Тёмный

Why Third Person Isn't Good 

YummYummtheMan
Подписаться 36
Просмотров 2,3 тыс.
50% 1

A visual critique of third person perspective in DayZ and ARMA.

Опубликовано:

 

7 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 67   
@bestvideogameplayerintheworld
@bestvideogameplayerintheworld 6 месяцев назад
Never understood why third person pvp games were popular.
@igasuguseidasju1699
@igasuguseidasju1699 6 месяцев назад
3rd person view in PUBG was the thing that made me not play over 1h ridiculous mechanic for pvp
@lehtokurppa7824
@lehtokurppa7824 6 месяцев назад
Luckily they introduced the 1pp mode
@MrAlexmiele8910
@MrAlexmiele8910 6 месяцев назад
You can play FPP or TPP. And in TPP you can switch between FPP and TPP… not sure I understand your complaint…
@midnightslasher6049
@midnightslasher6049 6 месяцев назад
​@@MrAlexmiele8910the issue is what the video author points out? It shouldn't be an option in PvP games to begin with(at least without alternatives)- its completely stupid and unfair and basically ruins any semblance of realism or what makes combat... combat. "hardcore" shooters like ARMA, DayZ, PUBG, etc shouldn't have this feature unless you manually turn it on. Imagine what Escape from Tarkov or even CS2 would be like if you could see around corners without revealing yourself in any way.
@abdou.the.heretic
@abdou.the.heretic 6 месяцев назад
​@@midnightslasher6049oh no I feel left behind because everyone, when given the freedom to choose, they chose TPP.
@MrAlexmiele8910
@MrAlexmiele8910 6 месяцев назад
@@midnightslasher6049 oh I get what you’re saying dude. I’m just pointing out that in PuB, when you choose FPP, you can only use FPP during that game. But if you choose TPP, you can alternate between FPP and TPP… that seems fair.
@Redofreko
@Redofreko 6 месяцев назад
this video is legitimately just showing objective and fundamental issues with 3rd person in ARMA and dayz and people are still getting angry lol never change
@noahengstrom
@noahengstrom 6 месяцев назад
I'm shocked this video exists today. The 3rd person question was answered like 10 years ago. I remember in the early Arma battle royale mod. there were 2 versions as I recall. Hardcore was 1st person and normal was 3rd person. 3rd person was just a different game altogether. Imagine playing Tarkov with 3rd person. it would be a game, just a really different game. I agree, with your message. I'm just wondering if there is really any debate about the topic.
@twopaps5505
@twopaps5505 Месяц назад
I am still waiting on the birth control question and why it didn't work for your parents
@Tarkonomist
@Tarkonomist 6 месяцев назад
This is huge, I really hope more people especially future devs get to see this :D
@techterror1282
@techterror1282 6 месяцев назад
I hope they don't listen to it. I enjoy third person. I don't play games like this to experienced realism
@abdou.the.heretic
@abdou.the.heretic 6 месяцев назад
This is huge 😂 nigga this is ice age knowledge
@Tarkonomist
@Tarkonomist 6 месяцев назад
I MEAN IT REALLY depends like something like tom clany wildlands or whatever i get that its not a big deal if its stricly pve BVut at the very least there needs to be options that are stricly FPS that promote more competitivce realisitc play@@techterror1282
@dali1384
@dali1384 5 месяцев назад
@@techterror1282 you don't care even when he shows that it is literally cheating for the high ground player, or the guy at the wall... at least in pvp there is no way to keep 3rd person
@lucifer8166
@lucifer8166 6 месяцев назад
this is common sense.... i just waisted 2:37 of my life........
@twopaps5505
@twopaps5505 Месяц назад
Your entire life is a waste so it is nothing new
@Ashtonaz
@Ashtonaz 6 месяцев назад
It's really for any first person pvp game, third person sucks. People also do this on Roblox PVP games but on there, you can zoom out literally a field away and easily flank them
@jtf2k442
@jtf2k442 6 месяцев назад
Im sending this video to a friend who actively defends third person on the premise that since both parties have it, it makes it fair, when the defending party always has the advantage with third person, At least in 1st person all defenders will usually have a advantage anyway but at least with 1st person you both have to expose yourselves making it fair. Thanks for making this video
@abdou.the.heretic
@abdou.the.heretic 6 месяцев назад
Be a defender then, what's stopping you from contesting the position of defense, oh shit did that just put you all on fair ground??😅
@Scrahdabley
@Scrahdabley 6 месяцев назад
dudes acting like they didnt know this
@tobybeggs8676
@tobybeggs8676 6 месяцев назад
I mean, videos still not wrong tho, he’s just pointing it out using an example
