Why We Prevailed: Evolution and the Battle for Dominance

Подписаться 1,3 млн

Просмотров 160 тыс.

50% 1

We once shared the planet with Neanderthals and other human species. Some of our relatives may have had tools, language and culture. Why did we thrive while they perished? Join evolutionary biologists, geneticists and anthropologists as they share profound insights about the origin of man and retrace our singular journey from fledgling prototype to the most dominant species on Earth.
This program is part of The Big Idea Series, made possible with support from the John Templeton Foundation.
The World Science Festival gathers great minds in science and the arts to produce live and digital content that allows a broad general audience to engage with scientific discoveries. Our mission is to cultivate a general public informed by science, inspired by its wonder, convinced of its value, and prepared to engage with its implications for the future.
Subscribe to our RU-vid Channel for all the latest from WSF.
Visit our Website: www.worldsciencefestival.com/
Like us on Facebook: / worldsciencefestival
Follow us on twitter: / worldscifest
Original Program Date: June 2, 2012
MODERATOR: John Hockenberry
PARTICIPANTS: Alison Brooks, Ed Green, Chris Stringer, Edward O. Wilson
John Hockenberry's Introduction 00:00
An abstract look at evolution. 2:20
Participant Introductions. 5:00
How many different species were there 100,000 years ago? 7:05
Why did certain populations move? 10:05
Does the fossil record suggest that everything started in Africa? 12:00
Did the early groups compete directly or was there luck involved? 15:13
Where neanderthals slowly going extinct as humans came onto the scene. 22:56
What would we have seen in the physicality of neanderthals? 31:20
Are there any rapid physical adaptations from neanderthal? 37:58
Do encounters of different species make for more rapid evolution? 42:57
The greatest human variations are in Africa. 49:10
Going to the dentist 100,000 years ago. 55:40
Early cave paintings and the beginning of human communication. 1:01:06
The gene for language? 1:10:50
What was the evolutionary accelerator for humans? 1:14:25
Do we see signs today of evolutionary mistakes? 1:21:40
Being an aggressive species leads us to the top. 1:25:55

Наука

Опубликовано:

17 июн 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 182

@WorldScienceFestival 6 лет назад

Hello, RU-vidrs. The World Science Festival is looking for enthusiastic translation ambassadors for its RU-vid translation project. To get started, all you need is a Google account. Check out Why We Prevailed: Evolution and the Battle for Dominance to see how the process works: ru-vid.com_video?v=8GEloPVEh-8&ref=share To create your translation, just type along with the video and save when done. Check out the full list of programs that you can contribute to here: ru-vid.com_cs_panel?c=UCShHFwKyhcDo3g7hr4f1R8A&tab=2 The World Science Festival strives to cultivate a general public that's informed and awed by science. Thanks to your contributions, we can continue to share the wonder of scientific discoveries with the world.

@fukpoeslaw3613 3 года назад

Wat schuift 't?

@paolazo-l4790 3 года назад

Great! I've done some for Ted, and now for World Science Festival ! Thx

@jostanton4445 2 года назад

I love the world science festival, who needs TV ! not me, you see it's because of the availability of great educational programs like this that makes me happier referee yiiiipppppyyyyy

@jayasravanivankayala9058 2 года назад

I totally agree with you

@Wrotan 3 года назад

What a fantastic panel. Id love to sit and talk to these folks for hours.

@blairhakamies4132 2 года назад

Programs like this elevate us. Thank you 🌹

@paolazo-l4790 3 года назад

Fascinating! thank you all What strikes me is the title : Why we prevailed. in past tense. Like if it was already done, We Have Prevailed. The reality is that we are the latest of the latests. We've only been here for the blink of an eye (100.000y) and we take it all for granted. Maybe we share this fact with neanderthal that got him extinct... tic tac

@wbiro 2 года назад

36:20 She made a very good point, and it did not sink in with the others, which shows how scientists remain attached to their ingrained dogma even in the face of superior thinking, which bounces right off them.

@dwwolf4636 2 года назад

Not quite. Neanderthals had less upper arm mobility. Specifically throwing motions were not as efficient for them. We can also see a high frequency of terrible skeletal damage to neanderthal males. They likely attacked large prey animals with spears in melee. Not very safe. Sapiens specialised in lighter throwing spears.

