Тёмный

Why Total War: Attila Is an Atmospheric Masterpiece 

HappyCompyTW
Подписаться 15 тыс.
Просмотров 17 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

7 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 261   
@Lord-H
@Lord-H 3 месяца назад
I seriously can't enjoy the game with its atrocious performance, might as well play Medieval 2. Running TWW3/Three Kingdoms/Pharoah just fine ultra settings 1440p, same with Rome 2 or even the amazing Shogun 2, but Atilla seems cursed to never run well or at least at 60 fps no matter how many pc's I build, which is a huge letdown.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
100%. It's a great game that feels awful to play. I don't complain about the performance just to be funny, I complain because it ruins the game. I have over 2100 hours in Rome 2, but "only" 440 hours in Attila. That's mostly because the horrendous turn times are a waste of my time when other TW games actually respect it. I would bet you money that Pharaoh's 189 faction mega map will have faster turn times than Attila's Rome 2 sized one. Maybe instead of wasting money on failures like Hyenas, CA could task a small team to actually support their products that still need help, like this one? Edit: pinned your comment because it resonates hard.
@Lord-H
@Lord-H 3 месяца назад
@@happycompy Absolutely agree, chasing trends and throwing money into the pit, the funds that went into Hyenas are just insane, it could have done wonders for their existing products and sold thousands of copies, it's just dissapointing and exhausting. Especially dissapointing when a company has such a legendary IP, only to release a good game, and to leave it unfinished to chase the next new game.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
​@@Lord-H"and to leave it unfinished to chase the next new game" has been CA's modus operandi since Empire Total War. They treat their games like Call of Duty releases instead of the big, replayable strategy games they are. Firaxis and Paradox understand this. Civ 6 released in 2016 and it got new patches and DLC well into the 2020s. Stellaris and Hoi4 were also released in 2016 and they're both STILL getting updates and DLC. -Empire released in 2009, got dumped in 2010. -Rome 2 released in 2013, got dumped in 2014 (yes, they eventually went back in 2017 but that was a unique case, and Rome 2 still has game breaking AI bugs) -Attila released 2015, got dumped in 2016. -Warhammer 1 I'll give a pass because it was always gonna be a trilogy and the content carries over -Three Kingdoms 2019, dumped in 2021 -Thrones lmao You hit the nail on the head, it is exhausting and frustrating.
@Lord-H
@Lord-H 3 месяца назад
@@happycompy And to see it detailed in a list like that only makes it more depressing.. half the funds that went to Hyenas could have gone to a team like that, keeping all these games at top shape, it's really not that much to ask, instead it just keeps going. I would wager even Warhammer 3 is only safe as long as 40k or another more profitable TW comes around, even then the game keeps crumbling with bugs under the weight of DLC, at this point I just wish they would focus their work on letting devs work on the main games themselves before adding it or leave them as is. Great videos and topics all around, keep up the good work!
@dattilo1
@dattilo1 3 месяца назад
They patched the game a few months ago, performance is much better
@blebcat
@blebcat 3 месяца назад
Been through three CPUs and GPUs since Attila released, and my performance improvements have been utterly negligible. They just need to fix it. It's one of the best historical titles they ever made.
@smoke12785
@smoke12785 3 месяца назад
I heard setting the game's vram from the preference file to 3000mb and lowering the amount of cpu threads to around 4 helps.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Yup. Ironically I'm on my third CPU/GPU combo as well since this game released and it still runs like absolute shit. The turn times in particular are atrocious. It's why I only have 400 hours in it.
@mephisto279
@mephisto279 3 месяца назад
Its a phenomenal title, and my first Total War game. Why CA leaves it to rot? I'll never know.
@James-sk4db
@James-sk4db 3 месяца назад
I turned down the resolution and it seemed to really help me. All highest graphics but resolution set 1 lower than my monitor really helped
@alexsitaras6508
@alexsitaras6508 3 месяца назад
It would have been my most played Total War if the performance wasn't so bad. Age of Charlemagne really is excellent.
@KTA1sVidsandFacts
@KTA1sVidsandFacts 3 месяца назад
Rome: "I'm fighting for my fucking life!" Eranshahr: "The fuck they doin over there?"
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
The Sassanids really are chilling in Total War: Attila like introverts were during the pandemic lockdown 😂
@PeteL-u1d
@PeteL-u1d 2 месяца назад
​@@happycompy huh? Ever heard of the Hepthalites?
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
@@PeteL-u1d small fish compared to what ERE and especially WRE are dealing with
@KC_312
@KC_312 3 месяца назад
Happy: "When Attila FINALLY FUCKING DIES" I felt that deep in my soul.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
The cutscene that plays when he dies hits different too.
@huantruonginh2946
@huantruonginh2946 3 месяца назад
How to kill him, i’m just new😅
@captainvalourous6668
@captainvalourous6668 2 месяца назад
As someone who is bros with Attile thanks to Arcadius' ( The Eastern Roman Emperor ) marraige to Attila's auntie this pains me. 🥲
@SpaceTalon
@SpaceTalon 2 месяца назад
@@huantruonginh2946 you have to clap first few hordes and then he spawns. Mind you, you will have to defeat him 2 times, since the first time he just gets wounded. I recommend baiting him somewhere his horse archers will not perform optimally.
@jackstone112
@jackstone112 3 месяца назад
Atilla is my favorite hands down, i struggle to let go and play other games becuse of it
@mihaimercenarul7467
@mihaimercenarul7467 3 месяца назад
The performance îs awful tho
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
​@@mihaimercenarul7467love your pfp!
@jamreal18
@jamreal18 3 месяца назад
How I wish Sea People in Pharaoh are really intimidating and coming from sea
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
They need to come in as a focused force. Having their stacks scatter like sticks in the wind after they spawn makes them feel less like a massive invasion and more like a bunch of random armies. I know they said that they're reworking the Sea Peoples and the Land Peoples in the incoming map expansion. We'll see what they do.
