YouTube's copyright system isn't broken. The world's is.

Подписаться 6 млн

Просмотров 8 млн

50% 1

No copyright infringement intended. | Watch Money, my new Nebula Original series, when you join CuriosityStream for only $2.99/month: curiositystream.com/tomscott
WRITTEN BY: Tom Scott
SCRIPT ASSISTANT: Andrea Marks
CAMERA: Jamie Drew
CAMERA: Joe Stone
AUDIO MIX: Graham Haerther
EDITOR: Isla McTear
CAPTIONS: Caption+
WITH THANKS TO:
1901 Arts Club
The Camera Museum, Soho
Evan Edinger
The Lexi Cinema, Kensal Green
Mandy Celine
Abigail Thorn
Tim Bunn
LEGAL CAMEOS:
Leonard French / ljfrench009
Devin Stone / legaleagle
QUASI-LEGAL CAMEO:
Jay Foreman / jayforeman
MINECRAFT SEQUENCE:
Joel "Smallishbeans" / smallishbeans
MUSIC
Epidemic Sound
Canon in D solo piano recording courtesy of ProstoRecords and Envato Market
Canon in D rock recording courtesy of Kora3000 and Envato Market
STOCK PHOTOGRAPHY
Images used under license from shutterstock.com
PRODUCER
Reb Day
© Pad 26 Limited MMXX
Chapters
0:00 Introduction
1:09 Chapter 1: The Mess We're In
10:08 Chapter 2: No Copyright Infringement Intended
22:18 Chapter 3: Content ID
28:21 Chapter 4: Where Do We Go From Here
39:00 Trailer and Sponsorship
40:07 Credits and Outtakes
tomscott.com
/ tomscott
/ tomscottgo

Опубликовано:

14 май 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 18 тыс.

@TomScottGo 4 года назад

Yep, 42 minutes of video. This was a big project. Plus: I've got an all-new five-part original series called Money over on Nebula, which you can watch as a bundle with CuriosityStream! curiositystream.com/tomscott

@kwirro 4 года назад

Thank you!

@BillyC 4 года назад

Long form videos are awesome! Thank you so much Tom!

@stormtrooper8470 4 года назад

1 week ago

@CyberedCake 4 года назад

How did you post this a week ago but the video was released 3 minutes ago?

@dandanthedandan7558 4 года назад

The hero we don't deserve but needed

@astrrra 3 года назад

Actually, don't ask photographers how much their gear costs. Unless you want to see a crying photographer.

@hariseldon02 3 года назад

Sounds like a good motif

@Dman6779 3 года назад

i would like to see that

@hariseldon02 3 года назад

@@papasscooperiaworker3649 Something to take a photo of

@Bobis32 3 года назад

some of the landscape photographers i know have over 35k in kit

@raffimolero64 3 года назад

@@hariseldon02 but then you'd be crying too

@jackiemorey6911 3 года назад

"We need to dramatically shorten copyrights" *Disney didn't like that*

@SlapstickGenius23 2 года назад

Well yes, but it takes a lot of time, as I’m not a copyright abolitionist either.

@TheBluePhoenix008 2 года назад

We know this is never happening

@combinetheelite 2 года назад

iTs NoT CaLlEd CoRuPtIoN iTs CaLlEd LoBbYiNg -Disney

@Rauruatreides 2 года назад

After all, if Disney didn't lobby for extended copyright, then lots of its stuff would be in public domain.

@Noobshire 2 года назад

I certainly agree that the music itself should come under something more akin to patent law. You get X years to make your cash from your product after which it's all fair use, recordings notwithstanding.

@elisha.schiff Год назад

Love how the entirety of this video is Tom making absolutely *sure* this video won't get copyright strike

@shayaanm7122 Месяц назад

does this really have no comments

@SethHixie Месяц назад

@@shayaanm7122Its just the two of us, buddy

@ruler255 Месяц назад

⁠@@SethHixieno, it's just the three of us

@NHikel319 29 дней назад

@@ruler255I'm here too

@Lemony123 18 дней назад

@@NHikel319 well, its now the fifth I guess

@athos401 Год назад

Seeing Jay Foreman casually appearing as a lawyer made my day

@viruscumoruk Год назад

Funny scene

@realhuman5688 11 месяцев назад

@@viruscumoruk aaaaaaaa

@viruscumoruk 11 месяцев назад

@@realhuman5688 hi

@story3877 10 месяцев назад

He is the best

@TerryTheNewsGirl 6 месяцев назад

Mine too!

@edisonyi1188 4 года назад

Love how Tom always looks simultaneously 24 and 42.

@dibbidydoo4318 4 года назад

but average would be 33 which is close to his age.

@ADeeSHUPA 4 года назад

@@dibbidydoo4318 hM

@null3007 4 года назад

He's a palindrome human.

@hatedumb 4 года назад

@shrowdy ydworhs Receding Hairline That's basically it

@FHL-Devils 4 года назад

@@hatedumb - and greying sides - that's an even stronger hint of age.

@MillywiggZ 4 года назад

No red t-shirt. This looks serious.

@zoltano_cortez 4 года назад

I laughed more than I should have at this..

@user-hk8yp7cw1v 4 года назад

Oh boi this got serious real quick

@kaischrank 4 года назад

13:32 + 22:16 Is this not red?

@Owen- 4 года назад

It comes in later dont worry

@runguardian6868 4 года назад

There is from 10:00 to 28:00

@dave_yarders Год назад

You forgot a very interesting fact about copyright expiry! The Peter Pan clause. All copyright in the UK lasts for the author's life + 70 years, apart from one specific work: Peter Pan. The author gave the rights to Great Ormond Street Hospital and the law was written to make sure this copyright lasts forever.

@TheGreenTaco999 Год назад

lmao

@wilh3lmmusic Год назад

Only for royalties though

@itheuserfirst3186 Год назад

And I thought their libel laws were absurd. Geez.

@itheuserfirst3186 Год назад

That has to be the most extreme act of virtue signaling on record.

@nialmontana Год назад

I suppose the idea of having a charity clause where royalties earned get sent to a charity but leaving it sort of partially public so that people could reference and use it's material but a reproduction by a new company would have to specifically get permission and pay the royalties.

@samanthak9346 2 года назад

a fun way to explore how messed up copyright is is to attempt to liscence a picture of a newspaper that doesn't exist anymore. The author sold it to an orginization that no longer exists, that was bought by a different company, whose image management system is different from their text copy management, and the only way you can find the image of the original newspaper is in an archive which has its own licensing agreements and the original author is dead but not for the required time for your country to move it under copyright. Courage to anyone whose job requires it!