@norwegianzound 2 года назад

Didn't get that from the follow in responses

@Rico-Suave_ Год назад

This was awesome, an honest science conversation, watched all of it

@thickdripgenetics1149 2 года назад

We sure have prevailed, at the coast of how many other creatures 😭

@schoowoolovesbooboo2170 2 года назад

Every creature that's ever existed has either died or will die

@borbalaszeplabi694 3 года назад

Lovely panel

@luizahelenaberriel7984 6 лет назад

No final das contas esse debate diz muito sobre a condição humana. Concordo com Edward O. Wilson quando ele diz que ser uma espécie extremamente agressiva, é uma vantagem evolucionária.

@kapilchaudaha9679 2 года назад

1 million science lovers!

@ChrisMontgomery-xtrmagamr 5 лет назад

Zoolandia, Recently rediscovered would have been dry land at points back to 100,00 years so they very well did walk to Australia and the Hobbit people of the Flores Islands were on more than just a small island at that time. Recent discoveries has made most of this extremely outdated info in just 4 years.

@xLiveFreeDieFreex Год назад

Zealandia... zoolandia is a movie

@nepstar1962 6 лет назад

I like this guy. He knows his job, and the way he does it explains why we prevailed...

@marcgottlieb9579 2 года назад

I think he knows the truth genetically but in the long run he's finished...It is already a scientific fact we jumped evolution due to intervention..And we know the guilty party...

@LarS1963 2 года назад

@@marcgottlieb9579 Maybe you should look up 'scientific fact'. Keep your fairy tales out of this.

@davidviner5783 Год назад

Awesome.

@Chamelionroses 9 лет назад

Social human hierarchy seem to be influenced in power of such things as knowledge and other things like that of psychology and sociology. Though terretorial battles even of the mind ( ideas and concepts) through altruism and violence occur there is this battle who holds and controls such powers constantly. It is that also some beliefs and superstitions fact based or not influence even further the habits of individuals. In turn influences what people learn, have bias, and share in experience. This in turn influences from such experiences the whole as community or group. There is an experiment with babies with puppets. The puppet they regect verses the one they liked. Some babies wanted to punish the puppet that felt bad in tossing it or some form. The experiments were of foods and boxes. The way that children observe and conform for evolutionary survival is interesting. Do remember too that adaptation of how smart or strong may help or may not the individual, but not always will genes be passed to the next generation. I have a feeling many forget and claim superficial reasons (like stereotypes) for a sure success when other wise that is not the fact.

@wordgeezer 3 года назад

Gurdjieff put this quite simply ~ man can do nothing

@reimannx33 2 года назад

Ever since brian green interviewed lara bowdrowski, he has not been the same.

@DeepikaAditya 2 года назад

i feel the different facial features are because of hybridisation of modern humans and archaic humans who had left earlier and reached different places

@Lovelights11 4 года назад

We are a species of interdependence, not domination. This arrogance will be our destruction unless the awake people will wake the sleeping.

@ikaeksen 5 лет назад

7:52 why digitized video cant get the word ^^ information ^^ right. Its in many videos on youtube like The story of carl gustav jung.

@katiekat4457 4 года назад

Ikaeksen Ratzakuz what are you talking about? They don’t even say the word “information” around the time you point out. They do say intonations though. Maybe expand your vocabulary. Word of the day calendar perhaps?

@fukpoeslaw3613 3 года назад

@@katiekat4457 "intonations" ? Where did you hear that word? Don't you mean "intimations"?

@fukpoeslaw3613 3 года назад

You both are a bunch of funny jokers 🤤

@NaturalVTSKilla 8 лет назад

Please music from evolution edit

@polarbianarchy3333 2 года назад

A sound bite to consider, human nature is not confined by our nature. Aggression is very appropriate yo survive in nature. However, our ability to construct complete environments within the natural environment means to me, we can set up dynamics that incentivise connection and cooperation in mutual health and well-being. This is adaptation meme mutations, ontop of a genetic foundation . Mt assumption is environment incentivises behavior, dominance comes in with large populations, eventually of anonomous strangers. Very different than the population who evolved knowing every human in a 500 square mile area.

@Sophiedorian0535 2 года назад

How about roaming patterns? Human hunter-gatherers have a tendency to re-visit places within the same generation.Did Neandertals do that, too? Or did they roam in the manner of a slow drawn-out flight?