@jamreal18
@jamreal18 3 месяца назад
@@happycompy that is nice to hear
@Zarastro54
@Zarastro54 3 месяца назад
There need to be sea battles for the SEA People.
@mariusbehm9874
@mariusbehm9874 3 месяца назад
@@Zarastro54 no there where no see battels 1195 bc was the first but see battels come in the iron age 900 bc
@richardiv385
@richardiv385 3 месяца назад
@@mariusbehm9874There were amphibious battles, like when the Egyptians won by ambush in the Nile delta. It would be nice to have ships in the game just for that
@tefky7964
@tefky7964 2 месяца назад
Its honestly fascinating to read how people prefer Rome 2 over Attila for its freedom, while in Attila you might be forced to act in specific ways and lead wars against specific enemies, because I fully get what they mean, but with the opposite opinion. I like how factions in Attila are different, even two very similar factions with very similar units and starting position near each other have different problems and you are forced to solve them and as such play differently for each of them. In Rome 2 you can do what you want, which means freedom, but when everyone offers same freedom it means that all factions are same. When I won a campaign as Celts in France and then another campaign as one of Greek states my playthroughs were very similar, conquer few neighbors, build few armies, conquer few more territories and soon you are basically unstopable, there aren´t any factions that might be a problem. Sure, each faction have different buildings, units and some different bonuses, but in the end they all play in very similar way and you face the same problems. Some factions have it easier, some have it harder, but your problems can usually be solved by another expansion. In Attila as some factions you just freely expand too, as some barbarians you should probably run to the west and plunder along the way, as Rome you try to survive... When I tried to play Slavs and normally expand I was totally screwed without chance to defend my lands, so I had to try again and fully invest into few fortified cities where I led some of the best defensive total war battles I fought against massive Hun armies, which just didn´t happen to me in Rome 2, there I am the one who is supposed to just attack as every faction, not to desperately defend my cities. In Rome 2 I never thought "wow, they are strong, they might actually fully conquer me". Sure I might lose an army or a city, but you just don´t get an actual fear about survival or motivation to try another tactic, the only tactic you need is expansion.
@romainvicta117
@romainvicta117 2 месяца назад
It’s mad how within just a few minutes of the video I instantly have a strong desire to redownload and play it again
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
And behold a red horse...
@romainvicta117
@romainvicta117 2 месяца назад
Got a favourite faction you like to play as?
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
@@romainvicta117 Honestly? The Franks, the Saxons, and the ERE.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
I'll tell you one thing, and I'm not afraid to say it. My estimation of Honorius as a Roman Emperor just fuckin' plummeted.
@ReviveHF
@ReviveHF 3 месяца назад
The success of Three Kingdoms Total War was built upon the foundation laid in Attila Total War. Many of the RPG elements, battle mechanics and campaign features in Three Kingdoms were actually pioneered in Attila. Unfortunately, Three Kingdoms got abandoned. Remember CA promised us to add in Korean, and Japanese, Hunnic and Kushan Factions back in 2020? Yep, that didn't happened.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Three Kingdoms was done so dirty man.
@blecis74
@blecis74 2 месяца назад
Yep I remember that, I’m still pissed off about that, 3k was the best TW game ever to be made (in my opinion) and could have continued to get better and better, but no CA just had to abandon it, what the true reason for the abandonment was I don’t know, but abandoning Attila and 3k was really stupid.
@nms8397
@nms8397 3 месяца назад
Attila is great because the battles are tactical. Talk about how good the battles are.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
I much prefer Attila's morale system over Rome 2's. The battle AI is only better. But Attila doesn't have guard mode 😂
@f3wbs
@f3wbs 2 месяца назад
I really love the atmosphere because its just so *dark* and you just have to find the light from the grand campaign to Age of Charlemagne.
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Exactly!
@Ajaylix
@Ajaylix 3 месяца назад
I think the only youtuber i seen that does not like Attila at all is Pixelated Apollo. But i was curious about total war starting 2 years ago. Eventually, i got Attila and Rome II for a combine $30 in the deal and its probably the greatest gaming investment i ever did. Still play DEI and vanilla Attila alot.
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Hell yeah man im glad you're enjoying them! Ive got thousands of hours combined. Enjoyment per dollar for these games is off the charts.
@MelkorGG
@MelkorGG 3 месяца назад
100% agree. Historical feel is more important than historical accuracy. Attila does this perfectly. Some people may hate me for this: I would even go as far as to argue for horned helmets on Vikings in a Medieval 3. It's what most people recognise as Vikings, therefore it gives the feel of Vikings.
@astadew
@astadew 3 месяца назад
No. I think most people know vikings didn't really have horns by now
@MelkorGG
@MelkorGG 3 месяца назад
@@astadew You hang around with too many smart people. 😆
@jobogriff1209
@jobogriff1209 3 месяца назад
could not agree more
@Atreas40000
@Atreas40000 3 месяца назад
horned helmets no. Generally prioritize atmosphere. Yes.
@James-sk4db
@James-sk4db 3 месяца назад
Horned helmets were a sea peoples / Sardinian Bronze Age thing. So the normal arguments that it’s too impractical to use are wrong. But yeah I think the protonorse in Attila and the vikings in throne of Britannia look good
@andreascovano7742
@andreascovano7742 3 месяца назад
Attila felt grounded, I don't know how else to put it
@benjaminhodzic4840
@benjaminhodzic4840 3 месяца назад
Atilla needed just 1 more month in production and it would have been a true masterpiece. Cutscenes for staying and winning as pegan, reunite empire mission, confederate option, AI that goes into retard mod if you have 1 ship near their transports, AI with better stacks etc...
@PlainDoll
@PlainDoll 3 месяца назад
agreed 100% one of the main reasons why i love it so much is that no other game has managed to capture the feeling of "the end times'' as much as this one
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Exactly! Pharaoh is the only other game that gets within striking distance of it. But Attila did it first and did it the best.
