That isolated bass from Shepperton Film Studios, May 25 1978. I listen to that over and over again, and try to play it like that. I've slowed some sections down by 1/4 and still, too many notes and there's no way I can play it. He was and is the all time best.
That's the one and only time I've seen Noel Gallagher humbled and, in places, a little scared. Daltrey's ability to scream just the same as he did in the 70s is, to my knowledge at least, unequalled as an original 60s rock star.
@@danypierson9446 ich = der größte keith moon fan = bis nach pluto + zurück seit seiner geburt!!!!: = aber totalster respekt für den guten herrn zak!!!!!!!!!!!!!
He is just killing this gig, and rightfully so given the familial relationship with 'Uncle Keith Moon' who I believe bought Zak his first drumset and gave him a few lessons. It is ironic that Keith was a welcome additional father figure in Zak's life because Ringo was a bit absent and suffering through his alcoholic addition. Another interesting factoid is that when Keith The Who at age 17 years old he only drank milk. It was keeping up with John Entwistle and others that his alcohol addiction took ahold of him.
@Mister Sifter He hasn't accessed any images you moron. He was trying (admittedly stupidly) to prove the site would take payment. You are accusing him of something he hasn't done and using grotty language like "pumping the kids" shows exactly the level of sensitivity you view the issue with. The reason we have a legal system is so that evidence is heard and punishment administered according to the offence. The alternative is ill informed berks like yourself making people guilty on the basis of "because I say they are".
@Mister Sifter I always find it's those who see a nonce behind every tree that are the ones with things to hide. A case of 'methinks he doth protest too much".
@Mister Sifter He was cautioned for accessing a website containing child abuse images That isn't the same as downloading and viewing. If you can't see the legal distinction then I think you're always going to miss the point. He was also placed on the register for 5 years. To spare your limited intelligence any maths that means he's been off it now for 12 years. Has anything come to light since? No it hasn't.
+The Saw Entwistle was amazing. He, and the rest of the band, weirdly are very looked past when people think of legendary bands. I think they just were never locked into a particular sound, so people do not know what to with them.
Roger that. The Ox had these great galloping bass lines that just never ended. No other power trio (plus vocals) could sound quite as full as the Who because of Entwistle.
Yes, I was thinking about Oasis and their inspirations. The claim was they were a Beatles tribute band, but I've never heard that in their best known songs. What always stood out more was the 'mod' inspiration, in their clothes and hairstyles, so I think they probably took more from The Who than the Beatles. Possibly they thought it was better for solidarity as 'northerners' to claim affiliation to the Fab Four.
@@rogink nah they were huge beatles fans but noel was influenced just as much by the who, the sex pistols, the jam and the stone roses, bowie, t-rex, slade, elton john and others
@@jonasrmb01 Hmm. I'd agree with the Jam as they were the main force with the Mod revival in the early 80s. Yes, any musician is influenced by others, but I'm struggling to hear any from those others you list in Oasis.
@@rogink Slade all day. Those first 3 albums stink of Slade. Not just the heavy guitar sounds, but the songs are littered with Slade melody. I'm not saying they weren't clearly influenced by others such as the Beatles but Slade is the most apparent.
I think the greatest song ever written to be played live is this one. Townshend has a knack for writing music that is explosive when played live on stage. The song moves along dramatically and intensely throughout building up to a truly magnificent ending. Let's face it. The Who simply kicks ass live. Every time I see and hear them. Always have, always will.
Even though Noel is 33 there he looks like a little kid in a candy store playing with The Who. These guys are a lot older than him and you can also tell it's a dream come true. So yes this is a kid in the candy store.
For this marvelous energetic song you can wake me up in the middle of the night. I was in my 20s when I was hypnotized and 70 years now still am. RIP John E. & Keith M. Rock and roll will never die🎸!!!
Best bass player of all rock history : John Entwistle, all over the neck all the time, killer timing, a real driving force. And that kid of Ringo's there behind the drumkit is a good pick. i love Daltrey who never ceases to amaze thoughout the years, fit as a youngster and vocally impeccable.
I have even more respect now for him. Brilliant composer and performer Noel Gallagher has played to the biggest crowds in the biggest venues across the planet, yet he looks literally awestruck up there surrounded by The Who. Who would NOT be??