@supreme_leader_of_the_internet Год назад

Just do it and find out who owns it by the lawsuit

@Roomsaver Год назад

@@supreme_leader_of_the_internetExpensive but probably easier than tracking the copyright holder down. Cunningham’s Law perhaps?

@lXlDarKSuoLlXl Год назад

@@Roomsaver it's not expensive since you'll most likely get a cease and desist, not a lawsuit, so, it kinda is faster hahaha

@kirbwarriork3371 10 месяцев назад

@@supreme_leader_of_the_internet Reminds me of "Easier to ask for forgiveness than permission".

@anon-fq3ud Месяц назад

I tried to find an old newspaper article mentioned in a book to use as a source on an article I was writing about the SNP in Scotland. I started at 9PM and gave up at 5AM, the layers of licencing murdered me.

@voidmayonnaise 4 года назад

Disney lobbied copyright law into absurdity. 70 years after the creator’s death is bloody absurd.

@chongjunxiang3002 4 года назад

70 years is enough time for Disney to create real life film to further extend the already fair use books.

@AugustusBohn0 4 года назад

speaking of that horrible corporation, get ready for them to make things worse again in 2024.

@generictimestamperstupendi9021 4 года назад

@@AugustusBohn0 what are they doing in 2024

@Tessa_Gr 4 года назад

What really pisses me off is that most Disney films aren't their original work. Many of their films are about fairy tales and similar stuff so that they don't have actually write new and original stories. Especially as someone who grew up with the tales of the Brothers Grimm (not written by the Brothers themselves, they just wrote down fairy tales) it really angers me how shitty and morally corrupt Disney is.

@Robbedem 4 года назад

I don't even understand what the creators life has to do with it. It should just been x years after public release. (20 years should be plenty)* *Tom Scott seems to go for 50 years. Maybe 20 years is still short, but IMHO 40 years should be the max.

@simonr7097 4 года назад

I was thinking that "death of the artist" would be a reasonable limit for copyright duration, but then I realized that it would create a new motive for murder.

@IHateNumbersOnNames 4 года назад

Ooooo boy

@Mr_O 4 года назад

not to mention artists who die young

@annakaro9081 4 года назад

Haha, yes, I am a writer and I also thought that "I won't need copyright after death" but now I'm scared to say it out loud. But I wouldn't want copyright to expire while I'm alive because I'm afraid of seeing what some people might do to my precious characters.

@yellowcactustvz4929 4 года назад

@@annakaro9081 We know you write furry porn

@Obviary 4 года назад

* stabs walt disney * Mickey mouse for everyone!

@NopeNaw 2 года назад

The music industry is completely absurd with how much of a mess it is to keep track of what license is applicable when and where. It's kind of disgusting, in all honesty.

@itheuserfirst3186 Год назад

The music industry has always been the the most scumbag riddled, low life attracting, business in media.

@scmbgoogle7790 12 дней назад

can't they just say "you can use it, just don't use it for bad""

@emma_loomis 11 месяцев назад

30:50 I love that he put the text above where the captions are so those that require/enjoy captions don't have to turn them off to read the text, turn them back on, and rewind. It is one of the most common things I see where people put text right under the captions, which are unmoveable on mobile devices. His videos are always so well thought out and lots of people appreciate your work.

@dracula0 9 месяцев назад

Yea I appreciated that too

@Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa-db2ff 3 месяца назад

Kind of late but you can put the video in full screen which places the captions outside of the video, or rotate for phones

@wormwoodbecomedelphinus4131 3 года назад

"We live in a society" but its 42 minutes long and well made.

@inyoface5456 3 года назад

Underrated

@lethauntic 3 года назад

We do, in fact, live in what is called a society.

@PrettyBitchLuna 3 года назад

Facts

@inyoface5456 3 года назад

@@TheFalseShepphard true

@legohexman2858 2 года назад

@@TheFalseShepphard I'm cool because I don't do popular things

@p0cket646 3 года назад

Imagine being a little kid online who doesn't know what copyright is, and accidentally losing your family 35k from uploading baby shark

@hurricanemeridian8712 2 года назад

Literally this

@Ciara_Foxx 2 года назад

Back in my day kids lost their family's money in online poker.

@gdxnsk 2 года назад

-Any game with lootboxes ever

@bruhmoment1835 2 года назад

.. deserved

@bhagwatipawar4476 2 года назад

@@gdxnsk Geez, those kids were actively investing online though it was a short time investment 🤣

@ianorourke9709 2 года назад

Can we just take a moment to appreciate the incredible collab between legal eagle and tom scott?

@Dreckmal01 Год назад

There are a handful of great youtubers making an appearance in this video.

@thepenguinmafia Год назад

That was my fave.

@murpledeer 9 месяцев назад

“This man is an actual lawyer I have no clue how I convinced him to film this” was incredible

@ilmarilah1195 9 месяцев назад

The Collab confirms that legal eagle, Tom Scott and tierzoo are in the same cinematic universe Edit: Tim Scott did a collab with MrWhoseTheBoss. And chased the jet lag team around London. That confirms that jet lag also belongs

@freekingfreaking246 9 месяцев назад

And Jay Foreman??

@AnnoyingSoundsMadeRelaxing Год назад

The thing that infuriates me is that many copyright cases end with the confiscation of computers. That’s not an eye for an eye; that’s an eye for a dirty look.

@dororo2597 10 месяцев назад

Cases example? Give me pal

@tristan5299 3 месяца назад

@@dororo2597 one extreme example is Kim Dotcom. When he lived in new zealand, he got (at the time) illegally swatted (a court ruled after that it was legal) and all his drives were illegally provided to the fbi. He 100% infringed on copyright, but they broke *multiple* laws to get him. And a lot more sketchy stuff going on that I left out. Go read up on it on wikipedia or something.

@lottery248 Месяц назад

@@tristan5299that's even worse than RU-vid's!

@williambryant4139 3 года назад

"How old are you?" "Somewhere between 23 and 52."

@OffTheWagons 3 года назад

same with me, I have heard people guess 20yrs old to 40yrs old but I am 38

@davidbanan. 3 года назад

Some where between 0 and 80

@innocentbeancreature2370 3 года назад

I’m 0-69

@grqfes 3 года назад

I am somewhere between 3 and 30. I guess Google knows..

@game-guy 3 года назад

@@grqfes ye i guess

@redulis_oni8391 3 года назад

The Creators: It's RU-vid's fault RU-vid: It's the Creators fault Tom: It's the world's fault

@webmasale 3 года назад

It's the greedy corporations fault

@bakacdaz 3 года назад

(Tom) Scott (not Pilgrim) Vs The World

@Miku-uw2sl 3 года назад

Tom’s right

@kris_0520 3 года назад

@@bakacdaz Friggin’ brilliant!