@spaghettitime3263
@spaghettitime3263 2 месяца назад
I love how the horde mechanic makes the campaigns so dynamic. I remember doing a Saxon campaign and pushing out the Danes early on, but not totally crushing them, and having them return dozens of turns later and fracturing my kingdom so unexpectedly. I was so frustrated yet so impressed
@Vadim_Ibragimov
@Vadim_Ibragimov 3 месяца назад
Most people will disagree with this, but I strongly believe that Attila has more variety in it's campaign than TWW does. Take, for example, WRE, Sassanids, Veneds, Ostgoths, Alans, Franks and Huns (sorry if I wrote something wrong). Each one of this faction has absolutely unique campaigns. Their initial challenges are completely different, their goals are completely different. In each of these campaigns you as a player will think about completely different things. As Franks you will decide how to grab as much roman territory as possible without getting overwhelmed with public order issues and lack of finances to rebuild stuff (or instead you can expand into German lands, becoming roman ally and protector of the Empire's borders, which is absolutely different experience). As Goth you will decide how to settle your tribe without getting killed in a couple of turns. As WRE you will try your best to protect your huge empire (unless you're a pussy who abandons Roman lands into barbarian hands!), whereas as a slavic faction you will stand your ground in 1-2 settlements against hordes of Huns. And when you think you've tried everything in this game, you will learn the Dark Cult exists. And you will try to get it as any of the faction and spread it across the ancient world, which is funny as hell. Each of these campaigns demands different strategy and approach, but all of them gives unique experience
@nomooon
@nomooon 3 месяца назад
That's why Total War in Ancient / Medieval Western Hemisphere is always fun. That's why I never really got that deep into Shogun Total War series, or Empire / Napoleon Total War.
@smokejaguar67
@smokejaguar67 3 месяца назад
Attila is my favourite total war game - I still play it today
@TPhoton
@TPhoton 3 месяца назад
the best total war creator is back in action! :-) consider doing another live stream at some point
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Ayyyeee thank you! You're too kind! I'll probably do a live stream when Pharaoh's expansion comes out. I'm not sure if and what I'd stream in the meantime, but we'll see :)
@MedjayofFaiyum
@MedjayofFaiyum 3 месяца назад
You’re going to see a lot of RU-vidrs doing livestreams for Pharaoh update
@danieltobin4498
@danieltobin4498 2 месяца назад
I played a lot as the Eastern Roman Empire. It’s a very unique feeling I rarely see in most strategy games. You inherit an empire that’s not great but not terrible. You have a LOT of work to do. You constantly feel like living on the edge of a knife. You’re either worrying about barbarians closing in on Greece, praying they’ll be content with your western Roman neighbors. Or you’re worrying about the eastern factions, praying they don’t declare war on you JUST yet! Act 1 is you fortifying your provinces and building your economy. But act 2, is when you finally go to war with the eastern kingdoms. If you win, then congrats. Act 3 is about consolidating your new empire and expanding your borders…and seeing the aftermath of Atilla’s genocide as you try to save Rome
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Yes! The ERE is one of my favorite campaigns in Attila. Praying 🙏 that the Sassanids don't declare on me every time I click end turn is nerve wracking!
@grolash6219
@grolash6219 2 месяца назад
It feels like you are the last bastion of light in a dark world.
@luigisaguier8336
@luigisaguier8336 2 месяца назад
The battles in Attila are the best and most immersive powerpoint simulation I've ever seen! Well done CA
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
LMAO 😂😂😂
@sativa-sloth6099
@sativa-sloth6099 2 месяца назад
Hey man i just happened across your videos today, and thank you for not absolutely dunking on Total War Pharaoh like everyone else seems to do. Im one of the few that plays Pharaoh, i have over 100 hours in game and i actually enjoy the gameplay. Especially the increased emphasis on diplomacy. And the fights are some of the most well done
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Hey sativa, thanks for watching and for leaving your thoughts. You got me going, so allow me to go off for a second. When Pharaoh was announced, I went from excited to bitterly disappointed when I saw the map. I LOVE the Bronze Age Collapse and I think it's perfect for an apocalyptic Total War setting. I wanted Troy to expand to include the whole Bronze Age world years ago! When the game launched, I bought it anyway, and loved a lot about the gameplay, particularly the deeper campaign. The battles felt MUCH better than Troy's as well (like you alluded to). But that map...what the fuck was that, man?! It pissed me off so much because they were so close to greatness but whiffed HARD. I thought that was it, that we were never going to get a good Bronze Age TW game because of Pharaoh. I ended up rage-quitting my review script halfway through and basically stopped playing Total War altogether. Then they shocked me (and the dozens of us who played pharaoh 😂) when they announced the map expansion. I mean I was truly shocked, man. I figured this game was dead and done. The expanded map and scope looks like it's EXACTLY what I've wanted since Troy. It got me excited enough to get back to making videos because this game really could end up being a true banger of a historical Total War that we haven't had in years. If it lives up to its promise, it could be near Rome 2-levels of replayable for me. Needless to say, I'm HAPPY to not have to dunk on it! I feel bad for people who hate this setting because I feel like a kid on Christmas. Fingers crossed 🤞!!!
@waqarsaleem8611
@waqarsaleem8611 3 месяца назад
I never had problem playing Western Roman Empire. I retreated back to Italy and garrisoned Aquileia (North eastern town of Italy) and stationed 1 full stack. Hunnic massive stacks were unable to take that single settlement and thus prevented from invading Italy proper.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Nice. The good ol' "retreat to the heartland strategy." The same one the Assyrians used to survive the Bronze Age Collapse. Those soldiers in Aquileia must've been some crazy veteran troops by the time Attila died in your campaign.
@waqarsaleem8611
@waqarsaleem8611 3 месяца назад
@@happycompy I had to kill Attila 3 times before he finally died for good. I didn't like his death bcz it alleviated some pressure and i wanted non stop war and pressure. Keeps the game interesting.