@xthe_moonx 5 лет назад

doesnt neanderthals and the dovos have their own "out of africa" story?

@Chamelionroses 9 лет назад

I wonder how many ancient animals used other animals as servants in hunting, gathering, and nomadic ways. Humans seem to find ways to use other animals as livestock and farming, but as well for nomadic travel and sending of messages long distance. How resourcful and inventive weather in battle or in gain other ways I think has also influenced growth in population. One way or another it seems communication and how languages evolved played some part as well over territories.

@Chamelionroses 9 лет назад

It is a sad thing.

@trentp2000 9 лет назад

***** we have been slaves for a very long time. Its been a pattern for a long time where we get to a point in our slavery and then fight back gain our freedom only to allow ourselves to slowly become enslaved again. The really shitty part is how many people want to be slaves because they don't want to take responsibility for their own lives. And then the rest of us are punished for their ignorance and apathy.

@trentp2000 9 лет назад

Think about this.. how many thing are considered a privilege that are regulated by government ? since this video is in weed ill use it as example. Witch is worse for your body heroin or marijuana? Why is it legal to get millions of people hooked on heroin based drugs but if someone has a natural growing plan that doesn't cause any of the problems that the other does you go to jail. I don't even smoke weed but the fact is as an adult human man I should be able to do anything I want as long as I'm not hurting anyone else. That is if I weren't a slave that had to follow my masters rules/laws. I probably could have explained that better but I just don't understand how so many people don't care that they are brain washed slaves.

@skyjuiceification 7 лет назад

Trent P ...interesting. And insightful.

@Chamelionroses 7 лет назад

Trent P so baby to child being human trafficked ...they want to be slaves or abused as slaves? People want to be slaves to addictions consciously in desire from birth to be so , or when does this happen whatever addiction? One can be addicted to drugs even if legal...can be addicted to gambling among other things not drugs...and assumptions and stereotypes of things relating to addictions alone doesn't change a thing. Logical fallacies about how slavery has always been around doesn't help either...subjective definition to whatever is from a dictionary accepted. It is a pattern to breath and try to survive nature too. No one is born without ignorance, and not everyone is allowed so easily to look on information. Some reasons of censorship isn't always one group or another , but many cults do it besides indoctrinating kids whatever psychological methods. Besides whatever laws or rules whatever culture world wide in history...people do things any how besides consequences. All things have risk and dose is the poison. Even oxygen can kill , but that is besides the point. I never smoked weed or had anything illegal. I agree people should be free to choose and this especially if it doesn't have harm to others intentionally or otherwise. Though there are no perfections to this. I wish more were responsible or desired it bravely.

@PremjitTalwar 11 месяцев назад

A correction, the population of earth is over 8 billion, NOT 7 billion.

@thomasvieth578 4 года назад

This is actually a post factum hindsight type of question. It’s sort of like this is a Jackson Pollock painting, how did he do it? I’m eager to hear your answers

@pinchebruha405 2 года назад

he splattered paint on canvas, zero genius involved zero actual talent!

@mr.osx3423 5 лет назад

Is Ed Greene brother of Be Greene ?

@nssherlock4547 3 года назад

No, spelling would be your first clue. E Green and B Greene

@bobaldo2339 6 лет назад

It is such a ludicrous idea that "culture" began at some specific point in human evolution. Chimps have culture. Elephants have culture. Sea mammals have culture. Undoubtedly all our hominid ancestors had culture. I guess Hock is referring to modern human culture when he says "culture".

@MtnTow 5 лет назад

Little people on an island with big feet? You mean small flippers?

@acejames7718 4 года назад

Nope hairy, hobbitses feet, Precious!

@elaineandrepont 2 года назад

What I have learned on my own in 2005 and through a Nutritional Health year long course and subsequent certification: Everything was running quite smoothly until chemical engineers and Botanists manipulated the Wheat, Barley, Rye, Corn, Tobacco and Soy to grow on any terrain. These enhanced plants forced the adaptation of bacteria and yeast that thrived on these robust plant source foods. Foods mostly meant for cow and pig feed. Since they are inexpensive sources of fiber and cows can digest due to their numerous stomachs for proper breakdown and absorption of nutrients. Once these newly formed grains were engineered in 1930, and sent to various poverty stricken countries, they have naturally taken over as in replaced permanently throughout the Earth. Our human digestive systems have taken the brunt of these early experimental GMO’s. These stealth, highly adapted, bad bacterial and yeast are outnumbering our good gut and intestinal biomes. This processing started the beginning of the incline of disorders and disease, and the direct decline in physical and cognitive health and wellness of mankind.