@RobertPayne556 3 года назад

Found all the schills. TRIALS WILL BEGIN IN DUE PROCESS.

@baddrivingsouthwales4789 Год назад

There are companies out there that just seemingly try their luck with claiming copyright on entire or parts of music videos by independent creators. A friend of mine had a claim filed against one of her videos for some of the footage…yet every second of footage was filmed by her; and it was just POV footage at a beach. Took her ages to get the claim settled.

@DontYouDareToCallMePolisz 9 месяцев назад

That's... Evil

@born2war 2 года назад

I remember someone told me I was stupid because I paid $5 for a small stock picture of a rose to use it for a cover into Wattpad. But I was not taking chances, even if the story had zero readers.

@SanctuaryADO 11 месяцев назад

What's the story called mate? I wouldn't mind reading whatever you wrote.

@born2war 11 месяцев назад

@@SanctuaryADO Thanks a lot, Ben. But it is in Spanish 😅 In English, the title is Blood and Roses: Versailles Palace. Vampire story.

@SanctuaryADO 11 месяцев назад

@@born2war haha that might be a problem considering I'm a monolingual sod. Ah well! Have a good day mate 👍

@RoflcopterLamo 10 месяцев назад

@@SanctuaryADO MTL poetry never stopped nobody

@jackgreen05 2 месяца назад

@@born2war Hola! Yo hablo español pero no pude encontrar tu historia 😿

@SuperShesh2 4 года назад

“This is an actual lawyer and I have no idea how I convinced him to do this” Lmfao

@michaeljohnson7929 4 года назад

His videos are actually really good. Legal Eagle.

@tomwintle3311 4 года назад

His channel is really good! LegalEagle They both use Curiosity Stream too :p

@faust7756 4 года назад

I saw him and was like wow its legal eagle

@georgedoty-williams2085 4 года назад

They both work for CuriosityStream

@farenhite4329 4 года назад

Michael Johnson sue tom wintle for infringing on your comment!

@rebmcr 2 года назад

I like how Tom's idea of annoying is just Tom but wearing a Hawaiian shirt.

@raziasultana5222 2 года назад

lmfao

@HashimAziz1 2 года назад

I like to think it's a whole different alter ego called Tim

@lilylopnco 2 года назад

@@HashimAziz1 The dollar store Tom Scott, Tim Scot

@Eric.-. 2 года назад

Tim Scitt

@KCGamingBuddies 2 года назад

@@lilylopnco tim scotch

@Gabo_2825 10 месяцев назад

7:12 not Tom foreshadowing the worst apology video that would be released 3 years later 💀

@GreatGizmo74 9 месяцев назад

😂

@dominiquarz3868 9 месяцев назад

Omg😂😂😂😂

@sidchaini 9 месяцев назад

Could you elaborate which video you're talking about?

@qwertyuiop.lkjhgfdsa 28 дней назад

person who has only seen coleen ballinger's apology seeing someone playing ukelele: 'getting a lot of coleen ballinger vibes from this'

@austinevplab7167 2 года назад

Happened to me. Bought music from a "Royalty Free Music" site which included a copy of the music license. Got a copyright strike and when I challenged it all they said was "They disagreed. Copyright is still in force."

@ev-0163 4 года назад

The guy who wrote the dictionary: imma bout to end everyones career

@tohfawalker159 4 года назад

phthalo blue you can’t copyright a single word and a phrase is difficult to claim copyright for. I think the smallest amount of text you can easily copyright is a paragraph or more.

@Gogglesofkrome 4 года назад

@@tohfawalker159 I suppose a good example of this would be a poem, but even now not a lot of people really even respect that, especially considering how most people who write poems simply don't have the monetary or legal power to make such a maneuver

@big924 4 года назад

I don’t think a single string of words should be able to be copyrighted, like a single line from a poem, roses are red shouldn’t be able to be copyrighted and if you yourself are making a poem, and use “the raven was riding on the wind” etc. shouldn’t be copyrighted

@big924 4 года назад

If you are replying to me, it’s not supposed to be real poetry, it’s a stereotypical exaggeration not supposed to mean anything but to illustrate what part of the poem it’s talking about.if it’s not replying to me then cool

@kindoe6399 4 года назад

It's joke

@zozodj2r 3 года назад

Convincing Legal Eagle to be a vampire is a decent flex

@yolo-sy6zl 3 года назад

true

@gearheadlydia 3 года назад

I'm kind of curious who the voice behind the camera was during that scene.

@baconlord9062 3 года назад

Leagle

@t3hd0n 3 года назад

i immediately came to the comments to see what was said about this scene

@nicelizreu1 3 года назад

Woah, I missed that. Anyone have a time stamp?

@shangerdanger Год назад

what i think is so interesting is that an artist of a song will own the video if there's a song and a video together... why don't I get to still own the video just because their song is on it?

@itheuserfirst3186 Год назад

Lobbyists and lawyers. The end.

@grants7390 Год назад

if you mean an original video that you made with someone else's music in it you cold just delete the video, then re upload without the music. if the video doesn't work without their music, then maybe you should pay them to use their music.

@connermarchetti7522 11 месяцев назад

Damn that's crazy all I have to do is pay to use their music? let me just whip out my wallet full of ca--oh wait

@grants7390 11 месяцев назад

@@connermarchetti7522 then don't use their music. It's their property if you you can't afford to pay to use their property, then don't use it. they worked hard to create that work of art, or paid tonne of money for the rights to the work of art.

@connermarchetti7522 11 месяцев назад

@@grants7390 if I'm not making any money and giving credit to the artists I fail to see why it's wrong for me to use their music. I could care less about the monetization I just wanna make fun tribute videos for shows/movies I love.

@lowmax4431 Год назад

I'm just impressed by how long he can monologue without making a mistake

@ash_tray_6 9 месяцев назад

I think you missed the credits then haha

@jamestreveil4866 3 года назад

I think the biggest injustice is that you can't defend yourself without having buckets of money to spend on lawyers.

@giffkeplen2951 3 года назад

That's the problem with RU-vid's copywrite laws, the impossibility of contesting it. You get to send a request to the claimant and if that fails it's court or you just accept the loss. If someone uploads a 40 minute video and it has 8 seconds of fair use content, that content can be claimed and every cent of revenue goes to the claimant.

@TheEndernal 3 года назад

Why capitalism sucks

@giffkeplen2951 3 года назад

@@TheEndernal Capitalism doesn't suck, unfettered capitalism sucks. Well regulated capitalism is the only functional economic system out there.

