I've never seen or played a game with a better story. I wish he didn't die, but it was so John and them to live, and in my opinion, his was a noble one. He died doing good high honor or low. He did it for John.
From what we hear about gang before Blackwater massacre, they used to be Robin Hoods, but something changed, maybe cause of Micah, maybe cause of something else, that's why I almost can imagine that in 4:06 Arthur after "I am sorry, ma'am...", he almost wanted to say, "...we used to things differently..."
I still can't believe how God of War won Game of the Year award over RDR2. RD2 was the best ever. Nothing comes close to the story and character and game play, details of this. RDR2 is a masterpiece.