@pinchebruha405 2 года назад

fantastic facts. I have been trying to tell people that obesity is a direct link to the bastardization of foods. but instead of saying hey my body is not right what the hell is going here, we have people saying accept me as i am and I'm beautiful movement! i call this the finger in the dam solution!

@pjeffries301 5 лет назад

Which one is the Philosopher? Ohhh........

@quinndeluna8032 2 года назад

An hour into this and I haven't heard the reason that I learned 15 years ago with which is that Homosapians were far more social and therefore gathered in groups of 30-50 versus the very small family groups of Neanderthals vastly improving the Homosapians survivability because they were working in groups.

@pinchebruha405 2 года назад

well interesting. can we say that the left may be more homosapien since they are far more open to all in caring extends to non family members as where the right seems to be very closed off and only seem to care about their immediate family and culture

@Rico-Suave_ Год назад

Watched 1:12:00 minutes

@codexox1 2 года назад

Amazing analogy and discussion. They try to be politically correct most of the time when they say that they are using Harvard Language LOL.

@polarbianarchy3333 2 года назад

Equilibrium

@strawberrymilksamurai 2 года назад

22:15

@theitineranthistorian2024 Год назад

groupishness explains almost everything about humans. it’s the whole political reality of trump and fox. it would be interesting to see these people today. brilliant

@jennifertrotter363 7 лет назад

Love Howkenberry!

@jiggy_ziggy 7 лет назад

hockenberry sucks, always interrupting

@bobaldo2339 6 лет назад

Usually with his stupid questions, or his lame jokes , Nicholas.

@bryanwood7771 3 года назад

Freewheeling johnny..how would the world science channel quietly get rid of him..by having Brian green n others do some narrations..I'm sorry but him trying to be a comedian DOESN'T WORK. A joke every half hour is fine but every third sentence?!?. I love watching this program but he spoils it to the point of not wanting to view it.

@wordgeezer 3 года назад

Is there such a thing as outer space? If beings from other parts of this galaxy are visiting Earth today; ~ Would they be impressed by NASA and our educational programs? ~ STEM comes to mind...G%

@namename6866 2 года назад

Nope it all controlled by corporation system one world order one world religion one white man system.

@orloification 4 года назад

I love these lectures.. I just wish the hosts would stop trying to be comedians

@vypw0069 9 лет назад

Why do they all got large lumps on their faces

@adambrumwell9248 9 лет назад

vypw0069 Do you mean the flesh toned microphones?

@alexgregor8441 5 лет назад

I mean it's obvious.

@aisles23 4 года назад

What the fucker record 😂 25:42

@tantiwahopak101 6 лет назад

Since 99% of human genome and chimpanzee genome matches each other. So have we mated with them too? Also what about the other animals that r closely linked with human genome?

@aloevoice 5 лет назад

when checking for admixture / intermating you don't just compare overlap of DNA. You look for known markers, known to be SPECIFIC (unique) to one species. We find Neanderthal specific DNA only in modern non-africans, mostly in Europeans and scientists can even roughly trace when in time this came into our DNA. hope this helps.

@pinchebruha405 2 года назад

@@aloevoice ok I have a question; if we know know that we have three lines humans could've come from does that mean that evolution and skills etc are different among man now.

@pascalguerandel8181 10 месяцев назад

Neanderthals DNA has already been sequenced 😊😊

@rickquest6385 5 лет назад

Okay, this is bugging the crap out of me, does the first guy keep saying NeanderTHAL?

@katiekat4457 4 года назад

Rick Quest That’s how they taught you to say it 40 plus years ago when you were in school. When I was in school in Massachusetts they pronounced it “thal” too. Although, now I say “tal” because more people now say it that way. But 40 years ago most people said “thal” at least in America they did.