Yep Noel did a great job. I daresay he wanted to do the song justice too. From his perspective, being the student of classic rock that he is... he knew it was an opportunity to cement his reputation among the greats, and he was really on point. I always wondered how he snared Zak to play with Oasis for 3 years, and it's clear this is where the link started.
@@lfcstevewalker he has to, no point in copying Pete whilst he is there, he has to complement the townshend riffs. Astonishingly enough though, one powerhouse guitar from pete sounds fresher and less convoluted than this 2 guitar version. Nevertheless a great version (as is Substitute with Kelly Jones)
One chord played in anger from Mr Townshend would lay Oasis to the ground. They'd be out up to their Mancunian scams before the sun went down. They were lucky, very lucky. Their is no argument about that. We all know it.@@marcusnolte7476
Seen loads of great bands over the years seen The Who twice once in the seventies and the eighties they were the best band I saw live by a country mile
@@ant-1382 "The Rolling Stones, only recently lost there first original member"? Either Brian Jones did not die in 1969, or "your as clueless as you're their".
At the end of the day Noel loves the originators of rock n roll and he proudly pays homage to his heroes. And for that I respect him. Good on him for having the guts to take on the prestigious honor.
The Who are one of the best band and. this would be ever ,without any discussion. For what concerd stars, frontman, on the stage was been true since the Who arrived on the stage.... and they let the world exited by any other emotion can come from thè best and out of mind band live.. I never hàd the priviledge of seeing thè Who live ....more just yesterday I've listened Roger that saw if hàd a signifian go on with live. Ròĝer I bag you, yòu must resist since I'll😮 had monete to see The Who live. SORRY FOR MY ÐISASTER WITH INGĹISH
@@doctorprick2843 OASIS THE BEATLES EVEN WHEN THE BEATLES SPIT FOUR MEMBERS HAD NO 1 HITS ALL QUEEN BAND MEMBERS WROTE NO1 HITS THE WHO NEVER HAD ONE THE BEST THEY COULD DO IN THE UK CHARTS WAS NO2 THE EAGLES DEACON BLUE ALL HAD NO1 HITS THE VERVE. SPICE GIRLS EVEN AFTER THEY SPLIT HAD NO1 HOW WHEN THERE SHITE
This is awesome! I’m 73 and grew up with this music. I love oasis. Their music is a homage to our generation. Noel will forget this Rock on roger and Pete!
Remember a lovely Townsend story; on the last tour before Entwistle died, they were soundchecking (Miami or somewhere). These guys had already been playing together for about 400 years, so you'd think they'd know what moves each was likely to make. Entwistle did something so completely outrageous and unexpectedly amazing on the bass that the whole band apparently stopped dead, and Townsend said 'what the FUCK was that??', to which Entwistle just grinned.
Not to take away from your story, but great musicians do that to each other all the time. Charlie Watts was famous for just changing the timing in the middle of songs just to mess with the other guys. It was always subtle enough not to ruin the song for the fans, just enough to keep the other band members on their toes.
@@glenchapman3899 Charlie and mick Taylor were the best musicians to have played with the stones, Jagger and Richards are seated on the table of the songwriting virtuosos but were lucky to have great people to help them transform their ideas into sound
@@glaswegiansouth-side2350 if I had to pick just one I'd have to go with Chet Atkins. Not my type of music, but what he played is far beyond anything I could do.
@@normandecaesen286 Ive heard of him but i have never heard him 'if you get me' lol.Its a question that i like to ask people like yourself who KNOW the guitar.Thanks for the reply.One other question tho? lol.In the rock'n roll world who would you say was best? EG Jimmy Page...????? I just love guitar music it appeals to me.
@@glaswegiansouth-side2350 I've been inspired by every great guitar lick I've heard since about 1972 when Deep Purple released "Made in Japan"....lol. My guitar style is mostly Joe Perry, Joe Walsh, and Billy Gibbons with a touch of Thin Lizzy from the lp "Live and DANGEROUS". My advice is "Keep Rockin' ". It's been cool sharing with You!!!