@TheEndernal 3 года назад

@@giffkeplen2951 true

@rqb6731 3 года назад

was gna comment about that being a problem with america but giffkeplen said it perfectly, we need more government assistance

@whistletoe 3 года назад

if photographers weren't more generous they could singlehandedly destroy the meme industry

@randon19yearold 3 года назад

If by industry you mean random people's instagram and facebook accounts

@n30m84 3 года назад

Annoying 15 year old your name fits you really well :)

@randon19yearold 3 года назад

@@n30m84 Thank you :')

@walidfakhfakh3660 3 года назад

@@n30m84 you quanaze q AYAUAUNEN quaaaannze depressed year old

@gregtv1467 3 года назад

@whistletoe No they couldn't and that's why they haven't.

@thebestmcmeow Год назад

How you manage to keep someone with ADHD (me and probably a lot of other people) hooked on videos talking about the in theory most boring things on earth is beyond me. Yet you do, hats off because that is truly amazing.

@calihhan4706 Год назад

This is how we learn 🙃

@roserose6418 Год назад

Tom's such a good presenter. A consistent energy and pacing, with no overly-complex words. Doing that while still being engaging is a underrated skill

@JoshuaTootell Год назад

I fell asleep. 🤣 Okay, I do that all the time and just rewind when I wake up and see what I missed

@ThisWillCharacter Год назад

It’s hyperfocusing, getting rlly in depth about weird random things is an ADHD trait

@ducminhduong9873 Год назад

Because the topics are not actually boring, and a lot of work went into them to ensure that translates onscreen.

@JouMxyzptlk Год назад

My problem is with the choice I get: I can tell it is a false claim, and the OTHER party has to agree "yes, it is wrong". That is the part which made me put up less and less videos on youtube, 'cause the other party can still say "it is mine" even though it clearly isn't. This disadvantage is my problem with youtube.

@justalonelypoteto 7 месяцев назад

the good thing is that if they want to insist, they have to actually file a lawsuit. The bad part is you have to provide your details so you can be sued if you wish to dispute it

@ThomasTheThermonuclearBomb 4 месяца назад

@@justalonelypotetoThe bad part is when people actually steall content and you can't do anything about it unless you file a lawsuit

@GuuMonster 4 года назад

Tom: Copyright shouldn't last longer than 50 years... Disney: I sense a disturbance in the force...

@legendarynoodle2438 4 года назад

*a disturbance in money

@Sydra. 4 года назад

5 years would be even better

@dougbrowning82 4 года назад

Originally, it was 14 years, with an option for a 14 year extension, just like patients. A lot has changed over the years.

@UltimatePowa 4 года назад

14 years should be the most it should ever be.

@tomasr.2945 4 года назад

It's ironic that you're quoting Star Wars: the franchise that Disney bought to be their cash cow and will most likely hold on to for years to come.

@AtomicLegion 3 года назад

Nothing is a better example of copyright being a joke than how disney was able to maintain copyright of mickey mouse after the copyright expired.

@jollyboyspecial 3 года назад

Disney claims copyright on things like Grimm characters. Disney seem to think they can own copyright on the public domain.

@NateROCKS112 3 года назад

And, furthermore, the Supreme Court being like "sounds about right" in Eldred v. Ashcroft.

@NateROCKS112 3 года назад

@Mr Right utility for a corporation isn't justification for depriving the public of a free culture. While Mickey Mouse was the lucky one, there are many works from 1926 that aren't preserved because it's illegal to do so. Disney wouldn't "lose" Mickey Mouse; they could still produce works based on him, since Disney is part of the public. Mickey Mouse entering the public domain isn't "splitting" the two; it's letting people create stuff with Mickey Mouse, sure, but Disney will remain associated with the character for generations to come. Edit: Copyright is a bargain. Instead of paying tax money for public transportation, we pay freedom for increased production of creative works. However, at some point it becomes diminishing returns, and we shouldn't give up more freedom. As it currently stands, Disney is pirating Mickey Mouse from the public.

@NateROCKS112 3 года назад

@Mr Right if you're being serious, I have lost all hope in humanity. It's over. Big media corporations win. Nothing can ever convince your brainwashed mind that copyright is not property and that too restrictive copyright is robbing the public of their creativity.

@NateROCKS112 3 года назад

@Mr Right did want to also note that trademark law would still cover Mickey Mouse-based logos that Disney makes, so in that case consumers wouldn't be confused about which company is associated with that logo.

@plat6164 Год назад

The next step after dealing with copyright is dealing the reality that some works only ever gain serious traction after the copyright owner can no longer benefit from royalties. Like some now famous artists never being recognized during their lifetime.

@deedeeen Год назад

That partly arose due to the lengthy copyright durations.

@VanessaMagick Год назад

And that sucks, sure, but is that a problem that needs solving?

@deedeeen Год назад

Well, _somewhat._

@Mr_Brains Год назад

Because of copyright slaugthering them like sheep

@jakubrogacz6829 2 дня назад

And that's the issue if it became PD it would kind of incentivise author to give out free copies that could possibly interest someone. In my country anime became popular only because piracy. Otherwise most people wouldn't even know what it is.

@kenakofer 2 года назад

One thing that's great about the hypothetical 50-years-from-publication copyright is that you don't have to track down the creator's death date to determine public domain status. For lesser-known creations, it's far more difficult to track down personal information about the creator than it is to check the publication year. This goes back to what you mentioned about "orphaned works". If no one knows exactly which John Smith it was who authored this book, can you be sure he's been dead long enough?

@MrProtjes 4 года назад

"I'm really surprised nobody has sued giphy for all their money yet." giphy: *sweats profusely*

@jpobi9880 4 года назад

Hahahha exactly my thoughts.

@jpobi9880 4 года назад

*giphy sues Tom for being mentioned*

@SangoProductions213 4 года назад

Ah hah! But in order to sue us, you have to pronounce our name!

@Voreoptera 4 года назад

I think some organisations should not exist.

@Cymes 4 года назад

My name gif.

@wongsaraf 4 года назад

Tom : We need to shorten how long copyright lasts. Disney : So you have chosen death.

@ordinaryshiba 4 года назад

I actually thought of this for some days

@HH-je3sh 4 года назад

Nice comment

@CoriHaws 4 года назад

Did you get a loisence for that quote?

@changsiah2 4 года назад

Disney hater

@awesomeguy2009 4 года назад

@@changsiah2 they're an evil company, dude

@radaro.9682 2 года назад

That you differentiate between legality and morality makes me happy. That's something few people do enough.