@robertclive4707 2 года назад

Genes 2x DNA (Man) & 3x DNA (ET) & more

@Chamelionroses 9 лет назад

Can other animals than humans talk or even understand languages of other species of life on this planet. I wonder if body language and sign language was one of the first cultural languages. Even clicking sounds is one kind of ancient language but beyond this how language evolved I have to wonder how so it changed.

@Chamelionroses 9 лет назад

I have seen some where songs need taught to young or birds will not know them. Crows and parrots in general were already thought clever for some time. Even crows in using tools. That is interesting what humans are finding out about other animals. Thanks for the reply.

@Chamelionroses 9 лет назад

I would say bird brain has a new meaning perhaps.

@JamesToupin 9 лет назад

Of course we have recently discovered that Orcas (killer whales) can speak dolphin languages.

@Chamelionroses 9 лет назад

It is so cool what other creatures do morally, tool making, and socially. It has not been that long ago that most folks would even say animals have no emotions or these other things.

@Chamelionroses 9 лет назад

I wouldn't expect a fish to climb a tree as it has no use of it.

@Snorkeldykkeren 6 лет назад

Ehmm, insects and other micro-organism`s is the most dominant species on Earth

@johnchappell4492 6 лет назад

Prevalent, yes....Dominant, no. Dominance is more about power, importance, influence. Dominance is not just a numbers thing. Clearly you don't think a fly, grasshopper, or bacteria is dominant over you, even a whole swarm of them. If 10,000 bees build a hive outside my house, I eradicate them, they don't eradicate me or force me to move. You've also grouped together millions of different species, and compared them to one species. A logically false comparison.

@katiekat4457 4 года назад

Snorkeldykkeren but invertebrates don’t have the same intelligence as vertebrates. That makes all the difference.

@JGM0JGM 4 года назад

@k1w1 The first two sentences from the Intro text in the Video Comments section above: "We once shared the planet with Neanderthals and other human species. Some of our relatives may have had tools, language and culture. Why did we thrive while they perished?" The discussion was totally on point, not about what you thought it should have been about.

@Sluchowiska 9 лет назад

Science doesn't really need clowning, why everything needs to be fun? Just host it in adult manor.

@kesokrunch 9 лет назад

I think that it's part of the way he host his show or something, Neil DeGrasse makes a lot of jokes in his show and for the people that are envolved in science or studying as I am we enojy it because we know that the person who is presenting a lecture and makes a joke or say something funny it's because they love it and enjoy it, they are persons that think a lot and those jokes just appear in the moment, just enjoy it.

@mamunurrashid5652 9 лет назад

This host did better than other in WSF...

@panatronicfreud6484 9 лет назад

I think this guy is great, I've watched quite a few panels he has hosted, and he is entertaining as well as fairly conversant in science. He opened with a few jokes, a time tested way to win over an audience, but the discussion is enlightening and serious. How many people will watch this compared to, say, the Yale free course lectures on evolution? I imagine exponentially more for this video. In the US, we definitely need to make science more palatable to the masses, at least if polls are to be believed.

@mamunurrashid5652 9 лет назад

***** I agree with Bill.....This host is well conversed in science...

@DarkMatterVisible 7 лет назад

That was a remarkably idiotic comment. I'm not sure where you are from, but I can guarantee that Americans have contributed more to the world than...whatever hole you crawled out of.

@chanpol321 4 года назад

Climate change occurs when changes in Earth's climate system result in new weather patterns that remain in place for an extended period of time. This length of time can be as short as a few decades to as long as millions of years. Scientists have identified many episodes of climate change during Earth's geological history; more recently since the industrial revolution the climate has increasingly been affected by human activities driving global warming,[1] and the terms are commonly used interchangeably in that context.[2] Wikipedia

@namename6866 2 года назад

it because it over populated with building and houses roads infrastructure, etc weather and nature does not care what is s built in it way , the will be the same weather pattern earthquake volcano etc It is people and building that is in it path of nature. Peoples n corporation system need to start listening to the indigenous native people they do know what is best to live on earth how to cure and maintain it, natives did tell these corporation not to build what happens disasters to infrastructure corporation system wanted they not spiritual to the land and earth . Land means people earth is the soil.

@wntu4 6 лет назад

We prevailed because our ancestors weren't building 'safe spaces' and handing out participation trophies.