@Annatar3019
@Annatar3019 Месяц назад
My love for this game was sealed when as a new player, playing visigoths and trying to sack rome, I was attacked by 5 full stacks against one of my armies. Somehow that battle was fought down to just two remaining soldiers (not units, soldiers) and the roman soldier was victorius. I did loose the battle and my faction leader, but it was such a massive blow to WRE, that my one remaining army was able to completely conquer all of hispania with ease. Once Hispania was conquered, I had almost no public order issues, all the factions around me loved me and I was rolling around in more money than I knew what to do with. Only campaign I ever finished. Been chasing that high ever since.
@happycompy
@happycompy Месяц назад
Sounds epic!!!
@GhenTuongHB
@GhenTuongHB 3 месяца назад
I will pay anything for TW Attila 2. I would buy it if they just fixed all the bugs and performance issues and re-released Attila.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
I'd settle for an optimization patch 😭
@No-Name-1993
@No-Name-1993 28 дней назад
TWA with the WRE on Legendary is the best campaign possible, surviving what should be almost impossible the re expanding back out while the world burns around you is such a great buzz
@No-Name-1993
@No-Name-1993 28 дней назад
For an easier ride choose the ERE where the Sassanids are the primary threat
@seanbinkley7363
@seanbinkley7363 Месяц назад
Killing Atilla (actually killing him) in battle, as Western Rome, with emperor Honorious was one of my proudest TW achievements.
@Realtimehammer
@Realtimehammer 2 месяца назад
Awesome to see you back bro! I love Attila, wholeheartedly agree with your argument about the atmosphere, it is amazing! Though on the balancing side of things they have made some egregious decisions, especially the ERE and their infinite money glitch, which sadly makes that faction specifically unchallenging unless you give away your money constantly (from mid-game onwards). The stupidest thing is, I don't think its possible to mod this, I've taken a dive into modding Attila, even created a mod to rebalance some of the Roman's weaker points, but I have found no possible way to edit or remove the faction traits. I think the ERE is a hit and miss in relation to basically every other faction. I would have made their faction trait a 2% increase on their income instead of their treasury or something like that.
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Thank you! As for the ERE, you could probably change the value of their faction from 2% to 0% with RPFM. Worth a shot anyway.
@Realtimehammer
@Realtimehammer 2 месяца назад
@@happycompy what is RPFM? Maybe its superobvious and I'm just not familiar with the acronym :P It would definitely be worth trying if that could do it.
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
@@Realtimehammer it's called Rusted Pack File Manager. It's one of the main tools modders use to edit the database of modern TW games :)
@Realtimehammer
@Realtimehammer 2 месяца назад
@@happycompy as you can tell, I'm a beginner in modding still :) Thanks for the tip bro, will defs check it out!
@alikh4541
@alikh4541 3 месяца назад
Awesome video dude👍 I love Attila for this reason exactly. it feels different.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
It really is unique!
@gergoradoczi8939
@gergoradoczi8939 2 месяца назад
the last TW game that was challenging, and where you needed strategy as opposed to the exploitation of insane faction mechanics like in warhammer. great video!
@tophholland
@tophholland 2 месяца назад
This game is so slept on. While not my favorite, I have over 500 hours.
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Yeah, it's not my favorite either but it's such a unique title.
@wickedautisticchristian4530
@wickedautisticchristian4530 3 месяца назад
Still to this day this is my favorit TW game bechose of all the things that makes you angry and when you sucsed you realy fell it
@mohamedmedhat7594
@mohamedmedhat7594 2 месяца назад
I'm very glad you changed your mind about Attila TW.
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
How so? I've always thought that Attila had incredible atmosphere.
@Imperial_Legacy
@Imperial_Legacy 2 месяца назад
I’ve been burnt off by Total War games for some time, but you made me want to install TW Attila again. By far my favorite Total War game of all time
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Man you and me both, Imperial. I basically took 2 years off of Total Was minus a few dozen hours when Immortal Empires dropped and a little bit of Troy here and there. Series has just been stale af. New Pharaoh map has me back though.
@Imperial_Legacy
@Imperial_Legacy 2 месяца назад
@@happycompy yeah! I’m looking forward to playing pharaoh since they announced the map expansion (I haven’t bought pharaoh yet and the main reason for it was because the map was bad), but I feel the same way about TW… CA just hasn’t released a great historical title in almost 10 years and we get frustrated waiting for it.
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
@@Imperial_Legacy absolutely. It's been drier than the Sahara for historical fans.
@Chad6o
@Chad6o 3 месяца назад
I purchased this recently, simply because it's a requirement for Crusaders Wars, a CK3 mod, and it was on sale. But your video presentation was exciting enough for me to want to give Attila a try, so thanks.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Have fun!
@MedjayofFaiyum
@MedjayofFaiyum 3 месяца назад
Napoleon nails the atmosphere for me. I need to make my alternate video essay to this one
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
You should! I would watch!
@MedjayofFaiyum
@MedjayofFaiyum 3 месяца назад
@@happycompy I'll make one for sure! I've tried in the past but failed lol
@advokatarkadiya3274
@advokatarkadiya3274 3 месяца назад
Attila is my favorita TW game and this video covered it pretty well. i love it
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Thank you for sharing man. I'm glad you enjoyed it!
@erivej
@erivej Месяц назад
When you play a historical game, other than some first person shooters and RPG, the object is to change history.
@albertdevivies4540
@albertdevivies4540 3 месяца назад
I made some of my best campaign on Attila. One where as the Westerns Roman Empire I desperatly try to hold the hunnic hord. Turning border city into forteress only to see them fall one by one until I finally defeated the hord before it enter italia
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
That sounds epic!
@albertdevivies4540
@albertdevivies4540 2 месяца назад
@@happycompy It was ! But the best part was that when I defeated Attila for the first time he retreated into the frozen wasteland that was the Balkan and I had to send an expedition to find him and defeat him for good. I succeded but lost my emperor and 90% of my expedition in the process. Its kinda sad that TWW never gave those kind of feeling with the chaos invasion
@jansenjunaedi4926
@jansenjunaedi4926 2 месяца назад
Best total war up until today. The only time I played a total war where my butt is on the edge of my chair as I watch my 1 unit limitanei in testudo holding 5 enemy units like a boss while screaming "don't break!!".