@Drakshl Год назад

I think the biggest issue with the copyright system on RU-vid is that the holder of copyright from 15 seconds of a 2 hour video can just make money from your entire video. Let them ringfence the section of the video with mid rolls they can profit from, and not just take everything. thats just me though

@squeakybunny2776 5 месяцев назад

What if I rip off a complete music video or movie even and then out 10 hours of random footage after it?

@ThomasTheThermonuclearBomb 4 месяца назад

@@squeakybunny2776Then people probably won't watch the random footage, and the ads there wouldn't make any money

@adamgill 4 года назад

Look at him - showing off being outside.....

@affalaffaa 4 года назад

La Di Da

@taaviparn9175 4 года назад

@@affalaffaa schlob on me knob.

@danpreston564 4 года назад

In Milton Keynes, no less.

@OrenKaplan83 4 года назад

a) Britain only closed down this past week. b) It was probably shot weeks ago and only finalized editing now.

@alamrasyidi4097 4 года назад

Probably prerecorded before the entire mess

@eoghan.5003 4 года назад

"Tom Scott: the feature length film" is finally here wow that's a lot of likes when all I did was say the predictable comment under any long video

@dolphinboi-playmonsterranc9668 4 года назад

Nah, this is TV documentary sized. Feature length is an hour and a half or longer.

@pavarottiaardvark3431 4 года назад

@@dolphinboi-playmonsterranc9668 The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences define "Feature Length" as 40 minutes or over. As just over 42 minutes, this video qualifies.

@danielchequer5842 4 года назад

Tom Scott: The Movie

@6105boe 4 года назад

Tom Scott 2: Legal Boogaloo Tom Scott 3: Tom Scott Is Not Free Tom Scott 4: Scott Goes To War I can go on.

@eoghan.5003 4 года назад

@@pavarottiaardvark3431 Thank you, gallant aardvark, for rescuing my joke from the veritable gutter of technical inaccuracy.

@1Kekz 6 месяцев назад

These are the best closed captions I have ever seen. Great work by your subtitler! I'm a subtitler too and this inspires me a lot.

@Saint5555 Год назад

The current trend of popular musicians selling the rights to their catalog to big media corps for hundreds of millions is only going to make the copyright system even more vicious

@iquipthedip 2 года назад

RIP TomReacts, you were ahead of your time.

@shadetraveleroftheunknown4949 2 года назад

What?

@adamkerman475 2 года назад

@@shadetraveleroftheunknown4949 bruh

@luginess0 2 года назад

True legend, swiped away by Tom Scott.

@wastery9113 2 года назад

@@luginess0 an example of how big channels are asses like tom scott

@AydenRose04 2 года назад

This scared me for a sec ngl, but then I realized what u meant

@_yerf 4 года назад

Jay Foreman just can't exist without screaming once in a while

@Madhattersinjeans 4 года назад

mood

@Max-se3ii 4 года назад

Mahogany

@FarHuntCH 4 года назад

Oak

@nickvanruiven 4 года назад

Jay Foremapman

@TGLapin 4 года назад

That was the best part

@endleontiozae7061 9 месяцев назад

I think that getting your work to enter public domain on a large scale should be an honorable thing.

@lorenwood890 4 месяца назад

The basic logical conclusion that people don’t want to accept is that intellectual property is not a type of real property, it doesn’t fit its definition, there is no scarcity, if I replicate an ideia no idea is lost. There is though a difference between using someone’s idea, and fraud were you pretend it’s yours, that is wrong, but replicating existing ideas such as patents should not come with any legal or moral wrongdoings

@imnonene 4 года назад

>using quasi-lawyer for the legal cameo >using actual lawyer for the vampire cameo Tom has his priority right

@Magtranya 4 года назад

Tadtathep Thepboriruck Isn’t Leonard French an actual copyright attorney? (Rhetorical) Jay Foreman is a comedian, but one of them is a lawyer licensed to practice for sure

@Bootleg_Jones 4 года назад

Leonard French isn't just a copyright attorney, he's our *favorite* copyright attorney.

@Spiderboydk 4 года назад

Leonard French is a practicing attorney besides being a youtuber.

@baylinkdashyt 4 года назад

I totally missed that it was Leonard, though I did spot the Eagle.

@guest_14.1.19 3 года назад

So basically, "No Copyright Infringement Intended" is the lawyer version of "An apple a day keeps the doctor away" right?

@oxybrightdark8765 3 года назад

Kirisaki Mortis yanno, some people are allergic to apples.

@sanmoon3543 3 года назад

Oxy Bright Dark and others are allergic to copyright

@izxodii 3 года назад

@@sanmoon3543 you are brilliant.

@Ventorath 3 года назад

I'd argue that while the phrase means nothing legally, it shows a willingness to comply if asked/told to take something down, which might be enough to keep some company from going ham against you (or RU-vid). Provided they're not making money on it.

@deebur8777 3 года назад

Yes!!! Exactly

@Tepalus Год назад

Lawyer: "We're going to sue you out of existance" YT/Aphabet: "I don't think so"

@asteroid889 Год назад

Copyright is supposed to protect small creators from big corporations, but it ends up protecting big corporations from small creators.

@PremierCCGuyMMXVI 9 месяцев назад

Very well said

@yaboi-km2qn 9 месяцев назад

no its supposed to protect the big companies.

@TFBPDK 8 месяцев назад

Isn’t it meant to protect both.

@zorimanar2247 8 месяцев назад

Copyright is meant to protect anyone who's work is being stolen. Big or Small. It's just that big corporations tend to benefit more, and also lobbyed it out of proportion.

@DavidBromage 4 года назад

The single reason copyright was extended from 50 years to life + 70 years was Mickey Mouse was about to enter the public domain.

@krdjmtc 4 года назад

I think for IPs like Mickey Mouse, the copyright should continue as long as the owner continues to produce new content with it. This would keep Star Wars copyrighted while Back to the Future would eventually fall into the Public Domain.

@CatCheshireThe 4 года назад

@@krdjmtc Honestly this isn't even really necessary because Disney could very easily argue for trademark protection on the image of Mickey Mouse (given how his image is so fundamental to their branding) which already works like this. Trademarks are good as long as you're using them. Steamboat Willie would lapse into public domain but the image of Mickey Mouse would still be owned by Disney as long as Disney exists.

@koboldcatgirl 4 года назад

@@krdjmtc Why?

@krdjmtc 4 года назад

@@CatCheshireThe Oh okay, that makes sense.

@TheGuyWhoIsSitting 4 года назад

I think Disney is trying to get around that with their steamboat willie introductions logos.