@hummelman
@hummelman 6 месяцев назад
@@tobybeggs8676 10 years after the fact, and multiple versions of Arma from the original on.
@twopaps5505
@twopaps5505 Месяц назад
shut up
@twopaps5505
@twopaps5505 Месяц назад
This whole video is a clear example of the weakness of old gamers. In their prime they might have been able to adapt and overcome difficulties to win the game, but as they aged they just make silly videos to beg for the devs attention. Maybe you should just pull yourself up by your boot straps and overcome this difficulty like you overcame fighting bin Laden on the beaches of Normandy or whatever you old boomers claim.
@user-px8wc8ll2q
@user-px8wc8ll2q 6 месяцев назад
Imagine playing war sim then a zombie sim but not in first kill person
@Sholto_David
@Sholto_David 6 месяцев назад
Obviously, if you play third person against someone in first person, you have an advantage. But if you're both able to use third person, it isn't necessarily worse or better, just different. I played PUBG a lot when it came out, and it became wildly popular in third person. It makes for more positional and tactical play compared to just raw aim duels, and fastest reaction time wins - some people don't find that very engaging either.
@elaine6344
@elaine6344 6 месяцев назад
You could do the same tactics in first person you just had to pop up and check where the enemy is while planning your attack possibly giving them a chance to see you, and maybe even initiate a dynamic gunfight. The worst part is 3rd person players won't peek at all if your looking at them I've been in a open field and a dude pops up on top the house I'm going towards but he waited till i was 20 metres out and then failed, then for the next few minutes he wouldn't peek until i looked away made for a pretty piss poor gunfight when he wouldn't fight without me having to turn my back even when he is in cover and I'm in the open, keep in mind I'm in first person playing peekaboo doing 180s trying to get something to happen Same as people who wait at the end of containers for you to be 2 feet away, if they had to peek they would have no chance, so they wait for the easiest possible kill. Tldr 3rd person players hate gunfights, 1st person has prolonged gunfights and way more ammo gets used due to the fairness of it
@Sholto_David
@Sholto_David 6 месяцев назад
@@elaine6344 Just sounds like you don't understand how to play games with third-person perspective, friend. Why would the guy on the house peak to give you a "fair fight" unless he was trying to lose 😂 Some people may not enjoy third person, or perhaps they're worse at it, but that it isn't inherently "bad" or "good". Yes, third-person perspective favours different strategies, including holding angles without having to look around them.
@Ramrodio
@Ramrodio 6 месяцев назад
@@Sholto_David it's not a lack of understanding, it's being annoyed at people playing like huge pussies who can't get any kills unless the fight isn't fair
@ztcajun
@ztcajun 6 месяцев назад
Dont play with third person then.
@Gekquerel
@Gekquerel 6 месяцев назад
if the issue here was personal preference in pve, then sure. but in pvp, it provides these unfair advantages as shown in the video
@ztcajun
@ztcajun 6 месяцев назад
@@Gekquerel yes so play on servers that have it disabled, I understand there is a advantage that can be used both ways. There is something for everyone in arma, you just have to look.
@saminasser7807
@saminasser7807 6 месяцев назад
Not much going on in your skull
@abdou.the.heretic
@abdou.the.heretic 6 месяцев назад
​@@saminasser7807how? I play on multiple shooters that have an option for either FPP or TPP with optional FPP to enable. I understand his view concerning realism, but I don't see how that's a problem, what is even his point? Play where it's fair for all or don't play at all. I hate how TPP is mostly chosen by players but tough shit, people like what they like.
@saminasser7807
@saminasser7807 6 месяцев назад
​@@abdou.the.heretic shooters are the exact scenario where third person makes absolutely no sense, other than to check the drip. But the very essence of what makes a game a shooting game is the fact that you have to be able to find and shoot the enemy using the eyes in your head. If you wanted a camera flying around you telling you where the enemies are then there is absolutely no purpose in putting in any real effort in hiding/ finding the enemy when there is no risk to you. If anyone uses 3rd person in a shooter then you are genetically weaker and belong in the fruit fields picking berries.
@HarbisonelII
@HarbisonelII 6 месяцев назад