@ReptilicusTV
@ReptilicusTV 3 месяца назад
As grimdark as you can get in a historical . God do I love this fucking game. Also,2024 compymaxxing
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Agreed. As a fellow Pharaoh enjoyer, I'm curious what your thoughts are on Pharaoh's atmosphere compared to Attila's?
@ReptilicusTV
@ReptilicusTV 3 месяца назад
@@happycompy Half baked just like a lot of other cool concepts - you feel the rising dread,sure,but the biggest problem is that the crisis events are pretty irrelevant,diseases are a joke unlike RL and there's not enough build up / warning to the different invasion waves,just small flavor text in the corner when you mouseover a different sea people tribe wave. If the crisis events were more impactful/interesting on top of an actual buildup for each wave,it could come close/match Attila.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
@@ReptilicusTV I completely agree 👍
@ReptilicusTV
@ReptilicusTV 3 месяца назад
@@happycompy Don't worry tho there'll be a high quality mod team at work for this soon after the update.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
@@ReptilicusTV Bold of you to assume that there will be more than exactly 37 concurrent players playing Pharaoh and that modders will justify working on it 😂
@skops7343
@skops7343 3 месяца назад
Yes, Atilla was my favorite. Maybe Rome or Medieval when those came out and I was younger, I probably had more fun with those but Atilla I got into a lot.
@jankristek7533
@jankristek7533 3 месяца назад
Attila is my favorite Total War. Its setting, empire survival theme for the Romans. It would be nice if CA Sofia could use some of their magic on Attila as they did on Rome 2.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
If only man...
@vonxoliver
@vonxoliver 2 месяца назад
Every time i play Attila, i feel gratefull living in this easy and comfortable times compared to people who lived during the collapse of Roman Empire, imagine dealing with famine, desease, long winter, civil war, banditry, and heard a guy nicknamed "The Scourge of God" went rampage in Eastern Europe💀
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
No kidding 😂. You and I both.
@cyrusshakeri1103
@cyrusshakeri1103 2 месяца назад
Some of the campaign mechanics (aside from the Huns) are pretty good in Total war Attila. In Rome 2 I found myself often frustrated with the AI because of their blatant disregard for diplomacy. In Attila however, you can actually push a faction into accepting peace terms (except the Huns and their vassals). I often just mess with some of the gothic factions and either destroy them or offer them territory. This normalizes our diplomatic relations and they eventually trade with me and protect my border provinces from invaders. The blood animations for Attila are also really cool in my opinion (much better than Rome 2). And cavalry armies really carry some weight; to the point where you can just outmaneuver every infantry army thrown at you with a cavalry full stack. I love being a horse lord 😂. There is also a great sense of urgency and planning. This game is not just for the average dork looking for glory, it is for the seasoned strategic commander. It forces you to actually adopt policies (defensive/offensive). The player has to consider the consequences of his actions and he has to make sacrifices. All in all, I find TW Attila a very well rounded game. I even learned economics and long-term planning because of it! I love it’s harsh and uncompromising nature 😂
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
That was a great read 👍. "The player has to consider the consequences of his actions and make sacrifices" so true.
@godoforder1828
@godoforder1828 3 месяца назад
The thing about this game is the sheer contrast with rome 2s theming. In rome 2 you are the greatest empire europe had ever seen rising from a small collective of cities to become a glorious powerhouse. The MOMENT you open attila rome's campaign, its all downhill and youre just fighting to barely survive, seeing the glorious empire you built in the first game collapse into oblivion
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Exactly! Compare the atmospheres of Rome 2/Attila to Empire/Napoleon or Shogun 2/FoTS. The Rome 2/Attila difference is night and day.
@nelson_sauvin
@nelson_sauvin 3 месяца назад
Great video man! Some fresh air in this sea of Pharaoh and Warhammer news. Give me Rome II or Attila any day. I really hope that you are back for good. Cheers!
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Thank you Nelson!
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Which Total War (or strategy) game do you think has the best atmosphere?
@anormaldudewhowasattackedb9864
@anormaldudewhowasattackedb9864 2 месяца назад
3 kingdoms for me at least come close with matching attila's atmosphere (obviously completely different atmosphere but still). Attila somehow can present the end of the world scenario better than the actual end of the world in warhammer despite how muchi love fantasy
@Thongger
@Thongger 3 месяца назад
Everything looks so miserable and muddy and covered in shit . I love how grimdark everything is
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Yeah. It's the exact opposite of Rome 2's aesthetic.
@Tom-sd2vi
@Tom-sd2vi 27 дней назад
You can fix the performance by limiting the amount of cores/theads the game can use to 4/8 in task manager. Also, turning shadow quality 1 notch down from the highest helps a lot on the campaign map.
@ElBandito
@ElBandito 3 месяца назад
Attila is also great because Medival Kingdoms 1212 mod is there.
@cloacky4409
@cloacky4409 3 месяца назад
good to have u back dude
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
thanks cloacky! It's nice to see you again too.
@user-jb2nn3on2d
@user-jb2nn3on2d 2 месяца назад
the best part of the total war series
@helena14
@helena14 3 месяца назад
Rome 2 feels like you are in a well made theme park of the acient world, Attila feels like you are there yourself. Only Total War Game (alongside Napoleon) where I never skip the intro.
@christianweibrecht6555
@christianweibrecht6555 3 месяца назад
Would be awesome to play Rome 2 with the mechanics this game introduced
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Absolutely it would...dude don't even get me started 😂. I made a whole video ranting about how Attila should have been a big expansion for Rome 2.
@romainvicta117
@romainvicta117 2 месяца назад
6:36 got me
@unklezam7873
@unklezam7873 3 месяца назад
All time masterpiece. The crown takes Charlemagne DLC for me. I wish they would make a Medieval III based on that.
