knowledge on hiduism and mythology are speaking shit here about devdutt cuz the fact and view of devdutt shatters their radical and small beliefs People are so scared of new perspective Sad to see these people
That is not the reason. People have not read Hinduism themselves. Most of the people are young also. 50% of the things Devdutt ever said or written already known to me from my parents. The reason is older generation used to read, the current is just watching media.
@@vinsin328you are very correct. Without reading they do not develop the understanding to atleast give proper pro or counter views. Remain small minds.
@@shahrags by whom, some RU-vid videos, bring yourself in the real world his books are in the curriculum of some of the best universities in the world like Columbia University, Oxford etc.
@@ankansenapati3600 thank you so much for opening my eyes...but I don't think I have to believe something just because it is taught in Oxford....this is also just a RU-vid video...why are you so offended?
I too was in the same state as you but I feel really bad in telling you that many of the things that Devdutt Pattanaik says are biased and even not the morally or ethically correct interpretation of indian mythology /history. Please look into this yourself, you'll know better.
I agree with you He has some agenda . Dangerous guy. I usef to watch devlok with devdutt. Mithi churri i got dipressed He said ram was a non vegitarian Sita admired ravana Laxman rekha is not much mentioned in scripts.it is too much made up Sabari is just a little mention in scripts and they are too much made up Etc etc etc
@@tanmay6207 tumhe lagta hai jo ye sab crap mante hai unlogo ne kabhi hinduism ki core book padhi bhi hogi??Vedas ke core me jaoge to wo aatma ki bat karta hai hum to male female me bhi ulajhne ko nahi bola gaya hai moksha pane ke liye
@@roshanjahan2433 mere bhai janta bhi hai kon logo ki baat kar raha hu mai? Puri Shankaracharya ke baarey mey suna hai? Vo ye sabh mante hai nahi yakeen tou unki videos dekhlo RU-vid pe. Unhe tou paramparagat vedic education mili hai fir bhi vo ye sabh kehte hai chahe tou link bhi dedunga video ki
Absolutely correct stated in the beginning ... God's idol/picture MUST be EAST facing.... and NOT to be placed in the east. Ppl... kindly take note of it. Thankyou🙏
i don't understand devadatta patnaik jidhar bhi jata hai udhar log usko gaali dete hai, fir bhi creators usko bulakar podcast karwate hai.. either creators comments read nahi karte ya unko kuch farak hi nahi padta
And why should it matter? People comment but never provide any valid and logical reason. Which part you didnt agree and provide evidence otherwise? You will not do it just like others.
@@hope2251 If you watch it you will understand what I want to convey , This man doesn't even know to translate he translate according to his interpretation . What may look 6 to me may look 9 to him if he is on another side of the boat (i.e Pseudo-liberal)
Pattanaik Ji ... नर्क... ki baat karte hue.... ek baar bhi nahi kaha.. that... Jis ne apne "children" ko theek se treat nahi kiyA.. wo नर्क jaayega.... Lekin har koi har baar count kara deta hai ki... Jo apne maa-baap ko theek se treat nahi karta wo नर्क jaata hai..🤨 Why, almost everyone, makes an Ironically Paradox statement?
He is not a historian. He is mostly a translator of Hindu text and their meanings. He at times add his understanding also. He only reads mythologies like Purana, Symbols etc.
The various species of Ephedra are widespread in many arid regions of the world, ranging across southwestern North America, southern Europe, northern Africa, southwest and central Asia, northern China and western South America. But he chooses the word central asia only to strengthen the arguments of his favorite historian Romila on Aryan invasion😝😝 if you search there is many herbs in the world which could give you the adrenaline rush about which he talking about but i dont know how he claims so surely that the plant have been identifiedand ephedra is the same Soma that rig veda is talking about. KUCH V bolta hai
He never talked about Aryan Invasion, he talked about Aryan migration and mention of that in Rig Veda. He said that is what historian believe. You have published any scientific journal otherwise please let me know and update the wikipedia. Again he said what is written, why are you blaming him for that, it is what is taught around the world.
soma is a indo variety of ayushcha . soma is psychedelic herb which uplifts the consiousness even patanjali mention techniques for dhyan using psychedelics herbs . thats why it was much advanced compared to other civilization because they alleviate their congnition using psychedelics herbs called soma
Just watched few episodes of ' Devlok ' on discovery plus...it was too superficial and nothing complete and in-depth..most of the talk was his own hypothesis and illogical conceptualization..highly disappointed..