@@normandecaesen286 Ritchie Blackmore on Purples Guitar is a great 'no doubts'.Thin lizzies Gary Moore another great.My 1st was Steve jones from the punk band 'The sex pistols'who every MP in Westminster slagged off as dangerous were inducted into the NMHOF which tells you and i that they wee great and the MP'S of London were wrong AGAIN LOL......Keep rocking old soldier were never too old.....Oh aye as we say in Scotland Syd Barrett' wouldve been a great only if????? Thanks for all
ONE of?? ANY of Petes "creations" is THEE greatest and goosebumps I get still today , is greater that teh first hit of crack I ever took. Those of you in the know , know what a bell ringer is , and I get one every time I listen to these guys... ' just do it" Not to one up anyone but I have seen them 12 times, Last time took my youngest daughter and had Great seats. It was Quadriphinia and MORE, the more was..." dont get fooled again", thats it.... , one song equals "and more"? sorry pete, I`m getting up in years too, I`m only 4 years behind ya , but for what i spent , I felt teh" and more" should have been a bit more. So teh next time you guys came to Phoenix, I "DIDN~T get fooled again" and stayed home , enjoyed listening to you guys on the internet recorded in some other city, Saved over $600 and didn`t have to fight traffic. 13 would have been a unlucky number anyway. Oh, My daughter was 23 at teh time, and she has sure been introduced to The Who all her life with her old man cranking them up on his 60`s stero and huge speakers, She said she got off more at home rocking out with dad but still enjoyed the show , and watching dad rock out, admittedly it was not"" the best I ever haaaaaaaaadddddddd!!!!"""No no.I still love you Rog and Pete, Keep it up dudes, and RIP John and Keith, your replacement are great , but they will never be either of you two. Yea I`m old but who is Noel Gallagher ?
The highlight of Noel's career, even by his own admission. He said; 'Pete Townsend, a bone fide rock guitar legend and me, the guitarist in Oasis only because I was the only one who could play guitar'. Respect Noel, that night you knew you was playing with the greatest Rock and Roll band in history. A fantastic rendition of the greatest rock song in history.
The Who are insects compared to The Beatles or Zeppelin. Even in 1968 they were still opening for the Doors in the USA. The Doors would have been opening for Zeppelin, no doubt
What can I say? I was there. Immense. I have never liked Oasis or anything about them, but the sheer boyish pleasure from Noel's face of being where he is, and him stepping up to a fucking terrifying job, earns HUGE respect! I thought The Who were old when they did this lol....only in their 50s then....... and Zak really is fucking superb.
I never liked Oasis myself but applaud Noel who is perhaps a better guitarist than a songwriter, particularly as his songs were sung poorly by his brother, sliding around the notes for example.Mike Post turned Wonderwall Into a good song with his arrangement and vocal accuracy. I must say though Noel appeared grateful to be up there with The Who and he went up in my estimation after this performance. I've seen the Who at least 14 times and lost count and they have never failed to give value for money. Professional throughout their long lifespan and always in touch with their audience.
Clive Bindley - You’re right! I was getting confused as it was Zak. Make the Rock Royalty count just 1 then = The Who. I’m not discounting Noel. I actually think Definitely Maybe is one of greatest albums of all time. Morning Glory has 3 good songs on it........and then Noel has spent the past 25 years just regurgitating it all!
The two guitars complement each other perfectly. Noel's thick Les Paul lead sound with Pete's thin Strat Rhythm style. I've seen other Who videos of live concerts & they're missing this element even when they have another guitarist on stage.
Mr. Entwistle's bass lines are absolutely fantastic. The way his notes blend into the song, fabulous. It's interesting to note that the lion's share of the left channel is his! Most of the guitars seem to be in the centre and right of it. Amazing musicians! 😎👍🏽
They should keep this lineup! Love it! Noel's Gibson gives this classic a nice edge against Pete's Fender Stratocaster. What I've always loved about THE WHO is that every guy in the band is unorthodox and yet it works better than almost any other band you care to name. Still the best live band I have ever seen.
The Who is one of those bands that as a kid I felt instantly cool when I realized I loved this band as a 6th grader late 70s. I know my next statement is opinion: This quite possibly the greatest rock anthem ever. This song has it all! I realized that the Who in 71 with this album, Who’s next, totally evolved and transformed into this newer, cooler version of the Who. IDK, I can’t explain 😂 This by far is one of the coolest songs ever from start, middle, and end. Ty, Who for being so FN cool!