@EREenjoyer
@EREenjoyer 3 месяца назад
I made the mistake of buying Attila as my first Total War game when the pandemic was in full swing! Its personally my favorite because of the atmosphere and gameplay!
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Username checks out
@GradyGame
@GradyGame Месяц назад
great video! best total war game ever...
@happycompy
@happycompy Месяц назад
Thank you 🙏
@Tbpoilspill2010
@Tbpoilspill2010 3 месяца назад
If I win the lottery or get enough money to fund a good team. the greatest total war like game to ever exist will be made and not to make the creators rich but to make the gamers experience disgustingly rich and enjoyable
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Hey, crazier things have happened.
@prpitprp4927
@prpitprp4927 3 месяца назад
I would like to have a total war medieval 3 or a total war during the 16th century
@AngryHistorian87
@AngryHistorian87 3 месяца назад
To be fair, there were no named Sea Peoples leaders in Egyptian texts, which is why there isn't a single villain to hate like with Attila.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
That is a totally fair point! I actually like the idea that the Sea Peoples are a "faceless horde" rather than them having a Big Bad. The Mongols were the same way in Medieval 1+2. The difference is that the Mongols invaded in one MASSIVE concentrated horde, whereas the sea peoples just sort of scatter into the wind after they spawn.
@mephisto279
@mephisto279 3 месяца назад
The air was filled with smoke and blood.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Rome was weak...
@mephisto279
@mephisto279 3 месяца назад
@@happycompy They made ready for war.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
@@mephisto279 the world had fallen into shadow.
@mephisto279
@mephisto279 3 месяца назад
​@@happycompy Man, I wish CA would just give this game the love it deserves. They Gave Rome 2 more new DLC before Atilla!
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
@@mephisto279 I know. IMO all it really needs is a "potion of speed" type of update that fixes the performance and turn timers!
@andrewfish3141
@andrewfish3141 3 месяца назад
Is a reason why is my fav total war game all time and i know for a fact for most total war veterans is the same... youtubers included like Andy's Take,Termi and probably you ^^ Well for the best mods also,try Fireforge mod for Attila or Fall of the Eagles same feeling same atmosphere,took me a lot to understand why the lighting is like that in Attila!!! 555ad (Age of justinian) ad also gives me the same vibes just got updated (beta)I was waiting for some one to highlight what you just did...if only the performance......nuff said ^^
@munen-muso
@munen-muso 3 месяца назад
Attila is my favorite of the Total War series. Although, it must be pointed out that Atilla was Germanic/Gothic/Barbarian, and definitely NOT Mongolian/Asian. (His name is of Germanic origin, he is depicted as Caucasian in all the earliest artwork, and he was born north of the Danube River, which is Eastern Europe😆)
@arkadisevyan
@arkadisevyan Месяц назад
its like the triple volley in empire total war, its fake but its perfect
@mattcat83
@mattcat83 Месяц назад
The visual design is very difficult to make its units clear and distinct to play with on the tactical map.
@lunsen402
@lunsen402 3 месяца назад
They do really capture the whole "when the world stopped making sense" with attila. Better so then they´ve done with any other game. Pharao, warhammer 1 and three kingdoms in a sense are all thematicly similar to this what with pharao and warhammer 1 both having their own "attila invades" but as you point out it falls flat becouse of no real build up, as for three kingdoms it does have the whole "an empire collapsing" thing, even have that mechanicly just does not have the sort of everything burning down theme though i guess. I do wish they revisit it if only to fix the preformance though couse i can barly stand the game as it is whenever i sitt down with it becouse of the shit preformance even after having managed to get the games FPS up somewhat through my own trouble shooting. It is frustrating.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Wow you just made me realize I didn't even think about the fact that 3K has an "Empire collapsing" theme. I mean, the centuries old Han empire is literally collapsing at the start of the game! I guess that's because the gameplay and "vibe" don't really play up that "destruction/collapse/survival" as much as they play up the various characters and their personalities? I'm not sure. On paper, 3k could have a CATACLYSMIC APOCALYPSE vibe but in practice it just doesn't 🤷‍♂️. It feels more like a "grand epic" atmosphere. Could also be due to my general ignorance about the conflict/story.
@lunsen402
@lunsen402 3 месяца назад
@@happycompy I imagen it is for the theme of the work it is based on (romance of the three kingdom) which starts with something along the lines of "the empire, long divided, must unite, long united, must divide" Basicly chinese history telling is fairly cyclical. China will fall and remerge sort of deal. So while the game is techincly a apocalytic one taking place at the collapse of an empire (one of the most important ones in east asian history, basicly the rome of the east in a way) the undertones of the story is that a corrupt and weak dynasty give way to a greater and stronger one. So maby thats why it doesn´t have those tones might be becouse of the idea of china presisting dispite falling apart. Though i guess we won´t know unless CA decides to explain themself :)
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
@@lunsen402 that makes sense. Thank you for the write up!
@lunsen402
@lunsen402 2 месяца назад
@@happycompy Was a bitt worried i wrote to much. The three kingdoms is a really intressting period in chinese history though am still more a fan of the victorian age in europa.
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
@@lunsen402 I think a Victorian Age game that ends with WW1 would be FIRE 🔥🔥🔥
@martinguerra5152
@martinguerra5152 2 месяца назад
I agree with all points except with the outcome, they made it so depressing i don't like to play it. Its my issue with all art that tries to make something deliverly ugly, if they succeed then they have something ugly. A super subjective point, i know. I imagine that's one of the greatest appeals of Rome II, its beauty. But not the only one, Medieval II and Shogun II are as beautiful as great gameplay and i dont feel deppresed by playing them.
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Yeah. There is no beauty in Attila. It's ugly as hell 😂.
@user-dw6fr9zn8o
@user-dw6fr9zn8o 2 месяца назад
When the objective becomes SURVIVE you know you’re fucked
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Exactly. I love it.