@kavertia6261 4 года назад

Can we just talk about the fact that LegalEagle just appeared out of nowhere in this video acting like a vampire being fought off with “no copyright infringement intended” as the cross? I didn’t know how much I needed this.

@sadianaheen7270 4 года назад

that made my day. that bit was funny.

@bensmith6518 4 года назад

Haha yes I watched the whole video too. I don't think your comment is fair use.

@kavertia6261 4 года назад

Ben Smith _sigh_ I’ll go get my lawyers...

@Sheridan2LT 4 года назад

LMAO WHYYYYY :D That's so perfect haha

@satyris410 4 года назад

Indochino...

@caseycu 2 года назад

When NASA has *repetitively* gotten videos and live feeds taken down, I’d say it’s broken af. And yes, I get that content ID is a response to an outdated system, but it’s still a broken response.

@CollinKeegan 9 месяцев назад

Another important thing I think about the difference between patents and copyright is that patents are described and archived as part of that process, so there isn't the "orphaned works" issue for patent. I honestly think the archival aspect of copyright is something that would be nice to be specifically addressed in law, like adding archival and backup without further distribution until copyright expiration to what is considered a fair use, or having a patent-like system where media must be submitted to a central government database whenever copyright is legally enforced (so if a cease and desist was sent or a lawsuit was brought, to be enforceable, the media would have to be submitted). And then there's the issue of DRM... anyways, that's all just to say that I think it's really important to not lose even obscure bits of culture and art.

@joebykaeby 4 года назад

Tom: "We need to shorten how long copyrights last" >Mickey Mouse wants to access your location

@elplain 4 года назад

🤣🤣🤣

@gnomsrepnay 4 года назад

Mickey Mouse wants to wipe your location off the face of the earth

@mr_biscuit 4 года назад

*Mickey mouse wants to commit war crimes*

@toschrama 4 года назад

The reason it is already 70 years is because of Mickey Mouse... and it is up in 2023

@shyresearcher 4 года назад

Isn't there a compromise? Something like after 50 years copyright holders have to pay $10k per year to maintain their copyright. Small potatoes for seriously valuable properties, but this system would allow the other 90%+ to transition into the public domain.

@jorgeaura2890 3 года назад

I just love how the legal system is set up in such a way that is cheaper to admit you are guilty than defending yourself in court. You are supposed to have a fair trial but that's impossible when you are facing a multibillion company that can hire as many expensive lawyers as they want. The justice system isn't just at all.

@alimohsin496 2 года назад

It is what it is :/

@nullbeyondo 2 года назад

Why do you `love` that? Disgusting. Edit: It's ironic how the normies who never got my sarcastic response telling me if I ever heard of sarcasm~

@sydnearuppert5305 2 года назад

They were being sarcastic

@frameturtle 2 года назад

@@nullbeyondo heard of sarcasm?

@rfichokeofdestiny 2 года назад

That’s because it has been thoroughly and completely distorted over the past 150 years or so by government “regulators” on behalf of well-connected interests.

@spectroglobe8433 2 года назад

Every time I’ve watched this I’ve thought to myself “That looks like Evan Edinger’s bedroom” and I finally checked and indeed it is

@chrismerrell7957 Год назад

US CASE Act: "Hey, this guy wants to sue you because you stole his work." Guy who stole the work: "Nah, I'm good." US CASE Act: "Understandable, have a good day."

@thesenate933 4 года назад

This dude switches between looking 40 and 20 the entire time

@odorikakeru 4 года назад

The senate That’s kind of what life in your 30s is for most people. σ^_^;

@milkyu_ix 4 года назад

I’m beginning to think Tom is going to forever stay young

@daltonweathersby1320 4 года назад

He’s 35

@macomputersuck 4 года назад

He's 66

@scyfrix 4 года назад

@@athirkell Right. Plain observation of something mildly amusing is evidently a sin. How dare they.

@realhawaii5o 4 года назад

When Legal Eagle got scared away like a vampire... That cracked me up.

@steveaustin2686 4 года назад

IKR. I had to stop and rewind I was laughing so hard. Especially about the little note at the bottom.

@kikilo9647 4 года назад

@@steveaustin2686 I couldnt see the letters so i kept thinking which video was that???

@flarinflint 4 года назад

The third party "legal expert" is Jay Foreman btw (You can find his channel on yt)

@LordBhorak 4 года назад

And the other lawyer is Leonard French (a real deal copyright lawyer).

@regan3873 4 года назад

For some reason my time thing is backwards but if anyone is curious (like I was) it’s @11:50

@haukuror8596 Год назад

Still come back to this gem every once in a while. One of Toms greatest works

@ElliotShayle 7 месяцев назад

This is such a great video! I don't disagree with anything in it. I just think the biggest tragedy is that 3 years on, there's barely any talk or political action about actually reforming the system. We're still just patching it up as we go along...

@JFGaming. 3 года назад

World said no then Tom said yes but didn’t show his bad side Edit: wow so many likes thx guys

@user-up7nb6id1f 3 года назад

edgy, cool

@qu4rtz732 3 года назад

that's tom scott for you

@hilal_younus 3 года назад

And even the fact that most people don’t even care/know anything about copyright and watches this at 3 am... (Yep, it’s me)

@LuneWatcher 3 года назад

It completely corrected what i thought fair use and copyright was like, I am on RU-vid a lot which made me more invested in the video and its subject matter. The video was also presented very well and in an entertaining way, this probably had months of effort put into it.

@piarateking8094 3 года назад

why wouldnt you?

@Watrmeln 3 года назад

Jay foreman screaming is way funnier than it’s supposed to

@reidarkollstrm5218 3 года назад

Jay foreman is always funny

@TechnicallyLogical2009 3 года назад

Timestamp please

@reidarkollstrm5218 3 года назад

@@TechnicallyLogical2009 2:56

@anschelsc 3 года назад

And, ironically, I really want to use it as a reaction gif

@aeaeeaoiauea 3 года назад

Also 11:45

@tritoner1221 Год назад

this video is amazing! the way you play out scenarios to showcase how absurd copyright laws are is genius

@ornstein714 10 месяцев назад

I know tom isn't a lawyer but seeing him in a suit does make me want him to defend me in court by providing the rock solid alibi that i was in the abandoned city of Pripyat

@aquamarinerose5405 3 года назад

> "We need to shorten how long copyright lasts" *Disney would like to know your location*

@gab_v250 3 года назад

Every relative of a famous artist: yesn't.

@ih82r8 3 года назад

Disney is mean about their stuff. They've limited releases and sales for eons; even calling it "the vault" where it all lives. They are the Scrooge McDuck of the corporate world.