Noel looks like a kid that just got his childhood dream arrive on his doorstep, save for jamming with the Fab Four in heaven, this was as good as he could have ever hope for.
I thought this was fantastic ! Noel is clearly a very talented player ! But I thought all of the Who made him so welcome and at ease ! This is a fantastic version of that song ! Probably my favourite
Noel got to play with one of the greatest musicians who ever lived: John Entwistle. It must've been a bit intimidating, because John never broke a sweat, he just stands there, the greatest, & silently says right, show us your stuff. Pete's my favourite, there'll never be another Pete, but you can't say enough about just how talented John was. And amazingly, Roger's voice is better now than it was in this video from 20 years ago. He's really worked hard to maintain his vocals, his passion for live performance is what keeps this band on the road.
I love Datry's head nod to Noel with the line "take a bow to the new revolution"... , Noel's simplified guitar breaks serve the song very well, and young Mr Starkey is a hell of a drummer.
OMG! I have died and gone to heaven. This is my all time Who favourite and Noel Gallagher is just "the man" I am a big Oasis fan and Noels guitar style is just unique. If you close your eyes and just listen you instantly know its Noel on guitar. I watched a You Tube video of Oasis on Jools Holland singing Slade`s Come on feel the noise and it had that classic "Oasis" sound. Same as the video on here of Oasis singing Neil Young`s Hey Hey My My.
And your point? Roger was 56 here, at this point he was Rockin for almost 40 years. 15 years wasn't that long ago compared to how long he was in The Who.
+donaldrocks101103 And the scream is as awesome as it ever was. He s still in the Who and the Who are still touring. They pulled Detroit this year because Roger Daltry has meningitis. But they still knocked the daylights out of Glastonbury.,
Hahaha!!!! ......yeah......"back in the day.........." makes me feel older than I'd like. Time is a movin' don't be caught by surprise that this world is changing. I have to remind myself. ( deep in "the time of the end." )
Well done to Noel for having the balls to do this , at least he got a taste of what it's like to play with the really big boys ! instead of ' our kid' ! The Who were very generous to him & Zak Starkey is brilliant !!
One thing I always loved about Noel is that he always respected where he came from,musically.Lennon/McCartney and Jagger/Richards were the same with Little Richard ,Chuck Berry and Gene Vincent in their day.
Pete Townshend called Noel Gallagher & asked if we'd play lead guitar because he was just so bored playing it. Noel, who's a friend of The Who said yes & even though they rehearsed the song, Noel knew it by heart. If you listen, he play's it in the original cords Townshend wrote & it sounded great, even with Townshend playing his usual way. It was a nice change..... Thanks for the UL.....
@@robmorris7128 I believe at the time considering that was a benefit concert, Noel was a great choice. Oasis was a great band with a large fan base. I'm sure Townshend, Entwistle and Daltrey knew that before agreeing on asking Noel to perform with them... I like how Pete Townshend says just as Noel walks on stage, ''Thank God he didn't bring his brother''.......
WOW, what a fabulous opportunity for Noel to be in a true Rock and Roll legendary rock band. Mr Starkey, what a drummer.... The WHO sounds like the same energetic band from the 60's & 70's
Iconic song. Two really interesting guitar players, powerful singer, and the man who invented modern bass playing, Loved the way Noel Gallagher looks ... he's really conscious of not fooking the song up.
Don’t get why ppl are slagging Noel off. He does a great job. If he was as bad as these yanks says The Who wouldn’t have invited him. Noel has a enormous catalogue of great songs and well deserves it. End of story.
What's even cooler about this is I believe the Les Paul Noel is playing was owned by Pete Townshend and then later Johnny Marr before Marr gifted it to Noel.
The Who has played this classic thousands of times, but that performance is one of their best. Noel adds another dimension and allows Pete to focus on the main riffs. The OX, ThunderFingers, is bringing thunder throughout. Have seen the Who about 16 times. This rendition rocks!
The guitar Noel is using was actually originally Pete Townsend's. Pete gave it to Johnny Marr who gave it to Noel Gallagher. Fitting that Noel used it here