@selucusptolemy3149
@selucusptolemy3149 3 месяца назад
I love Attila and Pharaoh TW
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
You are a man of culture.
@Juvelira
@Juvelira 2 месяца назад
THE BEST TOTAL WAR EVER
@DirkusTurkess
@DirkusTurkess 3 месяца назад
Over the time of this video I managed 2 turns.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
I'd laugh even harder if the abysmally slow turns didn't ruin the game for me 😭
@zlatinalexandrov102
@zlatinalexandrov102 3 месяца назад
After completing the Western Roman on Very hard everything seems very easy
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
You're a masochist. Respect 🤘
@user-fl7zn2tn9q
@user-fl7zn2tn9q 3 месяца назад
How do you deal with the unfair ingame battle stats when played in very hard
@zlatinalexandrov102
@zlatinalexandrov102 2 месяца назад
@@user-fl7zn2tn9q I try to fight mostly unfairly with more armies than my opponent but at the beginning is very hard I always lose battles but I try to do as much damage as possible and play defensive battles, when defending a settlement I win battles with smaller armies with choke points
@marcofantesini5058
@marcofantesini5058 3 месяца назад
Playing as the huns and burn every great city of europe is peak total war experience. But they could have polished it better
@skierus_maximus
@skierus_maximus 3 месяца назад
Yeah Attila is absolute GOAT in atmosphere but I want to point on Teutonic campaing in Medieval 2, especially on soundtrack. Where other campaing has pretty wide spectrum of sounds (Britania has celtic wibes, Crusaders have Kingdom of Heaven inspiration, Americas have a precolumbian vibe) the Teutonic campaing have practically only grim sounds. I mean even intro in this campaing is pretty despering (we summon demon and must deal with it now vibe). Victory theme always cheerful and lively here is grim and sad (we are victorious but what change this?). Pre-battle theme in teutonic campaing is also different, something like apocalipse is now and no matter what happend now is doesnt matter, we are die anyway but our honour demand to stand here and fight. Personally this is my favourite (even if Attila objectively do it better )
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Good shout out! I sleep on the Teutonic campaign because I usually don't play the mini campaigns much in TW games. You're right, it has a banger of a soundtrack.
@therexbellator
@therexbellator 2 месяца назад
I dunno, I've been meaning to return to Attila at some point, but I just enjoy Rome II more. I appreciated its theming and mood early on, like you do in this video HCP, but for me the biggest problem with Attila is how scripted and "on rails" some of the factional campaigns are, and this is further compounded by the game mechanics. One thing I love about Rome II is the ability to customize provinces according to my needs. Need food? Set aside a province with fertility and have it focus on agriculture to produce food for your cities. Need to pump out trained, high level units ASAP? Have a province geared toward military production and training. Need money? Focus on commerce. You can't do that in Attila. Your hands are literally tied from the beginning. The squalor system is odious. Every building improvement and technology that makes your life easier is gated behind either squalor or the need for squalor removal, and by the time you get it, you're struggling to hold on because you're dealing with constant incursions. I can deal with loss of fertility, but Attila is simply overtuned toward frustration. I've watched Legend and Lionheart play these campaigns, and what this heavy-handed game design means is you have to play the same way every time. It just lacks interesting choices for me. "Mood" and "atmosphere" only go so far in maintaining my interest. Even you admit in your video it's utter bullshit, but your tolerance for bullshit is way higher than mine. But who knows? It's been a few years since I last played, maybe I'll enjoy it more now. Either way, great video HCP!
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Hey Rex, long time no see! As you probably already know, like you, I also prefer Rome 2 over Attila despite Attila's deeper (superior) game mechanics. The biggest reasons for that are the turn times and the setting. I may have a higher frustration tolerance than you for bullshit gameplay, but i have a VERY LOW tolerance for slow turn times. Its like a black hole that sucks the fun out of the campaign for me. The setting is just less interesting to me than Rome 2's Classical Antiquity. Rome 2 might have a more bland and inoffensive atmosphere, but that's part of what makes it so replayable. It's the ultimate sandbox in a setting with lots of interesting cultures. I agree with you about the provincial buildings. Like i said in the video, the fact that provinces have to have self-sufficient food production is frustrating, and like you said, it makes it so that you can't specialize your provinces in Attila like you can in Rome 2. In Rome 2, capturing Egypt is a prize because it can feed your whole faction. That's not the case in Attila. All that said, i still appreciate Attila and its boldness when it comes to how it presents its atmosphere. It's divisive and less replayable, but it's also unique and full of character. I just wish it didn't feel like shit to play.
@therexbellator
@therexbellator 2 месяца назад
@@happycompy I hear ya, that's why when I finally get around to Attila I hope I can approach it with fresh eyes. Or maybe I'll just look for a mod that tweaks the gameplay to my liking lmao. Thank you for responding!
@MedjayofFaiyum
@MedjayofFaiyum 3 месяца назад
Excellent editing
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Thank you so much Medjay!
@ZubiForce
@ZubiForce 3 месяца назад
"Clicks like, watches the video" I have the game but never played it (won it on a ruffle!) and I guess it suffers from the same as other TWs I have "some" interest for. And that is Rome 2 and Warhammer 2/3. When I fancy TW is either Rome 2 for historical (unbeatable age and location in my opinion, diversity only matched by WH) or Warhammer 1/2 if I fancy the magics and monsters. I did play a single campaign of Troy that was super long and fun because I had been in Sardinia on holiday visiting a crap tone of bronze age stuff and come back all hyped about it 😂 Same goes for Shougun 2 and 3K... some day maybe is just... Rome II is the one for me
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
I hear that. We like what we like 🤷‍♂️
@Tubehauge
@Tubehauge 2 месяца назад
Paraoh has that mobile game feel to it with the UI etc, i just prefer Attila
@phile1832
@phile1832 3 месяца назад
I love attila, i have about 2500 hours init
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Holy cow...nice 👍
@CptSlow89
@CptSlow89 2 месяца назад
My first TW game was Rome 1... Now last that I played was 3K and is amazing. Yesterday I started with Rome 2... Maybe I will try Attila after it, but probably on easy difficulty... Btw it runs like shit.