@Jeshua1737 2 года назад

God created the Universe

@pinchebruha405 2 года назад

Which God? sadly you're not helping humanity by hiding behind a fictitious character made up to explain what science is actually doing today... i bet you go to doctors! my personal opinion is that religion has done more harm than good for mankind and still at it,

@polarbianarchy3333 2 года назад

The facade of dominance is why we are moving towards extinction... We are not dominant lolol we are arrogant

@martylawrence5532 11 месяцев назад

There are FIVE information codes in every cell, aside from blood cells. The five are the DNA code, the mtDNA code, the epigenome code, the 'sugar' code that lines the surface of every cell, and the lipid code making up cell membranes. All these had to work in unison. The makeup of these for life are mathematical impossibilities-by-chance. To say the ribosome sums up evolution is ludicrous. That is defined as a 10^50 or more. It's far too complex without outside intelligence to make it happen. On top of this, the Intelligent Designer is a master chemist with 65 different hormones in the human body. We are a creation.. Not an evolution. Quite simply everyone, there is a biological system already in place...therefore God-engineered, logistically...doing all of the classic adaptations. What is this biological system? It's called the epigenome. It's actions is called epigenetics. This includes adaptations seen in Darwin Finches without any natural selection of DNA mutations. Instead it's modifications by chemical tagging turning genes up and down or on and off for different structures such as new beaks for new diets. This is FAST...doing its job in just 2 generations, not millions of years by 'evolution'. Evolution is a scam folks. We are an intelligent design by Jesus Christ. This means he offers a free gift of eternal life just for believing in it and believing he resurrected. Take the free gift today!!!

@smithkuenne9132 3 года назад

Birds will prevail.

@pinchebruha405 2 года назад

insects

@ROSEASTARR-rl1ln 2 года назад

Nope, octopus can already edit their DNA

@derekscanlan4641 6 лет назад

my personal feeling - animal domestication we had dogs. there is no evidence that any other human species ever domesticated wolves the advantages this gave us are incredible, if you stop to think about it

@aloevoice 5 лет назад

you are talking about the history a few thousands of years ago. The time period discussed here is much much much further ago, before there was evidence of domestication of animals.

@srarocmi 4 года назад

Humans didn't domesticate dogs it was dogs that came to humans because of food availability. So who's smater? Current genetic & archeological info also has shown that wolves evolved from wild dogs. Dogs came first. Knowledge must be kept current as it is ever evolving itself. Keep learning.

@fredbergloff6119 2 года назад

FOOLS! The blind leading the blind

@Chamelionroses 9 лет назад

Also I wonder of slavery and how that may have influeced why humans came out on top of the human hierarchy. The best things like food would go to the most powerful and so would chances of mating. Seems to be in many various cultures of the world and influence of health care available. Though how different are people today under these sorts of things known about the past?

@aloevoice 5 лет назад

we have very little evidence how stone age people actually lived socially. We only know there was violence committed towards entire (small) groups or families. This could have been simple robbery, family or group feuds or part of genocide or tribe hostility. The only evidence I would see towards slavery in indigenous people at this stage of development would come from indigenous tribes in the Americas partly practicing slavery. Actually there are so many conflicting theories on what are the best mating strategies for stone age humans and there is no way of finding out, how dating and mating occurred, that I find it best to ignore such theories. The only way to confirm them, would be if we found remains of family structures with a male fathering children from several women - this would suggest a patriarchal way of unequal distribution of female mates. As far as I know, there is no evidence of strongly hierarchical societal structures in the early stoneages, mostly way after agriculture and first civilizations were established (for instance Babylon - where again interestingly, we dont know what the private life and dating and mating and actual societal structure looked like)

@dr.johnpaladinshow9747 4 года назад

Almost all WSF's music intros are really boring... at best.

@IIIIIawesIIIII 6 лет назад

That's already the third person called Green I see on that show. What kind of incest-company is this xD

@nssherlock4547 3 года назад

Different spelling,no relation,Ed Green, Brian Greene . Dont know who was the third person.

@pinchebruha405 2 года назад

we are our own worst enemy....so Zombies are coming!

@curtcoller3632 2 года назад

We know that we know nothing.

@michaelgorby 2 года назад

That's a self contradicting statement.

