10:7:28 the reason why ali was last and accepted and not first is a whole other story which they didn’t let the Shia guy speak. Umar,muayaya, Abu bakr ect all together forced ali to accept Abu bakr as the first even though ali was meant to be the first (said by prophet). Why did they force that’s a whole other topic that’s too long to be said in this comment. Ali accepted because he knew the consequences of not accepting so he did accept whilst not happy. Learn the context before speaking
As a guy wearing a Raw shirt said 12 Imams are not i Quran so does abu bakr or umar or usman is in Quran yeah Sureh Tauba ayath 40 but in tafseer it is not a fadaiil and even in his condemnation in Quran plenty of verses, Is Quran 100%in a complete state? Bcz according to Bukhari and Muslim and Mainstream players Umar ibne khattab,Abdullah ibne umar clearly stated that Quran is not in his complete state. Aslo AISHA narrates he use to give Fatwa from Quran but that 10 vols (Parah) have been eaten by goat. So how once could just insist to show from Quran about Imam. On the other hand The complete Quran Alhebait A.s and Imams do have and also Sureh Imran Ayath 33: Jaffar Sadiq says in the Ayath there was also "and choosen Prophet Mohammad Sawaw and offspring of Muhammad Alal ALEMEEN" IN Tafseer. Once could possibly be il_lertate or have 0 knowledge about the history
The ahle Sunnah because they don't follow the correct sunnah are unable to control their emotions, unable to learn proper manners. I don't understand why we keep debating these fools....
For all the ignorant who think Imamate isn't in the Quran, you're wrong. Surah bani israeel, verse 71 : "On the day We shall call forth everyone with their Imams...." Surah anbiyah, verses 72 & 73 : "And We bestowed upon them Ishaq and Yacoub as grandsons and made each of them righteous. And We made them Imams, who guide by our command..." Surah Baqarah, verse 124 : "And (remember) when his Lord tried Abraham with (His) commands, and he fulfilled them, He said: Lo! I have appointed thee an Imam for people. (Abraham) said: And of my offspring (will there be Imams)? He said: (Yes) But My covenant includeth not wrong-doers" So Imamate IS mentioned in the quran. AND It's mentioned to be in the lineage of ibrahim. AND it's said they won't be wrong-doers, meaning they'll be INFALLIBLE. AND it says Imams are made DIRECTLY by Allah. Now, the number 12 is mentioned in hadith. Bukhari 7222 & 7223 : "Narrated Jabir bin Samura: I heard the Prophet saying, There will be twelve Muslim leaders. He then said a sentence which I did not hear. My father said, All of them (those rulers) will be from Quraish." Furthermore, it's not a coincidence that "Ismael" is mentioned exactly 12 times in the Quran. Even in the Bible, genesis 17:20 mentions 12 Lords/Kings from Ismael's line. As for orders to follow Imams, and seeking guidance from them. Surah Nisa, verse 59 : "Obey Allah and His messenger and those with authority." Here, Allah is ordering unconditional obedience to the ones in authority. Since Allah cannot order unconditional obedience to wrong-doers (because that'll be unjust and Allah is Just) and from Baqarah 124, only Imams are NOT wrong-doers. Hence Allah ordered following of the Imams. Surah Maida, verse 55 : "Your master is only Allah, and the prophet and among those who believe, who gave zakat in ruku." Which is a direct reference to Ali a.s.
It was narrated from Jabir ibn Samura that he said: “I heard the Prophet (S) say: “Verily, this injunction (Islamic injunction) will not expire until the reign of twelve people ends.”
he Prophet proclaimed: “Man kuntu mawlahu fa aliyyun mawlahu” meaning: “He whose Mawla I am, Ali is his Mawla.” The Prophet then prayed: “O Allah, be a friend of whoever is his friend and extend your support to those who support him.”
Ya Hajib. you are finish,. you are using words to justify your inconsistancies, The twelve imams, are the decendances of Ali. is obvious, great job bro Sayyid Haamid
If Allah chosed Ali why wasn’t he elected ? Makes no sense. And one point is very important, ask yourself and please be honest. Why is it that when you follow your imams, that the Islam based on Quran and the sunnah of Mohammed loosing its value because the practice of your belief is based on the imams. Every logical thinking person should admit that Shia is not the path that Mohammed told us to follow. Furthermore he completed the religion so nobody after him can tell us what to do when it’s against his teachings. Please think about it…
You're making no sense. Since when does a divine appointment need elections?? When was prophet Muhammad elected?? Imams are proven from quran and prophet pbuh. Imams are parallel to the quran and prophet. Don't portray them as two different things. Prophet Muhammad included Imamate before completion. Get your religion straight.
@@diamontz360 yes. And it's not something I came up with. The Quran has called Ali as "nafs" of the prophet, according to surah ale imran verse 61 & Muslim 6220,6225. The prophet pbuh compared Ali to himself, declaring : "Ali is from me and I am from Ali" as seen in Bukhari 2699,4251 The prophet pbuh also chose Ali as his brother when the muhajirin and ansaar were made brothers, as per Tirmizi 3720. So, Ali and the prophet are comparable, but the prophet is obviously superior of the two. Also Ali is an Imam, not a prophet.
Hijab : “i didn’t interrupt you” , this is a blatant lie. Hijab interrupted him several times which prolonged the time it took for him to ask his question and then has the audacity to say “you’ve been talking for a while”
By Allah, Muhammad Hijab didn’t answer the question because if he answers the question that there is no evidence in Quran and Sunnah that Allah allows people to choose the divine leader, then the Sunni school of thought falls apart
Shiaism is built on lies and twisting of words. Even your video of 1 hour tile is a lie lol, its ~40 min compared to the 1+ hour debate. Here is the full video: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-MWI2kyo77IU.html&ab_channel=MohammedHijab
The mere thuggish and prideful demeanour and behaviour of the Sunnis, compared to the professionalism and civility of the Shia brother, proves that the example of Ali ibn Abu Talib AS is the tradition of true righteousness.
On an unrelated note If the shia believe that the quran is not preserved, thats enough of a proof for me to know that they are not on the correct aqeedah or path and Allah swt knows best
Hijab keeps dancing away from arguments and using tactics to distract others from valid points. See below: 31:6 And of the people is he who buys the amusement of speech to mislead [others] from the way of Allah without knowledge and who takes it in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment.
@@user-ly3ju6rj3u Thank you for passing your fatwa- the more you speak the more you will judged on the day of judgment. Perhaps it'd be better to educate yourself rather thank heckling!
31:6 And of the people is he who buys the amusement of speech to mislead [others] from the way of Allah without knowledge and who takes it in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment. See you on the day of judgement brother.
Hijab avoided the question that matters. The Shia gave him information that will lead to the proof that imam Ali should have been the caliphate right after the prophet, which will then lead to the rest of the imams. It is clear hijab was avoiding it.