@FatKidAtRecess
@FatKidAtRecess 3 месяца назад
the problem with total war Attila is how badly it runs unfortunately
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Yep. It's why I'm hard stuck at 400 hours and can't be bothered to put in much more. The turn times are the deal breaker for me.
@James-sk4db
@James-sk4db 3 месяца назад
Try reducing the resolution, by one setting, worked for me.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
@@James-sk4db For me, it's not so much the battles, it's the end turn times. They take forever.
@James-sk4db
@James-sk4db 2 месяца назад
@@happycompy yeah same, but resolution shift helped with that too.
@corwinusm.7875
@corwinusm.7875 Месяц назад
so atmospheric masterpiece all i do was instal Medieval Kingdoms 1212 xd
@happycompy
@happycompy Месяц назад
No shame. Attila has awesome mods!
@saguntum-iberian-greekkons7014
@saguntum-iberian-greekkons7014 2 месяца назад
Yes yes very interesting. What is the mod at minute 12:46?
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Dark Ages 705 AD
@saguntum-iberian-greekkons7014
@saguntum-iberian-greekkons7014 2 месяца назад
@@happycompy thank you
@haroldgodwinsonshouldhavew3875
@haroldgodwinsonshouldhavew3875 3 месяца назад
Attila is the darknes that consumes and Thrones is the hope that is born out of it
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
That truly is depressing hahahahah.
@NatrajChaturvedi
@NatrajChaturvedi Месяц назад
Rome 2 turned me off the series and I only came back after Warhammer 2 so I missed Attila at release. I have tried to get into it a couple times but I just have never been able to. Maybe someday in the future.
@ayeejiff9847
@ayeejiff9847 Месяц назад
God made this game and with Mods purified with Gold
@ronduptor
@ronduptor 2 месяца назад
I have more than 200hrs on this game. That's only on the 1212AD mod tho.
@MedjayofFaiyum
@MedjayofFaiyum 3 месяца назад
So what you’re saying is total war Pharaoh needs to be Attila
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Exactly.
@MedjayofFaiyum
@MedjayofFaiyum 3 месяца назад
@@happycompy Understood. I hope the free update does this a lot
@MercenaryJedi
@MercenaryJedi 2 месяца назад
Attila does have great atmosphere, as much as I like the game I'll admit it makes then endgame rather boring. By the time the Huns are gone, over half of Europe has been razed and the AI is horrible at resettling it. Maybe it wouldn't have meshed with the theme, but I would have liked to see the game leaning into the Migration Era theme a little more by allowing factions to emerge in desolated regions if given enough time.
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Yeah it's true, if you survive Attila's hordes the end game is a wasteland. There's a mod that makes the AI resettle at least. I love that emergent faction idea.
@bokonoo77
@bokonoo77 2 месяца назад
Read Henri Pirenne Dark ages were not started during that era as even during those so called barbarian states the Roman infrastructure maintained and especially trades were promoted Only after the islamic takeover of the Egypt, Levant and North Africa that the real dark ages started as East-West trade removed and Western Europe was fully encircled
@TheWastelander86
@TheWastelander86 3 месяца назад
Behold, a white horse...
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
Your username fits with Attila's vibe lol.
@messengerslave5874
@messengerslave5874 2 месяца назад
I saw someone get stabbed in the face with an axe so I didn't buy it
@tomzicare
@tomzicare 3 месяца назад
Optimization and unit flags :(
@happycompy
@happycompy 2 месяца назад
Yuppppppp
@CptSlow89
@CptSlow89 2 месяца назад
Playing it with TOB. Shame that Atilla doesn't run like TOB... Also I don't like really slow pace and survival game. I think public order and sanitation is creeping you too much so I need to use mods for that. Also climate change is too much. I love the gfx, combat and campaign map compared to Rome 2. I don't like Rome 2 UI, its easy game so I want to try maybe some DLC campaigns for Rome 2, maybe they are more fun.
@mihaimercenarul7467
@mihaimercenarul7467 3 месяца назад
Too bad the performance is atrocious even with late gen computers.
@Sugaarpanda_87
@Sugaarpanda_87 3 месяца назад
Performance????...EXPLAIN PLZ
@mihaimercenarul7467
@mihaimercenarul7467 3 месяца назад
@@Sugaarpanda_87 i mean how well it performs on PC. You can even have high specs for your pc and The game would still perform badly, with constant fps drops on high and even low Graphics, and The game is more CPU dependent.
@happycompy
@happycompy 3 месяца назад
​@@mihaimercenarul7467 Yup. It's absolutely horrendous. The turn times really kill my desire to play the Grand Campaign these days. I remember CA's lie that Attila was made for "next gen" PCs back when it released 😂. Well here we are, CA. Next gen PCs, and Attila still runs like shit!
Далее
Ranking EVERY DLC For ROME II (2020 Tier list)
25:27
Просмотров 339 тыс.
Нарвался на сотрудника ФСБ⚡️
01:00
Аруси Точики ❤️❤️❤️
00:13
Просмотров 367 тыс.
3 REASONS WHY TOTAL WAR ATTILA IS HIGHLY UNDERRATED
10:05
Can I last 100 turns as the Western Roman Empire?
36:48
Kingdom Come Deliverance 2 is EVERYTHING fans wanted
15:34
Total War Is Dying And This Is Why
16:21
Просмотров 177 тыс.
Anti-Player Bias Total War Attila
1:08:54
Просмотров 208 тыс.
Rogue Trader is Nearly 40k Perfection
52:24
Просмотров 71 тыс.
Why does late game suck?
23:53
Просмотров 379 тыс.
Total War Attila The Eastern Roman Experience
18:14
Просмотров 25 тыс.
Concord: The Biggest Flop In History
17:46
Просмотров 546 тыс.
Нарвался на сотрудника ФСБ⚡️
01:00