@Erikaaaaaaaaaaaaa 3 года назад

Hilarious and original joke, mate

@memerboi69.0 3 года назад

disney going bankrupt

@gab_v250 3 года назад

also Nintendo to be honest.

@quetzal8100 3 года назад

The fact that you got an actual lawyer to perform as a vampire for a 10-second clip cracks me up to this day

@simp-slayer 3 года назад

He's a RU-vidr too, channel name is LegalEagle.

@EikoandMog 3 года назад

For bonus points, he's a copyright lawyer!

@priyanlevesque 3 года назад

666 likes. Please don't ruin it anyone.

@drkrik4985 3 года назад

@@priyanlevesque It's 888 now

@bilbo_gamers6417 2 года назад

All of the laws around copyright need to be gotten rid of and built from the ground up. It's not just copyright that is a joke, it's the idea that the government cares about protecting its citizens at all. You only have a right to a fair trial if you can afford a lawyer. We need to make it so that even just a pro bono lawyer could have a good chance of being able to defend their client with cases like this. Anything less than that is just the government walking all over the little guy and giving special unfair permission to the corporations that they empower.

@jamesseanbondconnery1648 Год назад

the emotional fervor you feel regarding this topic is depicted in the editing, and i love it

@nottsoserious 3 года назад

Love how Tom has to add a criticism to all his examples to dodge copyright

@SteveFrenchWoodNStuff 3 года назад

I think it's more to drive the point home, to make the message of the video more clear.

@jodagondrago8293 3 года назад

*Still sets a copyright strike*

@JSSMVCJR2.1 4 месяца назад

@@SteveFrenchWoodNStuff It's Both!

@iuriepripa3171 4 года назад

That literal switch from "fact" to "opinion" was smooth.

@Phroggster 4 года назад

I heard some facts after that switch was thrown; I want my money back

@lokeshchandak3660 4 года назад

@@Phroggster i'lll pay in like

@TheEarthCreature Год назад

I really always have loved the format of your videos. There's just something whimsical about how things blip onto the screen at your command and all of these little clever camera tricks like smacking your reviewer self Tim off the screen.

@putriddivine 9 месяцев назад

@MR-vj8dn 9 месяцев назад

But it’s all about justice. If I made the song, I sure want to make the money of it. Not give the money away.

@MR-vj8dn 7 месяцев назад

@@MrJuiceHugo I don’t understand what you’re trying to say.

@JSSMVCJR2.1 4 месяца назад

@@NerdTheDemon ooooh, good point.

@hollingharris659 4 года назад

the problem at the root of all of this is that it costs money to defend yourself in court

@howardbaxter2514 4 года назад

A lot of money

@lettuceman483 4 года назад

imagine hating people trying to get into the mainstream so much in order to be considered innocent you need to be rich

@moisedieucaryoteescholecte8439 4 года назад

@@Halorocker101 Well... Mostly all evil

@jackasshomey 4 года назад

@@Halorocker101 money is just a system of trade, it's an inanimate object, the users of the system did such things with it... Conclusion: Human's are evil.

@stairworse 4 года назад

@@jackasshomey Someone gets it.

@RegitYouTuber 4 года назад

Looks like my old IT teacher’s advice that “crop the top off an image and it’s not copyrighted anymore” might not quite be right...

@KatyaLeonie 4 года назад

Lmao not copyright if you alter the image

@yeetushmm6073 4 года назад

ok, the Regit who plays battle cats is here?

@damionlee7658 4 года назад

If you take a book with a colour illustration, and you: 1. Use tracing paper to trace the image outlines. 2. Transfer it to drawing paper. 3. Scan it digitally. 4. Use an art program to colour it in. That is still classed as copyright infringement 😉

@vikramvalame9990 4 года назад

Regit the Cat Battler

@arandomguywitharandomname4187 4 года назад

Just crop the whole image

@OperaceFlakpanzer Год назад

This is good enough to be a proper documentary in some well known TV outlet.. good work Tom!

@mikepetersen2927 Год назад

The red jumpsuit, the gumball machine and the bowling pin! What a great homage to a great show!

@1998tkhri 4 года назад

Imagine just how many contracts Tom needed for this video.

@no1DdC 4 года назад

Tom's lawyers needed lawyers to sort this one out.

@ailaG 4 года назад

Yes, a RU-vidr with less followers would probably be in trouble. (Or they'd ask RU-vid for help and hope they say yes)

@ten.seconds 4 года назад

I think the contracts might be copyrighted..

@Frungi 4 года назад

@@ten.seconds Which is why we’ll never see them

@GiatrosDys 4 года назад

:thinking: Can contracts be a work of art or be modified to become a work of art?

@darnwrong794 4 года назад

Jay: aaaAAAAaaaaAAAAaaaaaAAAAAAAAA Glad to see my favorite youtuber got some screentime.

@thedj9553 4 года назад

Darn Wrong *screamtime

@awesomefajitas 4 года назад

Darn Wrong classic jay

@jayj9278 4 года назад

aaaAAAAaaaaAAAA

@jamiesermon3881 3 года назад

Jay

@dabiga2315 2 года назад

Imagine looking out your window at work and seeing a guy walk by a dozen times angrily gesticulating and saying _"disPUTES"_

@specialfred453 3 месяца назад

Tom Scott: "... one of the world's biggest advertising fir-" RU-vid: *plays an ad*

@emilye.9059 3 года назад

I feel like if there were a school for becoming a RU-vidr, this video would be apart of the syllabus.

@stephencook2971 3 года назад

I disagree, I think it could instead be a part of the syllabus.

@theantimatter 3 года назад

Courses have syllabi. Schools have curricula.

@williamwontiam3166 3 года назад

I mean, we should put together a class for it at some point.

@elnico5623 3 года назад

Quick question, would they ask for permission?

@speedrhythmics1839 3 года назад

769 likes lmao

@marcusturner27 4 года назад

Tom just called the entire meme community the Internet's nerdy underbelly. I'll take it.

@YouGotPwnd 4 года назад

haha look at this epic memer

@69mviewsnt 4 года назад

We'll take it

@upwaveflash8429 4 года назад

that’s bullsh*t

@prestonang8216 4 года назад

*insert mike wasowski face

@radjadawamindra697 4 года назад

He's right, and we're proud of it.

@cementi4381 Год назад

Copyright law is designed so that those with the money can buy the rights to whatever they want so long as they can afford the lawyers.

@YraxZovaldo Год назад

No it isn’t

@getreal2592 Год назад

@@YraxZovaldo It didn't used to be that. But that's essentially what it's become after decades and decades of corporations lobbying congress to change the laws to fit their moneymaking motives.