@chrisfay5431 4 года назад

Honestly don't try to be a comedian!! Your not funny

@oscar8and8 9 лет назад

I get it!, The egg came before the chicken did! How silly of me to think a fully grown hen had an egg!. Go figure!

@supersonicdickhead374 8 лет назад

fish and dinosaurs laid eggs millions of years before there were chickens, so yes egg came first.

@shiitakestick 4 года назад

rooster came first . ( j k )

@amirarsalanganji8304 3 года назад

@@supersonicdickhead374 well if you phrase it as ,,egg’’ then yes but they mean chicken egg

@billyhack9673 2 года назад

You are still too stilted in explaining women’s roles in natural selection. Good grief Charlie Brown.

@michaelchangaris1632 10 месяцев назад

Love the rebaked racism in the idea Neanderthal descendants are the most related and special ‘very successful group.’ Love even more how a stage full of smart people did not challenge him intellectually and let another guy say dark continent as if it was an ok thing. I mean really? The empty Africa idea has been long since debunked and is on the European racist heap, but somehow people aren’t intellectually strong enough to hold open information with out going back to ignorant racist tropes.

@myAutoGen 9 лет назад

Wow, that little video near the beginning was horrible. Irritating, meaningless, self indulgent nonsense.

@marykarensolomon7103 4 года назад

I thought this was a fascinating discussion, with well-selected panelists. Some of the comments below are so random and childish.

@FlockOfHawks 2 года назад

the inglish dude begins way too many sentences with "i think" : that's not science

@pauldusa 5 лет назад

you have too easy, i watch T.E.D. They talk real not general as you do, what about people don't prevail, Reasons ? I can only watch your show for 1 minute,, bye,, get better !

@beaulah_califa9867 7 лет назад

This is the worst moderator that I have had the displeasure of watching lead a conversation in some months. He contributed nothing to the conversation. His sophomoric and misguided questions killed any chance for a coherent and informative conversation. Why is he there exactly? His dumb questions contributing FALSE conceptions, perceptions, and understanding of human evolution. He took the SCIENCE out of the discussion.

@bobaldo2339 6 лет назад

Most people who watch these videos understand the scientific conversations better than this annoying "moderator" does.

@dustinsmith8341 6 лет назад

+Vincent Roche Did you call the man in a wheel chair "hot wheels"?

@semientroy 9 лет назад

As a Christian scientist, I will make some predictions: 1. Man will never create life from non-living material. 2. Man will never find life outside of earth. 3. The world is not getting any better. And it will get continually worse until the day Jesus returns. 4. As time goes along, the book of Revelation will prove itself true. Read it and watch for the signs!

@supersonicdickhead374 8 лет назад

1. creating life is creating life, the state of the material would be irrelevant. 2. Most of life is outside earth, with some inside (worms eww) 3. pick a time when the world was "better" after first defining "better" 4. are we theeeeere yet?

@paulwilkinson1539 7 лет назад

oh FFS, Fuck Jesus!

@DarkMatterVisible 7 лет назад

If you think today is worse than it was 100 or 500 years ago, then you are every bit as stupid as you sound, and possibly more so.

@bobaldo2339 6 лет назад

You can go back to sleep now, Christopher.

@Shattered-Realm 6 лет назад

Some creator mate to put us on a planet that is 99% inhospitable to humans without technology. Leave us on a world full of predators with no natural defenses in frail bodies that age and become ill in so many ways that doctors train for decades just to be able to diagnose and treat (with modern medicine) one organ system failing. That's how many ways or bodies have to fail. Planet wise 70% is filled with toxic sea water which is too salty and causes rapid dehydration. the 30% of it that's land is mostly hostile as well. We can't survive in deserts. UV light burns our skin to a crisp around the equator and the further north we go the worse it gets because it's too cold and impossible to live without technology. There's not enough oxygen at high altitutudes. ect. Were adapted to live in a very narrow band around the equator in savannah's because there's to many lethal predators in rainforests. As long as we stay in the shade in the savannah we're fine. If I was god and I was creating a world and the human body. I'd leave out creating deadly viruses and bacteria and The whole planet would be would have a nice comfortable 20 degrees C temperature maybe a little cooler at night with a thick ozone layer so we would never get sunburnt. Humans if we had to die would just die painlessly after a certain age. Cancer wouldn't exist and so on.