Some people are saying Rajiv Malhotra is better than Devdutt Pattnaik, but he is just a part of Hindutva politics.Rajiv Malhotra wants to come in limelight and sell his books so he is doing politics against devdutt pattnaik.Religious scriptures are written by humans, you agree or not. I also do not fully endorse Devdutt Pattnaik because he misleads sometimes but Rajiv Malhotra is not saint. He is like Sadhguru, having a toxic fanbase. The problem is Rajiv gives a single interpretation of hinduism and imposes it to be true, a part of hindutva politics. However, hinduism has been open for various interpretation for ages. Devdutt gives an alternative persoective of hinduism, which i like, unlike the rigid conservative conventional ones, the favourite of hindutva lobbies to oppress free speech of secular and neutral hindus.
Rajiv Malhotra supported scammer nityananda who has his own nation and caught in a sex scandal.He even had a talk with him. These people have made hinduism a joke nowadays.
This person is a crypto convert, sar pahle Sanskrit to Sikh lo, itne sare wrong translation kar rakhe hai apne kitab me. fir speculation karna 😅. He really think we don't understand what he is trying to prove.... He is trying to prove Aryan migration theory. Itna hi academic ho to proof kar do na😂, Aryan migration ke proof milte Ha, but iska bhi proof milta hai ki Hinduism developed in India not Central Asia.
Wokes are leftists with unregulated sense of morality. And he's a stooge. But Kuch chamcho ko unhe ke talwe chatna hota hai Jo anti Modi ho.😂😂 Yeh chumtiye toh Taliban ko bhi "Mera Taliban álag hai" KA tag de rakkhe the...😂😂
There is white n there is black . In reality there’s only shades of grey . There is bias everywhere . If u r approaching anything looking for proofs to strengthen u r bias then ull only strengthen u r bias . Rather approach with examining u r belief . Then u r pov gets refined
Pass me that Video. Neeraj Atri is a communist supporter He has no idea of hinduism. File a case for mistranslation. Atleast please tell every one where has he mistranslated.
Thank you for bringing devdutt ji. He is really an amazing person to learn about sanatan dharma and indic mythology. And please don't listen to this boycott gang.
What do you wanna prove by calling someone to your podcast who openly says Hinduism is a mythology and not history? I don't know about others but I have unsubscribed.
He never said Hinduism is a mythology. Let me give you an example. Ek story hai which is saying garud goes to heaven to take the somras and bring back to earth for people. Another story mentions that earth is standing on a bull. One story mentions that hanuman swallowed the sun Ab ya to tu in sab ko literally sach man ke khud ko andhvishwasi sabit karle, ya fir jhoot man ke Hinduism ko jhuta bol le. Devdutt ne dono me se kuch nhi kia. Usne is tarah ki stories ka actual logic samjhaya aur bataya ki ye mythology hai kyunki sach me hua nhi hua uska nhi pata par ye hume ye sikh sakta hai. Isn't this much better than accepting those unscientific stuffs?
@@Nero6570 What that has to do with anything? Do you know Sanskrit? Do you know Arabic? Do you know latin? What non-sense do most of the Hindus talk. Do you call yourself a literally fool?
@@vinsin328 Listen you dumba****.He claims himself to be an expert on hindu scriptures...for an historian it is a must to know sanskrit to talk on hindu scriptures.Just like it is necessary to know arabic to talk on Islamic scriptures,understood you ma*adarch0d.
Sahi mein bro.. Yeh Devdutt khud hi ek scam hai.. Again wanted to insert foolish Aryan invasion theory... Zed Avestha is Sanskrit derived word and there are lot similarity between Rig veda and Zorastrian Zed Avestha...
Soo.. the video inspired me to "plan the death", my death.. n thn when I like casually think about what to leave behind n all.. m suddenly like wait.! M i going to die soon n this video is like a sign or something from the universe n all.. fir meri fat jati he n m like nonono n i stop thinking about it 😅
In case anyone wants to know. Egyptians god's का concept youtubers like Comicverse ru-vid.com/group/PLp1zSymEu3zLsCrrIi8owQAcCOXV3eRSq desinerd ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Al1jCxSzxcY.html and many more had explained in 'Moon knight' series breakdowns briefly.
Abnormal people where 2 yrs old kid knows about sex and violence. Please provide your address if you have guts and I will file a case against your whole family.
Bro tells mythology, speak facts bro ,Devdutt Pattnaik has already brainwashed most of the people , just getting him in show and praising him won't help it . Alas Mr Pattnaik is a mythologist writer after all like romila thapar.