@ThomasTheThermonuclearBomb 4 месяца назад

@@YraxZovaldoNo, it literally is. Watch cgpgrey's Rules for Rulers if you want to know why

@laurax1179 Год назад

This video has so much more rewatchability than a 42 minute video about copyright law has ANY right having!

@krishacz 4 года назад

Fun fact to make you feel old: If copyright lasted only 20 years like patents, Peter Jackson's Fellowship Of The Ring would be entering public domain next year

@phlaxyr 4 года назад

@Dan Stuart bruh

@PaleGhost69 4 года назад

The owner of the patent can renew it when it expires. Companies can't die so they can hold patents in stasis indefinitely. Car manufacturers bought other people's patents to hide electric cars and higher mpg and lower maintenance gas cars because it would cut into their return profits.

@noahmay7708 4 года назад

@Dan Stuart You rarely see people disliking Fellowship of the Ring without mentioning the book and holding it up to the sky like their holy bible.

@brandy1011 4 года назад

@@PaleGhost69 Renewing a patent is only possible for the 20 years mentioned (counting from the filing date, not the date of introduction to the market). The only exception I am aware of are products that require a licensing procedure, such as pharmaceuticals and pesticides. For them, the maximum duration is 20 years + the duration of the licensing process, but no more than 30 years. Of course, you can improve your invention and patent the improvement in a new patent, which would again last for a maximum of 20 years. But the "base" version of your invention would be out of patent protection earlier than the improvement.

@SupermotoZach 4 года назад

STOPPPPPPP

@Strajaize 4 года назад

I watched half an hour of this thinking it's been 10 minutes. Imagine having Tom as your professor...

@bigbunstudios7494 4 года назад

69 likes

@KJohansson 4 года назад

Then we would have learnt some thing!

@Pittigpiertje 4 года назад

Imagine your professor putting 10% of the time into his lecture

4 года назад

"Welcome to todays lecture... thanks for listening, goodbye."

@DrBrainTickler 4 года назад

I would get thrown out of his class for showing him that he's a simple-minded twat with myopic vision.

@eazyb9094 2 года назад

I love how you tie everything together in your videos

@OtakuUnitedStudio Год назад

Loved the Legal Eagle cameo, and I can tell you how you convinced him to do it: he is straight baller.

@gregorflopinski9016 4 года назад

Mickey mouse: *going into the public domain* Disney: welp, hey congress Congress: yes master Disney: here’s 4 million, do your magic

@philltheotherguy1868 4 года назад

snurk agurk 4000? That’s rookie numbers.

@JaneDoe-dg1gv 4 года назад

Phill The Other Guys politicians sell for cheap; no joke.

@Ilsezwarts 4 года назад

I love how you changed 4000 into 4 million. Prolonged copyright is Disney's biggest concern, wouldn't surprise me too much if we are talking about multiple billions being spent here.

@komokozy 4 года назад

Totally right, had a marketing teacher in collage 18 years ago that told us that Mickey Mouse was going into public domain in about 3 years, but it would never actually happen due to just this.

@gregorflopinski9016 4 года назад

@@Ilsezwarts was a mistake on my part

@alexhauptmann298 4 года назад

An actual copyright dispute I had to send to RU-vid once: "The Brandenburg Variation is a public domain work. This particular version I am streaming (as can be seen in the video) was rendered by myself from a MIDI file going into a vocal synthesizer, rendering the lines 'pee is stored in the balls'." I don't exactly think Sony has released anything involving that particular libretto.

@lastfirst5863 4 года назад

Damn them. I want that song.

@damnbro_idc 4 года назад

Sony doesn't want the truth of pee stored in balls to come out.

@nuddle7726 4 года назад

We must hear that song.

@ChaosAT 4 года назад

Du Cuxel

@ModelLights 4 года назад

Realize the title of this video is incorrect and misleading 'RU-vid's Copyright System Isn't Broken. The World's Is.' BOTH are broken, there is no 'either / or' choice. That there are all kinds of problems in the real world copyright law and that it's been extended by corrupt special interests and legislators doesn't negate that what RU-vid does is obviously poor and often incorrect.

@TNTErick Год назад

I love how Jay is cooperated in here just to scream

@orangebeagle3068 Год назад

I know this is anecdotal evidence, but I did buy Untitled Goose Game solely because of a youtuber. I probably would not have know about the game otherwise.

@zachbrown1630 4 года назад

even as a fan of Tom’s content, i’m amazed at his ability to keep me interested in subjects like this for over 40 minutes straight. absolutely brilliant.

@petrabanjarnahor229 4 года назад

Except i stop at 16 minutes for a lunch.

@youtubesuresuckscock 3 года назад

Didn't last 5. This video was WAY longer than it needed to be.

@cedarsapling 3 года назад

@@youtubesuresuckscock I thoroughly enjoyed the entire thing. I would feel sad about missing so much of this video if it was only 5 minutes long.

@ADNAN0MNM 3 года назад

Exactly. Around 22 minutes mark I realized it was not a regular 5-10 minute video and slightly surprised I was still interested.

@aleigor450 3 года назад

A video that takes Copyright seriously and discuss it in details? I hope it's 40+ mins long. It's one of the most complicated matter in our time and at the mercy of an old legal system.

@maxk4324 4 года назад

Doctor: I cured cancer with a pill that also gives you the ability to fly and browse the internet in your dreams, how long do I own it? US Govt: That'll be good for about 20yrs. Better start thinking of your next gig. Disney: I drew a mouse driving a boat, what do I get? US Govt: You mad genius! You'll be milking this cow for the next century my friend. Welcome to the good life. Hey, wanna try this crazy new pill? Don't worry the patent just ran out on it.

@trickytreyperfected1482 4 года назад

Well I guess if you persistantly extend the copyright long enough, you get to keep your mouse.

@superbob24 4 года назад

A pill that did all of that would make so much money that you should have no problem living the rest of your life off of it.

@Kian139 4 года назад

You own the pill until you sell it. You don't own the idea of such a pill. Government has granted you the monopoly right, but the idea is not property.

@1101 4 года назад

@@superbob24 That's.. I don't think that is his point.

@adventofnull 4 года назад

Don't pills have that same patent issue in the US? They minimally change the formula to renew the patent, and they monopolize it.

@lasercraft32 11 месяцев назад

I think the worst part about copyright law is that its used specifically to _take money_ from people who use stuff without permission, when instead the main goal should be to _prevent theft._ Its just another money-taking scheme for already rich companies and individuals more often than not. :(