Does it really matter though if everyone can use 3rd person? Like in, for example, PUBG, you have dedicated first person modes and choose your view modes. I think this more than solved the problem. And, well, the AI can't quite complain about fair play when it, most of the time, doesn't exactly abide to the rules either.
@netherminer101
@netherminer101 6 месяцев назад
That's kinda only in Tarkov so the NPCs act like the players but I have some instances in other games before however I thought those to be flukes as they only happened that one time
@Redofreko
@Redofreko 6 месяцев назад
I think that leaning changing which shoulder the camera is on helps a little bit but I've always preferred first person since you have to actually be exposed to see people
@HarbisonelII
@HarbisonelII 6 месяцев назад
@@Redofreko There is a survival game called SCUM that checks if you have LOS on the enemy even in third person, also negating that issue.
@RyanG-ij8xq
@RyanG-ij8xq 6 месяцев назад
Arma looks good on RU-vid… but when I get on the game it’s ASS
@Synickal
@Synickal 6 месяцев назад
Facts
@Agent0range-A-
@Agent0range-A- 6 месяцев назад
❤ i fully agree these games are ment to be realistic and competitive 3rd person takes away from that a completely ruined it for me and the industry has done it to nearly all the games because its what the fortnite want... I switched to Vr flat-screen sitdown gaming is dead to me it was a good run but its been going in a direction I ain't gonna follow I don't care about their agendas I don't want them listening to my chat banning me if I use words they don't like im done with the whole market.. Vr hasn't been corrupted yet like the console market its still small studios that do what they want 😉
@gharretje
@gharretje 6 месяцев назад
Are you, comparing Arma to Fortnite?
@Agent0range-A-
@Agent0range-A- 6 месяцев назад
@@gharretje do they both have 3rd person view?
@gharretje
@gharretje 6 месяцев назад
@@Agent0range-A- if fortnite has 3rd person view, yes. But so has mario kart. Your implication that 'these games' get ruined by 3rd person, and the industry has done it because of trying to copy fortnite, overlooks the fact that games like arma have been around a lot longer than say fortnite. Unless you mean it seperately. But then mentioning it in one sentence suggests there is some correlation between the two.
@funny3scene
@funny3scene 6 месяцев назад
More like why third person IS good.
@kyotoshi3045
@kyotoshi3045 6 месяцев назад
More like you didnt get the title. x)
@prestonbaker8456
@prestonbaker8456 6 месяцев назад
Good yes. But not for a engaging pvp experience.
@funny3scene
@funny3scene 6 месяцев назад
@@prestonbaker8456 whatever advantage I have I’ll take, especially in dayz. Maybe not so much in arma, but definitely dayz
@Netlogic.
@Netlogic. 6 месяцев назад
@@funny3scene How is it an advantage when it goes both ways?
@funny3scene
@funny3scene 6 месяцев назад
@@Netlogic. depends entirely on the situation, such as wall peaking and being on a roof like this video depicts. The other person being in 3rd person makes no difference in those scenarios
@jebbroham1776
@jebbroham1776 6 месяцев назад
This is also the reason that WT sucks.
@devildog1009977
@devildog1009977 6 месяцев назад
sounds like someone gets killed too much. just go play on a first-person server and quit complaining
@helios4753
@helios4753 6 месяцев назад
2rd person is good because 1st person isn't as good as my real life eyes
@Guerrila_man
@Guerrila_man 5 месяцев назад
F 3rd person
@nicholas8228
@nicholas8228 6 месяцев назад
Great video, I first want to say I prefer first person only everything, I hate 3rd person locked games whether it's single player or online. However I think in pvp it's fair to say everyone has access to it so it's kind of a mechanic and it's only unfair if you don't understand how to use it and that's more of a learning curve. In pve it's definitely breaking immersion but some people like that gameplay. A lot of people play games on easy because they just wanna run through it and I'm personally guilty of that and playing in 3rd person is another advantage to make something easy
@TipofmyStick
@TipofmyStick 6 месяцев назад
BUT YOUR PROMOTING 3rd PERSON ??? 🤔
Далее
Picking A Faction In Foxhole
12:52
Просмотров 117 тыс.
The Pussification of Videogames
14:35
Просмотров 759 тыс.
Modus males sekolah
00:14
Просмотров 11 млн
Fixing Plastic with Staples
00:18
Просмотров 1,3 млн
The Future of DayZ? - Arma Reforger's New DayZ Mod
32:42
Squad Tips For Noobs, By Noobs
3:29
Просмотров 20
PUBG Was Amazing (and How it Got Bad)
20:44
Просмотров 1 млн
When did games become so soft?
14:56
Просмотров 654 тыс.
Arma 3 Epic Battle
6:56
Просмотров 597 тыс.
Squad Epic Moments #8
9:49
Просмотров 86
13 Must Have Mods For Solo Antistasi - ARMA 3
10:03
Просмотров 77 тыс.